My Ideal Peter Sam

If something you grew up with still holds up, by all means, don’t abandon it. But I’m a firm believer in recognising and addressing kinks in such things and regarding things the way they are instead of how I remember them. Story structure means a lot to me, I strive to consider appeal from several angles, including but not limited to that of an average railfan, and I have been asked by viewers on many occasions what to my mind works and doesn’t work with various aspects of Seasons 1 to 5 of Thomas The Tank Engine & Friends.
Written, recorded, & edited by me:
/ @astrayterrier6811
www.deviantart...
www.deviantart...
Music by SmittyG513:
/ @smittyg513
Screenshot from “Four Little Engines” by Wilbert Awdry, Britt Alcroft, and David Mitton.
Photographs by Nigel Menzies, Luke Ryan, and various others.
Thomas was bought by the Mattel business.

[@kierenheinz7880]

If I remember correctly, the reason why his funnel was a lot larger was because it was a separate piece they just fitted on top of the original funnel of the model, as it would be easier to work with besides having to work with multiple models or something, like how they just placed on the nameplates and used something like tape over the SR plates.

[@auraknight1004]

Peter Sam back in his Railway Series book colors

[@comicfan1324]

I know that he’s from the CGI series, so I’m not sure how you would make the photo shop if you’re going for a model series aesthetic, but I think it’ll be interesting to see how you would interpret Luke

[@tidmouthsheds4596]

Hes not from the cgi series he was in the railway series waaay before the cgi series, he also appeared in the model series.

[@BluebellProductions-m6k]

​@@tidmouthsheds4596Actually he was talking about Luke

[@LukeOfSodor22]

Well he did do Bear who is an RWS character and he does have a video on Murdoch who is an TVs character

[@johnathonmcjohn3]

​@@tidmouthsheds4596 ah yes luke *in the railway series* *_and in the model series_*

[@TankEngine97]

So Peter Sam and possibly Sir Handel are the Corris Railway representation in your AU. If Duke is the Ffestiniog representation, (I'm guessing) I wonder which railways would Rusty and Duncan represent.

[@LukeOfSodor22]

Duncan could represent the royal air force

[@mrbluebelltrain55]

Maybe rusty could represent Ruston Hornsby diesels?

[@jackswan3420]

I recall him mentioning Scotchman at some point who I believe was another 2'3"

[@Sudriantank12]

​@jackswan3420 who is scothman?

[@sarahziegler1582]

I would like to see your take on Spencer

[@EternityKingdomsHeadHoncho]

He’s beautiful I’ve been looking at him for five hours now

[@stuartbarclay7940]

Perhaps you could do Sir Handel next?

[@zackwessling7102]

I agree!🙂👍

[@RyanHo242]

Yes!

[@daringpyrritator7163]

It’s a surprise to see you jump from the SR’s number 2 to its number 4. So I’d definitely like to Sir Handel next. Additionally; and I don’t know if it’s been corrected by another viewer, but you were somewhat incorrect about slate mining in your Skarloey video, as the railway has another slate quarry off of Rheneas.

[@matese1912]

So basically RWS Peter Sam just with a red face

[@Cookie-wc8su]

peter sam's funnel looked like that because it had to slide over his old one???

[@AdamGore-v1s]

Sir Handel

[@ThomasOfSodor_1]

Rusty?

[@HufflepuffBatboy]

Seeing as you've done Peter Sam, I think it's only right that Sir Handel should follow as the other Corris Railway representative.

[@HufflepuffBatboy]

Something I forgot to mention; do Sir Handel and Peter Sam get renamed from Falcon and Stuart and end up on the Skarloey Railway per the books? Or do they remain on the Mid Sodor Railway?

[@tazzer11]

Maybe sir Handel next?

[@LukeOfSodor22]

Maybe Sir Handel

[@zackwessling7102]

Sir Handel!

[@joshuaW5621]

Imagine how people might react if he does post-season 7 characters and doesn’t make Dennis and Norman different classes cause they have a problem with 11001 prototype having a another sibling in Thomas while simultaneously being outraged when BadManoredProductions tries to make the Skarloey engines not complete clones of the Talyllyn ones.

[@ThomasSirHandel]

Honestly he should just stick with either RWS or TVS liveries for the Skarloey Railway instead of just making the narrow gauge engines clones of the Tayllyn counterparts.

[@hudsontrainguy1217]

I’m waiting for Sir Handel

[@Cashtron-d8b]

Oh my guard, he's beautiful, also what's the other narrow gauge railway, the Mid Sodor Railway probably. also I think I'd like to see a location next, maybe knapford station, you haven't done a location before yet so it would be interesting to see something like that.

[@Peckettw42012]

Sir handel should be next

[@NVRacingProductions]

Vote for Sir Handel 👇

[@Lucat_Here]

Today on Badmannoyed Productions, we have RWS Peter sam in the TVw Jokes aside, I think you should put a spotlight on Ivo Hugh next, a lot of possibilities there

[@BluebellProductions-m6k]

I'm betting he'll be the Lynton & Barnstaple Railway representative

[@joshuaW5621]

I’d be curious to see some Vale of Rheidol representation considering that railway’s history of being the last steam line on BR.

[@BluebellProductions-m6k]

I honestly hope that the Darjeeling Himalyan Railway can get some sort of representation.

[@Cashtron-d8b]

@@BluebellProductions-m6k or he just doesn't exist because he literally does nothing in the RWS

[@Pusherthepush]

Can you do Sir Handel

[@scifiguy9000]

Sir Handel next.

[@traintimeboy]

Ahem. Billy

[@LukeOfSodor22]

He's dead

[@Steamteamrailworks88]

Please do Derek the Paxman Diesel in your ideal version. With the joke of him being a locomotive with IBS (Irritable Bowel Syndrome).

