[MV] 휘인 (WHEE IN) - Good Bye (Prod. Jungkey)

[@exessen1684]

*"I just want to say that the shape of love is diverse and melt that into a painting? I want to say that, whatever form it is, it's all the same love."* -Wheein

[@monemori]

💖💖💖

[@TQM]

I didn't realize what that meant in the teasers, but after watching the MV, it makes so much sense. Another reason to love Mamamoo Her paintings have a whole new meaning for me now.

[@Kitamurasama]

Wait... the actress was actually in love with the girl in green dress?

[@wendymooremusic]

@@Kitamurasama yes

[@viv6222]

My theory is that the two women were in a relationship 😭

[@sellyjxxx7572]

Hwasa - Twit ( whats like to have a stupid partner) Wheein - Good bye ( making a big decision of letting go, break up and acceptance ) Moon -Eclipse ( reflects that moving on needs to show your other side and be fearless ) Solar - Spit out ( enjoy life and tell the world how much you love yourself and ready to love again) First Female group to have all members undergo solo. Love it!! 🤩🤩

[@elina460]

all members of loona have solos too

[@wheeinqueen]

First korean group from small company and 3rd generation, and second korean group in history , to have all their members charting in Billboard world digital songs (the first group to have all their members charting is 2ne1 😉)

[@Pyxyty]

Ya'll gonna pretend Easy dodn't exist? Smh

[@issanagayyesoryes]

@@Pyxyty of course not, Easy is the reverse of Twit

[@violetta698]

Actually the conclusion of Twit is that she was the stupid partner all along as she didn't appreciate her partner

[@CrazyPingPong97]

just in case some international fans didnt know, Goodbye was at #1 on Melon chart (the most popular streaming chart) after its release and stayed in Melon top 100 for 5 months which is an impressive feat for a song without any promotions! just wanted to assure wheein fans who are disappointed by the number of views in this MV!! totally valid though, continue streaming!!

[@edev6070]

CrazyPingPong97 international she gets dirt while nationally flowers. I really don’t get international kpop fans.

[@simsan4743]

Yes! So proud of her and not just Melon but all streaming chart except Flo which some said was not valid cause it was rather new. Correct me if I'm wrong.

[@elsa1048]

Wow WHEEIN POWER

[@blobblobblobblob7065]

that's good to know omg

[@theacarino7114]

Still streaming, thank you so much for the info! ❤

[@averilluna322]

My girlfriend of 10 years left me a year ago. Told me repeatedly that she loved me when she's breaking up with me but afraid of what other people might say. Saying that we're not kids anymore and she'll take a chance on a man. Don't know but I felt used. Haha. Listening to this song is both sad and therapeutic. Wheein's voice is magical, it either takes me away from reality or made me deeply feel the reality.

[@orengk2443]

Nah, that girl wasn't brave enough. "We're not kids anymore." Yall are consenting adults. She'll take a chance on a man because she isn't strong enough to stand on her own two feet without one. The trash took itself out. You'll find your love

[@rinrinrainbow4173]

I'm so sorry to hear this. You deserve someone who fully commits to you no matter what. Sending all the love.

[@Maximus-rt3zx]

I'm really sorry you had to go through this. I hope you're healing well ❤️

[@stfuidk9798]

I truly hope you’re feeling better and healing, something similar happened to me, not on the same scale but similar, so I can relate a bit. I wish you well.🤍

[@JoYSunnYy]

It remind me of a manga that I read .

[@Strawberrt4-]

Wheein is super talented, beautiful she is born to shine please support this baby

[@pepperyiyi]

Lol how’s she boring I don’t get people she’s sooo much fun besides her talent?

[@wheeinqueen]

Unnecessary comment fam u.u

[@Strawberrt4-]

Wheein Queen Leewan Li, don’t get me wrong, I just heard it a lot of times from haters so

[@pepperyiyi]

Vanilla Cake I know you are not saying that I just don’t get it in general lol

[@exessen1684]

Kind of an odd comment but ok

[@kucukseylereadanmsbirsiir3517]

Lets find who is main vocal in mamamoo! Solar: Like Wheein: Like Hwasa: Like Moonbyul: Like

[@yizhuoluv2186]

küçük şeylere adanmış bir şiir its solar, but they all deserve main vocal tbh

[@kucukseylereadanmsbirsiir3517]

@@yizhuoluv2186 i know

[@GabbyBruce20]

Nadie she’s actually a very good vocalist, she trained as a vocalist before making the switch to rapping so she could debut.

[@XxwalaweixX]

@@GabbyBruce20 yup, she's been a vocalist since trainee but she had to change to rapper position since Solar, Wheein and Hwasa is too good

[@brawlgachaecrin2400]

türk müsün?

[@yunqi9835]

this mv was really a bold move by wheein and rbw, they could've gotten lots of backlash but still went with it. their support towards lgbtq+ community is really amazing

[@allenclw3361]

Can you give me examples where LGBTQ+ videos have gotten backlash ib Korea in the past 20 years?

[@unknownfangirl1712]

@@allenclw3361 well for example lgbtq+ is really hated in korea

[@spbfce]

@@allenclw3361 I mean Korea are pretty conservative when it comes to LGBTQ+. But not all Koreans dislike the idea, they are just embarrassed to admit it since it will bring controversy.

[@angel_inur9536]

Wait this mv is about lgbtq+???but the girl fell in love with a guy?

[@jieunsoloist]

@@angel_inur9536 Not the girl is crying because her ex-girlfriend is with another, she is at home remembering the moments with her girlfriend Sorry my bad english

[@RebeccaBlink]

REDD ALBUM IS COMING YALL IM SO EXCITED

[@lllllllll5315]

YESSSSSSSSSSSSSSS

[@teamomumumumuch25]

Yes!!!!! We're so excited

[@nmirzaie4343]

Rebecca moomoo when?🤣

[@hy.1230]

@@nmirzaie4343 april 13 ❤️❤️❤️ Redd wheein solo album

[@idalseonyeo12]

same

[@pinkcloud17]

wheein achieved no. 1 in melon and in other charts for this song that was announced only 7 days ago and promoted only through sns, no tv and radio promotions. her last solo activity was may 2018 too. she really just did it with her wonderful voice.

