Judging and Grading every Fitness Channel (Ⅰ: Greg Doucette, AlphaDestiny, Ryan Humiston...)

[@NaturalHypertrophy]

2 corrections: 1: Greg Doucette's God complex score is 2, not 8, making his total grade go from 106.5 to 100.5. 2: Buff Dudes' total grade is 137, which I forgot to mention before the transition.

[@CFC.NobarR]

I think black pill and parasocial relationships for greg should be 0.

[@chrisstanley9477]

Day 29 of asking NH to do a livestream for the next fake merc character study to celebrate his comeback. #ReleaseTheLiveMents #ReleaseTheMercGameLive

[@nicholasingratta423]

Throw in Jeremy either and Steve Shaw next time oh and mind pump they rule !

[@superyan4100]

Natural Gallant and Scooby please!

[@amongus2908]

Love this video, but I think for Sean's humour score, he does have some comedic content, like his vshred videos. But still, I agree most of his content is not exactly comedic

[@AlexLeonidas]

Interesting grading criteria, gets you thinking about the fitness community as a whole and what impactful content creation is all about. I appreciate your honest review.

[@arcaneknight9799]

Alex, thanks.

[@MentalGains]

@@arcaneknight9799 Arcane, thanks.

[@wyattcote4700]

@@MentalGains Mental, thanks.

[@Chicken_m4n]

@@wyattcote4700 Waytt thanks

[@Taps2121]

@@Chicken_m4n Key, thanks.

[@GVS]

**runs to grab popcorn**

[@JivecattheMagnificent]

Here you go, my dude. 🍿🍿🍿🍿

[@GVS]

@@JivecattheMagnificent **nom nom nom**

[@mickeychan2223]

So Sad that you are not on the list!!!!

[@GVS]

@@mickeychan2223 I think the "Ⅰ" means it's a series.

[@TedwardUltimate]

*popcorn eating intensifies*

[@fakestradio4741]

Someone needs to make a ranking system on NH’s haircuts

[@someone-oe1mo]

For sure I personally like his messy hair because I also have messy unkempt hair

[@GutsAndGlory734]

Lol the Ello Yuchube channel needs to make a ranking system of NH hairstyles

[@bigsmokenoextradip7705]

@@GutsAndGlory734 yep

[@chrisstanley9477]

Day 29 of asking NH to do a livestream for the next fake merc character study to celebrate his comeback. #ReleaseTheLiveMents #ReleaseTheMercGameLive

[@someone-oe1mo]

@@chrisstanley9477 tf does this have to do with the comment

[@suron9135]

cannot wait for part 2: Please include Jeff Nippard and Rennaissance Periodization in that one.

[@FitLabb]

Jeff Nippard is the best in the biz as far as I’m concerned. Follows the science, he has about as much honesty & integrity as anyone can have, has tremendous knowledge & experience, & is just a great guy.

[@someone-oe1mo]

Also Geoffrey and rerival fitness

[@cesare4214]

@@FitLabb Jepp Nippard is a fake natty, hiding behind his "sience" bullshit. If you're enhanced atleast be honest about it.

[@Lb-ri5wr]

@@FitLabb except he thinks eggs, cheese and red meat are are healthy, making him unwatchable

[@spandyspandanbaral717]

@@Lb-ri5wr Because those are actually healthy

[@Pedro_Le_Chef]

53:04 Jasmine Blowhole stubs his toe on furniture, alerting the Frenchman to his presence. Another failed operation, he retreats and goes back to the drawing board, biding his time. 54:56 Retreat operation codename "exodus" did not go smoothly. Agent's forehead hit the doorknob and he collapsed into a fetal position for five seconds. A a more accurate blueprint of the house is a requirement for next operation.

[@smartsimplefit]

Jason’s .308 rifle will go through any necessary dry wall in order to take out NH

[@Pedro_Le_Chef]

@@smartsimplefit Dry wall? You think NH doesn't already know this? The insides of his walls are filled with failed bodybuilding programs. No kind of caliber is capable enough of getting past the sheer volume of garbage programs fitted inside NH's walls.

