Must-toonekurg~ Karl tries the dead chick tossing out of nest~2017/06/01 8:25pm

Hatching Asynchrony and Brood Reduction:
web.stanford.e...
Infos about the season: www.looduskalen...
Estonia Black Stork Camera:
pontu.eenet.ee/...
• Must-toonekurg

[@liznm-natur-channel]

Why do birds kill their chicks? www.looduskalender.ee/forum/viewtopic.php?p=516905#p516905 summary of the season: www.looduskalender.ee/n/en/node/1707

[@franniebanani6532]

liznm it either senses it's diseased and dying or already dead needs to make room for the survivors to grow

[@arnottpotter6225]

In this particular case im pretty sure the adult purposely killed the runt to save food for the other babies. Survival of the fitest. No one ever said life was fair.

[@kailashchavan2506]

liznm eqefrt

[@Rundownbuildings2]

I don't think that she kill her chicks because if she kill that chick and she know that it already dead then why don't she leave it over that and kill the reas of her kids????So I think she did not kill her chicks.

[@lvldarwin]

Survival of the fittest. It's usually the other chicks that kill a sibling when the mother is away.

[@sapnadhand2101]

it's very sad to see any living being die,especially when it's a parent and a child. i'm very thankful to scientists and researchers who educate the general public about the world around us. life is not always a bed of roses, and this adage applies to everyone and everything. plz continue to upload videos so that we can protect nature for future genrations

[@liznm-natur-channel]

thanks for your comment

[@chimpolaspos7445]

Sapna Dhand

[@silkfantasies5899]

Sapna Dhand u

[@MuhammadkhalilHameed-zt4sh]

Sapna Dhand I am respect your comments💓💓 03476029083

[@DS-wh6is]

Very thankful to scientists? Let me help you awaken. You are on the wrong path. ❤️

[@janemillerick9614]

just one of many: "Black stork parents have been known to kill one of their young, generally the smallest, in times of food shortage to reduce brood size and hence increase the chance of survival of the remaining nestlings. Stork nestlings do not attack each other, and their parents' method of feeding them (disgorging large amounts of food at once) means that stronger siblings cannot outcompete weaker ones for food directly, hence parental infanticide is an efficient way of reducing brood size. Despite this, this behaviour has not commonly been observed.[14]" en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_stork

[@shifatmahmud7996]

Jane Millerick so basically its kinda an abortion except the parent kills their own offspring?

[@Mary56]

WOW! I've never heard of parental infanticide. I do know that Blue Heron chicks kill each other when there's a food shortage, (siblicide) but not the parents.

[@ArtixxFoxxes]

Its nature and this is how they continue their species. Humans dont like it but thats fucking fine. Its how nature has come to deal with shit. If there wasnt a need for this they wouldnt have to do it. Many animals practice infanticide. Its natural af for them. When there isnt food and you can only feed one...and you got 3...the strongest one wins. Cause they will be strong enough to survive and carry the species on

[@elzayx9222]

​@@ArtixxFoxxes Well said

[@jefffraley7094]

I was wondering if these birds had reverse serrations on the inside of their beaks, since the fish they impale don't slide off easily. Looks like that's a yes.

[@mrbushwookie6051]

You mean barbs?

[@seltaeb9691]

Ooooh get you Mr Attenborough!😉

[@seltaeb9691]

@@mrbushwookie6051 it means what he says. Reverse serrations is explained better visually than barbs which comes in different ways depending on the animal.

[@ツライさん-m1i]

鳥も生体反応を本能的に確認する術を持っているように見えました､すごいですね

[@judywright8455]

Yes from stress and abuse. The chick was fine and thriving all along, even at the morning feeding this day. But Katie has been picking it up and shaking it by the head the past week as if to threaten it. Seems Katie didn't like the baby's size. This am Katie removed the baby from the nest area and kept shaking it, throwing it around, and no food of course. Now the baby is so weak and Dad is in on the action to oust the baby. How sad. Best try not to be the last born chick in this species. I read the detailed post about species behavior by another viewer. Thanks for the info. It's so cruel to see this in real life.

[@jomarhl897]

Judy Wright I feel same way too not like people just simply saying it’s nature, well it is but have just have some respect and feelings as well you know

[@VAULT-TEC_INC.]

Obviously it wasn’t “fine” and certainly not “thriving.” Look at how skinny and underdeveloped it’s wings are co pared to the others.

