MTH Restoration Big Boy

[@Thomasthestreamliner]

THAT kind of big boy sure is something and it's whistle, bell and sounds are like the real 4014

[@EngineerDaylight]

Who knows, they probably got it from a recording of 4014's whistle and Bell

[@Thomasthestreamliner]

That's right, they did

[@sleeves_rail_archives]

MTH did a great job on this model! I love how accurate it is in terms of details and actual recorded sounds from the 4014!

[@fishxy2123]

I went and saw 4014 a couple years ago when it came to Omaha NE. What an experience to see Big Boy in person for the first time. The whistle was beautiful.

[@Hawkers02]

It came to Sidney, NE and spent the night twice

[@westernpacificrr]

3895 doesn’t get the recognition it deserves

[@Hawkers02]

I think once 844 needs a refresh 3985 will be on the list

[@thomasreinker3402]

@@Hawkers02 the UP stated earlier this year 3985 is officially retired and will not be restored.

[@chainsawcharl1e677]

The Challenger was the best of the 3 UP locomotives. Really sad to see it retired.

[@RailRide]

@@chainsawcharl1e677 You may know about this already, but for those not in the know, the Railroading Heritage of Midwest America has acquired ownership of the 3985 (and 5511) and is well into the process of restoring both to operational condition in their shops in Silvis, IL.

[@miguelChivasFan17]

I really like how it has the correct Bell and Whistle sound for the restored Big Boy 4014. Also cool how the PFA was the recording from the 150th Anniversary of the Golden Spike celebration at Ogden

[@felixthetrainfan4819]

omg that's looks shiny 😱 Great model

[@MackBricks]

Wow. That thing is incredible! They nailed that whistle, and the sound effects, 😍😍! We don't get this in the Lego train hobby! Great video as usual!

[@That_Thicc_Cat]

There’s are MOC trains but they typically don’t have sound effects

[@thealphawildcat5868]

We'll get there sometime, Henry.

[@That_Thicc_Cat]

@@thealphawildcat5868 hopefully, I 4014 set would be awesome!

[@tenderenginesinc6435]

Anyone else find it very relaxing to sit back and watch some Eric's Trains reviews or is that just me?

[@CassandraPantaristi]

I do.

[@MattsTrainsTractors]

I own Lionel’s Vision Big Boy #4005. Ever since the beginning of my appreciation for the hobby Lionel has always been my #1 locomotive manufacturer. I love my big boy, but I must admit, I am a little jealous.

[@evankoren]

Just don’t make it derail like the real 4005 did!

[@MattsTrainsTractors]

@@evankoren lol!

[@Thomasthestreamliner]

The 4005 was the big boy that had a terrible accident 68 years ago

[@jerzeydolphins]

i actually like it all Glossed Up, and those PA sounds were ON POINT ! thanks Eric,

[@islandofmisfittrains5114]

The big boy is by far the most gorgeous steam loco out there. Can't get any better.

[@catnipleaf8680]

Whatcha gotta do now is double-head this thing with the 844

[@anthonystrains8149]

Wow the model is absolutely fantastic! I love that PFA

[@chrisscott8934]

Man bigboy looks shiny and polished up what a great looking model to your layout

[@Toaster844]

Maybe now MTH will make an 844 to run with the Big Boy! Nice model Eric

[@Ericstrains]

They already did, several years back.

[@Toaster844]

Wow I had no idea hmm, I’ll have to look and see if I can find it somewhere

[@calebtrains2261]

@Eric's Trains This Thing Looks AWESOME, The Passenger Freight Announcement Was AWESOME Also.

[@greensplatter3480]

Eric, It has been forever since we saw the rest of your layout. You should really take some shots of the trains going through the rest of your layout,

[@michaelbezak5401]

What a monster, the smoke and whistle sounds are on point. Nice job MTH and Eric for bringing this to us.

[@Jamersonde]

I was at the ceremony many of those PFA sounds were recorded at. It was an awesome sight with awesome sounds accompanying it!

[@Handlesarestoopid]

I want a Big boy that has a crew talk voice say "We're high ballin" in Ed Dickens voice

[@EngineerDaylight]

You're right the PFA sound is just plain awesome.

[@EngineerDaylight]

I really do hope that MTH continues Because I'm really going to be sad if they close down, they make some of the best models and most of the cars on my layout are MTH

[@sammodeltech]

Nothing has been decided yet about MTH business. They might continue business like MTH ver2 or something.

[@jsgtrains3176]

HI Eric, As always. One helluva review. What a beautiful job MTH DID on this loco. I am blown away! Hope you are feeling better these days. Best, Joe Gozzo

[@dantop1280]

That is a gorgeous piece !!!!

[@ErikVince]

That startup sequence is very cool love how you could see the smoke coming out of the smoke stack

[@emrilbennett8704]

3:19 wow! That’s so cool!!

