3 Disturbing True Craigslist Horror Stories - Vol. 5

Here is another throwback to one of the first videos that really made this channel explode.
Story 1 : Henry Trebek
Story 2 : "TheHunter17"
Story 3 : "Stan Mac Sr."
Follow the new Insta: / realmrnightmare
Twitter: mista_nightmare?l...
If you want to send a personal TRUE story of yours, please send it through email: [e-mail]
Anything with poorly structured sentences and grammar will not be read, so please just make them neat and understandable. Please also state how you would like your name to be credited in a video.

[@owntone5]

If I was a killer on Craigslist and asked a guy to meet me in a cornfield and he agreed...I would be worried he was coming to kill ME!! Lol

[@jaym8808]

Imagine a Craigslist killer making a deal with a Craigslist killer. "no way I'm pissing in the cornfield too go into my car instead"

[@Astro.babyyy]

@@jaym8808 yo this comment made me choke 😭😭😭

[@seal1093]

sus

[@brainstormfilms1113]

😂

[@unusual3372]

I kinda thought of this

[@Ezio-Auditore94]

Craigslist is kind of like the adult version of strangers offering candy to kids.

[@clxzy6412]

So underrated

[@A.90c]

Word

[@unusual3372]

Strangers offering cheap price objects to adults

[@liathepurplegalactichybrid3321]

Honest to god

[@susangarrett5808]

Put perfectly

[@devontaebolton7066]

He screamed "come back" as if he was gonna stop and turn around, say "Ok ok u ain't have to scream damn"

[@dylansimko1701]

Devontae Bolton “come back!” Oh, okay. Sure thing buddy.

[@randomstuff6088]

Lol

[@iiblueytv2767]

Guy: "Come back!" William Afton: Oh. Well in that case "I always come back"

[@bananakingcomment6651]

That’s funny af

[@TheChroniclesOfTheEclipse]

It’s a girl 🤦‍♀️ he could have gotten laid

[@emme2141]

I wonder if two predators have ever catfished eachother on craigslist 😂

[@rattingcheese687]

Lmao. Like two bullets hitting each other in the air…

[@Totalitarianistfr]

@@rattingcheese687 lol wtf

[@tallstar513]

You think they just kinda sit down for a beer? Just talk about killing and shit? 😂

[@cwaltzmusic]

Yeah. I catfish myself.

[@m3lmartinezx3]

The way this world is I would say there is a 99.9% chance that happens atleast once a month

[@fenris610]

craigslist descriptions be like "new nintendo switch $10 cuz i found out im allergic please meet me at the knife-lover murder cave" and people go "OH WOW 10 DOLLARS"

[@kkane6228]

I've been there...its quite nice😃

[@huckleberrysucks]

@@kkane6228 wtf

[@judeanpoet3687]

Can you do $9.50?

[@queeniebeanie3196]

7 dollars and you got a deal

[@lulupompy12]

Lol.....funny 🤣🤣🤣shit dam $10... on ma way to the knifes lovers murder cave..that's a cool cave..

[@Diety555]

If we can't meet in a public place in the DAYTIME, we can't exchange.

[@flukeman022]

Then let's meet in the middle of a forest.

[@madelineziller4726]

CocoButter RIGHT??? Like it’s common sense😂

[@alibressenette3043]

CocoButter hiii cocoa butter💅🏽✨💕

[@Diety555]

Hello 👋🏽

[@Diety555]

Right! 😆

[@canidconsulting5118]

Craigslist/Marketplace meet up checklist: 1) Go late at night 2) Tell no one of your plans 3) Go alone, unarmed 4) Carry cash - lots of it 5) Choose secluded, dark location (rural cemeteries/abandoned buildings are perfect) 6) Leave weapons and phone at home 7) Be a sport and go along with anything 8) Look your best; dress provocatively

[@daveninava]

That Genius Man Thank you for that man You Deserve This Support all lot

[@canidconsulting5118]

@@daveninava The original poster would want to thank you personally, but they went missing shortly after going to meet with a craigslist seller....

[@Quipie]

@@canidconsulting5118 💀

[@The_Reel_Demon]

@@Quipieliterally ☠️

[@angelinaboyle423]

Im fucking dead 😂😂😂😂😂

[@tjstravelingtales]

Second story: “Do we really expect these things to happen?” Me with anxiety: yes, yes we do.

[@catspjs6229]

Legit, happens every single day !

[@LadyAstarionAncunin]

I said aloud, "YES!"

[@Allthingsedits505]

Yepity yep yep

[@martyd7176]

“Wanna buy this laptop?” “Sure...” “Cool, meet me in this corn field”

[@genocidecrusade6534]

Hello today person

[@a_dolls_purpose_a_dolls_pu526]

Yey! Free corn too!!

