No, Gen. Shoaib, I'm Not A Traitor - Part One

[@micklesmith7316]

Dear Sir, you have totally surprised me. Thank you Abdul Sami Jehangiri Abbottabad.

[@waqasshaikh4365]

A very good explanation. Shame on General Shoiaib.. Hoodbhoy sahib should file defamation law suit against General Shoaib.

[@rushikeshbarge]

One thing is for sure, when learned people start to troll they do it brutally.

[@rohitkashyap7476]

There is a video of Salman Rushdie trolling Imran Khan.... It's Gold

[@rushikeshbarge]

@@rohitkashyap7476 lol that was roasting session...

[@saiqakhan4148]

Imbecile generals are not educated. They are third rate matric pass

[@msohailshah]

The retired lt. general brings down the collective national IQ whenever he speaks.

[@Recluse7477]

"Countries have armies, but Pak army has a country" This line coming from someone like A.Q Khan truely shows us the reality of things, they reality of who really runs the country

[@tasaz1593]

If these corrupt and inept Pakistani politicians could run the country without looting and compromising national security, the armed forces would not have to get their hands dirty. The army very recently had to even clean these people's sewage drains in Karachi for god's sake. Billions of budget went into zaradari gang's pockets. Similar stories elsewhere in Pakistan.

[@fayyazahmadsheikh2844]

Shame on you. Without Pak army your country will look like Syria Iraq and lybea

[@tasaz1593]

I have my doubts Dr AQK said this. I think he's been either misquoted or coerced into saying this. Publicly he's a very patriotic person who advocates a strong defence based on his partition Muslim massacre experience.

[@faisalnadeem7621]

@@tasaz1593 Dr A Q Khan quoted an advice from a fellow scientist, "If you have not given them a bomb then they will lick your balls. If you give them bomb then they will kick your balls." Proven right a few years later when General Musharraf humiliated Dr A Q Khan.

[@tasaz1593]

@@faisalnadeem7621 Try to understand the situation at the time and give credit to both persons for getting Pakistan out of a terrible situation where almost all world powers were gunning against us including arch enemy Bharat. It was a planned trick and it worked. Army nor AQK are guilty of anything except their great contribution to our defence.

[@Citizenoftheuniverse23]

I agree with your setting the record straight. These Generals are DUFFERS who have lost every war and SURRENDERED in front of a few hundred soldiers of Indian army, in 1971.

[@shahjee675]

You have forgotten abhi Nandan.indian air force was destroyed in 1965 and 1971...the Chinese recently taught you the lesson.. poor hunger stricken army showing muscle power on Kashmiri civilizen..

[@nitulranjanguha355]

@@shahjee675 You have been mercilessly beaten by Indian army in 1971 & 1999. You have surrendered in front of Indian army in 1971;& divided into two parts. In Galwan, China lost 45 soldiers in accordance with Russian News agency TASS & China lost 35 soldiers Vs India's 20 in accordance with US News and intelligence agency. So we taught China a lesson also.

[@shahjee675]

@@nitulranjanguha355 haha dil ka behlanay ko nitul yeh khayal acha ha..free advice you should listen to foreign media and not just Arnub Goswami

[@nitulranjanguha355]

@@shahjee675 TASS is a Russian News agency, who is a friend of China & Pakistan. US News & Report is an another internationally renowned news agency. You are living in fool paradise. You & China are the liar most nation in the world, which whole world knows.

[@BhupendraSingh-mz2hn]

@@shahjee675 you didn't destroy shit my boy. You have been beaten black and blue in every war but baaz toh tum aate nahi ho. PAF is a joke, ran away after shooting down 1 old mig-21 when your radars started lightning up of su-30 and mirage-2000 on 27 feb, himmat thi toh engagement thodi Der aur karlete why started running away? Tum logo ko brainwash kara jaata hai Bachpan se. Just look at your school books, full of hatred for non Muslims and jews.

[@ShakilChaudhary]

Prof. Hoodbhoy, My compliments on coming up with such a nice and cogent rebuttal. I am particularly happy to note that you did not use uncivil language.

[@manmohanjuyal7572]

Dr Hoodbhoy deserves to be Education or Minister of Science & Technology.

