Musicians *REVIEW* RWBY Vol 2 OST (*Surprise Unboxing?!*)

[@FixTheWi-Fi]

Die is the most applicable song to the real world in all of RWBY tbh. Boop's complete change of pace at the start and general "all-over-the-place-y-ness" is just so Nora. That entire song is Nora's mind in a nutshell.

[@TheNowerianRaven]

Born an angel, heaven sent, Falls from grace are never elegant Thats my favorite line

[@billsutherby]

It's honestly one of my favorite lines Jeff Williams has ever written

[@jonjohns8145]

Mine has to be "Truth Will rise, revealed by Mirrored eyes" ... First time I heard it I knew Ruby was going to uncover something big, didn't expect what happened in Vol 6 though.

[@argisus1279]

@@jonjohns8145 Yeah lol, Sacrifice hinted to a lot of things lol.

[@nacht5766]

Sacrifice is a song more likely about salem, ozpin and the gods..

[@Elizabeth-go4kv]

Never knew how true it would be...

[@shingshongshamalama]

Oh my god. _Die_ is all about the illusions being shattered and our heroes learning what a harsh, unsatisfying place the world really is, even specifically calling back to _Gold_ from the first season. And it plays when Neo pops up to cockblock Yang from actually getting a satisfying victory over Torchwick, leaving the girls frustrated and desperately searching for more leads. It even _literally ends_ with the illusion of the villains shattering before our eyes and revealing that they've already escaped. Holy shit that's clever.

[@indocraptor2662]

I dont see a time stamp comment so i thought i would make one 1:58 : Time to say goodbye 14:26 : Die 29:13 : Shine 40:16 : Dream Come True 54:46 : Caffine 1:11:11 : All Our Days 1:19:53 : BOOP 1:30:00 : Sacrifice Your welcome

[@icarus433]

Thanks 🙏

[@nyx9624]

This is the shit, and so are you. Cuodes.

[@bellamypearson5003]

Thank you!

[@artemisblake3241]

You forgot Time to say goodbye at 1:58

[@indocraptor2662]

@@artemisblake3241 thank you i just edited it

[@rmdur7567]

Miles confirmed in the Volume 6 commentary that they did plan and write Chapter 3 of Volume 6 even before the show started. So yeah, that's why there's so much foreshadowing in Sacrifice and other songs.

[@lfz4611]

sacrifice is about raven talking to ozpin.

[@rmdur7567]

@@lfz4611 That's what I believed too after Volume 5, but after Volume 6 I'm almost convinced it's from Salem's POV.

[@dawnfallon6812]

I agree with Luis. RWBY has a knack for using the music to give that little glimpse. Divide is another example of foreshadowing in a way that haunts you when you finally get there.

[@lfz4611]

@@rmdur7567 yea fuck every season new perpective

[@mikelove8720]

@@rmdur7567 i agree bro sacrifice is a fucling dope song, but it's DEFINITELY from salems perspective

[@SirsMadamsEntertainment]

Once again… big thanks to FlyntofRWBY for making his videos so that everything is accurate. Amazing fan service provided by a fan to all the other fans of RWBY !!! Link to his channel in the description!!! Time codes: 1:59 - Time to Say Goodbye 14:30 - Die 29:30 - Shine 40:13 - Dream Come True 54:49 - Caffeine 1:11:11 - All Our Days 1:19:54 - Boop 1:24:22 - *Surprise Unboxing* 1:30:00 - Sacrifice

[@ryanpaloma4951]

Yo!

[@PG9_]

Why'd I have to scroll so far down to see this bruv 💀

[@MegaDuke4life]

I love how Time to Say Goodbye also have gave us context on what to expect

[@dmillz5501]

It makes a lot of sense with volume 6 in my mind.

[@jaimeeking8584]

@@dmillz5501 cue Nora’s overly dramatic “EXACTLY!!!!”

[@ravenhull]

I remember when the FNDM were anticipating this OST, looking forward to songs like Caffeine... Then suddenly all we were talking about was Boop, which we had no warning.