[@Theendoftimekaliyuga]

I don't even understand these jokes I mean the dude could take NH out with a telepathic attack from his home, ha the fact it hasn't happend shows that reptilian lord bloho is merciful

[@fatcat22able]

Can’t wait to see Jason Blahino graded in the next video!!

[@smartsimplefit]

250 easy

[@blahasdirtysock3657]

Jason is the heir to Louie Simmons guise

[@panzershreks3811]

Hope to see NH rate himself in part 2. Would be interesting to view how he perceives his own channel and content

[@matriaxpunk]

This

[@CeltyST96]

that wouldnt make sense, he always talks about objectivity and subjectivity, if he would rank himself for example for programming he must give himself a 10/10 because he wouldnt run the program if he didnt believe it is the best for him. So it always is his subjective view.

[@matriaxpunk]

@@CeltyST96 ok, so he would get a 10 in that one, so what, that's only one parameter.

[@CeltyST96]

@@matriaxpunk he cant rank himself at all. He needs to let go of his own subjectivity and see himself through the lense of his subjective audience view. The whole Criteria system is not objective at all, firstly its based on the things he thinks is the most important, so obviously he scores higher on his scale beacuse it is made out of his own standpoint. which is fine, but would make the whole system fall if he would rank himself. He doesnt know any of these people personally as much as he knows himself, saying he ranks someone based on the habit of promoting supps while he doesnt do it is just his own criteria, most mainstream fitness channel think its part of the game or even useful to a certain point. so it becomes completely pointless of him ranking himself to his own morality.

[@matriaxpunk]

@@CeltyST96 I disagree, those standards are ideals to strive for, he doesn't need to be living fully according with those standards. So he could perfectly subjectively judge how much is he living according with those standards and parameters that he himself has set. Is the same thing as when you are judging your own physique, you judge it comparing it with an ideal physique that you have subjectively chosen but that you don't have achived yet, so you can determine how far or how close your actual physique is from that ideal.

[@highsol222]

Sean is the only guy I trust at this point. Everyone else seems to always get SOMETHING wrong. No Greg! I will not eat fake foods to lose weight just because they "taste good.."

[@KS-MDCCLXXVI]

Damn less than a 75% for alphadestiny? I'm glad I never had to submit a paper to this guy

[@kevinflores3141]

Lol

[@derbistheeternal2947]

Fax. Harsh asf

[@2caiden4u]

Fr lmao

[@davidmccright3764]

Let’s see Scooby1961. He basically taught me everything when I started lifting in 2008, for better or worse. But he was the only channel I found value in at the time

[@TheSuperMerc]

I second this.

[@Mikeystonet]

He definitely laid the foundation of fitness for me!

[@pierofasulli1076]

fake natty fraud

[@zenon652]

Skateboard squats...

[@ssdabel]

ahah the remark about Omar's comment section is 100% on point

[@someone-oe1mo]

Therapist:NH with straight hair isn't real he can't hurt you NH with straight hair:

[@lesegoshibambo1994]

Dude! Great video! Here are some of my suggestions: 1. Mark Bell 2. RedDelta Project 3. Calisthenics FAQ 4. Peter Khatcherian 5. Broly Gains / Goku Pump

[@lucasoscar]

Insta-liked just for the Saiki thumbnail. Ps im curious about Will Tennyson and Jeff Cavalieri

[@dariolance7637]

Your humor keeps catching me off guard. Alex should have gotten more points for his physique and Omar a bit less in my opinion. Also programming should be getting 20 points in my opinion. Otherwise it seems fair. Very entertaining as usual.

