Nirmala Sitharaman Rips Adhir Ranjan For 'Hunky Dory' Barb; Watch Fiery Clash In Lok Sabha

[@radharangarajan7211]

Wonderful reply by FM

[@Kiran-zo6fj]

I'm from Karnataka, Karnataka govt facing shortage of money this because of 5 guarantee of khangress govt.

[@kdmptk]

If you keep on giving free everything of course you will run out of money

[@viki19910]

​@@kdmptkone way is there like TN can start alcohol shops😂..btw I am from TN and I feel shame on it😢

[@pradeepdeepu1806]

Yes becoz of free things like electricity and bus free for ladies we r facing this problem .... hence I had voted for BJP only knowing this problm but ultimately kongress bastdrs came I hate them

[@glanzan5057]

Then you are not from karnataka people are not fools here 😂 Ye chuna apne chacha ko lagana

[@Kiran-zo6fj]

@@glanzan5057 you think I'm not from Karnataka 😂😂, chuna ab tere chaha ko hi lagaho. ಮೂರ್ಖ ಜನಗಳೇ ಹಾಗೇ ಕಾಮಾಲೆ ಕಣ್ಣು.

[@openwings9458]

Strong reply.....shuts up thr mouth....did anyone heard someone says to opposition 'Maza aagaya' after sitharamans reply😂

[@sarathchandrapothuri9917]

yup twice i that i heard it and laughed lol

[@DishanthJ]

Never ever can a woman be so in way as our Finance minister Smt.Nirmala Sitharaman ma'am.👏🏻

[@Kiran-zo6fj]

What a strong reply.

[@jhkblr2600]

IMF too has such distribution mechanism. If they find that a country spending money on segments which they are not allowed too or should avoid then they stop payments to that country even if the money is part of bailout package.

[@ST-jl2tb]

She wasn't talking about any payment stopage. She's highlighting towards their budget mismanagement and was saying that earlier government was managing budget better so it looked Hunky Doorie, but since present government is not following the fiscal prudence and announcing unsustainable schemes, for which they are lacking resources and which is destabilizing their state budget, she isn't responsible for that.

[@SharlatanShenanigan]

Dude do you understand the difference between handouts of IMF and tax revenue allocation to states? Maybe Congress thinks that "tax" is their grandfather's legacy they can distribute however they want but that is not how the constitutional process works. If you are spending money on 5 helicopter trips a day, then that is a revenue management problem. Stop blaming everyone else for your failures, maybe people will take you seriously.

[@suryanarayana8476]

FM follows FC's recommendations to the last word. FC-15 recommended 41% devolution. Many legit organisations are telling that only 35-36% is being devolved and never crossed 40% since decades. Why can't the FM publish a white paper and clear out the confusion about the actual devolution once and for all?

[@rudolf895]

Now she will give a dramatic twist saying speak to FC. They should recommend and they would have told FC to not recommended shit. This govt is corrupt to the core

[@gks29]

WONDERFUL REPLY BY THE MADAM NIRMALA SITARAMAN

[@sigmamale8028]

W Sita Raman proud intelligent women

[@richagulati3106]

Bang On ... FM

[@mukeshßishnœ29]

Mature response by FM without any political gimmick...

[@aneshsreeja]

Apt reply ❤

[@doctech3223]

We want strong opposition like in USA democratic vs republican. Here opposition has no sense, absolute majority.😂😂😂😂.bjp will win till 2060.

[@harshpashte4871]

After 2060 khangres = dekho BJP desh loot liya 🤡🤡

[@weird_philosopher]

Strong opposition in USA?... 😂😂😂😂😂😂... Bruh really? Do you even watch any news about USA politics? On one side there are Republicans and on other side is lunatic laughing stock woke democrats...

[@weird_philosopher]

And there's hardly any democracy left because they are trying to jail Trump and Nikki Haley is a pseudo democrat...

[@SharlatanShenanigan]

AHAHAHAH? USA? Strong opposition? They have no opposition. They are a uniparty whose only opposition are the people. I agree we need strong opposition but USA pattern is an example of what NOT to follow

[@srinivasam3638]

Nonsense Adhir Ranjan 😂😂😂😂😂

[@shivarajraj6859]

Right reply🎉.

