New Strong Evidence for Existence of Planet 9, Here's What We Know

[@dustinosborn6269]

I don’t typically take planet 9 videos on KZbin seriously, but if Anton is covering it, it’s worth a listen. 😊

[@raisnaix]

facts

[@BobWidlefish]

💯

[@Ratzfourtyfour]

Same.

[@danielvermeer3363]

Mainly trustworthy as he will also tell you it's definitely not, if it's definitely not.😂😂

[@DNotzz]

That’s funny because science seems to always be behind “pseudo-science”. The problem is these modern scientists have become too skeptical. They’ve lost the ability to think “what if we have been wrong all this time?”. They think everything has been found and studied. They are so wrong. And this is just another example of that. Hopefully so,eBay soon they’ll come down of their high horse and realize the universe, reality, we, are a lot stranger than we could begin to imagine.

[@WynnofThule]

If a study ever comes out against Planet 9, you should title the video on it "Planet Nein"

[@kerolokerokerolo]

I was thinking all time during the video about possible names... all I could think of were deities names, but as it was kinda a different type of planet, I thought it could be cool naming it after an egyptian deity. your idea cracked me up thoug

[@Deletirium]

​@@kerolokerokerolo I would sign up to go explore Anubis, for sure.

[@phoenixjones7191]

​@@kerolokerokerolochronos because it took forever to find it

[@kerolokerokerolo]

@@phoenixjones7191 lol

[@kerolokerokerolo]

@@Deletirium I've always loved Ra or Osiris :D

[@ralphralpherson9441]

Ever since I learned about Quaroar, Sedna, Makemake, Orcus, and Eris, I have been fascinated with minor planets. I love how bizarre and unexpected most of them turn out to be (like having weird shapes, or rings outside its Roche limit, or bizarre moons). How amazing would it be to have the technology to visit these bizarre frozen worlds? Sometimes space is so vast and amazing it gives me chills.

[@andrewfarrar741]

Can you imagine trying to name all of the planets?

[@ralphralpherson9441]

@@andrewfarrar741 You mean like, in the solar system? Or the galaxy? Or the Universe? Because even in the solar system you're gonna be a while.

[@andrewfarrar741]

@@ralphralpherson9441 We can also MakeBelieve™️ humanity exists in an infinite expanse of universes, each containing countless atoms, stars, galaxies, and realities. Who knows, maybe our universe, with all its complexities and wonders, is just a tiny atomic particle in the grand tapestry of the Supraverse™️ which contains the Metaverse©️.

[@DashMcdash-gz4qq]

​@@andrewfarrar741no

[@ralphralpherson9441]

@@andrewfarrar741 That would be nuts, however.... I always found the Metaverse/Multiverse theory to be a shitty lame argument. Its just a non-theistic place-holder for God. (An extremely vast powerful thing we cannot observe or detect by any means, that explains a lot of shit we dont understand yet). Hence, lame argument. A "God of the Gaps" argument for atheist cosmologists.

[@CarlForgey]

The search for planet nine has been going on for so long, it started out as the search for planet ten!

[@dearthditch]

😂 I’ll be happy so long as the people who deleted the 9th planet aren’t allowed to help name the replacement

[@rogerwilco1777]

@@dearthditch Its gonna be called "Not Pluto"

[@metalswifty23]

​@@dearthditch I'll be happy if they call it Mondas

[@uncertaintytoworldpeace3650]

They should name it brap hog

[@allentac6222]

@@rogerwilco1777 Well that would be Goofy. I’ll show myself out.

[@jordanremington]

I found your channel about 3 years ago and I try to listen to every video you drop. I am very poor and unable to donate, but when I have money some day I promise to give you a donation to say thanks for doing what you do. Thank you Anton!

[@barbthegreat586]

Take care, Jordan and enjoy free resources!

[@phillm156]

Yes, KZbin can be full of knowledge and resources. Use them to further yourself.

[@jordanremington]

@@barbthegreat586 that is greatly appreciated! I hope you are well and keep supporting Anton!

[@jordanremington]

@@phillm156 thanks for the response, I try everyday to learn something new. Hope all is well with you brother.

[@JenMaxon]

Just by turning up and clicking the thanks button you are making a contribution. So don't sweat it. I hope you enjoy the videos as much as I do

[@ryanwoods5493]

I tune in for Anton because he speaks directly to the point. No CGI or AI coupled with click bait video titles.

[@markamd1]

Calm down 😂

[@TheMeritCoba]

Instead, you get an 11-minute video(because of the ads) that could have been five minutes long and doesn't deliver. I stopped watching his channel because of his tendency to pad his videos, and here I am again, falling for it.

[@DonnaChamberson]

I love Antwon’s peen

[@antmarghearth-veg-flat]

all cgi..what? a bunch of bs like religion

[@ryanwoods5493]

@@antmarghearth-veg-flatis your hair blue?

[@skateboarder27292]

There’s very few people who’d get a click from me talking about planet 9… but Anton is one of them. 😂

[@rogerwilco1777]

ITS FULL OF LIZZURD PEOPLE!!!, (trust me! I watched ancient aliens!!!)

[@traveler263]

is planet 9 also flat ?

[@lifedevice]

@@traveler263 Yes, probably flat. Likely has nazi bases all over it too, like everything else in the solar system. 🤣

[@PASHKULI]

Guys, it is not a planet! It is a dwarf (and dead) star, brother to our Sun. Our solar system is a binary star system. By the way Jupiter once could have also become a star but it did not.

[@aquarius5719]

Think of it. Oort cloud has plenty of objects. What are the chances of having planets with high inclination?

[@marcse7en]

Before Pluto was reclassified as a dwarf planet, in 1966 there was a Doctor Who story called "The Tenth Planet." It starred the first Doctor, William Hartnell (1908 - 1975) and introduced the Cybermen from the planet Mondas.

[@RaikenXion]

Nibiru is "Planet X"

[@commodorezero]

Eris was briefly considered the 10th planet for a few months.

