Munich (2005) - Did I Commit Murder? Scene (10/10) | Movieclips

[@frankdodd3355]

I liked this movie very much. It was Spielberg's most controversial and uncompromising film. Isrealis and Palestinians both roundly criticized and condemned it. That's how you know he did it right.

[@galencox4278]

YES

[@THEmetopholus]

Not necessary

[@mauriciokrebs2913]

great script

[@jonnybirchyboy1560]

In reality you can only condemn Israel. Racial supremacists committing ethnic cleansing.

[@martinmendl1399]

@@jonnybirchyboy1560 Because these peaceful Palestinian organisations like Hamas and Black September that have commited countless terrorist attacks are so admirable... no, there is no right side in this conflict.

[@davidhutchinson5233]

Geoffrey Rush...nothing short of amazing.

[@hing420]

Wait...THATS BARBAROSSA?!!!

[@ricarleite]

Ben Kingsley was cast but he had to back away due to other commitments and Geoffrey Rush was brought on last minute

[@Hopscotchlemonadespritz]

@ricarleite Didn't know that! The casting worked, even so. My favorite scene of theirs is around Avner's dinner table much earlier in the film. You can feel the frustration reaching a breaking point as desperation hits and then consent to continue on as they've been.

[@KarlRoloff69]

Lol I thought it was james woods

[@youbian]

That last line is so poignant. It defines in one moment the futile attempts at peace. Here is a fellow Israeli asking another to break bread with him; and he can’t.

[@rs7458]

That scene represents the two type or Israelis: one based by faith and the other to their government.

[@claymac7895]

Can’t or won’t?

[@livreyes4148]

I never really understood the last line. Why won’t he break bread with him 🥺

[@xMorbidArtx]

@@livreyes4148Because he’s the one that will have abner killed.

[@dakritic]

@@livreyes4148: I always felt it was because he resented that Avner didn’t want to go back and live in Israel

[@JimmySailor]

It’s a really brilliant film. The final “No” is the rejection of of Avner’s Judaism. Because Bana’s character has rejected Israel’s policy he is now no longer Jewish in their eyes. It’s the final betrayal, that a land that could be founded on open exceptance. A “last place for the Jewish people” could in tern reject someone, just because he refused to kill for them.

[@abhayawasthi9345]

Eric Bana deserves more lead roles or a franchise like 007/MI. Wonder why did he not get much leads, man got acting & physique both.

[@Gabster1990]

He takes long breaks after filming.

[@tiburc10]

Maybe because he likes to make good movies that has some value other than just entretain?

[@reeceburns8077]

He's also very humble when it comes to his acting because I watched him in an interview for chopper and he said "I'm not actually a good actor I just know how to mimic people"

[@ScotchRanger945]

Say what you will about Hulk...I thought he did a pretty good job playing Bruce Banner. But his best role (imo) was "Hoot" from Black Hawk Down

[@SicKno-i5r]

He said in an australian interview recently that Hollywood was "fun" but he's done with it, and is mostly focused on Australian Indie movies now.

[@prettysingh5300]

Eric bana is amazing actor...

[@d.a.v.9381]

"Only the dead have seen the end of war" -Plato-

[@coreytoomey7579]

Avner: "Break bread with me." Ephraim: "I'm disinclined to acquiesce to your request."

[@khairiaris]

That's a lot words, I am just a humble land thieving Zionist..

[@ajward9112]

I thought I recognised the actor behind Ephraim. I couldn't place him as I watched the movie, thanks so much for making the connection.

[@AqvaSerpentis]

“Means no”

[@Apeinator3D]

By far one of the most brutal and graphic depictions of violence I have ever seen in a film. I was much more disturbed by the violence in this film than Saving Private Ryan.

[@goodputin4324]

Two Ozzies having a heart to heart talk lol

[@gardensofthegods]

I never knew that Geoffrey Rush was from Australia

[@AnthonyDukesConsulting]

@jonathanbirch2022*karen

[@ScottyShaw]

I would love to see a blooper version where they act this same scene as Aussies Bonus points if Bana does it as POIDA

[@samuelstacey2309]

@@gardensofthegods He’s a national treasure. My uncle went to school with him at Everton Park State High School here in Brisbane.

