Mrs. Fields vs. Crumbl Cookies Taste Test | Food Feuds

[@MADblogVideo]

stevie: the only thing that makes me feel good is a naked man. everyone: *collective doubt*

[@Pizza4Lunch]

All the single straight men watching are celebrating.

[@WillttocSicated]

@@Pizza4LunchIn perpetual hope 😂

[@DietBajaBlast]

So next episode a woman will come on set and walk around in a bikini. Right?

[@WillttocSicated]

@@DietBajaBlast That’s reserved for Good Mythical Evening

[@levithebaddest2369]

😂

[@rachel4339]

I never knew how badly I needed a man to tear away his shirt and present a beautifully worded monologue lamenting the passage of time and its impact on cookies, but man, that really lifted my spirits! 😂

[@Shebeast3]

same🎉

[@igolffff]

I'd prefer if Stevie did it

[@elizabethgeorge168]

Nothing against Mrs. Fields, but I think a better comparison would be Insomnia Cookies vs. Crumbl 🍪

[@elizabethgeorge168]

​@@OldManYellsAtCloudsbecause of the specialty or "gourmet" flavors, rotating menu, etc. Closer quality and price point.

[@peggarick2756]

Yeah, I thought the same! I've had Insomnia but not Crumbl, but they seem to be more similar to each other.

[@DKF_oli]

i said the same thing, totally agree.

[@gibu002]

Who?

[@abbeyk6064]

insomnia wins in my book

[@melindarivera6598]

15:31 you should take the price into consideration with these. That's $10 difference between the two

[@swasome5821]

Size/value wise they are the same value, or nearly the same value. At the end of the day though, I am not buying mini cookies at either price.

[@HeHateMe1]

Link would struggle greatly trying to factor price into the mix and giving a ranking. I LOVE IT!!!

[@melindarivera6598]

@@swasome5821 very true!!!

[@colon_sausage]

6 mini cookies for $17.99 is ridiculous

[@miapark9748]

That's exactly what I was thinking like wtf!

[@mage1439]

Yeah, I buy a dozen doughnuts every month and they're $7 and I already feel like that's too much. No, thanks, mini cookies.

[@rachelspencer777]

I came here to say this

[@ericaneilsen2817]

I don't think that pricing is right. That is not what it costs where I live.

[@jakegreedy3247]

@@ericaneilsen2817 You have to remember that they are in LA, everything is more expensive lol

[@gretchman]

The appropriate-ness of Chase delivering that letter while wearing a Taskmaster sweatshirt is absolutely wonderful.

[@hurbanlegendss]

Came here to comment the same thing 😍

[@zd523]

i love that Josh probably went to the producers and said “i haven’t been shirtless in awhile, can we change that?”

[@gypsyfox3285]

Right! 😂

[@highlycaffeinated6864]

😅

[@savaunbrown]

He's obsessed w the fact that he's very very slightly muscular

[@korndud]

he was flexing his abs so hard during that speech lmao 🤣

[@iMakeTheSpackle]

@@savaunbrown Na if he where obsessed with looking muscular he wouldn't primarily do crossfit.

[@radix4801]

Wait, Mrs Fields started her company when she was just a Little Debbie? How did this not get more attention?

[@Tehilla-v8q]

josh delivering a monologue shirtless was not on my bingo card for this morning

[@unorthodoxnoobs]

It should always be

[@BeppeTorped]

And here I thought I was straight

[@jacqueline8121]

I feel like we should be more prepared for things like this than we were

[@patrickblakethesaint]

But he's always shirtless and often monologs... its my entire bingo card

[@bobl9993]

Yea I wasn't expecting that either 😅

[@iPatchT-T]

Wow 1:07 Never did I ever in my wildest dreams expect something even close to that in a show like GMM.

[@sethpino2963]

What lmao have you watched the show before?

[@iPatchT-T]

@@sethpino2963 regularly

[@SimplySarah1990]

Are you new here?

[@notyourlioness1625]

17,99$ for six mini cookies is INSANITY 💀

[@iamyou3080]

Yeah, like absolutely not. I can make my own cookies.