[@thisissupposed]

I knew of Ceres and Pluto for most of my life (some of my classmates called me crazy for drawing Ceres with the other 9 planets) but I only just learned about Quaroar, Sedna, Makemake, Orcus, and Eris. Now I'm interested in Planet 9 as well. Just imagining all of these are out there makes me get the chills.

[@howiewood]

My favorite Space Dude!! I grew up in Houston Tx.,during the Apollo era,and was a school kid when we lost the Challenger shuttle. The resurgence of the space industry is much appreciated, n I feel needed. I love your subtle accent ,and no matter where you got it ,you're as American as apple pie in my heart. You are a great asset to science ,education and one of my favorite obsessions. Im back in school, pursuing a Mechatronix degree...Your take on stuff is passionate, and I think ,very genuinely refreshing. I think n feel that U r one of the beautiful people in my life and you always lift my spirits and give me a fire under my ass to study more diligently. I have a good feeling that you have a similar affect on others as well .plz keep it coming,Ive been following You for a good long while and wont stop watching and learning from you ,so dont stop,you're doing agreat service to me and many,many others. You seem like the kinda guy Id enjoy having a beer or five with,.. maybe one day, ..Ican dream and I know that you're a dreamer too ,.Peace Out,,Howie from Houston. ;)

[@matthewdudael1931]

Hi Howie ! Please what is Mechatronix ?

[@grumblesmudie3141]

Way back in the mid 1990's I had a friend who used to talk about this but the difference was that the planet was orbiting almost 90° to the other planets.

[@smurt1403]

I consumed 6 sausages today.

[@jonstfrancis]

Yes, I remember that concept too.

[@greysunited7317]

@@smurt1403 Probably not the food kind ;)

[@FitzgeraldStanburyWeissV]

@@greysunited7317 LMAO

[@PASHKULI]

Guys, it is not a planet! It is a dwarf (and dead) star, brother to our Sun. Our solar system is a binary star system. By the way Jupiter once could have also become a star but it did not.

[@ricsim78]

Anton is always worth listening to. While other videos contain clickbait titles, Anton tells facts as they are known.

[@MyraSeavy]

It will be so interesting to finally know! One way or another! I'll be patiently waiting! 😊

[@archmage_of_the_aether]

Not me, I bought my ticket, I'm going out there to check for myself

[@christinabeanma6618]

Spoiler alert. It's the oort cloud. 😅❤ Thank me later

[@VikingTeddy]

It's the blackhole future humanity will use for interstellar travel.

[@bigguy7353]

It's called Pluto. Since what? 1954 or something?

[@bigguy7353]

​@christinabeanma6618 Right because you know everything. Ok.

[@dg8620]

If aliens land one day and its being covered by all the networks, I ain't stockpiling toilet paper until Anton confirms it.

[@william14able]

Get a Bidet now, just for preparation

[@brigidsingleton1596]

​@@william14able Does that mean that if you (?)/ America(?) has _Biden_ ...that you(?)/America(?) is / are already _more than_ three-quarters the way there...?!

[@IanHobday]

If you wait for confirmation, all the TP will be gone. Always keep an extra pack at home...

[@clemlo4973]

Stock pile toilet paper but do not forget youre towel.

[@leighz1962]

Make sure to check the expiration dates on toilet paper. Don't want the old stuff.

[@waynesmallwood6027]

People tend to forget that the diameter of our solar system is based on our sun's gravity well, not the Oort Cloud. Our Sun's gravity well is approximately equal to the Centauri System's gravity well at around two (2) light years. That's how far out something could be orbiting, at any inclination, and only recently getting close enough to noticably influence orbits. "Could be," not "positively is".

[@racookster]

If anyone had told me twenty years ago that our understanding of our own solar system was incomplete (as Zecharia Sitchin heads sometimes did), my response would have been, "You're crazy. We've got it pretty well mapped out." I might have been wrong about that.

[@RandOm-hr5jn]

Yup, it seems it pretty much depends on whether we are lucky to spot it or not, finding planets in our back yard turns out to be more difficult than first thought

[@7xr1e20ln8]

I think the lesson here is to be humble. Everyone trashed Sitchins hypotheses outright.

[@johnbox271]

"In 1874, Max Planck's advisor, Philipp von Jolly, a Munich physics professor, told Planck that studying theoretical physics might not be a good idea because there wasn't much left to discover. Planck told the story in a 1924 lecture, saying that von Jolly described physics as a mature science, with only small things left to examine and classify." 😉

[@Lund.J]

The Vatican's infrared telescope is named Lucifer for a reason. PlanetX manifests through heat(aether) before its dim reddish light is seen. Mythologically, it has several names, depending on the point of view: In a way, it is the counterpart of the archangel of the sun (the supresser of the dragon, Michael). On the other hand, it is the fallen Elohim (6th Sephira), the sun-demon ("Sorat"), the "failed sun", in which sense it is the counterpart of the Creator, or the Destroyer. Jeremiah 48:8 Jeremiah 48:18 Jeremiah 51:48 Jeremiah 15:8 Exodus 12:23 and many others...

[@Lund.J]

The Vatican's infrared telescope is named Lucifer for a reason. PlanetX manifests through heat(aether) before its dim reddish light is seen. Mythologically, it has several names, depending on the point of view: In a way, it is the counterpart of the archangel of the sun (the supresser of the dragon, Michael). On the other hand, it is the fallen Elohim (6th Sephira), the sun-demon ("Sorat"), the "failed sun" ("dwarf"), in which sense it is the counterpart of the Creator, or the Destroyer. Jeremiah 48:8 Jeremiah 48:18 Jeremiah 51:48 Jeremiah 15:8 Exodus 12:23 and many others...

[@rhysun]

Imagine discovering a black hole that's close enough to send a probe to.

[@leepatterson5710]

So much science could be gathered, and we could learn so much about the universe from such an object so close.

[@QH96]

We should first send some probes to uranus.

[@Hiznogood]

I would sleep better not having a black hole that close!