[@j.r.bhandari2286]

Hello ' you are vary right. I have seen Hoodbhoy's many video. He is a great man. Further this General is a complete liar' liar & liar only

[@aalemfaazel4198]

Gen. Shoaib's accusations could be incorrect but Dr. Hoodbhoy does have a problem, and that has to do with a perception that he airs Pakistan's dirty laundry which is then used by the enemies of Pakistan to hurt its national interests. Since Hoodbhoy's audience consists of foreigners and Westernized/liberal Pakistanis (who live in Pakistan), who are not in the mainstream, his criticisms of Pakistan's various institutions, culture, and ideology goes against the grain of what ordinary Pakistanis expect from him. At times, he appears too angry, wanting to nuke the entire system (no pun intended), and at other times appealing for help from like-minded liberals. In the end, it doesn't help his cause. What the Dr. Sahab needs to understand is that to bring about change, you first have to become a loyalist and an insider. You have to praise what is good and come up with solutions for what is bad. If you are negative all the time, people get exasperated and start questioning your motives. I think this is something that Dr. Hoodbhoy needs to work on. Finally, Gen. Shoaib is no fool. His defense analyses are generally very good. I am sure he is rattling the cage to bring out the worst from Dr. Hoodbhoy, and he might have partly succeeded.

[@WaseemAltafOfficial]

@@aalemfaazel4198 What you call "dirty laundry" comprises "hard facts" known to the entire world. And by the way, the citizens of Pakistan through their elected representatives determine Pakistan's national interests and not government servants based at GHQ & ISI. Lies, lies and lies are what people like you want to propagate in the name of "national interest". When you found your entire narrative on lies you stumble and fall down and this is what happened to Pakistan over the years .Altaf Hussain Qureshi was writing "Mashraqi Pakistan sey mohabat ka zam zam beh raha hai" when East Pakistan was burning. No lies please! Dr. Hoodbhoy is a true loyalist and everybody you speaks the truth is a loyalist and please do not brand others as traitors who do not agree with your narrative. So let us tell the truth and do away with lies. By the way, Amjad Shoaib is just a bully and nothing else.

[@ShakilChaudhary]

@@aalemfaazel4198 Thanks for your comment, but why do you call yourself "Aalem Fazel" (Scholarly Person)? Anyhow, I hope you would read my submissions with an open mind. You have written that Gen. Shoaib's accusations could be incorrect. Do you still have doubts about the fact that his accusations did not have a single grain of truth in them? I wish he had done his homework before producing his video. According to you, Prof. Hoodbhoy “airs Pakistan's dirty laundry which is then used by the enemies of Pakistan to hurt its national interests.” What do you mean by Pakistan’s dirty laundry? What do you say about Noam Chomsky and Arundhati Roy? Are they both guilty of the same crime? Why do Pakistani patriots admire them? In 2006, President Hugo Chavez, an “enemy” of the US waved Chomsky’s book during his speech at the UN to denounce the United States. Should the US have put him to the sword for having provided ammunition to the enemies of the US? I am asking you these questions because we live in a global village and Pakistan is not located on some distant planet from the world. You have declared that “his criticisms of Pakistan's various institutions, culture, and ideology goes against the grain of what ordinary Pakistanis expect from him.” So, he should say only those things that “ordinary Pakistanis” approve of. What do ordinary Pakistanis expect from shining patriots such as Zaid Hamid and Orya Maqbool Jan? What do ordinary Americans and Indians expect from Noam Chomsky and Arundhati Roy respectively? You have written that Prof. Hoodbhoy “needs to understand is that to bring about change, you first have to become a loyalist and an insider.” So, he is not a loyalist. Is he a traitor? The list of those who have been declared traitors in Pakistan is very long. It includes Huseyn Shaheed Suhrawardy, a leader of the Pakistan movement, Sher-i-Bengal Fazlul Haq, who presented the Lahore resolution, General Ayub Khan, Pervez Musharraf, Zulfikar Ali Bhutto, Mushahid Hussain Syed, and Hamid Mir. Even the founder of Pakistan was not spared. Chaudhry Rahmat Ali called him the Quisling-i-Azam. Coming back to your point, would you please name a few Pakistani individuals who brought about change by becoming loyalists and insiders in the last 73 years?

[@asimayub7215]

Heartfelt gratitude and utmost respect & love for Dr. Hoodbhoy, the way he refute false allegations and self made claims with patience and dignity................ while such Retd. Generals must shut their mouth & should think twice before hurling nonsense on other respectful citizens...............

[@changamanga3419]

SHAMEFUL ! It is a shame what this country has done to its scientists who served it with distinction. Patriotism cannot be the domain of uniform with salary & pension.

[@nowie4007]

Absolutely

[@gauravchauhan8423]

As an Indian and student of science.. we respect Prof. Hoodbhoy for motivating us to enjoy science in an ethical way. Prof. You are the best things happened to a nation like Pakistan.. I wish Pakistanis could ever imagine his worth.

[@faisalkhan-jo1sw]

he is amazing.... he used to do a science education program on PTV " Asrar e jahan". absolutely loved it as a kid. he is the one who got me into science.

[@trndsttr7585]

How's Arundhati Roy?

