What If Walter White Couldn’t Survive Breaking Bad?

[@murgeproductions]

Who else would change the breaking bad universe if they died early?

[@vanhestell8329]

Pryce.

[@UnwantedGhost1-anz25]

@@murgeproductions Louis

[@the.marvelous.mitori]

Hector

[@luna_macaroni]

Huell

[@thedodgeviperacr5935]

Jessie dying in episode 1 would definitely change a lot of things

[@boyankrastev5007]

Waltuh, put your plot armour away waltuh

[@johannvonbabylon]

1:12 "Moments later, Walt wakes up in a hospital bed. He's blind and has no jaw but he's still alive and conscious, and he's about to spend a long rest of his life wishing he hadn't imitated the 'under the chin' thing you always see in TV and movies."

[@theorangeoof926]

He’d be an even more disabled Hector.

[@trainguy1548]

Remember at the beginning Season 5 of Better Call Saul when Saul/Gene was recognized by the taxi guy who drove him home from the Hospital, and he called the vacuum guy and asked to relocate but changed his mind? What if Saul Goodman didn’t change his mind and decided to relocate to a different city/state?

[@BlackangelKatakuri]

Or out of the country

[@Nina2Rina]

Feels like it would just be uneventful? Like either he moves and goes back to a boring life or more likely he finds someone else who tempts him back into that life until he eventually gets arrested anyways. I think that was the point of him deciding not to relocate because he cant help himself to going back to being a criminal

[@BlackangelKatakuri]

@Nina2Rina I mean once you commit a crime you're a criminal even if you never commit crimes again. That is unless the crime you commit isn't serious and or you're given a clean slate.

[@connormartinson7619]

I feel like it just pushes it further, he would’ve slipped up again

[@PETHRIS]

I love how every one of these involves Gomey just being the chillest, most helpful guy possible

[@murgeproductions]

Gomey the goat

[@Philosophocat]

Gomey the Homie ✊🏽🚩🇲🇽

[@jftalmadge1978]

10:00 Skyler was so upset at Hank and Marie that she gave birth to Holly right there.

[@murgeproductions]

Lol

[@ANP4158]

@@murgeproductionscan that actually happen? 😮

[@Simon-px8mi]

If you look closely Walters gun angle would miss the brain if fired. Many people survived suicide attempts because of a wrong angle. And I think he would be found unconscious by the fire department, on the ground with a bloody face instead of dying in this scenario. It would be interesting to see the conversation between Hank and Walt in custody. I think this would make for an interesting scenario

[@murgeproductions]

Intere

[@Simon-px8mi]

@@murgeproductions I edited it a little because it would play out more than just Walter dying. He would be taken out the picture, but there would be even more story since he was alive. I bet hed try some trick to come out innocent about it after he wakes up but who knows.

[@murgeproductions]

It’s an idea, that I can see happening

[@Smok3_710]

I just imagine Walt in custody with a huge cartoon hole in his face.

[@ketomine.]

“conversation” even if he survived it, I doubt Walt would be able to talk. he’d probably have to communicate like Hector

[@jeffy26am]

What if Nacho went to jail in 2002 and didn’t get out until Breaking Bad? What if Lalo actually died in the S5 finale? What if Mike worked with the Salamancas?

[@venturatheace1]

All interesting ideas

[@jorgedeguzman65]

​@@venturatheace1 I don't think Lalo dying in S5 finale would affect anything

[@darthtader5802]

@@jorgedeguzman65actually it would have a big impact. If he died in season 5 he wouldn’t have killed Howard meaning Kim and jimmy would have likely stayed together. Jimmy was using work to distract himself from that whole situation so if he was still with Kim he may have not even worked with Walt after the badger case.

[@jorgedeguzman65]

@@darthtader5802 You're right,I didn't even think of that,I was only thinking about the cartel side of the story

[@Ironman-ko5vw]

If mike worked with the salamancas, gus would be long dead and nacho would be alive

[@marcobisi7768]

Jesse doesn't suffer in this one? This isn't how we do things around here: He goes into extreme debt because of the medical bills caused by Tuco's beating. There, fixed it for ya /s

[@murgeproductions]

Lol

[@charlie-j4o7u]

Don't forget that Krazy 8 was a rat. This probably would've been different as they wouldn't of treated Krazy as a criminal.