[@nekdozahadny4846]

It's like every physicist wet dream... But I doubt it will be black hole :/

[@noobslayer815]

@@Hiznogoodit is still so far away from earth that it wouldn’t matter

[@user-dreamers1987]

Hi Anton, thank you for all you do on youtube. I appreciate it very much. Welalin!

[@TheSlayneProphet]

There is something about that smile at the end of your videos. Plus, they are always so informative. Thank you, Anton!

[@LDSG_A_Team]

I have been waiting for you to talk about this, Anton! Thanks!

[@polygondon]

I planned to write a comment Anton would see, but this channel has grown so much since I last looked. It's been such a long time. You deserve all this success!

[@mleise8292]

At least we see you 👋🏼😊

[@CaseyW491]

In case nobody has told Anton today, you too are a wonderful person. Ill always choose to listen to him on anything before just about anyone else. Edit: We need more positive and uplifting people in this world. Be kind, everyone.

[@lindaseel9986]

Well said. 😊

[@jamessoucy3740]

Agreed!

[@eddiebowens1919]

It will always be planet X to me, You know 10. I with Jerry on this one.

[@leighz1962]

China says it is an 11th planet, Xi

[@eddiebowens1919]

@@leighz1962 awlsome

[@Trucking4Jesus]

@@eddiebowens1919 very awlsome

[@dj.j5099]

I'll seriously call it Nibiru 😂

[@jlert7297]

Yep

[@mrexists5400]

Would be awesome if it was actually a black hole, we'd finally be able to throw random stuff at a black hole to see what happens

[@l10zzardk1ng2]

What if it throws "stuff" back at us?😅

[@brianwesley28]

​@@l10zzardk1ng2Like Species 8472 if the Borg don't leave them alone in peace.

[@disasterincarnate]

celestial rubbish bin.

[@sneeringimperialist6667]

If you threw a comet into it, the radiation pulse would sterilize earth...

[@Ninjaned]

I volunteer to be thrown 🙋🏽‍♀️

[@boxy3087]

Black holes in our solar system would be astonishing and scary at the same time

[@jero4059]

A solar system in our black hole.

[@George_M_]

A black hole the mass of a planet would have no effect on the system beyond that a planet would've had. They don't magic extra suck gravity. It would just be really hard to find.

[@boxy3087]

@@George_M_ you’re right.

[@inesis]

Finally, a video about planet 9 on KZbin that isn't complete doodoo!

[@douglaswilkinson5700]

Anton lists the sources he uses to create his videos. You can read them for yourself and judge ther quality for yourself.

[@curiositycloset2359]

Event horizon has the actual guys writing papers on it. There's probably Something there. But it's a needle in a haystack, looking for a dark object somewhere in space.

[@fredericjanelle]

Gaston Lagaffe!?

[@bigguy7353]

Yeah it's called Pluto.

[@cherriberri8373]

​@@bigguy7353 no, you confusing dwarf planets for planets. Pluto is a wanderer like the rest but just quite, quite small

[@aaron_d_henderson1984]

great information. I still think some of these TNO's are a product of our sun capturing objects that other solar systems may have ejected (which partially explains their orbits). but it does make sense for something like planet 9 to exist, even after the hundreds of TNO's we have discovered.

[@plektosgaming]

Absolutely. Our own galaxy is oddly shaped due to a previous collision with another cluster about 10 billion years ago. When we collide with Andromeda in 4-5 billion years, it will create more oddities, I'm sure.

[@goobot1]

Could even be something that was once there and then got ejected and we are just seeing it’s past influences

[@plektosgaming]

@@goobot1 Because of that past collision, every 40-60 million years or so, something "bad" happens to most solar systems as a large number are displaced slightly. I'm sure you know about how our sun wobbles up and down as it circles our galaxy. It shouldn't do that. And so we get rogue asteroids, things captured or ejected, and on and on. A lot less stable than we thought it should be. And why always being on one planet kind of IS silly, long-term. But we are talking about tens or hundreds of thousands of years, not decades, so we do have time.

[@lostboytnt1]

Glad to see you back and feeling better!

[@dexio85]

He looks drunk though - slured, slow speech, etc. I got used to his word cadence and speech over the years, it's easy to notice :(

[@FutureChaosTV]

​@@dexio85 I disagree.

[@chadatchison145]

As unlikely as it is I'm hoping it's a black hole, can you image how exciting it would be to have a black hole so close to us, the experiments would be almost endless and invaluable.

[@Friendlygiant666]

Yes and no. Yes because of exactly what you said and the things we can find out but no because of how terrifyingly destructive they are and what they could pull out from the Ort cloud and send our way

[@QH96]

The whole planet should vote on who to throw into the black hole once a year.

[@leepatterson5710]

@@Friendlygiant666 How would a Neptune sized BH be any different than a Planet 9/X the size of Neptune?

[@XavionofThera]

@@leepatterson5710 If something goes inside the black hole couldn't it flare gamma rays that could be bad for us?

[@OscarGonzalez-ld4np]

​@@leepatterson5710 Small correction, that would be a black hole with the mass of Neptune. Its size would be on the ballpark of a basketball which is not that terrifying even though it absolutely can tear anything apart. A black hole with the _size_ of Neptune would probably be an issue.

[@Daydream3rz]

I love Anton so much. He always makes me feel welcome and he’s always so polite

[@sp_ce.]

I’ve heard the certainty this study gives for a gravitational anomaly is 5 sigma. That’s really conclusive, 99.99994% chance (if the data and modelling are correct).

'Sigmas' don't translate into probability like that. I think what you quoted is the probably that we observe something at least as extreme as the data we did observe, in case their null-hypothesis is true. That's not the same as probability of the hypothesis being true. In this case, modelling error is one of the big things to watch out for.

[@jameshart2622]

Statistics like that are only as good as the assumptions you feed them. If there is some kind of systemic or observational bias, or other mistake, you can get absurd statistics results that mean nothing. Of course, the researchers know this and have probably already asked for help finding such things.