[@AffectionateBear-sg9ju]

Mans got the the SR red

[@thomaseadbhardmcqueen7511]

What you said about the Mid Sodor has piqued my interest. I wanna see Stanley next

[@Cashtron-d8b]

yeah honestly I have no clue what he meant but hey maybe he'll do something interesting with that railway.

[@johnathonmcjohn3]

i require sir hand

[@thethomasninjagoguy]

Sir Handel next

[@BDAThomas]

I would like to see one on Salty, if he's in this AU. (Also, I don't mind the engines having different colored faces, but my question is... why do they?)

[@ExtraEngine1]

Ideal Duke.

[@SillyDartPony]

Ideal Henrietta

[@razer7134]

If Skarloey and rheneas are green and Peter Sam and sir Handle are red dose that mean that Duncan is going to be blue

[@mrbluebelltrain55]

Tbh personally I would rather keep him green but still a cool take on my second favourite character, btw could you do sir handel or Duncan next?

[@caledonianproduction]

sir handle

[@Enzo-fk1tx]

Ideal Rosie perhaps 👉👈

[@RedJubilee]

Could you please do your ideal Harvey? I’d love to see your interpretation on him!

[@thewiseoldowlproductions6127]

Prediction for your take on Duncan: he’s going to be the botchman engine from japan

[@tomyoldiron6715]

Only thing missing was his hackworth Valve gear

[@MagicLampStudios]

I decided not to bother with that. The rods and slide valves on those models gave enough headaches already.

[@tomyoldiron6715]

Haha, funny.. meanwhile i love seeing them in action. But i understand, they are weird.

[@John-vp5ju]

I would like to suggest a video on either Rosie, or 98462 and 87546 because ive seen your interpretations of them on your other channel and i would like to hear more about them.

[@BlueMusicalEngineStudios]

I'd like to see your ideal Sir Handel next please

[@jenniferphillips5300]

I have a idea for bertum as a 0-8-0 tender engine custom built

[@Sudriantank12]

Do Duke next

[@thomasparodies9730]

Why are Sir Handel and Peter Sam red. And why does Sir Handel have white lining while Peter Sam has blue lining?

[@isakdahlgren8335]

i love your vidios and you just cep uploding thank you

[@NexusWorks924]

I think Spencer or Arthur Sir Handel or Duke would be interesting

[@andrewharveyofficial]

Umm duncan? Where are you

[@savagegardenfan9680]

I would like Terence next.

[@TechyBoi01]

Ooooo Brass, do Diesel 10 next

[@MichaelJones-vx7lt]

I would like to see Duncan next maybe?

[@Cashtron-d8b]

probably doesn't exist in his headcanon

[@reeceemms1643]

of course I'm sticking to my ideas: Lady Diesel 10 Emily Rosie Arry Bert Splatter Dodge Scruffy (new one added) Hector (another new one) Duke Bertram Sir Topham Hatt.

[@mrbluebelltrain55]

What about nevile and sir Handel

[@reeceemms1643]

@@mrbluebelltrain55 I forgot about those two.

[@stuartbarclay7940]

Not bad!

[@alegotankengine5413]

Sir Handel Next please!

[@jacobrumens9601]

Do Duncan and Bulgy next.

[@YaBoyNamedGheee]

Sir Handel Next!

[@floridasteamer]

Ideal Emily?

[@mikeyandfriends7356]

What about Neville?❤

[@CaledonianEngine]

Can you do arry and bert next please?

[@bobkolterjahn4266]

Please do Sir Handel!

[@thecooldude9830]

Can you do diesel 10 please

[@XavierThe_BFYCHost]

1 thing i hate about all the ideal thomas :their face being coloured

[@petesplayroom797]

JUST WHY ARE THE FACES THE COLER OF THERE PANT.

[@Cashtron-d8b]

He just likes the look of it

[@jjcuriel]

Do sir handle next

[@MaxTheKiller1915]

Could you make duke please

[@KASHandZack_-Ytube]

Pls do the mid sodor railway

[@Siderodstudios]

Like maybe Winston or nevil or summin

[@nickdoe6058]

can you Sur Handel next please

[@starhunter1269]

DO HANK NEXT

[@Sudriantank12]

Bro, you just did peter sam but red

[@BluebellProductions-m6k]

Whats wrong with that?

[@daringpyrritator7163]

That’s exactly how he looked in The Railway Series.

[@BluebellProductions-m6k]

​​@@daringpyrritator7163Exactly! Just with a few tweaks.

[@Sudriantank12]

There's nothing wrong with it. I'm just saying.

[@EvanTheGreenB12]

Do Rusty Next :D

[@Cashtron-d8b]

pretty sure rusty isnt in his headcanon, instead it's just basically alf

[@gray298heavyweapons]

Would Rusty be male, female, or non-binary in your ideal?

[@FictionalADDON]

Kinda wish they stick with the O gauge narrow gauge engine so they can work on the issues. Plus the larger scale models are ugly as hell.

[@alexthelnerj72]

Do sir handle

[@Emanuelson11yt55]

Duncan or molly please

[@EvanTheGreenB12]

Do Duncan And Bulgy

[@Chanellegray-t8u]

Can you do Stanley

[@Cashtron-d8b]

which one lol?

[@ThatboyJames05]

Hi

[@E4ridingagain]

Day 2 for asking Billy

[@greenengine03]

lemme help you there bro

[@E4ridingagain]

@@greenengine03 holy shit what the fuck

[@TheRuinedBreakfastOfficial]

Harold

[@littlebacongreengreatweste2606]

Yea, Green Peter Sam is better…

[@stevenmosco20]

sir handle

[@ReallyUsefulPinkEngine29]

Sir Handel