[@syedamarmusa6512]

I wish Indians could ever imagine the worth of Arundathi Roy 😂

[@nimeshmarker]

Very well articulated respected professor. Sad day when such a towering distinguished personality has to prove his loyalty to his country and its people. As a keen observer of Pakistan this probably ranks in my opinion one of the finest truths spoken about your nation. Your conclusion in part two tugged at my heart strings and teared me up. The pen is mightier than the sword. The Truth Always Prevails.

[@Mraks2053]

Sir, I have my utmost sincere respects for your knowledge, wisdom and above all the way you use it for the betterment of people of Pakistan and India. I honestly hope some day good senses will prevail on leaders of both our countries. Regards.

[@sabtainkhan8965]

Doctor saab is right and to the point and whatever he speaks about .he does his homework ..they dont have any answer to what he says, so it's not surprising that they are calling him traitor

[@financialtrader3435]

If he says this nonsense about you, he's the one who is a traitor. You are a gem, Dr sahb 💎💕

[@gaurishification]

Sir, A person of your stature neednt reply. You are the sanest voice in an insane country. Respect from India.

[@sadiamanzoor4791]

It is important to refute these false allegations. Silence emboldened the enemy.

[@rehmansaeed229]

I've been listening to Dr. Parvez hoodbhoy for a very long time in various formats and I believe this man to be rational logical and above all a decent person. And he has been teaching science and spreading the awareness for its importance for a very long time which we as a country are in dire need of. It would be self detrimental for the current generation of Pakistan to ignore our teachers for the sake of fake and expensive political rhetoric that has no grounds in factual reality.

[@DarkCr3ed]

General Shoaib is unfortunately the conservative military mindset that has been imposed on Pakistan since it's inception. We need to educate and spread awareness of the right mindset this country needs to enrich itself and there is no better person who is actually implementing this through his own message than Dr. Pervez Hoodbhoy.

[@KanishQQuotes]

It is not conservative but rather narrow minded and insecure

[@parbhat76]

Thank you Prof. Hoodbhoy. I like to commend you for making this video as a rejoinder to baseless accusation of Lt. Gen. Shoaib. I was really impressed that you kept your composure in this situation. I believe that Lt. General acted totally irresponsibly and without any thought given to the allegations. Let me say that Mohtarma Hina Jilani was right when she said Pakistani Generals are duffers and Lt. Gen. Shoaib has proved that.

[@nowie4007]

Facts

[@rajeshnathaniel8678]

Evidence does matter. Long live 🇵🇰, thanks Dr. Pervez.

[@EngineerMuhammadAliMirzaClips]

Everyone has RIGHT to have his OPINION ! ! ! We never BLAME others without any PROOF ! ! !

[@theholiday3836]

Assalam Alaikum teacher

[@theholiday3836]

@Al Franco Reported.

[@tECHnOpinion.]

What a man you are Mr. Hoodbhoy. Pakistan is really lucky to have someone like you as a citizen. We Indians would love to have more citizens like you who can contribute so much to the country. Its a shame, that instead of using your knowledge & expertise to grow itself, Pakistan & its Army Generals like the one in video is busy pulling you down. Really shameful. I wish & pray that in India, we never never never see such a treatment of our scientists or anywhere else in the world. Wish you the best, Mr. Hoodbhoy 🙏🏽

[@mobeenahmad5326]

ھود بھائی اللہ پاک آپکا حافظ و ناصر ہو گریٹ ھود بھائی

[@virendraSingh-je3sx]

Respect to Prof. Pervez from India. May God bless you good health and long happy life.

[@jegindersingh2634]

Sir, I am a great admirer of yours for a long time. Why? Because you have so much of humanity in you. You are also a very brave and courageous man. You speak the truth; it takes courage to speak the truth. You are inspiring and the youth of your country would become great human beings if they follow you. If anything happens to you Sir, I would be the first to protest.

[@mt6611]

The general did a great blunder to choose Dr.Pervaiz , so sad and shame on this general criticizing our dear teacher.

[@navinbhatia]

This ex- Ret. Lt. General Shoaib should be ashamed of his allegations against Dr. Hoodbhoy and offer a public apology to him if he still has a shred of honor left in him. I guess growing old is normal but becoming mature and wise is optional. Dr. Hoodbhoy has respectfully and honorably cleared your unfounded and baseless allegations with grace. God bless you Dr. Hoodbhoy and give you more wisdom and power.

[@digetalised]

Both India and Pakistan needs scholars like you... you are the beacon of knowledge amd wisdom.... Respect from India

[@sabahatthussainn5515]

@Manu Singh dr Modi? 😂

[@jayarajnair]

@@sabahatthussainn5515 Modi is a politician.Like any other politicians he has his own political games. India is a democracy ,so nothing can do about it .But when it comes to the administration politicians became administraters and will do their job. All of our politicians follows the same

[@izazkhan3455]

Sir you should file a suit for damages and compensation against this bull. he must prove his allegations in the court of law.

