Amish Style Peanut Butter Cream Pie

I had so much fun making these pies for you all! And they turned out great! Here is the recipe for you to enjoy!
Peanut butter cream pie
2 cups milk
2 tablespoons butter
1/4 cup sugar
2 egg yolks or 2 whole eggs
1 tablespoon flour
2 tablespoons cornstarch
1/2 teaspoon vanilla
1/4 teaspoon salt
Melt butter in saucepan. Add milk and sugar. Mix rest of ingredients with a little milk and add to milk and sauce pan. Bring to boil. Use this as your basic vanilla pudding for all your cream pies.
Let the pudding cool off then sprinkle your sweet peanut butter crumbs on the bottom of your pie shell until covered,Then add your Pudding, sprinkle on a few more crumbs, top with whip cream, and then garnish with the rest of the sweet peanut butter crumbs! This only makes one 8 inch pie.
PS I always make this pudding a little richer by adding some rich milk like half-and-half, cream, Or like this time I added a can of evaporated milk. I think it just makes the pudding taste a lot creamier! :-).
For the peanut butter crumbs put a couple heaping tablespoons of peanut butter in a small bowl and add your powdered sugar a little at a time until it is nice and crumbly.
Please visit us as well at:
www.montanahavenlabradoodles.com
Facebook - Montana Haven
Instagram - Montana_Haven

[@denasewell]

You are such a domestic Goddess...an amazing cook...loving wholesome Mother! Your home is so beautiful and well kept! Your husband won the love lottery as you are the wife and mom anyone would aspire to be. My children are all grown but I love that KZbin has content creators like you everyone can learn from regardless of their past or background. So many young women do not have role models of substance! This was a great recipe I made it and everyone loved it!

[@angelacooper4043]

Yes treasure the moments as they will be gone soon enough ,I hope she stays around ❤❤❤ kids are so precious ❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@gaildavis710]

She's a momma's girl! I bet she will be a good cook when she's older!!

[@jenniferlee7167]

OHHH My Priscillia, those pies are picture-perfect! I could almost reach through the screen and steal a bite! Yes, please do give us a tutorial for the bread. And Joas was correct, you looked lovely in this video. A perfect hostess and a delicious meal!

[@MontanaHaven]

You so much Jennifer!

[@karenhummel49]

Looks delicious! My father was born and grew up in PA, Easton and Reading. He was Pennsylvania Dutch. He left PA behind after the war and settled on Long Island. He loved Shoo Fly pies Scrapple and typical Amish recipes. Thanks for the pie recipe!

[@deborahschaub2925]

Yes, definitely a tutorial on the bread and anything else that you are looking to share with us. Thank you for yet another amazing video & Shalom

[@RVBadlands2015]

My Dutch mom always baked a dessert for every dinner we had. I sure do miss her.

[@janicew6222]

Pie looks delicious and would love to see bread tutorial.

[@swissmiss857]

The pies look wonderful. I'm sure they taste just as good. What a Sweet Hostess.

[@susanschuck8124]

Priscilla and Joas I just cant get enough of your videos. Always so fun to watch. Your family is beautiful. God Bless You for taking the time to share with us. Looks delicious. You are quite the baker!

[@MontanaHaven]

Thank you Susan!

[@sylviaashworth5851]

The meal and pie looked delicious 😋 Y’all are such a beautiful family with the love of the Lord shining through your life❤️. I would love to see a bread tutorial.

[@angelabaugh4446]

Dad and daughter sharing pie, how sweet.

[@MontanaHaven]

It’s the best :-)!

[@lceec7012]

The pies look amazing. My husband loves peanut butter. Your family is beautiful! God bless you and yours.

[@gallerybethmichaud409]

🙆WOW! Priscilla all your 💚love filled dishes are an array of taste sensations! From inside out, your hospitality is glowing! (I helped myself to a spoon dip of peanut butter for the last seven minutes of viewing pleasure.) 😊B.