[@VineyardGHS]

Joe Biden did that lol

[@thestraydog]

​@@VineyardGHS You realize that these cookies have been ridiculously overpriced for like... a decade now?

[@sethweir8752]

@@thestraydogyou realize they were only founded 2017.. not to mention popularized till years later. Not even half a decade

[@Nakia11798]

Very much so. We have a local specialty cookie place and you can get 6 regular-sized cookies for $8 and tax.

[@lynnlove14300]

That Josh bit was specifically put in for me

[@lejluminati4832]

idc about cookies, the real winner was my eyes 😌

[@purepunk18]

Im sorry, 6 mini chocolate chip cookies for $17.99 American!!??!! Does it also contain hidden treasures!?

[@EarthCybebe]

No it contains the disillusion of the American Dream

[@mage1439]

Depends. Would you consider diabetus a hidden treasure?

[@24hproduction30]

It’s called diabetes

[@luisdefilippo]

@@EarthCybebe bhahaha this is perfect !!!!

[@christinasanders4962]

I literally had to rewind to have her say that again, because I was in disbelief

[@alexandercampbell7903]

Forget mall cookies. I love the smell of mall pretzel.

[@p3rs3arsk4]

Remember when Link once said "shookie coogar" instead of "sugar cookie" and no one noticed, but I did. I thought about it the whole episode.

[@Andrea-cg4xm]

Please😭😭 what episode??

[@p3rs3arsk4]

@@Andrea-cg4xm GMMore - Gross Condiment Cookies Taste Test, timestamp at 09:09 😅

[@ejghostmez6195]

@@p3rs3arsk4👑

[@Midrealm_DM]

16:08 - *Entrapment:* the action of tricking or enticing someone into committing a crime that they were otherwise not inclined to do.

[@entropy9101]

Crumbl cookies are way too overhyped and very mid for how much they cost.

[@empressboogie1213]

Wholeheartedly agree, I don’t like their cookies at all

[@ThatMidnightRambler]

​@@empressboogie1213they aren't bad if you split one with 3 other people lol a whole cookie is too much

[@prasiolite]

The one I got just tasted like it wasn't cooked. It was revolting.

[@jesse6851]

At least the 4 pack is a decent value

[@JG-yk6ny]

For sure, and they are so sickly sweet and overly rich.

[@kellinomnom]

'Nibbler' is a character on Futurama. ❤️😀

[@philm5380]

To shreds, you say?

[@justnone9809]

why didn’t they compare it to Insomnia cookies? why would they compare to store bought

[@AF_StarrProductions]

Insomnia is so good

[@MarinaraSauce78]

Ms. Field’s is a bakery with a storefront too.

[@DKF_oli]

it’s not the store bought mrs fields, but i agree it should have been insomnia. they’re much more popular these days and more similar in other ways IMO.

[@debthomas8799]

Store bought? Which is store bought? I can walk into a Crumbl cookie bakery and buy freshly made ones and I can walk into Mrs Fields bakery to buy freshly made ones. I guess technically both are store bought.

[@olanaowen7320]

Mrs. Fields stores/bakeries used to be EVERYWHERE.

[@The44kGaming]

7:42 casually says ... "you're special Link..."

[@Stefstylezz]

Hahaha, Stevies *WHAT* at 16:28 is gold

[@Humanh8red]

1:27 I AM CRYING

[@QuayHollywood]

Good morning! Next, do Insomnia v Crumble.

[@dissonancE..]

Are there Insomnias on the west coast? I thought that was mostly a north east thing. My absolute favorite 2am cookie spot though so if there is they should 100% get some.

[@iugtlkf]

@@dissonancE..we have insomnias in florida so maybe an East coast thing

[@riro7170]

I haven't watched gmm in awhile, i'm glad i chose to watch today's ep💀

[@RapMaRzRemixes]

Mini Cookies $17.99 for 6 on one side and $7.99 for 6 on the other. Was that an error, cause price should factor in the ratings if it's that much more expensive

[@Nakia11798]

$7.99 is absolutely reasonable for 6 cookies, but $17.99? No

[@LordDragox412]

When you're rich like them the price difference doesn't matter, only the taste. After all, what is $10 difference, that's like what, a single banana? /s

[@thomasleonardis711]

That’s like 8 bananas bruh.

