A (Brief) History of Brain Sciences

[@NanoWaver]

Thanks a lot Ryan for supporting this channel

[@nessidoe8080]

🙌 Hooray for Ryan! 🧠👍🏽

[@AaronQuitta]

Great video! Thank you to Ryan!

[@ernestopreciado4895]

Thank you so much for this! :) As a philosophy and now also neuroscience student and history of science enthusiast this has all I would've ask to be in a perfect video. Definitely buying your book soon.

[@Fjado]

Let me know if you need a kidney, Ryan

[@Cognic]

Very interesting video! I did a whole playlist of videos on the history of Neuroscience but you guys summed it up in one video! PS: I'm really enjoying reading your book!

[@NicoAssaf]

It'd be sooo cool if you made a video on neurophilosophy and the different views on the consciousness debate (dualism, identity theories, idealism, mysterianism, even panpsychism). I know that that's kind of pushing the boundaries of your channel, but that's exactly the kind of content that the brain sciences need! When it comes to the hard problem of consciousness, collaboration between philosophy and science couldn't be more of a pressing issue. You tackling the topic would be perfect.

[@Blabbermouth-w5w]

Disagree: at least until the general field of philosophy isn't dominated by white men and I start seeing non white males regularly find their way into my world of philosophical experience.

[@NicoAssaf]

@@Blabbermouth-w5w It's a shame that you would rather not consume quality content based on the source's race, but I'd wager most people have no problem with studying white philosophers as long as the arguments are thought provoking. And this is coming from a Latino. Also, they could easily talk about, for example, Susan Blackmore's insights into consciousness, so I don't see why a video on the topic would necessarily not be diverse, especially coming from a channel that's proven to be very open to counterculture.

[@adamabraham2537]

This channel is a gold mine.

[@yana.mp4]

Interesting topic! I'm really interested in multidisciplinary approaches to psychology - integrating neuroscience and biology to understand ourselves a bit more :) theres some really interesting research looking at the microbiome and how that may be linked to depression and anxiety

[@shripradabhuvankar776]

Thank you, Ryan!👍

[@teteraf]

The difference between neuroscience and psychology looks analogous to the physics-chemistry divide. The analogy breaks at the mind/soul mystery.

[@Panckeswitcheese]

I don’t really understand this comment because I don’t understand what analogous means but I’m upvoting it because it sounds very interesting 🤔

[@pifre3051]

@@Panckeswitcheese Very much me also

[@gms9608]

@@Panckeswitcheese analogous = similar

[@andresgonzalez-gm5ry]

I just discovered this gem of a channel. Suscribed!

[@alguienjuandelpueblo5630]

I was just thinking about this topic recently. Great Work! But there was no mention of trepanation, the first surgical practice used since ancient times to treat traumatic brain injury, headaches, epilepsy, and mental disorders. The fact that trepanning was common in primitive society to treat behavioral disorders (spiritual possessions, as they called them) is evidence that people knew that somehow the brain was responsible for producing behavior. This practice was common since Neolithic times in Europe, Siberia, China, and the Americas. I know the history is a bit problematic since it gave rise to the practice of lobotomy, yet it is an important piece of history nonetheless.

[@neurotransmissions]

You're right that it's absolutely an important piece of history! We talk about it in our book, along with a looooot of other things. It's hard when you're trying to fit in a lot of history into one video. Unfortunately, trepanning was cut for time, but it honestly could be its own video in the future. Keep your eyes peeled!

[@chat-arina]

I live in a university town in Sweden and one way the students, and others, get “test subjects” is by offering money, if it concerns medical studies where the subject gets something extracted or injected to their body or if it’s something that the subject have to do over a longer period of time. Almost everyone else in other studies gets offered movie tickets, through cooperation with the university and the largest movie theatre chain in the country. Most who apply are still young people, most of them white. Unless the students, or other, actively search for other subjects, which takes more time.

[@radhikashingwekar90]

According to me, neuroscience is the hardware, and psychology is the software. Neither can function properly without the other

[@leahalfonso7256]

Every time I watch a video about the history of any study it makes me so sad to think of everything lost in the library of Alexandria.