[@helenchua3408]

RBW is dumb af, we been knew. When Wheein hit #1 with Jungkey with 'Anymore' they should've green-lit a single album with full promotion straight away. It's a real testament to her talent and Jungkey's composition skills that she can comeback after a year and pull off the same feat.

[@izzywoods794]

Yay!!

[@ray-xv7yg]

nation's main drummer im so proud of her sob

[@adara4635]

It was almost an all kill except for that FLO-chart :( So happy though!! She did amazing

[@nono-js8sy]

Proud🙌🙌🙌🙌

[@kairosen8302]

Holy shit Wheein actually just pulled a freaking K.Will on us. She's an iconic legend for a reason

[@aizzkww]

Chloe

[@XCalliXx]

Kai Rosen What does it mean "she pulled a k.will on us"?

[@kairosen8302]

@@XCalliXx If you go watch Please Don't by K.Will (released in 2011 or so I believe), you can see the parallells and similar patterns :)

[@nora-wb7sk]

calli at the end of one of k.will’s videos you see he wants his newlywed best guy friend as smth more

[@kalaksed]

it doesn't hurt that both videos have the same director. i'm pretty sure wheein tracked them down specifically for this

[@saintxxem1896]

wheein: the song is full of high notes jungkey: well i thought you'd hate it if i give you an easy song jungkey wasnt lying guys

[@wheeinies_dimpleee1484]

"I don't know if just the shape is different but I think there's many forms of love...and I think in the end it's all the same love. I want my message to be conveyed to many people. just like how there's a heart in the painting and all the colours melt together, it's all the same love" - jung wheein honestly love her

[@shobo4482]

omg i saw your comment like two days back on wheeins pastel cover! i notified you about the one month reminder! lmao holy shit

[@wheeinies_dimpleee1484]

@@shobo4482 damnnn i remember! i was so grateful for that 😭 i'm very surprised you found this comment it's like in the depths underneath all these others

[@shobo4482]

​@@wheeinies_dimpleee1484 noo it's like the third comment from the top for me lol! wheein bonding people through her attractiveness 🙇🙇 what's your favourite song of hers?

[@wheeinies_dimpleee1484]

@@shobo4482 ACTUALLY? that's wild and yes wheein the main slayer fr she even aces in bonding people virtually 😍🙏 my favourite song 😭 that's that's hard like lately ive been loving paraglide, 25, easy, the usual yk? but im also addicted to melody (i'm not sure if yk it, i happened to come across it one day) just overall her music 🛐🛐 hope she releases another album smh what's your favourite of hers?

[@shobo4482]

@@wheeinies_dimpleee1484 ace in everything we love her! 🤩🤩 lmao it really is a hard question dhdndn omg yes i love all those! have you seen the like 30 second long song "deserve"? shes so fucking hot there help dndksm like even more than usual oh i don't know melody, I'll check it out now yeah it's been a while I'm starved of new wheein content 😔💔 i love D-Day pastel easy watercolour...tbh everything lmao. have you seen her cover of solars honey? it's so good! and also the demo of hip that she released ughhh i love her so much honestly

[@gagasaccomplice1089]

I actually cried while listening to this. I just broke up with my girlfriend a few months ago and my family has been saying "I told you so" and I should've never got together with a girl. Wheein really helped me to move on from my situation by representing a subject that had been neglected by the media. That's why we moomoos love her.

[@yumekojabami210]

i’m so sorry for what you had to put up with. i hope you’re not listening to them. but yes that’s also why i’m grateful for this music video

[@arieldiakonikolh8258]

:(

[@AlejandroMoralesQuiroz]

I hope little by little you start doing ok. xo

[@tieraazman6968]

I feel sorry for you but believe pain we’ll make us more strong

[@ShroMashiro]

get well really soon for ur heart. cheer up!!

[@todayis_yongsun6514]

This Mv was so smart, it's straight enough for the Koreans but if you watch carefully it's about a wlw relationship. I have so much respect for wheein and rbw for making this happen. Everything was so beautiful 😭

[@mamamoo4x4ever96]

Ikrrr

[@jjw_llwd]

BIG BRAIN MOMENT

[@justignoremyusername]

Ikr!!

[@rutujaajadhav]

IKRRRR

[@constablk100]

What does WLW mean

[@ringadinga451]

You can tell SO MANY PEOPLE comment before watching because barely anyone seems to be mentioning the fact that *THE WOMAN WAS IN LOVE WITH THE OTHER WOMAN*

[@Ytb_hovie]

YES. I think they are former lovers for the girl to enter her house easily.

[@alexmavigok8915]

Right, when the couple entered the house the guy was panicked to see everything destroyed, while the woman was just standing there crying, because she knew it was her ex-lover, that's why she went directly to the painting room

[@aaliyahetc.6687]

Mamamoo definitely support the lgbt I love that about them.

[@amazonz8590]

Oh I didn't get that from the mv. I need English subs

[@Ytb_hovie]

@@alexmavigok8915 and the song is about cheating makes me wonder who's the cheater T_T

[@mila7399]

mentally, im still in this wheein era

[@adamwithbiebz]

The scene of wheein singing in front of the pink background is my new religion tbh

[@laviender]

Tbh SAME

[@angelicanina7117]

The fact that she painted that "background" is 🥺✨✨✨

[@moonbyulhamster1673]

If I'm not mistaken its Orange color, and she painted that

[@jill9149]

wheein is the nations vocalist pls listen to those flawless vocals

[@sarcasticsam8262]

Wheein has such a unique emotion to her singing and she’s so underrated in the kpop community damn. One of the best female vocalists in this generation for sure

[@ilive4anime.]

Do tell where you have seen her or any of the mamamoo members be considered less. To my knowledge, they have all been considered great vocalists

[@jihyosboobeesweat9412]

@@ilive4anime. yeah im pretty sure solar is considered one of the best vocalists

[@yesok5355]

Honestly Mamamoo is not underrated at all anymore. They are always praised for their vocals. And they deserve it.