[@EllieBelle1993]

@@thomasleonardis711”how much could a banana cost anyways? $10?” It’s a quote from the show arrested development 😂

[@thomasleonardis711]

@@EllieBelle1993 oh ok. That whooshed right over my head. My bad. lol.

[@alexsis1778]

10:57 Link is so right when he said "It's too much!". The comments definitely support you Link. As for Rhett, these comments definitely don't seem to be loving it. Crumbl is ok at best, but not worth the cost.

[@mavzdog]

Not a big fan of crumbl. They’re not “cookies,” and they are always too sweet

[@alyssawssinging4039]

They calories are insane too haven’t had one since I new how much calories are in a crumbl cookie

[@EvanPedersen-p1u]

Tried them once, won't do it again!

[@archieman68]

tried a sliver of a vanilla cookie with vanilla icing after carrying it half across a hotel on a school trip and it was so bad. Also their boxes are so flimsy that thing was scary in the elevator.

[@lauracarruba6347]

​@@alyssawssinging4039 yessss it's like a full day's calories for a pretty good cookie.

[@Xsyven]

I really like the first bite, but then I suffer through the rest of the cookie. Meanwhile, Mrs. Fields tastes like aluminum.

[@adamhenderson6943]

I don’t even need to watch the video. Crumbl doesn’t make cookies. It’s like some weird mutant cookie shaped cake hybrid thing. But it is definitely not a cookie.

[@aawillma]

Tbh if they called them cakies or something it woulda been nailed.

[@kristenm9832]

It's not even good cake, too dense

[@DesignBurgess]

Okay Link…

[@adamhenderson6943]

@@DesignBurgess lol I posted this like immediately after I started the video! I didn’t even get to Link’s comments yet.

[@scoob1670]

100% agree

[@JamesUK85]

$4-5 for ONE cookie?! That's wild.

[@MattMcConaha]

If you can't get a full company match on your 401k then you can't afford these cookies.

[@Nakia11798]

Yeah, we have a local specialty cookie place and their cookies are approx $4, but that's AFTER tax, and they're really good cookies.

[@stinamaddox2433]

Cookies for rich people.

[@Crofflzron]

those prices are for ONE cookie? I thought it was for the 4-cookie box. One cookie für 4 or 5$ ... why?

[@arixkuun]

it's a pretty big cookie lol

[@ericadams4898]

Josh is so funny. That dude will do anything to entertain. Thanks for a good laugh to start the day. 😂

[@Werewolf_Korra]

Nice of Josh to assist the GMM channel. Helping the little people. 😉

[@henri1298]

6 mini cookies for $17.99 is so criminal. People pay that?

[@XxCrankyMoosexX]

Obese people who are on social media too much.

[@beesvoyage1833]

Good mythical evening from Asia! 🎉

[@omegaclan4326]

stevie loving josh’s performance was just icing on the cake for me 😂

[@justachick9793]

Hello, Josh. 😅 I hope Johnny Cakes is tuning in this morning. 😂

[@thestraydog]

Jonny Cakes is gonna be the sole reason that there's gonna be a "most watched" banner of that part

[@phillipschuck]

Links face expressions get me every time 😂😂😂😂 I love you guys 😂❤❤❤❤

[@MrWizards1974]

Crumbl has too much flower in the mix for me. More like cake not like cookie. I have never had a Mrs. Fields cookie I didn't like.

[@tiarahudson4241]

Yea, Crumbl is way too much into cake territory for me. Not the consistency I’m going for.

[@mangomash8396]

To be fair, the definition of a cookie is literally “a small flat or slightly raised cake”

[@MrWizards1974]

@@mangomash8396 You define it however you like but you cant flatten a cake and call it a cookie.😜

[@DanielJacobs-rz1zl]

​@@MrWizards1974You kinda can but that's not what they are.