[@sammowastaken]

he's still a criminal just one trying to get a better deal by working with the cops

[@vanhestell8329]

What If Jack's Gang were involved early? Like War with The Cartel or Gus?

[@inferno1277]

this would've been an amazing show on its own

[@Nate-139]

They'd stand no chance. They're lucky all the big players were dead by the time they rolled around

[@vanhestell8329]

They could be those "banditos de motos" in BCS, as mentioned by Eladio and Nacho. So there was more of them.

[@kingDowahs]

Ngl that would be awesome, Jack, Todd, Kenny and their gang vs Gus, Mike and the Cartel

[@shockwave2617]

Hey, I suggested something similar where the Salamanca's would stage a war between Jack's gang and the Cartel.

[@UnwantedGhost1-anz25]

This is the only time we have seen what a hypothetical Cartel War looks like. And I'm not disappointed in the slightest. 👍🏼

[@murgeproductions]

Not really a war more like a mild annoyance, lol because Gus only killed hector. Then his entire operation was taken out in 15 minutes

[@UnwantedGhost1-anz25]

​@@murgeproductions Then Gustavo in the original shouldn't have said "prevent a war" to Jesse. I guess he likes overestimating himself & empire. 🤣

[@murgeproductions]

lol could be.

[@MyUsersDark]

@@murgeproductions Maybe he should have gone in with more than 2 guys

[@GrizzlyGamingYoutube]

Do you guys remember Telltale's the walking dead? Where the story changes based on your choices and what you say, We need a Breaking Bad version of that, that would be so cool. And they need to take inspiration from your takes, because your "What if's" translate so well in this concept. Keep up the videos i enjoy them!!

[@murgeproductions]

Any time brother, wish that was something too, I’d love to do one of those

[@RickyGGaming_TX]

I wish for that too for a long time

[@Zeromasterxv]

These are some ideas for what if: Walter is caught in the RV by Hank? Would the plan against Don Elario have failed? Would Jessie have died from the sniper who was shooting at the chicken brothers? What if Lalo didn't discover that Nacho had betrayed him?

[@adrusk]

I don't see the way that Lalo doesn't notice that Nacho was the one that opened the gate, he could think that Nacho didn't betrayed him if he saw his corpses...

[@abramsullivan7764]

What if Jimmy didn't let Howard in his, and Kim's apartment? Or actually What if Kim actually keep driving straight to her dream job instead turning a bad choice road?

[@Gahwotchii]

he would've probably stayed there pounding on the door, until lalo shows up and shoots him and the door open

[@ElectricFury]

I'd like to think Saul does get affected slightly when he no longer has access to Mike as his P.I. The quality of his law services would probably decline, he might start using Steven Ogg's character from Better Call Saul as a replacement P.I. but he is a bit more unhinged compared to Mike. I could see a dodgy case go wrong because of this that leads to legal reprocussions for Saul (much less severe than in the normal timeline, but potentially enough to have a court case that he can lure Kim out to to apologise and own up for his mistakes just like in Saul Gone, but with probably a much shorter prison sentence at the end meaning he could properly re-unite with Kim and have a happy ending together after serving his time.

[@rbstudios6502]

What if Mike wasn't sexist and killed Lydia the first chance he got?

[@BlackangelKatakuri]

How was he sexist? She got to him through her daughter which makes sense considering how important to him his granddaughter was.

[@rbstudios6502]

@@BlackangelKatakuri it was a joke lmao

[@Conman-albuquerque]

@@BlackangelKatakurihe literally says “that’s what I get for being sexist” when he regrets killing lydia

[@BlackGoldTech]

@@BlackangelKatakuriwatch the show bro, Mike calls himself sexist for not killing lydia

[@BlackangelKatakuri]

@@BlackGoldTech That's not sexism it's a bad line .