[@moonbyulhamster1673]

She only underrated outside the international fandom, in korea an I-moomoos she so popular, Wheein already expercienced 2 PAK songs

[@purplekiss_swan]

I'm crying. Wheein's respect for LGBT makes me very happy. 🥺Wheein I love you. It's nice that the video is about LGBT people. 💖

[@sara-yc9jw]

SHE IS “LGBT PEOPLE” lmao

[@ariana199]

@@sara-yc9jw LMAO SHE'S JUST RESPECT LGBT..BUT SHE'S NOT LGBT PEOPLE

[@coolkitty154]

@@ariana199 She's never said it openly, but I think at this point we can safely say she is at least somewhat LGBT lol

[@thatrandomperson5828]

@@coolkitty154 Lets just enjoy the music, and the fact that she respects LGBTQ+ instead of pushing a sexuality on her, just like how we shouldn't assume an idol's straight, we shouldn't assume their queer, in fact their sexuality should be none of our business anyway.

[@your.lovely_monster]

@@ariana199 how do you know?

[@user-dx2yi3ms1w]

How many international fans are here to support Wheein ? For me 🇩🇪

Philippines leggooo 🥰🥰🥰

[@TheZouzou13400]

France

[@concealsecrets]

🙋🏻‍♀️🇸🇬

[@senayalman2227]

Turkey 🙌

[@Amanda-10702]

Taiwan！！♥

[@rbwartistsstan7720]

There’s a reason why the CEO of RBW said that Wheein is the backbone of Mamamoo. Her voice can literally back up, blend, and/or pair with any voice, any genre, etc. Of course, this does not discredit the other members at all; they are all talented and skilled. But I think we can all agree that Wheein has the best technique and widest versatility in the group.

[@Sunflower-vd1jj]

RBW Stan totally agree. She can pull off any concept and that amazes me every single time. I love her so much. 💗

[@wrong3555]

yes yes she's always been my fav vocalist

[@rbwartistsstan7720]

Credit to just a leaf 🍃

[@addlykajateklai1790]

Totally agree with you... Even RBW producer said that wheein voice matches any genre of song... And the fact that she can convey emotions very well made her be the producer's favourite to sing their song guides...

[@vadjulawakaru]

So true

[@starsoup4mybutterbean962]

Correct me if I’m wrong/ in case someone needs an explanation :) Story is that she breaks into her and her ex gf’s old house in which her ex gf and the new bf live. She reminisces on the times she spent in the house with her gf while finding her ex gf’s stuff like perfume and lipstick and trying it on bc she misses her. In heartbreak, she also messes up the place, paints over her ex gf’s painting, and throws away the new bf’s stuff. The ex gf knows it was her bc of the bf’s face being painted over in the picture but she’s already gone and moving on. Hope this helped! :D

[@borellaborhani3260]

She really is an angel 😭

[@disstann6930]

Ty for explaining 🙏

[@eliottemple563]

I have heard that however I don't think there's enough evidence to prove that, that is her ex gf house it could be the ex boyfriend but its really hard to tell for me

[@ais5013]

i think ex gf is more correct since the girl is more shown than her boyfriend

[@borellaborhani3260]

@@eliottemple563 i mean it’s obviously ex gf...

[@IWANNAKNOWKNOWKNOWWHATISLOVE]

i love how she actually painted the background for this mv

[@san1000]

Why no one talks about the mv.. This mv is such heartbreaking yet beautiful at the same time

[@leksudiib307]

Agree, freakin heart breaking

[@thealola4464]

It's so beautiful ..

[@basurachic1069]

Wheein is my mamamoo bias not only because she is extremely talented, but also because she shows all the time how much she supports the lgbt community/people of different races.. JUST STAN MAMAMOO EVERYONE

[@CraigWinstanley1]

NaySway i agree. When you think of all the great artists in the world, creative people, such as Wheein, see things with great clarity, display consideration for people without prejudice and a have a sensitive and caring personality.

[@alice0067]

STAN MAMAMOO who are real life goddess and such inspiration for woman.They are very talented and supports other people

[@colinaskey3733]

I love her too :3 she's so sweet and funny, loyal, talented and a true self, lucky the person that will have the chance to enter her heart.

[@jessicacabral8346]

Just imagine not coming to the kpop world and not knowing this piece of art

[@jadoremusic620]

Tragic!!

[@moonsunbish8396]

Totally!

[@GabbyBruce20]

Jessica Cabral I’ve only been here since April and I’m sad I wasn’t here sooner!

[@sunn_69]

Imagine the tragedy of not being a Moomoo

[@sweetvanillacoffee]

This could be a nightmare

[@yeoj1n907]

it's good to see yourself represented in mainstream media, especially if it is something monitored by societies and industries that still aren't open for human decency and equality. thank you wheein.

[@itzjustdre27]

*The only few kpop artists who actively speak about the LGBTQ+ community and empathizing with them.* Some artists might show support in a superficial way but this was deeper than that. This was beautifully produced, shot & her vocals matched so well with this.

[@mariamoomoo1441]

Even in HIP they included drag queens, Mamamoo are inpiring

[@msasma3240]

Thank god for them. These four women are truly setting new, progressive standards in the Kpop industry. They are quite literally the reformers and molders of the future of Kpop. They will be remembered for their overt rejection of traditional and oppressive Korean standards

[@nindylestari2648]

i come back to this MV after watching BTOB4U Show Your Love's MV. on that MV, Seo Eunkwang portraying same sex love, which reminded me of Wheein's Goodbye MV. BTOMOO really *be* that group that embrace all kinds of love. as a moomoo & melody, i totally stan the right groups.

[@leiy7952]

1am kst #1 Melon #1 Genie #1 Bugs #1 Soribada #1 Naver Congrats my baby, you literally soar 😭 Edit: if it wasn't to FLO, Wheein just had 13 realtime all kills. She got numerous #1 in MNET too sighs.