[@WarbossR0kt00fSant0s]

I see this as Hector talking things out with Barbarossa.

[@scriptaman2888]

How he delivered that "no" at the end..impeccable acting

[@sitdowndogbreath]

Because you cannot be seen with him that's why and you can see the regret in his eyes.

[@AnthonyDukesConsulting]

@@sitdowndogbreathit fits too as the “No” had gone the other way at the airport earlier

[@texastoast5202]

@@sitdowndogbreathsitdowndogbreath- Thanks for clarifying that for me! I always wondered why he said no to the dinner invite by Bana! I didn’t know if it was that he just didn’t want to OR he thought it was too risky or maybe a set up.

[@kiernanmooney6210]

This is a movie about a patriot who goes out to avenge his country and then that country completely abandons him

[@kiernanmooney6210]

@@josephmaietta6522 bro two things can happen in the same movie.

[@kiernanmooney6210]

@@josephmaietta6522 that’s not what I’m saying or what the movie is saying. The world isn’t divided into terrorists and heroes.

[@coreytoomey7579]

2:41 Earlier Avner said no to war. Here Ephraim said no to peace.

[@jeffsor47]

That's your wack interpretation? Have spmeone explain the movie to you.

[@tipdub]

@@jeffsor47 no u explain

[@jeffsor47]

When the terrorists want peace there'll be peace, their decision.

[@selectland1]

He said no to dinner.

[@Michael-e6d1i]

(1:28) "Why cut my fingernails ? They'll grow back". Best line in the movie.

[@omerbrooklyn8716]

This film is tot-ally underrated.

[@lilybond6485]

“Why cut my fingernails - they’ll grow back”. - and there you have it.

[@lilybond6485]

@@meherenow793 😊

[@abhivan100]

Eric Bana is hell of a good Actor ❤️🙏🏼

[@joshweiner4645]

yes, it's too bad he's faded from the industry at this point.

[@TheGiua1973]

One of Rush's greatest roles.

[@alexayers9463]

This was Spielberg's best film of the 21st century.

[@averagejoe6617]

Debatable, but its definitely up there.

[@neroresurrected]

I agree, at the very least it is way underrated to be as good as it is. Eric Bana was amazing in this film.

[@neroresurrected]

nakedBison69 Lincoln was good but it seemed a little overhyped. With movies, it usually boils down to personal preference. For me Munich as a story has been significantly under told historically than anything Lincoln related and the acting in this was all around amazing. Both films are great but for me Munich is the best thing Spielberg ever did.

[@liampatrick3110]

On the contrary

[@ciaranoconnell4783]

His most underrated film this century for sure. People forget about it but it's a terrific film.

[@hanscombe72]

Two of our Australian National treasures. What a way to end a Spielberg movie! Watch when Avner’s wife puts their baby daughter on the phone. “Hello darling, it’s your papa.” An incredible piece of acting.

[@davidlean1060]

It is rather nice to see Bana again. I always liked him as a lead. Ozzy mates know him from his early stand up days too. Wasn't his version of Chopper a bit on a comedy sketch show to begin with?

[@AnthonyDukesConsulting]

@@davidlean1060he had a character named “Poida” that was popular. Not sure about Chopper before the flick. He was brilliant in that also

[@davidlean1060]

@@AnthonyDukesConsulting I went and had a search and there was another Ozzy who did a chopper impression on tv..Chopper reading the weather, Chopper at airport customs etc, but not Bana. His character did things like spoof game shows etc, am I right?

[@ScottyShaw]

@@AnthonyDukesConsulting I've been a huge fan of Poida over the past several years

[@drgeetchadha]

I love this movie. I first watched it when I was 19 but I couldn't quite grasp the deeper politics and meaning at the time. Since then I've seen it multiple times and every time I watch it I have a new level of respect and appreciation for Spielberg. This might not be his magnum opus but it surely is one his best works and a very poignant piece of cinema on its own. In the light of what's happening in the world, this movie is a testament to the fact that we rarely learn from our mistakes. War has no end. Hate has no end. "There's no peace at the end of this, no matter what you believe"; sums up the movie pretty much. Thank you Mr. Spielberg for this masterful piece of work❤

[@racializedkanadian]

This just might be my favourite Spielberg film. It is most certainly his most courageous work to date.