[@KonathaoSoberuNartio]

I mean to be fair there is a tiny tiny glimpse of it leading up to the dance when Ren and Jaune were tslling about girls. Its playing through Nora's headphones.

[@charlietango261]

Velvet *is* best girl. There's actually a Deep Purple reference iin "Caffeine". Casey actually has the lyric "I'm a highway star".

[@jaimeeking8584]

The moment you realize the intro song in volume 2 summed up volume 6 in the way team Rwby views the war against you know who.......man the foreshadowing is nuts!

[@Gameguy-gk8lx]

Sacrifice is definitely one of my favorite songs in the whole show.

[@SirsMadamsEntertainment]

SAME!! -Bruce

[@billsutherby]

It's a fantastic song, and contains one of my favorite lines: "Born an angel, heaven sent. Falls from grace are never elegant." However, I really like Divide, if we're talking about "villain" songs. But my absolute favorite song in the entire series is Red Like Roses pt 2

[@MegaDuke4life]

@@billsutherby I'm a red like roses part 2 fan as well

[@randomim42]

Your groups analysis is very unique on all the other reaction and breakdown videos that you go over all the musical aspects of it and not just a lyric study. It's really interesting and Im excited to see it as you guys continue into vol 3 OST and onward

[@SirsMadamsEntertainment]

thanks! Sometimes I think we talk too much but that’s why I put the time codes in for anyone that doesn’t want to hear our breakdown... But yeah.. we love the lyrics too 😁 -Bruce

[@Geth-Who]

There's a fan song called Answer To Me by Gypsy Caravan, explicitly written from the POV of Ruby and Yang's dad following the events of Season 3, or if he ever got hold of certain people and knew what they did to his kids. Jeff liked it, complimented them on their Soundcloud upload I think - worth a listen.

[@SirsMadamsEntertainment]

Yeah .. that sounds killer.. will have to check it out 👍🏻

[@raulvalencia8573]

As a Music student, I find it funny how my leisure time is helping me understand my homework.

[@SirsMadamsEntertainment]

Raul Valencia cool! What instrument or vocal part are you studying? College or HS, etc?

[@raulvalencia8573]

Sirs & Madams Entertainment Baritone in Vocal Performance degree in College!

[@ravenhull]

You know, having watched the series from the start, the Pyrrha songs bring tears...

[@Great_Olaf5]

I just adore that slight echo at the end of Time To Say Goodbye. I also really enjoy any time where the music drops, and the singing comes back before the instruments do. All Our Days is just spellbinding. Evidenced by your near utter silence throughout it. I agree with you that it most of it really fits the sisters, but there is a big problem with putting it as Yang to Ruby, because that opening mentioned years before they met, and Yang is only two years older than her. Sacrifice is an interesting one, because I'm convinced it hasn't actually happened yet, as of the end of Volume 7. Or that it happened a long time ago.

[@alexkindberg2505]

I just realized that Yangs part of Time to Say Goodbye foreshadows her mindset during Volume 6

[@adamlee4447]

Don't know you guys will see this, but thank you for this series. I went to college for music, but am currently in a job where I don't really use my training anymore. Just listening to you guys talk about music that I love so much (and that I normally don't get real musical discussion about) has been such a revitalizing experience for me. I can't wait to finish the rest of this series of videos. ❤️ I'm having a blast.

[@j7zephyr831]

When he said "well, with a title like boop" after knowing he said he liked Nora best I was in a fit of laughter

[@Shino2912]

It's so nice to hear previous OST an see how everything is connected. This is why Iove this show so much. Thank you!! Can't wait to see your reactions to the V3 finale

[@angel__king]

Okay looking back on it I can’t get over how good the drums are in Sacrifice. Like they stand out that perfect amount to be noticeable but not stand out more than they need to and holy crap they are so nice the entire song

[@lord_chozo7341]

Love your dynamic, and especially your musical expertise - it's a great addition to the range of RWBY OST reactions from all the reactors that bother with the OST, and that I love so much. Thank you, this was a great video :-)

[@kieranhoare7239]

The song 'all our days' (the ballad of tai to yang), while it fits tai to yang it's actually a song written by Jeff to Casey, both of them have confirmed that it's about them and not any particular rwby characters

[@YukiBusujima]

Love seeing you guys really dive into these songs with music knowledge. I've spent most of this video being like 'oh so that's what that's called' and it really helps me to understand why RWBY music is so good. Edit: Would also love to see your thoughts on the CFVY book after you've caught up on the show.

