Red Dead Redemption || Choice & Sacrifice

A tribute to the character 'Arthur Morgan' brought to life by Roger Clark.
____________________________________________________________________
I've wanted to make a video about Arthur for some time, one showing the choices he had to make and the consequences that shaped and impacted those around him.
____________________________________________________________________
Song: Assassins Creed 4 Black Flag - Nassau Ambient theme
_____________________________________________________________________
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for fair use for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.

[@pvnkx]

this is the first time i’ve realized that John and Arthur both die in the same way. they both die fighting for who they love. this the the best edit i’ve seen, fr

[@willchalloner6643]

And both echo the same words “Go and don’t look back” before they sacrifice themselves

[@whalebone1206]

Me too.

[@scottnomore9489]

It meant a lot to him.

[@pwngeeves]

This video is proof that the best KZbin has to offer is often the most hidden. Thank you feller, you're a good man.

[@josephwatson4292]

What Hosea and Lenny say at the beginning of this video is so touching knowing that they both died in saint denis and are buried together (might be wrong in that last point but I am pretty sure).

[@rokkfel4999]

No your right they are burried right next together

[@notgoodbutitry3000]

@@rokkfel4999 wait were in saint denis?

[@rokkfel4999]

@@notgoodbutitry3000 ughhh damn I can’t remember it’s been like a year since I played but I know it’s out of the city itself

[@notgoodbutitry3000]

@@rokkfel4999 oh thanks

[@bodhip]

@@notgoodbutitry3000they were buried together, north of Saint Denis in the swamplands

[@Abhinavmodders]

Can't stop my tears R.I.P Mr. Morgan 💐💔

[@natalia4303]

And John ❤ [*]😢

[@thecowboy9698]

"You know all that ever mattered to me was loyalty? It's all I knew, it's all I ever believed in." - Arthur Morgan. "I'm an uneducated killer sent here to do all I can do well." - John Marston. "I've got a plan." - Dutch Van Der Lynde. "I'm a survivor. That's all there is, living, and dying." - Micah Bell. "You're the only one of these fools that I trust." - Sadie Adler. "I've been doing this long enough to know that you dont hire a Saint to catch a Sinner." - Sherrif Maloy. "Maybe it's a sign... try, try to do the good thing." - Mary-Beth. "He didn't have a choice. He was good, and he did good." - Edith Downes. "You can never change a person. We only become more of who we really are." - Chief Rains Fall. "If we were all like you, things might've turned out differently." - Reverend Swanson. "Take a gamble that love exists, and do a loving act." - Sister ... (Can't remember her name off-hand.)

[@notgoodbutitry3000]

Nice

[@bbrandumbb]

"You can never change a person, we only become who we really are. " hits hard. Playing the second game before the first game and seeing what Dutch turned into, a decent man who helped the poor and did everything he could for the gang into a no good blood-thirsty killer broke my heart. Imagining what Arthur and Hosea would say, Dutch's brother and son, sometimes I'm glad they both passed...so they wouldn't see who Dutch really was.

[@coolrank12]

Sister Calderón

[@justice_of_Youtube]

@@bbrandumbb they can see him bruh, they saw what he became, ever heard of heaven?

[@mr.jameson218]

@@justice_of_KZbin Have you ever considered any belief other than your own?

[@UnfortunateSon7]

Even micha admitted that Arthur is a good noble man at 4:54 That’s how much he is good 😞

[@Colter94]

when he said that i mean in the game?

[@obamareloadsyt629]

Przemogrzemo in chapter 6 camp interaction

[@Linnnaeus]

Maybe this is the gold that Dutch was after

[@quantumgamer5072]

I'm gonna find whoever left that one dislike and give them a stern talking to what greatness is!

[@CraftBlox45]

Damn O'Driscoll!

[@CraftBlox45]

@Tristan Norvelle Thx

[@eadn1392]

The way Micah talks about Arthur towards the end makes it sound like they are actually friends. Imagine their bond if he didnt lie and betray the gang

[@sebastiendokmajian2310]

Where was that scene taken? I don’t remember that in the game cutscenes and it’s only a voice over

[@spikey288]

@@sebastiendokmajian2310 it's an optional dialogue in camp

[@mr.jameson218]

They could've had a buddy cop movie.

[@skellington1094]

I disagree

[@mrcliche9252]

That line with Micah at 4:50, makes me show that he actually did respect Arthur if not loved him like a brother, I hated Micah at the end of the game but, hearing that, gave me some better perspective into Micah, I can’t forgive him for what he did, but I can say I don’t hate much no more.