[@AS51515]

Awesome reply 😊

[@srinivasam3638]

👍👍FM Nirmala Seetharaman 🙏🙏

[@complexcircle]

Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury Wrong profession U should be in Circus 🎉🎉

[@Tony_Montana659]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@captain._levi]

I can proudly say that there was more discipline in my class than in the parliament. Shame on our politicians because discipline is the key , literature doesn't matter, discipline matters.

[@HEDONISTIC_SLAYER]

There is no need for discipline and all 😊. Argument and its counter part are required to discuss politics. If they will sit in parliament in disciplinary status there will be no freedom of speech

[@captain._levi]

@@HEDONISTIC_SLAYER What freedom of speech? They are in the parliament because of people for people. Not to argue with each other and earn money for arguing. And why are illiterate politicians allowed in Parliament?

[@HEDONISTIC_SLAYER]

@@captain._levi so please tell them another way to discuss 😭😭. What an audacity to say that they are not allowed to argue. there are two parties they had to argue to reach to an outcome and there is no judge who is going to give his judgement both had to show them as good. Also you are contradicting on your own statement as you said literature doesn't matters so why calling them that they should not allowed in parliament coz they are illiterate

[@OneWorld2024-u9q]

Thats why Genius people like you must join politics and bring about that discipline and dignity! Till that time, we must respect them, because, that are the ones in action! Sitting on sidelines and lecturing can only happen in class rooms. Sir!

[@ST-jl2tb]

Mr. /Mrs whoever you are. These are not some school going students. They are there to debate, discuss and contemplate the issues with regards to policy framing and it's implementations, that runs this country. Aligning 140 cr belonging to different castes, creed, religion, sex, place of birth, launguage, etc is no joke. This is a part of democracy. U hate it ... Avoid watching it.... Simple

[@reasoningtrick0]

क्या बोला है मैडम ने ! 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏 बहुत अच्छा एक महान लीडर🙏🙏🙏 जय हिंद जय भारत

[@NareshKumar-rm6cw]

Karnataka govt unable to fulfill freebies that's why making nuisance

[@harehare3488]

Ranjan's mind voice I know she is slap me on face but what to do I am forced by jokers to question what should not be questioned He he he he

[@kdmptk]

Karnataka has its state flag. Which state has its state flag? Having a state flag itself a sign of separation. That's why Karnataka minister is asking for a separate Karnataka country.

[@anuragchakraborty8766]

The people of Karnataka have the right to make their own decisions. The people of Karnataka reject the BJP's hindi imposition and Modi's dictatorship.

[@texray1991]

Flag will not define separate country requirement, some stupid politician said and you're anchoring for him

[@mydopevids959]

​@@anuragchakraborty8766then people of India will teach you.

[@initiator0016]

@@anuragchakraborty8766 That hindi thing was actually was setup by congress with 3 language policy for non hindi states. It is BJP govt. that got rid of it in NEP 2020. I don't care about BJP but at least find the right reason if you are not separatist,

[@anuragchakraborty8766]

@@initiator0016 Don't try to shift blame away from Dictator Modi.

[@kaunBanegaKatorapati2434]

I think Indians have stopped watching Hamas Times like me🤔😅

[@truthislogical]

Nope. Btw it's Moscow Times

[@plusultra7258]

lol. Good joke@@truthislogical

[@zacthegamer6145]

All their reporting is mostly anti Indian interest with zero news about Hindustan.

[@SocialTak-cb1ho]

This media is funded by hamas ukraine and Moscow or middle East,they have nothing to do with Indian news 📰😅

[@therealbirdmachine]

Yes I too stopped watching Hamas Times 😂😂😂😂 Now I'm currently follow ANI

[@chandraaiyar3228]

What has Adhir Ranjan got to do with Karmataka? 10th class pass and criminal from West Bengal.

[@Tony_Montana659]

When Rajan speaking I feel it's in Nigerian parliament....foolish rajan got detailed answer his masters advices him to ask 😂😂😂😂

[@nikhil-zz6mr]

Ranjan

[@rajashreegudi6655]

Forgive me - BUT IT IS TRUE- Nigerians have beautiful English language skills. This guy has only one comparison- chief minister of Bengal. Both have horrible Hindi and English.

[@Tony_Montana659]

@@nikhil-zz6mr don't so pin point you got what I meant.....

