How to Buylist Magic Cards | Selling Your Magic Cards for Cash or Store Credit with Card Kingdom

This video is a walkthrough and guide on how to buylist Magic: The Gathering cards. Buylisting Magic cards is a great way to sell your cards and get value for ones you do not want or need, and turn them into cash or other cards. One of my favorite parts of buylisting is how you can get decent value for a lot of those commons and uncommons that normally sit in that booster box indefinitely.
Now you can buylist Magic cards at a lot of different companies too, and I'd recommend going with whoever you currently buy cards through. If you don't have an online retailer then check out Card Kingdom. They are who I have always used and they have fantastic customer service. If you want a place to spend all your new cash or store credit here is my affiliate link:
►Shop Card Kingdom: bit.ly/CardKing... (affiliate link)
►Become a Patron! - / mountainmanmagic
►We got Merch!!! bit.ly/MMM-Merch
Use code: Mountain for 10% off all orders!
More Content to Scope Out:
MTG Draft Guides: bit.ly/2yJC4J5
Should You Buy Product Reviews: bit.ly/ShouldYo...
Iconic MTG Cards: bit.ly/2YKWagA
~~~Contact Information~~~
Email: [e-mail]
~~~Mailing Address~~~
Mountain Man Magic
PO Box 1183
Jackson, WY 83001
~~~Other Ways to Support the Channel~~~
►PayPal: paypal.me/Moun...
►Venmo: @MountainManMagic
You're awesome, Magic is the best game on the planet, and thanks for being part of the community!
#buylistmagiccards #sellmagiccards #mtgfinance

[@MountainManMagic]

Hello and thank you for watching! Comment with any questions and of course LIKE and SUBSCRIBE for more awesome MTG content!

[@aaronhanson3844]

Fun Fact: MTGA codes can be buy-listed to Grayvikinggames.com. Just have to send them an email.

[@ottis679]

Earned a sub from me, turning up your video to 1.25 made it the perfect video to explain this

[@MountainManMagic]

I've rarely had someone say I need to talk faster haha - but hey, whatever works for you. Thanks for the sub!

[@ShawnSansonetti]

Well this video would have helped considerably a few years ago. Better late than never though, right? Great content as usual! You've got talent for being able to keep people engaged and cover a topic in detail without spending too much time on it. Hope you're having a splendid time!

[@MountainManMagic]

I appreciate that my friend - thank you and I hope you have some awesome buylisting experiences from here on out lol

[@DarthDubhslaine]

I hoard my cards like a dragon hording treasure, but this is good to know if my wife ever gets tired of being outnumbered by the growing stacks of cardboard 😂

[@MountainManMagic]

That may or may not be a big motivator for me too. I get the sideways look of "oh where did those boxes come from..." and I all of a sudden feel like organizing and selling some haha

[@leehunt6031]

Great information, definitely might have to do this soon. I've been wanting to get rid of some bulk for a while now

[@MountainManMagic]

You should - it feels great to free up space and get $ for it! lol

[@ChristopherPisz]

A really important bit of information is missing. How much do they charge for the service? If it's not a % or flat fee, then how much lower are they buying compared to TCGPlayer?

[@stoiccrane4259]

How do you address buylisting smaller orders? For instance I have a few planeswalkers and relentless dead lying around I have no interest in but want to get rid of but the USPS boxes seem waaaay too large for the few cards I want to sell. #buylist

[@MountainManMagic]

Great question - You can always try the envelope route, or padded mailed/smaller envelope for that. Not a bad idea, especially if you have some extra toploaders lying around. Still may cost more than you want to pay, but WAAAAY cheaper than the big ol' box!

[@ericwilliamson5548]

Great video and great advice! Keep up the awesome, bud! 😁

[@MountainManMagic]

Thanks buddy - hope you're well my friend! :)

[@meaningfulmax9351]

Thank you for the tutorial man. I subscribe to your channel, I like your video, and I thank you. Little side note: it would be great if they bought all the bulk that you have this way XD

[@MountainManMagic]

Thanks for subbing and glad you liked the video! Bulk is always a pain lol

[@art_kols2324]

I'm sorry if I'm a pain in the ass but it's my first time shipping anything and I can't find information about shipping out packages what exactly do I need to do??

[@MountainManMagic]

No worries at all - when you hit submit order, you can either check your email or your account. On each sell order it will give you the address to ship the cards to CK at. If you can't find it, just email support and they'll help you out too.

[@x_DNR_x]

This is an AWESOME Video,... I was always hesitant about this, but I have SO MANY cards from Dominaria to the Current Set that i have been going through & keeping only 2 of's & putting the rest in a trade binder. It would be nice to not deal with hassling about trades cause prices are a little off.

[@MountainManMagic]

This is pretty much what I’ve done too. Got the cards I want to keep set aside and then the rest get buylisted whenever I get tired of organizing or handling them.

[@jackinbox2056]

Hey, I was hoping someone could let me know if they give ANY credit for LP cards. I have a ton of NM and LP cards, so I was wondering if I could just send both at the same time and they'll sort them out from there? Thanks for any info!

[@MountainManMagic]

Yes, you would not get as much credit/money for LP, but they will pay and show how they graded each card, which is very nice!

