New Criminal Laws Which Kick in July 1 Will Create Legal, Judicial Mess, Endanger Life & Liberty

[@sareshn]

Criminals in the parliament should not be allowed to make laws for the people of this country.

[@krisgopi_8]

Spot on. Right now 32 % in LS are having criminal cases as per latest reports .

[@cyrilabraham1776]

Every move made by the BJP/Modi government seeks to strip the citizens of India off any power they have under a legitimate democracy and channel such powers to a handful of self-serving politicians in power. And, this is the recipe for a Made in India FASCISM. unfortunately, those Indians caught up in the ecstasy of poojas and mandirs and Nalanda and cow vigilantism, have no clue that the democratic rug is being pulled under them.

[@morvaridfernandez3105]

Well said

[@celestialspartan7977]

How about getting elected and doing the rest ?

[@PraakashRanjann]

Criminal made laws needs to be changed

[@Chorchowkidar]

old Criminals make new Criminal Law

[@kuldipguleria2615]

Interesting, even smart comment.

[@Chorchowkidar]

@@kuldipguleria2615 thankyou Sir

[@godschild1756]

#Not..... OLD..,‼️BUT‼️ Ever..Live.. CRIMINALs...making new Laws😂

[@PraakashRanjann]

Criminal made laws

[@jimmatrix7244]

New criminals inherit from old criminals. Cannot blame Congress for having criminals.

[@goofychameleon]

Sadly, “vagueness and uncertainty” is the bread and butter of our politicians.

[@thinkingmonkey1153]

and lawyers and courts also.

[@humaneffortwins5570]

Vagueness is required by advocates to make money

[@3596760]

Vagueness and uncertainty is more with legal fraternity and not politician. What can be better example than SC changing its own decisions on 377 and so on in 50 years. So all the persons convicted earlier were convicted wrongly. Certainty is the word missing from our judicial system and vagueness is the norm. Interim bail to Kejriwal during elections another example of vagueness and extraordinary exemption

[@rahulchitale644]

It's bread and butter of judges and lawyers also.

[@Ranjit-Sidhu]

If Karan Thapar was not on KZbin, we would never have known about so many important issues. Nobody discusses such things in the media.

[@kumarnarayana5105]

When law-breakers become law-makers... the voice of justice is imprisoned ! When thugs, looters and mafia run the law... the society is put under choke-hold ! 🙏

[@jawaharlalkoul460]

When judiciary is most corrupt and partial in our country That Is Called Bharat Then What Is Future In Store For Bharat.

[@PraakashRanjann]

That's what India experienced for 70 yrs,mafia criminals made laws for themselves,now that needs to be changed.

[@serendipity0775]

That's so scary.

[@antarasinha8639]

Very well said. 👍👌

[@sunidhiprasad3566]

What a beautiful and befitting summation!

[@viswaghosh1]

Seems these RSS-VHP-BJP fascists in power are only focused on criminalising India. Jobs, inflation, economic growth, demographic dividend, democratic values, secular values (sarva dharma samanvyaya), positive discrimination, federalism, press freedom, etc., etc. - nothing matters. Only criminalisation of the nation and expanding incarceration is high on these fascists manifesto.

[@PraakashRanjann]

Criminal made laws being changed,great for country, criminals ki phati hui hai 🤣🤣

[@smita568]

Seems like it! There's some RSS agent in every other govt institution in our country that hold major executive positions and help suppress dissent by bullying people into silence.

[@hasria123]

Bravo Karan, GOAT of Indian Journalism 🙌🏽❤️🇮🇳

[@tadepalliprasad]

The joke..let the members of parliament against whom criminal cases are pending be first decided before they can enact new laws!

[@mrghost277]

The first thing they do when the come into power is that they close all the criminal cases filled against them and that how honest our judicary system is and 99% are criminals in the parliament, yahan jiski lathi uski bhains aur yahan garib ko kabhi bhi insaaf nahi milta aur yeh criminals yahan to ab biological nahi supreme divine beings hain

[@PraakashRanjann]

We don't need mafia made laws in the country

[@tomadds]

Thanks

[@praboobas]

Thanks!

[@b.k.choudhary6443]

An absolute concern about these new laws , their form, content and objectives of bringing them , is in the minds of judicial and general public. Thus is a good discussion in light of it.❤

[@ankitsrivastava1571]

Eye opening conversation.

