SHOCKING| Sadhguru Responds To Sri Sri's Remarks on Adiyogi

Рет қаралды 106,814

Mystics of India

Күн бұрын

Пікірлер: 839

@hari7priya Ай бұрын

Sanatana Dharma is multi-faceted and multi-dimensional. We love both of them and their perspectives

@rajendarmenen3672 Ай бұрын

Interesting.

@jumdas1049 19 күн бұрын

@@rajendarmenen3672. Loving does not help against invaders

@UshaRani-gy6ne Ай бұрын

I am an Aol follower I also admire Sadhguru equally Read his books Even if Sri Sri Ravi Shankar ji has made some comments the social media need not highlight them or compare them A totally foolish attempt !! Both of them are doing in their own ways - uplifting the Human Spirit In quite modern ways In fact I tell people learn Sudharshana Kriya or Isha Kriya Whichever you prefer The effect is same The spiritual growth is inevitable I am grateful to be living in their times Let both the Organizations grow many fold The Sanatana Dharma is introduced to us in quite unique ways Accolades 🎉to both the new age Gurus 🙏🏽

@1970pinkey Ай бұрын

They are speaking to their own disciples.so the advice is for the people who follow their path.These videos should not be uploaded .

@pradeepkrishnan7144 Ай бұрын

What is surprising is that Guruji chose to pointedly speak. Something that in my opinion, should have been avoided.

@prembiswas3511 Ай бұрын

It was totally unnecessary of Sri Sri to call something Sadhguru has said as nonsense. He should mind his language and intentions.

@starlovervii9721 Ай бұрын

when 2 guru saying stuff that contradicts, the followers are confused.. of course they gonna point out and highlight the issue

@gmail7894 Ай бұрын

Gurus do this intentionally. As you said, let it bepur private exploration and uhnderstanding, not for social media. Jai Gurudev

@GondTribe Ай бұрын

"Adiyogi" is a term commonly associated with Lord Shiva, particularly in the context of yoga and spirituality. While the term "Adiyogi" isn't directly mentioned in the most ancient Hindu scriptures, it's referenced in various texts and traditions: *Scriptural References:* 1. *Tirumurai* (Tamil Shaivite scriptures, 6th-12th centuries CE): Adiyogi is mentioned as a name of Shiva. 2. *Shiva Purana* (10th-13th centuries CE): Describes Shiva as the "Adi Guru" (first guru) and "Yogi". 3. *Linga Purana* (5th-10th centuries CE): Refers to Shiva as "Adi Yogi". 4. *Bhagavata Purana* (9th-10th centuries CE): Mentions Shiva as "Yogeshvara" (lord of yoga). 5. *Agamas* (Shaivite scriptures, 6th-12th centuries CE): Adiyogi is referenced as a name of Shiva. *Texts and Traditions:* 1. *Tiruvachakam* (Tamil devotional poetry, 9th century CE): Adiyogi is invoked as a divine name. 2. *Shiva Sutras* (aphorisms on Shiva, 10th-12th centuries CE): Describe Shiva as the ultimate yogi. 3. *Hatha Yoga Pradipika* (15th century CE): Mentions Adiyogi as the originator of yoga. Sources: 1. "The Shiva Purana" (translated by J. L. Shastri, 1970) 2. "Tirumurai" (translated by G. U. Pope, 1900) 3. "Linga Purana" (translated by J. L. Shastri, 1973) 4. "Bhagavata Purana" (translated by C. L. Goswami, 1971) 5. "Agamas" (translated by K. R. Sundararajan, 1995)

@swamivivekanandmaharaj6451 Ай бұрын

And in Marathi Varkari Sampradaya, it has been said--- "आदिनाथ गुरू सकळ सिध्दांचा"(Aadinath is the Guru of all the Enlightened Masters). Aadinath is the same as Shiva or give him any other name.

@swamivivekanandmaharaj6451 Ай бұрын

Thanks.pls post this comment everywhere.

@GondTribe Ай бұрын

@@swamivivekanandmaharaj6451 oh nice 🙏🏽 Dhanyvad for the info. 🕉️🪷🚩

@swamivivekanandmaharaj6451 Ай бұрын

@death00123 🙏 Osho and Krishnamurti also spoke against each other. There are a few other examples. I think its divine working; only foolish devotees quarrel. I tell the real spiritual thing: Shiva is the Nirguna Brahma and Aadiyogi is the Saguna Brahma or form of Infinity. Why this quarrel???😄

@shekarv7528 Ай бұрын

What sadhu guru says is right, but Sri ravishankar says or want to win for what purpose, is it a intellectual debate . New thoughts flows make way for it . And be in the society.

@geetharajagopalan5369 Ай бұрын

Sadhguru and Srisri spoke these facts at different contexts. Why the media is combining this, which was said at different events and contexts. They ate not confronting. Both are doing wonderful service to all people of the world. People of vested interests try to create conflicts from their separate different speeches.

@bhagwanbhagchandani5627 Ай бұрын

HINDUS MOSTLY DONT LEARN AND UNDERSTAND SO THE FOOLS GOT CHANCES TO FOOLED THE FOOLISH IDIOTS. MEDIA ARE MOST DANGEROUS TRAITORS FOR RELIGIONS

@International-indic. Ай бұрын

Don't speak nonsense I repeat don't speak nonsense. Sri Sri is crap & you are his crap follower

@durga12343 Ай бұрын

This channel is by a Sadguru follower. Just letting you know if you dont know.

@sujataerande2224 Ай бұрын

If this is a sadguru followers channel, I am more surprised how he could allow such controversial video to float.@durga12343

@_anbh0143 Ай бұрын

@@International-indic. and your worthless opinion dosent mean anything fool hahah😂 go do something nice with your life rather than judging these two great gurus !

@agungdarmayuda5754 Ай бұрын

I Think Sadhguru and Sri Sri have a same way and point of view. But this kind of controversy just from language, misunderstood meaning and words. In the end of the day, Sadhguru and Sri Sri Believe in Mahadeva, Shiva.

@manikyum Ай бұрын

No. Sadhguru and Sri Sri only believe in making money.

@MsPerfume25 Ай бұрын

Sri sri is better more real and down to earth❤

@amarendraborah6941 Ай бұрын

"Don't impose on others what you yourself don't desire to follow !" - Plato.

