New Muslim Learns About HARAM vs HALAL (This Must Be WRONG!)

[@discoverwithtony1719]

Converted to Islam 6 months ago, raised as a Cuban Christian. I can tell you this is the best decision I have done in my life. Keeping up with the daily prayers gives me the most faith i have ever felt. Alhamdulillah

[@lloollllooll2307]

May Allah keep you steadfast and increase you in goodness

[@world_end3r]

"When you read Quran you turn to Islam. When you understand Quran you turn to Christianity" Jesus loves you bro. Turn from that satanic religion.

[@fedesetrtatio1]

What stopped you from praying when you were a "Cuban Christian". Are you aware that you swapped praying to the true God of Abraham yahweh now to a false pagan Arab God Allah.

[@world_end3r]

@@fedesetrtatio1 "Father forgive them, for they know not what they do"

[@discoverwithtony1719]

@@fedesetrtatio1 First of all, have you read the Quran at all? If yes, you have unfortunately read with a blind heart, because otherwise you would not write that "Allah" is a false God, because Abraham and also Jesus have called God in ancient Aramaic Allah. I can tell you that the Cuban faith is witchcraft through the whole santería that is led there under the disguise of "Christian faith" and behind many saints are actually African voodoo gods. Thank Allah I have chosen the right path, may Allah guide you.

[@istoleyourcake-p5k]

Assalamualikum Bobby I m a muslim and was watching people converting to islam and then I found your video then I really felt happy when you converted to Islam from that on I subscribe to your channel and started watching your videos🤗

[@ViolettaVie]

Assalaamu alaykum, I had a dog growing up. We lived in a dangerous neighborhood and we got her to guard the yard. She was very good deterrent. She only came in the house a handful of times when there were storms and we worried for her well-being. We had a side door that led to the basement and we made her comfortable there. But she never went into the main part of the house.

[@ahmedfadhil9682]

Dog saliva and Swine flesh are haram. Its our responsibility to take good care of animals. By shk Assim al hakim, Even if you cage them with proper food and shelter its okay to keep.

[@Mardark-e4s]

I also had a dog growing up he would be in our backyard and we made him a doghouse to shelter from storms, but we would let him in when the storms would be really bad. He was a great security dog

[@abdelkarimbaghdadi2094]

As long it doesn't live in the same house like entering ur bedroom and kitchen and is for guard u're totally fine.

[@ViolettaVie]

@abdelkarimbaghdadi2094 Yeah, I don't even think it was more than 5 times we let her in the basement. But that was because of storms. We had a terrible snowstorm, and a hurricane or two. Other than that, she was always outside. And it was a good thing. She helped slow down a criminal who got into our yard and our neighbors' yards who also had dogs. It was like every dog on the block got a piece of him.

[@abdelkarimbaghdadi2094]

@@ViolettaVie it's alright 🙏🏻

[@ahdid6105]

Dear brother, We always learn new things. Never reach the end of knowledge.

[@yasminbhoola6826]

Very informative for both Muslim and non-Muslim. Alhamdulillah. Keep posting these videos Very educational.

[@jovial2004-gd1gy]

hi Bobby I love your honest reaction videos

[@TheBobbysPerspective]

Thank you my brother

[@unaddan]

it's always gave me goosebumps when seeing somebody is so wise in act and thinking

[@sapio2000]

Asalam Aleikon, Regarding to the music in weddings: it is not allowed to have music in weddings, Only the playing of "doof" (tambourine) which is a shallow "small" drum. It is only allowed in {Weddings, Eid and the arrival of a family member who has been traveling for many years}. the doof is only allowed to women not men (If men do it, it is haram and considered to be Imitation of women which is a major sin). In wedding men get separated from women just like in salah. in women's part it is allowed to have the doof being played there, but not in the men's side. I wish I have cleared this issue u got

[@RenderingUser]

This ^

[@Anonymous-co3jv]

I will add to what you wrote. It's similar to tambourine in the sense that it is open from one of the sides. And different that it doesn't have coins on the edge of it. Moreover, as you have mentioned, it's permissable during celebrations. Yet, it's also permissable for men and women in the same way. Different scholar have different opinions on this point, nonetheless, it's most likely permissable because usually laws that are for men applied for women and visa versa, unless otherwise stated.

[@ljubicanstvena]

👍 thats it guys. I dont know why people always say there are scolars who allows, I mean if they allow they are a very small group, thr biggest part of ahlul sunnah wal jamma'h scolars forbbids it.

[@mikidias]

Music is completely "Mamdouh" and "Halal" in every Islamic countries that I personally know and I have personally been into and, therefore, music is played all the time, everyday without specific rules. They even got international singers known worldwide..... My favourite artists are Abdul Majid Abdullah, Rashid Al - Majid, Majid Al - Mouhandis, Majid Al - Raslani, Zayed Al - Saleh, Rabi Al - saqer , Al - wasmi, Omar Abdallat, Aziz Al - yami, Saleh Al - yami Azouz Al - Said and many others...... They are all Arab Khalliji singers 👨🏻‍🎤 🇸🇦

[@ljubicanstvena]

@@mikidias just bcos ppl in "muslim" countries listen to music doesnt means that music is halal, it is not a value, the value is Qur'an and Sunnah. Ppl follows their sinse and do what their souls like and want, thats why we have the guadience of Qur'an and Sunnah to know whats good and whats bad. In arabic countries its terrible how they fall down with music loving. Like I said just bcos of that, that people love music it dont makes it halal 😉☺️

[@Kinderlieder-Kindergeschichte]

you explain things well brother Bobby, I'm proud of you. May Allah continue to bless you.

[@mohammedsalman1498]

They way you explain and clarify every point hats off to you brother ❤

[@OneGodAllah]

As usual I find Brother Bobby's Perspective the best perspective to watch on youtube.

[@TheBobbysPerspective]

I appreciate that bro

[@world_end3r]

​@@TheBobbysPerspective"If you read Quran you turn to Islam. If you understand Quran you turn to Christianity"

[@kakarote100]

@@world_end3r no way. I understood trinity and "hypostatic union" and was far ahead than most trinitareans to realize how doing proskeuno to someone who is 100% man (human body+ human soul = human nature) and 100% god (god nature) is literally idolatry. *Worshipping the 100% god in christ may not be idolatry but getting your proskeuno accepted by a 100% man in christ is literally idolatry.* Hypostatic union is the partnership between man and god. Do not fall for this sham.