[@mnsubramanyam]

Thank you Karan, for bringing such discussion in to public

[@amania9254]

She's very right, unfortunately 😔 but electing a monster power hungry dictator has its costs, not surprising! But truly respect to Heroic protectors of Democracy, freedom,... and all values of idea of India, in this case she is Indira Jaising!

[@teresavarghese1177]

It's a horrible situation and if it comes into force, the CJI has allowed it to be so.

[@CPSingh_Third_Eye]

मैंने नए कानूनों को विभिन्न स्रोतों से समझने की बहुत कोशिश की। मैडम, आपने जितनी सारगर्भित, सरल और स्पष्ट विवेचना की है, उससे मैं बहुत आसानी से समझ गया। सराहनीय। थापर जी की इंटरव्यू कला का पहले से प्रशंसक हूं। सादर, 🙏❤️

[@jimmybindra]

What an opinión Karan ..no sabía de esto !! Gracias a tu Guest también 🙌👋 -- India is growing into a dal-dal living place already, poco a poco.

[@smile4tango]

This is thinking out of the box!! Bang on Indira Jaisingh!!,👍

[@jravindranath8345]

In our democracy, these laws which have far reaching consequences need to be debated thoroughly in parliament, media and public before implementation.

[@shrestaassociates4063]

It was announced by home minister not law minister as P M announcing demonetisation instead of FM

[@LillianBadalkar]

Create confusion and chaos among the populace was the technique of the ancient times and we are now dragged in the 12 th century. ! It is most unfortunate to have such reckless govt. In 21 st century of 140 crore people. What a Tragedy !

[@teresavarghese1177]

Irresponsible voters.

[@mainakdey5845]

There has been a small change in the bench tilted towards the ruling govt.. the voting is skewed.

[@KanchhiSingh-ky6ov]

Sir ,you are the only person ,awair us.we are thankful.

[@christinetina4361]

OMG what an eye opener.

[@MrPicklu123]

Modi s ego. CJI is perhaps eyeing on plum posting after retirement

[@MegaMicraman]

CJI can't bring in new laws, it's down to parliament.

[@serendipity0775]

Since we now have a strong opposition, can they not oppose this?????

[@piccog3154]

Please try to understand - Ordinance has been issued during Modi 2.0 - Now, Opposition has to protest in Parliament and We, Citizen has to protest in Streets. Then only, it will be repealed like Farmers Law. Be ready, this law will affect each and every citizens. Fool Modi 2.0 Government

[@ArjunAJ-nw7rl]

They can.

[@serendipity0775]

Why havent they bothered ?​@ArjunAJ-nw7rl

[@myanthungezung2970]

The most funny part of the new criminal law is that the law was drafted by the Home department which consists of criminals and passed by voice vote of some section of criminals in the Parliament to be used against them😂😂😂

[@Oceansta]

now the Tadip[aar will decide what is criminal and what is not. Brilliant.

[@satyamanitiwari1348]

New Laws needs more discussions in parliament they should be postponed for at least 2 years many Amendments are required to be done, moreover judiciary, police, advocates all need refresher courses presently these laws looks influenced by power politics

[@gautamgangulyguwahati9717]

Excellent coverage. One feels that there should be national debate before the new Laws are implemented. These were framed during last government without opposition views. Now. The new legislators should contest.

[@Oceansta]

And so it begins my dear countrymen...

[@meganathng7600]

Thank you very much mam your personal opinion and advice to the public we welcome❤❤❤

[@dostondoc23]

Can these be called "laws" at all as these 3 were hurriedly passed in Parliament by a government which threw out about a hundred Opposition parliamentarians. They needed to be properly debated upon for all their pros and cons, and then voted upon.

[@dostondoc23]

This is precisely the point Ms Jaising mentioned towards the end of the interview.

[@Kaivalya7267]

Respected sir , don't rely on borrowed wisdom ,read the laws first by yourselves.

[@dostondoc23]

@@Kaivalya7267 Most revered sir, I have read the laws. Educate yourself on the intention of some particular laws. Certain politicians don't simply throw out the Opposition and hurriedly pass laws for benevolent purposes!