[@adamhudson2443]

I will bum.you for the laptop

[@cece2858]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 THESE FOLKS CAN NOT BE THIS STUPID CAN THEY!?!?!?🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔 ( sarcasm or course)........ NO FUCKIN WAY! THESE STORIES ARE SOO CRAZY!!!! 🙄🙄🙄🙄

[@zorychavarria5748]

Marty D 😂😂

[@celsogarza6372]

"What would have happened if I wasn't wise enough to run away"? You would have gotten yourself a used tv stand in mint condition.

[@MetaMortis21]

Lmao

[@jasonk876]

He should have just grabbed a piece of furniture and ran away, instead of going upstairs. You can have your cake and eat it too.

[@patriciabrown5071]

Read that at the same time he said it lol made it creepy

[@epicty3607]

Just hold the guy at gunpoint and say"ok how much you want for it"

[@pokiest1]

😂😂

[@AmallahGaming]

"It's not my problem anymore" It's always frustrating hearing stories end this way. You should absolutely report to the police what happened. ALWAYS. Just because you made it out safe doesn't mean the next person will. Do better.

[@LadyAstarionAncunin]

They might as well just say, "I'm selfish, so..."

[@noshow22]

Good thing you made yourself the arbitrator of what is decent and what is not. Where would we all be without your beacon of moral guidance?

[@AmallahGaming]

@@noshow22 Pretty cringe sarcastic take.

[@Quinn91202]

Because people are selfish and don’t care as long as it doesn’t hurt them personally

[@blanchefful]

Exactly 💯 What is wrong with these people!?

[@Kitty-eq3ze]

Its honestly blows my mind that there are so many people that just give out their home address to complete strangers on the internet. And then they're shocked when something bad happens.

[@lcolsen22]

Murderer: Meet me in the cornfield. Guy: Okie Dokie, Neighbor! Murderer: I can't believe that actually worked, holy crap.

[@brandoncaldwell95]

Deal of a lifetime. But, ya. A too good of deal is just that. Too good

[@scottvelez3154]

The deal of a lifetime, because you'll never live to see another deal.

[@itsjackiebro1872]

🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@sadetucker2094]

@@scottvelez3154 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

[@GhostRangerr]

Natural selection: it's my time to shine

[@sebisgood2241]

“I’m in a cornfield just get in my car” Seems legit

[@melissaacosta639]

LMAO

[@mylovelyname2365]

Agreed

[@havilavi472]

@@melissaacosta639 exactly just stupid 🤣

[@MrFOZ]

🤣🤣

[@aize1888]

💀

[@ruledbyvenusss]

“deep down i knew this situation was far too suspicious for it to be real” then why tf did u meet a stranger in a cornfield in the middle of the night to buy a damn laptop

[@KitAE0]

If someone is *that* comfortable with the idea of a stranger entering their home by themselves or just "slipping" into their car while the person isn't present (basically forms of letting you into their personal space), chances are they feel that way because they *know* they aren't the ones in that position who are at risk.

[@anessalove1537]

I hateeeeee when you’re running for your life and the one you’re running from yells “Come Back” like I’m gonna turn around and be like “Okay, but cut it out”.

[@ItalianStallionBDM]

Yeah happens to me all the time

[@HillBillyBrown]

Anessa Love LOLLLLL but that's def me like "I'll come back if you stop being crazy and just hit this blunt"

[@notyourstoknow3190]

It's like those people who say in a horror movie, "Is anyone here"? As the the killer is going to say "Yeah,I'm here to kill you is that ok?"

[@keeppiecefull5294]

That happens to you alot? Buy a Glock if you constantly find yourself running for your life.

[@johnsmith-oh9is]

@@keeppiecefull5294 Mossberg just put out a new handgun that's pretty nice for concealed carry. Just got one and it's fun to shoot

[@louisasmiles]

I went to my brother's police graduation... The chief of police said, " if you walk into anywhere/a situation and feel that something is off, it probably is. Trust your instincts" guys, if something doesn't feel right, get the hell out.

[@snafu1433]

*RUN BITCH RUN*

[@tjbratcher6034]

F. Fuck E. Everything A. And R. Run

[@MandenTV]

smiler fear is why humans are still around today. It's an ancient feeling and should be trusted. But also fear =\= paranoia

[@Yirialo]

Carolyn Hale yes!!!

[@DeathLife-th1tk]

Always...trust your gut

[@heatharnholt2136]

"Stay strapped or get clapped" Shin Tizu art of war.