[@pedropenna7480]

I have one question. Im thinking about selling some of my many cards. BUT... what if i do the buylist, send the cards and so on.... but in the end, the price they offer is diferent from what was expected, not for the conditions of the card, but because the price in the buy list changed.... the condition of the cards is something that i can imagine what it will be.... but the price that makes me decide to sell the cards is very important... so, what i need to know is: "does the price of the cart pointed in the webside buylist changes over time EVEN regarding closed lists already in progress?" (i know the price changes over time, but, if the price was 5 when ive made my list and sent in the mail, and when they are grading the buyprice drops to 3, will they pay the first 5 bucks that was offered at the time or will they pay 3 bucks now?)

[@MountainManMagic]

When you buylist the cards you're adding them to your cart and then you "submit order." Once the order is submitted you get a confirmation email with the list of cards, the amount of each card, and the price CK will pay for each. So, even if the price drops after you sell those cards - it doesn't matter, because the order already happened. Then, you'll get paid or store credit sent to you once CK gets the cards and grades them (assuming they're all NM), and all the values are based on that order you submitted. Hopefully that clears it up!

[@pedropenna7480]

@@MountainManMagic you have help!! Thanks!

[@laurapigg5132]

Yea... their prices are kind of crap. I'm a level 4 seller on TCG player, and after the 10% they take of my sales, I still make way more than what I'm selling. Granted, for bulk I'm sure this is ideal than holding onto it. I looked at a foil anime cyclonic rift, they sell on TCG for $115+ . . . Card kingdom was going to offer $66. Again for bulk, card kingdom probably worth it. But I do not list any cards for below 25cents because most ppl would rather pay 1.25 in shipping than comb through bulk in LGS for cheap cards and because TCG lets pro-salers have a store front at no cost to the seller, usually ppl add a lot of other items to save on shipping.

[@sammypearce1944]

So what do you usually put inside the box to prevent the cards from moving around in transit ? Like what kind of tape do you make sure the box you're putting the cards in stay shut if you put them into a fat pack container how much tape do you need to use ? Sorry for so many questions

[@MountainManMagic]

I don't worry about the packages opening up in transit, because I do put enough around them that that's not possible. If I have any extra newspaper, junk mail, or packing from an Amazon package I'll use that to make sure the buylist order is secure. If I need more the post office often has enough unused magazines or whatever I need to fill in the gaps.

[@LordJaroh]

Very well done video! I am no subscribing. One question - do you know the best place/way from Canada or whether it is worth doing it to CK from Canada? I have checked out a few buylists, and most sites have very clumsy/terrible buylist pages. (That Card Kingdom site looks nice!)

[@MountainManMagic]

I know Card Kingdom ships internationally, but not sure how that impacts buylisting orders. I'm not sure if there are other taxes or fees put on international orders, but I don't see why you can't buylist cards as long as you can get them shipped to CK. Also, why you no subscribe? You should subscribe.

[@LordJaroh]

@@MountainManMagic Hah! That should say "now subscribing"! I am just leery of shipping coats from Canada. Pretty sure it costs much more than $17USD (our shipping up here sucks).

[@MountainManMagic]

@@LordJaroh ah got ya - yeah that’s tough my Canadian friend :/ - some folks have friends stateside they can go to, or are close enough to the border to handle it on their own. Good luck

[@jinkxkng]

any tips for dealing with taxes? i wen to use my store credit and was getting hit with 300+ dollars in taxes

[@MountainManMagic]

That's a good question - I haven't thought of it, but I suppose it is something we all have to set money aside for. Not sure there's an easy way around it unfortunately.

[@jinkxkng]

@@MountainManMagic sucks paying inflated prices on reserved list cards on top of taxes sigh*

[@philtheunikorn3154]

This is nice but I'm trying to sell some of my 100 card decks... Not selling cards I don't want... selling decks that wreck in standard

[@MountainManMagic]

I'd try eBay or facebook groups if you're trying to sell a full deck - you most likely won't get full value, but would be the quickest way to move em.

[@DannydeFou]

#buylist , great video thx!

[@MountainManMagic]

Thanks for watching!

[@windowman7042]

#buylistmagiccards Loved the video, thank you!

[@TripleMMM47]

Dang I’ve been through most of my cards and it’s all mainly bulk 😭😭😭

[@MountainManMagic]

Now comes the process of finding what is not worth keeping and finding a school, library, or LGS that can use them and get them to kids who will be stoked to add any cards to their collection. I've probably given away upwards of 20 booster boxes stuffed full of cards thus far. I'm going to keep telling myself it was all money well spent 😂😭

[@x_DNR_x]

If you did go with store credit, they just keep the amount on fill & you can use it towards Any card, Say a very expensive Reserve list card?

[@MountainManMagic]

Exactly. You can keep saving up the store credit and then buy that dual land or whatever you got your eye on. You can also set alerts if the card you want isn’t available so when it is you can jump on it!

[@x_DNR_x]

@@MountainManMagic I'm guessing that you only get recognized using the Affiliated link if 1 is buying cards?

[@MountainManMagic]

I think so, but hey give it a whirl either way lol

[@Memesmaster11901]

can i sell here if im from UK?

[@thayn2339]

This is a godsend. I've been trying to figure this out for a week.

[@MountainManMagic]

Thank you - this was something I was struggling to understand when I first thought about selling cards, so glad to hear it helped you!

[@mitch91Z28]

#buylistmagiccards

[@TonyCook7]

CK is a huge rip off. Wayyyy too expensive and pay you little for cards. Sell and buy on TCG.