[@MontanaHaven]

Thank you so much! :-)

[@amydavidson9866]

My dad grew up Amish. And Amish Peanut butter pie is the best. It’s my all time favorite. I make it around the holidays and any family gathers we have.

[@AlliKat7329]

I truly enjoy your videos so much. I'm a single, 24 year old nurse who is praying to have a family like yours someday! Lord knows I want nothing more than to be a homemaker and raise a house full of children. Thank you for posting. :)

[@MontanaHaven]

We pray for your dream to come true!

[@rebacrow5604]

I love y’all. I wish I could live in a log home. I love y’all’s family. Y’all are so honest and I can tell how much yalllove one another. Be blessed

[@pinkywilliams8063]

Thanks Priscilla for sharing another GREAT recipes.....

[@dianalinscome5830]

Hey I just love all of you, your hunting with your beautiful sons with their daddy. And love your sewing the beautiful dresses for you and your adorable girls. And your cooking content is great. Most of all I love your love for Jesus Christ. God bless you all ❤✝️

[@MontanaHaven]

Thank you for your kind comment Diana!

[@laurarosas5899]

You teach us so much not just a baking recipe. Through your children, you teach us patience and love, with your husband and children you teach us what a family should be, and also by inviting friends over, you teach us what Jesus said, love thy neighbor. God bess y'all. From a small bordertown with Mexico. Bendiciones!

[@MontanaHaven]

Thank you and blessings to you Laura!

[@debbieroberts600]

Peanut Butter Pie , Was my Husband’s Favorite Pie! Look’s Delicious !

[@psalm6273]

The pies and dinner looked amazing...your guests were very lucky!!! Thanks for this great video...and Priscilla is a beautiful person inside and out!! God Bless!

[@marielee2399]

This is one of my favorite Amish recipes. It looks delicious!

[@frandemianczyk]

Wonderful video Priscilla!!! Everything looks so yummy!!!! Thank you so much for sharing with me!!!! Joas is right, you are so beautiful Priscilla, inside and out!!! Chloe is Joas & Grandma Miller’s mini me!!!! Sending love and prayers to all of you!! 🥰❤️❌⭕️🙏🏻🏔

[@gracechilcoat9075]

Thank you for posting this, I never knew about poking the sides, just the bottoms.

[@jeanjacobs9965]

Greetings Priscilla! Oh my goodness, that looks fabulous!! Thank you so much for sharing it. Love and blessings ♥️🙏

[@truejoie]

I'm so excited to try this recipe. My family has always enjoyed going to amish and mennonite restaurants while visiting Lancaster, PA. The pies were the best part! Your table and meal look amazing! Thanks for sharing and God bless!

[@ozarkview928]

Your pie crust is now my go to , thank you !

[@belindasmart3759]

Beautiful dinner and great looking pies. You do a great job your family is so blessed.

[@skristenl]

It is such a blessing to have found your channel. I am reminded how good God really is

[@MontanaHaven]

Thank you so much for your comment!

[@cathy3546]

Thank you for sharing your cooking and your family. Love your sweet Chloe! 🇨🇦

[@theitaliancook9843]

Hi Priscilla, I can’t wait to make the peanut Butter pie ! I am Italian and we too love to cook and have family and friends over and love to overdo with the cooking. A few years back we visited Penn. and got to have lots of Amish meals and fell in love with the wholesome quality of all of it. You made turkey gravy with your meal, what is that eaten with , did you have turkey also. Keep up with all the cooking vogs , I am learning so much of your culture. Thanks again , you are truly a blessed and special women ❤️

[@MontanaHaven]

We use the turkey gravy over mashed potatoes.

[@sarahsiskin6780]

Why am I watching this when today is a day I never ate!?? So busy! Now I am really hungry!! This looks amazing, Priscilla!

[@RVBadlands2015]

What a perfect meal and dessert.

[@annemarks675]

Amazing looking food as always Priscilla xxx

[@sarahsheartshome]

Your home is SO beautiful. And your friendly, sweet spirit is so refreshing. The pies look delicious and I'm going to make some! I love the dinner meal ideas! Share the BBQ sauce recipe!

