Nietzsche's Ubermensch Or Iqbal's Khudi? Which is the right course ultimately?

This is a question posted on one of our channels by a student who opened up the minds of everyone and it became incumbent upon us to post the answer on all our channels.
Thank you for raising the standards of thought for all of us. Keep posting questions

[@MuhammadAbdullah-oq2xs]

اگر ہوتا وہ مجذوبِ فرنگی اس زمانے میں تو اقبال اس کو سمجھاتا مقامِ کبریا کیا ہے This is Iqbal to Nietzsche.

[@sardarkhan1367]

Urdu m krin ye aisy session please Sahil Sir.

[@arehaan4552]

Love u brother From kashmir 🖤💞

[@furqanahmed4093]

topic : rational thinking somebody : how to think?? sahil adeem : i don't want to make this 8 hour long session !!

[@zainmeeran2953]

True!!! 😅

[@shehlaasif5271]

OMG it is so much mind boggling talk, I listened twice, and going to listen one more, that I usually do.

[@x2umer]

And I'll write each and every word of him

[@mkbk9168]

Second time watching and want to watch again.

[@mkbk9168]

Brilliant!

[@adamson_07]

33:53 meanwhile my 5th time listening to this🥲

[@shaktipaulsharma4922]

Japan and Pakistan are two countries: Pakistan was created because Bakhtiar Khalgi burnt Nalanda; Japan was created when few monks who survived from the butchery of Bakhtiar Khalgi fled to Japan. Pakistan is a failed state ; Japan is a dynamic and vibrant country. Buddha ,2600 years ago, declared that there was no God and soul.

[@mahtabhailian]

اور کسی آدمی کے لئے ممکن نہیں کہ خدا اس سے بات کرے مگر الہام (کے ذریعے) سے یا پردے کے پیچھے سے یا کوئی فرشتہ بھیج دے تو وہ خدا کے حکم سے جو خدا چاہے القا کرے۔ بےشک وہ عالی رتبہ (اور) حکمت والا ہے ﴿42:51﴾ اس قرآنی آیات کی تناظر میں عبداللہ بن حرام کے ساتھ کلام کے واقعے کی اصل حقیقیت اور تاویل کیا ہے؟ راہنمائی فرمائیے

[@ig0ddessify]

Are you serious? 3-4 minutes? Sir this video should be watched over and over! To let it sink in! JazakAllah Khair, this is exactly what we need! I wish I could just come live there so you could DOWNLOAD all your knowledge on me! MaaShaaAllah you're doing an AMAZING job!

[@Officialelia-p]

I am come here again to understand better ya you right

[@AbbasiOfficial]

I love this, thanks for explaining some of the points I will share this with Pakistanis who are very anti Nietzsche and yet they have NO IDEA of his philosophy, many thanks again brother I hope you can do more such youtubes in Urdu for Pakistanis

[@madeehaumair3565]

It's not only Pakistani but also some critics in Europe misunderstood him.

[@sahildicaprio]

Sahil Adeem is our kind of Jordan b peterson. Love from indian occupied kashmir.

[@maverickkhan8341]

3 Times that has happened.(You missed Hazrat Abu bakr Siddique)

[@furqanahmed4093]

how could anyone watch 3-4 mins of this?? this is on another level of understanding.

[@amirshamshad1735]

After being inspired i wrote some words but dont know these are up to the mark or not کامل کر دی اوج بنی آدم کی محمد کے زریعے ذرا جھانک تو سھی ھے کیا شاھکار تو رب کا

[@umarfatehaan]

Tang Aakr Khud hee Noch Liye Apne Par Adeem, Dil Mutma'in Hua Na Kisi Bhi Udaan Se. Sahil Adeem's father Adeem Hashmi👍👍❤

[@saeedbaig4632]

You should talk in your father language English don't touch Ur du because it's your mother language.

[@mrnobody7440]

We want more videos like this .

[@ShahjadShaikh-cz5eo]

Aap tabligi jamat ka kam kar rahe hu thodi angrzi fhek kar islam ek zaheni bimari hai aur aap bahut hi bimar hu 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😢😢😢😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😅😅😅😅😅😊😊😊😊😅😅😅😅😮😮

[@cartoonqueen1895]

I don't believe darwanzim because why today monkey is monkey😮

[@vimalsingh7390]

Iqbaal do not question existence of God but wish to be subservient. He seeks only attention of god while writing his destiny. Irrational belief can not become a sound base of philosophy that is problam with theology..