[@RosileeJe]

I love getting to hear you guys go so far into the music itself, it's so fun to listen to. The reaction to Boop was hilarious and Sacrifice is definitely a favorite song for me, both musically and lyrically. I only got really into rwby's music near the end of vol6 and hearing Sacrifice especially after learning of everything shown, just, oh damn that foreshadowing is REAL. I can't wait to see reactions future volumes/OSTs Also from the beginning of the video: "I know time signatures, not math" is one of the most relatable things I've ever heard 😂

[@marksullivan2978]

Shine for me is a personal favorite though this entire soundtrack is my favorite.

[@bel410la]

Boop is always gonna be sweet. Ren and Nora are my two favorite characters and I love them with all my heart. I just hope they have a happy ending. They have been in love for the longest time too.

[@SirsMadamsEntertainment]

Did you happen to see our original tune.. “Boop Too”?

[@jonjohns8145]

(before starting the video) "Well, That's 2 hours of My Saturday I will give up" ...... (after watching the video) "TOTALLY WORTH IT!!" ... 😄. Excellent reaction guys .. wonderful details. For the record, I support the idea of a RWBY Musical myself. As to Sacrifice, I like to think of it being a song from the prospective of a certain Vol 5 character (you know the one) instead of it being from Salem's point of view. I would LOVE for you to revisit it when you do the Vol 5 OST.

[@TheAverageNooob]

I did not "All Our Days" was what Jeff thought of Casey and that extra layer made me cry when I heard the song again. Its beautiful.

[@RinnzuRosendale]

Jeff can fit a guitar solo into any genre.

[@ravenhull]

Fun with y'all being both fans and musicians looking at it in both directions.

[@jasonwinterboer5232]

1:18:07 "Isn't that cute... BUT IT'S WRONG!" I love this "Two Stupid Dogs" reference! I quite this line all the time, but nobody ever gets it... Thank you!!!

[@Cheddarhead7]

Sacrifice doesn't have a confirmed point of view, it's not necessarily from Salem although she's one of the most likely options

[@dawnfallon6812]

Raven, to Ozpin. They're not there yet.

[@deadsha5492]

i think its either cinder to oz or raven to oz

[@goddesssalem4842]

@@deadsha5492 Cinder has nothing to do with Oz, why would she be talking to him???. Show them gods and dailtes blind the people and keep them of their knees. Does that sound like raven or cinder to you

[@deadsha5492]

@@goddesssalem4842 both cinder and raven hate people with more power than them. They don't want to be controlled. Oz has godlike power and keeps people blind to the truth. Both cinder and raven know this. That makes him an enemy of cinder and raven. Likely the only reason cinder is on salem's side is so she can get powerful enough to overthrow her

[@goddesssalem4842]

@@deadsha5492 Cinders an illrelevant boring character who doesn't even have a backstory, sacrifice has absolutely nothing to do with her character. What exactly has cinder sacrificed, she hasn't sacrifice a damn thing for anybody. How exactly is cinder going to overthrow Salem, she just a weak ass maiden who continues to fail at everything she does. Hopefully once we get her backstory RT will kill her off. I suggest you watch murderofbirds Salem sacrifice video, it will make sense to you

[@brandondodge6040]

I'm not entirely sure who's point of view that Sacrifice is about, but I think they are talking about Salem and Ozpin and their personal conflict.

[@KushinaUzumaki32]

i think raven

[@joenull5945]

I took it as Raven's point of view of the conflict between Ozpin & Salem and her saying nope to it.

[@brandondodge6040]

@@KushinaUzumaki32 I can see that being true.