[@Tony_Montana659]

@@rajashreegudi6655 I meant from his dressing...... Fool

[@nikhil-zz6mr]

@@Tony_Montana659 Rajan nane doesn't suit this fellow so I pointed out.

[@Sinha_Ayush]

Naam hi Adhir hai Thoda dhiraj rakh bhai

[@santoshrathod1643]

😂

[@rrh8854]

why AR gave only karnataka state as example,,, one proposed this and his party is in power now,,, when he geneealises his point why can't he take states ruled by other than his party,,!!😝😅😅???

[@NationalistBhartiya]

Beautiful explanation & reply Congress 🙏

[@kandasamysurendran3818]

Nirmala Sitaraman zindabad

[@Granite-u5s]

Why don't AR go and take some sleep, he needs it!!

[@mpraoin]

The opposition leader has lost his creditability He should come out with facts and figures rather than indulging in irresposible talk.

[@SuperRoshanlal]

Why only adhir speak from congress ?

[@plusultra7258]

Just think how much of the biasness she had to deal of this person

[@tusharmohapatra7704]

Nirmala ji kool .. INDIA with Modi

[@nirmalakutty9416]

Excellent madam finance minister ki. Your precision and control over administrative matters are colossal and far reaching public statements that resound and echo honesty and accountability

[@RahulKumar-b1h5f]

Someone please ask him not to talk, he always talks rubbish

[@Mithisatnarzary_123Z]

You talk in fantastic way mam just love it ❤

[@SathishKumar.lsathish]

Mp from karnataka

[@subramani1073]

Keep answers and replies.

[@tejasraj7270]

Karnataka govt misused with the funds provided and now they are bankrupt so putting the blame on Central govt. And adiranjan is shouting like a mad dog. Foolish argument

[@subramani1073]

Who is indirectly controlled finance commission? Everyone knows.

[@Abhi_Srivastav_2307]

Same persons who were controlling during 2004 to 2014 And the same formula was there And even less money was given Lol

[@dontbelonghere80]

Its in Pakistan , controlled by Hafiz 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@ajaybabu7136]

Centre should make public how much centre has released to each state atleast for 23-24 so that the non bjp states cannot bluff and blame centre for their guarantees

[@muralemgs6476]

Show the documents for the people which you are telling madam

[@Iamlucifeerrr]

Guarantee freebies without proper planning leads to these things, heart goes out for Karnataka people, they should've chosen bjp. Delhi freebies are so well planned salute to aap

[@psk2266]

Congress strategy... Give Freebies, without any limit.. Become Beggers... Play Victim Card.. Become Andolanjeevis...

[@sat_talk]

AR is just a time waste in parliament ....Comedy show by AR

[@AdvGautamishaw]

1 GOV job at 5 PC per family must policy SC ST OBC EWS UR all Stop 7 PC GOV salary Give 5 PC CTC 100 times more candidates gives bank po / neet / PSC/ UPSC exam Give benefits to most family not many in 1 family to get VOTE in 2024

[@suseelananjan4178]

Congress mukth bharth.

[@shivarajraj6859]

That right this Congress govt gives all free and wasteful State GST that is 50 percent of GST and blame Central Government.

[@veenaagopala5083]

i think ms sitaraman should not take the opposition seriously. they are anyway fools and will not understand even if she explains 100 times. why spend energy on explaining to fools.

[@rrh8854]

as a minister she is bound to reply, let it be any fool..!!!moreover it is questioned in HOUSE,!!😳😳😳if it were in a rally she could have brushed aside....

[@SachiKrishna-em3vl]

This fool Adir is screwed

[@nagarajanmp4785]

How finance commission so liberal for BJP ruling states ?

[@Silent_Shishya]

Because the Finance Ministers of BJP states set forth their requirements properly in front of the Finance Commission than the INC Finance Ministers

[@subramani1073]

It is clearly seen inadequate financial support from center to non-BJP ruled state.

[@chaatkedekh]

And every Indian supports this. In every non bjp state see the financial condition, all the states are burdened by freebies. Congress has nothing to do without progress of country

[@domeshmandavi927]

it's not non bjp ,this is congress+ govt. Freebies voters,dying self honour

[@rickycool6083]

How do you know its centre to state and not the state itself? BJP doesn't what goes to which state it is done by formula.