[@kaileyxrae]

That was a beautiful monologue, Josh. Thank you for that🤣🤣🫶🏼

[@UrsusUrsa]

Josh revealing what's under his shirt was a real Ned Flanders Sweater moment, had no idea thats what he was packing

[@blodpudding]

You obviously don't watch Mythical Kitchen, he's shirtless a lot over there.

[@DietBajaBlast]

@@blodpudding And where are the women in skimpy clothing? Sexist standard and you know it

[@emdrozz]

Yeah the fact that we ever see Josh IN the shirt is a miracle

[@jijitters]

I guess you've never watched Good Mythical Evening. This is an old sight by this point lol

[@themaskedcrusader]

How many people are tacitly trying to correct Rhett that German Chocolate isn't from Germany?

[@nature4083]

good morning early risers!

[@cannongerber3257]

It’s always funny to see that one person who thinks everyone lives in the same time zone

[@fancynecromancy]

Definitely working overnight

[@carenb3204]

It’s 3am in California, and I haven’t slept yet…

[@Bludlungg]

Watching this at night but good morning🙏🙏

[@nature4083]

@@cannongerber3257well i’m saying it to the early risers of my timezone.

[@madlad29]

I highly agree with Link this episode and personally would put most cookies ahead of Crumbl. They are verrry overrated and very cake-like. It's like the Starbucks of cookies. There is a specific culture that goes there just because it's "fancy and trending" when in reality, if you have lived a little and explored a variety of these things in your time, then you know that just ain't it at all.

[@elizabethgeorge168]

@@madlad29 I've never felt so validated lol. I'm glad that the majority her seem to agree that Crumbl is 1) not cookies 2) undercooked/weird texture and 3) wayyyy overpriced

[@DanielJacobs-rz1zl]

​@@elizabethgeorge168Only the third part is true everything else is not and not a lot of people really agree with those.

[@leealot]

Of course my mom walks in durning Josh’s monologue

[@MrVovansim]

Did she like what she saw?

[@Shebeast3]

she caught the good stuff hehe

[@Buddystemz]

Are you preteen?

[@skearney9786]

Chase with the taskmaster sweater, love it

[@carollollol]

Come on!! Those aren't SMALL, those are NORMAL size cookies.

[@QueenJaneway]

Tell me you’re European without telling me you’re European 😂

[@Cheezytoasty1]

Crumbl "cookies" are way to sweet ive never even come close to finishing one. Its like biting into a cake thats way to sugary and doughy. They dont taste good at all.

[@tashabishop1515]

I love sugary and doughy, they just aren’t that great lol

[@DanielJacobs-rz1zl]

​@@tashabishop1515They are.

[@wesleyrussell8386]

In the description, "we're pinning (pitting?) two cookie powerhouses against each other"- you KNOW you wanted to say "two bad batches"

[@margeryk000]

Chase said "Thank You" in ASL. Very Cool.

[@imKlutchx]

I didn’t even sleep yet , good mythical insomnia 😭

[@leapot6972]

So real 😭help us

[@staywavyfriends]

Same here

[@zd523]

they didn’t do insomnia cookies though

[@tooturtly]

🧟‍♂️

[@UrsusUrsa]

I'm in my last hour of a 12 hour shift, so right here with ya

[@purplefn3587]

The crumbl cookies I had were half raw in the middle and sickly sweet. The chocolate with strawberry cheesecake icing was the only good one but even that was so sweet I could never have more than half

[@markekar6021]

bleh, crumbl isnt very good

[@Nakia11798]

The boys seemed to agree

[@dereks7745]

Very overrated.

[@arixkuun]

to each their own...

[@quinnzelreign8775]

I thought I was on my own with that opinion. All my friends love Crumbl and I think it's absolutely disgusting.

[@madddie.]

i love josh soo much

[@quintessences]

I’m hoping crumbl looses. It’s so expensive and the cookies are so sweet I can’t even finish 1 cookie.