[@MASNSEN10]

Chez les humains . Il y'a l'avortement . C'est cruel comme attitude pour se débarrasser d'un nouveau né .

[@darthsavant23]

Judy Wright the chick was sickly & dying. Mother was shaking it attempting to get it to move more. Mother instinctively knew it was runt of litter and weak. They often has one in every batch.. nature is rough.

[@MuhammadkhalilHameed-zt4sh]

Judy Wright most honour from side to tour words

[@TwinAero]

Is this a biological instinctive behavior or do the chicks learn this process as babies as apply it when they have nest of their own?

[@TrustGod-l6j]

Reminds me of what I have to do to get my kids out of bed for school.

[@heatherconklin6798]

Hahaha same

[@pecilaable]

All birds do that ,to keep the nest clean.But birds of prey usually eat it.

[@dhirajsthakor7519]

T

[@LaphyTaphyCreation]

That's the coolest line I've ever heard 0w0

[@raidenmk4473]

A stray cat had her babies in my backyard. They were old enough to see and walk around when I noticed they were back there. The mother grabbed one of the kittens with her mouth. Pulled the kitten to the side and started eating the kitten. All I heard was a cracking sound. When I noticed what she was doing. I was like WTF she bit the kittens head off. The mother cat looked at me and keeped eating away.

[@SarahHere4GodOnly]

💔😭💔😭🌈🌈🕯️🕯️

[@ahuramjito2802]

🤢

[@djr6876]

I know the expert says its trying to toss it out of the nest, but is it really that hard to do? Looks like he’s trying to revive it to me.

[@michaelshannon6558]

Nah. He’s just standing bf in one place too close to the center of the nest to be able to drop it out of the nest. He’s not smart enough to move toward the edge.

[@wayzospace]

Today on Karl tries Karl tries the dead chick tossing put of nest

[@Akai-Shade]

This momma bird is showing typical behavior. Flipping, pecking, slight tossing, stepping. Are signs she's desperately trying to bring her chick back. Like most birds during nesting they try their hardest to raise all their chicks. Of course this chick is obviously the smallest and was probably starved by it's siblings, at this moment in time momma bird had no chance to stop it because well only strongest will live. It is obvious she's checking the chick to see if it's alive. If it is but is rapidly dying she'll have no choice then to dispose of the chick because if she leaves it she risks her chicks of either getting sick or predators will easily find the nest from the dead chicks smell. If it is dead she'll just do the same. This is very common with nesting birds and it is something we have to accept.

[@liznm-natur-channel]

this momma bird is a male

[@amandaelaine2363]

I wonder why it kept tossing the dead chick around? Why not just get rid of it?

[@Alex-dw2hz]

А разве это не та птица, которая мучительно убивала птенца? Если да, то зачем она его пытается оживить??

[@alanchuangi]

such a poor baby, rest in peace

[@hypergrafi3769]

Sadece 3 yavruya bakabileceğini düşündüğü ve onu daha zayıf gördüğü için istemiyor olabilirmi?

[@primitiveshakil4925]

osthir video boss....I love your channel .... never miss your video

[@jack86]

Looks like the mom wont let it go. That's the saddest thing for the stork to remove the perished chick out of the nest. May the wind bear your soul swiftly to your anchestor, little chick

[@낙화유수-d7u]

이런걸 어떻게 촬영? ㅋ 상당한 연구. 깊은 끈기. 뭔가를 이뤄낸다는건, 이토록 처절한 번민으로? 엄청나다 !!

[@excel2minutes]

Actually chick died long ago.But mother is trying to awaken it pretending to throw it out of nest. But it's unknown how it died.

[@kwgrid]

Watched the preceding clips. Is the chick dieing from the stress?

[@AsadKhan-dd7pp]

She did not killed her chick he is dead itself.now she is relactant to throw him away.

[@yautjaelite2396]

Asad Khan no she killed it, some birds often kill or reject the weaker offspring seeing as how they won’t survive for long.

[@music0cool]

No she killed it for being weak

[@av3r3st24]

what I'm thinkin

[@rubyh.3838]

The mom killed him (in this video its the dad), watch first video kzbin.info/www/bejne/gqLcYpuHZd1rpJo

[@tharei6156]

Asad Khan im previous video actually the mama killed that chicks

[@beterminated9205]

I think it is CPR for birds baby

[@TheStepmonkey]

2:02 The sibling is trying to hide its face just to not see his death brother's face so close...

