[MV] NU'EST(뉴이스트) _ Good Bye Bye(굿 바이 바이)

[@Pamview]

Idk where the original comment went but there’s a deep theory and story behind this MV: Ren throws up a flower and shows his abs because he’s tired of people calling him a flower or pretty boy. He wants to show that he can be manly and sexy too. Also symbolism of hanahaki disease, the feeling of a one-sided love throwing up flowers. Because no matter how much they love their fans and work hard, they’re not getting it back. JR chases after the fish representing how they’re been so close to chasing fame but never get it. He then eats it to represent a rebirth (their album title) Baekho rips the old boring wallpaper to reveal a prettier more interesting one to represent how in the past he’s never been considered one of the handsomest in Nu’est and wants to show that behind his looks, on the inside he is beautiful (don’t worry baby you’re gorgeous) Aron is seen looking out a closed window representing his longing for America or how much he misses his family and life over in the states. Minhyun is supposed to represent the sacrifices and hardships of Nu’est. Suicide with the bathtub for how much they’ve wanted to give up. And tattooing his own arm to show that no matter what Nu’est is forever. At the end they’re all seen happy jumping with fireworks to represent how they’ve achieved the image they’ve wanted to portray. Goodbye bye is also kind of saying bye to their old selves in the comeback. When I found this out I cried. Hope y’all enjoy and give them lots of love!!!! They deserve it. Nu’est fighting ❤️

[@spandanthapamagar1176]

Pamela Vu ikr 💚💚💚💚 they actually said bye to their old selves and made a comeback with a new concept 💜

[@handdii]

AND THE FACT THAT NOW THEY REALLY MADE IT IS SOOOOOOO RELIEVING!! :):)

[@catalinapop3087]

Pamela Vu Thank you for sharing this! It is definitely very touching. I did not expect this, but they got under my skin pretty fast. I am an ARMY, so I appreciate the hidden messages and symbols. I think this is my favorite Nu’est song so far but I haven’t listened to all of them. I’ll order their last album today. They’re really good and should get more recognition.

[@scarlet-4]

I love them, they are amazing, they deserve more.

[@nekograce7914]

Pamela Vu for real? Baeko is hot!!! Ppl be crazy. And I thought the flower was a Hanaki’s disease thing...wasn’t making sense. Lol. Thanks for the sum up

[@K-Ville]

One of the most underrated songs of 2014.

[@ciel983]

One of the Most underrated groups *

[@spongebobdaddy9100]

Nu'est would have gotten way more attention if there weren't so many comebacks & debuts this year. 2014 has been a really busy year, hopefully Pledis will choose a better comeback date in the future :P

[@ciel983]

Lee Taemin I wanna give Pledis an award for choosing the best times for Nuest Comebacks xD ! * F(x) comeback & henry & g.o.d * they really chose the best time

[@soniayung8624]

Honest coming from a GOT7 EXO and VIxx fan, this is a rly good song it should have been a lot bigger :/

[@kyuhera]

One of the most underrated songs of 2017

[@ddmarti6019]

Nuest was the first group that got me into Kpop. I remember my friend showing me their debut, and I thought they were going to be huge. Sad to see talent go unrecognized.

[@streetnecco1797]

They were my first too ;( .... I dont understand why theyre underrated ;(

[@wgraceb]

nuest was my third kpop group tbh but it saddens me to see them go unrecognized. they deserve recognition because their songs are amazing and they work so hard for comebacks. when they do have comebacks I'm never disappointed they're all amazing. the members also deserve to be praised for everything they do. pledis sadly doesn't promote their comebacks like they should and don't pay nuest much attention anymore because of seventeen. don't get me wrong I love nuest and seventeen but since seventeen debuted, pledis doesn't pay attention to nuest much anymore. I really hope they have a comeback soon, and us nuest fans can only hope pledis will promote it correctly and actually pay attention to them!!

[@ddmarti6019]

I MISS AFTER SCHOOL SO FUCKING MUCH THEY WERE SO BIG WTF HAPPENED

[@mvc1412]

Dianna Martinez Update: After School might be disbanded.

[@wgraceb]

i totally agree with you!! do you have instagram???

[@nami-co2534]

2024年も聴く！カムバックして！！！

[@NotFound12789]

Hanahaki disease (하나하키병 in korean) is a fictional disease where the victim coughs up flower petals when they suffer from one-sided love. I love the story behind this fictional disease

[@Souzana1998]

The song is so underrated .. Sold so little , no wins , little views. Yet their best track for me . Freaking underrated like Nuest...

[@sherylturk]

I'm just glad they are no longer underrated. The views I wouldn't completely worry about and now they are selling albums and getting triple crowns for being number 1 on the charts. Sometimes you have to go through a difficult time to come out on top and right now they are getting more popular by the day. Since June 25th they added more than 100,000 new fans so I know they are happy. Hopefully you look at their videos on Vlive as well.

[@Souzana1998]

sherylturk of course I keep up with nuest and waiting for the ot5 comeback as well .. They have gotten so much more popular but I do believe we can make it higher !