[@francescashanti5342]

I really enjoy your videos. You and your family are so inspiring to me. May God bless you every day of your lives. Love to you all ❤️🙏🥰

[@lonestar4374]

That's exactly how I make it :) And love love peanutbutter pie! Probably my Favorite pie. I don't use the box pudding either,always cook it.

[@janetbond6811]

Made this today for my mother in laws birthday and everyone loved it! Thanks again for sharing! Love your recipes!!

[@MontanaHaven]

That’s wonderful Janet!

[@cindygoblirsch9438]

Thank you Priscilla! The pie looked wonderful. I noticed that your taste testers look a lot alike. What a beautiful table and the food looks like our family likes to eat. God Bless!

[@beckir7606]

My eyes smiled today with finding your channel and this recipe...Thank you so much for sharing your family and recipes with us! We are blessed...May you and your family continue with blessings, family , faith, love and pure cooking!

[@MontanaHaven]

Welcome Becki!

[@beckir7606]

@@MontanaHaven Making again today - 18th time!!!!

[@hayride5953]

Always been my favorite pie. Kinda funny, I brought some to work and now several of my Mexican coworkers now insist on having it at break time! Nice video, just discovered your page. Love the homey atmosphere.

[@MontanaHaven]

Welcome!

[@terrybrown9206]

Pie crust looks good.

[@donnaplumridge9769]

Oh my, the peanut butter pie looks so good! Unfortunately, I would be the only one eating it, as the rest of my family don’t like peanut butter! Your dinner looked good as well! Thank you for the recipe, I’m going to try it the next time I have a get together, a long with other pies or cakes as well.

[@ActionForAging]

We always loved the peanut butter cream pie from Dir Deutschman in Ihio Amish country, but no longer live near there. I’m going to try this. 💕

[@rachaelcosta3154]

Priscilla you are a beautiful person inside & out!! Your meal looks scrumptious & oh those pies! Yummy! Thank you for sharing!

[@MontanaHaven]

Thank you Rachel!

[@monashegda3112]

What a joy to learn some your traditional dishes. The bread looks delicious!

[@sarahsiskin6780]

Priscilla, I made this pie today and I want you to know it’s gone!! All eaten after dinner. It was so so good, I’ll be making this again. Thank you!

[@MontanaHaven]

I am so glad it turned out great!

[@suelapointe5299]

You make such wonderful recipes and you are an excellent teacher. I think you should produce a cookbook although I realize it is a lot of work especially with 5 children.

[@MontanaHaven]

Perhaps one day we will :-)

[@jerrywalker2699]

Sounds great looks yummy

[@sharongraybeal4804]

What a blessing! My husband has always loved peanut butter pie when we go to a Amish restaurant in Ronks, PA. called Dienners. After watching this I told him this southern girl is going to make him one! Thank you so very much for sharing it with us. I hope your dinner with family and your friends was a wonderful time of fellowship.

[@MontanaHaven]

Thank you Sharon! I hope your pie turns out amazing!

[@hildamclawhorm6305]

I just found your channel, I love you and your family❤️

[@shaunagriffin1178]

If I hadn’t watched you make those pies, I’d swear they were store bought. Beautifully done. Dinner looks great also. Thanks for sharing!

[@jamesbacon7415]

Love your video and want to try your peanut butter pie ! You have a sweet family 😍😋🤗

[@sarahsiskin6780]

Oh yes! I want the bread recipe!! Wonderful video

[@margareta9893]

Pie looks amazing!

[@jeannebrinkman8889]

Thank you for the recipe ❤️ Beautiful family❤️and video ❤️

[@jerrilynernsting903]

Thanks pricilla a looks real goods I like peanut butter pies.thanks a love this pie..

[@shallyjoseph3690]

Awesome Priscilla! Blessings

[@valariecroslin1427]

Have Priscilla I love watching your show thank you for you and your families willingness to do this

[@jerrilynernsting903]

Looks real good Priscilla a Amish is real good..