[@varoonipanchal1836]

Hats Off to Indira Jaising who showed up enough courage to speak on this platform. Many Thanks Karan Sir for taking initiative in making this video. Democracy, Life & Liberty is coming to or is already endangered ?? What else is left to get in more endangers situation ?? Are we all Indians together are heading towards this change and ready to live in this change ? Thoughtful Questions but unfortunately no constructive SOLUTION !! If there is still any constructive SOLUTION left please inform !!

[@123xyzabccba]

14:18; Nothing can be expected from the Supreme Court of Bammans …..The CJI owes his position to his bamman caste just like how his father also

[@mohanv88]

Nitish naidu will face 1st set of charges for supporting basmasur

[@g-frostgamer3927]

Let the new law be made applicable to those sitting in Secretariat.

[@anchitsharma7380]

Both white-haired humans are wise and great in their respective fields. The Wire, thanks for bringing this interview.

[@lawyermahaprasad]

We Are navigating towards a storm.

[@good114]

❤❤

[@annemaryfernandez5076]

Very grave and troubling situation.

[@sanjayb4159]

But the opposition is sleeping over this highly important matter No sound

[@churabhok2869]

That's because they will also get caught in this law 😂

[@lofidarkness4919]

Thank you for providing knowledge to the people

[@tarzan40005]

Utter chaos will surely reign supreme for the next few decades, if not several years.

[@GauravKumar-xe1oi]

Congress, BJP and Sibbal have lost their mind. This new law code must not be applied until it is widely discussed in public.

[@allanantonandrew]

Stakeholders in current dispensation are blind to the future; still forgetting the past. Indira ma'am is bang on the best voice to raise concerns before it's too late too incisive. Criminal justice system gadbad hai hi, nahi to law commission cpc bhi amend karwa dete .. evidence act is to go in totality, else we're in soup 🍲 🍵

[@zapechisho7145]

Karan Sir...why are you not inviting nta members or national exam board for all this mess on Central exams like NEET and Net.

[@vijaymalhotra6612]

Modi Sarkar is best at creating confusion and suspence in all walks of governance.

[@anilpurnajidhoke4712]

A matter of great concern as much as I know of law.

[@kanilin946]

You are the BEST Karan Thapar.. Fortright..no beating about the bush.. Love listening to your interviews..Simply great!

[@iemon7722]

Jaising, consummate legend!

[@JumgeSora]

God bless this country 😮

[@gardenbyneelam]

Ready to become criminal under new law altimatly all people shall face heat of this laws.. And ready to spent 10 year in prison for a braking traffic rules...

[@malinidhir]

Thanks for the good work done by you and wire 🙏🌺

[@satishsharma9307]

I fail to understand, why our prominent SC lawyers like Kapil Sibbal, who otherwise undertakes discussions on many critical national issues although had talkshow on the issue but in a very casual way, without raising any red flag against the implementation of these new laws especially on long term impact of this law on citizens.

[@-VAJRA-]

You should always keep in mind that he’s also a prominent politicians as well who has held important portfolios throughout his illustrious career as a politician A politician will never go against their self interest nor against the self interest of the political associates

[@Thakkidu_Mundan]

Lawyers get more money when there is chaos. Is it bad?

[@alvonnashortt170]

Mr Kapil Sibal already did in and is still doing it

[@FalggersPoint]

Sibbal sahab ne sabse pahle hi Kiya ye...jab log samjhne me busy the

[@satishkumarl4999]

Law also should change or amended according to times we live in,

[@rajeev7898]

This Government had added a new mess to the already existing one created by it😢

[@scariathoppil2271]

Is there no unbiased, objective, competent Law Commission in this country to suggest laws for the good of the people of this country because criminals at least many of them sitting in the Parliament as law makers of this country cannot be expected to make proper laws for the good of the people of this country. Are proper consultative procedures being followed which used to be there earlier in this country for law making?

[@jayakalyanaraman5029]

Are we becoming a nation of outlaws!

[@gurdeepsingh1616]

Very true ji

[@abhimanyuyadav5251]

Lack of deliberation can hamper the rights of the accused. Taking into consideration that half of the members were suspended when the bills were being deliberated. Also lack of understanding of the laws to the Judges as well as the lawyers without adequate infrastructure of training is another loophole. I am surprised that govt. has taken zero efforts to setup training sessions for lawyers especially for the ones who are private independent lawyers.