@gamingandtechgaming6284 Ай бұрын

@@amarendraborah6941 "giving the example of people who didn't know anything about the mind to who are above it"- amarendra bahubali.

@atmavikasa Ай бұрын

@@agungdarmayuda5754 no they don’t. See things for what they are. No need to paint the reality rose !! He said what he said - but why he said it is another thing. It was absolutely unnecessary. But all publicity is good publicity 🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️

@priyankahalder6473 Ай бұрын

I do have the experience..if your body is totally synchronised with nature it is impossible for that person to sleep at that night..I personally experienced this

@PrithviBathla-ub8oy Ай бұрын

But you are saying opposite, the ppl who are yogi, bharmachaari etc they sleep early and they wakeup early, like sadhguru said waking up around Bharma muhurta for spiritualy active ppl ? Second thing if wake up at night then what time sleep day or afternoon?

@gogimanju3739 Ай бұрын

@@PrithviBathla-ub8oy The writer is talking about staying awake and being upright on Maha Shivratri night. 🕉️

@priyankahalder6473 Ай бұрын

@@PrithviBathla-ub8oy I am only talking about mahashivratri night...other days I keep waking up automatically at 3:30 am when I am practicing yoga regularly because body gets synchronised with nature...and I too sleep around 8-9 pm...but in mahashivratri it is different..and for experiencing that there should be some kind of synchronisation of body with nature

@madhusudanparanjape6262 Ай бұрын

Interesting, sister. How to do that?

@Flo_wer_and Ай бұрын

@@madhusudanparanjape6262 come to Isha Yoga Center and they will give you tools how to start synchronising yourself with nature

@JP-fy4ts Ай бұрын

Instead of comparing just stay on positive side of theirs energy. I immensely respect Sadhguru and Sri Sri is MY Gurudev 🙏

@getsoundar-ch7yz Ай бұрын

Cumon Sri Sri has no energy except the food he eats

@riteshpilare3481 Ай бұрын

@@getsoundar-ch7yzYou are saying as if you stay with him throughout the day 😂. Who are you to judge a Guru? Did you know that many Himalayan Saints visit his ashram to take his darshan.

@SnDy2004 Ай бұрын

Comparing sadhguru to anyone is pure foolishness

@riteshpilare3481 Ай бұрын

@@SnDy2004 Any solid substance behind that? Go and ask other Sanatan organisations about Jaggi ji and you will never use these sentences again for him.

@getsoundar-ch7yz Ай бұрын

@@riteshpilare3481@riteshpilare3481 Yes brother I'm energy sensitive. Ive felt the Presence, the energies of great beings like Atma Nambi , Sadhguru, Pradeep , and some less known Masters . Ive felt no such vibes in SriSri's close proximity. I'm into spiritual since teens fr 21 years

@viroh123 Ай бұрын

This is what the Britishers did to Bharat, divided by casteism and created the concept of Patriarchy..... now it's dividing the faith in spirituality. Viewers don't get played, have faith and trust which ever Guru you follow. There is no right or wrong, life keeps evolving, beauty of our culture is that nothing is cast on stone. Jai Hind and Jai Bharat 🙏🙏🙏

@zenmaster4829 Ай бұрын

I don't want to argue with you about castism origins but even if Britishers introduced it then why even the biggest Dharmacharyas of Hinduism accepted it whole heartedly? Why did all the Hindus start to practice like it was embedded in their genes from 1000 years ago ? Why Dharm samrat Swami Karpatri Mahraj doesn't debunk instead he supports it ?

@peacefulindian318 Ай бұрын

@@zenmaster4829I have read the Mahabharat. It was written centuries before the Muslims and Europeans invaded, colonised and ruled India. In Mahabharat there was caste, the kshatriyas were the soldiers. And Karna was not recognised as a khastriya person, because he doesn't know who his mother was! It's wrong to say the British invented the caste system! The caste system was part of the Hindu dharma. Now it's being linked socially and economically by the people! The fact is, every community in the world has some form of divisions! That's the reality! 😀🇮🇳

@naveensharma8115 Ай бұрын

totally agree.. so beautifully put .. unite we stand, divided we fall !!

@manjuladuggar8298 Ай бұрын

👍👍

@narayanmurali2451 Ай бұрын

Stay united but we must have healthy debates to find the higher truths of life otherwise we will be stuck in lower truths such as modern science and repeat the endless cycle of birth and death.

@ShravanKumar-vi9gu Ай бұрын

Words were fighting, while the sound was expanding into the silence. Shambho...!

@rahulsls Ай бұрын

I like the explanation of Sri Sri Ravishankar 🎉🎉🎉👍

@rahul43751 Ай бұрын

@parthasarathiacharya3028 calm down . no need to be so hyper just because he liked the explanation of sri sri ravi shankar.

@Divine-Instruments725 Ай бұрын

The 3 Vishnu's are the scriptural evidence. The highest energy days should take advantage of it

@pvp6770 27 күн бұрын

Double shree has to get elevated to triple shree to KNOW ' THAT WHICH IS NOT '

@antoniowillz4847 Ай бұрын

Shiva didn't come as a Adiyogi he became a Adiyogi when he begins to give instruction as a yogi showing ppl how to live better and the many ways one can get enlighten

@amarendraborah6941 Ай бұрын

"The world is, infact, a mixture of truth and make - believe ! Discard the make - believe and take the truth !" - Ramakrishna Paramhangsha. Lord Shiva will continue to occupy the pride of place in the heart of the people, owing to just one simple reason ! He had come forward to drink the poison, on HIS own accord, for the well-being of all - when no one was willing to do so ! I am given to understand that once I.S.Johar, the famous Bollywood Comedian, who happened to be an atheist, was asked by a journalist - "How do you prove that - there's no GOD !" Rapid came the response from Johar Saab - "The presence of god - men !" People should be watchful of the machinations of all such - styled gods and pseudo - gods, euphemistically called god - men, if not GOD ! Let it be very loud and clear that I use to worship Lord Shiva - the Presiding Deity ; but not certainly an ordinary mortal - masquerading as an avatar of Lord Shiva ! It goes without saying that the very idea, in itself, is not only repulsive and outrageous, but also extremely sacrilegious and blasphemous, since it puts the entire GODHOOD to utter shame ! Our religious scriptures also recognized no other avatar, other than, DASHAVTAR OF LORD VISHNU ! May the WRIT OF THE CREATOR - be it ISHWAR, ALLAH, GOD, or whatever - prevail over everything for ETERNITY ! 🙏🏿🙏🏿🙏🏿🙏🏿🙏🏿🙏🏿❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