[@debbiewhitley8612]

Children are such a blessing from the lord . We have treasure every moment . . Pricilla your food looks so delicious 😋

[@tannaphillips6840]

Looks delicious!!!

[@michelemagni2501]

Priscilla you are beautiful on the inside and out🥰! So happy I found this recipe! I was lucky to grow up with close family friends that are “old order Amish” (that’s what they call themselves) from Western PA and they would make this pie❤️💕! I LOVE it! Thanks so much 🌸

[@gloriablankenship1678]

You have such a special family. I am so glad I found your channel. I love your pie recipe and can’t wait to bake it for company. I will be watching for your bread tutorial. God bless you and your family.

[@MontanaHaven]

Thank you

[@terihandrick2333]

How nice to share dinner with dear friends, and oh those pies look delish. Yes, please do a bread video. You are a great teacher, love to watch your videos. Blessings to all.

[@reidumphrey1980]

The pies look AMAZING! My Family loves your channel so much. It is so relaxing.

[@beverlymurray6554]

Loved this video Priscilla!

[@jerrilynernsting903]

That looks so good hope to make this pie real soon

[@sarabrunsvold2461]

The pies look scrumptious!! The whole has made me very hungry!! The table looked beautiful and so did Priscilla!! Please make a bread making tutorial!!! God bless you two and your sweet family!!

[@PierAndre]

Grüezi us dr Schwiiz/Bern...! Ooooh, that pie looks great. 🎂 I'm going to bake it too. Kids and grandkids will love it. 😋 I have to convert weight and mass to European though...! Thank you and love from Switzerland. God is faithful! Gott isch tröi! (Swiss German)😊

[@MontanaHaven]

Danke! I hope your pie turns out great!

[@mlm7598]

What a lovely video. Everything looks delicious! The peanut butter pie looks fabulous as do all the others delicious foods on the table. Joas, you have a beautiful loving and giving wife. I love how you are both so genuine to one another and the children. Your home is so lovely...........thank you for sharing with us. I would love the bread recipe as well. Such talent all of you have. Blessings

[@MontanaHaven]

Thank you so much Mary Lou!

[@springer2112]

You & Joas are knocking it out of the park! Keep safe!✌😎🏴‍☠️

[@cathyrodeheaver8694]

That is my favorite way to make peanut butter pie also. I agree with it being rich, but yummy.

[@kortniratliff8321]

My 2 year old, Jace, is always with me in the kitchen too. Thanks for the recipe! Definitely trying it

[@jeane561]

The pies look so good as does the whole dinner. Nothing better than good food, family and good friends❤️❤️❤️

[@grammieseven6604]

I love your videos Priscilla. Everything looks just delicious honey. You and joass are so loving to each other! Just the way The Lord designed marriage to be!! Chloe is a blessed little one with you as parents!! Love you and Gods blessings ❤️❤️🙏

[@Gustav92069]

Hello Priscillia, the Pie looked dangerously fabulous and I thought there goes my diet, LoL ;) Yes, I agree with Deborah, it would be wonderful if you did a tutorial on the bread. Thank you for sharing your time as well as Joas time, may I say you looked beautiful. God Bless you all. :)

[@MontanaHaven]

Thank you so much! And I will definitely do a bread tutorial sometime!

[@kathywebster9167]

I just started watching , i live in Anacortes Washington state on Fidalgo island.. occ I went to visit my family in Illinois snd loved seeing Amish folks . I sure have enjoyed your journey , I love your family values .. xoxoxo

[@MontanaHaven]

Welcome Kathy!

[@SM-wr9nb]

Thanks or sharing this recipe, I am going to make it. Such a sweet video!

[@donnabrant9031]

I really enjoy your videos. I made your peanut butter pie for my husband and it was a big hit. Thank you for sharing.

[@MontanaHaven]

Awesome Donna thanks for sharing and trying it out!