[@Smiuley]

I really love the melody and the verses, but I just don't the chorus :D it's so often like that for Nu'est songs

[@aimpostera8759]

@@Smiuley the chorus sounds quite generic except that last part minhyun sang. That part haunted for quite some time in the past.

[@bigbangpavedtheway9271]

:3

[@kleopatramavrokefalou7308]

it looks like I am the only one that prefers Ren with short hair. He looks so beautiful in this MV😍😍

[@walnutsss]

yep 😍😍😍

[@kdj5711]

yep ren with short hair is so damn hot

[@papayar6863]

Κλεοπάτρα Μαυροκεφάλου i like him either ways

[@lettingthepeoplesmileismyw3398]

Me toooooo

[@nazirulbasirah8948]

Κλεοπάτρα Μαυροκεφάλου me tooooooo

[@rainbow-yk8hq]

Such a good song by Nu'est. They leave good music and disband in good way. No scandal and no bad thing happen in this 10 years. May they success in life and career.

[@rainbow-yk8hq]

Stan since hello era, all I can say I'm proud to be L.O./\.E

[@mununglahadi444]

👨‍👩‍👦👋👋👋👋👋👋😀😁😁😁😃😄😄😄😄😅😅😆😆😅😅😅😄

[@JayLovex]

I mean, Aron was a bit problematic a couple times, let’s be honest, but it could have been worse.

[@TeenageFangirlDiaries]

​@@JayLovexwhat did aron do????

[@eunhasupremacy]

@@TeenageFangirlDiaries "Young Aron expressed his opinion of women on Music Access Radio Show saying that they were too gossipy to be friends with, and, I quote, “that’s why guys are, like, superior.” He went on to justify the comment by saying that he wasn’t trying to be offensive, but that women are better to look at than to be friends with. Oh, the fool-hardy ignorance of youth."

[@annyten]

*AFTER YEARS, I JUST REALIZED REN HAVE HANAHAKI DISEASE HERE*

[@wanfication479]

SAME!!

[@jadet9640]

What is that disease ?

[@Umusual]

@@jadet9640 its not a real disease, but it's from a (I think japenese) myth that if you fall in love, you'll throw up flowers until the love is fulfilled.

[@adiela_9778]

@@jadet9640 Hanahaki Disease (花吐き病 (Japanese); 하나하키병 (Korean); 花吐病 (Chinese)) is a fictional disease where the victim of unrequited or one-sided love begins to vomit or cough up the petals and flowers of a flowering plant growing in their lungs, which will eventually grow large enough to render breathing impossible if left untreated. There is no set time for how long this disease lasts but it may last from 2 weeks to 3 months until the victim dies unless the feelings are returned or the plants are surgically removed. There is also no set flower that blossoms in the lungs but it may be the enamoured’s favourite flower or favourite colour.Hanahaki can be cured through surgical removal of the plants' roots, but this excision also has the effect of removing the patient's capacity for romantic love. It may also erase the patient’s feelings for and memories of the enamoured. It can also be cured by the reciprocation of the victim's feelings. These feelings cannot be feelings of friendship but must be feelings of genuine love. The victim may also develop Hanahaki Disease if they believe the love to be one-sided but once the enamoured returns the feelings, they will be cured.

[@baekhonews411]

@@adiela_9778 is the a comic or manga based on this?

[@레몬마요]

죽 들어보고 있는데 이그룹 노래들이 자극적이기보다 이야기성이 있고, 그 정서가 담백하고 부드러운 느낌이에요. 그 점이 좋게 느껴지네요:)!

[@InspiritDiamondLife]

Luhan and Sehun are Ren's parents. Ren is JeongHan's mom. No wonder Jeonghan is beautiful. It runs in the family.

[@melyssa5]

Such a beautiful and talented family

[@patatanigibi]

+Inspirt_DiamondLife페트린 Very well said. Such great genes.

[@cai0409]

+Inspirt_DiamondLife페트린 Except Jeonghan is older than Ren

[@Hw5f]

+Inspirt_DiamondLife페트린 that bootyful family tho

[@InspiritDiamondLife]

Caitlin Manning omg haha I just realised that! I assumed Ren is older cause Nu'est debuted earlier than 17.. 😅

[@bianca3441]

my online best friend sent me this song before he commited suicide. he is half korean so whenever hes sad, he can only express himself in korean. im now staring blankly at the screen and crying while this song is playing. i love you kyong, thank you for everything.

[@MINARIch39]

i am sorry, i am new with nu'est...who d*ed?

[@bianca3441]

@@MINARIch39 i was talking about my best friend, not nu'est

[@missingyu7825]

I'm so sorry for your lost :'( stay strong!!

[@썬써니-y4l]

댓글수 5천에 놀라고 댓글 전부 영어 해외팬인거에 또 놀라고 얼마나 해외로 돌렸으면 ㅜ이제 한국에서 빛좀 보자 뉴이스트 홧팅!

[@akdlg9sjjslk8]

Ren's too handsome in this ;-;

[@janechaisson2186]

Isn't he always beautiful ? To me he is:)

[@aleskandra_]

+Lessa Robinson now he looks better ;)

[@yoursonlychanyeol2760]

omg I thought I'm the only one who noticed

[@pgtprogamertr4508]

*#RGpesetmez*

[@crystaleangel5736]

ikr!