[@loovlehcuppatea2830]

Will say Sean's shorts channel where he does skits is pretty funny

[@smartsimplefit]

Part 2 or 3 ideas: GVS, Bald Omni Man, Scott Herman, Brendan Tietz, Fitness FAQs, Steve Shaw

[@Lb-ri5wr]

this was a good video, if you do any more of these some suggestions would be scott herman, mike isreatel, brenden tietz (more of a powerlifter/bodybuilder) and of course athlene x lol (also it's only fair that you grade yourself too)

[@123onepiecefan]

Great video as always. Please do Jeff Nippard, Bald Omni Man and Athlean X next time

[@nanomaster4497]

I would love to see you review Alan Thrall, jeff nippard and Ivan Djuric (squat everyday guy)

[@C-OBrien]

I would love to see another with guys like Jeff Nippard, Renaissance Periodisation, Alexander Bromley, Johnny Candito and Matt Vena, some of the best imo

[@Croissantrophy.meme.channel]

You should grade "Ello Yuchub" channel

[@kemptonbryan]

I think the grading scale needs an update. The worst channels here received ~50% and the best channels received ~72.5%. Once this series is being wrapped up you must standardize the scores along a bell curve.

[@tuukkai1841]

It is a necessity to include BroScienceLife in the next instalment

[@SuperTank121212]

About to start my Sunday deep clean, headphones in and let's go 🛫

[@Tom-tw1wd]

New haircut looks sick pal, looking like a king frog now

[@simondehaas6460]

Excited to get to know some new channels through here!

[@thedavidji]

PART I Alphadestiny: 146 Greg Doucette: 100.5 Buff Dudes: 137 Sean Nalewanyj: 148.5 Omar Isuf: 143 Ryan Humiston: 105 PART II Shredded Sports Science: 137 Musclemonsters: 123 Jeff Nippard: 150.5 Geoffrey Verity Schofield: 147.5 CT Fletcher: 121.5 Eric Bugenhagen: 133 PART III Steve Shaw: 130 Kinobody: 116 Natural Hypertrophy: 143 Scott Herman: 144.5 Team3DAlpha: 134 AthleanX: 104

[@wavetime3651]

I didn’t know I needed this, please post more in the future

[@KidMangaX]

How is AthleanX not on this list? His channel is enormous.

[@CorvetteBro]

Just the name of his channel and what he is known for makes him a well known meathead.

[@JivecattheMagnificent]

Hahah, now, I have a funny feeling that Buff Dudes aren't going to have a great score. Was kind of surprised to see them in the lineup, to be honest hahah. I feel like Alex, Sean and Omar are the ones to follow, here (for me, at least).

[@PauIdenino]

Agreed

[@StrongandConditioned]

You pop up everywhere Jive 😂

[@rickythericky2267]

Do natural gallant bodybuilding. Guy has a ton of experience, is funny and has an amazing physique and unique opinions to say

[@Firm-Tofu-King]

Renaissance periodization is the best objectively

[@stubdto2479]

Could you do a Legends of the Past on Serge Nubret? He's my personal GOAT bodybuilder and undeniably has one of the best physiques of all time. Have heard you speak highly of him before and would like to learn about his life and bodybuilding methods in more detail, especially from you

[@Croissantrophy.meme.channel]

Greg, integrity: zeeroo 🤣

[@gabrielatto1741]

Loving the new haircut :)

[@Protein-Man]

Fresh haircut Mr.Baguette

[@altj5684]

I like your cut g

[@Croissantrophy.meme.channel]

53:04 Blubla has found your location 54:56 😥

[@FinC1_]

Love to see your opinion on K Boges. He's definitely got an interesting take on calisthenics/weighted calisthenics

[@Pedro_Le_Chef]

How come you didn't use weighted criteria? Such as a 10/10 in programming giving more value than a 10/10 in humor. It seems strange to regard all criteria of equal importance.

[@wakawaka1976]

It’s like a video game… imagine the different builds in Dark Souls. Yes some mean a lot more than others but different skills have different worth to different people. Some people just want to be entertained while others just want the science and yet others need both. Lots of noobs love Greg D and aren’t that serious about lifting. Lots of guys think NH has no personality and is boring. Different strokes for different folks.

[@DeZeRsZGmd]

Part 2 next please

[@Abdo.R.Mohamed]

i Actually don't agree with Greg's usefulness being an 8 , i would give it a 4 max .. u can literally sum the channel up in 3 sentences that he just repeats over and over again and nothing new : for losing weight : "calories in Vs Calories out" , "Low calorie dense food" . for training : "train harder than last time" all 3 of them are true yes .. but still its super generalist without any nuances and u just outgrow it REALLY fast , i don't thing u can learn anything from him past the Early Novice stage .. not even late novice !