[@cat-tl8pp]

No, it's because they are trying to keep warm. Baby birds are known to huddle together to keep warm from the cold

[@nonchalantjay7702]

TheStepmonkey you can clearly see them peck at the body a view times

[@diabl2master]

Why does she pick it up and put it down repeatedly?

[@DeinoZu]

Rest in peace bro

[@llamar6070]

She never “tossed” it out the nest.

[@drizzle_246]

Llamar the title says "tries". Doesn't mean she did it.

[@tinamkrkmn]

Dumb asses HIS NAME IS KARL. that's not the mom

[@FrancisMburukamunyu]

Are you choking on something? She seems to wonder. Half wanting to let go half not sure.

[@DerrBeezy]

Awww I felt bad 😢💛 Edit: Feel

[@nathangagnon4950]

It wasn’t tossing it out, it was trying to revive it.

[@dr.physiker9930]

She is bringing it back to the conciousness !!

[@kevinvu5432]

No....she is not...are you really a doctor?

[@sliceman8422]

She is doing what has to be done so the rest will live.

[@shellmora]

Did the other chicks kill it?

[@こまさん-c7o]

木の幹が下を向いてるのに、どうやって作ったの🤔🤔

[@Naturezaedicasdecultivo]

Porquê ela fez isso?

[@mohsenazizi4768]

In different species of animals, the rules and logic of living are different, and we must accept the facts of wildlife.....While stronger chicks are not aggressive towards weaker siblings, as is the case in some species, weak or small chicks are sometimes killed by their parents. This behaviour occurs in times of food shortage to reduce brood size and hence increase the chance of survival of the remaining nestlings! Sad but real😔

[@愛子様-g7s]

ちょっと切ない動画ですね(´；ω；`)お母さん、動かなくなった子供を必死になんとか助けようとしてるのかな？ ちょっと悲しくなった。

[@eduardomichael4432]

Meu ovo

[@yairst2053]

違いますよ。自然は残酷です。残りの大きなヒナに十分にエサが行き渡るように弱く小さなヒナを葬ろうとしてるだけです。

[@meggi8048]

why do they dispose the chick and not eat it instead? isnt this waste of resources?

[@marionwolf2450]

Why the chick is dead??

[@elekrii]

Is one of tje babies dead??😢

[@イーブイさん]

そりゃ大事な我が子が動かなくなったらどうすればいいかわからないよね😢 っていうか高っ！！ 高所恐怖症には無理だ…😱

[@わらびもち-y6k]

間引きのために親鳥が自分で殺したんだよ。これはまだ虐め抜いているか、死んだかどうかの確認をしている。 いかに人間が自己解釈＝自己都合の強い生き物か分かるコメントだね。

[@kenichiro7130]

人間の道徳心を動物界に押しつけても。。。 これは間引き行動です。かわいそうだからではなく、他の子たちの生存確率を上げるための術です。進化の過程で築き上げたものであり、彼ら動物には善悪の意識があってやっていません。 全ては子孫を残すため

[@СардорИсмаилов-ц9л]

Очень тяжолая картина... 😓 Я так понял, она хочет реанимировать малыша, но понимает, что все очень плохо...

[@ЕвгенияПашкова-ц6щ]

Сардор Исмаилов вот бедненький ребёнок. Как же жалко этого ребёнка. Он жить хотел с мамой. Царство небесное и земля пухом этому бедному ребёнку. Гринпис.

[@saltmadam7937]

Не хватает еды..самого слабого часто сбрасывают с гнезда.Осенью улетают на зимовку,если птенцы будут слабые,то не долетят.Естественный отбор...

[@ВалентинаЧетина-в4ъ]

А она все старается, надеется)

[@Tv-ec2xn]

@@ЕвгенияПашкова-ц6щ она сама его прикончила, так что сопли распускать нет причины.

[@ritadebrunetti4632]

Это она же его и убила, есть полное видео, не для слабонервных, оно ужасное.

[@Bahzing1]

Its shaking it to wake it up...looks bewildered.

[@dianaking2172]

What happened to the chick?