[@world_end3r]

@@kakarote100 Are we gonna ignore the fact that Allah is an unrighteous judge and says many times that he rebukes humankind? Brother that is not a true God. Your religion was made by a decieved by satan prophet that married a child and thought there is nothing wrong with it. Besides your religion was made 6 (if not even seven) hundred years after the death of Christ. And why in every religion (Hindu,Islam etc.) There are talking about Jesus and the true Christian God, but Bible itself doesnt talk about any other similar religion. I could not even accept your religion because in your Quran there is written that Chrisitans and every similar to Christianity religions will be suffering the most. Belivie in Jesus! Before its too late bro. I tell you this guy in the video read Quran but never read Bible. Cause he would never be Muslim.

[@world_end3r]

@@kakarote100 You are Trinity itself. The flesh, soul and spirit.

[@Tia-fy9dr]

Hi bobby! I am a muslim from Singapura. I'm from South east Asia, and history of Islam spreading starting from Indonesia to the rest of Asia is by music. Music helped spread Islam teachings faster, and brings muslims together. As I am muslim who speaks zero arabic, and that could be said for most muslims who does not grew up in the middle east or learns arabic language, its a struggle to learn and remember a new language. Personally, I couldnt remember all 25 prophets names mentioned in the Quran unless I sing it! There's songs pertaining to Aisha ra (prophet saw wife) which described her relationship with the prophet saw. Its purely educational music. As per Imam Shafi'i school of thought, music is permissible if its in rememberance of Allah. For example Rahmatun Lil Alameen by Maher Zain, which praises the prophet Muhammad saw, for guiding us towards Allah, proud to be a follower of his sunnah and being a part of his ummah. Some said music in Islam is haram, because music is and could be the source of evil as it makes us develop certain emotions and influence our thoughts. I am sure you know there are songs out there that associate themselves with Satan. Different school of thoughts differ in opinions, so it is important to understand when a scholar comes out with a ruling, we need to understand the context of why and how they came up with that particular ruling. So it is important to know the difference, and in the Quran Allah said in Surah Al-Ma'idah 77 "O People of the Book! Do not go to extremes in your religion, other than in truth." Hope this helps!

[@zaidpansare5650]

What you are talking about is called "Nasheed". Music is prohibited by the consensus of all 4 schools of thought.

[@amna415]

mashallah despite the fact you're a new Muslim, you're well knowledgeable about your deen... i've born as a Muslim alhamdulillah but watching your videos teach me new things and reminde me of others... just few points to mention: drawing nature is NOT haram as long as its a non-living things + music generally is haram EXCEPT the "duff" instrument which is what we use at weddings... keep making videos brother, may god bless you :)

[@ahmedibrahim1426]

Exactly the same.

[@osamaanees8406]

His question was to play music in those weddings you need to practice it. How will the person practice it?

[@amna415]

@@osamaanees8406 he did mention practicing on guitar and other instruments which made me think that he might not know the permissible instrument… playing, practicing, or listening to music according to Islam is not allowed unless it's with a duff… in my country, we have traditional songs and poems that are played using Duffs at weddings and sometimes without... We just vibe and clap together to light up the place

[@warriorofislamempire]

Haram PFP

[@amna415]

@@warriorofislamempire Oh right!!, I didn't even notice lol... Not me saying it's haram and having the haram as my pfp 😂 I’ll change it don't worry, nevertheless, I didn't draw it and the picture is nearly noticeable and causes no harm... our prophet once saw Aishah bint Abi Bakr play with some of her dolls and a horse with wings, he didn't forbid her or asks her to stop playing them, he simply asked what are those and even laughed at some point during that interaction (I'm just giving you the overall of the hadith, you can look it up word by word if you feel like it)... I think my point here is that Islam is a religion of ease (الاسلام دين يسر) for example watching educational cartoons are permissible as long as there is no harm, fault, or misconception ideas about god or our deen

[@حسينمحمد-غ1ص3ع]

جزاك الله خير

[@JesusisaMuslim]

After I have read the Quran, I realized that all what humanity needs is this heavenly law. “The legislation of Quran will spread all over the world, because it agrees with the mind, logic and wisdom.” - Leo Tolstoy .

[@rtxz5697]

Allahu Akbar ☝️

[@darkshadow07186]

False Information is Haram brother, Leo Tolstoy didn't say a thing.

[@Rayleigh.]

@@darkshadow07186 Is this a joke or you just didn't check it up before answering this ? Because you're the one lying here, brother.

[@peterrego3771]

@Ahmad Usman Reaction Muslims don't like to have their own Quaranic verses in the channel. They block you... Quaran 24:33 Something new.. miraculous words promoting the art of prostitution..here on earth...for men to practice for their heavenly reward of 72 virgin prostitutes... Prostitution in the Quaran... Amazing Alah / Jibreel / Muslim men like Andrew T promoting/encouraging this sinful stuff..The MEN are to blame as much as the women...AND what happened to the BURKA...Same prostitutes go out wearing it..What a JOKE.! 24:33. And let those who find not the financial means for marriage keep themselves chaste, until Allâh enriches them of His Bounty. And such of your slaves as seek a writing (of emancipation), give them such writing, if you know that they are good and trustworthy. And give them something yourselves out of the wealth of Allâh which He has bestowed upon you. And force not your maids to prostitution, if they desire chastity, in order that you may make a gain in the (perishable) goods of this worldly life. But if anyone compels them (to prostitution), then after such compulsion, Allâh is Oft-Forgiving, Most Merciful (to those women, i.e. He will forgive them because they have been forced to do this evil action unwillingly). / promoting prostitution.... And the poor women are blamed!!! What is the use of the burka ! Isn't it a BIG JOKE? And that too by Alah in the Quaran !

