New 2024 Indian Scout Bobber vs The Competition! (Harley, Triumph & BMW)

CARDO - the best comms units on the market! Use "MOTOBOB" to get 10% discount on their PACKTALK EDGE, FREECOM X and SPIRIT lines, and 15% off the PACKTALK BOLD and FREECOM+ lines:
motobob.cc/u/cardo
Also thanks to all of our other channel sponsors - you can find out more about each of them here!
CALIMOTO - the ultimate navigation app for bikers! Use the code "BOB30" for a 30-day free trial, or "BOB10" for 10% off a premium membership:
motobob.cc/u/calimoto
METZELER - the crème de la crème of motorcycle tyres. We've used their adventure-ready Karoos, mile-munching Tourances, sticky Sportecs and Ractecs, and the king of all-rounders, the Roadtecs. All of them get a huge thumbs up from us, so do check out their full lineup here:
motobob.cc/u/metzeler
SPEEDO ANGELS - keep your expensive-to-replace speedo clear of scratches and damage. Use "MOTOBOB20" for 20% off any product:
motobob.cc/u/speedoangels
QUAD LOCK - our #1 choice of motorcycle phone mount, well before they came on board as a sponsor. We love their top-drawer build quality, as well as their huge range of mounts, accessories and adapters that mean you can always find a setup to suit any bike. Use this link to get 10% off all products:
motobob.cc/u/quadlock
BEMOTO - excellent insurance cover with brilliant customer service. Quote "MOTOBOB" for free licence defence cover:
motobob.cc/u/bemoto
Want to be one of our sponsors? Email [e-mail]

[@triumphthunderbird1]

Triumph and Indian are the pick of this bunch for me.

[@winchester92stevebrook44]

I bought the Triumph, twin front discs/looks/solo riding only. However I also love the Indian, and would seriously consider the BMW.

[@MrEvhel83]

Indian looks like a real cruiser should! Beautiful bike!

[@dandelpozzo2121]

Ironically, I just sat on the R12 2 hours ago. I've ridden all but the R12, and even owned a Scout. As a shorter rider (5'5" with 29" inseam) I think other shorter riders won't care for the ergonomics of the R12. The seat and frame are quite wide at the stand-over point and the seat digs into my thighs. The width results in my heals being 1.5" off the ground. No flat footing this bike. I can flat foot the other 3 bikes. I would also say the R12 doesn't carry its weight as well as the other 3 bikes. The R12 feels heavier. Also, the upswept exhaust design on the left side of the R12 means no luggage on that side of the bike - very strange design. Also strange is the lack of a fuel gauge. My initial enthusiasm for the R12 has waned before even riding the bike.

[@CaptainAhnungslos]

Thank you for this insight. I'm 5'5" too and looking for strong bike for my short legs. The R12 was on my list. Now not anymore.

[@AndyPat239]

just to add, even for us shorter folk you can't stretch your legs out on the beemer..

[@glowingbunny5865]

Been to a funeral today and feeling down - but a cheery MotoBob upload salvages my day. Thank you Bob and team…👏

[@max8591]

Similar situation here... You're not alone... Hang in there!

[@glowingbunny5865]

@@max8591 Thank you and god bless…

[@user-gn1yg5pn4u]

Be well Sir

[@cowmath77]

7:35 I’m sorry, did you say $4,000 for a passenger seat and mount? What the actual phuck

[@iopusor]

He did. Its a third party making these that only sells heavily customized bikes and only works on new triumphs. Its insane price still tho.

[@ilikelampshades6]

Triumphs reliability would win it for me

[@domsbits3922]

Another aspect to add is SOUND. THE BOBBER WINS

[@NealosMetropolos]

106 Nm at just 4k rpm puts the Triumph engine as the best of this bunch. The Indian engine has always been gorgeous but with just one disc up front, both Americans are off my list.

[@marton_horvath]

I'm stuck on trying to compute the kind of savagery you need to pay 4000 GBP for that abysmal passenger seat on a bobber

[@hgurskov]

Wow you Brits get spoiled!.. the price for the Triumph is 28203 pound here in Denmark... but the best looking of the them imo

[@logangodofcandy]

Not being taxed to hell and back isn't luck.

[@MarkLAdkins01]

I have owned the Indian Scout Bobber and I own the Triumph Bobber as well. Both are wonderful bikes...loud and visually appealing. I would say, though, that the Triumph handles much better than the Indian and is a bit less stretched out - thus feeling more balanced. The Indian is a rough bike (literally...it is very rough feeling on the road any my spine agrees), but cool factor is extremely high. Though I do love them both, I would choose the Triumph overall above the Indian. Just my two cents!

