[MV]JYJ IN HEAVEN

[@nguyenchau7895]

If you're still listening in 2024 you're a certified legend.

[@ms.febriant8667]

I'm here, and I still crying watching this MV 😭

[@eeescanyo]

intro still gives me the chills

[@moxy666]

or you need to move on to some decent music from this decade. sounds exactly like the last kpop song I heard. dire.

[@สราวุธชุมดาวงศ์]

ฟังอยู่ ทุกครั้ง ก็ ยังเพราะ คนับ

[@sasasape9046]

Im still listen this song

[@hanna_mellow5728]

I love how old generation MVs have their own storyline and thats what makes the song are more meaningful everytime we watch it :')

[@sabrinabeebc963]

hanna_ mellow YAS thank you!!

[@rezkyramadhani8053]

Your post was 1 month ago. We still hear this even in 2020 😅😆

[@CheikhaRania]

Agree

[@DJ-tx3ux]

Cry Cry, Lovey Lovey, Day By Day, Sexy Love and so on.

[@gummybaam]

I love it too.

[@연유-s8r]

이 노래도 잘 들었었는데 작사, 작곡 김재중이 한거....천재냐 진짜 인헤븐 라이브 또 보러 간다 라이브가 진심 ㄹㅈㄷ임

[@Possumpicnic]

Kim jaejoong's self-written and composed songs will always be the best and truest to the heart

[@heyyobangsat8695]

Song jihyo beauty and natural. No plastic surgery. She still beauty in 40 age

[@sochimawokocha2285]

Jihyo literally still looks the same now

[@hyunra9443]

@@sochimawokocha2285 true 😍😍

[@hamylevu2684]

You know the best part of old (and kind of underrated) Kpop masterpieces is that the comments are truly for people discussing the music, meaning, talent, story behind the song... not some shits like 'abcxyz views to go!' '#1 PAK abc chart congrats' 'let's keep streaming'

[@АнгелинаГаљевић]

True

[@kym5115]

Trueeee

[@aeria.gayonk]

trueeeeeeeeee 😥

[@eri6984]

Hà My Lê Vũ it wasn't underrated in that time with older kpop fans

[@YulianiSYuditri]

True... And I don't like that kind of comment...

[@tysedon]

Man, youtube suddenly recommends this mv to me again after so many years of not listening to this song. I remember replaying this mv a lot of times and just crying while watching it. I tried to put this into my favorite playlist just now and turns out I've already put it there in the past. This is one of my all-time favorite songs, I can't believe I almost forgot about it. Now, 11 years later, I still cried. Thanks, youtube algorithm for recommending this video again.

[@Teddy_001]

Тоже плачу , посмотрела в первый раз из-за того что увидела Джиё. Хотя и не понимаю слов кроме "люблю", клип заставил меня плакать ❤

[@hanaackerman2076]

😭😭😭😭😭

[@토깽-e2g]

2023년은 없을까 ,, ,,,, 진짜 송지효 개입쁘다.. 런닝맨에서 뮤비 주제로 얘기하는거 보고싶다,, 왕창 꾸미고 주인공으로 나와줫으면..

[@sarmengsokharydeth9665]

I miss the old kpop where you can enjoy everyone song, even though you not their fan .... No fan war !

[@Nisha-ns3pg]

Z6X so true

[@larapalma3744]

But they're fun!

[@nhunhunhu7722]

Nah, fan war has always been happening in KPOP. Don’t tell me you dont remember AFS or the biggest black ocean KPOP fans made to SNSD back then

[@xxqqzzaa]

actually, there always have been a fan war. what we have now is much less extreme than what it used to be.

[@superiorqueenempress2784]

There more fans war than before but war has always been part of the kpop world

[@cuddleweather]

The song is beautiful, the mv is beautiful, and so are Junsu and Jihyo. *Its even more beautiful because of the story behind the song* since Jaejoong wrote it for his friend who commited suicide :'(

[@norsyafiqah6248]

Sorry to ask but who is his friend?

[@mysteryelysian]

@@norsyafiqah6248 Park Young Ha

[@milla327]

Who is the actress?