[@ffferdinanddd]

What if the skaters never called Tuco’s grandma “Biznatch”

[@UnwantedGhost1-anz25]

I hope Tuco won't somehow get information on Mike's Daughter-in-law & Granddaughter as the Cartel informs him about the war & his uncle's death. 😓

[@adrusk]

What if Gus killed Mr White and slaved Jesse? Gus: -You are fired. Get away from Pinkman Walt: -And if I don't? What else you do? I'm death however Gus: *pulls the trigger * Just as we saw in the episode Face Off, when Gus's men kidnapp Jesse and forced him to cook using intimidation and watching every Jesse step (maybe not as violent as Jack and his crew). It could keep that way untill Mike comes back from Mexico and... could go to Jesse's side?

[@murgeproductions]

Interesting, I’m going to screenshot this

[@derekschmitt9994]

I could see Mike on the surface accepting Jesse’s fate to not get his hopes up if he can’t help, but behind the scenes be vouching for Jesse to Gus and raising hell for him to be able to leave in time.

[@UnwantedGhost1-anz25]

Who would have thought that life without Walter H. White would be miserably chaotic? I wonder what life without Jimmy would be like? Oh wait!

[@MunnaMobile000]

what if Walt pulls the trigger but the safety is still on. But instead of panicking and trying to salvage whatever he's got like in BB, he gets in the RV and drives to the nearest police station and turns himself in? Maybe he leaves Jessie on the side of the road so he can escape on his own whilst Walt turns himself in with a dead Emilio and unconscious Crazy 8?

[@murgeproductions]

I mean, I still see the ending turning out the same but it’s a good idea though

[@shockwave2617]

@@murgeproductions How so? Walter would be alive and able to give an extensive explanation and apology to his family? Further, Crazy-8 would still be alive, thus Walt would have to think about how he'd respond to Domingo's claim that Jesse was his partner.

[@WalkwayEmpire2007]

What if Gus was killed along with his partner

[@sagesarrazine6270]

Or even instead of?

[@solarfishysticks4496]

"nobody ever gets murdered at taco cabeza"

[@murgeproductions]

Hahahhaah

[@shockwave2617]

Great as always! However, I disagree with Gus' fate because Gus would still have Gale and the lab, thus unless their was a negligible discrepancy in quality between Gale's product and the Cartel's product which is doubtful given how skilled Gale is. Hence, the most likely outcome is Gus does something similar to what he did in the original timeline with the major changes being that he'd lose more of his men because there would be more Salamanca's alive. Depending on how you power scale the characters there is a chance Leonel and Marco could take Mike, Tyrus and Victor with them.

[@GothamsMostTrusted]

Man, you need to reach out to Gilligan and Gould and team up to create your own BB spinoff. You'd fit right in the writer's room. Stellar job playing with the ramifications of this universe as always.

[@murgeproductions]

Wouldn’t even know where to start to get in contact with him…what do you think, Twitter??

[@GothamsMostTrusted]

@@murgeproductions I mean, it's probably the fastest and most direct way, perhaps. You just never know! But, I'm rooting for you either way

[@murgeproductions]

Why not, I’ll give it a shot

[@Grumpollion]

Ted has still committed fraud in this timeline, but this time Skyler doesn't have Walt's money to give to him to give to the IRS in a settlement. Ted is going to jail, and maybe Skyler, as his accountant is too.

[@murgeproductions]

Yeah it’s going to be bad for teddy

[@mostyami]

Man I imagine the effort of finding clips and merging them together to make these stories, keep up the good work 🔥🔥

[@jericore]

i love the way you narrate through these, adding your own callback to previous canon lines/quotes. being able to create suspense and mystery as well. love it ❤

[@murgeproductions]

Happy that you enjoy it

[@fallenknighttyler8695]

What if Tuco never got hooked on meth?

[@UnwantedGhost1-anz25]

What happened to the taco shop hideout by the time that Breaking Bad began?