[@idontcare7922]

​@@darkshadow07186you're not Muslim but Tolstoy was One

[@matikhan8178]

Really impressed by your knowledge ♥️♥️♥️

[@DawahTrucker2024]

Masha'Allah great video and yes Bobby I do agree with you there's a free mistakes made that need correction and tweaking

[@Ausaidkmr]

Happy for you You are the real hero and you are going change the ideologies of the world

[@TheAbdlMalik]

14:41 Salam Bobby! This is a question that I, Myself, have asked for a while and still receive multiple responses. The truth is "Music" is a "gray area" within Islam. There aren't enough textual evidences, to support whether or not the Prophet ﷺ forbid or permitted certain instruments, so the scholars conclude music is at least Makruh (Disliked) or Haram (Haram). There were some instruments that weren't popular or around during his time, and when you go through different narrations, there are times he allowed it and times he didn't. Biggest example of allowing it is during Eid or Weddings. Though Muslim scholars claim this is the more dominant opinion, in order to know Music, one has to study it and practice it. This within itself is also debated amongst other scholars. To conclude, the default is SPECIFIC Music is Haram, and the others is permissible (Duf, The Flute or Tamborine). All in all, it's important to understand this and decide accordingly on how we act on it. In my opinion, I don't inherently see anything wrong with Music, however, I'm aware of how often I listen to it and the affects it has on me. And Allah knows best.

[@homtanks7259]

JazakAllah'u khairan brother

[@Who.R.]

I live in Germany. One night I went to the gym and on the way back a drunk man was about to hit me. Fortunately, I ran away quickly and he couldn't catch me. Alhamdulillah❤🥰

[@sol3406]

Ok

[@3aeren]

Lol ey?

[@Who.R.]

@@3aeren why are you mad? Im just telling the truth about alcohol🤷🏻‍♂️

[@3aeren]

@@Who.R. mad, whose mad? Anyway, cool story brah

[@Who.R.]

@@3aeren Everyone is free to believe or not🤷🏻‍♂️

[@neerodz2650]

Asalam alikum brother, about music is a complex subject which is very hard to explain in it entirety, just know that there is 2 different options on it being absolutely haram in every situation, while the other opinion says it's halal if it's not related to any other sin or immorality such as concert where there is mixing between the two genders and even alcohol involved So there's no consensus "ijmaa" (اجماع) on music being haram or halal And in this video it says music is only allowed in celebration, i think they ment singing not music

[@oceanworld1383]

Say Assalamualaikum not asalam alikum BC meaning changes and in reply say Wa aliakum mus salam

[@neerodz2650]

@@oceanworld1383 I'm a native arabic speaker, we say in Arabic "السلام عليكم" that's 2 words not one, so saying it like that makes more sense to me as arabic speaker, however there's no science to English using arabic origin words

[@oceanworld1383]

@@neerodz2650 U r Arabic speaker but I wrote in English how to pronounce it and u wrote Asalam alikum if any one reads will read like that and I wrote Assalamu alaikum that pronounce is good and also meaning will remain same as Arabic ....

[@mohammedabdulhadi9224]

ask those who say that music is halal at wedding to PRODUCE THEIR PROOF IF THEY ARE TRUTHFUL yes bobby you are right it is haram to touch the opposite gender regardless of your intention except in emergencies we do not respect falsehood we merely do not incite those who are upon falsehood, we merely educate them

[@hoopoe9629]

Ibn Abbas reported: Aisha gave away one of her relatives in marriage to a man among the Ansar. The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, came and he said, “Did you send them a girl?” They said yes. The Prophet said, “Did you send someone to sing with her?” She said no. The Prophet said, “Verily, the Ansar are a people who love poetry, so you should send someone along with her to say: Here we come, to you we come, greet us as we greet you.” Source: Sunan Ibn Mājah 1900 Grade: Hasan (fair) according to Al-Albani عَنْ ابْنِ عَبَّاسٍ قَالَ أَنْكَحَتْ عَائِشَةُ ذَاتَ قَرَابَةٍ لَهَا مِنْ الْأَنْصَارِ فَجَاءَ رَسُولُ اللَّهِ صَلَّى اللَّهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ فَقَالَ أَهْدَيْتُمْ الْفَتَاةَ قَالُوا نَعَمْ قَالَ أَرْسَلْتُمْ مَعَهَا مَنْ يُغَنِّي قَالَتْ لَا فَقَالَ رَسُولُ اللَّهِ صَلَّى اللَّهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ إِنَّ الْأَنْصَارَ قَوْمٌ فِيهِمْ غَزَلٌ فَلَوْ بَعَثْتُمْ مَعَهَا مَنْ يَقُولُ أَتَيْنَاكُمْ أَتَيْنَاكُمْ فَحَيَّانَا وَحَيَّاكُمْ 1900 سنن ابن ماجه كتاب النكاح باب الغناء والدف 2/136 المحدث الألباني خلاصة حكم المحدث حسن في صحيح ابن ماجه

[@mezo4197]

​@@hoopoe9629music ≠ singing

[@hoopoe9629]

@@mezo4197 singing is a form of music so I think you meant musical instruments…. But isn’t the general rule that something is considered to be lawful unless there is proof of its prohibition?

[@mezo4197]

@@hoopoe9629 well singing isn't haram unless it has harmful words as for musical instruments there is plenty of evidence for it being haram and I am not free enough to look it up for you

[@prankeddlol7140]

@@mezo4197 there is also a hadith about some instruments being allowed.

[@MoeedKhan1979]

Wow. Your videos are super duper informative. Keep it up

[@haidar8856]

The music issue is a bit complicated. There are different types of music, for once, there is the filthy type which promoted sin such as the majority of current western music. There's also the innocent type, in Arabic these are called "Anashid" which is basically sung poetry, it actually sounds nice. Although there's disagreement between scholars on music, we can say that as long as it is not filthy, then it's halal.

[@humairahannan2010]

Assalam Alaikum wa Rahmatullah wa Barkatahu brother I say every Muslims play this dua every time (Lailaha illallah nastagfirullah nasalukal Jannah wa naujobika minnannar nar)Ameen

[@amera3009]

Yes Bobby. Anything with a soul we are absolutely forbidden from drawing, painting or sculpting (sculpting is the worst of these to do) But we can draw things that are inanimate without a soul

[@bleazertm7698]

yeah the video is kinda weird, especially the part about music and painting

[@amera3009]

@@bleazertm7698 yeah definitely. It’s because many non Muslims when they search for Islam unfortunately seek info from Muslims instead of the texts and not all Muslims are equal in their knowledge so they end up with strange answers that are wrong sometimes

[@infostatics]

Time is moving so fast.. So i've been member for 6 months 8 days now with Bobby Perspective Channel..