[@Lupirio23]

I was about to freak out about all the Vol 6 nods, but while I originally thought the "Sacrifice" was a way of referring to getting rid of Salem so they could be judged and made whole again without her influence causing them to fail and Salem will just not let Oz. If it is done from Raven's view; then the "Sacrifice" would certainly elude to the earlier lyric of Oz stealing lives, fighting Salem to keep her at bay.

[@BrittanyArtPoetry]

A lot of the year one story and more about team CFVY is found in the two novels ‘After the Fall’ and ‘Before the Dawn’

[@danielmilcent9654]

Weirdly, Sacrifice always remembers me of a character from another show, i watched all of RWBY and that's still the impression i get from this. The character is Nox, from Wakfu, especially the calm creepy part close to the end

[@XFizzlepop-Berrytwist]

Eyyy! A wakfu enjoyer! Thats rare!

[@ArchImperatrix]

My Dad taught me to play Bass as a kid, never did play professionally, just play for fun and meditation. But as you guy were talking about, I started out playing only Rock, Metal, Punk and Rock Blues, my Dad made me listen and learn some Jazz; Ella Fitzgerald, Miles Davis, Dave Brubeck Quartet and the like. I still don't like listening to Jazz 28 years later, however, I do enjoy playing Jazz (it really fun to play) and it has made me a far better Bass player then I ever would have been without listening and play it. Also real bassist don't use picks ;p Well I guess the could use a pick, I guess they could play with with their feet too that would be just as useful ;p ;) Love your guys musical analysis. I know its been pointed out but Sacrifice not from Salem point of view, main theme line "You can't take {my} life {I'm} not your {Sacrifice}" is not something Salem would or need to say. It's Someone who is no longer falling for the lies everyone else is and will not give their life for this lie of a world. Even from what we know at the end of Volume 3 this isn't Salem or Cinder. What we learn later make it less likely either of them are the view point of this song, than more. There is also lovely foreshadowing for later as things from Volume 6 Chapter 3 as talked about as it was already been written when Sacrifice was written. Things that the 3rd candidate and correct person could known some of.

[@SirsMadamsEntertainment]

We don’t need no stinking picks!!! Anytime I’ve been in a cover situation where I want to stay true to the original the fingernail works just fine after playing with your pickups. If there is a need I’ve thought about doing quick tutorial lessons on techniques I’ve picked up over the years. ~ Sterling

[@musicisum0405]

1:30:58 I absolutely love that part. Sometimes when I'm listening to Sacrifice I'll rewind a few times just to listen to it over and over

[@whenwordsfailmusicspeaks246]

Sacrifice doesn't have a confirmed point of view. But a lot of the FNDM think it's from either Cinder's or Raven's point of view. Several things Raven says in later volumes lends weight to it possibly being about her.

[@dmillz5501]

The opening piano also plays when raven is talking to cinder in thier volume 5 fight.

[@dawnfallon6812]

And Raven's motif borrows from Sacrifice. And there is a later song that some in the FNDM believe is the answer to Sacrifice.

[@fernandogalian2794]

Is Raven to Ozpin. First she talks about Summer when she "died" doing what she was told to be good... the she talks how Ozpin sow the death of heroes and then rips the seed of a new generation of heroes... She is not another sacrifice for him and his lies that where revealed by Ruby and D'Jinn also Oscar, they all have "mirrored eyes" but is more to be Oscar than Ruby... All the plans he does are worthless. What if the sacrifice they made were all in vain?

[@goddesssalem4842]

Remember when everyone thought this was cinder song???, Remember when everyone thought this was raven song. It's turned out to be another Salem song

[@whenwordsfailmusicspeaks246]

@@goddesssalem4842 ??? Nothing in the lyrics implies it is a Salem song. Especially since several lines of cannon dialogue in the lyrics were spoken by Raven in the show.

[@lucasinazumai9873]

Normally I would skip the reactors comments on the video they watch if they're viewing several videos at once. But this is one I can't skip because of how intriguing their comments and thoughts are. Much like Renegade Faction and Blind Wave on their reaction videos, I watched the whole video just because the stories they have were intruiging.