[@hellogtea]

Humanity held back by 1000 years

[@njchannel8013]

neuroscience knows our behaviour starts in the brain and our behaviour affects the brain. brain is a source of ourselves. anything is in the brain. psychology is a broader disciplines, attempts to prove several social concepts like gender, culture, behaviour mechanism without looking into brain. the fact people behave certain way, have certain sexual attractions etc. its all has a source in the brain. neuroscience is narrower but it nails it. neuroscience wins. neuroscience is a science, psychology wannnabe science.

[@MintySomething]

Thanks Ryan!

[@mbeware]

Thanks Ryan!!

[@eddie1975utube]

You guys are wonderful communicators. Subscribed!

[@yanca6830]

wow this is quality content

[@ellalia354]

Thanks Ryan!!!!

[@MrAlemao]

Thanks Ryan

[@tarickw]

The cat is definitely the star of the video

[@neurotransmissions]

Loki sure does like being the center of attention.

[@melissapether8611]

Thank you, Ryan! :)

[@whattheycantteach5064]

thanks ryan!!

[@bianka94825]

Im totally partial between the two sciences as a neuropsychologist😎😁

[@armordcrab]

Pogchamp:Ryan

[@expeditionindieforschung8380]

Thanks Ryan! About the problem with using psychology students: funny enough, most psych students at my uni were women. Like, 99%.

[@WGSMRW]

Thank you Ryan!!!

[@curiousnervecell9579]

Thanks, Ryan!

[@simondcruz4719]

I’ll donate my brain Ryan!

[@rachelf6745]

thanks ryan

[@hridessapkota]

Yayy the video is up finally 😍

[@neurotransmissions]

Thanks for watching the streams! I hope you like it!

[@imtiazchoudhary3976]

Thanks ryan ❤️

[@payrimdwein9082]

1:10 split into neuroscience and psychology? isn't psychology just coming up with theories by thinking (like psychoanalysis) which is kinda getting some kind of inner feeling and philosophizing about it, and neuroscience actually tries to look at the brain structure and define its parts? and then we can do data science on psychology, and data driven neuroscience, clearly data science is the win Micah

[@jpadma9]

Awesome video! ❤

[@Kenkire]

There is no "better". It's all together. My wife has a masters in Psychology. I Studied Sociology. I believe you can't have one without the other. You need all of these disciplines in order to help people.

[@rupambanerjee2066]

Nice video. But there is a whole different field of Indian Psychology. Please explore it.

[@Luna-wu4rf]

Thanks Ryan. Good job on having money

[@TheThreatenedSwan]

No mention of Galton, Fisher, Pearson, etc

[@alejandroa1st]

When will the book be available in Mexico?

[@kcr_army_666]

Good video 📹👍👌👏🙌😀

[@malimali6686]

Where can i get the book from Europe ?

[@neurotransmissions]

Great question. Depending on where you are in Europe, you can try online vendors like Amazon or go to your local book store and see if they can order a copy for you!

[@bianka94825]

Im from Hungary and I ordered it on Amazon😇highly recommend, it gives you an overall explanation on everything having to do w our brain in such a fun, digestible way. Love that its colorful and entertaining while delivering scientific info.

[@regalmedia9487]

can a person without a degree become a neuroscientist? can he start his lab or work in a lab as an employee?

[@rahmikarakadoglu5602]

automatic translation not working please take care

[@mark950-d7d]

Thank You Ryan Wasn't Descart a Gnostic?

[@umcanalsemfuturo3302]

Coloca as legendas em português (BR)

[@neurotransmissions]

Hello! I do not know Portuguese, so adding subtitles in that language would be very difficult. If you know someone who would be willing to translate it, we could send them the transcript.

[@leonardorubertmauer4975]

@@neurotransmissions hey, I can help translate your videos. How can I get into contact with you guys if you want the help?

[@avi12]

10:23-10:35 The audio became desynchronized from the video

[@neurotransmissions]

Good eye! I saw that after I uploaded it. Luckily it's a short clip and not horrible. Not sure what happened there. Maybe a cat bumped something while I was editing.

[@Kenkire]

6:52 Hi Loki

[@skeptik-ci5xo]

Cool shirt 😼

[@Ahrimanfr]

More like KrippaRyan, thx !

[@yjawhar]

The way I see it... Psychology is an abstraction of neuroscience.

[@avi12]

If "mind" exists in another realm of our body, how is DID a thing?