[@euthemia]

The actress is Song Ji-hyo

[@vickyapsari]

PARK YONG HA😭😭😭

[@hyc1308]

I swear that Ji Hyo is the most beautiful and charming woman I’ve ever seen. I really hope that my future girlfriend can have such big and gentle EYES like her.

[@petanimuda8449]

xhhduxuxjdjehejdheodjejehwjeh ryžkdjsjse iejejsksksje hemdid yfdi * 8j *fjfj dkeejejduxhxjcifudufu uf uf ufuf f ujxjjfjdidj dudjff

[@multifandombish1855]

So u going to love someone by their eyes

[@YohanaChr]

2023 and I still listening this song... love it

[@user-do-0201]

와 간만에 듣는데 노래 여전히 좋다ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 5:01 여기 화음 예술임...

[@weiseblume]

I found JYJ thanks to Jihyo, and I'm so glad she helped me to find such wonderful artists.

[@Love4candies]

Welcome!

[@DokuraChannel]

Yeah, she's the girl of monday couple and Gary is an amazing guy too! lol

[@linhtran-mz9bi]

Miss mong

[@HELLOdavyXD]

Please watch DBSK back in the day when they were all five members 🙌🏽😢😭

[@AB-ni4no]

jihyo who? the girl from twice?

[@고마츠나나갤러리-k5l]

해외에 거주 중인 학생입니다. 이 노래를 듣고 바로 부모님께 전화드렸네요. 내 생활에 너무 치여서 나를 사랑해주는 사람들에게 혼자 신경 쓰지 못했다는 것, 그리고 작중 준수씨처럼 후회하는 모습을 보고나서, 뮤직비디오처럼 시간을 되돌릴 수 없다는 것을 깨닫고 바로 전화했습니다. 감사합니다. JYJ

[@ttocareeny]

진짜 흔하지만 흔하지 않았던 이때의 감성과 바로 과몰입이 가능케 했던 무드의 너무 좋은 노래들...죽을때까지 사랑해❤ 준수도 지효님도 지금도 이쁘고 잘생겼지만 완전 어리고 풋풋하다😊 (+노래 너무 좋아...내 스타일)

[@sweetheart9650]

I was young and in love with this song,,, i can't believe I'm 25 years now and it still hit the same,,,, 2023😢

[@Rita-zw7td]

Here I am 2020 , crying again while hearing this song , it can't be old at all . This song is just like a piece of paradise. Like I'm in heaven 😭💜💜 Love u JYJ Today, tomorrow , and every single day 💜💜

[@annyperez3141]

I'm crying too, I really miss them.

[@TheRYUMA7th]

Damn, song ji hyo is the most beautiful girl in korea... Who is with me?

[@estrellaella1323]

TheRYUMA7th yes

[@user-no4gc6rv8k]

Yes she is

[@AnimationAirlines]

song ji yo out

[@taetaetybts6734]

Me

[@beverleykorte7525]

😚😚😚😚😚😎

[@user-ce4or9yr2k]

송지효 미모 미쳤다... jyj 시절 노래들 정말 좋아했는데 추억돋네😂

[@smileofyerin]

2020 anyone?

[@leejia8934]

2020 and still have a goosebumps while hearing this

[@BibiOwned]

Yep. Still crying in same part of the song. xD

[@dinaraeva]

Me

[@tevaldiaryasetiawan8023]

@@leejia8934 indeed true. Feels goosebumps everytime hear this. One of songs that touched my life

[@ThePhantomXIA]

Meeeee

[@TheKayk15]

I listen to this lying down with my eyes close and I start to cry because this song really teaches you to appreciate the people in your live because they can be gone before you know

[@karollytamasela4807]

JYJ Catagory : Legendary Kpop Singers

[@mahirrahman1194]

Karolly Tamasela also TVXQ

[@olena.dymytrenko]

totally agree

[@Cathy-n8h]

이 뮤비 속의 준수가 너무 예뻐

[@alliehoffman-shaw4365]

This makes me think of Jonghyun. He's in heaven now, too. Jaejoong has lost 2 friends to depression now. I'm so sorry, babe. My heart goes out to you. #SHINee #JYJ

[@milla327]

Were jj and jjong friends? Apparently i missed their interactions?