[@ajdominguez1002]

Sun Tzu. Nice try

[@Ryan-bd5ot]

@@ajdominguez1002 people like you are the reason comedy is dying

[@ajdominguez1002]

@@Ryan-bd5ot so a tomato family is walking along, but the child falls behind. While running, they fall to the ground d and splatter. The father turns around say, "ketchup"

[@Muzan_JacksonHEEHEE]

@@ajdominguez1002 wow👏

[@IamtheSpy2005]

"IF FIGHTING IS SURE TO RESULT IN VICTORY THEN YOU MUST FIGHT! Sun Tzu said that and I think he knows a little more than you do pal because he invented it!" ~The Soldier

[@thegreenmanofnorwich]

A lot of these stories involve escalation. Each tiny "just do this" that seems a bit suspicious, but not so much as to put the individual off. That said, by the time you're meeting someone at an abandoned building called Slaughter Farm on Dead Man's Lane, two miles outside the town of Abandon Hope, it's really time to reconsider those choices.

[@traw7021]

Yes and no. There were 🚩🚩🚩 very early in each and every single one of these stories. These people were just complete morons 😂. All of them. They all of a sudden end up meeting “the seller” at some sketchy ass place yet they all STILL follow through going against their gut instinct and fucking COMMON SENSE LOL. Just my opinion tho 🤷‍♂️

[@hed2410]

To check out knife sharpeners, lol...

[@marcusjones6098]

"Do any of us expect these things to happen?" This man had you come to a cornfield in the middle of nowhere for a laptop. Like...

[@9annax]

Right? Like if you're not stupid or you read the news you should probably expect that... Who asks someone to meet them on a empty road in the middle of the night for a laptop?

[@max_pluto]

He said this as soon as I read this comment

[@wozing]

Idk, I'm from a rural area. It's not *that* out of the ordinary. Just a few too many red flags at once.

[@thebeingwithnoicon7561]

@@adamhudson2443 cool... (Obvious Sarcasm)

[@janhill102]

Marcus Jones Ikr who in th hell would go, noone actually....unless u had a cop go with you. I think the first story guy shoulda called the cops, he might've saved someone's life..

[@cooki3luhverz]

“I thought it was weird she was telling me to let myself in...” *Lets self in anyway* 😂😂

[@johnnyrobles7872]

Maybe he though something else would happen ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)

[@henrymob2651]

HaVok Swift *moaning intensifies*

[@sirenz11]

@@henrymob2651 wtf

[@Raven-fu1zz]

Actually kinda normal in small towns, in big cities tho its either a mom tryna get some or a get the hell out of there situation

[@zombies4evadude24]

Johnny ಥ_ಥ christ

[@anitaford4138]

I just find it incredibly amazing that each victim didn't stick to their gut instict of trouble because they didn't want to be rude!! Seriously?!! Now THAT is a scary story!!😮😮😮

[@leslierae6416]

And this, folks, is why I NEVER go pick up anything on Craigslist by myself.

[@kj3112]

If someone texted me saying “let yourself in” during the night, just know ya boy is leaving in the car within seconds

[@jm21zuchiha_81]

Your just ‘That Nigga’ init?

[@codenametango3247]

I'll just let myself into my car instead.

[@plsbrorevivemeihavearaygun6102]

Lit

[@kj3112]

Jeromiboss21 Uchiha I’m that nigga

[@user-ck8xm5oj5h]

That Nigga but, you sure your that nigga right?

[@shayesherwin8098]

“What would of happened if I wasn’t wise enough to run away” sir why did you go in?? 😂

[@shanibunni194]

Right! If the person can't open the door clearly something ain't right haha

[@derrickp2628]

Exactly. I was like wise ain't the word I would use to describe you buddy

[@tjohnson2139]

Complete idiots in these stories. No one would be that dumb. I’m serious. These stories seem unrealistic. No one can be this stupid

[@SimmaChode]

@@tjohnson2139 honestly you'd be surprised how clueless and gullible some people can be to obvious danger. Sometimes you just don't think it'll happen to you.

[@geminiflamez]

Hahaha exactly

[@GhostRangerr]

"You want a $5 laptop?" "Meet me in a pitch black place that is far away with no one around and come alone"

[@jonshaylawilliams222]

Fr ppl so stupid

[@meinsouza]

How many of these "just let yourself in" stories do we need to hear so people stop dealing with these creeps

[@LadyAstarionAncunin]

Dummies are born every day, so, never.

[@ilikebands4696]

I got my puppy on Craigslist two years ago, and she’s a very healthy dog, and no one got murdered so that was cool

[@maddieandmoby]

i like bands Neto

[@simonh5110]

i like bands well that’s a plus

[@GenjiSimpOw]

I really thought you said your dog was wealthy so I’ll just see myself out the door

[@CC-lm1tw]

Same

[@jdutka13]

Same

[@willow8415]

- always bring someone with you when you go to meet someone to buy something - unless it is completely unavoidable, make sure you meet them in a well-lit, public place

[@jessieqk12]

Bring a weapon too.

[@something1241]

Also during the day

[@scottvelez3154]

Have a team of ex Navy SEAL's with you as bodyguards fully armed and a sniper team.