[@mz6137]

Salam Brother, I've got an advice for you to increase your knowledge of Islam and to increase your good deeds by making the viewers also watch. Listen and start to get knowledge from the most popular scholars of our era like Sheikh Ibn Uthaymeen, Sheikh Ibn Baz, Sheikh Salih Al Fawzan and so forth. These are some of the best scholars and you'd immediately notice their level of knowledge and their humbleness towards the religion. I advice you to start with such videos and record them so other muslims can further increase their knowledge. Jazaka Allahu Khayran

[@myislamonly]

Yes this is the correct way of learning Islam. Bobby gets a lot of comments from sects and deviant groups who don’t know the religion properly and promote misguided "scholars" and "shaykhs" which then lead to further confusion and in the end indulging in bidah, which the prophet ‎ﷺ clearly made haram. May Allah guide us all and open the heart of Bobby to the correct Sunnah and may The Most High allow him to benefit from our best scholars. Allahumma Ameen

[@mz6137]

@@myislamonly Yeah Bobby is still new to the religion so his not at fault here but i kinda want him to start to get deep into the religion as much of the videos he currently watches don’t provide new information and sometimes tend to spread confusion since some people that recommend the videos are from deviant sects. I recommended those scholars because literally 1 video from them increases your knowledge tenfold and it would be extremely beneficial not only for bobby, but rather the entire ummah. سلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته و عيد مبارك brother

[@naimahmed3720]

Good advice brother. Before Bobby was Muslim, it was ok for him to watch any videos on Islam. But now he’s reverted, he must make effort to seek out authentic sources of information.

[@myislamonly]

@@mz6137 Wa alaykum as salam wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuh akhi.

[@hikmanafia]

​@@myislamonlyMy dear Brother, Bid'ah is not a law in fiqh There's Bid'ah wajib such standardization of Qur'an with so many added things and the main goal is our ihktiyaar to preserve the Glorious Qur'an Bid'ah Sunnah such taraweh being performed jamaah. 'Umar RA don't hesitate to say "this is the best bid'ah" There's Bid'ah Mubah, Bid'ah Makrooh, Bid'ah Haram too And the school/madzhab has different analysis from so many the exact same hadits If the ijtihaad has been perform by the ulama who authorized, the difference in many conclusions will be compulsory to us to: open heart And every imam of fiqh do that open heart attitude in high level & we should take good lesson

[@munisamakhmudjanova8358]

Love your videos! Thank you! Can you also make a comprehensive video with answers you got for those questions that you had if they were answered. Thanks!

[@Kinderlieder-Kindergeschichte]

regarding music: TLDR: it's haram according to all 4 sunni schools, except singing without instruments (good content - men for all, women for women) and the handdrum for weddings and on Eid. Quran 31 : 6. And of mankind is he who purchases idle talks (i.e. music, singing, etc.) to mislead (men) from the Path of Allah without knowledge, and takes it (the Path of Allah, or the Verses of the Qur'an) by way of mockery. For such there will be a degrading torment. Ibn Mas`ud (close companion) commented: "by Allah, this refers to singing." “[Allah said to Iblis:] And befool them gradually those whom you can among them with your voice (i.e. songs, music, and any other call for Allah's disobedience)…” [al-Isra 17:64] It was narrated that Mujahid (may Allah have mercy on him) said: “And befool them gradually those whom you can among them with your voice” - his voice [the voice of Iblis/Shaytan] is singing and falsehood. Quran 25 : 72. And those who do not bear witness to falsehood, and if they pass by some evil play or evil talk, they pass by it with dignity. "From among my followers there will be some people who will consider zina (illegal sex), the wearing of silk, the drinking and the use of musical instruments, as lawful. And there will be some people who will stay near the side of a mountain and in the evening their shepherd will come to them with their sheep and ask them for something, but they will say to him, 'Return to us tomorrow.' Allah will asunder them during the night and will let the mountain fall on them, and He will transform the rest of them into monkeys and pigs and they will remain so till the Day of Resurrection." - Bukhari 5590 Exception: The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ peace and blessings be upon him) entered upon her and there were two girls with her who were beating the duff. Abu Bakr scolded them, but the Prophet ﷺ said: "Leave them, for every people has an 'Eid." - Nasai 1593 "The Messenger of Allah ﷺ said: 'What differentiates between the lawful and the unlawful is the Duff (simple handdrum), and the voice (singing) for the wedding.'" Nasai 3369, Nikah Abu Hanifah said: "it is not permissible to pay anything for singing and wailing. This is our view. And he said: musical instruments are the wine of the soul, and what it does to the soul is worse than what intoxicating drinks do." (Majmu’ al-Fatawa, 10/417) Ibn Abi Shaybah (may Allah have mercy on him) reported that a man broke a mandolin belonging to another man, and the latter took his case to Shurayh. But Shurayh did not award him any compensation - i.e., he did not make the first man pay the cost of the mandolin, because it was haram and had no value. (al-Musannaf, 5/395). Al-Baghawi (may Allah have mercy on him) stated in a fatwa that it is haram to sell all kinds of musical instruments such as mandolins, flutes, etc. Then he said: If the images are erased and the musical instruments are altered, then it is permissible to sell their parts, whether they are silver, iron, wood or whatever. (Sharh al-Sunnah, 8/28) Shaykh al-Islam Ibn Taymiyah (may Allah have mercy on him) said: "The prohibition only has to do with listening, not hearing. Hence if a man passes by people who are engaging in some prohibited kind of talk, he is not obliged to block his ears, but he should not listen unnecessarily. Hence the Prophet (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) did not instruct Ibn ‘Umar to block his ears when he heard the shepherd’s flute, because he was not listening to it; rather he was merely hearing it." [Majmoo‘ al-Fataawa 11/630]

[@roman8929]

Your a good man brother - i really enjoy your perspectives on these videos and look forward to your uploads. The dawah you are giving is straightforward, no nonsense and fair. May Allh bless you brother - keep up the god work.

[@omarelghoul9256]

When u said we should respect others but without compromising the truth... It brilliant 💯👍👍👍👍❤️❤️❤️❤️. U said what salafi Ulama r trying to establish

[@mohammadzain32]

But abdul wahab najdi was munafiq Jahannami

[@adenmohamed4956]

Jazakallahu kheyran Yaa akhii 🤲 thanks alot

[@SA1F]

Peace be upon you, my brother. Regarding the issue of music, I would like to say that there is a great misunderstanding among Muslims who do not speak Arabic, as they do not differentiate between the ruling on singing and the ruling on music, because music in Islam is prohibited in all cases and is not permitted even in weddings or events, but the issue of singing is different among Muslim scholars, as some of them forbidden it and some say that it is only hated ( mkroh) based on the meaning of the words during singing, and this is a common mistake among non-Arab Muslims or those who do not speak Arabic because of the lack of distinction between the meaning of the word singing and music in Arabic. May God reward you with good.