[@sathyanarayanan1554]

Is there any Refresher Course for Advocates and Judicial Officers And Magistrates/Judges to get amply conversant with the New Set of Laws? There's serious apprehensions that the New Laws will create a host of disturbing issues in the long run. Last, how will Police Authorities deal with the sudden implementation? They too need to be tutored about how to make use of it! The General Public needs enhanced legal awareness and alertness too.

[@hackiechan8125]

Certainly it will make justice delivery system a mess

[@lourencodafatimasouza1479]

Try all MPs and MLAs under the new criminal laws to get the FIR from parliamentarians.

[@Roy_21y]

This barbaric attitude will not work anymore . The opposition is much stronger now .

[@serendipity0775]

We can only hope so cos this was passed bfre the new govt was formed 🤞

[@Roy_21y]

@@serendipity0775 some elections are still left .. there's no way if BJP loses .. Nitish Naidu will still be with the NDA.. nd that way BJP will lose the throne ... So yeah , lots of uncertainty ...lol ...

[@Vjane-b9s]

Even opposition seems to b not oppos the bill...

[@maverickbboy3647]

@@Roy_21y bro opposition will also use these when in power and don't trust any politician blindly they will exercise in their terms

[@Roy_21y]

@@maverickbboy3647 Rahul and Priyanka are different.. they proved themselves ..

[@gilbertdsouza7752]

Was the due process followed while enacting the law passed ? Why has no suit been filed by anyone ??

[@teresavarghese1177]

Because the judges come under the control of the Ruling party.

[@KrishnaGMisra]

Laws should be simple and can be understood by the public. Principle of laws require that it makes everyone in the country equal in the eyes of the laws . Judges and lawyers are the beneficiary of bad laws and they protect criminals for pecuniary gains. This business of lawyers and judges should stop and people judge themselves by using the laws and it's principles enshrined in the constitution of India. Regards

[@ZubairAhmad-yj9et]

As a wild West American, everybody should carry a gun 24/7/365 and be trigger happy. Right to carry bigger and bigger guns.

[@BinaSingh-p8p]

Laws cannot be applied retrospectively; how can be judged for something done when it was legal, and which is now illegal under new laws

[@siddharthanvarier3342]

If a defendant commits, say, murder, and tries to get away with it,with the help of an EXPENSIVE DEFENCE ATTORNEY, where does the question of his LIFE and LIBERTY arise?

[@ashwanibansal5459]

The Supreme Court of India must intervene and should postpone the implementation of new Criminal Laws till the necessary infrastructure of forensic laboratories , training of police and lawyers and judges in the new criminal justice procedure and evidence production , formation of new courts for trial under new laws is completed

[@siddharthanvarier3342]

Indirajee, addressing and resolving VAGUENESS AND UNCERTAINTY is a matter for the Honourable Judges and juries to decide. It is not within the ambit of citizenry, but lie within the domains of the judiciary

[@madhusudankharwar1052]

Thanks for this interview.

[@neildcosta5932]

Our country's law makers have been and continue to be past-masters at writing ambiguous and vague laws. That leaves the laws completely open for our 'know-it-all' lawmakers to 'interpret' them.

[@merlinfrancis9754]

We have jokers running our country, they've made it into a circus, imagine the chaos.

[@shrestaassociates4063]

Karans enunciation super..

[@HarpreetSingh-ke2zk]

By avoiding the selection of bombastic and sarcastic orators as our leaders, we can reduce the problems that arise when they become ministers. Often, we choose leaders who excel in manipulating words and enjoy taunting their opponents. This tendency caters to our common interests, and such individuals exploit it to their advantage. Consequently, we end up selecting leaders based on their rhetorical skills rather than their experience and expertise in relevant fields.

[@Kalyani-c9b]

Level of implementation of law is important rather than creating draconian and fascist laws

[@rtikku9580]

Karan, Please pick up topics that are of much larger impact to masses like: 1. Possibility to have all lower and district courts turning into e-courts. Litigant and judge from different part of country so to have minimal influence either way. All hearings online and timely judgement. Once the courts start functioning in a truthful way, the flimsy cases will be withdrawn automatically. Mind you most cases are just to intimidate. 2. Abuse of women laws in the country. Do you see possibility to have some changes to 125 and 498a in favor of men given the widespread abuse of this act? 3. Corruption at local level especially at municipality level and govt dept that deal with land issues. Take the example of HUDA / HSVP in Gurgaon. Possibly the most corrupt. How do we connect judiciary to complaints that we have against our local administration? The opposition will find most fodder here. Though Modi govt may not be corrupt at the top, there is ample corruption at the bottom of the pyramid. 4 Things like the months of vacation that our judiciary enjoys. This is a mockery of modern judiciary system and goes in the face of the lowest common denominator who slogs 12 hours a day 365 days a year to put 2 square meals on his plate. Please choose some topics that affect the great masses of this country directly. Thanks