@vipinrajkt8221 Ай бұрын

Sri Sri discusses Shiva Tattvam, while Sadhguru refers to the entity known as Shiva. They aren't contradicting each other; rather, it's a matter of perspective that might be causing confusion...... 🙏🙏

@_anbh0143 Ай бұрын

yea like there is sri vishnu and his avatars ! its more like a avatar version of shiva that sadhguru is mentioning and the energy sri sri is mentioning

@vikisridharan1345 Ай бұрын

Bro, u haven't heard the other videos of Sadhguru where he mentions that Shiva is cosmic energy etc., just like Sri Sri Ravishankar. Sadhguru also says that because Adiyogi imbibed the qualities of Shiva and since he was the first Guru we know who did that, we call him ALSO as Shiva. And Sri Sri also said the same in a nother video. Before watching all their videos, pls do not make videos like this. Sri Sri Ravishankar is not contradicting nor is he mocking Sadhguru. And Sadhguru is also never against Sri Sri Ravishankar. Gurus never do that. It's only the half baked disciples who do all this.

@getsoundar-ch7yz Ай бұрын

No bro Sri Sri is jealous of Sadhguru

@MrSreenir Ай бұрын

Sri Sri Mentioned, some people say this and that -- indirectly referring to Sadhguru.. its not about Sri Sri or Sadhguru.. its about the truth..

@prantikghosh2800 Ай бұрын

U r pest@@getsoundar-ch7yz

@getsoundar-ch7yz Ай бұрын

@@MrSreenir laugh emoji

@The.World.Of.Siva666 Ай бұрын

Only Sadhguru mentioned 15000 years adiyogi lived .....so obviously Sri Sri mentioned Sadhguru......he is the real half baked guru 😊...tel your guru to be fully baked

@pbikash_ka_vlog Ай бұрын

There is no another Sadhguru in this universe..he is optimum..His logic and knowledge is pitch perfect

@arunnarayanan3428 Ай бұрын

You are wrong. There are many sadhgurus. And there is mahavathar babaji. And beyond all that there is trimurtis and jagadguru Shiva who is acting through various gurus we see.

@GondTribe Ай бұрын

@investor615 Ай бұрын

Sri Sri seems confused and is wrong in this context

@arunnarayanan3428 Ай бұрын

@@investor615 No one can say such a big vast topic in a few words. So Sadhguru says a few aspects, Sri Sri says some other aspects, Mahavathar Babaji's followers says yet another aspects. It is not absolute truth that we are dealing with, it is just outside petals of truth that can be said. So follow and understand max possible truth aspects from different gurus before realising the absolute truth yourself. That is the play/leela by The Supreme Guru.

@investor615 Ай бұрын

@arunnarayanan3428 hindu scriptures has all the answers

@onlyhuman5669 Ай бұрын

Gurudev sri sri ravishankar and Sadhguru are saying the same thing in different ways.. They're both gurus, and regardless of what they say, they're connected and love each other.

@prashanthkumars4707 Ай бұрын

Every one has their own way . We can follow which makes more sense to us. Sadhguru teaches from his experience and practices . Sri Sri teaches out of his learning from his gurus and scriptures .. huge respect for both doing wonderful service to the society

@MsPerfume25 Ай бұрын

Sri Sri is WAYYYY MORE REAL & BETTERRRR❤❤❤❤❤❤❤😊

@prashanthkumars4707 Ай бұрын

@@MsPerfume25correct … I knew I been following Sri Sri from almost 13 years ago… and sadhguru from last 8 years … I’m learning from both . But I have my choice to take things what I need from their teachings to make my self a better. Just following gurus is one aspect of life and experiencing your life as you needed is bigger aspect of life , without getting trapped in comparing who is big or small. Even when Sri Shankaracharya started his journey this was happening in our society . Later he shown no one is superior. As everyone believe that shiva himself born as Sri Adi Shankaracharya to show the world no one is superior in this world. That’s why sanathana dharma is still flourishing

@GondTribe Ай бұрын

@@MsPerfume25sri sri is simpler but Sadhguru has the depth. You'll see his beauty only if u understand him otherwise sri sri would look better because he is easier to connect to.

@prashanthkumars4707 Ай бұрын

@@GondTribe absolutely 👍… experiencing is most real than just knowing … by reading scriptures we can know .. but even without reading or by reading scriptures we can experience shiva … adishankaracharya himself says to touch consciousness, vedas are not a prerequisites. Only the bramha jigyasa is needed.

@sanvc Ай бұрын

My Spine. That was a sixer. Out of the ground :) I used to read a lot of scriptures. After doing Isha courses, understood what should be the priority. Sadhguru teaches the missing link. It is written in the scriptures itself, that spoken/written words cannot convey Yog/Dharm/Shastra in its entirety. Too much dependence on scriptures makes one Padat Murkh.

@ashwanikumarsingha1019 12 сағат бұрын

We have utmost respect for both gurus. Both views are welcome

@dharanisairaj9426 Ай бұрын

Both said the same thing ....where is contradiction ? shiva is everything

@benjamindsouza6736 Ай бұрын

This guy in the video sees contradictions where there are none!

@geethakrishnamurthy8682 Ай бұрын

When Ravishankarji speaks about Shiva he sees. Him as Brahman whereas Sadhguru mentions His one aspect as Aadhi Yogi , introducing Yoga to humanity. Both are correct.

@dudeabideth4428 Ай бұрын

I also felt the same.,

@janeeyre1455 Ай бұрын

they complement each other. Truth is always contradictory

@Neel306 Ай бұрын

Totally agree. Lets not try to bring down each other. Pleeese. We have enough enemies bringing us down. 😢😢😢😢😢😢😢

@SoothingHerbs Ай бұрын

Shiva as nothingness is different than the being who appeared and started the first teachings of yoga

@arunnarayanan3428 Ай бұрын

One is Shiva, adiyogis correct name is shankarnath.