[@fredamiller3482]

Peanut butter pie is my favorite pie! It looks delicious! I also make as much food ahead of time when I have company. Less stress the day they come & I can enjoy it more.

[@jerrywalker2699]

Just love your family, you guys have such a happy looking family full of smiles..bread looks good 👍

[@MontanaHaven]

Thank you Jerry!

[@joannamicangelo8062]

It is so nice to see the love and respect you and Joas have for one another. You are a blessing. Could you explain why you use spelt flour and the kind of brown sugar you use in your cooking.

[@MontanaHaven]

Spelt flour is healthier with less gluten and we use Sucanet for sugar. You can find it on Amazon.

[@jerrilynernsting903]

Looks great very good got to try this pie..

[@944gemma]

I love to use lard for my pie crust. I also love when I can get some fresh fat and make my own lard.

[@kristinburgesen7400]

Thank you for another wonderful video!

[@ToryE1959]

Looks amazing

[@paradiseseen]

I'm enjoying your videos for the first time and they are really great.

[@MontanaHaven]

Welcome to our family!

[@carlafranklin3081]

Beautiful inside and out!

[@MontanaHaven]

Probably a bit later this summer :-)

[@gracechilcoat9075]

Last Thanksgiving I tried a new pie crust for me, brown sugar crust on a pecan pie. It came out delicious!

[@candimclane6739]

I'm drooling! Looks so yummy! Here in Missouri we go to Jamesport to the large Amish community,for some good Amish food and deserts.Awww Priscilla is so pretty,and humble! Big hugs🤗 MeMe from Missouri.Oh,I made homemade vanilla for Christmas gifts one year.Got Madagascar vanilla beans on Amazon,and you put them in vodka,put in dark cool place for a few months.Shake once a month.Super good!

[@MontanaHaven]

Thank you candi! I really want to try to make my own vanilla sometime!

[@debrawilson8525]

You certainly made my mouth water watching you prepare that delicious peanut butter pie. I love the food videos. I love to learn and there's no better way than observation. You are blessing a lot of young girls as well as us older women as we never get too old to learn something new and worth while. As soon as I find a place that sells spelt flour I will be making cinnamon rolls and that delicious peanut butter pie. I would also enjoy seeing a video of basic bread but using spelt flour if you ever have a chance to do a video like that. Thank you and God Bless you and your entire family.

[@MontanaHaven]

Thank you for your comment Debra! I will hopefully do a bread recipe sometime again.

[@jamesbacon7415]

@@MontanaHaven I would like the recipe for your pb pie ,it looks delicious 😋

[@gordonbchristensen8727]

Love it when you cook.

[@thejaxson6222]

Amish peanut butter pie is my very favorite I always ordered it when we ate at Das Dutchman Essenhaus in Middlebury, IN before I bought one of their cookbooks. Now for many years this has been our family favorite made at home but ssshhhh don't let on how easy it is to make. :D Blessings to you & yours thanks for the videos.

[@lindapetersen1800]

That looks HEAVENLY am going to share this on FB it looks so GREAT!!!

[@MontanaHaven]

Thanks for sharing it Linda! Blessings to you!

[@melissalee1531]

Priscilla is beautiful inside and outside !!!!! Thank you for your channel! I really enjoy your videos! God bless !

[@MontanaHaven]

Thank you so much Melissa

[@deanebrownfield6866]

Best looking pie I have now seen but never had . Will soon take care of that by making one. Thank you Pricilla. I agree home bade crust and whipped cream are way way better than store bought - and way more fun too. Have a great weekend with the family.

[@utubewatcher60]

Oh my goodness!! Priscilla good job on the pies and delicious dinner! You’ve really grown through you tube video’s you’d never know you were once shy! ☺️ good job and god bless!! 💞💞💞

[@MontanaHaven]

Thank you for the encouragement Kim!

[@pamleslie1131]

This looks so yummy and easy to make. I think I am going to make it for March 14th - Pie Day 3.14