[@johannduplessis3467]

Yeah totally agree. I posted a pretty similar comment as well about the recycling where NH gave him an 8 but his channel is so repetitive

[@Abdo.R.Mohamed]

@@iangraham-white5717 thats why i said its super generalist advice with no nuances whatsoever .. Its basically a catch phrase for (Progressive overload) but without any method or plan

[@loovlehcuppatea2830]

Would love to see u cover Eric bugenhagen as well as Steve Shaw

[@unholydiver1095]

Feel Sean's entertainment and humor is made up for with the shorts he made. Actually surprised me he can be that funny given his serious approach in his made channel

[@MrTVx99]

Great video with a complex grading system but I disagree that all your 20 factors be weighted equally. Why humour and programming are graded the same, I don't understand. I feel like there should be tiers to this and the important factors are graded with more points. Also why do people on drugs get high points for physique? That should automatically be a deduction if what you are trying to promote is natural bodybuilding. Telling naturals that Greg's physique is better than that of Alpha Destiny when it's made with drugs is an automatic no no. Putting them on the same scale is just not okay. Is Alpha Destiny 7.5/10 out of naturals, sure. At the time of making the video that is fair. Where did the 9.5/10 for Greg come from? 9.5/10 compared to who? For a natural, it's a 0/10 because it's 100% unattainable. All it does is make the blackpilled teens on his channel to get on drugs or give up entirely. For a guy on drugs, it's a 7/10 because there are way bigger monsters than him. Maybe you're trying to be as pragmatic as possible but then you deducted points on his experience as well for being on drugs so you can't really use that argument. Also not sure how someone can grade high in Usefullness when they are graded bottom of the barrell in Integrity and Blackpill as well as Para social relationships (Greg). I mean what are they useful in? Creating a hivemind of blackpilled teens who will buy all his programs and jump on drugs with no ability to think for themselves? These are not the type of people we need to create. Greg has useful videos but you are looking at 1% of his content, most of his content is the same recycled garbage info, with a new thumbnail and title as a way to sell his supplements and programs. His content is extremely recycled and just because it has new makeup each time, it doesn't change the face. So the recycled content grade should never be 8 either.

[@lukaposeidon8490]

Woooah slow it down there Clark Kent

[@SeekAStrak]

"He sounds like a parrot." 😂😂😂

[@Lucaslf2_]

You really don't run out of ideas, huh. Good stuff

[@Simba257-o4k]

Grade our boy Bloheezy hemingway

[@algorerhyth]

your review of Greg is hilarious

[@boyka1408]

Love the shirt NH !

[@origamiscotty]

nice haircut NH

[@madhavgopakumar8597]

Would like you to grade Zack Telander

[@himurakenshin8541]

Will there be a part 2 with Vitruvian Physique, Jeff Nippard, etc?

[@boktorinator693]

Can you please review Vitruvian Physique?

[@20timesshoota27]

do blaha next XDDDDDDD

[@lastknownnatty]

Great video. Breastmode jones? Please and thank you. Great content.

[@timammann]

This is random but NH you should make a video about some of the clothes you have, you often wear sick shirts/hoodies

[@ajaxmaxxer]

Do you have any advice for lifting / dieting during ramadan fasting ?

[@peppyhydra4544]

I remember your old video about pointers on what makes a channel worth my attention or not, but I guess spoonfeeding us is good too? Lol

[@hunterofexoticgame4208]

You should judge More plates more dates

[@ScEscapism]

I really enjoyed this video and i'd argue all fair assessments

[@LiverpoolfanINchina]

Do fazlifts. Small channel but pretty good info

[@slushyslushy7777]

What are your opinions on the bioneer?

[@user-sr7wy7wz9x]

That haircut is a 10 out of 10 for sure

[@papluab]

You have both positive and negative metrics as criteria. While calculating the net sum, would you not subtract the negative ones and add only the positives?