[@gpjanke13]

Another great video. I would love a video to compare the new Scout to the RE Super Meteor to see if you believe the cost difference is worth what the Indian brings to the table.

[@raylocke282]

Genuine BMW for me,scratch out the counterfit " Polaris Indian " and your " Tea and Crumpits Trumpet !!

[@jasonkrumvieda1053]

Why the Nightster (975) and not the sportster S (1250) like the Scout?

[@CoberBox1]

For the bargain bobber you should have add the Guzzi V9 Bobber.

[@RickyG512]

Think you should of compared this against the Harley Softail Standard, not the nightster

[@-Tme]

I think you're spot on Bob. Objectively the BMW looks like the best bike of the bunch and I certainly prefer an upright riding posture, but if all four are in my garage I think the Triumph and the Indian are what I am taking out every time.

[@_ryukyuanhalfie_]

The Triumph & Indian hands down look the best IMO. I previously owned a 2019 Triumph Bobber, I miss that bike so much but sold it do to moving. I'll be picking up an Indian Scout Bobber in the near future because I need the option for a passenger seat.

[@Duckie313]

For me it was between the Indian and the Triumph Bobber, I ended up with the Bobber.

[@leonelbaldovinos8642]

Got the nightster as first bike what sold me was the service at the HD dealership honestly other dealers was like sit on the bike what do you think??? While HD it was try this models we got lets go for a ride what do you think?

[@spit421]

Cruise is Not standard on the R12 it’s part of the comfort pack at another £998, and you can spec flat bars. The pillion pack is £200 so over 14k in the end

[@a13bkd62]

Enjoyable review. I get your reasoning but for me, chain drive is not a positive so I'd place the others above the Trumpet. For me on styling and how it goes, the Indian wins. Cheers

[@BigMoeFo]

The Indian had 2 inches on the shocks. My spine says no. I can’t imagine that being a comfortable ride.

[@mithrandirthegrey7644]

The indian just looks the best... Curb appeal is big for me.

[@TulioG]

Triumph every time.. bobber Black or the TFC are dream bikes

[@stewy62]

I’ve no interest in cruisers but sometimes a bike in a genre that you’ve no interest in just grabs you. Now I’m a big R nineT fan and I do like the looks of the R12 but for me the Indian Scout Bobber in black is just so cool. Far too cool for uncool me unfortunately !

[@OLICIT]

I wouldn’t even consider the BMW, I See it more as a retro naked rather than a Cruiser

[@michaelfinck6945]

@Motobob: Thank you for this video! How are "heritage" motorcycles doing saleswise in the UK? I"m asking because in the German 2023 top50 sales the only "heritage" models are the 900 RS and the CB 650 R (which is extremely popular and holds 10th place, CBR 650 R is 13th). In fact there are no motorcycles from Royal Enfield, Triumph, HD or Indian at all to be found in the '23 top50. At the same time the Rebel 500 takes the 5th place 😅 This was different only a few years ago: The RnineT and the 48 were THE hipster bikes and held top20 spots year after year. 883 and Street Bob always top30, here and there a 650 from RE and a Triumph. So I'm curious if the new models can pull it off and turn things around. Obviously checkered flag for the café racers, now it's bobber time! The Shotgun. And every Chinese manufacturer has at least one bobber in the lineup. In terms of success I feel the R12 might have the biggest potential of the bunch. In my perception black and a stripped down look suits the bike the most. The dual tone colour shemes makes the bike look a bit old fashioned in my eyes. But - fair enough - I can see many buyers bling bling this thing up or modify it. The potential for individualiisation is huge. With the Scouts you choose from 5 different models and go from there. With the Triumph Bobber it is what it is basically.

[@fabianbarrios-ph2xm]

Triumph speed master, indian scout classic

[@bradymcrae7351]

As a mt09 rider. The only non naked/sport bike cruiser type that appeals to me is the scout bobber & 101

[@richardtomlinson2063]

I'm not convinced that the BMW is actually a cruiser by most people's definition...?

[@callumsmith338]

So you did a cruiser video without putting the most well known cruiser being an air cooled Harley in?

[@darrylredmill4376]

But the BMW is not a cruiser . Triumph is chain drive so that's out too. If only they did a speedmaster with belt drive!

[@johnDukemaster]

Belt drive eats alot of power. Stick with the chain and use drylube. It works!

[@larrykazakoff4848]

I would buy that. I agree

[@aidenscott71]

£4k for a seat? Come on now. That's just silly

[@shadowdove3250]

BMW R12. Silly choice to make it a dry clutch.