[@abdusalim4610]

I don't know about Loving him as brother, but he definitely respected Arthur's toughness, they all did

[@mr.jameson218]

Micah didn't care about the gang at any point. Micah saw the world through a lense of gray. There was no right or wrong, only surviving and dying. He seemed to only respect those who controlled the former and latter. Arthur was a capable killer and thus, earned Micah's respect.

[@thefacelessquestion3333]

Good thinking ,cowpoke.

[@Liam_Graer]

Isn't that Micah telling his boys/back up that joins the gang as it falls apart to watch out for Arthur as he is a "good guy almost a modern day hero like a cowboy in a little book" and that he is the one to hide the planning and sabotage from?!? I mean he isnt sayin hey guys this is Arthur hes the man hea saying this is one of the worst bloody do gooders i warned you about

[@sirsabr7960]

Arthur’s story is one of the best if not the best gaming story ever, no one will ever change my mind on that, Rest In Peace Arthur, and thank you for the best Arthur tribute I’ve ever seen...

[@severton3814]

i completely agree it was the best story best game ever no game can change that

[@elseantheophilus]

I like this... RIP Author Morgan

[@michellewithboyz]

Arthur

[@arthurmorgan6642]

Morgan was an author I didn’t know what books did he wrote?

[@michellewithboyz]

@@arthurmorgan6642 shut the f up 😂😂😂

[@25geagle]

Red Dead Redemption 1 & 2 will always be remembered for its graphics, open world gameplay, honor but most importantly, its characters we grew to hate and love. I thank Rockstar for giving us the game and masterpiece.

[@Guyson1999]

I find that Arthur Morgan gives the players a hard choice. I cried at the end

[@coolrank12]

"Take a gamble that loves exist and do a loving act!" Brilliant quote from Mother Superior Calderón aka Sister Calderón

[@joshlovesays]

“Mrs. Adler, ride with me”. Goddamn the chills I get.

[@Lucifer777_]

The greatest video game ever made. Hands down. I would dare to say, the greatest thing ever displayed on a screen for entertainment.

[@charlesniemann1987]

AGREED

[@Shaprilleigh]

OMG!! Speechless!! Really well made Couchy. Absolutely love it.

[@CouchyEdits]

Thank you kind stranger ;)

[@goinbelowzero14]

Arthur wasn't a bad man. He wasn't an outlaw. He wasn't a merciless blood-thirsty killer. He was someone who was scared to die. But he was also a man who was tired of fighting. He was tired of fighting, he was tired of running. He knew it was his time to go when he climbed up onto that cliff and saw the sunrise. Rest easy, Arthur 💔

[@axdde6428]

He was an outlaw but not a bad person

[@goinbelowzero14]

@@axdde6428 so true.

[@tavish4699]

when micah punched arthur in the face it hurt so much

[@zaydqazi9134]

Can't stop thinking about how Roger Clark did the motion picture for Mary grieving over Arthur's grave in the final cutscenes

[@Deliberately_Enigmatic]

When Arthur says Sure I'll be dead soon and the music was very sad and I am the kind of guy that cries or not usually but that made me starts to cry

[@randomstuffofgamingrg4784]

This game its just beautiful, the story, the environment, the characters everything is just perfect and this goes to both games. Rockstar didnt screw up the story like some other games, they made it perfect. And this tribute resembles that. Very well done!

[@moajek322]

How have this only 845 views.... this is the best edit I have ever seen.

[@Leon_S._Kennedy]

Idk

[@hellfireassassin211]

the tilly scene is heart warming and tear shaking

[@mr_pwkd5465]

I’ve seen a lot of these tributes & this is the most underrated by farrrr

[@hellfireassassin211]

wish we had more people like arthur in the world

[@atruegentleman6370]

There wouldn't be much of a world left

[@epicafleur]

I don't know why is this video have so small viewers. This make me sad. Creator, if you you looked at this comment, you made a grate work. Thank you so much

[@hanialaa3915]

Such an underrated video. I love coming back to these videos and tributes to Arthur and John remembering the game and it’s moments. My best game ever.

[@nathanrichards9379]

You have some talent feller guy. This is the best edit I have seen by far. Thank you for this hidden gem.