[@matiaspereira9382]

My 6th favorite (behind E.T., Jaws, Ready Player One, Indiana Jones 3 and Close Encounters of the 3rd Kind)

[@matiaspereira9382]

I finally watched the movie for the 1st time yesterday! It's a masterpiece!

[@brionhausgeld2415]

This scene strikes me as an homage to THREE DAYS OF THE CONDOR. Robert Redford and Cliff Robertson have a similar conversation in that area.

[@jeshkam]

Wow, it's in the same area of NYC? Cliff Robertson's office in the movie is in one of the WTC towers. Also, he was a pilot and on 9/11 he was flying 7500 ft. above the towers when the first plane crashed. BTW Three Days of the Condor is on my TV station tonight. 😊

[@brysteinberg1972]

Fantastic film!! The end is chilling with the Twin Towers featured because even though it’s filmed in 2005, this scene is 1978 I believe! So he put the Towers in and it’s even more chilling now where the message is violence begets violence!

[@juanr.aguilar420]

It’s stupid symbolism. 15 of the 19 9/11 hijackers were from Saudi Arabia, a U.S. ally, not the West Bank or Gaza.

[@IAMBENNYBLANCO.]

If anyone has not seen this movie..... DO IT! great film.

[@lollmemmSm0keweed]

Don't. Read about it.

[@ianinkster2261]

I want to know how much of this is visually accurate. How many of those buildings were built since the 70s?

[@Hopscotchlemonadespritz]

Accurate! I don't see anything amiss. Anything too new was probably removed digitally in post-production. Refer to Gangs of New York just three years earlier. There's a much crazier scene, practically shot from the same location overlooking a portion of Manhattan's skyline, summarizing some two centuries of change.

[@augaureliusserious]

I love to watch this scene when I begin to question the point of it all. "Why cut my fingernails? They'll grow back"

[@maralinekozial9131]

This movie is a hidden masterpiece that nobody seems to ever mention but give it time after everything thats been going on lately!!!! I first saw this back in 2010 & it instantly made me go out & buy a custom grey charcoal suit like Avner wears going after most of his targets!!!! I got nothing but wonderful complements & stares by females for wearing it too❤ To me this is the greatest special forces/government assassin film ever made!!!! Films like Jason Bourn & Jack Reacher & Mission Impossible & 007 & even more accurate films like Clear & Present Danger & Body Of Lies & Safe House & every other CIA/MI6/KGB/Red Faction type movie don't even come close or hold a flame to this banger of a 💎!!!!!

[@javierchairez2045]

Fun fact: these two voices a hammerhead shark and a pelican from finding nemo

[@monke777]

Sadly, still relevant. Especially after a day like today. Where will revenge take us?

[@livreyes4148]

Exactly 🥺

[@CharlesHanson-Whitmore]

You call it revenge. Most others call it cutting off the head of the snake. If you find another snake, do the same. Not revenge. Just practical & necessary.

[@Jupa]

One thousand more years of war of course.

[@robertoacevedo3805]

Yup!

[@vilkristproductions6772]

​@WylderWatkinspeace was never the point. Domination was

[@seamushogan9668]

I don't know why but this ending always stuck with me. Had to look it up again.

[@UnemotionalBandit]

This movie was meaningful

[@stefanmovieflixtomasi]

Ping very meaningful. To tell you the truth, I found this better than Syriana with George Clooney and Matt Damon.

[@rogerkincaid931]

@@stefanmovieflixtomasi - Syrian tackled directly to the geo-political aspect. The film covered from a slightly different angle. I found both equally meaningful, but this one is deeper than the other.

[@DanielMazahreh]

Syriana is the deeper and more truthful film with an extremely powerful message. Munich is still great.

[@z1az285]

one of Spielberg's very best films

[@druyou2321]

Ugh, you cut the scene before it pans to the World Trade Center!!!! Wtf are you doing?!