[@joellundkvist1308]

They sold tacos i guess

[@Grumpollion]

Gale also lives in this timeline. Presumably, he cooks for Gus in the superlab, and is left alive even after Gus and Mike die. What happens to Gale then? The superlab presumably remains undiscovered by law enforcement. Does Lydia attempt to contact Gale following Gus's death?

[@OskarrMason]

It got an idea for a idea for a what if, what if tuco was more level headed, as in he didn't take drugs and was clean, was more came and composed during drug deals and used words instead of violence. The only time we see Tuco not high on drugs as a normal person, was with his grandmother.

[@Cw542-l9c]

What if Marco didn’t get the axe and just shot Hank? Let’s say that Marco here’s the police coming and decides to just kill Hank, get his brother, and go back to Mexico. How will the events of Breaking Bad be with the twins still alive and with Hank dead?

[@AmyOhHenry225]

3 season show? More like 1 if I'm being honest. And it's not that surprising that the events of the show fall apart without Walter in it, he is the main character after all. I personally really appreciate you redoing this video, it's age restricted for me and now I can finally watch it

[@murgeproductions]

Hope you enjoyed it, expect more soon

[@absinthealice]

I agree. Without Walter White, there wouldn't be a show. A miniseries maybe, but no more than that.

[@murgeproductions]

But then again, there was an entire 6 seasons of better call Saul and he was basically a background character

[@AmyOhHenry225]

@@murgeproductions Yea cuz Better Call Saul specifically has two stories going on. Yea they interacted a lot but they've both got two different backbones in Saul and Mike for the most part. If you took either Saul or Mike out of their respective storylines in the beginning their storyline would suffer but the other may survive 🤷🏽‍♀️ could be an interesting What If episode

[@murgeproductions]

I’ll write that down

[@bobbyking2490]

Amazing video, Murge! So happy to see your content growing in popularity!

[@WholesomeSkullMan-tl6xx]

I’ve been subscribed for a few months now and I still just love this content. It’s fun and I like your takes. For the most part I agree with how you sort things, and it’s good that you stick to the story, but it’s still fun to go outside of it like you do sometimes. Good stuff! :)

[@darthpalpaduck]

what if when confronted by hank walter pretended he was confused and gaslit hank and didnt admit it

[@ElectricFury]

I don't know what circumstance would lead to it, but a What If? where Gus actually forgives Walt and he joins the team with Jesse and Mike to go to Mexico and take down the cartel would be cool. Maybe some sort of deal where Walt gets to run a piece of Gus' empire after Gus takes the cartel's market. Not sure how they'd settle on the issue of Hank though.

[@A_secondary_]

I love your videos, it’s always awesome to see the Breaking Bad world to continue. Keep up the fantastic work! What if there was a war in the cartel? Like what if instead of Hector having a stroke they left and all our war broke between the factions, with smaller people like Saul stuck in the middle.

[@gordonlawtie7237]

Dear Murge, please explain what if Huell Babineaux ate Kimberly Wexler?

[@murgeproductions]

He’s not huel when he’s hungry

[@aceslayer4883]

You know I love how these videos are always within the writing of the characters always very realistic

[@murgeproductions]

Happy you like the vids dude, there is so much more to come.

[@SFisher1993]

I kept thinking of Blade Runner when you said “Gaf.” 🤣 Great video!

[@murgeproductions]

Good one!

[@MidlothianOdyssey]

Congrats on 40k Murge! Very interesting to see what would happen if Walt's gun didn't jam. Idea: What if Tuco was released early? He serves his six months and doesn't stab the inmate.

[@murgeproductions]

Thanks dude

[@General12th]

Hi Murge! I was wondering how this was different from the original, but the changes were great!

[@murgeproductions]

Glad you liked it!

[@UnwantedGhost1-anz25]

I hope hundreds of thousands of viewers see it. This remake video is a W

[@murgeproductions]

Thanks my guy, do me a favor and share the video if you could

[@UnwantedGhost1-anz25]

​@@murgeproductions Yessir. 🫡

[@murgeproductions]

My GOAT

[@CardsFan6969]

Big fan of your "What If" videos. That's it, that's the comment.