[@tovalhall97]

I became sad when Athur died in the game the same I have to Jonh R.I.P

[@20AY11]

Just today this is my 3rd time watching this video Wooow this deserves is on of the best tributes ever made for Arthur Morgan 😭😭😭😭..... thank you for this your a good man 🌹

[@DkSejlin]

Arthur Morgan is by far the greatest character ever created in any game, movie or book. His character arc is insane and the amount of emotions he manages to build up within you, as you play the game is enormous. I love that man like a brother. Rest in piece Mr. Morgan. Great tribute mate. Eyes got teary.

[@charlesniemann1987]

FINALLY SOMEONE SAID IT LIKE THIS….ARTHUR MORGAN…IS BASICALLY THE JESUS OF ENTERTAINMENT AND ART AND THE GREATEST OF THE GREATEST

[@tylerbrown2469]

I cannot think of a more gratifying way to go out other than to give my life for my friends or family.

[@staytrue5307]

Can not*

[@juutuubnoob]

Great edit! Found this one in my recommendations and im glad I clicke it.

[@montexd]

How does this only have 200 likes?

[@bihox96]

Great tribute, mate! ;)

[@peters8512]

One of the best RDR2 edits I've seen. That it's only just come up on my KZbin compared to lesser edits with hundreds of thousands of views is a travesty.

[@RepoManInIndy]

I've said it before and I'll say it again.. Arthur Morgan is the best man I've known.. fictional character or not, I learned more from him than a lot of real people I've met..

[@garrettadams6158]

I knew I recognized this music from somewhere, but it took me a bit longer than it should have to remember where

[@SonLam2k1]

Awesome and sad at the same time thanks you buddy you make my day

[@davidladouceur8582]

You can see the heavens shining down on him at 7:30 🥺❤️ such a beautiful thing to see ❤

[@catatonic9328]

Really well made, well done 👏 Also.. I'm not crying you are.

[@xjamiec]

2 years later I'm going back down the Arthur Morgan rabbit hole, still brings a tear to the eye. Absolute legend

[@charlesniemann1987]

out of all the characters in all the books tv shows movies music art and all else ever created in this world and all others…ARTHUR MORGAN IS THE GREATEST PERFECT CHARACTER AND NUMBER ONE TO EVER EXIST THROUGH IT ALL..HES WHAT ALL MEN SHOULD BE AND NEED TO BE HE IS WHAT GODS VISION FOR THE PERFECT MAN WAS MEANT TO BE

[@arthurmorgan8756]

Buell is just like arthur. A great companion and with a big heart.

[@aideninishdaragh1407]

Just wow! Great job!

[@Red83256]

You left me speechless for about 5 minutes, all I have to say is well done.

[@devilred18]

Arthur dies at the top of a mountain. Implying he did his best to become the man people saw him as. John died defending his family. Showing he wasn't a good man but he was willing to do right by his family. Dutch died at the bottom of a mountain looking up at the man he ran from. This is poetic and none can tell me different

[@staytrue5307]

I can tell you different, you copied multiple comments, be original.

[@moazasiri5897]

This is just too epic good job man it hit me right in the feels

[@iameatingtrifle]

I'm almost 58 and I've been playing video games since they started, I remember playing pong when it first came out and text adventures. I've played on more systems and computers than I can remember. In my opinion Red Dead Redemption IS the best game I have ever played in all that time !! Great upload, thanks Couchy

[@monkeydcody30]

This is amazing.

[@mattfan5]

Thank you, I’ve watched just about every tribute to red dead and this is honestly one of the best. Thank ya friend.

[@fbitaco]

John died Arthur died god I cry every time both great players

[@batmqnq]

Brilliant, you are classes as an artist in my mind for making this video

[@kahlbutomacfarland]

Just dawned on me that Abigail had to ride off from two different men both knowing they were going to die to save her.

[@captainstu]

She’s had the easiest out of the whole gang (apart from Tilly Jackson and Karen)

[@kahlbutomacfarland]

@@captainstu I’m not the biggest Abi fan, but the easiest? John did abandon her with a newborn for a year. Easiest probably would have been Molly before she went crazy with middle school jealousy. Seemed literally nothing was expected of her.

[@inodinojan878]

Best tribute i've seen

[@wildbill9728]

Micah's monologue is very fitting, and that last part when he said "back in the day" that hit hard. funny how he was the enemy the whole ride with the gang.

[@jackbrooks1252]

I will always remember those words from the Sister. ‘There is nothing to be afraid of.’

[@johnson66775]

LENNY MY BOY !!!