[@markusmuller6173]

Doubts keep us awake while transparency creates trust.

[@arvinddeshpande6081]

आजतक बनी सबसे अनमोल फिल्म, धन्यवाद

[@AshishYadav-gz3jq]

I wish peace and harmony 🙏🏼 for everyone 🙏🏼

[@lucaslaino7292]

Avner felt like ali was right.he got no home after hearing the word from.ephrain s mouth.

[@RedStarRogue]

I once asked an Israeli who had seen the film (and likes it) if Eric Bana's accent was accurate. He said "I don't think he was trying to do one" or something like that lol.

[@jameskielland5018]

Bana's real talent is in accents. If I recall correctly, he got his start in stand up comedy and impersonations.

[@dnasty312]

​@@jameskielland5018the man's Australian and does an impeccable American accent

[@jameskielland5018]

@@dnasty312 Yes, he got the southern accent perfect in Black Hawk Down.

[@ScottyShaw]

@@jameskielland5018 For real. In fact, he sounds like he's from where I live now.

[@3rdEyeWide]

@@ScottyShaw It's because we (Aussies) are inundated with American media. We have a very small TV/film industry. The government actually has to set a quota to ensure there is at least some Australian content on the TV. It's changed a little with the dominance of reality TV (since it's so easy to produce). I'm a suburban Australian - never set foot in the US - but I'm told I have a slight american accent if I visit the more rural areas of Australia (where the typical Aussie accent is at it's strongest).

[@maralinekozial9131]

Im so surprised to see ppl catch on to remember this film after what just happened , i honestly thought id be the only person because im the only person ive met that has seen & talked about this film!!!! Its too bad its so unknown thanks to all these algorithm chasers that constantly talk & vote for the same old films that everyone has already seen because this is a extremely underrated masterpiece by Speilberg

[@amenamen1929]

Sadly it seems peace will only truly come when one side wipes out the other.

[@vocesdelrioriourbano7236]

When both wipe out each other.

[@dakritic]

When he returns

[@ddave7026]

@@dakritic amen

[@dreamlandnightmare]

There will only be peace when the human species is extinct.

[@khairiaris]

or another faction which seeks to wipe both..

[@deanciaglia2231]

Just 2 victorians having a chat 😂

[@egg64]

Ephraim gaslit Avner and his team about the lives they took in the name of Israel and the jewish faith; he could talk about it until he was blue in the face but when asked to sit with it, sit with the person that actually had to do the dirty work, he declines. Ephraim sees himself as the moral high ground but in the end he's just a coward that couldn't face nor carry out the orders he sent others to do.

[@Alton4]

loved that movie so much

[@Akshaypavan]

“ come home”

[@rolandosarabia810]

Hard learned lessons that life throws your way

[@silver4214]

In reality the black september division of the PLO got disbanded and never replaced, the hits destroyed a whole terror orginization, the "killing terror leaders make "x" madder and replaced with worse" not always happens

[@sitdowndogbreath]

That is always a concern that what you do makes things worse down the road.

[@InconvenientFactz]

Not quite true. You got Islamic jihad and Hamas. Operation in South Lebonan gave us Hezbollah. Without lasting peace, there will always be a worse enemy to defeat

[@aimanmarzuqi4804]

Wasn’t Black September replaced with Force 17

[@midimitrova471]

And I hope it does not happen now, 2023

[@esforza1388]

Hamas has now done far worse than what anyone in Black September or the PLO did. The Israelis did not make themselves safer.

[@Prosperr85]

That 'No' probably symbolizes the stubborn attitude both Israel and Palestine has against eachother. Allthough, that is how i interpret it No peace... no bread breaking

[@capital_of_texas]

I think so too. Both sides cry about the situation, but when that opportunity is placed right in front of them to end all the fighting, they always refuse it

[@glenmichaelwong517]

you mean the power hungry zionists who wants power

[@mikeg2491]

⁠@@glenmichaelwong517Hamas can’t even make peace with Fatah, this proves the stubbornness is both sides.