[@SirsMadamsEntertainment]

Thanks!! We appreciate that... the funny part is we would have these same conversations and interactions without the camera there.. many times we have gone down a Spotify or KZbin rabbit hole while hanging out and just listening and absorbing stuff 🤔😂

[@masterlionheart]

I have to say I love these reviews. As a musician I love hearing your takes as well. I especially love the middle guy's take (Matthew? Just found you guys) since he seems to understand a bit more about Theory.

[@SirsMadamsEntertainment]

Yeah... all three of us are well versed in music theory.. but Matthew has perfect pitch... the bastard 😂

[@masterlionheart]

@@SirsMadamsEntertainment yeah I picked up on that later in the video (and the other videos) that you all were all well versed in theory, lol. I appreciate that a lot. I normally ignore the OST reactions to the RWBY music, but the review by musicians caught my attention. And yeah...perfect pitch...I'd love to have that, lol.

[@Media_Paradox]

Nobody: Matthew: More Tambourine!! Haha love it!!

[@domex3963]

I dont do music, so when they go really deep in to musical terms, im just sat there like "they speak the language of the gods"

[@stravinci4705]

lol You always know you've got a proper music analysis going when the Rite of Spring pops into the conversation

[@wulvesgaming3523]

It would be cool to see your reactions and hear your opinions on EruptionFangs RWBY Soundtrack Explained series, to see if you agree or interpret the songs differently after hearing his opinions for each verse.

[@ojc113]

I always thought that All Our Days was Yang's point of view talking to/about Ruby. Even when I found out Jeff wrote this for Casey, I still didn't make that connection lol

[@tatianawolf1253]

someone probably said it and as clear rwby fans as well you may have seen it yourself, but now you can get/ have back story on team CVFY in the books.

[@tatianawolf1253]

it never occurred to me that all our days was father-daughter in the show ( i understand it is jeff and Casey ) but yangs dad and this song didn't really fit my vision of him. I always saw it between the sisters or the team. or even rubys mom to ruby before she went away and didn't come back although that was me stretching when we didn't have every possible charachter. .

[@tatianawolf1253]

sacrifice makes ence from salems view, I originally thought it might have more to do with cinder, awhen we really didn't know anything about salem and before all those other volumes of crazy stuff come out.

[@thepointydoughnut5358]

I still think Sacrifice would have fit much better during the maiden fight in V.5 than All Things Must Die. Not that that's a bad song, but this one is just way better at a lot of what that song tries to do. I'd kill for a "remastered" version of this song with Casey's more mature vocals and skills

[@ravenhull]

Have y’all considered looking back at a couple of Jeff’s early RT work from RvB, such as ‘On Your Knees’ and ‘Fall Into the Sky’ (which has early Casey vocals).

[@shingshongshamalama]

Caffeine. Fox: *is an edgelord* Coco: *is too fucking good for you get out of my face* Yatsuhashi: "Hey guys you want some coffee?" Velvet: *doesn't get a verse*

[@MrKradix2]

Post Volume 4 Light Spoiler.... The last song “Sacrifice” is also thought to be from Ravens perspective talking to/about Ozpin

[@MrKradix2]

Also a big fan of Repo Man Genetic Opera

[@SirsMadamsEntertainment]

S&M comes in a little glass vile. ~ Sterling

[@MrKradix2]

Sirs & Madams Entertainment a little glass vile? (a little glass vile)... and it goes into the gun like a battery (battery)...

[@yamikai04]

So this is the kind of intro you get when I’m not around. You’re welcome ~ Sterling.

[@MaulMachine]

If you need backstory for Team CFVE, they have a book called After The Fall.

[@valashar5313]

Late to the game comment, but Team CFVY is 2nd year in volumes 1-3 and a touch of their own first year (and some more of their 2nd year interactions w/ Team RWBY's first year) can be found in the book RWBY: After the Fall. I'd put in a mild volume 6 spoiler warning for the end of the book but I'm pretty sure that by the time I'm posting this that y'all have at least recorded your reaction to V6C1. Casey Lee puts up vids of her reacting to other's reactions to the RWBY soundtrack on her YT channel. The one she did for volume 2, specifically 'All Our Days' she talks about how she didn't know anything about the song until she went in to record and about halfway through she realized that Jeff had written it about HER and she broke down.