@benjamindsouza6736 Ай бұрын

Exactly! These people don't seem to understand; they're just playing with words out of ignorance & trying g to create controversies where there are none!

@GondTribe Ай бұрын

Yes you are right.

@sumittete2804 Ай бұрын

Yes, you are absolutely right. It's like if a person teaches math, then he or she is called as Maths teacher. Similarly, Adi yogi as a being was the first yogi to spread the knowledge of Shiva to humanity (sapta rishi), therefore that first yogi was called as Shiva too by the people. So, Shiva as a being is different from Shiva as a divine abstract transcendental entity. Furthermore, everyone is Shiva in the fundamental sense meaning that our absolute self is Shiva which we called as pure consciousness (Parabrahma). It's due to the veil of ignorance(Maya) that we feel separated from our true Self (Shiva) .

@Rahulvarma-hq1cs Ай бұрын

One who is enlightened never say im enlightened!

@ps-gh3hu Ай бұрын

Nope dude

@maringantikrishnamohan6975 Ай бұрын

Perhaps the so-called Sadhguru may be an exception ,please pardon me for saying ‘so called’ as i am not aware of his theory or mission etc

@cosmosapien597 25 күн бұрын

Why

@devaloshinigovender4133 Ай бұрын

I totally agree with Sri Sri Ravishankar. Shiva is Supreme no end no beginning... not adi. I always thought sadhguru talks so much nonsense

@mahaxlord Ай бұрын

Sri Sri is talking about Shiva the Phenomenon, which is not even Perceivable without being Enlightened.

@cyberspice4401 Ай бұрын

Chi energy,5th element...

@aravindvijayan3581 Ай бұрын

Gurudev Sri Sri Ravi Shankar talks on shiva as the subtle aspect of our being. He is not trying to bring down anyone but answering the misunderstood concept of Shiva. Keeping shiva limited to any being and classifying shiva as adiyogi and adiguru is limited to a particular time. However in the universal realm of life, the subtle aspect of Shiva is not any person, but the vibration itself.

@Flo_wer_and Ай бұрын

Sadhguru never said that Shiva is Adiyogi. It is the opposite. Sg has described the first person who transcended the limitations of duality and became first known person who did that, that’s why he is Adiyogi. And as this person (Adiyogi) has become one with everything or has become No-thing, he has become Shiva, or in other words he has touched that subtlest aspect of the existence or Shi-Va. It means that each of us has the possibility to become Shi-Va.

@cosmosapien597 25 күн бұрын

Sadhguru talks about Shiva beyond adiyogi too. But Sri Sri Ravishankar's tone was attacking.

@skillfullifewithmukta9086 Ай бұрын

Sri Sri ❤️ There is an old saying "We should not see the Guru with Human eyes". Whatever I have learned in spirituality is only through Gurudev Sri Sri Ravi Shankar Ji. He is my Guru. There is no comparison of two spiritual masters.

@mayflowerlily5326 Ай бұрын

This is the problem in hinduism... there are many number of Gurus and lot of infighting among their Bhakts. That's why Muslims and Christianity succeed in our country

@SSJOMI Ай бұрын

No, wrong argument. Common Hindus are selfish and they value material wealth more than anything that's why we are falling behind. We have many forms of God and we have many customs that's what make our religion beautiful.

@praveenshetty2066 Ай бұрын

Watch fully

@Konklish. Ай бұрын

Many wants the truth it's not on which religion succeeds.. Your personal ista can be Jesus Christ...if you are on spiritual path and have not found him, you have not found yourself... Don't display the ignorance in public... From here comes blind bakhts.

@sudipbhattacharjee9 Ай бұрын

Abrahamic religions that destroyed most of the known world failed to succeed even after 1000 years of blood shed, rapes, cruelty, loot etc

@compassioniseverything4262 Ай бұрын

Casteism

@amolhjoshi Ай бұрын

I feel this media nonsense has created all the tiff….. I haven’t seen a video where Sadhguru is saying that lying down on Maha Shivratri will do something bad to you, he just said keep the spine erect that night to reap benefits of upsurge of energy! It’s ok to disagree…. And even if these two gurus should put it in a specific way! Both gurus speak about the body energy and both are highly respected…. I feel no one should try to shatter that respect in any Hindu mind Neither media, content creators nor the gurus themselves Great respect to both these gurus 🙏🏻🙏🏻

@bindumenon6278 Ай бұрын

Correct.This media is creating a misunderstanding among people.Salute to both gurus🙏

@verybizeee Ай бұрын

Even Sri Sri Ravishankar conducts events through the Shivaratri night, attended by millions around the globe and he too stays awake. He meant, it is not harmful to lie down. There is no contradiction or controversy here. Similarly, about Adiyogi, there is a material and spiritual angle to everything in existence. It is just that one is referring to the spiritual aspect and other is referring to the material. There is no contradiction here. It is like saying Dvaita and Advaita are contradicting each other, but they are just two different perspectives of existence and both are right.

@dudeabideth4428 Ай бұрын

+1 to this

@RamakrishnaReddyUppati Ай бұрын

Yes I agree fully with Sri RaviSankar Ji

@surakshav5553 Ай бұрын

Wow !! The humble presentation of this video shows the growth and maturity of Ishangas!! Jai gurudev

@ramadaskrishnaraj1294 Ай бұрын

There are 2 sides to an argument and I think Sri Sri has just presented his perspective. Logical.

@arijitroy929 Ай бұрын

With respect to two educated Gurus.... Shiva is beyond the description of enlightened ones..... Till now no one could grasp even 0.000000.....1% of the Parabrahman Shiva...... Adi Anant Shiva.... No start and no End.... Manifests in numerous forms as per Kalpa and Brahmanda

@anshukaushik2223 Ай бұрын

This is classic examples of how great beings are misinterpreted. Shri Shri ji also say shiva as Adiyogi, as well as Adyant Rahita. If you hear explanation of Sadhguru as Shiva ... and Shri Shri explanation of Adyant Rahita... they are essentially same. So Sadhguru and Shri shri not contradicting they are essentially different way of approaching things.