[@lizardopalominolavander9111]

En las pekiculas de piratas del caribe geoffrey rush nacido en 1951 es doblado por jesse conde nacido en 1952

[@glenmichaelwong517]

avner( pro peace ) vs ephraim ( ardent zionist)

[@makhines431]

You only break bread with a fellow brother in the presence of your common enemy. Psalms.

[@tritium1998]

Salameh (the one that got away) did get assassinated in 1979.

[@xoancardenas]

That no always hits. Teed up and then bang. Great scene.

[@gpapa31]

Spielberg’s underrated masterpiece. IMHO sits side by side with Schindler’s List.

[@MPDLR]

HELP! I like this movie a lot but need to understand: 1.)Why did Ephraim say "no" to coming home for dinner?? 2.)What is the meaning of focusing on Twin Towers at the end? Thanks

[@JosephineSheesley]

1. It’s a sign that Avner is no longer considered a true Israeli because he questioned the morality of his assignment and the cycle of violence. Ephraim is merely reinforcing that Avner is now considered a nobody. 2. It’s either some kind of tribute to the attacks. But also pushing the idea that violence always leads to more violence.

[@luisrizo8813]

So topical.

[@retro.raider]

Two Aussie icons ❤

[@user-or6yn8pm3c]

Wondered why they chose all non Jewish actors as Israelis. Fauda is similar but those guys scream Sabich and Bourekas. I guess they wanted more classic handsome actors.

[@seankim884]

It’s Ruth Langmore’s Favorite Steven Spielberg Movie Ever!

[@MrOcto13]

You go to work to do your job, not make friends. Especially in the field of intelligence. Rejecting Bana's dinner offer was strictly professional, nothing personal.

[@peterfrank3365]

Aw, come on! The rest of the clips are unavailable for me.

[@tpampouk]

Same, unfortunately

[@eyb0ss679]

Me too

[@GhilenPeek]

This is my favourite Spielberg film and I'm not affected directly by the conflict.

[@covert0overt_810]

you could ask him to kill… but not break bread. brutal. nothing but a tool.

[@taddersauce3672]

Just like Big Boss

[@covert0overt_810]

@@taddersauce3672 "kept yah waiting huh"

[@Sahilprakash1999]

Geoffrey Rush he is one of my favorite actor of his movie Pirates of the Caribbean

[@stuarthoward203]

Why did he say no to his offer of dinner??

[@user-xh1tc9et7p]

He didn’t like him abandoning Israel and returning back to the service, I guess.

[@JuanGonzalez-th5dh]

That’s why I came here. I just saw the movie for the third time. I wanted to know why he said “NO” to dinner offer

[@stormydragon2668]

@@rodrigovasquez8331 I see it as more complicated as that. Notice Ephraim never answered Avner's "am I murderer?" question. Ephraim does see Avner as just an assassin now and won't eat with him because for all Ephraim's talk about coming home, he doesn't see Avner as a real Israeli anymore. Which is also why Avner knows he can't go really go back. He'll be let into the country, but he won't ever be home there again. Which is the ultimate tragedy of the movie. Avner did everything he did to save a home that no longer exists for him now.

[@cc-92]

@@stormydragon2668 I’m still confused because he was treated like a hero when he returned to Israel. Why doesn’t ephraim not see him as an Israeli anymore???

[@iagonovidelsky8290]

@@cc-92 he sees him now as an assasin, someone who didnt kill for israel, Avner is the one who is rejecting being an israeli. Ephraim tries to convince him that what he did had a purpuose, Avner declines that proposition. Ephraim then just makes what Avner should accept, break the relationship. Avner is confused, full of guilt wants someone to say he will be forgiven by everyone, Ephraim says he wont be forgiven by everyone, just by "his" people. When Avner invites him, Ephraim rejecting is the realization of what Avner wants to believe: if he wants to believe he is just a murderer, then he will be treated as such, the only "redemption" he had was offered by Israel, but that wasnt enough for him. Thats at least how i interpreted it, of course

[@francisconsole3892]

Avner is the one with the tortured soul. Ephraim has no such concerns.

[@TesterBoy]

I doubt that the Mossad operatives ever regretted their actions (except in the case where one man was mistakenly killed).

[@robertoacevedo3805]

Welp! This aged well!