[@chantalbellefeuille4310]

@@milla327 Jaejoong went to Jonghyun's funeral. There is a photo of him crying next to Changmin. Jaejoong actually got bashed for going since he is ex SM. It's really unfair. They should be able to mourn in peace for their colleague and friend and not be criticized for issues of the past.

[@milla327]

@@chantalbellefeuille4310 jj crying next to changmin? When did that happen? :o

[@chantalbellefeuille4310]

@@milla327 The first day of the memorial. The photo is on twitter. I just googled 'Jaejoong at Jonghyun's funeral' and the post came up.

[@chantalbellefeuille4310]

@@milla327 The photo shows of him more walking past Changmin but it's still next to him.

[@leng24468]

not kpop fan but love ji hyo after watching this mv, brain: ji hyo is so beautiful!ji hyo is so beautiful!ji hyo is so beautiful!ji hyo is so beautiful!ji hyo is so beautiful!

[@hyunra9443]

Me too 😍😍

[@짬짜면-z2m]

오랜만에 다시보는데 눈물난다... 연기 쩔고 김재중이 고 박용하님 추모하면서 지었다던데 진짜 슬프다...

[@marwabbt1699]

I can never forget this song and the clip The golden generation will understand me It is a song that will never be repeated😍 2023 and I still listen to it.. Ji Hyo She is truly a natural beauty This woman is an icon❤

[@sweetheart9650]

Me tooo,,, 😢

[@이레인-q8k]

준수 보다 여기까지 왔다 ,,,,, 그와중에 송지효 왜케 이뻐 ,,,,, 천사인가 ,,, 엔젤 ,,,,,? 🧚

[@유서녕-j3f]

일 년 끝자락에 또 들으러 왔다... 아는 만큼 들리는 것처럼 소중한 만큼 잊기 힘든 건가 너무 어렵다,,, 그 시간을 날린다는 게 제목만 봐도 가지 마 가지 마 거짓말 거짓말 다 들리고 울컥하는데 이걸 어떻게 안 듣고 버티는지 모르겠다,,, 어릴 때 어리게 좋아한 만큼 추억이 커서 너무 서럽다,,,

[@tarantallegra6002]

저도요.. 이네븐 앨범 발매되던 2011년 가을이 가끔씩 생각나네요. 내년이면 벌써 10년.. 진짜 믿기지가 않네요 홈페이지에 달모양 배너떠서 뮤비확인하고 했던때가 진짜 엊그제같은데.

[@rehnahai1]

this song is amazing..and it was written and composed by jaejoong...not everyone is capable of writing songs but jyj are true talents..i'm glad they left sm, now they can shine brighter...jaejoong fighting, jyj fighting

[@narunaru95]

Everyone can write a song so long they have something they want to express and an experience they can base it on. Don't get me wrong this song is wonderful.

[@rehnahai1]

narunaru95

[@rehnahai1]

narunaru95 yeah i know...but i still think that jyj's self composed songs are amazing, of course there are many other artists who are doing really well as well but jyj has more experience which they show in their songs and that's really wonderful

[@땡이-x4e]

와이거개오랜이네 이거예전에우연히봤는데 송지효너무심각하게예뻐서 넋놓고봤었는데..

[@KrystalMint]

The part of the music @ 1:12 reminds me of Bigbang's Haru Haru

[@CIXFARM]

I haven't listened to this song in years!!! And I'm happy because I'm listening to it again

[@excuseme1543]

SAME omggg

[@f.derzada5488]

Same

[@mediniamal47]

mee too

[@An1m3]

Same

[@Rita-zw7td]

This song is still killing me until today, it’s 2018 and I still feel the same feeling every time I hear it ...what an amazing magic inside it !!! thanks JYJ you always make me remember good memories whenever I listen to it ,,,we miss u guys :(

[@소영-r6w]

와 이거 진짜 오랜만에 듣는다..