@OneSupreme08 Ай бұрын

Whatever is close to ones nature one should follow, for example for my nature its working to be relaxed about it to follow the middle path thats why Sri Sri appeal more to me, but those who like more ascetic approach and are feeling good with more tapasya path Sadhguru might be more attractive for them. But there are no absolute rules. I feel absolutely no wrong with either of two Masters its important sincerity of disciple and to follow what is right, appealing and easy for you, for ones nature, thats all. Thats why you end up with only certain Guru and not with other cause God out of His Grace have been incarnated as many Gurus cause God know humans have different nature. But behind all those Gurus is only One Supreme.

@ramasundar785 Ай бұрын

100% agreed that this kind of controversies are not at all necessary, especially especially during these times where an absolute unity among Sanatanis is required.

@varunaol 28 күн бұрын

Gurudev Sri Sri’s explanation of Shiva seems to be in line with the ancient scriptures like Shiva Purana. When in confusion, always refer the puranas and the saints who are in alignment with the ancient texts. 🙏😊

@MahaKaala3111 Ай бұрын

This channel is run by isha volunteers. Don’t know what’s going in their mind to clash btw gurus by these unnecessary controversies. When you point out what’s right and wrong. It’s clearly by judgements. Inspite the fact they both have come from the same guru.

@arkaprabhabanerjee9654 12 күн бұрын

Sadhguru and Sri Sri Ravi Shankar both are my Guru, I love both of them and i am very very thankful to them ❤❤🙏🙏

@kushagarsharma796 Ай бұрын

Comparing two spiritual master's words is not right. They both say glories of shiva. By showing edited videos it will only create controversy which the other Dharma people will make fun of. We cant compell small children and very old people to sit and meditate on Shivratri night when their body does not allow them, but yeah a physically fit person who seeks spiritual growth can definitely do that. Sri Sri's Shivratri programme is also attended by millions of people from all over globe let's not show them that only we are right and they are wrong, coin has two sides and each spiritual master has its own way and own perspective. Sadhguru and Sri Sri both admire each other's work for society, lets not create small controversies over small things that will devide us.

@apoorvegaur Ай бұрын

Well, I personally feel Jaggi ji isn't enlightened nor an enlightened person celebrates its enlightenment day or Claims that he is enlightened in response to an external triggering when asked a question. Second, isha foundation people are so scared and shallow that if they were truly spiritual they wouldnt bother to justify their Guru's video in contradiction with another Famous Guru. I have never seen Art of Living social media accounts directly taking names of Isha or Jaggi Vasudev to justify any video of Sri Sri which is contrary. I think wise ones will know who's Enlightened and who's a fraudster !

@dhanvanti-dianaomaol2264 Ай бұрын

Absolutely agree! It makes sense & yeah Wise ones will know i think!)

@meenbhemah7762 Ай бұрын

Hinduism happens differently to different persons...Krishna leelas ...no need to compare ""the admin of Mystics of India "

@rakeshbandi2840 Ай бұрын

Please do not compare the gurus teachings. Each have their own way. I have done many courses with both of them. For this their followers they are like father figures and you never compare your father. Hindu gurus are facing enough criticism from outsiders already. Let's focus of spreading knowledge and wisdom

@MsStarwoman44 Ай бұрын

I stay awake, and I sit up because I trust Sadhguru.. I'm grateful for Sadhguru, I don't care what others may say, actually until I started seeing Sadhguru, I never actually seen all these other people, I'm pretty sure they seen Sadhguru on you tube and decided, to do the same thing... I mean, what ever a person wants to do is there business, but when I look at these others, I think, how many tree's have any of these other people planted? Sadhguru has made it clear to the people, just how important it is to grow tree's, having a tree farm!!! How many little rivers and streams have they helped to come back to the land and the farms, how many of them talk about saving the soil? How many of them talk about creating Heaven on Earth.. All I see them doing is riding on Sadhguru's back, you don't have to do this, you don't have to do that, I don't care what they say, fine.. I actually think that Sadhguru don't really give a rats ass what they think or say either!!! that's just my opinion, why? Because he is Shiva's partner! Shiva recruited him, these same people are trying to say that Shiva never actually existed.. how sad, very sad only!

@GondTribe Ай бұрын

You are right 👍🏽👍🏽

@ANTMMW Ай бұрын

Words of all gurus are just a curtain . Behind that is the truth is waiting for us. No comparison and no contradiction. All are here only for us , not for themselves❤🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻

@debobratapramanik1836 Ай бұрын

I have my own experience what mahashivratri can do .. and how powerful it is , it's just I don't wanna say those powerful experiences like this , also people keep assuming things . But in my experience mahashivratri is very very powerful and I'm clear on that .

@manikyum Ай бұрын

No. You are wrong

@debobratapramanik1836 Ай бұрын

@manikyum I don't need validation from you .

@manikyum Ай бұрын

@@debobratapramanik1836 you need

@myulal Ай бұрын

Yes, the presence of the Indian actress dancing adds so much power to it.

@debobratapramanik1836 Ай бұрын

@@myulal well you are so desperate to prove your action ... See that's the difference , you never even tried and commenting here about something which you are not experienced yet ; which amounts to lying . You can believe/disbelieve whatever it doesn't change the reality , first do it and see and then come here and prove me wrong .

@mangatinanda Ай бұрын

Very important for us the ishas and AOL followers to agree to disagree. Nothing wrong. Just go with whatever is truly working for you.

@sandeepshirsat7073 Ай бұрын

Everyone has right to express his her opinion about the Shiva so We can't say who's right or wrong,one can do sadhana following one of his guru and experience the shiv tatva itself.......

@anubhagupta406 22 күн бұрын

U have a beautiful voice..ur facts are evidence, which all people have seen on social media, u sound like a Saadhak🙏 and i request here if inferences can be pointed in a complimentary way.. Gurudev and Sadhguru are not contradicting each other... From wat I understand as Sadhguru message for all is that we must utilise the energy of the Shivratri Night by keeping our spines erect.. Sleep or Wake up is totally our choice.. no harm is suggested🙏 And Gurudev here is only pointing towards one part of the question- that there is no harm in sleeping that night. Gurudev has not said anything about Not Waking up or meditating that night🙏 It is the formulation of question by media and henceforth the obvious interpretations that are creating this so called controversy...which actually doesn't even exist❤ Sadhguru and Gurudev are One light..that is shining upon us today🙏

@tapanroybarman1669 Ай бұрын

An enlightened being does not proclaim their own enlightenment.