[@neelagrawalla9449]

Pappu Rahul Gandhi ka sabse bada Pappu Adhir !!😂😂😂😜😜🇮🇳🔥👍🇮🇳👍

[@manishtulsyan2922]

When khangress will rule a state this will happen, now the people of that state has to blame themselves why they voted for this divisionary political party who has always played seperation politics.

[@evolvealways]

Karnataka, Tamilnadu, Kerala list goes on.

[@tusharkantighosh4605]

Never meet a good chance to shut up. - Will Rogers . Otherwise ..............

[@swapnildahake1389]

Adhir should ask his CM from maha thugbabdhan about the pathetic situation in bengal . Never seen any city more dirty like kolkata

[@ronnielobo5879]

Good acting

[@michellemobilesfrancis9931]

nonscence finance minister

[@swapnildahake1389]

What more can you expect from follower of Pappu

[@srinivastirumala8023]

Can nirmala win an election

[@jesdaniel8303]

FM should behave properly

[@Ittoday18]

Less sense too much of unwanted drama 🦧 all the middle class people are the jokers

[@PrakharChauhan-t1x]

As a kattar hindu i know she is the worst fm she needs to overthrow from parliament 🤡

[@viki19910]

First show your original name then we will tell whether you are a kattar Hindu or mattar hindu😂

[@PrakharChauhan-t1x]

@@viki19910 i am bro prakhar Chauhan

[@anuragchakraborty8766]

@@viki19910 You better focus on Dictator modi silly bhakt

[@rickycool6083]

I wish he was a dictator so you would be thrown out of the nation for making stupid statements. @@anuragchakraborty8766

[@rickycool6083]

madarsa passout lol. @@anuragchakraborty8766

[@ramachandrannair4554]

Voters know that NO way to counter MODIJI. So complain dues center not giving. When priof of paid there. Cant centre file case against those persons saying lies.

[@rajashreegudi6655]

Congress does not even have a good orator any more! From Nehru who had mastery over literature and Indians who had forceful expression- where has it slipped down!

[@Sdey85]

Fair is an embarrassment to himself

[@WednesdayAddams-i5h]

Congress freebie is the problem

[@a.r.rajeevramakrishnan8197]

IMF has been given waning to India government about total debt condition of the country it has been growing fast like Argentina🇦🇷 near about 90 percent this finance minister never talk about total debt condition of the country

[@rickycool6083]

Because debt is not a problem in India lol. Maybe read up india's economics before saying india's debt is bad or problematic. Even 40% debt can be bad if the country's economy is bad, but you can't understand it lol.

[@a.r.rajeevramakrishnan8197]

@@rickycool6083 you are telling lies indian debt has been nearing 90 percent like Argentina🇦🇷Apart from that it will be a problem for coming generation not you and your modi

[@sujitdash6119]

They are in parliament to answer every question ask by opponent. Why type of attitude Nirmala showing, this type arrogance is not good for democracy.

[@vageeshamoriya3329]

The recommendations provided by the Finance Commission are advisory in nature and are not legally binding on the Central Government. Despite the 15th Finance Commission suggesting a distribution share of 41%, the actual allocation made by the Central Government was 35%. This indicates that the Central Government retains the discretionary power to decide the final allocation share.

[@rrh8854]

If centre has dicretionary power even since 1947,all Centre Govt.,s might have used it,, then why blame only present Govt.,,?? Seems just political,??!!😅😅😅

[@suryanarayana8476]

​@@rrh8854She just said that she follows FC's recommendations to the last word. Perhaps she only follows words not numbers. And please don't even get me started on cess and surcharge hikes.

[@mrchetan181]

0.34

[@estellelis9227]

It's true.. Non bjp ruling states are ignored by bjp govt 👎

[@amiindra]

Yes shameless freebies source money was cut by the federal government

[@pradhandigitals5247]

Not at all True!! Check in Odisha. Believe me, you will get the facts right.

[@inamco]

Is Finance talking about her personal life hunky dory?