[@badinvestor6442]

this song is so sad :,( i dont know if it is true or not i heard that jaejoong made this song for his friend who passed away he was abroad when his friend died since he didnt even get chance to say goodbye he made this song as a gift he didnt act in this mv because it breaks his heart to listen the song

[@badinvestor6442]

***** are you from norway? just wondering

[@shirleyc719]

True, jaejoong is the best friend you can be, is a great person, so give him lots of love

[@aninhaSOdemais]

ow god.. awesome!! Se isso for mesmo verdade, acho q jaejoong é o tipo de amigo para todos os momentos, é simplesmente incrivel! Um amigo para toda a vida :)

[@badinvestor6442]

Ane Caroline Belucci Augusto no lo se amigo me no habla espanol

[@aninhaSOdemais]

kkkkkk is portuguese ;) i'll try to translate to english.. I said : '' If is really true, i think jaejoong is a friend for all moments. He 's awesome!! He's a friend for all life :)

[@rocshelle17]

this is the best and saddest song I've heard... I cried...especially in the end 😢💖

[@glacecoco]

+레인캇세 I know what you feel giiirl

[@rocshelle17]

태성김 yes I had to quickly watch other jyj videos *sigh*

[@eileesmile2230]

I think so too and I also cried

[@914mongji]

SONG JI HYO!!!!!

[@linhtran-mz9bi]

Miss mong

[@MaiDKHOA-ly1tc]

I saw her tits

[@donnamunoz92]

We stannnn miss mong

[@Ran-c7d]

I just randomly remembered this song, good old times

[@candyliaban4233]

JYJ has so much love to give.They are very versatile, they perform beyond their comfort zone. That is why no matter how people ruin them. Still it is so ironic that they are still undefeatable. This music video is a proof that they are incredibly genius.

[@HannahNguyen1995]

Ah, so glad they casted Ji Hyo for this MV. Love her on running man.

[@f.runningman1658]

this is actually a drama ;) But i'm actually very glad as well

[@LaLa-iz6gu]

+Tess Tran Me too, she is so cute. If Kwang Soo's in it, so glad more, LOL =))))))))))

[@lyorin9845]

This girl is the definition of perfect....

[@taylor6101ful]

Lyo Rin agree!

[@hyunra9443]

True and agree with you, she is really beautiful and perfect ❤️😍

[@앨리스-z1v]

참 좋았었는데.....명곡이다 언제 들어도

[@worshipthecomedygodseoeunk4010]

ive never heard a ballad that's this intense and emotional than this song....and that's just purely impressive. you don't get kpop like this anymore

[@sewoonsmom6959]

If I know correctly, jyj helped composed this song and it's dedicated to Jaejoong's friend who committed suicide last 2010 RIP

[@vlaverra]

+Angel Mae To be exact jaejoong written and compose this song for his close friend :(

[@glacecoco]

+vlaverra omg what happened to his friend? :o I didn't know this

[@glacecoco]

Angel Mae I feel so sad for Jaejoong...

[@am.hegazy7273]

Last 2010 ? How many 2010 have you witnessed

[@cieleastwood7021]

And you have jonghyun picture in your profileee💔

[@DancingMomochine]

I agree with Sugar Kitt that some people might not necessarily be paying attention when driving. Before you call the drama/MV silly, get your facts right. Plus, it's just for an MV obviously it's fake but of course they would try to make it look as real as possible. And the reason why accidents occur is cause the driver is either drunk or not paying attention when driving.

[@lilochristina]

I read Jaejoong interview today and this MV popped up on my feed. Its been so long since I last watched it. So proud of his success.

[@imelamel825]

Indonesia mana suaranyaa...masihh gak bisa move on dr k pop jaman dulu 🌹🌹🌹 song ji hyo so beautifull 😍😍

[@ajiwijaya811]

Cantik cantik cantik

[@hyunra9443]

Cantik banget jihyo 😍😍

[@desasumbersari814]

Yuhuuuuu

[@nyainurjanah]

Hadir nonton MV ini berada nonton short movie salam dari kpoper zaman baheula

[@aprylledawndangkiw1429]

The first time I saw this a short version of this clip, I thought it was a movie. I kept searching for it, even stalked all movies of Song Ji Hyo just to know which movie this was. Now it took me three or maybe four years to realize its just an MV of a song. And now that I know, it just made me sad as I've been hoping it was a movie. Sigh

[@shayry5724]

Aprylle Dawn Dangkiw there is a longer version of this MV😂😂

[@aprylledawndangkiw1429]

Really? I immediately tried searching for every video of the song and the mv but it seemed like this was the only version. Would love to watch the longer version if there is tho. Thanks. ^_^ Can't get over this song and the story for the last couple of days after I heard this. Lagi ako na LSS. :-D

[@dieinonesecond]

Yeah, I watched a 10 min version before, but not on KZbin.