[@mbr936]

Ren in this video has otherworldly beauty, he seems ethereal, unreal

[@andersongillette1886]

This is the theory of this MV: Ren throws up a flower and shows his abs because he’s tired of people calling him a flower or pretty boy. He wants to show that he can be manly and sexy too. JR chases after the fish representing how they’re been so close to chasing fame but never get it. He then eats it to represent a rebirth (their album title) Baekho rips the old boring wallpaper to reveal a prettier more interesting one to represent how in the past he’s never been considered one of the handsomest in Nu’est and wants to show that behind his looks, on the inside he is beautiful (don’t worry baby you’re gorgeous) Aron is seen looking out a closed window representing his longing for America or how much he misses his family and life over in the states. Minhyun is supposed to represent the sacrifices and hardships of Nu’est. Suicide with the bathtub for how much they’ve wanted to give up. And tattooing his own arm to show that no matter what Nu’est is forever. At the end they’re all seen happy jumping with fireworks to represent how they’ve achieved the image they’ve wanted to portray. Goodbye bye is also kind of saying bye to their old selves in the comeback. I have copied this from another person here in the comment section. I just want to preserve this theory here so that anyone coming late can see it. I love you NU'EST.

[@aimpostera8759]

It’s from the user called P V or Pamela Vu when first commented.

[@sleepyhollow.]

actually, Minki throwing up flowers could be a reffrence to the mithological disease _Hanahaki Disease_ , where flowers start growing from one's throat when having one-sided love. the lyrics relate a lot too, so I'm pretty sure it's that

[@yeochiuwu_5985]

But baekho is my bias tho👁👄👁

[@SuperUltraGamer123]

Crazy... Baekho weas always the hottest guy in NUEST and now he's thriving

[@maritf5128]

2:50 The wall felt Minhyun's high note coming, so it cracked in advance.

[@Jシェシルオ]

Yup!

[@angelica4729]

+Marit F Tru

[@slow-diary]

차가워진 눈물과 표정 난 너에게서 왜 헤매는지 알지 못했어 풀리지도 않을 맘에 상처만 남기고 그럴 때면 내게 말해 ‘이 추억만은 남겨줘’ 사라진 Innocence 나만을 밝혀 주던 빛은 너인데 시간의 덫에 또 속아 머물 순 없어 * Good bye baby Good bye baby 너 없이 매일 눈감아도 이젠 그만 Good bye baby Good bye baby 니 손 다신 못 잡는대도 ** 끝없는 터널 속을 거닌대도 이겨낼 수 있어 And let me say Good bye baby Good bye baby 난 너 없이도 살 수 있어 죽지 못해 산다는 게 내일에 내 모습일까 봐 걱정이 돼 기나긴 삶의 하루 중간 어디쯤에는 널 잊을 곳은 있을거야 확신해 늘 아주 가끔은 우릴 돌아봐 노력은 생각보다 내게 솔직하니까 어제는 잊고 또 일어서면 돼 풀린 신발끈 다시 묶고 뛰면 돼 낡은 일기장에 적힌 우리처럼 길을 잃고서 더 이상 살 수 없어 남겨진 Innocence * Repeat ** Repeat 내 눈물이 땅에 닿는 모습 보일 수 없어 난 계속 Tic Tic Tac 나의 두 눈이 너의 입술이 다시 만날 땐 우린 빛이 날 거야 * Repeat 끝없는 터널 속을 거닌대도 이겨낼 수 있어 And let me say Good bye baby Good bye baby 이젠 괜찮아 without you

[@thanhhien6537]

NU'EST 2019 comeback

[@SugarBabyJKP]

2024❤ it’s been 13 years with them singing in my ear.

[@robertrodrik]

X2

[@Kngly1]

Okay I will explain this Mv for those who cant(from my Pov) Its a break up song, and its a very artlike music video * when Jr ate the fish: He wanted to die but intead of pills, theres a fish * So later Ren its on the toilet(All members are like one person) and instead of vomit it was flowers * A rose was burning...its meaning is love coming to and end pretty fast * Members were falling...its meaning is he trusted his way even when he didnt know what the results would be * Members are angry...mostly because of frustation of cant forget about her * Then they realize they can move on, and to show they over her...they all jump(Symbolism) * they scream but intead of sound...theres fireworks....like saying I am now happy that its over *Finally There was an incepcion reference when he falls to wake up..and realizing that it was a dream(ofc the break up part was true, only the symbolisms werent) *The title was double meaning : GoodBye= I hope ur happy //// and Bye= I forget about you

[@RichieAndWolf]

You can tell that this is a really meaningful and personal song. It's so sad and yet instead of giving up the person keeps moving forward. Great job.

[@ciel983]

wahh you're great thanks for explaining this for me and the other people who didnt understand it :)

[@Kngly1]

Smile SoUCanLive RichieAndWolf Ur welcome Smile, and Ye I think they did awesome with this concept :)

[@phuonguyen6319]

wow. amazing

[@aviona123]

see i wish i could see MVs like this instead of only just drooling over the hot members and their hotness omg did you guys see Ren i cant get over his new image and akadjgjskdkghvj

[@vashustampede]

choi minki could step on me and i’d honestly thank him, like damn. what a guy

[@CellaB23]

:D :D I laughed so hard when I read it! :D He's gorgeous!