[@yuvury1809]

They have about 700 calories in one cookie i heard

[@EK-xz8ig]

And they are just round "bars", or mini cakes in essence. Not cookies

[@klausjones5786]

To be fair, one cookie is not a serving. 1/4 is a serving. So that is an unfair statement

[@quintessences]

@@klausjones5786 but I think the implied serving of a cookie is a singular cookie. So it’s not unreasonable for one to assume the same w crumbl.

[@ChristiKolter]

@@yuvury1809700 is on the lower end. Most of their bigger ones are around 1000

[@Hammmmyy]

"Informative yet worthless" - Link 2024 8:56

[@lonerider5315]

Crumbl way to much sugar, and really most of the "cookies" taste the same

[@stephtaylor6292]

8:16 Is it just me or did they bite a perfect Wutang clan symbol in the cookie 🧐

[@jimmyispromo]

Yea... kinda lol

[@SilentlyCEO]

wow ​@@jimmyispromo idk you were a MB lol 😅

[@Cali_Em87]

Crumbl just tastes like it’s underdone sometimes

[@toddclark8398]

Absolutely 💯

[@jpete907]

That’s why it’s called crumbl they are cooked that way

[@undvined]

Because it is. In some places they are straight-up raw dough.

[@TheBigDean18]

Which is why I love them lol

[@belialbathory2299]

Because they are PURPOSELY under baking cookies. Food poisoning and saminila is their main seller.

[@deeann9066]

I want to see you guys do a collaboration with Josh and Ollie from the channel Jolly in the UK. They are awesome and I think you guys would have a blast together

[@triciamulan5982]

Thank you for that monologue. I really needed a good… monologue.

[@aSinisterKiid]

Mrs. Fields peanut butter cookie is so good. I could eat a 100 of them

[@madisonsmith7679]

MINNESOTA MENTIONED 🗣️

[@BiologicalEngineer]

I remember going to the original crumbl location all the time. Its absolutely wild to me that such a small town business from Logan, UT has come so far!!

[@Mrmigi1000]

Crumbl cookies are just too sweet in general. Lack of balance.

[@tooturtly]

i don't know crumble cookies. 😢

[@DanielJacobs-rz1zl]

It's really not.

[@iAmTrentMiller]

nothin like watching these silly videos on what cookies taste better, helps me forget about everything for a while!

[@Todd-pq5ih]

Never had Crumbl. Not sure they're on the east coast, but their prices are insane.

[@tiarahudson4241]

Crumbl is all over the US

[@lant7123]

The prices are somewhat justified because of their unwieldy size. One "cookie" is like 3.

[@riabouchinska]

They have them in New Hampshire and Massachusetts anyway

[@japanesecinema6736]

Crumbl is way too sweet...

[@staywavyfriends]

When Gen X cookies and Gen Z cookies collide in a head-to-head showdown.

[@grahamtiedtke]

Always love when the crew laughs in the back

[@knockoutking3764]

I love Mrs Fields! I have never had Crumbl

[@blcjackal6251]

Rhett hangin on to that $20

[@davidfox2360]

Cookies are not supposed to be cake-like.

[@mea3665]

You might want to look that up !

[@EK-xz8ig]

Even if they are, they need that slightly caramelized bottom to give it some structure

[@JohnnyL-d6c]

Looked it up. Cookies aren't supposed to be cake-like ​@@mea3665

[@juliotorres3147]

Who said? You? LMFAO

[@marr1235]

@@juliotorres3147Him and about 2 million other people… maybe a lot more. Also Link. But Link is… well… Link, so…

[@jimmyispromo]

That mrs fields brownie looks perfect

[@heathen_cooks]

Crumbl cookies are way too sweet

[@auzzydoesit8660]

1:00 why does Josh give me Mac from Always Sunny vibes, like "I got all this muscle we gotta do something with it" lol love you Josh!

[@TweaBandit]

gotta say, this might be the earliest I've ever seen an episode of GMM!!!