[@aprylledawndangkiw1429]

Ah. Must by why. Its a shame. But I think I'll try searching for the longer version. Thanks for the info

[@relinablacsmith4427]

Here's the longer version tune.pk/video/4358503/jyj-in-heaven-mv-full-version-english-subs-romanization-hangul

[@sandylin8972]

love Ji-Hyo...I came here because of her..didn't know much about JYJ and K-pop before. This song is awesome! I didn't know there's a profound story behind it..

[@dr.maryamabid9371]

They and SUJU brought me to KPOP in 2010! What amazing singers they are DBSK and JYP will be iconic forever! Love Xia's voice the mist although sometimes i canr decide whom to choose! All of them have beautifuk voices!

[@CRZYCoOLkaOS]

I just went to JYJ - The Return of the King concert and damnnnn, their live singing is amazing! I always knew that JYJ were extremely good at live singing, but they were even better than I thought! Sooo amazed, especially Junsu

[@tienlee9115]

I think one of the reasons why the old Kpop is better is bc it was more mature. Nowadays it seems like the groups debuting are becoming more childish.

[@franzenjanehermano4456]

Yes. Just to go with the trend.

[@Sadik-568]

What's the title of this drama?

[@hana1monme768]

@@Sadik-568 its not from drama or movie its pure made for this music video, if you want to watch the complete story try search JYJ in heaven drama ver.

[@fkfkfkfh]

True

[@valleycho8484]

Omg, I'm ur teammate

[@andythio7435]

this song never be promoted before, just because SM power,but this song still my favorite song even until now...

[@gizemmm861]

It just shows that Kpop Industry is two-faced. At first they were supporting jyj, because of SM JYJ was blamed. I always support them, but it is npt enough. Power is everything. And l'm sure that they want to be appreciated. Everyone wants. We can't show them our love. They can't find a fu*king concert area. The world is unfair really.

[@maluquiroz3544]

I loved this song. Now, I love it more. JaeJoon is amazing for writing this incredible song for his friend.

[@alex40061]

Tienes razon Malu, pero hasta ahora no se si la canta Jaejoon o Xiao :v.

[@ongnhan5740]

Put your hand up if you are watching this video in 2019

[@tuanha2589]

Trần Huy chào bạn

[@vuha4992]

Oh việt nam cass

[@TLSuperify]

dumbass its comment section aint nobody going to put their hands up here.

[@kusanagisensei5987]

RAWAN ALMADI 👻🙌🤷‍♂️🕺

[@vietlainhat7052]

hello cass :))))

[@jeonjungshookt3857]

AFTER 4 FREAKIN YEARS!!!!!!! I FOUND THIS SONG WITHOUT EVEN LOOKING FOR IT!!!!!!

[@sethkang4410]

+hun han yuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuup

[@보니-r5v]

damn :"D Atleast now the torture is over :P

[@hasutaehyung9941]

ARE U ALSO TRAPPED IN HUNHAN SHIT!

[@이수민-z2g]

Same xD

[@yoonmintrash4276]

I just searched up "heaven kpop" like 2 years ago and it was like the 2nd result 😂😂

[@phuongle9816]

Their voices are heavenly, such a perfect harmonizing. Ji Hyo is so beautiful in this MV :D

[@Quyennie9x]

This song is still one of the most beautiful Kpop songs to ever exist ❤

[@jinidasun2468]

Why is youtube suddenly recommending this? After so many yearssss

[@danakhleif4030]

Ikr

[@thaotrangtangthi4076]

You're not alone 😂

[@euhannbercasio8572]

It is to show the REAL KPOP. Not the kpop influenced by Western.