[@starrylunastro]

Tbh on Flo it still in the 30s range, but K-media already calling it all-kill that's all that matter anyway. So yeah, Wheein already achieved PAK hehe

[@hlianaslm7956]

What is pak?

[@최동일-n1c]

It refers to Perfect All Kill

[@SD-bw5gu]

Flo sucks

[@ei8ht158]

"Woahh, that's bomb yo! I'm like ㅜㅜ. Just like ㅜㅜ." Like, finally! She has gotten what she deserves (and more). I'm so happy for Wheein unnie! 💜

[@nuckesantiago]

The storyline is actually like this: The actress falls in love with her art teacher, but the teacher already had a boyfriend. that's not the actress' house, that's her teacher house. the broken-hearted actress throws away all of her art teacher's boyfriend's stuffs (toothbrush, clothes, etc). the dress she wears at the end of the MV is actually the art teacher's dress. So it's deeper than you guys thought. The song, the MV, everything, is just perfect.

[@Ortegay]

nuckelodeon thanks for the breakdown!

[@papelonagridulce19]

WHAT??? ---Me at the end of the video

[@kadita1931]

IS THIS THE LESBIAN CONTENT I ASK FOR

[@moomoomilu8428]

Thats actually kinda creepy

[@tanyavidushi1983]

Really...I thought it was something else

[@hajarweebu5595]

*from whatever it is, it's all the same love* -Wheein

[@amaris5141]

You know it’s a good song if you don’t understand the language but you understand the message

[@akudewi1]

Theres the sub in the cc btw

[@Xceleste_]

what ?

[@howsurdayytv5666]

u got me there ^_^ my friends dont understand how i like it Songs like this ..

[@lia4735]

*ONCE YOU WHEEIN, YOU CAN'T WHEEOUT*

[@mehh9364]

Armymoo?😁💜

[@IndayLabling]

Yeseu huhuhu

[@ilovehaseul5010]

BLIDZYMOO

[@twigtoyoulater]

This again i-

[@ilovehaseul5010]

@@twigtoyoulater how did I friggin

[@vanesa5395]

Imagine having the most gorgeous face AND the most gorgeous voice. Wheein can relate

[@thealola4464]

And most humble personality

[@vanesa5395]

@@thealola4464 Yes yes! ✊ Personality, looks and talent, Wheein's got it all!

[@ashhh0021]

Wheein's vocals gives goosebumps everytime. Her voice is just WOW

[@godlove81able]

JUNG WHEEIN THE MOST BEAUTIFUL WOMAN ON EARTH FIGHT ME

[@roheacapuyan8199]

THIS IS TRUE. IMMA FIGHT WITH YA.

[@milkyway7264]

Actually, the most beautiful HUMAN ON EARTH 😭😭

[@godlove81able]

@@milkyway7264 exactly

[@js103k]

Wheein’s voice is so expressive, you can feel the pain and the emotions through her voice. she’s so talented.

[@amazonz8590]

Lol I read expensive instead of expressive at first but I was still in agreement

[@CryKaze]

Of course Wheein’s voice is amazing but why isn’t anyone talking about the MV? That plot twist at the end got me twisted!!! 😱🔥

[@allaboutthatbi.5256]

Ofcourse dude it's included. It's just that people love Wheein that much but trust me, it's included.

[@allaboutthatbi.5256]

PS: I love every piece of this MV. Tons of love for them.

[@julietaarakelian2409]

Wheein's voice is that beautiful that is everyones MAIN focus. I didn't notice anything else before checking comments.

[@amazonz8590]

@@julietaarakelian2409 same

[@iwanttobeapillowsojeonginc8236]

I'm not a part of LGBT but i highly respect wheein for making a song like this💖 she's such a precious princess of mamamoo💖 we should protect her

[@you-ck5sp]

*listening to this made me realize that:* _wow, i really stan the right girl group :)_

[@leksudiib307]

So proud

[@shrutis]

Me too

[@ferrarolareine2166]

I was just thinking that!!! Out of all the groups out there, Mamamoo holds a special place in my heart. I’m so happy to be a part of this family. ❤️

[@wajihahadilah6966]

Me too❤️

[@exessen1684]

*CHART UPDATE:* (00:00 KST) #1 Bugs (=) #1 Genie (+1) #1 Soribada (+3) #1 Naver (NEW) #2 Melon (+2) #3 Mnet (+5) Congrats Wheein ❤️❤️❤️

[@tatyanaakoa]

Crying of happiness seriously I'm SO happy the song is doing so well, it totally deserves it😭😭😭😭😭👑💛

[@g.h3874]

I want a video of Wheein reacting to the charts like Hwasa did so cute ❤️❤️

[@fatimahabacan82]

Ok..kindly, Please tell us again the chart update after 10hrs or 24hrs...thanks

[@whiteradish2285]

whaaaaaaaa is this real? kyaaaaaaah omg. she deserves all of these huhu

[@Leondelachacara]

Wowwowo

[@renzdariusdeguzman_23]

Try to listen to it while your eyes are close, it's like you are entering the gates of heaven.

[@cupcakefanuzb5572]

If you do that you wont be able to see tge amazing mv

[@vivleggo309]

And miss the beautiful video? No way

[@renzdariusdeguzman_23]

Cupcake Fan UZB My point is, of course you will listen to this song to other music platforms like spotify or other related apps to stream because we moomoos or just Wheein fans in general will stream this song nonstop. Hahaha.

[@okami77full]

Its worst I'm crying a lot 😭❤💔

[@renzdariusdeguzman_23]

Pao MMM It will give you different emotions when your eyes are close. I mean I don’t understand Korean language that much, but basing on the way the song impacted or affected me, the song is very emotional and powerful.

[@hazelann3025]

im going thru the most hardest breakup ive ever experienced. thank you wheein for creating this masterpirce.