[@user-or6yn8pm3c]

No peace in the Middle East in 2023. Difference now is Israels allies are weakening and its enemies are stronger.

[@CSorgini]

@@user-or6yn8pm3ccolonial projects like this always fail eventually. If the people are united and strong enough they can withstand anything and they will fight back.

[@galacticlifeo1030]

*that accent though*

[@gordonhall9871]

i was 12 when all this started - followed it on ABC

[@drseuss5407]

Great people great movie

[@abhijeetvaishnab7738]

It’s my favourite movie

[@jamallabarge2665]

I don't understand why the handler didn't just put it on the line. "We trained you, we equipped you, the State of Israel is behind us and is still behind you. You committed to die for Israel to save Israel. Why do you indulge doubts now?"

[@jeffsor47]

Because he hadn't experienced the trauma of killing before, duh?

[@jamallabarge2665]

@@jeffsor47 "Because he hadn't experienced the trauma of killing before, duh?" Mossad employs Psychologists for this purpose. Psychologists to help prepare you, to debrief, you, to help you live with it. At least that's what I read from Victor Ostrovsky.

[@jeffsor47]

@@jamallabarge2665 Oh really? How long have you been in the Mossad, never?, really? You know less than nothing about these sort of things. I'll bet you've never heard of PTSD either. Comment about cooking or modern dance, you knw, something you're good at.

[@jeffsor47]

@Jonathan Birch You sound like a mental defective. Were you born with all 10 fingers and toes, just curious?

[@GABRIELADAWSON]

@@jamallabarge2665Ummm Intelligence Agencies usually Recruit Special Forces Operatives for International Missions but Ok.

[@texastoast5202]

Why did he say no to the dinner invite? I never knew why. Is there something hidden there or nothing at all!??!

[@KristianH1986]

Ephraim believes that he is struggling for the survival of Israel, and that Avner has chosen not to help in that struggle, and so Ephraim rejects Avner both because he is bitter about that rejection, and because Avner cannot pretend to be an Israeli without shouldering the burden of defending it.

[@texastoast5202]

@@KristianH1986 speaking of, do u know why Israeli and hamas are going at it again AND whose land does that belong to in your opinion?

[@KristianH1986]

I'm from Northern Ireland so I grew up in a very similar conflict. All I can say is, similar to Northern Ireland, one side has a very legitimate reason to lay claim to that land, however the other has now had generations and generations of their children live and claim that land as their own so the conflict cannot be agreed upon or will stop. One side wants one thing, the other doesnt and it can never be solved. @@texastoast5202

[@boomlazer5524]

Strangely, this channel has 30 million subscribers and the number of views is small and likes a maximum of 2000

[@Eye-of-Ra-2-27]

He referring to the “Devil” who is associated with Bread. Matt 4:4 “MAN SHALL NOT LIVE BY BREAD ALONE” The Devil has tricked everyone… But those who have eyes can see!

[@311Essie]

At the end he starts to realize he's more American than he is Jewish

[@fisherjohnson3440]

Are you guys ever going to do Shazam(2019)? It’s so hard getting good clips on KZbin.

[@jaiminsharma]

Try Flashback FM channel

[@KingDusk278]

Try buying the movie or watching it on movie streaming sites

[@absoabso7806]

No...

[@mac2105]

Which city/skyline is that? New York?

[@jiusepea9907]

Wonderful scene, thanks but why cut the last image with the twin towers ? Thanks again

[@jeffsor47]

Who flew into the Twin Towers, the Swedes? Duh.

[@jiusepea9907]

@@jeffsor47 what do you mean ?

[@jeffsor47]

@@jiusepea9907 Being facetious.

[@John-kv1xz]

Great movie

[@darbyheavey406]

Break bread with me……no…….just good operational security?

[@RICKONORATO]

What happened to their Australian accents?

[@3rdEyeWide]

They hid them in their kangaroo's pouch. They retrieved them shortly after the filming of this scene.