[@KeterLordFR]

I can't wait for you to reach Volume 4 soundtrack. It has some of the best songs made for RWBY

[@Batmans_Pet_Goldfish]

I get what you mean when you say you hear some Highway Star in Caffeine. I think it's probably also something to do with the way they used the keyboard during the second half of each verse.

[@ravenhull]

Looking at Sacrifice, I am now convinced this is directed at Cinder. "All the lives you took, yet no closer to your goal."

[@handtomouth4690]

I don't think it's Cinder, but I won't say because spoilers.

[@jazzyj3059]

Boop is so adorable 😻

[@shingshongshamalama]

Team CFVY are all banging. You can't convince me they're not.

[@timothystamm3200]

Am I the only one who thinks that Dream Come True sounds like an early to mid seventies Chicago song.

[@JanizMakudomaru]

The reason why it sounds simple is because the band "Simple Plan" came put and one old man was too literal and shared with his music industry friend "Simple Plan", and from then on music became more and more simple.

[@JanizMakudomaru]

No wonder Pyrrha got the discoish song. Disco is kinda DEAD. 😀

[@yuliybekutadaten-shi8294]

I always thought sacrifice was from raven’s point of view to both Oz and at times to Salem

[@billa3785]

During Caffeine. I think his voice sounds like Dave Meniketti from and old 80's California band Y&T.

[@SirsMadamsEntertainment]

Bill A ...totally fair 👍🏻👍🏻

[@KonathaoSoberuNartio]

Dude on the left VERY much reminds me of a friend of mine named Tim Sweat. Y'all wouldn't happen to be related, would ya? 😂

[@bensupersaiyangodbrony71]

Sacrifices about Raven talking to ozpin

[@wyatttingle2590]

Quick question are you planning on having the people that are currently doing the rwby reactions have a ost reaction aswell or do they just listen to it offscreen Also noice video so far i love all the musical analysis stuff

[@SirsMadamsEntertainment]

Wyatt Tingle ... yeah we want to include them as scheduling allows... these first two just didn’t happen that way.

[@wyatttingle2590]

@@SirsMadamsEntertainment okay thanks

[@yamikai04]

I was slotted to I just had shows booked for the days we filmed. The joys of being a working musician.

[@SirsMadamsEntertainment]

BrownSugaJerk oh that’s right... you were all scheduled to come over and then had to learn like 40 tunes real fast for a show that popped up.

[@Nvmzax]

I love your OST reviews, and if you do not review all the volumes like this I will ... I WILL ... be very disappointed.

[@SirsMadamsEntertainment]

Vol 3 comes out Friday. 😁 What was it about how we did this vid that you liked?

[@Nvmzax]

@@SirsMadamsEntertainment Well, I used to play violin for over 20 years. I was a part of a small orchestra, took solfeggio lessons and had the same tutor for the majority of the time. Music, all kinds of music, is still a major part of my life, even If I do not play an instrument at the moment. Now, despite English not being my native language, your usage of specific terminology while describing your thoughts and feelings towards RWBY music I really adore makes the experience quite different from the others and to be honest a real treat. And you Do feel it, you do feel it the same way I feel it! Keep doing what you are doing and keep on being passionate about it. It really shows that what you do is what you love, and that always brings a smile on my face.

[@colt1903]

Sassy "Hey!" Weiss is best Weiss.

[@j7zephyr831]

Always thought that Sacrifice was from the pov of Raven, talking to a dieing Summer for the first verse and too Ozpin for the second...

[@urtoryu_dy_althraidn]

I think Sacrifice fits better as Raven to Ozpin than Salem to Ozpin, but of course, that would only work if Raven knew that.