[@kylie64]

Scott Velez thanks for the info I’ll try that next time

[@spookylovely]

Better yet, meet at front of a police station in busy working hours

[@bobcharlotte8724]

Love the "What would have happened if I didn't run away", when they should be thinking "Why am I so stupid to have put myself in that situation to begin with?". Suddenly situations where those morons in horror movies that go off by themselves don't seem so unrealistic.

[@LadyAstarionAncunin]

Most of these stories about home invasions involve the home occupants running upstairs or in somewhere deeper into the house. I always imagine what they look like based on what people typically look like who do this in horror movies.

[@blunderman73dicks37]

"What would have happend if I wasn't a wise man and ran away" Dude if you were told to let yourself in and you did you can forget calling yourself a "wise man"

[@teagenthetiefling5296]

That one about the laptop is how people get murdered, ignoring like five huge red flags from the jump

[@blane6592]

Tiger Gray Exactly!!!!!

[@poshlady43]

Tiger Gray True...shop ebay!

[@infiniteblue895]

Maybe the guy had a huge bladder and took awhile

[@jasper6343]

he is an idiot

[@chaosbrownie9139]

True

[@richie4633]

see, this is why when I'm selling or buying on Craigslist, I always push to meet them at a mall or at a police station or any other public place with hundreds of people.

[@bpeitz4337]

The police station has hundreds of people

[@nicholas8484]

Rebecca Peitz lmao

[@loganrash6764]

When I buy or sell things on Craigslist I always meet at my bank. There's cameras and I don't have to carry any cash on me until I decide to buy and get a feel for the situation.

[@jejusss]

Yep this is a go to idea when you feel odd or even when you're sure it's safe, if they don't wanna meet you up on those place it's a giveaway don't ever negotiate when they asked you to comeover massive bait

[@nuclearswan]

Until they break down on the side of unknown highway 666 after the sun has set and the sky has an eerie red glow illuminating the top of the dearth of trees where given seller is waiting for you to find him with your gps to give you a used laptop. Then of course you have no choice but to go to him.

[@krognak]

"Hi Jenny, I'm down here in the pitch-black basement, come on down and shackle yourself to my radiator and I'll go get the free thing you came for :D" "I thought it was a bit sketchy, but I went down to the basement anyway..." Seriously these stories LOL

[@taylork.5427]

These videos blow my mind because it's crazy to me how many naive people get themselves into these situations. If you're buying or selling stuff on sites like this, always agree to meet in a public place

[@IDKontent]

If there is some things Mr Nightmare has taught us Don't use Snapchat Don't use craigslist Dont go out at night Don't trick or treating with anyone Make sure all your doors are locked Don't take night shifts Don't drive on highways Don't go to school Don't go on vacation Don't go to the gym Don't go out of your house Don't talk to any strangers Don't play fortnite Don't do anything

[@icxcarnie]

IDKontent "no u"

[@anotherguy6270]

devoly what does that mean?

[@noljdjdjdjjd]

another guy F

[@shad0wgh0stbr0gaming]

Forgot don’t babysit don’t dog sit don’t go camping

[@bellabean7019]

Hey! Thats what I already do! Jk But that is true!

[@Lyle-qc8ld]

I want one of these stories to end with “So I started blastin...”

[@Princesskeywest]

🤣🤣💀

[@Allahakbah]

😭😭

[@lordbasilisk]

I'd be more worried about meeting Frank off of CL than any shady crackhead.

[@sadetucker2094]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@marcyj937]

🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@Kro-RissaVirus]

“I’d heard all about those craigslist horror stories and this was exactly like the cliche build up to one, that’s why I decided to go anyway.”

[@pessigurl]

The first story: Man pushes open door and enters house Anna: Come up! Man: "Alright! Be right there! Man goes halfway up the stairs Man: "Anna, right?" Anna: "Yup!" Man gets to top of the stairs Man playfully yells, "Which side?!" Man laughs Man enters a room to the left, peeks in. Man: :Anna?" No answer, backs away Man: "Anna?!" Anna: "Over here, just come inside!" Something was off, her voice, wasn't a she. Turns around and plot twist... Chris Hansen: "Would you like to tell me what you're doing here? Why don't you have a seat?" Man, that was a scary story, lol

[@melanielanphier]

I just want the stand dude.

[@KrissyRoseAnimallover]

Huh

[@babyshea321]

😅😅😅

[@doomenthusiast]

This is amazing

[@Jrob170]

Just came over here to get the stand and watch the football game. It's the ravens and steelers.

[@SweetNightmares_]

"Want this table?" "Yah." "Alright come into my house at 9 where the curtains are shut and I don't reply back."

[@Russophile30]

🤣

[@chewymercury7026]

What would happen if a psycho met another psycho on Craigslist, and one tried to kill another??

[@patson420]

*madness*

[@ChrissyTina0687]

Romance... and it will be beautiful lol

[@taylorjohn9503]

Hahaha that's too funny 😂

[@Sabertooth2121]

oh i love that lmaooo

[@oSomethingWildo]

They'd both be dead with each others wallets in their hand?