[@Andrea-ij8ki]

It is typical in some species, the chick that is born last will be smaller and weaker than its siblings, the latest arrival of the brood will not be able to compete to grab the food brought to the nest by the mother and day after day hir health will worsen . As you can see the brothers are bigger and he is small and gracile because of food. The mother instead of helping him choose the strongest and abandon the weaker one.This is a pity it would suffice that the mother was more careful in the first 2 weeks to give food even to the last born, it would become as strong as the brothers. It happens in many species above all among birds of prey where the last born is eaten and the firstborn survives. Do you think a little about our women when they have to choose a partner, do you notice any analogy? :)

[@bryanwhite2886]

It is very very sad man trying her best to recover the chick . 😥

[@kevinvu5432]

No....that's not what is happening

[@greenmanggo4940]

What I see here is she try to wake the chick (maybe still hoping tht chick still alive)

[@thangvuong9196]

NeNeL DaNiaL Nope she's the one that killed it

[@mrblajeck3367]

Thang Vuong jeez how would you know

[@rubyh.3838]

mr blajeck kzbin.info/www/bejne/gqLcYpuHZd1rpJo watch first video. Momma bird kills the chick. This video is the aftermath when the dad comes to nest.

[@chinwl58]

Thang Vuong bullshit

[@anakkampungfelda]

Yes...that's true.. not kill...no One mother in the world want kill thier sun.

[@fawadfawadi4211]

Why you killed him, the bird ?

[@Eagle_Goddess]

Why did baby die????😭

[@madscientist9904]

とても興味深い動画です。 貴重な動画をありがとうございます。

[@sumitbodele]

That's very painful for the mother and to watch this video to see her baby is not alive.

[@venugopal.nmulavanaeruva4898]

I think its trying to give a natural treatment. If its gets some shake or slam, there is possibility to come back to the life. Her last try to save

[@tioonieretita7798]

Is this natural selection

[@291281]

Why die?

[@thiyang5887]

What's she doing?

[@thiyang5887]

Not understand

[@user-tr5gj9is3u]

Thi Kim kob nis

[@starkreality4969]

The mother killed off the baby because it was too weak and she didn't want to waste time and energy to feed it if it was going to die anyways. This is the father who is shaking the baby to see if it is still alive.

[@dogandchickenchannel]

Great video Enjoyed 😍😍😙😙😙 #########

[@jesusitorayala8214]

The mother tried to revive the little chic

[@jorgelcurioseavakinlife4450]

Una pregunta que estaba haciendo el ave con el o lo estaba matando o qué que alguien me explique porfa

[@aquilesvaestaparada4039]

karen Sofia Domínguez Agüero le está dando unos tiernos besos por que lo ama jjj

[@RapterGamer34]

Está verificando si sigue con vida o no, si fuera a matarlo ya lo hubiese echo de unos cuántos picotazos además para asegurarse si sigue con vida lo mueve de un lugar a otro para ver si reacciona pero se nota que ya murió

[@RapterGamer34]

Quizá ya lo mato antes quizá porque solo podía mantener a los más fuertes y el mas débil tendría que morir, que lástima

[@luna9411]

creo esta confundida ve ke su bb esta inerte y trata de ver ke pasa xon el esta preocupada..trarta de reanimarlo

[@jussaracattani9840]

Assim também penso. Tentando reanimalo.

[@lunacally4903]

The other chicks probably killed it so they would receive more food . I see it in birds all the time . Chicks throwing and pushing each other out of nests . Little bastards are ruthless .

[@Dylan-ur6yb]

Maybe the mama bird knows that theres not enough food for all of them

[@MalteseTV]

안타깝네요 새끼 한마리가 죽었네 ㅠㅠ

[@쇠몽둥이가약]

말티즈 TV 그러게요 제법 키운거 같은데ㅠㅜ

[@TheWillOfFenris]

It seems like shes really struggling with the decision. She really wants him to come back and cant stand to throw him out. She poofs up and hangs her head and becomes very still. Somber. :( birds have complex emotions. Poor momma.

[@kevinvu5432]

The stork killed the bird...