[@neurotransmissions]

I suppose the argument would be that all of those "minds" exist in another realm. Not saying I agree with it, but you could make an argument. On a related note, I'm also somewhat skeptical of DID as a diagnosis, but that's a personal issue.

[@LasseJ789]

Where's Donald O. Hebb and Brain Theory?

[@discon_csert]

I always thought neuroscience was like math. Certain things have specific functions and formulas. Psychology was like philosophy or art. Things *can be certain ways but not *always for every person or situation.

[@christophertylershort6183]

I love you guys and I don't want to be critical, you do you. Just my personal feedback though, it was odd to me that as 2 modern scientists, you gave so much credence to dualism. I'm not saying dualism is wrong, but it's like intelligent design, it's a valid philosophical argument but sort of outside the realm of science. Again, love your work though, and I'll keep enjoying your videos!

[@kutay8421]

Tyler you made an intelligent comment, but can I suggest my rejections to it to a some degree? Brain interpretation is how-many dimensional do you believe? Foe example if we think about the monetary system, it is one-dimensional: everything has a price, much or less. But knowledge can be interpreted and projected to quiet different domains and values. Duality is the magical eye-glass to spare us from the magnetic gravity of 1-dimensionality. Even if the dual is stupid and old fashioned. Don't you think? Over simplifying to century's norms is blunt or not?

[@leothecrafter4808]

4:20 Even worse, that looks like RPMI or DMEM, hopefully without cells.

[@lordsonspokenenglishacadem3898]

For your information, mind does not exist, it is brain and brain matters, thank you for ur time.

[@hellogtea]

Thanks 👍

[@phill6159]

The biggest question you won't ever try to answer is, does a human fetus have a form of consciousness.

[@Arunava_Gupta]

If by consciousness you mean subjective experience, then the answer would be, initially no. But when the conscious personality becomes connected to the brain, from that point on, it would be conscious.

[@kyledawson4535]

Actually best and brightest in the field would disagree. You view is very modern and his held by a loud minority that belivers fetuses are just a clump of cells that is expendable. ​@@Arunava_Gupta

[@michaeltiller782]

It’s crazy that a 24 year old could get dementia doctors proved it cerebral atrophy, enlarged ventricles, cavum septum pellucidum and depigmentation of the substantia nigra, with microscopic evidence of my brain scan showed all but was never warned you send someone out of icu in three days after being pronounced dead for 12 minutes you see all this damage to a child’s brain but failed to warn it’s crazy throughout all the years taking brain injuries since 7 would change but didn’t all most die from any of them then at 14 started taking chair shots Bobwire baseball bat shots to the head putting trough tables To me I had stage three cte and was never the same i Guess to get cte you must have a lot of head blows can’t get cte dementia from one brain injury people our dumb not to talk about someone’s condition

[@RafaelHA2010]

Good video but... u are rong... la psicología estudia la conducta o comportamiento, no la mente. Esto es porque "mente" todavía no es un constructo científico pero "conducta" si. La encargada de estudiar a la mente o psique es la filosofía. La neurociencia no estudia la "brain biology", estudia a las Neuronas que son la principal célula del cerebro. Para el estudio de la "biología del cerebro" existe la fisiología del Sistema Nervioso y para estudiar la fisiología o biologia del cerebro encargada de la conducta está la psicofisiología. Sin embargo la Psicología cognitiva es una transdiciplina que une a la neurociencia, la psicofisiología, la psicología en orden de estudiar los procesos cognitivos, y que también están asociados a nuestra conducta. and in places like México or India, there are More woman in psichology than men, that includes the population on the studies they do. Greettings from UNAM Facultad de Psicología CDMX.

[@nicc2366]

I have a mouth tic. Basically I move my jaw left and right. It’s SO annoying. Then i crack my fingers and move my neck. What should I do? Is there a way to completely remove it or I’ll stay like this for the rest of my life? I hope so and I hope this will work. Pls give me advice on what to do.

[@kkp2022]

Thank you Ryan!

[@zachwesterfield9066]

Thanks Ryan

[@mangolove5204]

Thanks Ryan!

[@esmeraldahechavarria5678]

thanks ryan

[@Nicholas2727]

Thanks Ryan!

[@chandaphillips1337]

Thanks Ryan!!

[@Mewzyque]

Thanks Ryan

[@Sigmaquandaleskibidi]

Thanks Ryan