[@davidguthrie5941]

"I didn't know what to do, so I hid behind the wall of running chainsaws."

[@julietteoscaralphanovember2223]

The police department in my town has special designated parking spots for people to meet when selling on Craigslist, marketplace, etc. There are cameras there too. I have met people there when selling items, i felt safe.

[@cnmathias5187]

If you can't meet me in front of a police station durring the day than no deal

[@robbiehernandez8019]

Hell I'm still hesitant about that.

[@cnmathias5187]

@@robbiehernandez8019 I know especially after watching this channel

[@deeznuttzinyamomsmouth1278]

Lmao pusssies

[@aw9376]

Grow a pair and quit being a little bitch

[@km-uy9rj]

^^ they’re both murderers

[@aoxieleah_2314]

bro if the person isn't answering the phone, but still texts you. It means they aren't who they say they are

[@YesuAiNimen]

You are soooo right. My ex gf used to do that to me. She was a fraud.

[@theceo1]

@@YesuAiNimen catfish

[@kaiseremotion854]

I just hate talking on the phone. I only text

[@abcdef-cf2uk]

No brainer🤔

[@reina2310]

Im mostly deaf so I prefer text :(

[@Theunihornable]

Cragslist explicitly tells you to do transactions in a public spot, in daytime, and bring a friend with you and yet it amazes me there will be people who do transactions in their home or in the middle of buttfuck nowhere

[@dazeslays]

"The cops told me to just be grateful that I wasn't killed." Give it up for our boys in blue!

[@olly1793]

It seemed like a cliché horror scenario.....so I made my way over to his location *Everyone face palms*

[@Sabertooth2121]

he IS that one idiot in the horror movies people yell at “DONT GO IN THERE” “DONT DO IT”😂

[@ireneangelucci8984]

Honestly, so true 😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@ASMRyouVEGANyet]

Your comment matches up with your profile pic

[@lahupuupetersee6739]

Yup THAT IS SO TRUE!!!😂😂

[@biff867]

I read this comment before getting to that story and just assumed you were parodying it... nope lol

[@lofiafterdark9882]

“Just let yourself in.” NOOOOOOPE.

[@naejimba]

Would have ran right then.

[@CircusoftheMoon]

Time to go to IKEA.

[@misstinahamilton5714]

Right??! - I would've been like I'm good as I hauled as...

[@elliotthay44]

Helll naaaah

[@laurawrigley5000]

Hell nooo I wouldn't just go inside someone's house I didnt know no way in hell

[@believenothingful]

Every time I listen to these stories I wonder if there's ever been a time when a killer met another killer. Like someone that was planning to kill whoever came to buy their item happened to meet someone who was planning to kill whoever was selling the item. And if so, what happened? Because I can bet those stories would never be told on those posts. Just like what would happen if 2 serial killers met, each trying to make the other person their next victim.

[@LadyAstarionAncunin]

You see that in the horror anthology, Holidays, in the New Years segment. It was interesting.

[@jonsprong1842]

Another seriously troubling thought is that Jeffrey probably brought his two friends to assist in murdering a family or roommates. 😳

[@bayleejoy5440]

why would u meet someone in the middle of a cornfield for a laptop in the middle of the night

[@danv7887]

You left the bottom half of your shirt at your ex’s

[@xX__Rat69__Xx]

Oooh roasted.

[@shhtrawberry1809]

@@danv7887 Ladies and gentleman I fouuuuund, a boomer!

[@ssj2rhandy]

Probably if you’re on a budget

[@vogue_paris3106]

Exactly, that doesn't even sound right.

[@Nickyfit514]

I have improved my english a lot by watching your videos.... I get to learn new words and the same time i am enjoying the horror stories and thrill... Its a win win situation... Thanx mr. Nightmare

[@ArthurShelby-PB]

Bobs n vagene

[@calebmurray3494]

Ranjeet Sengar same here

[@restingvard2704]

Same here

[@themanbehindtheslaughter5681]

Churro Art Why would he need proof for that? Jesus...

[@dianatrejo2006]

Ranjeet Sengar 😌

[@chapmankol]

Story 2 is my all time favourite horror story. Well written,well described and well read

[@m.i.zeiler2892]

“I waited for three minutes - there was no way he was peeing for that long” is the perfect sentence that makes the scariest story ever.

[@oskarszynkowski3000]

"Want a free TV?" "YEAH" "Ok meet me in in that abandoned house on silverstreet!"

[@Ben_Buchholz]

Meet me in that abandoned house on Neibolt street.

[@light161_]

meet me in that abandoned house in the forest

[@praticm2846]

"Ya sure"

[@kaleidoscope5054]

Worth it

[@mmaria_000]

LMAOO

[@Ben_Buchholz]

Craigslist is like year round Black Friday. You risk your life every time you shop and you get to meet shady, sociopathic people. But dem bargains, tho.