[@murgeproductions]

I appreciate that!

[@Mamba24_81]

i love these videos, keep up the great work!

[@murgeproductions]

Glad you like them!

[@Ezdoesit777]

Jesse wasn't in touch with badger at this point... could work with skinny pete

[@youngfxx8437]

Happy for my boy Jesse🙏🙏 I thought for sure he was going to be killed by Crazy 8 or arrested for killing Walter. He made it out successfully once again and he only got beat up twice! Let’s go!

[@RonBoom-ov7if]

What if Skyler never existed. I know this “what if” you might never do Merge but considering all the memes and jokes surrounding this, it would be very interesting to what happens if this would come to be.

[@coralreif3582]

Not so much a "what if" but I think it would be cool to expand/theorize on what happened to the Esposito girl from BCS that Jimmy wanted to give the scholarship to, and how his spiel to her affected her life. (as we see from the Wolves and Sheep flashback in BCS, sometimes speeches like those in this universe can be impactful)

[@l30ng62]

Jesse simply getting his life together gives me feels This also kind of feels like the beginning of a series of shorts episodically detailing various characters Breaking Bad. An interesting twist compared to the dense storytelling of the original.

[@darthvaderreviews6926]

12:45 Severe plot hole: Nobody ever gets shot at Taco Cabeza!

[@murgeproductions]

Until today

[@account.125]

How is this different from "What if Walter died during Pilot?" video?

[@account.125]

Oh wait, it's a better version of it.

[@murgeproductions]

I re-recorded it and added some details

[@Fionzi]

It’s monetized

[@murgeproductions]

Yep

[@UrBloodOnMyFace]

That video got age restricted

[@theantone7476]

What if Chuck successfully got Jimmy disbarred?

[@MrGuitarJockey]

What if Jesse bought the salon Saul offered him and laundered his money?

[@Miles1r]

I absolutely loved this video! I really enjoy the story's you tell. And im a big fan of the Heisenverse series.

[@murgeproductions]

Awesome, thank you! More content coming. If you can could you share this video anywhere you can.

[@jjewell2076]

I seriously think they need to do a “WHAT IF”Jimmy was allowed to be part of HHM law firm.

[@danielsantiagourtado3430]

Thanks For this! Love your content ❤❤❤❤

[@murgeproductions]

You are so welcome!

[@skeletonbuyingpealts7134]

Jesse, the true Cap'n Cook

[@useMarcos]

Video idea: what if Ernie didn’t manipulate all of the breaking bad universe?

[@danielsantiagourtado3430]

Gonna watch it all over again. This was Great 🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@mappingshaman5280]

I feel like eventually skyler would realise she's being unreasonable and forgive hank

[@Xayumcl]

What If Jimmy never Became slippin' Jimmy

[@StatTheMusicFinder]

Such a shame you had to change the title due to KZbin, keep it up dude

[@murgeproductions]

I did a lot more than change the title bro, but I agree KZbin be trippin

[@StatTheMusicFinder]

@@murgeproductions Damnn that sucks man, they let so much bad content on here too

[@murgeproductions]

RIGHT!!!

[@triforcewielder8500]

Very nice! Hola from Colorado

[@murgeproductions]

Thank you! Cheers!

[@Professional-Hater-No.1]

What if scenario: What if Walter, right before he died in "Feline," traveled back two years to the time of the "Pilot" episode and knew about the entire future? What steps would he take with that knowledge? Would he work for Gus from the very beginning, or start his own venture? Would he accept Jesse as his partner? It's a wild "what if" scenario.

[@TheDLVProject]

I own a Smith and Wesson model 39-2 which is very similar to the 745 and most likely Walter didn't realize the safety/disconnector was on(how could he). When on safe the model 745 trigger can still be pulled however the firing pin is blocked. You can clearly see the switch in the downward position which means the gun is safe. So even though there was a live round in the chamber the hammer was blocked from striking the firing pin. Vince did a great job on the scene representing firearm accuracy. Clearly for the stake of video the safety is off.