[@kingfoudomilani]

such a great video dude keep it up

[@khairulanwar3915]

who tf dislike this masterpiece

[@samhussain4954]

All them years,20years Aurthur gave his whole life to Dutch and Dutch left him at the end he could have saved him and shot micah

[@allinonedirection1949]

He could not be saved cause of tb but he can kill Micah for that shit

[@euandougall1713]

@@allinonedirection1949 dutch lost everything and I think in that final moment saw micah for what he was and did. I think he left in shock but he did eventually shoot him

[@matthewfinnerty6747]

Extremely well made man keep it up

[@speedyspider5426]

Jacks kid: dad what made grandpa leave that gang in those stories you tell Jack: alot of things but it was thanks to my uncle that grandpa realized what was best Jacks kid: what where they like? Jack: just men looking for redemption

[@justinkevin9635]

Great!!

[@billybamboom]

I like the song choice btw 🏴‍☠️

[@saintwabbajack]

It's beautiful

[@x_m_gaming8686]

nice video I liked 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻

[@dhrunssofast]

I'am crying...

[@scottjacobs7162]

We need a rdr 3 to find out about what happened in blackwater a game set before rdr2 just to get to play as Arthur more I need him back

[@gucciducci4386]

Their deaths tears me apart and I can’t tell who lost more in the end as arthor only family fell apart before he died but he was able to save Jonh’s small family when he knew they still had a chance and John died leaving his son to follow in his foot steps and abigail to die shortly after

[@V0LD3R]

Damn, its so sad..

[@LeanDada19]

Great video ,aurther is the best video game protagonists of all time and Charles is the best side character aswell

[@BryndenStrom]

That‘s just an awesome edit

[@puzzelflame3872]

love how all sacrefices in the red dead games are yust thrown out the window

[@timdj9826]

If you did not experience any of the following: be brought to tears, have watery eyes or let out a HUGR sigh during this video....... you may wanna check your pulse!!

[@thatjohnguyduh]

Those 4 dislikes are Micah and his goons

[@deebhoymcw2120]

I always thought marstons son was actually Arthur’s just the way Abigail acts towards Arthur

[@ArthurMorgan]

Thank you feller

[@RocknRolla0772]

Oh Arthur - don't you Arthur me. Funny and sad. They should make a movie from RDR in Hollywood with Morgan Freeman, Robert de Niro, AL Pacino and more like Once upon a time in the west

[@IronStaff7]

Its called Red Dead REDEMPTION for a reason folks

[@Lyxis]

Damn.... Jack really did lose everybody he loved

[@justsomerandombirdwithinte5896]

im just sad that arthurs sacrafice was practically for nothing

[@sebastiendokmajian2310]

Pleaseeeeeeeeee rockstar make a game about jack marston after the events of rd1

[@captainstu]

Only problem is it could get too modern

[@axdde6428]

@@captainstu Don't need to be red dead

[@Lucidplays34]

This video made me realize that Abigail probably knew John is going to die there. Hoped he wouldn't but with it being like with Arthur.. Also Arthur and John die in the warmth of the sun (even though their deaths were brutal), micah and dutch die in the cold and snow.

[@miniplier2960]

I want a red dead redemption 1 remaster.

[@bemethorband3859]

He may be a fictional character, but I was taking away when i walked up that hill at the end and i started...crying. i mean who didnt?

[@thefacelessquestion3333]

Damn Seems I need to play RDR1

[@vegetablack8114]

When did Micah say this fella's Arthur?

[@CouchyEdits]

Camp interaction at Beaver Hollow when his two other mates show up

[@hanialaa3915]

1:46 John remembering..

[@toogee1850]

When does Micah say that about Arthur? Him being a warrior and everything, played the game 3 times and I've never heard that before just curious.

[@christophercolumbus1169]

He says it to Joe and Cleet while they’re all sitting together at Beavers Hollow in Chapter 6

[@kuplungtv467]

You.... made me cry. I hate you. :(

[@ThatHanniganfellow]

Where did you get those lines from Micah???

[@CouchyEdits]

A camp interaction after Joe And Cleet show up.

[@nadja9055]

@@CouchyEdits I remember it..

[@severton3814]

i think agent Milton and Edgar Ross was the real villain.

[@icon_godey]

So fucking sad

[@kyleseageruberalles2222]

2:49 - 4:01

[@kaanseyhun7041]

Bro straight up used ac 4 music

[@RobotSpy13]

Where was that micah dialogue from

[@saintwabbajack]

When Micah brought his goons to the last camp, he introduces Arthur to them with this speech

[@daisymallender3868]

i wanna play red dead 3 as sadie