[@Tony_Montana659]

Did your mother sleeps with some one

[@Tony_Montana659]

Did your mother sleeps with some one

[@bellarikaleempeacechanel8810]

BJP realised that south Indians are getting more Sensible day by day our MODIJI started appeasing intelligently North Indians,who are largely illiterate Andhbhakts,by alloting more central funds for Vote bank Ignoring south Indians

[@sunilkumarpatnaik6953]

Since 2014 ..Central BJP GOVT. ..Odisha has NO RAILWAY FACTORY .... NO COMPANY /FACTORY in ODISHA by Central BJP Govt. No Budget provision for JOB CREATION in ODISHA. Since regular Natural Calamities in every year in ODISHA. ...there is need of Pay & Accounts Office under CGA on Natural Disaster Management Ministery/Deptt..

[@Slayermunch]

I doubt that adhiir has passed 2nd standard in his school at least? this guy is simply put in parliament to question with no logic.

[@sanchayanpaul5546]

Adhir Ji is confused it seems

[@muralemgs6476]

And what is the use of being finance minister then? Maden

[@shameersulthan723]

Why this woman is so animated and agitated...She can answer with bit of calmness. It is clear that she is incapable of handling pressure.

[@amiindra]

So Adhir C was calm and composed when interrupting her

[@fabioinfo5143]

Why Finance Minister Nirmala is always angry when she talks or reply even to simple things... It's not good for health at her age, she always behaves like in the opposition even in the government 😅😅

[@sangeetamenon3181]

Hahaah ar understand anything

[@BRC03]

Then how come developed Gujrat gets more funds than under developed states and also states which gave more cgst

[@jayasaiification]

Bcz gujarath getting more SGST.. also Maharastra, so they obviously get their rightful share. Establish more Industries you will have more SGST..simple

[@BRC03]

SGST is not given by central govt It his kept by the states and will be used by them.Share should be given from CGST.get the facts right. And about Gujrat it is still far in facts of nutrition index,eduction ,women empowerment and also social divisions. Karnataka is the second highest cgst paying state where as gujrat lies in 7th position

[@ashokroy5184]

कोई भी भाजपा नेता सच्चाई का सामना नहीं कर सकता। यह वित्त मंत्री हर जगह अपना अहंकार दिखाती है

[@simba8778]

Karnataka nataka govt aka congress govt dont have funds for election nor running karanataka becoz of freebies.

[@dianazou5836]

Congress party 🙏

[@srinivasam3638]

😂😂

[@mereyalexander4836]

Nirmala stop your proud and rude. Command . it is not good

[@truthislogical]

Nirmala sithararaman doesn't know economics -Subramanyam Swami

[@plusultra7258]

Still fastest growing economy.

[@vedprakashkumarupadhyay9523]

Do you really believe Swami, don't you know his political history and his daughter

[@truthislogical]

@@vedprakashkumarupadhyay9523 he is a strict hindu don't forget his role in ayodhya case

[@vedprakashkumarupadhyay9523]

@@truthislogical 😂 How naive you are he had no role in ayodhya case it was k prashasan who got us victory, it was swamy who got vajpayee govt fallen , and everyone knows his daughter Suhasini haider married to mulla damagesd so much against hinduism what can expect from father-in-law of mulla

[@rickycool6083]

She does, but this is not even economics it is quite literally just rules. lol

[@willsontariang2462]

U r wrong madam

[@rcmarsing6311]

BJP govt bad at Central yes yes.. We want congress back at central again

[@potlakrishna161]

waste minister doesn't even know anything about Indian finance system and how it works.

[@Abhi_Srivastav_2307]

It's seems like you yourself are John Maynard Keynes 😂😂😂 Bro , study the facts first then say anything. What's she is saying is 100% correct Money collected from direct tax are given as per the 15th finance commission report and it will follow till 2026 Radhe Radhe

[@prateeksharma3847]

@potlakrishna161 How ?

[@Abhi_Srivastav_2307]

Be it NPA, be it FDI or exports on India Or FPI Or GDP growth rates Be it Multidimensional Poverty alleviation progress or Share Market growth On all indicators Government is doing well And she is a waste minister 😂😂😂

[@Kiran-zo6fj]

Mostly you think you fit😂

[@gregoryantony7491]

BJP and its members The Fm for bjp always Boasting about itself , but no development for poor villages

[@Abhi_Srivastav_2307]

Bro where do you live? Please come out of your world and see the real world..... Things are happening on the ground But to see that ,h have to come out of your WhatsApp University campus

[@subratasutradhar8876]

Some louzy bstrds in the comments sections are supporting freebies 😂😂😂

[@sumanjoshi9649]

Wonderful reply by FM