[@barkupatree6871]

thank you for educating the poor and uninformed general shoaib!! the rest of us in the public support your efforts and courage in the face of a sustained and unending campaign to smear your integrity!! thank you for educating us with facts and context, professor hoodbhoy. CONCERNED ABOUT YOUR SAFETY. STAY SAFE!!

[@fawadzakariya7480]

Dr. Pervez Hoodbhoy is a remarkable man and a thoughtful patriot. His tireless and courageous contributions towards science education and rational thought in Pakistan are remarkable. The man is a national treasure and I am so thankful for all his work!!

[@TheUndergroundRockstar]

Kamal ker dia Pervez Sb ne. Amjad Shoaib and his shallow rhetoric badly exposed. Truth always triumphs.

[@adhipmitra]

You are a great Physicist ,teacher and humanist. If Pakistanis would have followed you ,it would have been a prosperous nation today.

[@mudassariqbal4612]

We respect you professor sahb...We know that you are right...In logun ko jawab diye bgair guzara nai hai...warna yeh to is qabil b nai k in pe apni energy waste ki jaye...

[@GorgeousMia]

We need more people lyk him in pak. Alhamdulilah we got him here. I wish my nation could see what personality we have.

[@deeptomar1]

I have been following doc sahab for last 8 years n i can say with 100% confidence he always supported peace over war he always supported education in Pakistan he always supported rational minds

[@airliner791]

Excellent response. You deserve your right to have an individual opinion about the subject.

[@singhvijaybir]

Hoodbhoy ji, you are great teacher as well as great human being, who loves huminity. Gen. Shoaib is a frustrated man who keeps on barking day and night on different propaganda channels. He( Shoiab) is the real traitor, General of a defeated army,

[@samratchakroborty8504]

The greatest loss for India is that we didn't get the opportunity to learn from this man at the Quaid-i-Azam University. As long as people like Dr. Hoodbhoy is there, Pakistan will remain a nation with immense potential. It is our misfortune that partition has deprived us from such minds as Dr. Pervez Hoodbhoy. Bless Pakistan, Love my Bharat 🙏

[@MrNitKap]

Dr. Hoodbhoy is a great scientist. But to say that it’s a great loss to India...yeah thoda zayadaa ho gaya. Of course any nation/society can use to its benefit the services of a highly educated professor like Dr. Hoodbhoy and in a normal circumstances one can imagine that Dr. Hoodbhoy could very well be a visiting or residing professor in an Indian univ...but I think the real tragedy is that Pakistan itself is not fully using the services of this professor.

[@samratchakroborty8504]

@@MrNitKap I'm sure that there are people with greater scientific prowse but it is not always about academics. It takes lot of courage to go against the flow. In my view, very few people have the strength of character to look beyond popular ideologies and Dr. Hoodbhoy is surely one of them. I've immense respect for him and I believe today's society needs sane voices like his to be a better place.

[@MrNitKap]

@@samratchakroborty8504 I agree with pretty much everything you said. The only part that I don’t agree is “The greatest loss for India” . NO, it is not.

[@kashifahmed62]

People of Pakistan are with you - Sir !

[@aartigupta8642]

I am glad we treated our nuclear founder APJ Abdul Kalam ji with utmost respect. Awarded him the Bharat Ratna award and made him the president of india.🙏

[@robinbaidwan8675]

Even we Indian support him.

[@sanjayv8467]

But the MilBus Establishment and Mullah-Genls are not with him!

[@jayakumardiwakaran2347]

You jihadis cannot hear a sane voice,it's the truth.

[@jayakumardiwakaran2347]

Dr. Sahab u should have moved in to India long back.

[@izeetv8334]

Doctor Sahab I'm dsciple of it knowledge and I shall was am always oppose to these like generals

[@pupul9855]

It clearly shows that this general is no intellect and inorder to get some fame he's targeting scholars and educators like u

[@aalemfaazel4198]

Gen. Shoaib's accusations could be incorrect but Dr. Hoodbhoy does have a problem, and that has to do with a perception that he airs Pakistan's dirty laundry which is then used by the enemies of Pakistan to hurt its national interests. Since Hoodbhoy's audience consists of foreigners and Westernized/liberal Pakistanis (who live in Pakistan), who are not in the mainstream, his criticisms of Pakistan's various institutions, culture, and ideology goes against the grain of what ordinary Pakistanis expect from him. At times, he appears too angry, wanting to nuke the entire system (no pun intended), and at other times appealing for help from like-minded liberals. In the end, it doesn't help his cause. What the Dr. Sahab needs to understand is that to bring about change, you first have to become a loyalist and an insider. You have to praise what is good and come up with solutions for what is bad. If you are negative all the time, people get exasperated and start questioning your motives. I think this is something that Dr. Hoodbhoy needs to work on. Finally, Gen. Shoaib is no fool. His defense analyses are generally very good. I am sure he is rattling the cage to bring out the worst from Dr. Hoodbhoy, and he might have partly succeeded. Sometimes, your stature increases when you don't respond to personal attacks and it sinks when you pick up a stick to go after those who are calling you names.