[@Andrew-Locksley691]

One big problem with this scene there location is on the east river looking west in 1975 the twin Towers of the world trade center would have dominated the skyline and been visible. Construction on the Towers was completed in 1973 .this movie was made in 2006 at that point There would have been a large void in the NYC skyline the freedom Tower would not have been constructed for another 10 years.I take back everything I just said I just watched the end and sure enough those magnificent Towers are visible. My bad

[@Andrew-Locksley691]

Correct but you should still see them.IDK but I do miss them !

[@HomeAtLast501]

This scene is totally ripped off from Three Days of the Condor.

[@jeshkam]

Slightly.

[@HomeAtLast501]

@@jeshkam Totally. You must be a half-wit. And that's okay.

[@jeshkam]

@@HomeAtLast501??? This scene has nothing to do with Three Days of the Condor WTF?

[@HomeAtLast501]

@@jeshkam Mr. Spielberg, I know it's embarrassing that you've been caught. But your humiliation doesn't justify profanity.

[@jeffsor47]

So?

[@SamLamsTop10Thankyoueveryone]

I never understood why he refused. Can someone explain?

[@nikfabbi87]

Probably because Avner is not willing to go back home, in Israel, so he basically rejects the way of life Ephraim embodies.

[@saghirhussain4360]

It's symbolic. Anver invited him out of a Jewish custom, Ephraim's rejection is a sign that he doesn't care about faith. The whole point of the film is to show that this is not about religion...

[@BrianSchiller-g9b]

Ephraim (Rush) represents the Israeli identity. When Bana's character (Avner) references their Jewish identity by asking him to come over and "break bread" and Epraim (Rush) says "no" and walks away, the writer, Kushner, who is an anti-Zionist btw, is basically saying that the Israelis have abandoned or lost their Jewish identity or character.

[@joshuaparker1726]

What about that woman he killed in her home?

[@jonnybirchyboy1560]

In reality, the Israeli assassin teams killed an innocent Moroccan waiter, and also a car bomb that killed a nun and a student. But they left that out the movie.

[@jeffsor47]

@@jonnybirchyboy1560 Did you know mistakes are sometimes made in war Jonny Bitchboy?

[@jeffsor47]

She knew the risks as an assassin.

[@jeffsor47]

What about her?

[@thejanagajasinghe5600]

I have this from 2006 . Worth intellectual movie.

[@BanjoLuke1]

There is an awkwardness watching this scene in December 2023, as the IDF ploughs its way through the overcrowded ghetto and wasteland that once was Gaza. I fear for Israel. It has lost its way and become a toy of the mad settlers of the West Bank and their bloodthirsty allies. Do I weep for the broken dream? I think perhaps I do. Now, there are monsters afoot.

[@speedking7224]

It has revealed its true colors

[@3rdEyeWide]

What do you expect is going to happen in the end? 70% of "Palestinians" supported the Oct 7th attacks (The PALESTINIAN Center for Policy and Survey Research). The "Palestinian's" own religion - 85-90% are Sunni Muslim - makes it a holy mission to get rid of Jews: Sahih Muslim 2922. Even a "moderate" "Palestinian" political entity like the "Palestinian Authority" has never published an Arabic charter that hasn't called for the destruction of Israel. The "Palestinians" have rejected two state solutions time and time again. At what point do you go "hmm... I think they might be sincere in not wanting a Jewish state at all". And how are other religious minorities doing at the hands of the adherents of "the religion of peace" in the ME?: "Christian Persecution in the Middle East reaching 'genocide-like' levels" - BBC 3rd May 2019. Christians made up a 1/5th of the ME population only a centur ago, now that's been whittled down to 5%, and Israel is the only ME country still with a discernible Jewish population.

[@CSorgini]

Man Looking at the History It was always this way.

[@CSorgini]

@@3rdEyeWideYou’ve shown a bunch of statistics but lets talk about that first one. “70% of Palestinians support the October 7 attacks” Yet, for someone so smart to list a bunch of numbers fails in humanity to ask “why” Why would they support that? Do you think it’s because they are trapped in an open air prison, maybe its because Israel controls the water and energy of gaza? Maybe its because they have decreased the fishing yields from 9km out to sea(where you can get the big catches) down to just 3km. Maybe it’s because for the last 75 years, the Palestinians have been ethnically cleansed. You fail to ask these questions and that makes you a close minded individual. So next time when you see a statistic like that maybe do some research into why.