[@Binjuice77]

I dont understant why this song wasnt popular?!!! its like so high quality and yassss kry kry

[@jhiarose4454]

+Binjuice77 they're so underrated

[@ladycrown3466]

NU'EST DON'T HAVE BAD SONGS

[@beast-beneath_the-moonligh6373]

FACT!!

[@missingyu7825]

Indeed

[@eveliinaaho2300]

True

[@vouslovez]

I'm not a fan of NU'EST but seeing them on the stage of Produce 101 S2 made me sad (esp. when kahi cried). I have known them for having Unique music videos (in a good way) and they are all Talented, the five of them. I just discovered that the 4 members are participating on the survival show and I hope everyone will support them and they already said that they're desperate and that it maybe their last chance to be on a boy group. Please support them all the way!

[@vouslovez]

It's sad that pledis don't like give attention to their older groups like NU'EST and After School.

[@conkhi4606]

ayaann Why were there only four members on Produce 101?

[@vouslovez]

I'm not sure why

[@conkhi4606]

i honestly don't know Oh I saw in another comment that he had a controversy? I don't know if it's true. Thanks for answering though.

[@Dgraygirl85]

And another comment said that it was Mnet that didn't want him to join; we will never know what are the true reasons

[@bellsandnawhistle]

The flower in Ren's mouth reminds me of a fanmade concept called Hanahaki disease. Where the person with one sided lobe starts vomiting flower petals. It can only be healed with the person liking them back. P.s Ren's hairstyle here is just simply amazing

[@TatiiiAndersen]

Yeah, exactly what I thought !! It also reminds me of Jin in the mv of I Need U

[@None_yu]

*mind blown* 👌 I just searched hanahaki disease on KZbin and this MV came up😂

[@alyzzaparkjihoonswife6419]

Bangtan B2UTY yea right

[@QN8375]

its 2016 and im still not bored of this

[@mvc1412]

+QN8375 God bless you!

[@Hafizchelsea95]

yeah me too !! ☺☺

[@NguyenVu-yd5xj]

+QN8375 yeah mee too you like Nu'est right??

[@nuestspromoter9030]

same gurl

[@pyh736]

SAME

[@shmarkpark5268]

Lovely NU'EST all of you filled me with so much happiness, your music never let me down, thank you for existing

[@NP21470]

Even with ren's hair like that he still looks prettier than me... :C

[@khymuchan101899]

MinHee Kim same feels

[@cess9272]

this song is just too good and DEFINITELY one of my top favorite nu'est songs. (who am i kidding tho nu'est's whole discography is a 👌💯)

[@user-tk6ev1xt9w]

nuest have so many good songs and they have like five beautiful visuals??? , why are they being sleep on??

[@lee_gyul_gyul]

😭😭

[@lee_gyul_gyul]

agree

[@tmdsb2655]

Because Pledis the snake decided to put them in China (even though China heavily restricts korean artists) with poor planning, for a long period of time, costing huge loss in korean fan base and little gain in China. Then, Pledis decided to send them off the Japan. With limited success in Japan and even more loss in Korea, Nu’est faded. They’re having a comeback in late April tho! Please support them!

[@mth507]

@@tmdsb2655 agree

[@jbmabansag8387]

Well not anymore hunny 🙅🏻‍♂️

[@foortunecookie_]

this song will never get old

[@Wayfinderss]

There are so many "break up," "I can't live without you" and "I can't forget you" songs and this one is no exception. But Nu'est's song and MV pops out to me in so many ways. The members look like they've matured and don't look and sound like rookies anymore (They are very handsome men). The symbolism in this MV is pretty interesting with the flower and fish. The beat and the dub-step towards the end is awesome and the lyrics are so meaningful which I love. It's catchy too and I can replay it so many times like all other Nu'est songs. Though I admit their latest songs haven't really exceeded their "Face" song, I'm still a fan and I love this song. They are talented and I'll keep supporting them. But seriously these guys need so much more attention. They have huge potential.

[@fannylam1020]

Totally agree. They deserve more attention.

[@Somaddude]

Agree also. Sick of the repetitive themes in KPop, but the MV sticks out in this.

[@Wayfinderss]

***** There are songs where guys or girls sing "I can't live without you in my life" or something like that because they feel like they really can't live without their beloved one. I was talking more so about break up songs so i don't see how i was wrong...? But definitely there are "I can live without you" songs as well.

[@honbonque]

blaqkn8 I thought what the previous commenter was meaning was that this particular song is about being able to live without someone, rather than "I can't live without you". (Just here to explain the comment, but in a way she's right, but also it's kind of implying all the songs like that in general.)

