NEW Vatican Apparition DISCERNMENT RULES DISCUSSED- Medjugorje, Garabandal, El Escorial

[@JamesClark-i8z]

Thank you for that very clear perspective. Very helpful

[@epcotethan9557]

Excellent analysis! I really like how you always examine these things with an analytical mind, not jumping to conclusions. I’m really glad to see you back!

[@christopherhassan3822]

Father Miles, we truly appreciate your wisdom and guidance, especially in assisting us to navigate and understand matters as profound as the appearance of the Blessed Mother. Your understanding and perspective on these matters are truly exceptional, and we count on you to help us see the truth clearly. We would love for you to keep guiding us with your clarity and expertise; your leadership is truly needed right now. Thank you so much, Father! Wishing you all the best, and may Mary continue to keep you in her prayers.

[@Belladicta]

GREAT TO HEAR FROM YOU ‼️ Return to Tradition did a good job covering this as well. I'm so glad you are covering this. Thank you. God bless 🙏🥰

[@charlesleake930]

Apparition of Deam Matronam Nostrae to French children, Maximin Giraud and Mélanie Calvat, occurred at La Salette-Fallavaux, France, September 19, 1846. Pray Her Rosary well and often.

[@DanielFernandez-jv7jx]

There is something that troubles me about the apparitions of our Lady belonging only to private revelation. If this is the case, then what is the value and authority of the rosary? That too get relegated to "optional."

[@What-vw1jp]

The rosary existed prior to the apparitions. It's the poor man's psalter for those who can't pray the Hours. It's how we lay people can participate in the Church's unceasing prayer. That is true regardless of any apparitions. That said, the Rosary is not strictly necessary for salvation. That doesn't mean it's not important. Life vests aren't strictly necessary items for water survival, but they certainly help and absolutely should be worn on the water. It's far simpler and very profitable as a layperson to say a daily rosary with devotion and trust Our Lady to lead us to Our Lord, than to try to develop and maintain something on our own that may be too much and then we get discouraged and quit, or too little or too vague so we eventually forget.

[@fr.hughmackenzie5900]

1:32: What do mean by "God" anyway? (to paraphrase a high-up theological advisor to me at a recent conference)

[@francoisegregyi233]

So you're back at last! There's no supernaturality in the three "apparitions" you mention!

[@MeisterEck]

excuse me, but are you blind? please look carefully at garabandal: the girls knew the deepest thougths of persons around them, levitated above the ground and miraculous healings occured there even years later

[@What-vw1jp]

​That just means that people didn't wholely make it up, not that it's supernatural. It could be demonic. Everything listed can be caused by demons Secret knowledge, levitations, even healings are not beyond the demonic. @@MeisterEck

[@charlesleake930]

this is why you obscure the truth : La Salette-Fallavaux, France, September 19, 1846.

[@PhilomenaChristine]

Holy Ghost

[@Bertiesghost]

You should do a video on Chris Bledsoe’s encounters with The Lady. It’s the real deal.

[@charlesleake930]

1569: Pope Pius V officially approved the 15 decade form of the Rosary we have today, forever altering the form of Our Lady's Rosary given to St. Dominic and St. Simon Stock. Who were they to override Our Lady's instructions? The return of the heretical Our Father prayer was stamped by the Masonic Pius V. The concept of the 15 Mysteries is introduced as an excuse to blend the non-biblical Catholic faith with the heretical stories in the bible. Sola Scriptura was the dogma of Calvinists and Lutherans and at this time had crept into Catholicism.

[@MeisterEck]

one day we will know if garabandal was from god or not. When the greatest miracle since christ appears in the pines, then yes. Besides, Padre Pio, Mother Teresa and Pope Paul VI believed in it

[@charlesleake930]

blah blah blah ..... “I vow to change nothing of the received Tradition, and nothing thereof I have found before me guarded by my God-pleasing predecessors, to encroach upon, to alter, or to permit any innovation therein” - The Papal Coronation Oath, broken by Pius V.