[@connor4435]

I don’t think Krazy 8 was still working for Tuco by the time of breaking bad, Jessie said he was a distributor so it seems like he’d managed to set himself up as some small thing on his own

[@whaletastic9200]

murge's hate for gaff's existence is comical

[@Sarkeysmusic]

What if skyler saw Emilio’s dead body

[@PlickyBoji]

no armour for walt.

[@bdup680]

What if Walt and Lydia become intimate

[@HyperionTrio160]

What if Badger never got arrested and then caused Walt and Jesse to never meet Saul?

[@DiegoAAlvarado]

A “what if” involving Werner would be interesting

[@GuacamoleMan684]

So if Walter dies almost everyone gets a happy ending

[@daviszdirector]

surprised you only got onto this one now

[@slothboy5094]

What if Walter was taken as a meth slave by Crazy 8 & Emilio after showing them the cook, like Jesse was in S5?

[@InfiniteCrafter]

What if Nacho was a Salamanca?

[@clonetrooper2003]

*HERE ME OUT* What If Walter Didn’t Throw The Pizza On The Roof? I know this sounds ridiculous but that event kinda led to him calling Skyler’s bluff

[@charlesflowers9479]

What if Tuco won against Hank in the beginning of Season 2

[@murgeproductions]

What If Hector Salamanca Recovered? THE COMPLETE STORY | A Breaking Bad “What If” Story kzbin.info/www/bejne/mJupf4ttpsymZ5o

[@ninjashep5264]

What if Nacho killed Bolsa & then himself, instead of just taking himself out Basically what if Bolsa dies at that point & isn’t around for the rest of the shows

[@murgeproductions]

I never understood bulsa purpose

[@laughisfun2003]

What if Saul found out about Huell’s cannibalism?

[@CeticWales]

I am surprised Jesse wasn't killed in a bank heist...

[@murgeproductions]

lol don’t tempt me, I’ll make a part two and finish what I started.

[@garrettplaysgames4349]

What if Kaley WAS the muscle behind the operation?

[@idostuff4439]

I love how there's a spoiler warning for something that happens the first 2 minutes into the pilot episode

[@murgeproductions]

You’d be surprised the comments I get lol

[@ilovewater570]

Could you do what if nacho Salamanca replaced tuco with selling meth with hesenberg

[@cyancatnp]

What if Lalo Salamanka never bought Hector the bell

[@darinfrank3765]

What if Gus and Tyrus spotted the bomb before Hector detonated it?

[@absinthealice]

What if? .... Skylar dies during childbirth. Walt & Jr & Holly I know... I know... Holly IS the mastermind.

[@murgeproductions]

Dark…I like it

[@ninjashep5264]

What if Nacho killed Bolsa & then himself, instead of just taking himself out

[@jamesfalakassa6663]

Heres an interesting idea, what if the salamanca twins sent Skyler and Walt Jr to Belize, sorta like what the season 2 cold opens were implying before the whole plane crash incident was revealed to have happened

[@airfriedpotato3958]

What if tuco snorted the mercury?

[@gamervlogsymas]

Alternative title: 'What if the Bad break Waltuh?"

[@idk-the-funny-rat101]

Can you make a what if about if there were police instead of fire fighters during the pilot Like this comment if Murge productions should make this a what if Plzzzzzz

[@murgeproductions]

Maybe in 6 months

[@idk-the-funny-rat101]

​@@murgeproductions LETS GO!!! IM SO HAPPY 😁

[@jonatanpl3899]

what if walter died in [insert episode] content farm possibility

[@milesperhour9256]

What if Walter accepted Elliot and Gretchen's offer? I'm pretty interested to see how things would go without Walter's interference at all

[@MrAaron-ek1wb]

In a lot of ways, Walt's early death is the happiest possible ending. There's an awful lot of people who would live. Now for a real good suggestion. What if Hank and Mike got into a brawl. Who would win?

[@murgeproductions]

Hank is knocking her out like he did Jesse lol

[@Monkey_lives_in_Krajina]

Gonna be mindblowing