[@foodies4284]

Please keep sharing such wonderful videos. One day these videos will create a thinking revolution. Coming generations have to go through this thinking pattern otherwise they may ruin. Allah protect all of us. ❤️

[@saadomar1101]

this man has wrong understanding of the concept of khudi.

[@zainmeeran2953]

Beautifully explained Sir!!! I have seen whole video, ALHAMDULILLAH! You literally changed my mindset. Thank you Sir!

[@israrahmed1871]

No brother I always listen complete videos and if I couldn't understand once I listen it again n again.. I looking for your videos n comments on any topics so please

[@blasty-gg]

thats how you make sense of difficult concepts , May Allah bless you and him :)

[@muhammadhusnain3230]

A.O.A sir why do you not make a complete vidio on masla kashmeer & palastine crashes and muslim ummah bcz mostly peoples included me that can not understand complete matters inside it thanx

[@Gazishahchak]

I am a kashmiri ask me.

[@53ajeem]

I totally disagree with u that Iqbal was influenced by Nietzche.I don't want to talk on how Iqbal turn this ideology towards Quran Sunnah seerat of prophet SAW. These was already existed in QURAN n Hadith sharif.

[@mubeensaccount]

Why u think like this sahil sir this video will watch only 3-4 minutes seriously when I started to listen this video i stop eating that I don’t want to miss any single word. Agar mujy kabi is sawal ka jawab dena pad gya to mere pas kya logical arguments hone chahiaey. Jazaka Kallah Khair sahil bhai

[@ziaulhaq4269]

Please work on audio quality

[@FaizJameel-w9c]

Ustad Sahil adeem

[@mamaonline7994]

May Allah guide us with right path and conviction. Thank you sir, have no words to express my feelings after listening this session. JazakAllahu khairun.

[@ahmadusman5847]

Wondering how do you see a person attaining that level of khudi with the ultimate reality of wahdat-Ul-wajood (the unity of being)? Those who have experienced wahdat-Ul-wajood have reached the pinnacle of selfhood? And vice versa.

[@evilprada101]

Zabardast tabsira.. loved it

[@saeedbaig4632]

بقول مولانا عطا اللہ شاہ بخآری " اقبال جب قلم اٹھاتے ہیں تو سنبھال سنبھال کر اور جب قدم اٹھاتے ہیں تو بہک جاتے ہیں ۔"

[@mohsinsaleem644]

Isko explain karien

[@goat-jd2cr]

We went through the whole video adeem sahab

[@faisalsaddique3323]

May Allah bless you shaikh! I always enjoy listening to you..

[@_Zardari_]

Wah ji wah, nibbe.

[@faisalsaddique3323]

@@_Zardari_ aagya tu jawan hoky

[@MrSaqibkhan2011]

shaikh?

[@faisalsaddique3323]

@@MrSaqibkhan2011 ustad i meant

[@MrSaqibkhan2011]

@@faisalsaddique3323 Jee bhaia vh mgy samjh agaya hai. Laiken how could he be shaikh? “I am the city of knowledge Ali is the gate” Jb apky nabi ne yae keh dia k tu ap ko iska yakeen nahi hai? Ap darwazy k pass kio naji jaty? Abhi ap bataya ga k ager apko kaba jaye k apko dil k marz hai ap kia kren gy? Ager aik acha engineer dil k bary maen bht achi baat ker raha hai tu ap kabhi usko ja k kahen gy doctor sahab ilaj kijia? Nahi ap expert dhndn gy. Dakhya Allah, islam, religion sab ka hai, her koi isky bary maen soch sakta hai samjh sakta hai bol sakta hai. Laiken ustad soch ker chunya. Abhi dekhya k khudi kia hai yae Ali ibn abhi talib ne 1300 saal pehly btaya hai laiken koi parhny k lia tyar nahi hai. Ajj ap comparison kerty hain laiken Ali ibn talib ki baat nahi kerty jo apky prophet k mutabik gate hai . Tu bataya kesy samjh payen gy?