[@TQM]

The shaving kit makes you think that she's getting rid of her male ex's things after a break up. And at the end, it's revealed that her ex is actually the other woman, and she's getting rid of his (her ex's new boyfriend's) stuff because she hasn't accepted that they've broken up. Kids, don't break and enter into your ex's home no matter how much you miss them *Edit:* Sorry, i just realized that most peeps prob don't know what she's singing about to help with the context of the MV, so here's some rough translation of the lyrics: Things can be like this, I thought I tried to forget, all the things of the past I tried I tried to start over again, because I knew i can't be without you I really tried It wasn't easy to forget you Anyone else would have done as I did I'm not unscathed, but this is too much to bear The memories of fluttering feelings from our first encounter They're just like yesterday, so clear that they can't be erased The portrait of you in my mind now feels like a lie, and I can't trust it anymore Good bye "How can you do this" Just like your words fading into nothing It's all over I didn't say it lightly Anyone else would have done as I did I'm not unscathed, but this is too much to bear The memories of fluttering feelings from our first encounter They're just like yesterday, so clear that they can't be erased The portrait of you in my mind now feels like a lie, and i can't trust it anymore As if none of it was real, give me a chance to erase you , don't say anything Why was I so foolish To believe everything you said to me How can I forget it all The portrait of you in my mind now feels like a lie Our first encounter, our time together, our everything Good bye To us

[@Ytb_hovie]

I agree.

[@ynnaescano3077]

U ARE A LIFE SAVER

[@primolla4609]

Oh welll thank you That helped a lot! (I was going to search for the lyrics right now) And this remind me of that one time I had a romance with a girl for months and when the things got a little hard she said she was straigh and leave... tisc tisc Yep it sutes the lyrics

[@Hannah-rh7il]

Thank you so much for the lyrics!!

[@jiminsoofer9860]

Thank you for translating and i dont mean to be rude but i dont think the last word means "goodbye to us" correct me if Im wrong but i think it means "lets break up" its okay tho thank you for the translation it helps alot 😊💗💗💗 and im really sorry if i sound rude and im sorry if i was wrong 😊

[@dje8741]

THIS SONG NEED TO BBE A DRAMA OST. SERIOUSLY !!

[@moon9106]

RIZIOMIX ikr it feels like itp

[@b.s.3000]

Yesss this.

[@innerkpop4471]

Yep this should be an ost song

[@g.h3874]

Ost to my drama life

[@sendmemoneythanks]

Omg yes

[@Moon-iv1xy]

Imagine having her colab with Chen to make a break up song it'll be freaking legendary

[@AlexaAgrelo]

We need that

[@vivian32]

Omfg yes please

[@auliyaihza1999]

YES

[@gimenab.ruizdiaz2539]

I'm EXO-L and MooMoo... Oh, my god, yeeeess~

[@dinachen2561]

@@gimenab.ruizdiaz2539 same

[@dr2drm88]

2023 and her vocals still touch one's soul.

[@starluvr23]

Did I understand the language: no Did I get emotionally invested to the story and cried while a beautiful voice serenaded me: yes Stan Mamamoo ❤

[@CraigWinstanley1]

Vincent Van Gogh once said “Normality is a paved road: It’s comfortable to walk on, but no flowers ever grow on it”. Jung Wheein and Jung Key are superb artists. For example, the image at the conclusion of this video has an unexpected impact. Vincent Van Gogh would have loved this form of art.

[@disgurstingshat3580]

Seriously, I see you in every mamamoo comment section. You must be a huge fan of them.

[@filmsquirksbts1132]

👏🏽

[@freyabeauchamp2572]

Wow

[@CraigWinstanley1]

Candice Bilab - thanks for you comment. I follow a lot of music artists because i appreciate creative people and i love music. I think MAMAMOO are standout performers, both individually and collectively.

[@CraigWinstanley1]

domesa 89 - you are kind to say so.

[@nicamrb]

this made me go through a break up i never had

[@Gloriayana]

Well said 😂

[@emxprk]

Same haha

[@lindsey2542]

I listened to this song for the first time in a while just now and god the amount of nostalgia that rushed over me was indescribable. I have a really bad memory, so while I don't actually associate this song with any particular memories, but I guess being reminded of 3 years ago still has an impact on my mind. It gave me chills. This song was genuinely such a weird opening into my adult life and how I would wander around with my sexuality. I will NEVER forgive the world for how underrated this song is.

[@LilyJoeM]

first 4 mins and a half: ouch poor girl went through a breakup, now she feels alone in her own home and tries to move on but her ex's stuff is still there and it's really hard :( last minute: HOLD ON

[@madeofcastiron]

literally my reaction as well lmao i was like "aw poor heartbroken girl :(" and then i was like "w a i t :O"

[@playdead2309]

lmfao same gurl

[@cyanblue1132]

That twist though 😲😲😲

[@biabibo18]

i don't think i get exactly what happend, what twist you're taking about?

[@cyanblue1132]

The twist is when you thought she was moving on from the guy but in the end she is inlove with the girl.

[@Camiita]

Stan Mamamoo, Stan Art Stan Wheein, Stan Talent

[@colynb]

i just wanna hug wheein and tell her that i’m so happy and proud of her

[@wink.7040]

Wheein put a lot of effort into singing....she deserves praise for all her hard work.

[@rheashaneeisma4353]

Quarantine made me discover this song and now I'm addicted to it, as well as to Mamamoo. Y'all support Whee In's solo, stream Water Color and other songs from her Redd Album.

[@chinwanyenify]

Me too, MAMAMOO really is a treasure.

[@rheashaneeisma4353]

@@chinwanyenify queens indeed

[@exessen1684]

The actress just confirmed that the woman was in love with the other woman 🥰 (Most of us knew but some people are still trying to deny it)

[@ameliaaa9436]

Exessen yay!! what’s the name of the actress

[@exessen1684]

@@ameliaaa9436 Song Chaeyoon

[@erapadasas5804]

is that the reason why theres a makeup brush on 3:18 because as I believe everything she puts in there is from her ex's things?? come on

[@exessen1684]

@@erapadasas5804 ..That's literally a shaving brush?? Wtf are you even saying.

[@Aurileas]

does those actresses have instagram btw? _(found chaeyoon's instagram but what of the other girl?)_ also where is that confirmation? I want to see it myself :D

[@capeffejany2618]

Vocal ☑ Visual☑ MV ☑ Song☑ Lyrics☑ Moomoos should be proud of Wheein 😉

[@teesha978]

I wish I could understand the song though 😔😭😔

[@treebeexyz6839]

@@teesha978 there's captions at the bottom!