[@sadetucker2094]

😂😂😂😂

[@gwennnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn]

lmao I love this!!! lol it’s almost Black Friday 2020 this should be interesting....👁👄👁

[@benfuller5]

Happy black Friday

[@Zen-sx5io]

I'd still risk it, and maybe I'll get into some adventures.

[@massielgarcia2357]

🤣🤣

[@minkxz8037]

These stories be like: I read an ad that seemed sketchy so I contacted the owner of the post. The owner sounded very sketchy so I asked for the address. The house seemed sketchy, so I went inside. The furniture was sketchy so I went into the dark smelly room. The person in front of me seemed sketchy so I ran back to my car.

[@LadyAstarionAncunin]

🤣 Exactly!

[@yakubutsu6241]

1:20 did this person really just flex on people who dont use apple?

[@PolygonIsland]

i once met a dude off of craigslist in a barn for some chicken parmesan

[@Snness]

Please tell us more!

[@meylonihewitt3325]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@dranksinatra8253]

is that code for something?

[@kkane6228]

Def code for 🍆

[@insecuree8194]

Girl bye-

[@skippygirl959]

I just imagine Dave standing on the side of the road next to his broken car, bladder empty, covered in dirt holding a laptop wondering why the guy skidded away from him.

[@CharleyCharlay]

skippygirl959 Lmaooo

[@icysurfer2]

xD this made me laugh too hard

[@richardgarnica6549]

skippygirl959 because he didn’t wash his hands lol

[@hayn1138]

HAHAHAHA

[@whatsgoingon07]

Why u leave bro?

[@-RandomVideos-]

Mr Nightmare’s kids: dad can we hear a bedtime story? Mr Nightmare: sure kiddos! It was 2017 in Danville Ohio and I was in my room watching KZbin when all of a sudden I heard a noise... 8 minutes later His kids: YOU WERE SUPPOSED TO HELP US SLEEP NOT SCAR US FOR LIFE

[@withonelook1985]

Having grown up in a very rural area of Utah, I can't tell you how many hookups I had in cornfields, or wheat-fields. My home town was next to the largest copper mine in the world, and there were so many abandoned tunnels we would sneak into. Never at one moment was it frightening.

[@venus-yz5ru]

“Hi” “Hi” “You want this TV, right?” “Yes...” “Ok I’m at the cemetery, just meet me there”

[@billduran8626]

Dht

[@joeysoG]

Lmaooao Hi Hi

[@Russophile30]

🤣

[@VVsupremacy]

And the person will be like "I'm coming right away" 😂🤦‍♀️

[@sashty1789]

"And make sure to get into that open grave I made for you" *oh okay!*

[@Amanda-xw5mi]

Stop meeting random strangers at lonely places, at night. Don't go into empty houses with someone saying 'hey there, come on upstairs / downstairs'. Carry a couple friends and meet in daylight in a mall or police station. You don't need a laptop that badly ok.

[@saintarthador4922]

31415 2635 sounds outlandish but it’s just another parking lot

[@dankmemes3645]

She is hot.

[@dankmemes3645]

I was just complimenting her and said nothing about her name.

[@latinas]

31415 2635 u sound dumb asl

[@gooberbeans7972]

😂😂😂5:05 He wasn't wise enough to turn around when "Anna" wouldn't open the door.

[@raicapulido1652]

“His name was Jeffrey.” Me: Jeffrey Dahmer😳

[@ianlawless7739]

*opens door for three suspicious people* You: Haha I’m in danger

[@lilyakydd9507]

Why is this so funny hahahahaha

[@manichannah]

Lilya Kydd lol my exact thoughts

[@Nick-dm7sw]

@@manichannah it's a Simpson's reference

[@havilavi472]

@@manichannah same here 🤣

[@manichannah]

@@Nick-dm7sw oh I gotcha

[@exaltedmadness1188]

Honestly, you getting more active is making me excited I look forward to these so much..

[@exaltedmadness1188]

Oscar Hernandez Ew, Cringe

[@aa-br4cg]

Madness Way * nuzzlez *

[@user-oc6bb4nd8j]

Madness Way RAWR XD

[@floridianrailauto9032]

R etarded A pple W eirdo R eeeeeeee

[@kodakwhite6909]

Madness Way he’s trynna mimic u cuz of the way u look

[@skibidifartsalot]

In the first story, the scammer literally texted them their address so they should have been able to report it to the police

[@walkercramer8765]

Probably an abandoned house

[@Quietu]

My favorite is that 90% of these stories end up being “hey, I am acting weird and asking you to do REAL sketchy stuff that it is 100% clear to any reasonable person is a thing you should not do. But hey…this is a HELL of a deal, though.” And person goes along with it.