[@munirdin9533]

ye general gadha hei,

[@agnosticatheist4093]

Yeh General Bina Kisi Sahi Wajah Dikhaye Jhuti Bakwas Karta Rahta Hai. Aise To Koi Bhi Kisi Ko Badnam Karde

[@atifshahzad1042]

Sir Dr Dr Pervaiz , we are sorry that we are not giving respect to great man like you. People like you are real heroes .

[@thediversity6203]

We stand by you Sir ! We need more people like you! Ignore these people!❤️ Much love from Lahore 🇵🇰

[@saeedahmad3748]

Thanks for bring all this out. I should thanks Gen Shoaib as well, I know you would never had brought these thing out which people of Pakistan had to right to know. Thanks my true Pakisnti Hero "Prof: Pervez Hoodbhoy".

[@SunilSharma-mv7te]

Sir,I am an Eye Surgeon from Delhi. My father was a physic teacher in Delhi. Hold same view s . Would like to meet you if I happen to visit Pakistan.

[@saleemmalik490]

Gen Amjad Shoaib continues to heap disgrace on his rank.With this man on it's side,the army needs no enemies.

[@PIRAVAL]

Bravo Professor Dr. Pervez Hoodbhoy. Respect from India. 🙏🏼

[@sumeersaxena1062]

The response from Professor has same depth as may be in his research work in Nuclear Physics. It is pleasure to watch his response in such dignified Urdu language. Its not about India vs Pakistan or we Indians taking pleasure for things happening in Pak, its about speaking truth with so much conviction and dignified manner. Kudos to you professor saheb.

[@allahbakhshsahib7763]

Sir you got a great respect and we all love you for your precious thoughts and valuable contributions in education and political thoughts. جب جاہل آپ سے الجھنے لگیں تو قالو سلاما

[@Jamilmaqsood1]

Dr sahib you are a genius person where as these retired people are mad to the extreme level ...

[@coolpoint942]

Namaste Sir, Great respect for you.. u are so genius and so gentle. Love from India 🙏🌹

[@sunildutta2023]

Pervez Hoodbhoy, Sir I have utmost regards for you and your teaching.

[@kaaaah2003]

Dr. Hoodbhoy is absolutely right. I read his article in Toronto Star opposing nuclear bomb whosoever possess it.The problem is that General Saheb is not talking about people in his rank and files who dragged Pakistan far behind. Who made Taliban, who is responsible for East Pakistan debacle, who are the richest generals of Pakistan, what is MILBUS, how come military officers living such a lavish life after retirement, who are the military officers involved in drug smuggling, why Pakistan was mostly ruled by military and who is responsible for Pskistan was dragged in FATF.....

[@aliraa3196]

As a Pakistani we r proud of sir ....i ve learned many things to u......we r aheading towards gen and establishment free country...... Is gen ko bhonknay do......u r an asset to me n my country

[@nademkhan931]

This was a Mike Tyson 'knock out in the first 59 seconds' of the General. Dr Hoodbhoy would have made a great lawyer had he chosen to go down that career path.

[@MasoodKhan-gg9rg]

NO, because a lawyer is the biggest liar on the land and Dr. Hoodbhoy is a teacher and a scholar.

[@inderjitsoni7616]

Parvez Sahib you are great. appreciate your reply to Gen. Shoaib with truth and logic. Gen. is blind with hate and never heard any truth from him so far. His statements are very misleading.

[@BAQARMZAIDI]

Hood Bhai, you have always been a man of character, you won another war, war of character. Hats off

[@balqees333]

Condemned. Well said dr pervaiz sb❤

[@shakeelnawazabbas]

Doc. Sahib, let the idiots alone, and carry on with your good work

[@saadjan3229]

Gen Saab is right about if We would not have made it then they would blackmail us rest of ours lives.

[@apnaranganathan]

We have to always remember that soldiers carry their thinking ability at the knees as only order and execute command reverberates in their minds. Science is like abracadabra, for them.