[@user-jh9kj5hk8h]

I don’t agree the kejriwal fiasco but I absolutely supportthe anti public property setablaze policy. We are already too burdened with GST.

[@mayamk5535]

Great very informative

[@sarojanidoddapaneni9734]

I am reminded of one stanza from Vemanacshatakam "The fruit Medipndu looks good externally when you seeinside one finds worms".

[@joogjoog100]

Ms. Jaisingh is oblivious to Section 531 of BNSS 2023, the successor to The Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973...the said Section provides for the repeal and savings and it's sub -section 2 which begins with a non obstante clause and clearly mandates that

[@lakshmitiwari4215]

Two law work together parrelelly...it should be challenged in Supreme Court,and larger bench should be decide the matter..

[@allanantonandrew]

14:17 preempt the trouble, CJI dyc is passing the buck too...

[@siddharthanvarier3342]

Freedom of SPEECH does not extend to making inflammatory and defamatory statements about the State of India, or any of it's citizenry

[@herbalyzt]

shocking... but Thank you KT & TW & IJS 🙌

[@jamilakoshy3324]

I hope these new laws will be stayed. Sick of this rubbish

[@GloriousDrHarendraSingha]

Eternal vigilance is the price of liberty.

[@Nik-mx3fm]

Why do i feel like,,,,,,,,the CJI is in, on it 😱🤯

[@virinderdogra6086]

Very articulated views.....

[@jessievarghese9935]

We could predict this without any scrutiny of the laws.it is par for the course as far as BJP goes

[@snehasisjena8714]

I prefer describing the BNS as rather the 'Anyay Sanhita' which is precisely aimed at justifying every injustice perpetrated by the govt that was prevented by the old criminal laws. I've got no doubts whatsoever, about the govt planning to bring about a dark era of oppression through these laws.

[@Chopraviraj]

My God! “law is taking its course”

[@peterthomas1861]

People favouring bjp rss on religious ground. Alliance partners, tdp and jdu are corrupted (flexible) political parties. It is good for wire, avoid earn the hatred of bjp rss.

[@SouravChakraborty-oh8zm]

Since we have legal enforcement in Sardah financial schemes in WB tampered archieve of CCTV camera. And a judicial crisis and civilian casualities.

[@SouravChakraborty-oh8zm]

Can we afford Drones and satellites surveillance instead. Infra-red clas technology.

[@SouravChakraborty-oh8zm]

Is there a wage bias of private legal firms like minimum wage or schoraship schemes for jurisdical sciences.

[@TheSwaraj]

Indira Jaising and Karan Thapar a combination well known to people.

[@mahendrakhandeparkar4316]

S.531 of the BNSS clearly lays down that all the pending cases are to be decided in accordance with the old law namely Code of Criminal Procedure 1973.

[@ekramhussainmir3903]

When criminals, underqualified become legislature , we cnt expect any thing more. Moreover, judiciary is above govt or under govt in respect of its function, just think it

[@blackjusticewebseries]

Watch Webseries Black Justice. Uncertainty and Vaguness is always part of Law which have exploited and benefitted every lawyer including her.

[@kasturiswami784]

She is the only one who wears the pants in the supreme court apart from dushyant dhave.

[@sm9214]

Quite understandable that it is very difficult for the vassal droppings and the remnants of the 20th century suzerain to come to terms with the independent, new age outlook of the present generation to get rid of the vassal state left-overs. In these vassals' view only Hindu practices alone need reformation. Their lexicon has it that: To oppose a bollywood scene showing a Hindu woman stripping with a Hindu symbol is '"Reprisals of freedom expression and artist' freedom". As opposed to this: if a school lays down rules against purdahs, the very same people would say 'it is denial of freedom to practice one's practices!!!' In sum, their self-defeating, polarising stands on two issues of the very same nature has driven them suffering with bipolar disorder.