[@enzi022]

I can't believe Wheein did a lesbian conceptual MV, where the girl is in love with the art teacher. Wheein I love you.

[@laviender]

Yes 💕

[@jasmine6990]

Wait, is that the story?? Because I got really confused 😂

[@Kichusabri21]

I'm confused too 🤪 but i love it

[@jiaminleo]

Bursting_with_sooyoung the things she used were all the things that belonged to her ex-girlfriend. The lipstick, the perfume, the dress. And the picture at the last you could see there are 2 girls in it but one of them got painted over (because they are no longer a couple) 🤓

[@hysey_7518]

@@jiaminleo wait i thought it was the pic of teacher and her boyfriend Edit: here 1:10 x0.5 speed

[@gkt0086]

WheeIn, it still hurts no matter how many times I listen to this.

[@supportmamamoo5089]

Honestly, I get so angry that this doesn't have more views

[@angelinepunzalan2134]

Stream HIP by MAMAMOO Please The fact that this single topped every charts is enough for us because we know that every memberin the group is well respected in korea the views doesn’t determine her versatility as an artist herself.

[@charred6683]

Relax, if you knew about every single awesome songs/artists not getting views you would fall into a deep depression. Most music in the world is underappreciated.

[@RebecaC12]

This song achieved an allkill in Korea, views aren't always an indicative of success. Trust me when I say this was a success in Korea ✌🏻

[@cakesniffer3848]

IKR

[@sarah1377]

Charred that’s true but this song is different- she was even nominated as Artist of the Year (Gaon) and even made it to billboard being the sixth female solo K-pop star to bow on World Digital Song Sales (2019)

[@Chwoo-gr7lf]

Jung Key feat. Wheein= Anymore Wheein prod. Jung Key= 헤어지자 perfect collaboration♥

[@windflower5755]

Apparently, Wheein's Goodbye and K.Will's Please Don't have the same MV Director ❤️🧡💛💚💙💜 Edit: the actress in the MV confirmed that her character was in love with her art teacher and the art teacher is not the man 😏🌈 She also made a yt video explaining the storyline

[@Ace-bk7iu]

No wonder, both mv had crazy plot twist 😂

[@AnakRantau0311]

Stream Windflower and Stan Mamamoo no wonder I can feel it .. I thought of the plot twist

[@sarateez1117]

oh my ❤❤❤

[@vorpheuss]

fallen Angel , please explain the twist, I think I’m dumb 😂

[@Sunmi_is_art]

@@vorpheuss At the end of the MV for K. Will's Please Don't, the guy in the MV rips a wedding photo, tearing the girl out of it. The video up to this point is somewhat ambiguous about who he was upset over (2 of his friends were getting married). At the very end, he tosses aside the photo of the girl and places the guy next to himself, crying. In this video, it's a similar ending. You are lead to assume that the MV is about a guy, that's she's tossing the guy's things out. But then at the end you realize that she wasn't in her own home. She broke into the home of the couple who came in. The guy runs off camera and the MV ends with a focus on the woman. She walks up to the painting then picks up a photo of her with her boyfriend, and sees that he was painted over in the photo. I will give you that it's left open to interpretation, but for me the fact the video shares the same director as Please Don't, the fact that we see her dancing with a female mannequin, putting on the other's woman's lipstick, clothes, and perfume, and the fact that the MV ends with a focus on the woman's reaction rather than the man's tells me she was actually in love with the woman. If she were simply wishing to take the woman's place, it doesn't really make sense why she was throwing away the guy's things, and why she blocked him out of the photo instead of her.

[@daria8854]

The fact that Wheein is singing a girl's "story" is amaizing

[@ferrarolareine2166]

I was supposed to sleep (almost 4 am) since it’s my first day of classes in college HOWEVER, INTERNATIONAL MOOS EXISTS. WE SUPPORT MAMAMOO AND OUR BEAUTIFUL WHEEIN.

[@jucy588]

Meeee Im already late for college, and I'm here watching it

[@Ace-bk7iu]

I skipped college today😂

[@yulyulkminnienicha6843]

Go Wheein. . . . Neverlands here for our Queen kind Mamamoo . I REALLY LOVE YOUR VOICE baby Wheein

[@luciag.1301]

❤💜❤ love back from moomoos❤💜❤

[@TravisTheRed]

Thank you!

[@xscHui]

Love u all for helping us 💞💞💞

[@sitwithtimi]

love u and thanks

[@wheeinstar4387]

Thank you so much ❤❤❤

[@deebs923]

Mamamoo really unbothered, they r going to have comeback song through queendom, yet wheein can realease solo

[@chrismae4670]

Wheein iloveyou 😥

[@cristianacoppola5889]

0:01 : ok this song is a masterpiece. Wheein is THE vocalist.

[@SnowconeSungjin]

VOICE OF AN ANGEL OUR WHEEIN WERE SO PROUD OF YOU

[@graceababan]

D*mn, Junkey is savage, but Wheein is just belting them hight notes like it's nothing ~ my unbothered queen! Jungkey's IG post: "Whee In is very playful and has a personality that puts people to ease so even though this was only our second time working together, it felt comfortable like we've worked together more than ten times. I especially like how Whee In's high notes has a melting tone, but the original song was keyed lower when we first recorded. With hopes to make the sound more heartwrenching, I cautiously raised the key a bit to where most singers feel burdened. However, Whee In didn't even flinch and trusted me completely so I just said 'screw it' and raised the song three keys higher. I'm sorry... Anyway, although the overall stories are different, I'd like to think the titles and the emotional tension continues from 'Anymore' to 'Let's Break Up'. Whee In sang spectacularly and I would like to thank her for all her suffering as well as to all the others who have worked with us. I hope this is an album that many can enjoy listening to and relate. 🙏"

[@onionaseyooppar2377]

Whose junkey??? Sorry I randomly clicked on this video but I do not regret that!! Btw can you help me with her like stuff that I need to know??