@deepaks8187 Ай бұрын

I think he didn’t respond to Sadhguru’s message because, on social media, the idea is spreading that Shiva was merely a man who lived 50,00 years ago, reducing him to a historical figure and missing the deeper truth. Sri Sri Ravi Shankar might be trying to challenge this misconception. It’s beneficial that both perspectives are available on social media, as it encourages people to think critically and not blindly accept something just because it was said by someone.

@raghunandanraghavachari3188 Ай бұрын

Whatever the difference of opinion of these Gurus, one important thing in favour of Sadguru was his tireless advocacy of Soil health, his practical way of rejuvenuation of Rivers, especially Cauvery Calling, and his gaint effort to spread the idea of soil wealth through many countries and its success. Also because of easy approach to many philosophical problems and debates without hurting anybody. He can be the Guru Of The Day and we all wish that his followers increase, and that He and his follower do not deviate on their first and relevant aims, and He and His followers could still Pull off a success in long run. We can but wish Him long life and he and his followers best wishes.

@akshaykachchhiinfinitelear811 Ай бұрын

❤❤ Thats really so nice of you. Just wanted to add/ask or u can say share…. Do u know about SeedTheEarth , Jaltara , 70+ rivers actully rejuvenated on fields by The Art of Living since years, meri delhi meri yamuna , lakhs trained on Natural Farming etc… just asking if you know or not ?? Bcoz few things are not widely shared on social media…

@SurajTratak Ай бұрын

So basically shiva is not a person it’s over cosmic stuff but Shankar became Shiva after enlightenment. So according to vishnu puran Shankar came from vishnu and brhma and shiva is a state of enlightenment

@raviedwardchandran Ай бұрын

"SHIVA PURANUM" Or SHIVA PURANA"...Is The Only Way To Move Forward... However It's Original Ancient Content's Also Been Casted & Edited Several Times By Ancients Soul's.... 🤔💥🔥

@durga12343 Ай бұрын

A few vital points if you have brains and are a proud sanatani: There is a reason why Shiva is depicted with a "lingam" and not an idol. If everything is shiva then there is no need to put a specific shape and form of a human to it. Secondly, saying things that are coming from "inside him" and not from the scriptures and how he has discounted the vedas doesnt really make him a flag bearer of "Sanatan Dharma". And thirdly, Sri Sri's answer on staying awake during Shivratri has been completely misquoted. The question was if it is harmful to sleep during Shivratri as this can be a superstition among masses. To which he said, not necessarily. Even Art of Living has huge elaborate satsangs and Rudrapooja (from vaidic tradition) during Shivratri. I wonder why you didnt mention that. A cult is built on keeping your brain aside and just following the thoughts of one person blindly.

@verybizeee Ай бұрын

Misleading video. Happy to see wiser comments.

@Vineetbishnoi003 Ай бұрын

we got Indian guru's controversy before GTA 6 🤣

@SathwickGowda-d3r Ай бұрын

Frankly, Ravishankar Ji sounds wise

@lakshmandevashya4664 Ай бұрын

Ravishankar's chela blindly wrote this comment I believe.

@benjamindsouza6736 Ай бұрын

@@lakshmandevashya4664I am no chela of Ravishankarji but having been with gurus of the ancient Himalayan tradition I can say Sri Sri is absolutely right!

@GondTribe Ай бұрын

@pravinsish Ай бұрын

@@GondTribeplease post in main comments as well….this is needed…this is really unnecessary…comment by Sri Sri…

@JuanDiaz-wv7nr Ай бұрын

Ravishankar says that the body has better circulation lying down and this is not true; when the body lies down, regardless of the position, it loses oxygenation, which does not happen if you are sitting. Any intermediate meditation practitioner can know for himself what happens in Shivaratri, and what happens in his spine.

@cacavb 28 күн бұрын

Tera business bada ki mera business bada.. So much competition these days in baba career.. Does it still going to be bloomibg career in future.. Or one guru end up following other guru.. Ravi shankar or jaggi who is biggest fraud.. But they are fruad

@zeelc Ай бұрын

Today's youth should watch Acharya Prashant ji.

@arunmisra5963 Ай бұрын

ऊँ हरि गुरु तत्सत् जय श्री राजा रामचंद्र हर हर महादेव जी🏹

@theprowess6019 29 күн бұрын

I feel more than anyone else, this channel keeps perpetuating the idea of them being against each other. The last few times I’ve come across it, it’s been here. Instead of wording it like this, it could have easily been a way to bridge both the knowledge together, like some other commentators have done here, please reflect 🙏

@adiavadataIOI Ай бұрын

🤍💙🙏Please understand....Divine is Achintya - Ineffable. So Divine is manifesting as Sadhguru Vasudev and Sri Sri Ravi Shankar and needs to do this leela, this play, where the Transcendent Origin in 2 different appearance bodys seems to a little bit contradict each other....because otherwise how to get the students, disciples, devotees to Samarpan, to Surrender to the Antar Guru which is Absolute Presence and Absolutely Ineffable. As Nisagardatta Maharaj shared: "The more clearly you understand that on the level of the mind you can be described in negative terms only, the more quickly you will come to the end of your search and realize your limitless being." - So any Guru speaking in any language will always hit a wall in that which they try to share because words and language are within mind. ParahShivah, Paramshiva, Shiva, Adiyogi, Adinath, AdiGuru - utterly Glorious utterly graceful words but STILL these can only point to the Transcendent Ineffable Achintya "That" can ONLY be REALISED. And at times both these Great and Genuine Authentic Buddhas have said this!!🙏🍎🌟

@arunnarayanan3428 Ай бұрын

So apt.

@1998mahendra Ай бұрын

they are conflicting, words may be different but the essence is the same , beyond words

@snehashankar3743 Ай бұрын

One day gandhiji was guru. Today after so manu years we get to know hidden truths and myths. Like that everything will unfold with time. Commercialisation of knowledge is a game in the spiritual market after all. Lets wait and watch!

@arunnarayanan3428 Ай бұрын

What hidden truths you to uncover about Gandhi? Did he do anything which a human was not supposed to do?