[@deaddead698]

14:30 Ok, will do

[@justotxsu1898]

All hail

[@7WomaNation]

is it were that keep mistaking Rush With Push Play

[@liamharrold3762]

casey's birthday is 25 November 1998 incase this helps :P so 21 this november :)

[@charredeggroll1967]

SPOILER WARNING "Revealed by mirrored eyes" Confirms that the song IS Salem talking to Ozpin. Mirrored eyes like shiny and glossy, or in Ruby's case, silver and bright white. And Ruby revealed the truth about what Ozpin was hiding all these years~

[@launchedplane3632]

When you get to the volume 4 soundtrack, you should listen to this amazing Male cover of "This Life is Mine." It's so good. kzbin.info/www/bejne/g2mqk5KrYrR3qLc

[@jauneork278]

Reviewing Die, I now think part of it is from salems point of view, The reason being.. is that i believe Time to die isn't something our heroes would sing, but something salem is singing towards the gods. of course team rwby is singing in this song also.

[@salemsremnent1247]

It's a Salem song, nothing matches for raven

[@Muxeroth]

You should add timestamps for every song

[@SirsMadamsEntertainment]

Tuxxer they are in the pinned comment

[@Iejir_Isk]

Ah, Sacrifice... the song that has sparked the most controversy I think. Also, part of the reason I stopped trusting Pinhead at all.

[@TheShockwave1138]

Yeah, Sacrifice is, in my opinion, not a Salem song, I've always read into it as a Raven song...

[@LordJuzzie]

Sacrifice is not really to do with Salem. Its more to do with another character but I don't know how spoliery this would be so I am not going to say.

[@ArchImperatrix]

You are correct; still surprised how many people think this song is about Salem or Cinder, its like that they got it in their head in early and wont give it up. Its odd Specially given the lyrics.

[@rmdur7567]

Honestly, it works for both. "Did the things you thought you should, all the things THEY said were good."

[@ArchImperatrix]

@@rmdur7567 It doesn't work for Cinder or Salem due to the title of the song and the main thrust of the lyrics "You can't take {my} life {I'm} not your {Sacrifice}" but if you what to ignore the main part of the song completely I guess you can make it work but you have to ignore the line and theme completely.

[@rmdur7567]

@@ArchImperatrix Salem's almost a literal sacrifice to bring the gods' judgment and make humanity whole again, because Ozpin won't gather the four relics until he's gotten rid of her. He's going to use her life, he's going to destroy her, in order to bring humanity together. There are some clearly direct references to The Lost Fable here too, especially when Miles confirmed they wrote that chapter even before the show started.

[@ArchImperatrix]

@@rmdur7567 She is not required to do O job just something he thinks, Not what was asked of him please delete your comment with all the spoilers

[@yoashbarak373]

I have to seriously disagree with the art chosen for Sacrifice. none of the characters portrayed are actually connected to the most plausible point of view, and who it is directed at. Saying any more is possibly spoiling for someone, so I wouldn't. but I'd say that a re-view of sacrifice's meaning after watching V5 is far more telling, and even moreso after V6.

[@insertsomethingrelatable2494]

owo < oowoo

[@Kaylakaze]

Sacrifice is from Raven's POV, not Salem.

[@nacht5766]

Rwby volume 7 is out pls give a reaction to it please.. I really love your rwby reactions thanks...

[@SirsMadamsEntertainment]

We are reacting to vol 7... we just have to abide by rooster teeth rules for youtube.

[@FixTheWi-Fi]

Unpopular Opinion: Lamar's raps are some of my least favourite parts of the RWBY soundtrack. I Burn is tolerable (albeit unnecessarily "edgy" with the swearing), but Caffeine would be so much better without it. He just lists off coffee types. It's just kinda cringey to me. They always feel forced.

[@mytho-seb]

I disagree except for I Burn, but I respect your opinion

[@Phantom_Fireside]

I agree hun, i could do without the one in Caffeine

[@ienzio7795]

Late but most versions of I burn don't have the swearing. Lamar didn't know the show was supposed to be kid friendly when he first did his part so he did two versions.

[@PG9_]

I politely tell you to leave NOWWWWWW

[@FixTheWi-Fi]

@@PG9_ This comment was made before Celebrate existed iirc. now *that* has a nice Lamar verse