[@ClosestNearUtopia]

You realist just now? Planet 9 or x, depending on the moment, has been speculated in my 1970s spacebooks. Also, the dumb study released in 2013, like anton said, was already known in that time as wel..

[@KaitlynBurnellMath]

Worth noting it doesn't need to be a planet or a black hole, though. Could just be more mass than previously thought (more asteroids/comets/dust/whatever) in the oort cloud.

[@Wiseman501]

@@KaitlynBurnellMath Unfortunately, this is most likely the case... Some mundane space rocks rather than a super cool black hole we can study and play with. However, if there IS a tiny singularity so close to us, it would help explain dark matter, prove primordial black holes, which is pretty much locked in anyway, and provide stimulus for generations of scientists to attempt to harness its properties. But... Life is boring. Most likely just rocks... Le sigh.

[@lvlndco]

I remember an outer planet being thought about in the 70's. It's pretty neat that these teams have been able to find evidence supporting that it may be out there and will be found.

[@PASHKULI]

Guys, it is not a planet! It is a dwarf (and dead) star, brother to our Sun. Our solar system is a binary star system. By the way Jupiter once could have also become a star but it did not.

[@Wayouts123]

Disney ahead of you

[@AltGrendel]

It’s a Death Star hidden by the Imperium ages ago.

[@edwardfletcher7790]

A Death Star the size of Neptune ? 🤣

[@mrsamaritan6881]

The Imperium? As in the Imperium of Man from Warhammer 40K instead of the Galactic Empire from Star Wars? lol

[@Flesh_Wizard]

​@@edwardfletcher7790 a deathier star

[@felixar90]

It’s a Mass Relay

[@halburd1]

that;s what the moon was and we were the ewoks a long long time ago

[@marksuplinskas3474]

Thanks!

[@sweatysam6264]

No thank you for keeping this channel going I'm so broke I can only contribute my 2 cents definitely worth it's face value.😆

[@sweatysam6264]

I'm not the conspiracy type but if Anton talking about it I'm popping some popcorn and tuning in.🌌

[@nozrep]

yes and it’s not even a conpiracy, so, you can rest easy. It’s a scientific theory that they have proposed and done calculations for, only have not proven it yet. So now they are looking for the proof with all the telescopes and stuff. If it gets proved, great. If not, it is still ok. Because it wasn’t a conspiracy to begin with. But a scientific theory to which scientists are trying to apply the five steps of the scientific method.

[@Corteum]

Now you have to become the conspiracy type to entertain Anton's new findings lol

[@PASHKULI]

Guys, it is not a planet! It is a dwarf (and dead) star, brother to our Sun. Our solar system is a binary star system. By the way Jupiter once could have also become a star but it did not.

[@sweatysam6264]

@@PASHKULI True Jupiter needed roughly 4-6 times its current mass to become a star.

[@davidmcmahon4192]

Just wanted to thank you for all the awesome info over the years bro

[@kirkiem23]

My dad used to tell me stories about another planet in our solar system. He said it was a story passed down to him from an elderly Navajo man. He called it the golden planet, it had a different orbital plane than the rest of the planets and a very strange orbit pattern. I have videos about it on my channel. Thanks for making this video!

[@BxBxProductions]

same. the annunaki told my grand aunt planet 9 has such a weird orbit because it has a reversed grav field which is what holds the other planet in their respective orbits

[@kirkiem23]

@BxBxProductions it's so cool to hear other people were told these stories too. I was told the reason humans want gold is because the beings on that planet need it for their atmosphere, to block harmful rays.

[@FutureChaosTV]

​@@BxBxProductions What rubbish.

[@FutureChaosTV]

​@@kirkiem23 Gold is not very good at shielding radiation except for mostly infrared light.😊

[@ajlucky0076]

The Navajo tribe has not existed for long enough to be able to see the planet up close. This is because of how far away it is. Sorry to burst your bubble

[@pdmv8471]

I have a question. Is this "object" in or near (or its trajectory) the Pleiades, Orion, and or Arcturus? I ask because of both, the translations of the King's Library of Nineveh regarding the Anunnaki and Nibiru as well as the Old Testament of the Bible (specifically Amos 5:8, Job 9:9 and 9:11, and of course Revelation 8:11 and 12:3-4).

[@barkmaker]

Who else remembers it being called planet X?

[@tiranito2834]

Yeah, because X is 10 and Pluto used to be considered a planet at the time. But yeah, that is a far cooler name. We'll see if it really exists or not. But just imaginate, if it really does exist... it will be pretty interesting to see the reaction of all the people who already believed in its existance. They'll be all like "told ya so".

[@MrWowh]

A lot of people lol

[@christinevenner183]

Yep.

[@coreyh9175]

When Pluto was considered the 9th planet

[@Quino2]

Or Vulcan

[@victorunbea8451]

"Dear astrophysicists, your moms thought I was big enough!" Pluto.

[@Robert-mls]

I’ve seen quite a few space and what’s in it vids and I wasn’t impressed until I came across Anton about a year ago. I trust him to give accurate information. I thought it was about time to thank him for the knowledge he’s stuck in my head. You know … just a gift of like 7-8 dollars, may be less than Canadian, you know that it’s not much like the price of a coffee. I’m sure he would really appreciate it. Have a great day all!! I hope you all stay safe, healthy and happy!! 🇨🇦☀️😎

[@chrisgriffith1573]

I remember when they call this Planet "X"... back in the 70's. "X" for ten, as Pluto was still accepted as a planet.

[@BigRichfrank]

💯 they hated planet X Soo bad they clapped Pluto. .. Just couldn't admit the "conspiracy theoriest" were correct again.😉

[@jesusramirezromo2037]

Planet X and 9 are different, Planet X was not X because of 10, but x as in unknown, Pluto was belived to be Planet X originally Planet X was supposed to account for errors in Neptune's orbit, and would be the size of saturn, and in the kuiper belt Planet 9 is in the inner ort cloud and the size of Neptune

[@berserkasaurusrex4233]

It still is. They had to wait until everyone left the conference to make their fake vote because they wouldn't have won otherwise.