[@sadiavine]

MA SHA ALLAH

[@AbdulSamadAli]

The Muhammadan Circle, دائرة محمدية: The descent of Adam and The ascent of Muhammad

[@mrooz7096]

Such unrelated concepts. Neitzsche's superior man is not the status that every man will achieve. Infact, there will be few. Khudi is available to all. Plus, to be a superior man, you have to throw metaphysics out of the future whereas Iqbal is filled with it. That is such a petty comparison. Khudi can be compared to Kierkegaard's individuality but no way with Neitzsche. Also, the first point that Darwinism drove Neitzsche is the right one because he himself talks about man as a pond scum. Plus the phrase that God is dead, remains dead and we have killed him is explicity explained by him. That Western tradition has killed itself/God by giving birth to natural sciences.

[@ahmadisrar9446]

Neitzsche uncovers those questions pertaining to human life, which were previously answered by various ideologies and invites humans to find answers to those questions on their own.

[@Wisdom_seeker313]

Although I learned about Nietzsche's Ubermensch for the first time ever and Iqbal's Khudi concept was really mesmerizing....loved it and learning a lot Alhumdulillah

[@faryalfaran4227]

Amazing !! Ubermensch understood finally JazaKAllah

[@azhariqbal6269]

SubhanAllah good MashAllah Khude ka ye taqaza hai khude mal raho pane Magher us ke by khude sy Jate rahe Khude apne

[@Shaqigujjar9422]

♡♡♡

[@rabiabasri7238]

I never heard anything this deep..i didn't understand Nietzsche concept..but I'll drill more Insha Allah.. Thank you for making us Think😊

[@ummebilal6151]

Shukriya.Very helpful.Allah apko salamat rakhe.Ameen

[@farehaaziz2805]

Keep it up. Saahil sir , u r doing excellent job. May Allah Subhanahu wa Taala grant you the best of both the worlds.

[@ahadkhankhattak9936]

Nietzsche would never have thought that a country would accidentally be formed in a corner of Asia and they would compare a great man like Nietzsche to a thief😂

[@Razzoronly]

Nietzsche cannot be compared to Iqbal , Iqbal is far superior than him.

[@Gazishahchak]

Iqbal is a legend.

[@shaktipaulsharma4922]

Iqbal wisdom encompasses Sailkot , so Iqbal Sailkotia. Nietzsche had a global wisdom. Comparing Iqbal Sailkotia with Nietzsche is your Thespian quality.

[@jalalshah1640]

What a grandeur extrapolation!May u achieve and pursue more.So content, was the lecture.👍

[@Sports7-u6b]

Thanks for English subtitles

[@ghufranata2717]

popped up in my search bar. wow

[@janktoty4043]

Bhai urdu me hi kr lety to acha tha...

[@abdulwahidhameed]

Thanks for sharing

[@farehaaziz2805]

I have listened the whole video.

[@dinalizi3955]

♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️

[@truthprevails3193]

Jazak Allah khair

[@asiajafri2027]

Aslamalaikum

[@AbubakarFarooqui]

Sahil Adeem 😍👌

[@Ocean5-6]

Keep it up

[@Live-Fitness]

Iqbal concept of khudi didn't come from nietzche, he was irreligious man while iqbal was a momin. Do you even know what you are saying

[@owaismazhar9990]

Janab kuch parh tou lein Nietzsche ko

[@Live-Fitness]

@@owaismazhar9990 aur ap kuch iqbal ko parh laye

[@rabiyamirfarook6875]

Beautifully explained

[@freakzilla789]

Zabardast MashaAllah!

[@danishqayoom2361]

❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️

[@zeeshankdar]

Beautiful

[@atifkha1502]

❤️❤️❤️🙏

[@pagedotplot8483]

No one can top Iqbal's philosophy

[@noxiousgamer8366]

salam, I WANTED TO ASK kia nijaat (salvation ) lene kelie sare gunah dunia me maaf hona zarori he umar bhar koi gunaah na ho, isnt it almost impossible for us to take salvation like this?? khuda to rehman, raheem, muaf krne wala he? agr me dunia me gunah muaf krwaye bgher mar gya to uska hisaab dena hoga ???