[@naveengosain1966]

Dr Hoodboy, I have immense respect for you. Please don't take to your heart the unkind words told to you by Gen Shoiab. Everyone knows about him, he is a pathological liar. His only goal in life is to defend the indefensible acts of Pak army Sincere Regards

[@manadya]

The best thing I observed about this video is comments! It was a pleasant surprise to watch so many Pakistanis standing by the Dr. This picture of such a wonderful support to a sane voice in Pakistan is a sign of hope. Else the footages of blackening the poster of a Nobel prize winner were damn detrimental.

[@rizwan1476]

People will call a spade a spade. Hopefully you are also doing the same with the crazies like Ranaut, Goswami

[@manadya]

@@rizwan1476 Wait, no rhetorics please. We judge the society by it's behaviour and not by some fringe elements. I have forgotten the name of college/university where the only Nobel laureate was insulted. The radical Islamist Maulana Khadim Rizvi had almost ten million folks gathered at his funeral and was termed as the biggest crowd ever in Pakistan history ever by their media. These are telltale signs .. The sane voices heard are rare and that's why this hon. Physisist enjoys Indian respect so much.

[@mak2118]

Dear Sir parviz hoodbhai, we all respect you and you are a great teacher and sincere country man. We love you.

[@saleemsabahat2856]

I am very ashamed you are a great man I have been listening to you since childhood I have never heard anything from you that would cause you to be accused of such a vile kind of thing You are the great capital of our country God bless you Protect and empower our people to use common sense🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷🌷

[@wasifumer9656]

Sir you are a legend these type of hypocrites can not judge you

[@sabtainkhan8965]

This is s slap on his face...I can't wait to see his response to this..because anything he says will make him look even more stupid..if that's even possible

[@aalemfaazel4198]

Gen. Shoaib's accusations could be incorrect but Dr. Hoodbhoy does have a problem, and that has to do with a perception that he airs Pakistan's dirty laundry which is then used by the enemies of Pakistan to hurt its national interests. Since Hoodbhoy's audience consists of foreigners and Westernized/liberal Pakistanis (who live in Pakistan), who are not in the mainstream, his criticisms of Pakistan's various institutions, culture, and ideology goes against the grain of what ordinary Pakistanis expect from him. At times, he appears too angry, wanting to nuke the entire system (no pun intended), and at other times appealing for help from like-minded liberals. In the end, it doesn't help his cause. What the Dr. Sahab needs to understand is that to bring about change, you first have to become a loyalist and an insider. You have to praise what is good and come up with solutions for what is bad. If you are negative all the time, people get exasperated and start questioning your motives. I think this is something that Dr. Hoodbhoy needs to work on. Finally, Gen. Shoaib is no fool. His defense analyses are generally very good. I am sure he is rattling the cage to bring out the worst from Dr. Hoodbhoy, and he might have partly succeeded.

[@sabtainkhan8965]

@@aalemfaazel4198 first you made it sound like he is against Pakistan. And that's the whole point he is trying to explain .and the fact that he feel the need explain to people his loyalty says alot about us .in your very message you called him outsider and not loyal on what bases ?? For not lying ?? Isn't it true that Pakistan is it not truly democratic? Isn't true that our education system sucks and the recent changes is not a step in the right direction but would make it even worse? Isn't it true that we have and we are using religion for political reasons? Isn't it true how badly we treat our minorities ? And isn't true that in last couple of centuries muslim world hasn't contributed significantly in science, engineering, medical etc

[@aalemfaazel4198]

@@sabtainkhan8965 You totally misunderstood what I had stated. It's not that he is a traitor; the problem is that his approach is wrong. He is too negative. He never has anything good to say about Pakistan. If you constantly have this attitude, someone would naturally ask, "then why the heck are you living here?" As they say, "love it or leave it." Even with a child you cannot take that approach. If you are scolding the child all the time, he or she will develop a strong resentment against you and would stubbornly refuse to listen. And at some time, the child will hit you back. But if you praise the child when he or she does good, the child will take you more seriously when you are unhappy. It is this simple psychology which Dr. Hoodbhoy doesn't seem to understand. Is Pakistan truly all that bad? I don't think so.

[@ahsansandhu6476]

General Amjab Shoaib has shamelessly removed his video after the masses exposed him and supported PH. What a spineless general and failure he is.

[@aalemfaazel4198]

@@ahsansandhu6476 If he has removed it because he realized that it was wrong then it shows that he is a man of honor!

[@KrishnaSwamyBhyravaS]

Dr Hoodboy is a precious asset to a country - revere him Pakistanis.