[@BigRichfrank]

@@jesusramirezromo2037 ?? Pretty sure planet X was way out and had a extremely large orbit around the sun . I think it was 30,000 years?? Fact is planet 10 was there all along 😁😁

[@jesusramirezromo2037]

@@BigRichfrank No, that's something they made up after they constantly failed to prove it exists Planet 9 has actual evidence, even if just math

[@john_blues]

It was cooler when it was Planet X. Planet 9 makes me think Bela Lugosi is about to show up.

[@KenjaTimu]

Planet X sounds like a Public Enemy album.

[@thhseeking]

Planet 9 from Outer Space :P

[@cybergothstudios94]

Bela Lugosi is dead.

[@thhseeking]

@@cybergothstudios94 Bela Lugosi is UNdead :P

[@hellskitchen10036]

We have a 9th planet, it's called Pluto.

[@theroastertaker3039]

I remember in 2015 when I was 10 fearing about planet X all the time lol. And remember you covering it and others. The memories when I wanted to learn about the stars haha. Glad to see you still uploading Anton

[@luxHMT]

Anton petrov has become my fav astronomer on yt, always up to date and blud actually knows what he is talking about

[@rundmk00]

tru dat blud lowkey

[@Rishi123456789]

I hope Planet Nine is real. Something about the Solar System having nine planets just sits right with me, bros.

[@kwjames87]

Heck yeah! :D

[@speed999-uj5kr]

Factually incorrect

[@Rishi123456789]

@@speed999-uj5kr Factually incorrect? As opposed to what? Factually correct? And how can that opinion of mine be incorrect? How can any opinion be incorrect? And, for that matter, how can any opinion be correct? I swear, you people get dumber by the day. lol

[@jamesmaxdavissands]

Sure can get strange out there when you post a comment . . . especially if you may accidentally have an opinion . . . SHEESH!

[@Gordon-r4h]

Actually there's 12 .. Martians Blasted Phaeton to pieces, an created the Asteroid belt from it 75k ya .. NASA, picked up mayday signals, sent from somewhere, 70/85k ya. Cuda been Phaeton.. Now there's 11..😮..

[@CasualCatOfficial]

I feel like Anton should do more videos on Planet 9, it’s one of the many space things that I absolutely love learning about

[@TimKeachie-o2e]

in 1960 on the cover of Time magazine; they showed a picture of Planet 9 but they called it Nibiru

[@michaelburns1096]

There was speculation in the 80s that IRAS detected a large body out there. With all this UAP stuff, I'm thinking of reading Stitchen... Planet 9's orbit hasn't been predicted to around 3600 years long, has it?

[@jamesblackwell5141]

Our solar system has encountered 'interlopers' though out history. Perhaps passerby stars and planets have had a gravitational effect we have not been around long enough to realize.

[@Unknown17]

Finally, someone is asking the same question that I am--namely, what if "Planet Nine" is no longer orbiting? What if it has gone rogue and is just gallivanting around the cosmos, never to return, like the dad who says he's just going to the corner store for some cigarettes and never comes back?

[@lucastornado9496]

@@Unknown17lol weird simile

[@jamesblackwell5141]

@@Unknown17 Whaddaya mean? He's not coming back??!! 😱😭

[@denysvlasenko1865]

"We" (as in astronomers who study this field) did realize that passing stars have a significant effect on outlying orbits.

[@Unknown17]

@@jamesblackwell5141 How can I put this to you gently? His orbit has become a bit eccentric.

[@carolbaughan8768]

Hiya, Anton!

[@gecsus]

I really enjoy your peaceful presentation. Unlike the high hype world around us, you present information that is well researched and you present it in well thought out and organized order. Thank you.

[@PASHKULI]

Guys, it is not a planet! It is a dwarf (and dead) star, brother to our Sun. Our solar system is a binary star system. By the way Jupiter once could have also become a star but it did not.

[@Demonrifts]

@@PASHKULI There are hypotheses that it may be a dwarf star. I always find assertions like this, said with full confidence and no supportive evidence, absolutely hilarious, though.

[@Taomantom]

Cutting edge as always!

[@hildepedersen8955]

Takk!

[@thomasm9384]

Great vid! love and peace to you and yours!

[@nekdozahadny4846]

Aliens in the observatory "they're onto us!"

[@l10zzardk1ng2]

It's never aliens though

[@tethyssurfer]

“A team of researchers” 0:17 convinced me right from the start. Those guys should be tumbling through space along with asteroids and other cosmic debris in your next video. At least they weren’t wearing white lab coats. Thanks for your informative videos Anton.

[@norbertzillatron3456]

When I hear "planet 9", it always reminds me of the special sf gem "Plan 9 from Outer Space". 🤪

[@BlackShardStudio]

SAME!

[@pooramelia]

Had a feeling I wasn't the only one.

[@nostromo7928]

I only watched that movie once and never will again. Viewed it in 15 minute increments and even then I thought I would start pulling my hair out! There's another old SF movie with Tor Johnson in it as a radiation-exposed scientist who goes mad and runs around in the desert trying to terrify people. I think it might be just as bad as Plan 9. Can't remember the title just now. 😂 Edit: The movie is called "The Beast of Yucca Flats."

[@michaelevans3904]

Thanks for the space info fix.

[@Kaasga]

I love the thought of desolate planets/dwarf planets so far away where time just stands still If not for the extreme conditions such planets endure i think they would be a rather peaceful place to be

[@stirfrybry1]

Nibiru? It'll be fun to see how the science community handles this topic

[@kayhawkins5925]

As much as people scoff at the idea of Nibiru many descriptions in the Sumerian texts have been found scientifically correct from the asteroid belt to the description of planets. If planet nine exists as a planet doubtful the public will ever know until it's no longer feasible to hide when it becomes observable in the sky.

[@ThoughtandMemory]

Nibiru doesn’t exist. At least not in the cuckoo way Nibiru fantasists think they know.

[@thegodofsoapkekcario1970]

The first Yakubians still live there and are at war with the Annunaki.