[@s.k9172]

Great video nice very nice very nice very

[@danielaa8781]

The bird was trying to resuscitate the chick based on instinct

[@frankskinner9806]

Daniela A nope the mom killed it and that's the dad

[@rawanchohan1333]

Daniela A 9711447363

[@rawanchohan1333]

Daniela A फोटो तो बड़ा मस्त लगा रखा क्या नशीली आंखें तुम्हारी क्या जवाब है आपका मैंने फोन नंबर भेज दिया है और कॉल करना मेरे पास आप कब कर रही हो यह बताना मेरे को ठीक है नंबर मैंने भेज दिया है

[@lmSheep]

Daniela A you have no idea what you are talking about lol the mother bird is the one who killed the chick to begin with

[@أميربأخلاقي-ع8و]

Daniela A Hii07516524689

[@toucha2058]

The chick is not moving anymore. That is so sad.

[@udkmefr11]

The other little baby chicks look so scared and confused

[@sesomoral9633]

Thanks for the information 👍👍👍👍👍

[@mohammadjulhas9260]

very very good mam

[@leewinmangang8031]

She is not killing,she is trying to wake him up...but...inside her heart is cried and broken........that's their nature....

[@Nizar713]

Happy mothers day

[@ijustpulledthetrigger5482]

nizar pk lol but sad

[@그분의뜻]

미친새.끼

[@BobbedMcBob]

Ew, poor baby chick. What happened to it?

[@skylerroblox2622]

Did you see this in real life or no but you could of help the bird

[@OG21020]

I've seen vids where another of the same bird species visited the nest and threw all the chicks out and the parent did nothing.

[@carnagecat7972]

Where

[@charzpak7173]

It's trying to see if it's still alive

[@rackinfrackin]

How do you know the mom's name is Karl? ;b

[@parveenbishnoi1560]

Because the guy named her

[@chrismarshall7220]

That bird seems about as clever as some of the blokes I work with 🤣🤣

[@kppwinn]

I think that if birds kill their chicks is because they either think or know something is wrong with them and they won't survive

[@jocelynramirez2253]

There's another video where it shows that the mom was killing it, the baby bird was alive but she killed it

[@evapclalnunmawii2561]

Mother is first trying to find out the possibility of wether the chick is stil alive...so sad how she try to awake it...i dnt think she try to throw

[@maxsheng8215]

Crane simulation. Apparently the adult is lifting a dead weight.

[@kppwinn]

Never seen trees move like that.

[@user-in4pd8qu53]

Жалко так! Даже птица пытается спасти своего детёныша! Аж сердце разрывается...😢

[@user-nanikore11]

親鳥の子供見てるしどうしよう…………感がハンパない(　・ω・)

[@Erika-yi1fj]

It's like she's comparing the dead one to her live chicks. "Ok moving chicks means alive, this one doesn't do anything so that means?????"

[@kevinvu5432]

No....for storks this is common...

[@kerpe2570]

Poor mami lost her baby 😞, so sad........but she can't be sad because she got four more babies alive and she can give her love to those alive babies, may God give her the happinnes to be fine, is so sad when we lost somebody from our family or a friend, that's why sometimes we understand animals when they lost their babies, may God make this mom be happy again

[@حيدرسعد-خ5ت]

هل هو مريض يبعده عن العش

[@tongkatali7643]

Survival of the fittest. Nature at its logic

[@ايهانابراهيمابراهيم]

هاد ميت من الجوع لنو أربعة الأم ما فيها تطعمي الأربعة 😔😔

[@رحمونيحنينالعراق]

لا مامات من جوع بس امه كتلته والله صح اكو ام مجرمه وهاذا شي عدنه بل عراق

[@successchem650]

Not tossing out to the next dear she is trying to awake her child which is called love.attachement with their children even after die

[@Pratapbrazil]

Wrong caption, he is in too much pain and try to give his dude CPR 😞😞

[@yassinalaesa6341]

سبحان الله

[@alejandroreyes9975]

Karl- Damn nigga why you in such a deep sleep

[@asifmetal666]

I think she tries to revive the baby. Or maybe she torn, don't know what to do

[@nathalyreis6894]

O pássaro matou o filhote?

[@sarfarazamindar6632]

She is confused what to do

[@reneeandbisan3978]

She looks like she doesn't want to get rid of it

[@tinydancer9602]

Did anyone else notice it moved when it was first picked up and put back down 🤔

[@SahtitBKK]

It’s look like it try to wake up that body but it isn’t.

[@pantherinthedarknessPandra]

Its almost like she is grieving she seems to shake it to see if theirs any life or i know some crane speciesthe parent actually torments and kills the runt it could be either one.