[@vipvip5356]

Link is the cookie police hahahahah: '' It's too muuuuch ! '' '' They gotta know where the line is ! '' '' They need to be carefull '' this was very funny !

[@isabella_gracee]

if you're seeing this comment, i hope you become a billionaire

[@nomoresaul]

Thanks, you too

[@cory356]

Never going to happen

[@estellawalsh217]

nah, only way to become a billionaire is to exploit others

[@ChristiKolter]

Perfect, now I can buy some overpriced mini cookies

[@ketameanii]

i don’t want to become a billionaire

[@Annie-pz5cr]

all my experiences at crumbl have solidified over and over that they’re really not good at all

[@JohnnyL-d6c]

It's crazy because the best cookies come from Subway lol

[@refinedsugar]

Are you in the States? You guys get the footlong cookie down there yet?

[@JohnnyL-d6c]

@@refinedsugar Yeah I haven't had one yet are they good?

[@refinedsugar]

@@JohnnyL-d6c not bad, but too pricey

[@tngirlintx1195]

WOOOOO HOOOOO….Josh coming in to save Stevie’s Day…👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼

[@ryderhann9948]

You guys really don’t play with how early you post. What time you guys record to be so consistently

[@TheBub2015]

It’s a joke from the Wired interview

[@euj0]

It's called Good Mythical *MORNING* it releases at 6AM US Eastern Time

[@smashed_penguin]

Probably record things at least two weeks ahead of schedule on average.

[@peggarick2756]

I hope you're joking that you think they're recording every morning. They record up to 2 months ahead.

[@blakeog2034]

JOSH DANG IT!!!! My god… that was something else!!!! Looking insane buddy!

[@hank_bloodshadow]

A 7$ cookie!? hwat!?

[@arixkuun]

they're huge

[@phillipburr2627]

Do Famous Amos vs Christie Cookie next.

[@jab2d3dCGmfg]

The answer is Mrs. Fields. The other ones taste like those chalky lofthouse brand cookies that used to be at the grocery.

[@Nakia11798]

They were so BAD

[@riabouchinska]

Aww man I love those… my grandma used to buy them sometimes, they taste like gross sugary nostalgia to me

[@ketameanii]

those are better than Crumbl imo, Crumbl is too sweet even with cutting it into fourths

[@refinedsugar]

Can't you still get them at Walmart?

[@Szaisthatyou]

1:06 never knew how much I needed that until now😭😭❤️🤧 I watched that too many times lol

[@JerryCannn]

mrs fields without a doubt! crumbl is so sugary

[@anniebangert]

i just really really love how southern link gets when hes passionate about something

[@HulaKatz]

Haven't seen her in years, but Mrs Fields was a young beautiful woman in the 80s

[@queenb1119]

15:42 - "It's The Nibbler! He just slowly bites at your edges!" He better not try that on my melanated sisters! They protect their edges at all costs! 🤣❤

[@fredommarie]

chase having BOTH of their wallets in his pocket just kinda makes sense .

[@autumnfarmer213]

The monologue in one take was fantastic

[@JohnnyJohnnyJohnnyJohnnyJohnny]

"I'm an extremist." - Link 2024

[@yansce]

finally bringing josh back thank you

[@joshweatherly8715]

Strange comparison

[@phoebekate1468]

What I love about GMM: 1. Everything.

[@alexleach9133]

Can someone give Link a piece of cake so he can actually know what cake is?

[@frigid19]

yeah when I think cakey i think like moist, fluffy and airy, not dense and gooey like crumbl

[@Tom-_-Hanks]

Thanks, thumbs up, have a great day.

[@spencerandrew5517]

Good mythical morning night shifters

[@imdaprophet]

What time does gmm start in the states. Everyone says night shift or insomnia

[@spencerandrew5517]

@@imdaprophet usually between 5am and 515 am where I am in the Midwest

[@imdaprophet]

@@spencerandrew5517 that’s crazy a lot of people in the U.K. are up for work by then.

[@elusivegamergirl]

Josh's abs, shoulders and shirtless monologue deserve a round of applause. 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