[@whindy9331]

@@onionaseyooppar2377 jungkey is the producer of this song and the singer's name is wheein.

[@pepperyiyi]

SPRING DAY wheein is from the girl group MAMAMOO

[@latenightcashews]

"so i just said screw it" that's a big mood

[@graceababan]

@@onionaseyooppar2377 Junkey produced the song. I suggest you listen to the ANYMORE, another great song by this amazing tandem.

[@thedummyaccount]

I really love ballads and the fact that this was sung by Wheein makes it a hundred times better 🤍

[@pinkribbon1007]

i really like this song, its sad wheein is underrated as always

[@shafiqahmohd8351]

Among mamamoo members, yes she is underrated. But she received charts all kill for this song and is still charting in korean music charts and that shows how much k-nets appreciate her as a ballad artist.

[@pinkribbon1007]

shafiqah mohd thats honestly heartwarming to know she is appreciated 😊

[@tunna_]

@@shafiqahmohd8351 🥺🤧✊🏻✨

[@RebecaC12]

She's actually quite popular given that Wheein doesn't do many shows on her own. Many artists want to collab with her it is said, but she's got anxiety and is quite shy around people she doesn't know. It is amazing that this song did an all kill without any promotion on her part. So immagine how much more could achieve if she did promotions, but anything to keep Wheenie healthy and happy!

[@anj8241]

Shes not. Stop saying shes underrated, wheein might read this and feel bad

[@qwheein4125]

Jungkey: "How high can you hit the note?" Wheein: "Yes"

[@UniBEARse]

This is actually true 😂 if you look at the translation for Jungkey's post in IG, he said the original key was lower but challenge wheein to go higher and higher

[@madeofcastiron]

@@UniBEARse and it wasn't just "a bit" higher, he raised it 3 keys higher! wheein is amazing

[@amaracea]

Haha I think it was more like Jungkey: “How high can you hit the note?” Wheein: “Oh I’d rather it be a little lower if we could” Jungkey: “Several octaves higher, got it” Wheein: [nails it anyway] Everyone: [shocked Pikachu meme]

[@charred6683]

The smoky voice low notes hit me first. Then the high notes. Then I realized her range is out of this world. No wonder RBW said she's the backbone of Mamamoo.

[@UniBEARse]

@@amaracea He literally said "Screw It!" and made it higher HAHAHAHAH he seriously trusts Wheein's vocals so much

[@plm7470]

ㅠㅠㅠ 드디어ㅠㅠㅠ 너무 좋아서 손떨린다..ㅠㅠ 정휘인 사랑해ㅠㅠ 진짜 너무 이쁘고 노래 너무 좋고 분위기있고ㅠㅠㅠ 휘인이 휘인했다ㅠㅠ 평생 사랑하고 응원할게ㅠㅠ 목소리 너무좋아서 귀녹을거같아ㅠㅠㅠ

[@아그렇쿤]

학교에서 애들 목소리 듣고 들으니 비교가 안되네요ㅜㅜㅠㅠㅜ♡♡♡♡♡♡마마무 놓지않을게!!휜언니 퐛팅!!

[@blankjihyo565]

I love you, Jung Whee In!

[@ringadinga451]

*THANK YOU WHEEIN AND RBW FOR MAKING IT GAY, MY HEART IS FULL*

[@Hwasasthroneismyface]

It's a sad song but I'm smiling through the whole MV because of the angel's voice 😌👌😌👌😌👌

[@someoneonthissite5008]

Oh, it's you.

[@outokana2632]

@@someoneonthissite5008 that was literally my reaction

[@Hwasasthroneismyface]

@@someoneonthissite5008 Yes it's me

[@dprawr6169]

Just impressive voice 💕😢

[@vinci2617]

me too ;)

[@tiffanycheng8000]

Wheein has the sweetest voice in kpop gg

[@homesickalien6194]

TIFFANY CHENG omg yes finally someone said it! ❤️

[@francineangelirendontulabi3749]

Still watching it todayy and I just realize it's her birthday! HAPPY BIRTHDAY WHEEINNNN ILOVEYOUUU💗

[@fauziahusni9250]

I'm crying without knowing a word about this song, that's how powerful our jung wheein😭😭😭 love from Indonesia🇮🇩🇮🇩🇮🇩

[@cleaalvina8596]

we must unite and keep supporting her forever😭😭😭😭

[@gantengindonesia2448]

I feel u mbak 😅😅😂😂

[@BeautifoolStranger]

"If you like the group, you like the whole group instead of just one member". - Hwasa 👑💕 so pls moos support their solos too... ☺️👍🏻

[@itattooedbyulnameacrossmyh3178]

This is applied to Moonbyul.. I pity her.. Her Mv's Eclipse not much views and she's the only member not winning any music shows...please supports her just like the other members.. I just expressing my 1 cent thoughts.. Tq 👑🥂💕

[@hwasaismamamoosmaknae2400]

@@itattooedbyulnameacrossmyh3178 yea buy atleast her album is selling pretty well

[@yudeiz]

ItaTTooedBYULNameAcrossMYheart Moonbyul’s Eclipse has more views than Wheein’s Goodbye Mv though?.. But I do agree, she deserves an award at least- I love them all

[@yhvs]

It's not a group it's a family.

[@eggeshroom]

Wheein hasn't had a proper solo promotion yet, but if she did I suspect it wouldn't get the attention as hwasa's solos or Solar's. Moonbyul's solo albums have pretty great sales but it's been almost 10 months and we still can't get her solo mv to past 7M views.

[@chelmiumiu]

Holy shit the Queen of Ballad is coming back, leggo get your second win Baby

[@quynhanhnguyen5761]

Chelsea Susanto leggo??

[@s.biaaa30]

@@quynhanhnguyen5761 it's like saying "let's go"

[@quynhanhnguyen5761]

Okk im sorry i think it's was EXID fandom🙏🏻

[@rfreamon]

I've enjoyed this MV since it came out, great storyline, fantastic voice, and smooth composition. After 2 years, only now did I realize it is implied she jumped off the balcony at the end 😢. Am I the slowest one in the group?