[@eritreanblackpanther7946]

so for dogmatism for example, if the person is not dogmatic, he gives a high grade. So he kind of redefine the grading to take that into account

[@lukino666]

This should be a series lol

[@basedabdu8653]

Greg got too high of a rating

[@carlicbread8199]

Ah thank you for uploading, saved my arm day. Screw content about making a nice body you need to make a video about hair

[@Croissantrophy.meme.channel]

Natural Hairpertrophy

[@lucasgraeff5391]

Sean Nalewanyj is quite funny on shorts and reels. Isn't this part of his channel?

[@onetwo8847]

37:19 IMO this was the least accurate score in this entire series. I'm not expecting veteran stand-up comedian level humour from any lifter... but Sean's YT shorts channel is easily some of the more consistently funny stuff coming out of the YT lifting community. Even if it's not for you, he does a solid enough job for at least twice that score given what other people receieved

[@leojamesfitness6031]

Sean's been an outstanding help on demystifying bullshit claims about supplements

[@Croissantrophy.meme.channel]

26:04 that was cold

[@Blizzarddz]

I believe, atleast nowadays that Alex does have more original content than some

[@mustafakamaran5195]

Sean nal humor 3? You must have not watched his reels/shorts theyre hilarious!

[@gabrielchambers22]

new drip AND new haircut :0

[@angrygoldfish]

Bro... did you comb your hair...???

[@rad_98]

Sean's cherry pie. 😋

[@jms0313]

Starting Strength?

[@andy3410]

Do knees over toes guy

[@XsenceTWJ]

The rare time when NH style his hair up

[@adonizi]

MPMD is like Greg but worse in every way.

[@whitefang9758]

*better

[@OMAR-vk9pi]

What? Lol

[@spbspb2413]

@@OMAR-vk9pi MPMD tries to sell you a shitton of stuff but at the same time he also educates his audience on how to do steroid cycles.

[@adonizi]

@@iangraham-white5717 Not only does he romanticize steroids. He promotes and sells them through his "trt clinic". Most of his videos blatantly prey on young mens insecurities. Videos like "why hes jacked and ripped, but youre not" answer being steroids, trt more spesifically. "Oh, did you know i happen to own a trt clinic link in the bio". Some people see these videos as educational, but i certainly dont.

[@yousefahmad538]

Do brian alsruhe

[@Bdjakcian]

Get a fade bro 😭😭

[@shaunlyne6048]

Please do Ivan Djuric in part 2!

[@Alanoo]

Yo NH, kind of a unique situation here This has nothing to do with the video But i am currently 16, training for 1.5 years so far and my legs are 26 inches... from my understanding that is an insane measurement, and it reflects in my inability to fit into literally any jeans Do you think i have the potential to build 30 inch legs naturally? Keep in mind i only squat 225 for sets/reps right now

[@frederickstudenheimer3378]

yes just squat narrow stance a lot

[@Nick-wx3nm]

The Bioneer and Bald Omni Man would be interesting channels to cover later in this series

[@GB-ld6lf]

Only 3 for Sean’s humor? His shorts are quite funny

[@C-OBrien]

Didn’t include Grizzly so it would be fair on everyone

[@mohammadjalloul9026]

Nice haircut bro

[@SuperTank121212]

What would you grade yourself NH?

[@PranjayVarshney]

12:30 looks like you haven't watched his podcast with jeff nippard. He farted on livestream which was very funny imo

[@Firm-Tofu-King]

Rich Piana?

[@user-wo5tc9ux7u]

what about mpmd

[@jasonn_lifts]

Renaissance Periodization 10/10🙏

[@wooshbr758]

I love Dr Mike but tbh RP has it's problems

[@CnSaliba]

no

[@XpertPetar]

Nice haircut

[@dicknuggetsvajsteak2551]

Nice hair 2day

[@franciscvmpbell]

Sean N’s humour is underrated. On his main channel, yeah, it’s very plain, but his shorts are hilarious.

[@formersperg5288]

Yh Sean will be really serious and all of a sudden he cracks a joke with a straight face that's really funny