[@ahmedfadhil9682]

Eid mubarak Brother. Hope you had an amazing First eid experience. Your sincere youtube follower.

[@awsiesamurai]

You should read imam ghazali's alchemy of happiness.📘

[@TheBobbysPerspective]

I'm at it!

[@procrastinatingperfectionist]

17:41 as far as I know u can paint nature scenes like mountains etc

[@H.Severloh]

As-salamu'alaikum my beloved brothers and sisters 👋🥰

[@yaserhady-kr7hc]

Waalaikum assalam

[@tabassumsultana4279]

Walaikum assalam 👋

[@marufhossain8909]

ওয়া-আলাইকুমুস সালাম ওয়া-রহমাতুল্লাহি ওয়া বারাকাতুহু

[@lutonzmn]

Very appealing videos and positive mashallah

[@Anonymous-co3jv]

Music is Haram, yet only one instrument was allowed by the Prophet Mohammed peace be upon him in weddings, Eid, and celebration. The instrument is similar to the tambourine where one side is closed and opened from the other side. However, unlike the tambourine, it doesn't have the coin shaped things on the edge of the instrument.

[@lloollllooll2307]

As salaamu alaykom May Allah keep you steadfast upon islam This an advice that we should all learn our aqeedah(creed) , the aqeeda of the salaf as Salih from scholars and students of knowledge that are upon clarity Barakaalu feekum

[@yassinzakar]

The issue is some people begin the discussion with insulting or spreading rumors as if it is a fact and demands us to be respectable of the so called opinion. If the Muslim is respecting them as human not the opinion, it is a form of grace and hope that other person is just ignorant not also arrogant. If someone is respecting rumors and insults, It is just like accepting falsehoods.

[@SAali-yb7bq]

MashaAllah welcome brother to the light of your creator Allah s.w.t ✨️ 💙 ❤️ 🙏

[@elhamhermas1554]

يارب لك الحمد على نعمة الإسلام

[@xeroz9762]

there is a hadith in sahih bukhari that in which the prophet says: there will come a time when Muslims will make music, alcohol, zina, lawful... which means music is haram

[@khalidalmalek4808]

Make dhikr of Allah oh muslims for time indeed goes by like the wind 😊❤

[@tyanie1994]

Assalamu'alaikum my brother bobi, MashaAllah ❤👍

[@aqibpeer7451]

The traditions of the Holy Prophet (saw). Rabi', the daughter of Mu'awwiz ibn 'Afra, said that the Holy Prophet (saw) came to me on the day of my wedding and seated himself on my bed just like other kith and kin. So our Ansar sisters began to play on 'Daf' (musical instrument) and sing in praises of martyrs of Badr. When one of the girls began singing in praise of the Holy Prophet (saw) he stopped her and asked to carry on singing as before. Firstly we need to differentiate between music and singing. As mentioned in the above hadeeth there is no harm in singing praises of martyrs or ethical words in general in a wedding. But any kind of musical instruments except the one sided Duff are totally prohibited whether in a wedding or anywhere else

[@publicpm8809]

Assalam o Alikum Wa Rehmat ullah and Eid Mubarak Brother. Want to rectify following two things in this video:- 1. Music is prohibbited, hadiths says that in the later days(nearing Judgment day) muslims will make Liquor, Music and Silk halal for themselves. 2. Photos, Statues are not allowed in homes, Hadiths says Angels dont enter homes where you have pictures hanging. Thanks

[@fahimredwan]

Love your videos Bobby🎉🎉❤..I am proud to be muslim alhamdulillah☝☝..Love from melbourne🇦🇺🇧🇩

[@patrickstick8249]

True muslisms do not live in western countries

[@tomolo2619]

Son of God does not mean that God has a child in Christianity! *what a mistake in the Qur'an!* Son of God are 2 titles one referring to the Word of God and one referring to creation (humans, angels, demons)

[@tomolo2619]

*what a mistake in the Qur'an!* Allah himself testifies that he has a son and he is the son as Christians understand it! Only the Koran writer was too ignorant to know what Son of God means! Allah's word which created everything is Allah himself too! *The Word Allahs which created everything is the Son of God according to Christianity!*

[@xzil2167]

​​@@tomolo2619ource: trust me bro 👍 😂😂😂

[@curious4466]

​@@tomolo2619what? Hey bro are you drunk or something? When did Allah said he has son? Do you even know what is a father and his roles? A father's role is to give wisdom, teach basic morality and to protect from danger. In that sense Jesus called Allah as father because all Jesus's wisdom came from him. Make sure drink less. May Allah give you wisdom.

[@andimuhammadrifkialqadri4001]

10:43 regarding sports tournaments (and any contest/tournament as long as it does not have any haram element), you can even include a prize in the form of any type of halal wealth (even money if it is received in the halal way), with one condition: the funding for the prize should not be taken from the applicants/candidates. the halal way to include a prize in a contest or tournament is through a third/outside party (it could be from the organisers themselves and/or through outsourcing such as sponsors). similar to playing poker; playing poker is not haram if the prize/reward was not taken in the way of gambling/betting (gambling is basically that the winner would take the wealth of the loser[s] who risk their wealth for the game/contest/tournament).

[@eam_mohamed]

Music is Haram in celebrations and in all times... the only thing that is allowed in celebrations is الدف: Tambourine...

[@rtxz5697]

Exactly 💯 Any music is haram, ofcourse. Source: Sahih AlBukhari 5590 But women can beat on the duff (a drum like musical instrument) in three situations: 1. Weddings. Source: Sahih AlBukhari 4852 2. The two Eid days. Source: Sahih AlBukhari 944 + Sahih Muslim 892 3. When one who has been away returns. Source: al-Tirmidhi 3690/ Saheeh al-Tirmidhi 2913 Hope that helps 👍

[@Adamrevertislam]

Salam Br Bobby Eid Mubarak to you and your loved ones, may Allah grant all you’re duas and bless you’re family with peace and prosperity

[@baszm]

Music in Islam is quite polarising. But according to one of the most respected scholar, Al-Ghazali in his book Music and Singing, music is not inherently good or bad but the conditions and circumstances would make the difference between it being halal or haram. One of the examples given was that a love song if heard by someone who is married, and it reminds him of his wife and deepens the appreciation and longing for her, who is halal for him, then it is halal for him. But that same love song if heard by someone who is not married and evokes a feeling towards someone who is not halal for him, like a girlfriend or any other girl, then that same song is haram for him. It is an interesting book that dives deeply into the philosophical and technical side of Islam along with the many layers Islam has to offer for those who has the capacity to do so. But the disclaimer is that at the end of the day, one has to be sincere and deeply aware of one’s own self when dwelling into the grey area. When in doubt, it is always safer to side with avoidance. By the way, I am a Muslim and a musician, and far from being perfect. I am also aware of my own bias and prejudices regarding this issue. So I hope that we can live with the sentiment of agree to disagree and pray may Allah grants ys mercy in our shortcomings and open our hearts to shows us the right path. Wallahualam.