[@Nathan-jt8zt]

@@ThoughtandMemorywhat in the way that there’s a 9th planet, like strongly evidenced in the video?

[@ThoughtandMemory]

@@Nathan-jt8zt The nibiru of modern conspiracy brings doom and destruction. Frankly if that were real and had the claimed orbital period of the conspiracy our solar system would be a mess and we likely wouldn’t be here. Planet 9 hypothesis I have no issue with. It’s based in science not ‘woo’ peddled by the likes of Sitchin and every crank who jumped on the woohoo train of uneducated interpretations of iconography and cuneiform language that doesn’t even note nibiru as a planet of doom that visits periodically.

[@rogerkulpnik]

There are ancient texts that describe celestial objects, like the phoenix, perhaps others that have been seen at 138 year and longer periodicities. Some of these describe intense meteor showers, objects passing by and obscuring the sun that aren’t lunar eclipses etc. The dates of the reports match up also from cultures on vastly different global regions too.

[@hamstsorkxxor]

138 year period is way too short to a period to be undiscovered planet. 138 years is very short on astronomical timescale. It would put the planet well inside of the orbit of Pluto, not that far from the orbit of Neptune. At that distance, you'd be able to see a major planet using regular binoculars or a cheap telescope!

[@Janky2912]

Very good coverage, I haven't watched one of your videos in a while now, however other videos covering the planet 9 hypothesis I seen lately, felt unfinished.

[@bb5979]

Its crazy how we can look out thousands of light years away but we still dont know what is in our backyard 🤷🏻‍♂️

[@codename495]

If a small child walks in front of a brightly lit window at night you can see it pretty well, even from far away. In a pitch black environment a large person could stand within arms reach and you wouldn’t see them. We don’t see the exoplanets themselves, we see the drop in the sunlight when they pass in front of their stars.

[@jeffholt9437]

​@@codename495excellent analogy.

[@nk_3332]

The deep oceans would like a word with you.

[@benspiers6147]

Glad to see you back, Anton. I hope you’re okay.

[@melipie22fablet]

Yeah, I specifically wanted to learn about " Nibiru/planet9" but in the most respectable way... so I directly came to Anton of coursr🎉 thanks

[@zaxko86]

It still surprises me that we cant find stuff in our backyard but we can see galaxys far far away. And the beautiful pictures from the James Webb.

[@rais1953]

Is it strange that we can easily detect huge objects that give off a lot of light and other radiation but have difficulty detecting a small dark object that radiates nothing?

[@ssenyl]

Why? You can notice a mount 100km away from you, but you can't observe bacteria living on your own hand. These are the same, just different scale

[@watcherofthewest8597]

The replies are not wrong but you are right too. its the feeling that we should know what is closest to us best...but in life and scientific discovery it is often those things we are closest to that surprise us the most.

[@Jon-hh3gz]

Simplest answer is we are still young in science and a lot of stuff people might think we should have discovered by now haven't been

[@garyphisher7375]

@@ssenyl We can see both the mountain and the bacteria. What's your point?

[@Simon_Jakle__almost_real_name]

"We" keep on forgetting or abandoning that a star like ours would often begin with a silbling, so if "Nemesis" had left the solar system, a correction mode could have started sucking or accumulating mass from outside (aswell as the Hills cloud), building up Jupiter until it would be a surrogate for "Nemesis" ("Jupiter, you'll be a star one day"), gathering so much mass, gravitation or "solar system spin" to even deduct Kallisto from Mars making Mars tumble slowly. So with Mars-Kallisto the normal planet system would have been a double System, like Pluto-Charon. And there's a gap in the Edgeworth comet torus (the "Kuiper belt").

[@Farcehole]

Most educated comment in the section. People forget that the planets don’t have the same inclination, so any “evidence” could just be the result of the chaotic formation of the solar system billions of years ago. The other problem is that the only people studying the possibility of Planet 9 are desperate for it to be true, and they aren’t releasing the thousands of other models which could explain any eccentric orbits. Confirmation bias is a problem in science.

[@michaelleroi9077]

Good thing you called it Nemesis and not the unmentionable Nibiru! Oops! I mentioned it!

[@Simon_Jakle__almost_real_name]

@@michaelleroi9077 The struggle of argueing for the better words still makes me kinda stare through the mist, kinda triple-ing the load in the mind(mine) when communicating, as far as i think i feel that. Just like "the greatest of all time" is mostly just a record so far (a lot of improvable examples 'd appear), expecting to stay in perseverance, not wanting to gather "younglings" that would keep on trying to follow me. But "i'm so queasy" appearing in "the off"...

[@michaelleroi9077]

@@Simon_Jakle__almost_real_name word…(s)! I’m there!

[@johnsinclair4448]

Are you just making random space related comments?

[@jt8673]

I have been interested in the idea of planet 9 possibly being a primordial black hole for almost ten years, since I first read about the theory. I would have trouble finding the literature but as I recall if it is a black hole it would be the size of a grapefruit (or possibly a grape, I can't remember) so actually pinpointing it would be very complicated. The most plausible way mentioned to locate it was to measure red or blue shift from passing objects, which would be complicated as well because most of those passing objects have not been identified either.

[@jimcurtis9052]

Wonderful as always Anton. Thank you. ✌️😎

[@davidponseigo8811]

It is interesting that we can discover planets orbiting other stars but can't seem to find one in our own solar system.

[@ep8009]

It's easier when you have a bright star in the background to detect something crossing in front of it. This would be against the black background with all the stars, producing no infrared heat and being far enough away to be extremely dim. All theory but it's actually harder to see things past the inner planets but in the solar system

[@cherriberri8373]

Imagine you're trying to find something near you in darkness with a far away light source, but by taking photos with a camera. Most of those photos are going to result in nothing and not even be pointed at the thing you are looking for. And even when it is pointed at the right thing, the only light going back into the camera is from that far light source reflecting from the target into the camera. But looking for far away planets is like looking at a cars headlights, you can see pedestrians going in front of car's headlights even if you cannot see the person themself.