[@JustinY.]

I swear you could read the Hungry Caterpillar and still make it sound terrifying

[@quentinb196]

Justin Y. Hey Justin

[@unbutteredtoast6412]

Hahahaha

[@cenan.88]

Justin Y. Hello

[@trippysavv9827]

I want him to

[@w3llahi]

Hahahahha

[@connornoiles2447]

I would of seen red flags the moment she stopped responding.. Even more so when she says "let yourself in"

[@XxGorillaGodxX]

Oi, it's a hellbent pic

[@connornoiles2447]

Yep :)

[@HarryK832]

I was thinking it was a chris hansen predator bust

[@chrxsdrxp_5638]

Whats up dolan i mean hellbent

[@spookiuwu768]

Ikr? Like come on bruh. A stranger just telling you to come into their sketchy ass house?

[@teatimewithianne4763]

“COME BACK” “okay as long as I get the maple TV stand.”

[@BigSpudz]

Hi ALL, MUCH LOVE FROM BIRMINGHAM UK. I just so happened to come across this Channel the other day and I pressed the button on My Phone to come off the the this Channel but accidentally instead of coming off the Channel I accidentally pressed play and as I was in the middle of doing something I just left the Video to Play and to My surprise I Loved what I was listening to and so from there on The rest was History and I've now become a Subscriber. 🇬🇧❤️🇺🇲💪💪👍👍👍

[@NL-xv3dh]

Why would someone meet up with a stranger at night. If it were me I'd meet them at daylight, somewhere with a few people around.

[@kaleyroach4134]

N L I know right I’m glad someone gets it

[@anobody7888]

right, like just meet up at a restaurant or a mall or a crowded park

[@nickel2442]

most people have work during the daytime.

[@SexyButCurious]

R Z But this there's a lot of retirees and stay at home moms out at the park,stores and mall, so it's still a good idea to meet in the daytime

[@Nick_4545]

I've met a few people off let go during the night but I always made sure to meet them somewhere like a gas station or something

[@mrbeast1881]

free chainsaw meet @ abandoned sawmill ASAP

[@awkwardcheese9655]

Which one the one out In the middle of nowhere or the one two miles from here?

[@Novasky2007]

The one with all the dead crows nailed to the fence just past the old well down the long winding lane there's no cell coverage tho so you may as well leave it.

[@creepywaffles4783]

Sure which? I would take a chainsaw!!! The trick or treaters are annoying! I KEEP THE PORCH LIGHTS OFF BUT THEY KNOCK ON THE DOOR ANYWAYS!!! (This is a joke honestly my neighborhood gets no trick or treaters) LOL 😂 I love sarcasm!!!

[@conservativedoggo2438]

Creepy Waffles you have to be over 30

[@nickatemelvin445]

when can I pick it up?

[@namarae614]

*Someone doesn't have an IPhone* Everyone in these stories: YOUR EXISTENCE IS NOW AN INCONVENIENCE TO ME!

[@diwinsabu490]

Craigslist Man: Brand New Mansion for $1 Please meet in the darkest, most isolated, creepiest place you know. I have asthma so we need to meet after 11PM Naive Man: Ok I'll be there at 11:30

[@diwinsabu490]

nah frfr some of these people are real naive in these sitauations

[@connorcason7491]

Never trust a guy named Jeffrey

[@nrgbunni.]

Connor Cason yesh jeffrey dahmer

[@lynksis12]

my name jeff

[@NucleaRaptor]

Jeffrey Epstein

[@jellyofthefish2530]

Jeffrey Star

[@jaketheaquarian1909]

ITS OG LOC, O.G. LOC!

[@TheEntertainmentguro]

"But does any of us really expect these things to happen?" YES, you are in a cornfield in the middle of the night

[@kinghayesgaming362]

I’ve watched so many of these videos and it’s sad how many people don’t call the cops because I guarantee other people end up falling for that same trick but they aren’t smart enough to get out of it

[@ChristinaPlaysAs]

I love your videos! This channel has brought me so much joy! Some of the stories the writer gets a little to into themselves and is either exaggerating or the story is flat out made up.

[@barbarahimes1041]

You’re in a cornfield to get a laptop? How did it even get that far? Yeah dude, something is definitely not right.

[@tamasue928]

Who the hell meets strangers at 10pm on side roads

[@km-uy9rj]

Idiots

[@tamasue928]

Lmao 😂😂

[@niamhfogarty3408]

My mum ;-;

[@YaiunicUP]

Niamh Fogarty Ouch.

[@Dreamskater100]

@@YaiunicUP Ahaha I like yr name!!!

[@rarabella5237]

While looking for a bargain on Craigslist, you lose your life in the process. That's a pretty expensive trade.