[@3rdEyeWide]

@@CSorgini I don't even know what I'm responding to as my original post is no longer showing. Hmm... Did you run off to mummy and daddy and tell them I have been writing "naughty" things? You want the "why"? I don't know if I said it in my last comment or not. It is a tenet of the Islamic faith that Juice must be gotten rid of. Sahih Muslim 2922. 85-90% of the "Palestinians" are Sunni Muslim. Ever since it's inception the Islamic faith has been determined to ethnically cleanse the region (and eventually the world) of all other faiths/ideologies (but they have a particular hatred towards the Juice as they see them as evil and corrupt whilst people of faiths like Christianity are well intentioned but "misguided"). Look up what the phrase "After Saturday comes Sunday" means to people of the Islamic faith. BTW - Gaza shares a border with Eqypt which the Eqyptians keep closed. Doesn't that make Egypt "Palestinian" "Jailers" as well? (I wonder "why" Egypt does that. Maybe you should research what has happened to countries in the region when they have accepted "Palestinian" refugees - Jordan, Kuwait, Lebanon etc). I look forward to this comment being reported and deleted. “When you tear out a man's tongue, you are not proving him a liar, you're only telling the world that you fear what he might say.” - George R.R. Martin

[@The_OneManCrowd]

What's a "Sabra"?

[@jeffsor47]

A native born Israeli.

[@The_OneManCrowd]

@@jeffsor47 Oh ok. My Jewish friend calls his friend from Israel that sometimes in conversation.

[@Ole66]

Why has no one ever said that it is souped up version of The Sword of Gideon

[@jonnybirchyboy1560]

They’re both based on the same book.

[@lizardopalominolavander9111]

Pero aqui es como si barbossa fuera dovlado oor el doctor octopus boostrap bill turner

[@adamnoble1689]

I still don't know why he says "No."

[@covert0overt_810]

because he saw him as a tool .. and nothing more...

[@adamnoble1689]

@@covert0overt_810 damn. That is sad as hell

[@achintachakraborty347]

He couldn't be seen with someone who is excommunicardo 💀

[@covert0overt_810]

or not going "with the program" you're with us or against us ... the creed of every gang that ever lived@@achintachakraborty347

[@Jarod-vg9wq]

1:37 exactly!

[@lizardopalominolavander9111]

Y erix bana nacido en 1968 es igual al johnny depp nacido en 1963 porque son doblados por ricardo tejedo nacido en 1972

[@Adrian-vy5vn]

A nadie le importa

[@Loner4Eva23390]

Whats the city in the background?

[@rogerkincaid931]

New York.

[@stefanpieper3757]

New York. With Twin Towers.

[@allwaysamarine6528]

NYC, MY BIRTH HOME.

[@dakritic]

Downtown Disney

[@The_OneManCrowd]

@@dakritic Pleasure Island 🏝 LOL

[@anthonyrowland9072]

"Palestine" would be a long *very* deserved movie...

[@17-MASY]

Did you see Shaun's video titled Palestine?

[@anthonyrowland9072]

@@17-MASY No I have not...

[@17-MASY]

@@anthonyrowland9072 Just type "Shaun Palestine" here.

[@joebudi5136]

Why wouldn't he break bread? So he is a murderer?

[@timmaloney9976]

He's disavowing him, and considers him now no longer a fellow Israeli. Basically a stranger. It gives Avner no resolution as a result, and with the blood on his hands.

[@stefanpieper3757]

He doesn't break bread with people that don't exist.

[@joebudi5136]

@Gerd Wiesler I still don't get it.. wouldn't join the fight? He killed 7 guys for Israel.

[@ciaranoconnell4783]

The Israelis have a funny notion of loyalty. You must be all in without any other distractions or loyalties elsewhere.

[@Trexmaster12]

_”You must be all in without any other distractions or loyalties elsewhere.”_ How is that a funny notion of loyalty? That's the very definition of loyalty.

[@slametsupriyadi3538]

HECTOR BARBOSSA 😆