[@michaelbishop1863]

Great show and great work bro. Glade your covering this. I've been watching a KZbin channel for 2 years. He has videos and pics of some amazing things. But be prepared, it is very shocking. He also has maps and pictures of the Dragon, the one that the Bible speaks about. Becky Louise on Illinois also has pics on her KZbin channel.

[@ReptilianRichardRamirez]

It's just the evil rogue planet from The Fifth Element. Nothing to see here guys.

[@josephstaton4820]

LEE-LOO DAL-LAS MULTI-PASS!

[@BlackShardStudio]

That explains the Hershey's Syrup dripping down my forehead....

[@HombreDeLaNorte]

The “Rouge” planets could be my favorite planet color.

[@ReptilianRichardRamirez]

@@HombreDeLaNorte for some reason this device replaces with word rogue with the incorrect version every single time it's typed. I think i need to delete the cache again or something. So annoying bro.

[@halfstache1070]

Or Yuggoth.

[@drPeidos]

A black hole near us would be very scary.

[@lethargogpeterson4083]

It shouldn't affect us much. There is nothing special about a black hole's gravitational pull on earth. If a 5 earth mass planet is that far out, the effect on our orbit would be negligable. If a 5 earth mass black hole is out there, the gravitaional effect on Earth would be the same, negligable.

[@nel99999]

​@@lethargogpeterson4083 what is concerning is if it has any effects on comet belts and stuff

[@lethargogpeterson4083]

@@nel99999 Good point, I didn't think of that. Although note that the effect of a similar mass planet would be the same as a black hole for that.

[@nel99999]

@@lethargogpeterson4083 of course

[@drPeidos]

@@lethargogpeterson4083 Sorry for my ignorance. Isn't the black hole gonna grow and engulf us all?

[@DuneStar01]

Gotta give Brown and Batygin some props by still undertaking the Planet Nine hypothesis, after so many articles have been posted to disprove it.

[@juharoning6361]

It is Nibiru

[@pyresflood]

That's what they say

[@azazel0783]

Nibiru... That takes me back about 2 decades, the good ole days of KZbin

[@unoriginalname771]

@@azazel0783 I remember those videos about planet x or Nibiru back in the day. It would be kinda funny if planet x really existed this whole time

[@azazel0783]

​@@unoriginalname771 yea remember them, with that intense music to accompany it 😂. If it is, I wouldn't even bother telling ppl, let them find out for themselves.

[@pfzht]

Probably a combination of TNOs on different orbits and larger clouds of asteroids, variations in Oort Cloud density, doing the pulling.

[@riyadhfirdausehh]

Maybe physics itself is missing something.

[@KenjaTimu]

Most definitely. More than 1 thing.

[@mikegrimm9492]

I think we are missing something in physics

[@Tw33zD]

Saw posts online and been waiting for you to cover this thanks

[@milesprowr]

Petition to call it Yomama ☝😑

[@douglaswilkinson5700]

The petition needs to be sent to the IAU in Paris.

[@martinblouin3639]

isn't Yomama planet 69?

[@fajaradi1223]

Yomama is a brown dwarf

[@pacotaco1246]

Nah we are gonna call it Ligmah

[@seebarry4068]

Seconded.

[@isthisoneunavailable]

There's always been a ninth planet. Pluto.

[@angry_transvestite]

Are you a planetary scientist? If you're not, you're just expressing an opinion. Classifying Pluto as a planet was an error that has corrected. Feelings don't count in science.

[@isthisoneunavailable]

@angry_transvestite the definition of planet was changed by the IAU in 2005, there was never a calculation error. They "felt" that a planet should be a minimum size that happened to be larger than Pluto. There was no error, just people "changing" definitions cause they can, just like the APA of trying to say gender dysphoria isn't a disorder - we all know it is. Scientific consensus is a goddamn fallacy. Just because a group of experts agree on something doesn't make it true. The sun revolved around the earth according to the experts for generations, at least in Europe. They were dead wrong, and dumb. Now I'm not saying that there's a political or sociological motive behind the reclassification of Pluto, nor am I saying that it was done intentionally. What I am saying is screw the experts, I'm putting it in my model of the solar system, with an asterisk next to it if need be.

[@ashraile]

Ancient Aliens did an episode on this where they covered the layout of Tenochitlan or whatever it was called, matching our Solar System planet orbitals, and at the far end of the layout which seemed to be overlooked, there was a ninth pyramid (planet) far away from the rest.

[@DelBoy573]

Ancient aliens is a crock of sh!t and spews nothing but pseudoscience and conspiracy theories.

[@ajlucky0076]

Yeah right lmao. That's a bunch of bs. They didn't have the technology that we have. If they did, we would have known

[@ashraile]

@@ajlucky0076 The show is called 'Ancient Aliens' for a reason innit

[@Miaholmes4952]

Brown dwarf. Might even have a couple planets orbiting it

[@edwardfletcher7790]

Hmmm something like that would be MUCH easier to spot, unless you're talking Phobos/Deimos size orbitals...

[@MrBlueBurd0451]

Brown Dwarf is basically excluded at this point, WISE would have seen anything remotely that size.

[@smilebeatz5103]

ye in the video he said the JWT could pick something like that up really well because of its infrared capabilities.

[@edwardfletcher7790]

​@@MrBlueBurd0451The number of times Anton mentioned primordial black holes makes me think he's got a personal theory 👍

[@BeyondAldebaran]

@@smilebeatz5103Does anyone know what is the infrared range on JWST, or WISE? How cool can they detect?

[@micho510900]

Nibiru with Anunaki on it confirmed. Thanks Anton!

[@HifdonIm]

Elaborate please

[@johnnyclifford9423]

I was in the comments looking for this reference. Ruh oh, they're coming back!

[@nightbeast8105]

@@johnnyclifford9423 yes.. all hail our returning reptilian overlords 🤣

[@peppermintgal4302]

Nah, I think it's Yoggoth. The mi-go have prepared our scientists psionically for their arrival! We will soon see the oily rivers of Yuggoth running beneath great basalt bridges, the sky rimmed great green pyramids shambling with horrors from the pit of the shoggoths!