[@Baekku_]

@@euhannbercasio8572 as how i see kpop always was influenced by Western, remember 1st n 2nd gen performance most was like bsb, nsync, old West artists etc, inspired by them? and added lil korean music soul that became kpop... But most of jyj n kim jaejoong songs seem more different than kpop, pop etc mb that's why

[@nowlomme]

Same

[@Joyful_Irina]

Man, everytime I get to listen to this song...my heart breaks into small pieces at the last scene of the Music Video... Sometimes we don't appreciate the other people's love as we should do.. this..is a lesson only life can teach you. Good job JYJ for remembering this important aspect of life everytime we listen to this song. I'm missing JYJ times..

[@dainanoaira4105]

vlog

[@LâmThanhHải-v5q]

2024 anyone?

[@peeice7778]

Me😊

[@inggridachsan314]

Here

[@valenlove1881]

Present 🥹

[@xeniahiu6832]

Meeè

[@diroiseden7890]

Me🤩

[@ippeunni]

coming back to this song after a couple of years makes me feel so nostalgic. also for those who don't know jaejoong wrote this song for a friend who passed away.

[@hyunra9443]

OMG deserves every time I hear this song ... It feels really sad and I sometimes cry when I see the lyrics ... It seems that the feelings of Jae Joong must have been very hurt at that time, he spilled all his feelings here, very sad and sorry heart that 😣

[@AfiiixD]

i always get the chill when jihyo cry. such good acting I must say

[@Gamerspot0]

Legend has it that that butt saved them both

[@rrrowxyz]

+Gamerspot0 this comment made my day. hahaha.

[@rynlexa226]

That butt is the legend itself xD

[@lemonan5244]

Totally agree that duck butt is magical

[@neogotmyback5506]

+lemonan hahahahaha deer Lord reminds Me of some one now! ....Jiiiimmm...I won't say it cause I'll be respectful to our jyj

[@aletheajacobs3600]

JaeJoong lovely hehehe thats what I was thinking

[@johnslade9751]

Every time I hear this song something gets in my eyes. they start watering up for some reason.

[@lianchoi_02]

김재중 ver 도 보고싶어 뮤비 개아련하게 만들어줬으면 좋았을거야...

[@real_zero3377]

진짜 이건 들으면 들을수록 명곡이다ㅠㅜㅠ

[@vietky645]

Song Ji Hyo so beautiful

[@gruvelynchy]

this song got a sad meaning and you can feel so much pain but i truly love this song and its 2015 still i am listening and watching this

[@dvonk46]

이건 노래도 좋지만 뮤비가 너무 감동임 ㅠㅠ

[@chrysanthemum5741]

I feel like crying today. So I came here. Everything that has beginning has to end.

[@snowaurora]

Ji Hyo + JYJ = unstoppable

[@mahadiamond9403]

watching In Heaven in 2019? Me: Always ❤️

[@sabihaathimni4421]

Watching in heaven in 03/06/2020

[@오오인곤-j6q]

군대에 있을 때는 지효 누나 진짜 예쁘다 밖에 눈에 안 들어왔는데, 이제 보니까 사랑의 끝이 슬프지만 아름답게 끝난 것 같은 기분이 드네요....

[@ウルクちゃん]

JYJ三人揃うとカッコいい🎵

[@berryareum3289]

#JYJ #INHEAVEN 열심히 활동하는 모습 보여줘서 고맙고 요번에 #BACKSEAT 1위 못하게 해줘서 미안해요 사랑합니다 JYJ JYJ FOREVER~

[@jenniferyamamoto6226]

I AM a fan of JYJ. They were my first kpop concert. I am hoping that we all remember these artists are humans. We all make decisions good or bad. I wish the best for Yoochun, Jaejoong and Xia.

[@jade_hannah]

이 팀 팬은 아니지만 이 노래는 꾸준히 듣게 되는듯…

[@tsubasangel]

Yoochuns manager from 2009-2012 has just passed away due to suicide and so i come back to this song since it was written for Jaejoongs friend who also committed suicide. it is so sad and so scary, the death of loved ones who feels so trapped they feel that they need to end their lives. he was a man that stood by Yoochun during hard years and that makes him a good man in my eyes. RIP.

[@CindyLee-g2f]

2019?

[@hoangha625]

yasss

[@sj3354]

Are you Korean?

[@ChiNguyen-fk8ff]

@@sj3354 Vietnamese

[@syrfhnaa]

Old good time💙 Jae's voice at beginning tho 💗

[@sj3354]

한국분?