[@allegheny48]

That is a good looking engine Eric. The gloss paint really sets everything off nicely. After watching this video and the one where you reviewed the other MTH Big Boy it seems that the restoration Big Boy's smoke unit does not have a fan. Other than that MTH certainly did its best on this engine. I also prefer seeing the gloss black tender rather than what Lionel did. Looks much more prototypical even though UP decided on using 3985's tender since it was already set up for oil and then painted it later on.

[@TyTytheTrainGuy]

Very beautiful model Eric! I really hope to have this one day!

[@FanRailer]

If the PFA soundset is the primary reason for spending the big $$$ for a new model, you can just save money by upgrading any existing PS 3.0 Big Boy by loading the updated sound set into the older Big Boy via the DCS system. That being said, all other reasons considered, if you have the money then by all means buy the new model.

[@Ericstrains]

Wouldn't make much sense to have that sound set in a non-restoration big boy.

[@FanRailer]

@@Ericstrains good thing MTH has two different ones to choose from. I have the non restoration update loaded onto my 4000.

[@maniacrailfan8060]

What do you do Eric?? 😩😩😩 I wish I could pick up models just like that. What a beauty

[@mattgrant2646]

Just wait till 4014 rolls this August. UP steam team may have decided and refinished the tender!

[@bfsproductionsytp]

Great review as always Eric! Really liking that paint job.

[@train-addict4656]

Nice Looking Big Boy , love the paint and the Smoke .....That's Like 100.000 Marlboro Miles of Smoke.

[@RDS51403]

Super shiny and great whistle!

[@v.c.ry2productions512]

I Like The Glossy Paint And The Whistle And The Bell It Sounds Exactly Like The Real 4014!

[@solutions2exist556]

Gloss paint is a killer. Looks great.

[@alexbrown2529]

Wow that sound is incredible! Great buy Erik.

[@thunderturbine8860]

Jolly good show Eric @Eric's Trains

[@timbober1]

Loved the articulation at 12:33

[@sammodeltech]

Wow! Finally I can watch this product review. I saw that model testing in Korea before shipping to USA. Also about disbanding MTH, nothing has been confirmed about 3 rail O scale division.

[@mikeread5132]

Thanks, Eric - fab vid - at 12:23 - that's a great view of the consist

[@tankthehedgehog105]

It Sounds Just Like 4014! I Love It!

[@rockyjohnIII]

You will have to come to Scranton Pa.(Steam Town) and see a big boy up close and personal.

[@AceTheWolf614]

very shiny and look's good nice work Eric

[@gabegamingchannel6425]

That’s a really cool train 🚂

[@Puddin_Pi]

Oooh! I ❤️ UP 4014!

[@emrilbennett8704]

4:54 what a way to take a rogue employees insult and slap it right back in their face

[@danieldoesdumbstuff]

If 4-8-8-4 is Big Boy, then 4-8-8-8-4 would be Large Man

[@BXGUY73]

This MTH model is just as good as LIONEL's VISION-LINE Big Boy. The only difference I see is the Glossy Black Paint job of the MTH model version, and the "BLOW DOWN SMOKE EFFECT" from the VISION-LINE model. The whistle and sounds of MTH are ON THE MARK. And if you are a bit concerned when it comes to the price, MTH wins that one by a landslide.

[@davvonmckenzie3911]

amazing looking engine

[@arduous1914]

Hi you all are great people! 👍

[@pinchy08]

I do see why you got this model. Great buy! However this video would have been spiced up by pulling out the Lionel Legacy 844.

[@jrx2662]

beautiful!

[@Bondmanproductions]

That looks brand spanking new

[@PainesvilleRailfans]

I have noticed in this video and the video in JDstucks channel about this last run of the big boys, that both models (from this run) has the chuff sound settings default to what sounds like two chuffs per revolution instead of the usual four. This is a simple fix by going to the DCS settings: Menu-> sound-> Chuff rate-> and press 4 to see a difference. Did anyone else notice this?

[@chainsawcharl1e677]

Really glad there's a programming fix to the 2-chuff problem!

[@zepledfan413]

The speech was definitely pretty cool. Something unique to set this model apart from an average Big Boy.

[@michaelpazman9961]

Nice 👍 love the 4014

[@charlesbissey9901]

I remember all of that speech because I was there

[@medora2499]

Hey Eric, I like your modern videos, but I preferred the older format of your videos where you went more in-depth with the details of the model. I understand that made the videos much longer, but that was fine. I liked watching those videos anyway, despite their length.

[@tallishyeti2756]

That’s quite the smoke unit!

[@westernpacificrr]

Hi Eric, Just so you know I am not one of your patreon supporters so to make it fair for others, I should not be included in the list for early viewing. I am only 13 so I cannot have a credit card to support you on patreon.

[@logannguyen1343]

Now Eric needs to review Lionel's version of the restored Big Boy.