[@RenderingUser]

That is an example of song Song is different from music Music is haram

[@baszm]

@@RenderingUser It is generally understood in this context a song is usually accompanied by music. Please don’t argue for argument’s sake.

[@baszm]

@@RenderingUser Seriously… great pink drink debate on your channel and you’re talking about music being haram. Brother… please keep your hypocrisy in check.

[@RenderingUser]

@@baszm it's a video I made a while ago. I shift deleted my music folder some time ago and have been trying to say away. You try the same

[@RenderingUser]

@@baszm also no, I don't think it can be understood in that context. Considering we're talking about some very old songs al ghazili considered. Which aren't normally accompanied by music. Not much of a history professional so I might be wrong. I'm not arguing for argument sake

[@metaljy08]

There is a Hadith in Bukhari's book about Aisha daughter of Abu Bakr went to a wedding to one of Ansar (people of Madina), and the prophet asked her if she used اللهو (a music instrumentl for the wedding

[@Ye-lx3rz]

14:58 any sorts of music is haram including on weddings or others.

[@agp4580]

yup

[@rtxz5697]

Any music is haram, ofcourse. Source: Sahih AlBukhari 5590 But women can beat on the duff (a drum like musical instrument) in three situations: 1. Weddings. Source: Sahih AlBukhari 4852 2. The two Eid days. Source: Sahih AlBukhari 944 + Sahih Muslim 892 3. When one who has been away returns. Source: al-Tirmidhi 3690/ Saheeh al-Tirmidhi 2913 Hope that helps 👍

[@Ye-lx3rz]

@@rtxz5697true there are some exceptions but me personally wouldn’t like the music on me wedding

[@rtxz5697]

​​​@@Ye-lx3rz Not any music, but rather duff (drum like instrument). Plus, your choice man 🤷‍♂️

[@Ye-lx3rz]

@@rtxz5697 ye

[@arkacoolin]

My personal understanding of hadiths about music,... that what is forbidden is music that makes people transgress limits, such as nightclubs and satanic songs... if music is only played for the arts of entertainment, and something positive and useful, that's fine. Wallahualam 🙏🏻 may Allah protect us from all evil.

[@mairakhan921]

music is strictly prohibited in Islam.....it is not allowed in any case. Only a Daff(musical instrument) is allowed but music and songs and poetry is not allowed in Islam as it will take you away from the rememberance of ALLAH..... Other than this love your reactions .....may Allah bless you always and lots of love from Pakistan.🇵🇰❤️

[@helixtk]

Please provide a basis for which poetry is haram. Categorically, I have understood this to be incorrect; the Sahaba themselves engaged in forms of poetry. "The ruling on poetry is the same as the ruling on speech or words, of which it is a part. The well known, general principle is that which is narrated in Mursal ‘Urwah ibn al-Zubayr: 'Poetry is like speech: what is good is good, and what is bad is bad.”' If the poetry involves words of love to a specific woman who is not permissible for the poet, or encourages sin, then it is haraam poetry. But if it includes remembrance of Allah, blessings upon the Messenger of Allah, encouraging good qualities and good conduct, then it is poetry that is mustahabb and recommended."

[@amomentspeace23]

then by this logic tv and movies and hobbies are haram? such a flawed argument

[@chaosinfernoid9008]

@@amomentspeace23 No they are not? What are you talking about. Its makruh rather cauz it takes so much time away its like wasted. Music isnt prohibited cauz it distracts guys. Its a powerful tool.

[@jamaljamshaid144]

I don't agree with that

[@chaosinfernoid9008]

@@jamaljamshaid144 Why?

[@gunner5210]

14:17 -There's a difference between clean singing and music. -Music and instruments are Haram 100% whatever when and where they're being played. Singing with no musical instruments and bad words is Halal. -But only the "Daf instrument" is Halal in weddings and some celebrations.

[@Ye-lx3rz]

17:47 you can’t draw a living organism any sorts of it. You can draw the silhouette of Human but never the face. You can still draw the nature,Cities and etc,Etc

[@ionlyafraidofAllah]

As I know you can also draw face but that shouldn't be completed like don't draw eyes or ears then it's halal

[@AyariMorade]

May Allah bless you brother

[@atom_829]

Corrections: ➡️ Touching A Non-Mahram(Not blood related) is totally Prohibited (Doesn't matter on intention). ➡️All Music instruments are haram(whether wedding or not). Only One sided Duff is allowed. ➡️ Making Paintings of living creatures is totally prohibited. Allah (s.w.t) will ask the person to make it alive(The painted being) on the day of Judgement.(According to Authentic Hadith). "And Allah Knows Best"❤

[@ladan3208]

In regards to your first point intention most definitely matters, sometimes some of a non-marram can accidentally touch you via handing you products, or when you pay for certain things wheee cash / coins are required. It’s not your intention to touch the person but it can happen

[@haa8793]

​@@ladan3208i second you that is what it means unintentional

[@atom_829]

@@ladan3208 If you try your best to avoid such Interaction,And it happened without your consent, Then it is not sinful. And Allah (s.w.t) Knows Best.

[@kiruagon1839]

There is difference of opnion for point 2 and 3 i invite you ro do your research - but for point one i agree (as far as i know)

[@atom_829]

@@kiruagon1839 As for Paintings, Animals,birds, insects, humans are all prohibited unless drawn Headless. Other than that is permissible to draw(soul-less creatures).