@Lol-y1j9j Ай бұрын

Half baked No truth in it .. Different contexts put together n creating rift

@amarendraborah6941 Ай бұрын

"The world is, infact, a mixture of truth and make - believe ! Discard the make - believe and take the truth !" - Ramakrishna Paramhangsha. Propriety demands that one should better ascertain one's own status first, prior to raising an accusing finger on others ! Propriety further demands that one should also try to inculcate the habit of seeing goodness in others, as well ; instead of finding fault on every available opportunity, on the slightest of pretext, and at the drop of a hat ! It raises one's mental/spiritual level by several notches up ! Propriety also demands that one should have that much pragmatism and magnanimity in accepting the reality - by calling the spade a spade ! Besides, propriety demands that people occupying exalted positions should maintain probity in public life, remain above board, and beyond controversy ! How right was someone in his assessment in saying - "People living in glass houses don't throw stone at others !"

@stick2roots Ай бұрын

India needs both of them and Hindus need them even more.. The difference in opinion is perfectly fine, that's the jignasu or seeker..India always encouraged other pov..

@MichaelJYogi Ай бұрын

Sri Sri is always going out of his way to contradict Sadhguru instead of speaking to the legitimacy of his practices. What a shame We sit erect during Mahashrivrati because there is the greatest upsurge of energy and pull of forces of the year (such as the moon). Sitting up allows this to happen more condusively. It doesnt mean you cannot lye down. Its like siting up while your food digests, its a little better for your body. It does not mean you wont digest lying down. Sri Sri is articulating this for unconscious people to run rampant and spean against Sadhguru to state he isnt legitimate. Sri Sri either say Sadhguru is not legitimate or just cut your nonesense.

@VishnuNataraj Ай бұрын

If you can't accept contradiction you can't perceive truth brother...look at bhagavat Geeta every chapter is contradictory to each other..!!! Master has their own ways of guiding their desciples each might be contradictory to each other. That's their game please don't end up in rage or false conclusion

@TwistedReality108 Ай бұрын

Great research and video 🙏

@phanindrapalagummi6142 Ай бұрын

nice... "instead of becoming educated, i choose enlightenment" tight answer to who puts knowledge in front end than experience

@nithinkshetriya6095 Ай бұрын

according to me ,both sadguru and sri sri answers are correct in their own way

@gopatopa Ай бұрын

Sadhguru is an enlightened being,while Sri Sri Is a religious scholar..One talks from inner experience while the other relies on books and scriptures.

@VishnuNataraj Ай бұрын

Don't judge thinks that you have no idea about

@MyBharatMahan Ай бұрын

It takes some intelligence to understand the deep insights shared by Sadhguru. It’s not for all, most of the people misunderstand and criticize negatively just for the sake of criticizing. It just shows their level of intelligence, let’s ignore and move on

@benjamindsouza6736 Ай бұрын

....and it takes wisdom to understand the insights of Sri Sri who has the scriptures & not his spine to back whatever he says!

@online_study_best_plus 25 күн бұрын

None can compete with sadguru when it comes to the truth, rationality, wisdom and oratory skills . How people like nashedi (AP) , RAVISHANKAR CAN be called spiritual leader when one can see jealousy in their content against sadguru.

@yagneshdixit3875 Ай бұрын

Well, both are doing their business, and we should not poke our nose in others business. :) :) Still, what Sri Sri is saying is according to our hindu shashtra. No where in our shashtra it is mentioned that Shiva was born or shiva died. Shiva is eternal which has no birth and no dead. And I think person creating this video is trying to get youtube view and comments to fill his pockets.

@necrocraftronix5522 Ай бұрын

Sadhguru is Enlightened 🙏🙏

@shrenujjain2213 Ай бұрын

Where were these enlightened beings hiding during Covid? Their inner engineering disappeared that time?

@necrocraftronix5522 Ай бұрын

@ Let me guess, you think that being Enlightened means being a magician that can walk on water, but no. Enlightenment is possible for everyone and just means that you have realised the self. They are still humans and can make mistakes.

@Meaninglesslife-u7x Ай бұрын

@@necrocraftronix5522 After realising the self, do you return to your old petty ways? Is there any self, does it exist or is it just a concept of the mind? Just asking..

@ananda118 Ай бұрын

SADHGURU IS THE NEW AGE GURU FULL OF WISDOM AND PEOPLE LOVE AND RESPECT HIM 🙏🕉🇮🇳

@benjamindsouza6736 Ай бұрын

I'd rather trust the gurus who have their experiences backed by the scriptures, which are the insights & experiences of countless sages, than any so called new age guru who only has the promptings of his spine to support whatever he says!

@Jeyakumar-hs9zr Ай бұрын

@@benjamindsouza6736 Reading scriptures is not going to prompt your spine. Then what use it is?

@sabinagraf6041 Ай бұрын

thank you so much for your thoughtful comment! it's also a way of peace work! thank you!

@dustinnorcross1604 Ай бұрын

I was a man full of light, I met a witch, which changed a life. I changed to show a different side, dark and on, shining bright.

@parimalaparashuramvidyalay7019 Ай бұрын

Adi Guru .. At the start of A Yuga or even we can take at the start of Mahayuge. Anadi Yogi... Beginingless, infinity back... 1. The supreme lord Brahman is Adiyogi because he guided humanity at the start of Mahayuge or Yuga. 2. He is Anadi Yogi.. because he is begining less. Normally Adiyogi is used for meditation because he brought it to mankind of this Mahayuga or Yuga. We Vaishnavas beleive Lord Vishnu is beginingless.( Refer to Vishnu Sahasranama) He is Anadi Yogi.. While lord took the Avatara as Sri Badarayana( Vyasa Maharshi) and segregated Vedas in to four. Created Puranas, Mahabharat and Ultimate BRAHMA SUTRAS for the mankind of this Kaliyug. Thus Lord Vishnu is Anadi Yogi as well as Adiyogi. Shaivas beleive in the same analogy that Sri Shiva is Anadi Yogi as well as Adiyogi. ( Mahayuge means Kruta, Treta, Dwapara and Kaliyug. Where as yug means only one among above four. ) Both the Gurujis Pravachanas are in accordance with Yuga and Maha Yuga meanings. We should enjoy sayings of great Gurus Gurus and our selves should study ADWAITA and DWAITA PHILOSOPHY with equal dedication to enjoy within... Hare Krishna Parashuram

@maitreyabadra2267 Ай бұрын

They both are right in their own domain!... Each 'man is an island' that includes the waters that separate and unite them in the same time... 🙏

@rameshkanagalsrinivasamurt9183 Ай бұрын

Cannot understand as to why Sri Sri chose to contradict Sadhguruji

@manjirichitnis5551 Ай бұрын

Sadhguru has clearly said why He is called Aadiyogi. It's not right to prove Sadhguru wrong by another Guru. Sadhguru has never done this. Whatever people may say we are true followers of Sadhguru n such criticism doesn't affect us. Just that this is not expected fro. Sri Sri. Just because somevrandom person wrongly accuses Sadhguru, others don't have to join hands with them.