[@Wayfinderss]

***** I agree. I understand with what that comment meant by this particular song,Good bye bye, shows that they can and will get over the girl. I was just referring to songs in general that I know of that usually say "I can't live without you in my life" because there are songs like that such as Son Jieun's "Can't Live Without You" song and Jay Park's "Can't Live Without You" song as well. But yes there are a lot of other songs that are about people getting over their break ups and moving on with life by saying "I can live without you." All break up songs in general have these kind of themes. But Nu'est song showed to be different from other break up songs in a way. They said that they can overcome and that's why they are saying good bye. We all have our own views and I totally respect that. I just wanted to clarify what I was saying in my comment just so others don't get confused and know what I mean. (Not trying to sound like a bitch or anything lol. Just trying to reiterate my point.)

[@mikeblossom90]

ANYONE STILL WATCHING IN 2016? ;) ..this song slayss and so does the video and OMFG REN U ARE SUCH A HOTTIE

[@faizsophia9687]

we're two now😁

+Faiz Sophia three

[@SoshiStars]

Four!

[@jazminrojas9280]

true

[@Ariel-ow8wx]

six😁 its a shame i just found this song!

[@saleynlove7793]

Even if the song wasn't popular when it came out. I think it's a piece of art. It's one of the first songs that kept captivating me when I first discovered Nu'est (after deja vu). I'm so curious what they will bring in the future.

[@lhg3891]

look at their New song ♡

[@MA-zv7is]

The only reason why they've been so underappreciated before pd101 was all because of Pledis incompetent. They got everything to be a top notch group the debut song were great, their concept were one of a kind and unique but because of Pledis were so incompetent they've been slept over. I'm glad they got the attention and recognition but i hope that Pledis didn't fucked them up again

[@honghong-y7p]

한국말이 없군... 렌이 저렇게 잘생긴지 이거보면서 새삼느낌 뉴이스트 다섯명 다 흥해랏💕

[@kirsten7770]

Why is Ren so freaking perfect! Put those abs away my heart can't handle it!

[@lauriefigula2173]

I'm probably the only who prefer Ren with his blond long hair ♡

[@MashaRain]

+Laurie Figula Nope, I'm with you on this one. I mean, he's always beautiful, but I still like the long hair better

[@lauriefigula2173]

Miriam RainChild Ah, that's so cool! :3 Haha, of course he is, :)

[@princessciara1212]

Me! I know he looked girly he was way cuter in my opinion

[@MashaRain]

Princess Ciara Did you see the new pictures today? long black hair :)

[@princessciara1212]

+Miriam RainChild. omg no where can i find them???

[@marceee1777]

THIS NEVER GETS OLD.

[@itsizayumi]

Minki and Minhyun is super handsome in this MV!!!! The song is super good, am I blinded back in the old days....😍😍😍😍😍😍😍 I’m totally in love with Nu’est

[@momma_ravioli]

0:37 ren's abs tho, woooooo it's hot in here

[@newbienewbie8974]

You should see their Na.Na.Na. music video full version. He showed more there. Actually they all looked sexy and hot there but its only available in dailymotion.

[@momma_ravioli]

thank you for the suggestion I will wahhahaha

[@multifandomyal3599]

*2019? Still waiting for Happily Ever After!*

[@anakarenemostellezacosta3285]

NU EST😘😍

[@anakarenemostellezacosta3285]

Minhyu🙀 Baeko😉 Aron😋 JR😍 Ren😘

[@anakarenemostellezacosta3285]

NU EST😘😘

[@ttyp.j6354]

And "love me "

[@gpu2064]

NU'EST❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@TheLoveDiler]

one of the best nuest songs ♡ miss them so much.

[@robertrodrik]

X2

[@itspeanut9125]

FREAKIN REN AND HIS SHORT HAIR HDLCIGECIGEICG I STILL CANT GET OVER IT. HE DESTROYED ME CLWLWIEDW

[@itspeanut9125]

AND THEY LEAVE HIM SHIRTLESS THROUGHOUT THE WHOLE FREAKIN MV. THANK YOU FOR DESTROYING OUR OVARIES EVEN MORE

[@ashhadrien9097]

It's Peanut ME TOOOOOO OMFFFF I CANT

[@GoddessRubyJade]

It's Peanut SAME, it destroyed me after knowing of him for actually an hour. I was like *scrolls through vine* "This ren dude is too much for me" *sees vines with short hair* I honestly actually wasn't ready

[@mio9138]

i'm sorry but hwang minhyun is so hot i can't handle this he is literally the whole package i can't breathe

[@geralcp2690]

SAME HAPPENS TO ME EVERY SINGLE SECOND OF MY LIFE, MINHYUN IS PERFECTION!

[@Kdramalover98]

i have never seen a more true caption. preachhh

[@zoradjurdjevic9987]

👍👍👍 And JR with blond hair, when Baekho became that fat?😮😮

[@jacklee2776]

I can't move on knowing that this masterpiece was not recognized.

[@kiiellox]

OMG How can Minhyun be that good. i mean look at his face, voice and BODY His body portion is amazing GOD!

[@vayoletarandasalcedo5665]

Hace 5 años y está hermosa canción solo tiene 12 millones de vistas...una pena, porque es hermosa! Todo lo que hace Nu'est 💖 es arte!