[@borismedved835]

((snicker))

[@trevormendez5363]

Let us all count together from 1 to 9:00 latest all get to go together and go to Sesame Street😂😅😅 Count Dracula

[@kurtdobson]

The Anunaki story is worth thinking about. The claim was they came to earth about 450,000 years ago from a planet (Iniru) with a 3600 year orbit around the sun that goes between earth and mars, and about 5 times the size of earth.

[@expression3639]

This claim was made by Zecharia Sitchin and has no basis in historical evidence.

[@Sathish-sd5kb]

​@@expression3639didn't he claim that he got that info from cuniform tablets of Sumerian tablets so the question is if that's true and how they knew about it!

[@tinkerstrade3553]

Smooth move there at 6:39 with the name. It's now unofficially named "Unpronounceable"! 🤣

[@PASHKULI]

Guys, it is not a planet! It is a dwarf (and dead) star, brother to our Sun. Our solar system is a binary star system. By the way Jupiter once could have also become a star but it did not.

[@Pichuscute]

Considering how seemingly difficult this planet is to find, it makes me question: do our models require Planet 9 to still exist in our solar system currently? Or could it be something that exited our system in some way or went through a collision that caused it to no longer exist? I assume the latter would still have enough evidence to figure that out, but who knows about the former, right? It'd be a disappointing answer to things, but as time continues to pass with more evidence but no discovery, you have to wonder if we are missing something like that.

[@rezking12149]

It's Nibiru! :O

[@babygoon25hrs]

Bro been teaching me about astronomy since i was like 12💀💯🐐

[@HVYMTL55]

If the math doesn't fit you must acquit.

[@azorian888]

1x1=2 not 1

[@blindtraveler844]

its probs just something passed by millions of years ago upset things and then continued on its way... but we can always hold out for blackhole, planet, megastructure or wormhole im sure someone else will add more highly unlikely things to this list but..... i suspect a few billion years ago something got kicked out and was lost into the void and kicked in some ort cloud objects as it went thru and derped all these objects which over billions of years have just changed orbits due to the roll axis they are on causing slight acceleration from radiation pressure from the solar wind resulting in the orbits we see today

[@n3v3r1s4]

definitely feels like a possible scenario yeah

[@dnocturn84]

There is a limited amount of time for this to work. Once this object has left our solar system, these distant objects and dwarf planets would soon recover from its influence and align themselves anew following the gravitational influence of the remaining known solar system. And soon human observers would not spot this cluster effect of them anymore. It's still not an impossible explanation, due to this taking millions of years to happen. We would be rather "lucky", to exist exactly at a time like this.

[@dr4d1s]

You are such a gem Anton; never change!

[@ImmortalLemon]

Maybe our solar system has a localized cluster of dark matter that’s creating the anomaly?

[@nekdozahadny4846]

Lmaooo I would laugh so hard if they proclaimed it as dark matter 😅

[@ImmortalLemon]

@@nekdozahadny4846 I mean my personal understanding of it is very limited. But from what I know, it’s high mass that has no visible origin. And apparently it’s everywhere because we can’t explain the structure of galaxies otherwise. So it wouldn’t surprise me if there was clumps of dark matter in our cosmic backyard

[@DavidPumpernickel]

@@ImmortalLemon Dark matter is pretty uniform in its distribution. It exists as a halo around the milky way, with increased density towards the core of the galaxy. As far as we know, there don't seem to be very small, very high density pockets like you describe

[@ImmortalLemon]

@@DavidPumpernickel that makes more sense. I still kinda doubt that a whole ass planet is the explanation for the weird motion in the solar system though. I’d sooner believe that it’s a result of the chaotic motion of all the garbage that we’ve passed through over the billions of years

[@cheebee2659]

I just had a localised cluster of dark matter, I feel much better now

[@markoa6999]

Could it be a dwarf black hole, does it have to be a planet.

[@adrianjameSASbury]

It would explain its lack of observation.

[@douglaswilkinson5700]

There are solar mass, intermediate mass & supermassive black holes but not "dwarf" black holes. BHs are described by their mass, spin and charge. There are dwarf stars. Our Sun is a G2 dwarf. But dwarf BHs?

[@davidwebb4451]

​@@douglaswilkinson5700Theoretically small black holes might have been produced in the big bang - these theoretical objects are known as primordial black holes.

[@lucastornado9496]

@@douglaswilkinson5700how have you never heard of a primordial black hole

[@sageastreaus7905]

My knowledge of space has expanded even more. Thank you once again Anton

[@12bigredd]

you mean NABIRU!!!! its got to have that name :)

[@jamalisujang2712]

The prolific yugioh handtrap is based on an unproven theory?

[@12bigredd]

@@jamalisujang2712 ? I just want plaent 9 called Nabiru is all lol

[@pwned2ice]

Hail The Giants!

[@12bigredd]

@pwned2ice maybe but still we can't let Elon claim it by calling it X lol

[@edwardlin2941]

The Annunaki planet. Check Sumerian history…

[@kromanaut]

Alway love your videos, Anton! You mention that it could be something other than a planet, for example, a primordial black hole, and it made me wonder: are there any possible explanations involving dark matter? Do proponents of the theory of dark matter as actual particles (as opposed to MOND or MOG,) posit that such particles could possibly clump together in such a way as to have a gravitational effect on the solar system, similar to what we are observe?

[@PASHKULI]

Guys, it is not a planet! It is a dwarf (and dead) star, brother to our Sun. Our solar system is a binary star system. By the way Jupiter once could have also become a star but it did not.

[@antmarghearth-veg-flat]

@@PASHKULI 😳😑😐😂

[@RemyMartinVSOP]

Annunaki are coming back. Look it up

[@theundone777]

Back when Pluto was still a planet, it was the search for Planet X and it sounded so much cooler.

[@antn8387]

Thanks for the update, Dr.