[@tasyarina5800]

When you fall into sin thing about ( >> Allah sees you, >>Angel are Recording, >> There a fact called from the Grave😔) I ❤ Islam because Islam☝ with becareful it's Halal and haram thanks💚

[@MirMdNasif]

14:00 music itself is not haram, rather use of musical instruments is haram... Even a Nashid becomes haram due to use of musical instruments.

[@Orbit77777]

I have a shih tzu dog 🐶 and she is obviously not for guarding nor hunting and she lives among us in our home and we show her so much love that I can’t believe this would be haram act, we are taking great care of one of Allah’s creations and she is so comfortable and feels so protected by us, I feel in my heart that I am obligated to keep taking care of her until the end.

[@sham00ly75]

My understanding is that it is haram to paint things that have a soul, like humans and animals..

[@MrSongib]

14:54 in my layman understanding, if the music lean towards bad stuff avoid it in any occasion either wedding or anything else. i think we already know the majority of music is haram. they promote some negative stuff but never the less some promote good things, but the quality of the music can be question aswell interms of the melody and what not, since we knew that can affect the brain as well. there are some soothing music with just instrumental in it but there are some edm stuff with just instrumental but it lean towards banging your head into the wall. xd so yeah better avoid if its cause harm either you can see it or not. imo

[@poeticfeint9717]

Salam Alaykoum brother. I have 3 remarks: 1- Music IS haram, as far as instruments are concerned. This view is shared by the absolute majority of scholars of old (assalaf) and of today's world. One of the main arguments is this hadith: روى البخاري في صحيحه رحمه الله، عن أبي مالك أو أبي عامر الأشعري رضي الله تعالى عنهما، عن النبي ﷺ أنه قال: ليكونن من أمتي أقوام يستحلون الحر والحرير والخمر والمعازف ...in which the Prophet peace be upon him says that there will be groups (i.e an aweful lot) of his Umma that will indulge in instrument-based music (different from mere singing), alcohol, sex outside of wedlock and silk (men cannot wear silk). Note how all of these phenomenons go hand in hand in scandalous parties, orgies and places of evil. The cristalisation of materialism and hedonism. It is also very similar to alcohol in a way, not everyone gets necessarily drunk and commits crimes indulging in drinking, but those who do have their lives wrecked. Music, similarly, sways your heart, magnifies your emotions, whether they are bad or good, it intensifies one's anger (typical metal heads), sadness (those that binge listen to depressive music), sexual impulses (typical modern rap and pop) etc etc. Also, u will almost never meet someone hafidh of quran, intimately religious and indulging in music, and those who do, usually suffer from many akhla9 (character) issues. One exception would be "aduff" which is some sort of drum-like instrument to women in weddings. This was the only exception in hadiths for women. As for singing, there are many details, but usually it's okay as long as it's not excessive and having good lyrics that are either informative or educative etc (just like poetry). 2- No handshakes or touch whatsoever between men and women. He's mistaken or trolling. 3- Statues of soul-less beings are permitted. Like statues of buildings, cars, trees etc. Statues of creatures with souls, i.e animals and men, are prohibited, utterly, no matter the context (art or worship); for many shirk habits have always started in an insiduous and seemingly innocent way, like "we're making statues of these good people to remember them only", which is exactly what pagans of old said to their prophets. Paintings, too, can only be of nature or artificial as in mountains, sea, trees, rivers....anything that isn't human or animals; cars, architecture, inanimate objects...etc. All of this is okay as long as it's not of humans and animals. But there are some exceptions, like isolated parts of humans, like in anaotmy books, like an isolated hand, or microscopic pictures...etc Anyways many many details in this topic, but none of it has to do with "except for art". It's all about pictures of soul-equipped creatures. There are tons of evidence, one of the main ones: قال ﷺ: أشد الناس عذابا يوم القيامة المصورون متفق على صحته I hope this helps, brother Bobby and anyone that doesn't know about these topics. If anyone needs further proofs from the Holy Quran, Sunnah and what sahaba interpreted....I'll be glad to help. Just so u know that these 3 remarks are fairly agreed upon and present no controversy whatsoever in the scholars community of islam, hence you can verify this by yourself from multiple sources - and you will reach the same conclusion. Assalam Alaykoum

[@aimenhamami8902]

From my humble point of view, I support that this comment is right, and Allah knows best

[@al3atilahamohsin584]

We want you to comment on the priest who converted to Islam in South Africa for two months. It has been in Mecca

[@exomata2134]

Bobby, The thing is when it comes to music not everyone consider it haram but most do (some schoolers say that music is halal unless it has haram content in it the bad words and sexual meaning) , it's haram if it takes you way from god and warshiping ultimately Also they are special music that is absolutely permissible like madikh( madikh is a sort of a songs where we praise Allah and the prophet) , and the music made with daff (daff is music instrument like drom but isn't as loud) Listening to music is haram but isn't a major sin that why many people of the Muslim gen Z doesn't really care sadly.

[@Hyper07777]

I seen Guy saying Music and Literal *KILLING* As SAME SINS

[@jehandahir1263]

Growing up my Islamic studies teachers always told me that music is haram but for a song to be halal it has to have 3 conditions. 1st there can't be any instruments except the Arabic drum, 2nd it cant have any bad words or it can't have bad topics and 3rd it has to be a male singing and not a women. Allah knows best

[@صلِّعلىخيرالانام-ل3ل]

Actually brother the ijmaa of the scholars is that music is haram no matter celebration or what not, but singing and presence of duff in weddings is halal as long as words of the song is not haram...duff is a kind of instrument like drums with noticing it shouldn't overtake the song ❤

[@malekdjamel-eddine4084]

God Allah bless you dear brother bobby and reward you paradise inchallah for all what you are doing for the religion. Please be patient and never give up until you will enter the Gate of janna in peace.🎉

[@yfrufeyfryd2129]

A general islamic rule to follow regarding things you don’t know if halal or haram (of course you can always ask someone with knowledge): Everyday matters are generally halal unless proven otherwise by evidences. Ex. all food are halal except the ones forbidden. Worship matters are haram unless proven otherwise; meaning you cannot just pray 3 times instead 5 or create your own way of worship without evidence as its bidah (innovation).

[@HAmar-lc1gv]

For music, what I know is that only the tambourine is allowed, during parties and weddings as long as there is no mix or obscene lyrics, opinions differ slightly near of the 4 schools but they all agree that musical instruments are forbidden. As for training with it, I have no idea.