[@usmanzafar4751]

@Andrew Higgins There is no such thing as moderate Islam. Islam is Islam. As for the question of progress, Islam does not prevents people to gain knowledge and wisdom. What is preventing people to get along with modern education is not Islam its just ignorance. Also you have got a point, there is nothing stopping conservative societies from progress. In fact the Liberal societies of West are those which are losing their hand. These societies have their social structures and norms crumbled and they are suffering from their own freedom. Their demographics are literally changing. Conservatives in those countries call immigration invasion. The Sun of Europe and America is dying. Pakistani should follow what it has as its foundation. Pakistanis should not follow principles of a dead civilization. They must and they can only progress in their own way.

[@rajatprabhakar6016]

He stupid India had no support from

[@tourwithmubeen]

Right

[@khalidmahmood3504]

Would you like to take him like tareek fateh ,adnan Sami for increasing your assets.

[@mypakistan9615]

🥴🖐️

[@tariqhayat336]

we support your point of view Dr sb

[@tehseenfatimasyeda3082]

We respect you Hoodbhoy. We salute you. My son has msc degree in Astrophysics, space science and astronomy from Karachi university. We all love you, and never care of Gen Amjad type log.

[@MARSCATanimations]

We need voices like Pervez Hoodbhoy. He spent all his life to promote quality education in Pakistan. we are proud of him even though I don't agree with all of his criticism of other fields like religion that he is not expert mainly :)

[@blazingsun8862]

Just because Amjad Shoib disagrees with Dr Pervez Hoodbhoy it doesn't he should call him a traitor. These things happen in a fascist state.

[@shivendrasingh8931]

Pain, Pain and Pain. He still lives in pakistan that shows his affection towards nation. Don't do this Lt.general sahab.

[@siddhanti]

Hoodbhoy sir, you are absolutely right. Amjad Shoib represents the Establishment voice, and he unnecessarily interferes &dabbles in politics and all other matters instead of just confining himself to his expertise area of Defense & Military matters.

[@rclrockyy]

Love you Sir Parvez Hoodhboy.

[@elyasmalik6264]

Excellent program

[@panoramicview7782]

Long live sir. These generals are stupid, do not listen them.

[@Khan_MW]

Please say the person who tried to defame you is extremely stupid. Please don't generalize.

[@Muhammad-mw8ww]

Salute u sir Teachers like u r truely deserve for salutes And request to general Shoaib sir to not let down the army more People like general Shoaib already give opportunities to make objection on our pak army (our true defendant)

[@mazeeshan]

@sahil thakur If there's a war or calamity in the country people like Pervez H will be first flight out of the country while poor soldiers will be fighting and at least generals will be behind him.

[@muhammadhussain5854]

@@mazeeshan yes lanat on hoodboy

[@rizwan1476]

It’s a shame that academics have to present evidence of their patriotism to “vaguely instructed” generals. Let the general know that he was hired to defend the republic only and no more.

[@mypakistan9615]

تم اور تمہارا دو نمبر نام نہاد سائنسدان 🥴

[@rizwan1476]

@@hasaanzahid_ he is in the business of shaping minds, getting his students to think independently - not being a “yes man” like Shoaib has been all his career.

[@hasaanzahid_]

@@rizwan1476 There are other ways of making people think independently than mockery of religion.

[@rizwan1476]

@@hasaanzahid_ when an uneducated molvi goes on tv and says that the sun goes around the earth because our religion says that, I think he is opening our religion to ridicule. when khadim hussain rizvi’s companions talk about fragrance of potty, I think they are making a mockery of our religion. when molvis rape kids in mosques and “ulemas” have nothing to say about the matter but have lots to say about “be hayayi” on tv, I know who makes a mockery of religion. please direct your concerns about mockery to the molvis and khadim hussain rizvis of pakistan.

[@rizwan1476]

@@hasaanzahid_ He is trying to separate science and religion - which needs to be done. Sadly a large percentage of the population, even the literate ones with a college/ university education, believe that all science is explained in the holy book. That is bad and will not lead anywhere good. Also bear in mind that this mindset ONLY exists in Pakistan. Pakistanis will use computers, iPhones, internet and other technologies - equipment designed and built on solid scientific principles; yet they will in the same breath say "Quran explains science". It does not. Its just a myth propagated by jahil molvis and a case of the blind leading the blind. The non-muslim world has progressed in leaps and bounds, reached the moon and beyond, while the muslim world is stagnant and living on borrowed ideas and technologies. Compare the scientific research done by all the muslim countries vs that done by Israel. The answer is clear to see. We are not in 4th gear, we are in the reverse gear.

[@abhisheksharma-ti3gr]

Come to India sir we need educated person like you

[@abhisheksharma-ti3gr]

@Arvinder Singh absolutely right

[@singhparihar8530]

@@abhisheksharma-ti3gr is wakat to India me bhi chutiyo ka bol bala hai

[@beingimran]

Brilliant response. You are an asset for Pakistan. Rock On

[@robinbaidwan8675]

Yes right n as a science student I respect him a lot.