[@raiyaniqbal1994]

"So yeah, you wanna buy this TV?" "Yeah." "Okay, just meet me at 2am in a dark rat-infested alley on Murder Ave." "The one where a bunch of meth-addicts live?" "No, the one where you can hear screaming on every corner." "Okay." bruh.

[@kingrandall8944]

Is it me or is Mr.Nightmare uploading more now?

[@kinglordchoo17]

The Chosen One. Yeah I hope he keeps it that way

[@dickface9525]

Yeah

[@aviunox]

It's summer lol

[@kyrieirving2436]

The Chosen One. Finally, we use to get 2 a month if we lucky. Now we got 5 in like a month.

[@oClassiic]

Petra bud he has a job, he still works over the summer

[@ashleyblack4073]

I think a red flag is when a “female” seller invites a rando dude to her house ...especially at night and alone?? Yeah I would never do that! I’ve sold furniture before but only while other people are with me

[@milodavis1507]

Youre racist as fuck.

[@Jenna7Baby]

@@milodavis1507 what?

[@tobi-xo3if]

@@milodavis1507 tf, you mean sexist? even so she isn't she's just being safe and using her common sense, unlike you.

[@thankseveryone4161]

Ashley Black yes Sir

[@jellyfishattack]

The story sounds made up.

[@Traveler-30]

The odd thing is even when we know deep inside the situation is sketchy our mind still say it could not happen to us. I mean we always think that how could it be possible that out of millions of people we could be singled out.

[@laughingcorrpseholly4136]

The first one “I wonder what would have happened if I wasn’t wise enough to run away” you shoulda been wise enough to not go Inside like that in the first place!

[@peteryang84]

There must be quite a lot of criminals looking for victims all the time on Craigslist which makes it the broodmother of horror stories.

[@olin_7]

No shit..

[@MrCompassionate01]

Yeah we're at volume 5 now so I'm starting to think Craigslist isn't a good idea. Also notice how the stories happen no matter where they meet and how. In the other person's house, at your own house, at a meeting place. No matter how the OP tries to arrange it there's always a danger.

[@C._Bradford]

Samantha Heron IKR that's why I always carry a blade when I buy stuff like this.

[@Turk_2023]

Always meet at a police station.....Police encourage it.... You remember the old retired couple in west virginia who went to buy the old Mustang with 50k I think? 5 years ago or so..... They still never found their bodies i believe.

[@alfredootbs6700]

Samantha Heron am I the only one who think she’s cute? Lol

[@Rovertimes]

Do people even have common sense anymore? That laptop one was a huge facepalm. Yeah sure middle of nowhere...cornfields....darkness....get in my car I’ll show you my “laptop” come on!!

[@reneerojas6046]

Yea, people do still possess common sense, but unfortunately, ''''greed'''' often prevails over it.

[@vincent4112]

Dude, I'm from Iowa and even I wouldn't meet up with someone in a cornfield

[@ASMRyouVEGANyet]

They have to look it up online to see if it's safe

[@WaywardZeppelin]

I'll show you my very small laptop inside the barrel of my pistol! (Because he was probably intending to murder the man)

[@IcePrincess751-kb9bq]

Alberto Cortez-I know,..it's crazy to think so many people can be incredibly careless,especially these days with all the horror stories about Craigslist.I've been listening to these kinds of stories for quite a few years now,and the one thing so many seem to have in common,is that a lot of people become too willing to take a big risk when they think they're saving a ton of money on an item on Craigslist.Unfortunately,the twisted freaks who victimize others know this all too well,and use this method to harm these folks.

[@primefischer6336]

I love how people are so willing to put themselves in danger for something that if they just stayed safe and didn't go would mildly inconvenience them.

[@notblazedfordays9536]

1st story- that’s the problem with the world “not my problem.” Let’s not call the cops immediately and allow this person to do the same thing to someone equally as stupid as the guy who went into the house thinking it was legit.

[@RamenRP]

Person: meet up at my house Me: nah we meet up at a crowded chipotle or we don't meet up at all Person:... Me: thats what I thought

[@robertrobinson7830]

Bex Rico LMAO

[@kaelyn8181]

Lmao this is the best comment I have ever seen😂😂👏

[@lizmowrey9866]

Yep. I always meet in like a Walmart parking lot at 2pm

[@danielhill8926]

See this is what i mean use intelligence

[@elchoya8770]

so you didn't get the t.v stand?

[@ImSoReadyToRetire]

reggie julienne 🤣🤣

[@lailag6379]

😂😂😂

[@KonsciousKomedyKay]

Exactly thats what im saying!! Thats some nice ass wood

[@idrow1]

That made me burst out laughing. Yeah, I don't think they got it, lol.

[@drake.707]

The best comment goes to you.

[@f450empire]

The Craigslist horror stories are my favorite I wish he would do more

[@Unapologetikallyblaque]

Yes! Yes! I do expect bad things to happen if I meet strangers in a cornfield at night by myself. I’m a skeptic though