[@lhg3891]

es verdad , se lo pierden! Son hermosos♡

[@marciapalta4440]

Tienes razo ellos deverian ser numero uno 😍😍

[@Sofibu10]

De acuerdo contigo ;w;

[@jakiesan8747]

Así es que injusta es la vida, pero nu est hace lo mejor por sus verdaderos fans 😜🥺😔🤷😁

[@flor2637]

7 años y ahora es 14 M son legendarias estas canciones

[@Iwoaiwhdins]

i absolutely love how Ren looks here T.T he should drop the long blonde looks and keep it dark, he's stunning! :D

[@sakurajapan3589]

Totally true!!!

[@LianBaher]

I can’t with Ren being this handsome mashaa Allah, the combination of pain and cherish is unbelievable❤️😭

[@Dorothy0785]

Goodbye bye symbolized the transition of teens Nu'est to mature nu'est. I felt their struggle in this songs how they trying hard to shows us more of their talent. I love you Nu'est.

[@affiefah6520]

I don't understand how NU'EST can't be popular like the other boy band . They have good song very much . Just weird .

[@asavagegarden]

because in korea, promotions are VERY important and Pledis did MANY bad decisions and they end up losing most fans there (and having a big fanbase in korea is obviously more important in order to be a popular group in kpop where matters... korea)

[@adaakudankamu]

Armyfy Valera just like bap and their company...we can relate it like that how it end up...but bap still slightly popular than nuest..

[@tokiimato]

joew Yeah but as a B.A.B.Y myself, I gotta say that B.A.P's case is quite different. They're actually on the right track in early 2014 (winning music shows and stuff) but the world tour and freakin damn lawsuit kinda ruined the momentum they had. So it's hard for them to regain their popularity as much as they had before after almost two years of hiatus. But I admit we're still a big fandom. NU'EST in the other hand was on the right track since their debut (as Face was getting much views). Action was a pretty good follow up until Pledis changed their concepts to Hello. It's officially dead when they came back with Sleepwalking. They lost many fans. (but I like the concepts that they're promoting starting with this song). What I'm trying to say is B.A.P was ruined in the middle of their rising towards immense popularity but NU'EST was ruined too soon. B.A.P still got the chance to feels what winning is like but it's very sad and devastating that NU'EST has never get the same opportunity and spotlight they deserved.

[@ahgasesatheartandalwaysbe4396]

Amirah Syazwani it's not the concept are the problem..but when pledis decide to send the to China & Japan for a very long time. it's like a hiatus for nuest in Korea that's the reason why

[@iamadreamer3149]

Let's hope that people will stop sleeping on them now

[@Victoryisalways]

Words cannot explain how much I love NU'EST and this comeback. It's been a long time since they've released new music, and I can't believe this is their first full album since their debut. But now I see why it took so long. They were working on perfection. There is not a single song in this album that is so so. They're all amazing. I only know NU'EST mainly through their music videos, and their music which I love, and I know all their names but I still have a hard time figuring out who is who. I am a fan, but a very lacking one. I promise I'm going to get to know you, our angel-like members, and your personalities better. I hope you stay healthy, and that you always smile, and continue to shine.

[@ShuaAlice3017]

Never in my life will I surpass this wonderful song

[@martinahwang9848]

14,190!!! This song is wonderful ... The choreography is great and I love the voices !!!

[@ella__700]

The fact that it was 8 years ago I can't believe it ever I miss you guys Take good care of yourself When K-Pop was fine it was the best not now it's full of scandals and insults

[@peachykyeom3103]

It's released on 2014 and this is the first time i hear it. This song is so good i'm disappointed of myself why i didn't listen to it earlier.

[@grazielly099]

PLEASE, NUEST, BACK FOR US

[@weeb-zl6bc]

Me: 1: *dies seeing Rens ABS* 2: *gets alive again bc needs the daily doze of Nu'est* 3: *REPEAT*

[@lemonade1788]

I am so proud of them.. they never got any award for the past 5 years but they never gave up.. after more than 5 years of fighting.. they finally got an award even if it isn't that grand.. Congratulations Nu'est!!!! Fighting!!!

[@thuydoan9239]

LOVE NU'EST

[@anajuliaperinadeoliveira3462]

Ggg

[@전휘탁]

도입부만 들어도 심장이 두근두근ㅜㅜ 말도 안되게 진짜 노래 개좋음 멤버들 비주얼도 이때 물올랐다 진짜

[@잉아잉-b2h]

맞아요... 제 최애곡 중 하나 많은 사람들이 들어줬으면 좋겠네요 진짜 명곡인데

[@toastiici]

Who else came here after watching their newest MV?

[@cat_pb]

meeeeee !!!!!!

[@khanhnhu7870]

me ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@arisshaya]

MEEE

[@Nada-mz2xt]

mee!

[@meowchiiin]

lol me.