[@sindhisangeet6852]

Sir you are great .Have a long and healthy life .Pakistan needs people like you.

[@billafghani]

Prof has its own point of view. General has no right to declare him traitor. Gadari K certificate bantna ab bnd hona chahaye

[@jahanagaz1954]

Sir, you're a gem. I always personally feel pride in listening to you. I feel pride that you're among us. The dirt that is being thrown around you will turn into a dust storm for those who intentionally air it until a late realisation strikes their sordid mind.

[@Lahoria9]

Love you Mr Pervez Hoodbhoy. Pervez sahib did a whole video series on physics in simplest urdu. Your game is way above. Your work has immortalised you.

[@Meowww12760]

Dissents are not traitors - they want to see our country on the horizon of success and development.. Long live Pakistan !

[@aviramvijh]

Wake up. The mindful here is an Indian and the mindless is a Pakistani.

[@universalscience360]

Great Dr Hoodbhoy sahib love you! You are asset of Pakistan and humanity, and this general is burden on Pakistan budget and on people of Pakistan!

[@aamirali138]

Wow, brilliantly replied. I salute your bravery. And, It's true that other countries have armies and Pak Army has a country.

[@abhinav.mishra17]

@Taqi Raza Khan Bangladesh was a part of Pakistan? Even Bangladesh is doing better after forsaking.

[@cruise343]

@Taqi Raza Khan No. You bow down to China

[@aamirqureshi4618]

Well done Sir Dr. Hoodbhoy..

[@pratapdas1943]

sir u are among very few Pakistanis, who are loved worldwide. ignore these fools

[@himanshhhh]

Bravo... u really hit the nail on the head now.

[@sultansalateen2706]

Love you Dr Hoodbhoy! You are our true hope

[@mikeprrior7278]

Dear Sir Dr Pervez Hoodbhoy, what a polite rebuttle, beautiful. i learnt beautiful lesson from this video[Replying very politely to liars with proof]. I hope generals will also learn from this video. By the way i don't think that this retired general may have enough courage to watch this amazing rebuttle. Every scientist and engineer in Pakistan always gives you highest regard. i am keen reader of your articles and sometimes i get confuse with your critically [harsh for me, roadmap for Pakistan] articles

[@nawabzadaaman8653]

This is difference between duffers mind & extraordinary mind , dear sir

[@hasansaleem4604]

this world belongs to powerful if pakistan has not nuclear power,what modi has done with pakistan is unimaginable

[@naeemkhan1951]

Dr 'hoodbhoy very well answered to the gen amjad .

[@NaeemAhmad-xd9zi]

If this general has any respect or pride(which I highly doubt it) should come up with a response to this video. What a lowlife general, I don’t know how he got into the army to begin with as a commission officer.

[@imtiazshaikh8195]

You are a rare intellectual that our country should revere, saddened to note that people like Lt Gen. Shoaib are misguided or follow their own prejudiced agenda... Keep up the good work, our country desperately needs you !

[@kanaka7552]

Prejudiced agenda, which goes against the wellbeing of the people of Pakistan.

[@Riccardocampagnieri]

Dr Hoodbhai, (deliberately spelt as it would be pronounced here in the subcontinent) I have my highest respects for you and have always watched your interviews and lectures available on KZbin. I have always found you rational, absolutely unbiased, been equally to wrongdoings on both sides. As a student of science (I am just an Aeronautical Engineer), always appreciated your videos on science specifically. Hence, no qualms that if given the opportunity, you are a Guru that I can blessed with. As to the other gentleman in this video, I have seen his views on many subjects dealing with internal politics of Pakistan and also on relations with India. I have seen and heard many retired Officers of Pak Forces, and they have been gentlemanly enough in their conversations. A few individuals have stood out for their interesting arguments, all entertaining. This gentleman falls in that category. It's a shame Dr Saab, that you have to waste your time in discussing this individual's tall claims. He is not worth it, but worth it considering the fact that he is an influencer of public opinion. A nation that cannot value the greatness of Dr Saab is a nation that is doomed. I strongly believe that if Pak can have leaders like him, would be the best of blessings for the future of the nation and of this subcontinent. At the end of the day, we are nations built from one. My regards to Dr Saab, I am genuinely concerned for your safety.

[@MuhammadAli-oh6uu]

Sir, you are wasting your time trying to teach this cartoon General. As a alumni of QAU, we know what is your stature. Please continue writing your thoughtful articles as your writing is something which I personally really really admire.

[@Travel_anand]

Solidarity and respect for you Sir 💐 this General Amjad Shoaib is a pathetic liar .. plz don’t worry about such crooks