[@prettylhen07]

when i feel really sad, i just have a listen to JYJ, TVXQ, and DBSK album marathon for hours and somehow, slowly my mood lifts up. P.S. my fave part of this song is from 5:00 - 5:30 . Gosh the harmonies! so hearteyes.

[@monishkasingh3145]

Crazy_Aziuian17 that part gives me chillzz

[@jyotisharma7702]

same, I get goosebumps everytime..

[@ImANightCreature]

I feel like we're opposites haha, whenever I listen to TVXQ and JYJ and DBSK I get more and more solemn due to the weight of their music I feel (or maybe because of the selection of songs I listen to lol all their ballads), and yesss same fav part! All the falsetto and harmony, so beautiful especially when coupled with the MV scene.

[@mohamadhidayat645]

TVXQ and DBSK is the same group right?

[@ALMyoutube]

2nd gen MVs will always be my favs 💖 The quality, the stories, the acting, the standard was really high back then

[@flyingfrisb1858]

Xiah is the reason why I'm involved in kpop wave since 2008. He is my first bias and after Baekhyun his voice is the best in the world for me.. Looking back at this got me so emotional. He is just so, perfect..

[@isabelindiracornejo]

This is the saddest most beautiful well-done Kpop MV ever. (no need for a contest)

[@dofnsidnf]

지금 들어도 너무 좋네ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ

[@SH-eh5co]

이 노래 처음 나왔을때 뮤비가 너무 슬퍼서 오열했었죠ㅠㅠ

[@alessandrea1755]

Beautiful lyrics+perfect harmony=masterpiece JYJ please comeback in 2019. We badly want to here your 3 voices together. 😢💕

[@Fido9Sung]

watching this in 2019 make me feel sad more than before 💔💔💔💔

[@tiandrawibisisti1662]

JYJ without Y (Yoochun) is just JJ :') Miss 'em so bad!

[@kttanna]

So sad :'( T_T

[@TomboCreations]

JYJ really is "JYJ IN HEAVEN" TAT

[@gabiburner]

it's hard to imagine it :-(

[@zerefuuutv]

-WHY WHERE IS YOOCHUN?

[@tiandrawibisisti1662]

@@zerefuuutv he's out from Jyj.

[@taku.174]

三人のライブ…………JYJの曲……生で聞きたいよ😢

[@soojikim18]

Still not over the emotions this gave me years ago.

[@unhasnguyen412]

Came here to listen again, because of recent Jonghyun's death. I remember Jaejoong wrote this for his friend that also committed suicide. Recent news that Jaejoong attended Jonghyun's funeral. ): I hope they both rested up in heaven. rest in paradise

[@vickyapsari]

Park Yong Ha😭😭😭

[@김수정-r3n5h]

내 마음을 울린 노래...진짜 너무 좋아유.. 겨울에 들으면 더 좋은듯..

[@TV-tq6km]

今も聞いている方いますか？🥺 JYJ復活してほしいよ、、、 ジェジュンだけでもjyjの曲ライブで歌ってほしい

[@LeeGoonkim9897]

JYJ please make a COMEBACK ALBUM !!!!!!!

[@quazia.raidah404]

JJ of JYJ Just wait 2more years then junsu will be back 💖

[@LeeGoonkim9897]

I actually made this comment few months before Just US album came out xD Guess I should this comment again

[@zurahjoe]

this is why i appreciate old kpop songs, but this song is just too beautiful, lyrically beautiful, visually beautiful, the story-line is also beautiful not to mention jihyo look so beautiful in here. ive watched it once and i cried because of the supposed story-line where both of them finally in heaven but after someone mention the song was made by jaejoong to one of his friends who committed suicide, thats when the waterfall works omg tears streak nonstop, listening to the voice like they were in pain while reading the lyric at the same time it is very emotional i kept on crying like how couldnt you?

[@rmftpek001]

2024년 청룡의 해에도 in heaven은 계속된다

[@laluna2264]

Watching Winter Sonata with Park Yong-ha. Had listen to the song dedicated to him. It's so sad how many beautiful souls the Korean industry has crushed/taken. May his soul be truly Happy❤