[@anyab812]

The thing about music is that there isn’t an aya or hadith sahih that explicitly says music is haram. There is one hadith that says only specific instruments are allowed, but some scholars say this hadith is weak. So you find different groups of muslims, some think that music is halal as long as it doesn’t spread and encourage sin (most popular music nowadays does), another group that thinks music is haram. You should look into it if you want to learn more

[@kellerdaboy9956]

Salam, Eid mubarak !

[@mustafahussein2892]

There is a big debate about music and painting. Personally when I go through something like this, I listen to both sides and decide which path to take. but In the end it is not a major sin. If you are a good Muslim, you will not go to hell because you listened to music, but you will be punished for it, and then you will enter heaven.

[@saintsour124]

the only instrument that is allowed is called the daff, which is kind of like a thing that is tapped upon and held with the hand, and used in eid, weddings, and other celebrations, beyond this there is no room of other engagements.

[@khalidbinwalid3352]

My brother Bobby. What do you think of Sweden’s actions towards Islam on eid Al Adha? Please make a video about it

[@Tinnin44]

The majority of scholars have held the position that musical instruments are prohibited with the exception of the duff (a special type of drum). However there are a minority of scholars that have held musical instruments to be permissible with certain conditions. So even if one were to adopt the minority opinion it does not mean that you can now listen to Miley Cyrus, Justin Bieber and Eminem.

[@AsfandyarAhmad-cm8fl]

There are some Muslims who believe drums are permissible, but no other instruments. Zakir Naik, maintains musical instruments are haram except for two-the daf (a traditional one sided drum) and tambourine, which are also mentioned in Hadith.

[@zariaalhajmoustafa2573]

‏‪16:46‬‏ the fight between the Albanian and Macedonian is more political and National then religious

[@TheBobbysPerspective]

Hats😂absolutely correct

[@zariaalhajmoustafa2573]

@@TheBobbysPerspective the problem and hate and fight in the Balkan is they Injected with nationalism is there said to see what happened Manchester Albanian and what is the Northern Slavs the same ethnic group and the same language the influence of nationalism look what I did to them

[@AbelOktavian]

Regarding favoritism, not only in Islam, even in Christianity it is haram. James 2:9 [9]But if you show favoritism, you sin and are convicted by the law as lawbreakers.

[@danielkhan1218]

14:28 Only the duff is permitted for weddings and celebrations and this is the consensus.

[@ahmedayman5563]

About the music ask sheikh Uthman

[@OneGodAllah]

Brother SNEAKO's in Thailand rn btw, do you guys plan on meeting or anything similar?

[@theblessedonewithfaith5644]

14:20 music is haram at all times, the one that they can play on wedding is 1 side drum

[@go_gym247]

Masha allah.allhamdulilla. your doing a great job.❤❤❤😍😍🤲🏽🤲🏽🤲🏽

[@TheGreatKatski-K9]

Asalaamu Alaykum Bobby, Music is not mentioned in the Quran, there is a part where it is perceived to be referred to in Surah Al Luqmaan but check out Nouman Ali Khan who questioned this to an extent of going to a Grand Mufti and even then it was found that its not explicitly stated that music is Haram. I believe it comes down to our own perception about what the music is telling you or influencing you to do. Thus if you feel something is pulling you into the path of sin then abstain from it. May Allah grant us all guidance. Ameen

[@anesmuhammad_thecalipher]

Actually , music is haram because there is a sahih hadith of prophet Muhammad (saaw) that said instrumentals are haram , therefore music is haram in both concerts and weddings and for listening, that's why there is nasheed.

[@nikolailang4157]

Before I reverted to Islam, I already lived a lot like a Muslim. Lowered my gaze toward women, hated gambling , and etc..

[@MysteryFinery]

14:22 @Bobby's Perspective , it isn't allowed Bobby. except normal singing, and some scholars allowed a specific instrument called "Daff" this video has right and wrong and it also paints an uncomplete picture.

[@rtxz5697]

Any music is haram, ofcourse. Source: Sahih AlBukhari 5590 But women can beat on the duff (a drum like musical instrument) in three situations: 1. Weddings. Source: Sahih AlBukhari 4852 2. The two Eid days. Source: Sahih AlBukhari 944 + Sahih Muslim 892 3. When one who has been away returns. Source: al-Tirmidhi 3690/ Saheeh al-Tirmidhi 2913 Hope that helps 👍

[@iso6610]

Salam and Eid Mubarak brother. I really like your content and I need to say that I really like your commentary in high pitch. Its really funny

[@astratr3b345]

13:02 only drums are allowed from all instruments that exist in world , in my language we called def drums

[@fishytick7516]

Daft drums are only allowed during special occasions

[@astratr3b345]

@@fishytick7516 yes bro like weddings or eid ul fitr or eid al adha

[@fikyd_]

"1000 year old book found in turkey contains a terrifying message" Reaction please

[@حسينمحمد-غ1ص3ع]

5:19 The prohibition of marrying aunts: They are the father’s sisters, whether they are sisters or half-sisters. Prohibition of marrying an maternal aunt: The maternal aunt is the mother's sister, whether they are two sisters or half sisters. - The prohibition of marrying the daughters of the brother: because the daughters of the brother are in the position and position of the daughters of man, and it is not permissible for a person to sleep with his daughter.

[@letmetalk2240]

@5:41 People of the Book refers to the followers of Prophet Musa AS and Prophet Isa AS who received the guidance in the form of Torah and Injeel. Bear in mind that both prophets were sent STRICTLY to their own people. I believe such people still existed during Prophet Muhammad's time. People who are not from their people can never be called the PEOPLE OF THE BOOK.

[@Khaled-wm1tu]

something called al daff is permissable in weddings it is like drum However, there were ahaadeeth that indicate the permissibility of striking the duff in some places, and they are: Eid, wedding, and the arrival of the absent. Here are the evidences, in order: a. On the authority of Aisha, that Abu Bakr, may God be pleased with him, entered upon her when two girls were with her during the days of Mina, they were warming and beating, and the Prophet, may God’s prayers and peace be upon him, was covered in his garment. Narrated by Al-Bukhari (944) - and the wording is his - and Muslim (892).

[@baker.marafat1750]

I am listening to you always and I am happy you have a lot of knowledge now on Islam you know now what are the rules, regarding music there is a lot of controversy about it, me myself I play music guitar as well as organ and keyboards and I am very good in it and I listen to soft music I don't see any problem in that as long as it doesn't motivate any desire in me.