[@neilexploreology]

Ive always liked your videos, and this is one of the best! Keep up the good work!

[@kekistanifreedomfighter4197]

Maaaaaan another Big Boy!? I swear Eric must have half of UP's fleet of these engines!

[@BlackOps-Ent]

Cool toy!

[@hornet224]

AMAZING.

[@someedgykiduhh7866]

We waited boys, and we finally got it

[@samstrainworld8050]

that pfa is from may 2019 i was there for that

[@jomama05]

Going off of the video i had taken from the golden spike 150 tour, the locomotive and tender were very shiny anyway. So this one is more accurate to the events than that of Lionel.

[@Porschedude8]

Very nice! 👏😌

[@renercadventures]

Really cool video 🥰👍I love it friend

[@Chessie1985]

Awesome review Eric!!

[@Xromatadia]

I wish i could get it :(

[@scottressler6632]

Awesome. Thanks for sharing.

[@americanpatriot1618]

Better than Lionel version by a mile!

[@Mnrr6131]

11:37. I like that shot. Kinda makes me think of the spot on the 1 train(subway line in New York) where it branches off of Broadway and heads to the tunnel

[@Ericstrains]

Cool thanks!

[@Mnrr6131]

@@Ericstrains 9:33 was that the same train or a different big boy

[@Ericstrains]

@@Mnrr6131 same train

[@Mnrr6131]

@@Ericstrains ok

[@charleshax]

12:33 it looks like 4014 is looking over the edge of the cliff to get a view of what’s down there

[@RichardModelTrains777]

Very Nice Eric. I have the older version MTH 4014, 20-3575-1 like you do that was reviewed by you a couple years ago. I actually like the PFA sounds from the older unit, but like this glossy black better than the flat black. Are those UP passenger cars Lionel or Golden Gate? They look really nice. Keep up the good work!

[@john2914]

Thats a big one.

[@TheGermanKnowsBest]

What smoke fluid you using or is it that MTH and Lionel fan smoke units just differ in output?

[@TonyFleetwood]

hey, you can always dullcote the tender and have the best of both

[@ErikVince]

That is a very interesting crew talk sound love it

[@ap70621]

That thing is quite a smoker!

[@timshaff]

I think the chuffs per rev need to be doubled on the big boy if I’m hearing that correctly. Other than that it’s an absolute masterpiece 👌🏻

[@chainsawcharl1e677]

Yeah! Why did MTH think we would not notice there were only 2 chuffs per rev. The staggared chuffs are great, but there should be twice as many. Come on MTH: fix this!

[@ALCOR_S3]

​@chainsawcharl1e677 the chuff rate can be changed from 1 chuff per revolution up to i believe 16 chuffs per revolution, so you can choose how many you want and eric probably didn't feel like changing it or prefers it that way, so mth didn't try to scam us or anything, it probably just shipped with the 2 chuff rate as default

[@timothydemarco3525]

Love the video Eric

[@MMID303]

Very cool

[@Mr300bowler]

Hey Eric when are you going to review that southern Pacific 4-4-2 A6

[@josephremenar3117]

Since I have my first grandson I want to start a collection for him. I purchased a Lionel LionChief 2.0 Berkshire (Red & Green Christmas model) and a starter set. I want to start collecting Polar Express rolling stock and accessories and noticed that there must be two level of cars, some are in the $70+ range and others in the $150+ range. What’s the main difference? I’m looking to purchase more higher-end engines and rolling stock and will be purchasing a Legacy Control system. Any advice? Thank you and I very much enjoy your videos. You’re the only one who takes the time to fully explain things.

[@MatthewTheRBXMan]

I have the Lionel ver and I love it

[@bretnewman286]

What smoke are you using and how to obtain the mass amount of smoke on these units. I ask cause I just bought a used one and it does not smoke like the one in this video. Thx

[@edwinsinclair9853]

Notice they correctly left off the ashpan dumping controls.

[@trainsandsirensofilinmiwi2080]

nice video i love big boys

[@stevenfd123]

That is a great loco!

[@user-gn1zq9nm8q]

5:55

[@marc_abby]

Why don’t put MTH this sound on there HO UP 4014. I don’t understand it.

[@CSXtrackworker]

Is this an actual coherent sentence?

[@0779BooBoo]

@@CSXtrackworker Good question.

[@EngineerDaylight]

I think it might have to do something with the size

[@stephenswift5531]

i would like to see this in salem oregon

[@nickystar600video3]

Does this have the smoking whistle effect?

[@jturner0901]

i have one if these but the wireless drawbar set up sucks, it seems to have a really hard time connecting. it randomly gains and loses it’s connection, it only stays constant if i hold up the drawbar against the tender side and i have no clue how to fix it

[@stephenswift5531]

How come the tender was barreled from the union Pacific 3985 locomotive

[@Im_TheLineageLifter]

I wanted to know when will they a make a fictional big boy that is streamlined