[@gominie]

REN REALLY LOOKS LIKE LUHAN HERE IM CRYING A LITTLE WHAT

[@stanloona5726]

they are long lost brothers lol

[@minnabegovac4533]

I thought I was the only one who think that :')

[@user-gd4ty2nq3u]

I'm happy they started dressing Ren like a boy

[@ciel983]

BubblesM To promote him & he Grabs more Attention to the group

[@wannabee7054]

I'm creing too ╥﹏╥

[@glorianaelizondoz.2373]

Three years and I can't believe my kids have gotten zero recognition. I'm a proud Carat, but I truly believe SVT have amazing superiors to look up to in their agency. NU'EST will recover, I won't accept anything else instead.

[@kevinsweetmoon978]

Ren is so handsome . His hair style is so omg awesome I hope he will use that hair style again :)

[@lizhizhi]

when ren vomited flowers, I honestly only thought of hanahaki syndrome, which is a fictional disease where flowers grow on the back of someone's throat, and they slowly die, either choking on the petals when coughing it up, or the hanahaki flower's roots spread to vital organs. hanahaki happens when the person they love doesn't love them back, so they literally die of love just an interesting bit of information

[@yanyanli2165]

THATS WHAT I THOUGHT OML

[@gabriellalee4603]

mE TOO I CAN ONLY THINK OF HANAHAKI

[@SuperKrazyKatyKat]

Lia Shi that’s the point of the song.

[@justdewayuare2228]

im having nu'est mv marathon

[@iamaproudv.i.pbigbangtheki8737]

duuuuude this MV is sooo amazing ! i became a ㄴㅇㅅㅌ after i saw nu'est in p101 😍 ren in this mv looks sooo handsome omg ! nu'est fightiiing !

[@ateezsan-p7g]

Because despite everything NU'EST is and will be an iconic group in the kpop industry, even if they are no longer together, I will support their career separately.

[@jkcc2923]

rt, and still listening their music

[@hitalvr]

people sleep differently, i sleep on my left side, my dad sleeps on his back and south korea sLEEPS ON NU'EST

[@wongbdjzjdnsjdb6945]

anna 안나 so we shall not sleep on such a good comment

[@안나-p5x7t]

Porque a pesar de todo NU'EST es y será un grupo icónico en la industria del kpop, aunque ya no estén juntos, apoyare su carrera por separado.

[@aislinnmorales]

soy la única que cree que REN se ve muy guapo y atractivo con ese look?.

[@sheilakook8031]

créeme que no

[@aislinnmorales]

Mary Nuñez la verdad yo lo conocí con el look anterior y creí que era niña, con este nuevo se ve mas varonil

[@angelaoviedo98]

exactamente! Se ve mas varonil! *-*

[@esdenkaq160]

ren aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa*q*enserio no esta lindo esta guapo como macho hahaha ok no pero si no se ni que escribo

[@ohmysamanthaa]

you're not the only one; i now see Ren in a new light and he, don't hate me guys.. looks way more incredibly sexy with this hair than the hair he debuted with..

[@ShuaAlice3017]

Nu'est has beautiful voices. I'm in SP waiting for your comeback!!

[@martinahwang9848]

14,193!!!! The choreography and their voices are so perfect

[@야옹-d5q]

1. 국내활동 해외 돌리는고 절대 안됨 2. 노래 퀄리티 굿바이바이 정도면 훌룡 3. 컨셉 약간 섹시 카리스마로 4. 종현이나 민기나 누구 연기시키세요 5. 안녕하세요 같은 프로그램이라도 꼭 출연시키고 6. 민현 추가안되면 유닛활동 진짜

[@porcelainbear3]

Reading this made me sad x.x "The LOVEs are very aware that NU’EST is not doing as well they used to. All LOVEs understand that the significance of the word “rebirth” isn’t just literal, that there is a metaphorical resonance to NU’EST themselves. This comeback is about them getting back in the game, re-establishing themselves and acquiring the popularity they lost. They are extremely nervous about this comeback, because they are aware that this is potentially their last chance to prove themselves as worthy competitors to other popular groups." This song is so good; please help them get the success they deserve :)

[@Fruehlingsbiene]

Even if they are not going to win against the others maybe they'll succeed for themselves and rank at least higher with this song. I don't think this is their last chance as long as they stay together and us with them! ;)

[@porcelainbear3]

FagHagBiene I agree with you :D The fans won't let that happen. This is such a good song so I'll be sad if it doesn't get a win. I like it much more than Face (and I am so in love with that song too). ^^

[@Fruehlingsbiene]

porcelainbear3 Well, I can't love it more than Face (how can you? :D). Because Face was really different, it had the most meaningful lyrics ever in K-Pop. The guys stood up for tolerance in society. But it's not like this song is meaningless, so.. LOVE fighting :)

[@porcelainbear3]

FagHagBiene Maybe I shouldn't have said I like it much more xD I love both songs a lot but I do think Good Bye Bye is better ^^

[@pattyhan8917]

Beautiful nu'est has Goodbye Na na na And face off, Hello(hola, kel palsa Bonjour) And many other great song and they are also amazing too there is kindhearted Arron, jr, ren and the beautiful kindhearted blond and orange and black hair guy too very talented too as well

[@CrissaRain]

"When we meet again, we will shine" YEAHHH MY BOYS! NU'EST!! YOU ARE SHINING BRIGHT MORE THAN DIAMOND NOW!!