[@louis7931]

Just a reminder that this song slayed the korean music charts without a single promotion. So stop saying that Wheein is underrated just because this mv has little views.

[@Bongi344]

👍

[@whiteradish2285]

Yeah she's not. She's actually popular in Korea. Her singing voice and the genres that she likes to do the most are the genres that most of Koreans like.

[@mangakuota122]

This song is for eargasm main purposes, that you will play over and over again on your streaming app, not for eyes only to gain views

[@sweetmimosamommysaranghae3163]

Didn't 'Anymore' get a win in a music show without any promotions too, like damn the power Wheein has

[@RebecaC12]

@@sweetmimosamommysaranghae3163 yes... Wheepup would be as popular as Hwasa, maybe even more, but her anxiety is too harsh on her to promote. Yet, I'm so so happy that's her voice gets her loads of recognition just the same. Her craft shines through, and in the end that's what matters! Waiting for her album this year.

[@이벽춘]

항상 응원해요 우리 휘인님!!! 마마무분들도 다 응원하고 사랑스럽고,,,!! 사랑하고 사랑했고 사랑할거고 푹 쉬고 오셨으면 좋겠어요 저를 포함한 무무분들은 기다릴수있어요!

[@keiteumanoban6778]

I hate it because the amount of views are not enough! she deserves moooore

[@shahadalhumaidan5666]

It’s ok so many international fans don’t like ballads unlike korean she swip the charts when this song released and get nominated in an award show.

[@catherinecorcoran1738]

When you write I hate first impression is that you hate the song. Always write a positive comment and then write a 'but'to explain your reason. Just a comment.

[@keiteumanoban6778]

@@catherinecorcoran1738 ya thanks, but I'm good. I think 400+ peeps understand what I meant and I'm fine with that. Thanks for the suggestion tho

[@cloudsofsunset7323]

you got me

[@mehranerostami7976]

Like Dreamcatcher The worls didn't based on fairness

[@NguyenNgocThuanAn]

Happy birthday to Wheein

[@dmdd4848]

I SWEAR WHEEIN GETS PRETTIER EVERYDAY 😭😭😭 OMG I MISS MAMAMOO 😭

[@junkileraldi4124]

Why is no one talking about the story line?!? Wheein really blessed us with a certified bop AND this beautiful MV ❤️❤️

[@제이-s4h]

I'm dead I will build my tombstone here (💀) LoveuWheeinIloveuasmuchasthe universe♡

[@katey4057]

this song hits hard when your really getting through the same thing. every single lines weighs so much. what a craft wheein.

[@imnotokay069]

Omg the girl was in love with THE OTHER GIRL WE STAN

[@moonlightmin5279]

Moomoos, pls stream MV to support her first solo album and wish to her health!!!

[@aykayjk]

Please censor 5tr3am because vl3ws might be freezed by yt

[@moonlightmin5279]

anhime why? Is it unlegal?

[@차야-v6y]

This is her second album

[@xyz7802]

@@moonlightmin5279 youtube's policy? to cut vㅣㅌw from fans 5trㅌa^^ing

[@Since1997___]

👏

[@SuperMovieXD]

After MAMA2019 I think RBW should give WheeIn a physical mini album like Solar's or a dance single (away from the ballads) like Hwasa's Twit, her popularity has grown since MAMA this year and I think it could be a good opportunity for her as a soloist🧡

[@snehachoudhury5721]

Ikr she got a Pak with this song (as far as I know)

[@SuperMovieXD]

@@snehachoudhury5721 yeah, I know it but that was a single album. I was thinking about something bigger like Solar's album

[@bluesky3974]

solar's album wasn't actually a mini album tho because all of the songs were not hers

[@Kitamurasama]

Definitely! I love Mamamoo but I yearn to see her fill the entire scenario with her voice and her presence, each Mamamoo member has a very distinct flavor and I want to taste more of Wheein as a soloist

[@MYcametopary]

yes please rbw

[@imamikhtaromaqsat5213]

still here, and still crying when listening this song🥲🥲

[@Bluebunny21]

The mv was very well thought out and the twist in the end was the perfect bow to tie everything together. Jungkey's composition is heart wrenching and magnificent as always. Wheein's delivery of the song was undeniably flawless and overflowing with emotions... I only have praises for this mv and this song. Kudos to all those who worked on and behind the scenes. Now, I'm off to watch it and cry all over again.

[@user-milktea31]

누구나 겪는 실연의 감정을 성별에 구애받지않고, 특별하게 꾸미지도 않고, 그저 있는 그대로 짝사랑의 아픔을 그려내는 덤덤한 이 노래부터 점차 우리모두의 편견을 깨주길 바랍니다. 사람이 사랑을 하고 아파하는 이 감정들을 본인과 다르다는 이유로 무시하지 맙시다 노래 잘 듣고 갑니다:)

[@안알랴줌-h1u]

말씀을 정말 이쁘게 하시네요

[@축멍이]

빨리 동성애 편견을 없어져야 할텐데 ㅎㅎ

[@hummhum]

근데 저지른 행동은 도를넘어서버려서 ..

[@최윤정-y5g]

@@축멍이 그러게요...

[@이현서-z8n]

@@김숙자-d9g4n 아마 뮤비속 여주가 남의집들어가서 망쳐놓은게 도를 넘었다고 하시는것 같아요

[@exessen1684]

*CHART UPDATE:* (07:00 KST) #1 Bugs (=) #1 Genie (=) #1 Soribada (=) #1 Naver (=) #1 Melon (+1) #1 Mnet (+1) Congrats to Wheein 😭 Following in her BFF of 11 years' footsteps ❤️❤️❤️

[@user-insight]

wait so where can I watch these wins?

[@wheeinqueen]

@@user-insight on twitter fam :)

[@thanhhoale1457]

@@user-insight ichart

[@calebberlin5330]

Exessen what did hwasa get?

[@calebberlin5330]

Exessen what did hwasa get for twit?

[@supernova527]

WHEE IS COMING OMG