[@Wicked_RotF30]

Scout Bobber or Sport Scout? I wonder why the batwing fairing isn't an option for an add-on for Sport Scout or Chief but can option it for Scout Bobber. New rider looking to get one ordered as an reward to myself after i lose a lot of weight. 181lbs lost is the goal in under 1 year. Strict mostly water fast will be how i get there. Will take vitamins, but to avoid the nausea of taking them on an empty stomach, I will eat 1 small piece of candy with the vitamin daily. 316 days by my calculations will be needed to complete the goal.

[@spacemarine8289]

Harley needs to phase out that sportster line-up, it's simply too embarrassing.

[@thomasbouvier3203]

Scout 101 win hands down the match tho its quite more pricey

[@pipolebnene]

Triumph should have a design that allows two riders on it

[@Max_Von_Dripplesnoot]

It's called a Speedmaster

[@pipolebnene]

@@Max_Von_Dripplesnoot i know but it does not look as slick and cool its more bulky.

[@mistermaquaid1259]

why not the street bob?

[@yeejay6396]

I don't care what Harley does with the Nightster. As someone who owns one, it's far too limited for what Harley offers with it, regardless of the Included Pill on and passenger pegs on the Nightster Special model. RIP Bronx.

[@raylocke282]

Never mind millimeters,what is it in "American".

[@TheChrisglasgow]

Na lad Triumph is definitely the best of the bunch. There popularity alone tells you that.

[@MRo55i74]

Has to be the triumph every time , the style of the BMW just seems wrong

[@chrisjonesbath]

Whatever it is, the R12 isn't a cruiser. It looks too much like a parts bin special to me, even the R1200C had a better cruiser vibe about it. I'm sure it rides great, which for some might be all that is needed, but the Triumph and Indian have the right spin on the cruiser concept. The Harley looks OKish from one side and beyond awful from the other and looks count for a lot.

[@flexywing]

BMW for me please

[@urbanstrencan]

For me is Indian all day😊

[@DestinyLeap]

just choose the one that looks best, which is undoubtedly the indian

[@motosnape]

For me, it's between the BM and the Indian, but I wouldn't see much point in owning a second boxer engine, so realistically it would be the Indian. However, I'd have to ditch those awful, long wheelbarrow exhausts, to replace them with shorter slash cuts, like on the Triumph.

[@ricatiman]

he 2" travel rear shocks result in a terrible ride, always crashing over bumps...and the riding position puts an enormous kink at the knee.. it will be super uncomfortable.

[@Dnewman3402-6]

The rear shock on the Indian Scout is tilted way too forward and this limits the mechanical advantage of the rear shocks.

[@johnDukemaster]

I really struggle with understanding the new Sportster. The old one was such a nice bike. Both in looks, character and price. But the new one? Expensive, ugly and no character. I would take the Honda Rebel. (Which should be on this list mr Bob) I would probably go with the Triumph. That bike looks like a bike that has been "bobbed". And with that lowdown grunt....yummie!

[@D.N.A.23]

Harley looks nice and Indian , Triumph and BMW not my style , i ride the sportster 48 sexy bike

[@scottamolinari]

Wow. A BMW being the cheapest bike? Who would have thought?

[@SSS-mp8th]

Love the look of the Triumph bobber but the 77hp and over 500lbs just kills it for me. Went with a r nineT, lighter, faster and still nice looking.

[@TheChrisglasgow]

An yet they are surprisingly quick. Got 1 myself

[@xclent1975]

HD is no bueno

[@user-ck7pf4nv5k]

scout101 11111111111111111

[@simob7862]

The Indian will destroy the new Harley, v twin engine that has soul and character, the Harley is full of plastic and has a very small tank underneath the seat, the battery is buried behind the radiator and maintenance is not easy, the Indian is better built and is everything we wanted the Harley to be with the previous generation evolution engine which they could of done just like Indian. BMW will appeal to people who want a more modern kind of cruising and Enfield will grab the entry level cost effective 650 with the gap left by the Yamaha vstar and bolt discontinued. This big question is who will continue with this line of bikes? As an owner of a Harley 883 Iron 2017 i plan to return to a smaller more cost effective diverse bike the Triumph x400 the KTM 390 Adventure and the BMW 310 GS

[@LouisScatt.]

Indian all the way 😂😂😂😂😂

[@TheChrisglasgow]

Na Triumph looks n sounds better

[@Will-It-Wolf]

First

[@aromalito63]

it is not do not need anybody,the girldfriend needs to take the bus