[@taehyungsleftfoot2414]

still my favourite comeback of nu'est :)

[@rumrika]

Taehyung'sLeftFoot me too

[@paulamariap.cabaleiro5053]

i think the actual meaning,is to leave what hurts you, ren spitting flowers because of his "flower boy" image that he got judged of being a girl , aron staring through the window like he misses something which i suppose is his family or wanting to go back home, baekho ripping wallpaper because he says he's not handsome enough and he wants to prove people that is more than looks , jr eating a fish symbolizing the popularity they had and they let it escape but he's not willing to do it again and minhyun is self harm in general.

[@Peace-12230]

I am saying goodbye to my old self, i am reborn again and found my true colours.💞

[@alexiacruz9608]

this is surprisingly way better than I could ever have imagined. Nu'est, you're gaining one more fan here!♡

[@nora_s_norae]

I won't lie I'm sad and I'll miss NU'EST so much. But I understand and respect your decision. Thank you so much Aron, JR, Baekho, Minhyun & Ren for all your hard work to always give us good music and beautiful performances. Thank you so much for all the happiness, fun, energy, strength and courage you gave to us these past ten years. I'm so happy and grateful to be a ㄴㅇㅅㅌ and I'll always keep loving and supporting each of you. I wish you to stay healthy, to be happy and to realize all your dreams, you really deserve it guys. 💗🇫🇷

[@eyamin6262]

Take love from Bangladesh 🇧🇩

[@nora_s_norae]

@@eyamin6262 Oh thank you this is so lovely ♡

[@saadiapeerbux3246]

Yay I’m 🇫🇷 too I cried when nu’est disbanded 😭

[@toddochman]

They disbanded really??

[@daniellaelle4685]

Nuest gioi wa that la khong uon cong cho doi , hay wa nhge that la rat tai , ai cung dep nhu hoa . Nhat la oppa Ren . iu nuest nhieu

[@hoaphamj6725]

tăng view nha p

[@bearaeb]

randomly got this tune stuck in my head i can't believe its been 7 years

[@khristianarroyo582]

To think a legendary group is now on produce 101 hurts

[@joshwonkim0895]

That's how I've been feeling when girl group BESTie split and one of the members is now on the Unit.

[@minaryuzumaki]

Everybody is talking about Ren and "the guy who eats the fish" (JR.) but... HAVE YOU SEEN MINHYUN? HE LOOKS SO GODDAMN HOT!!!.

[@davionae.7292]

RIGHT!!!! I always thought that he and Ren were the prettiest.

[@minaryuzumaki]

Yes, exactly that haha

[@wallflower-lo3yx]

Kanaya Maryam Totally agree! Especially coming back to them and forgetting who everyone is, I was like.....damn, who is this fine looking boy?!?! XD

[@karklesvantas9782]

Kanaya Maryam FINALLY, SOMEONE NOTICES THE RIDICULOUSLY GORGEOUS BATHTUB GUY. YOU TELL THEM, KANAYA.

[@minaryuzumaki]

Yes, Karkat, The Bathtub Guy Need Protagonism Too.

[@annlyg5452]

AAAAAA THIS SONG REALLY IS A MASTERPIECE

[@martinahwang9848]

14,227!!!! Baekho's hair color is great !!! I love this song and its choreography is amazing !!!

[@nanaclown5929]

Its a good song, perfect choreography, and perfect MV

[@trangcoi1989coicoi]

I'm addicted to this song lately, Why can't I know it sooner... It's like my mood in sad love, I'm hard to forget the person I love for a while. Thank you "101 produce" has brought me here... thank Nu'est and i like Baekho

[@asavagegarden]

8 MILLION VIEWS! NU'EST FIGHTING!

[@leaderjiu4949]

captainbaekho 8.1 :3M

[@karleenelfoo9576]

now 8,615,822 views

[@minjeongvisualace]

captainbaekho 8.9 now 😁😁

[@황민한]

9 MILLION !

[@meiwo2083]

Soon we will be 10 million 😃

[@alicekim1291]

14,210!!! NU'EST in this performance is amazing his choreography !!! I love her, those dance steps make me fall in love with them even more ❤️

[@elenalin1334]

REN I LOVE YOU

[@susupattra5142]

🤘Thank you "JR", "Aaron", "Ren", "Baekho", and "Minhyun" for putting all their talents into the best for NU'EST. Throughout the past 10 years🥰

[@asavagegarden]

NU'EST Members: 0:19 Minhyun (Singer) 1:18 1:26 Aron (Singer and rapper) 0:32 Ren (Maknae and singer) 1:36 JR (Leader and main rapper) 2:00 Baekho (Singer) Fandom name: L.O.V.E. (ㄴㅇㅅㅌ)

[@HALI._.]

captainbaekho Thank you am so new to NU'EST ❤

[@lorenabp3662]

This group is amazing

[@minnierocks7462]

captainbaekho I am joining this fandom😀😀😀

[@isabellaguzman4690]

14,140!!!! This song is incredibly perfect ... Their choreography is great and their voices are magnificent ♡

[@amethystcahill]

This guys are underrated on too many different levels. Like 3 mil seriously? This song is amazing O-o