@laxmi994 28 күн бұрын

Gurudev Sri Sri explained that in different context. He didn't oppose or contradict Sadhguru actually. Infact it's the Isha followers itself who are posting these kind of comparing videos unnecessary. Other wiser comments under this video may help you understand better.. Peace✌🏻

@Kumar-xj7zh Ай бұрын

Beautifully and accurately said Anna. Very mature and clear. It’s true that Sadhguru is reaching more people every day, and perhaps that’s why we’re seeing more fake news and media attacks on Isha nowadays. I am one of the many whose lives have been transformed by Isha. Truth always prevails.

@ratulnandi508 Ай бұрын

SHIV & SHANKAR 🙏

@gopinathsubbegowda7184 Ай бұрын

Namaskaram, Very fitting communication to the ways of ISHA ...and Sadhguru. Thank you so much for this video ! As you said, I equally respect Sri Sri Gurudev! for his work and contributions to the soceity. It is important that the middle men (supporting teams) have sense of the objective that the both great Gurus are aiming ! Thanks again.

@santhoshrollsel7402 Ай бұрын

Sadhguru always kept saying and clear, Shiva is the very source of creation or loosely space or may be dark energy or dark matter Adi yogi is a guru who first showed humans that thr's a way transcend bodily limitations

@benjamindsouza6736 Ай бұрын

Dark energy & dark matter are but aspects of the Universe & not the totality of Shiva!

@alokjaiswal1745 Ай бұрын

Whats the point of argument, here both are going through different methodology And obviously their disciples will see it as a contradiction, so they just say it to keep up with the mythology Different methodologies work for different people. And remember there is nothing as absoluteness in the path..only non-absoluteness is the only absoluteness. All paths lead to the same ultimate goal शून्य. It is foolish to get into such arguments

@jaykumardharmaraj Ай бұрын

I opine Shri Shri guruji's words that if there is an Aadhi- there should be an End also. This is proved by Lord Shiva's challenge to both Lord Brahma and to Lord Vishnu- both were told to find the top and bottom(Head to feet). Lord Brahma with the help of his vahana- the Swan flew high and high to see Lord Siva's head. Lord Vishnu took the Avtar of a wild boar and dug into the Earth as much as he could. Unable to proceed further, Lord Brahma happened to see a petal of ( I have forgotten the name of the particular flower,, but it also lied along with Lord Brahma, and hence it is banned to decorate Shiva's idol) and there is no separate Temple for Lord Brahma. Lord Vishnu returned accepting that He could not find Lord Shiva's feet. So, this is my answer to Shri Shri Guru ji. The same was sung by Vallalar as -ஆதி அந்தம் இல்லா அருள் ஜோதியே ஆண்டவனே எமையே காத்தருள்வாயே .

@KiranAli-u8x Ай бұрын

That’s why In Sufism they say to take one teacher & follow his path. Some Sufi orders even forbid taking more than one path while others allow it. The reason being that every spiritual guide has his/her own way & that is the right way because ultimately there is no one right or wrong way. That is why every religion is different than others. Because we need to fundamentally understand that spirituality is not logical, it's not science or math or programming that needs to be consistent, it's more like art & literature, it relates deeply to your inner core & it's very subjective, in Sufism they have 30 different Sufi orders & each order has its own ritual's & methods of practicing, some work with breath, others work with chanting, others do ecstatic dancing & Zikr Circles. Each has its own custom's & unique traditions yet all lead to the same place. It's also true for the rest of spirituality, one group thinks that you can reach divinity through sex, other thinks that abstenance from sex leads to the purification of body which is essential for experiencing divinity, some encourage indulgence others encourage abstinence. It apparently sounds very contradictory if you think about it logically but when you look it more like an art rather than science, then you understand that there is no right or wrong Art because art by it's very nature is subjective. Similarly, there is no right & wrong spirituality because it's also highly subjective by its nature, that's why so many prophets & saints came each with his own unique path.

@shridharshetty8663 Ай бұрын

All Sanathana followers should be united

@isanasooraj Ай бұрын

Staying awake during shivratri is a custom that has been following for centuries. In Kerala people use “shivratri” for sleepless nights as a phrase. But at the same time I believe shiva is some one who has no origin and end “Aadyantha rahitha”

@anniesnowriversea Ай бұрын

It's the first time it made sense, bless Sadguru.❤❤❤ Enriched

@shreyasaha2891 Ай бұрын

Shiva is the ultimate. Though everyone's path is different. We should not fight among ourselves. Let's respect both the Gurus and move on the path of truth.

@robertbrooks6167 7 күн бұрын

The All (also called The One, The Absolute, The Great One, The Creator, The Supreme Mind, The Supreme Good, The Father, The Universal Mother and The Nameless) The All is All - The All is Mind - As it is Above - It is Below - We create the Universe in Our Minds - "The All is Mind; the Universe is Mental "

@rockykumarverma980 Ай бұрын

We should not spread such conflict .... Everyone has there own way of looking the same thing so instead of saying anyone wrong we should follow one path and experience it before passing any comments.... Shambho 🙏🙏🙏

@shrenujjain2213 Ай бұрын

Where were these enlightened beings hiding during Covid? Their inner engineering disappeared that time?

@sphinx4783 Ай бұрын

I did Inner Engineering on line during COVID...... sitting in the Caribbean 😊😊

@tensazangestu Ай бұрын

Isha foundation was actively engaged in providing covid kits and conducting online programs for frontline workers and providing free meals for rural people. Sadhguru was holding daily online sathsang for an extended period of many months to providing wisdom, yogic practices and extolling responsible behaviour among people to practise social distancing. Inner Engineering was available on online platforms so people arent at risk. So yeah, this enlightened being wasn't "hiding" and inner engineering hadn't disappeared.