The Lighthouse -- EVERYTHING Explained (The Ultimate Companion Guide)

[@Novum_YT]

As I mention briefly at the start of the video I've been in hospital with a collapsed lung for the last month and a half, my apologies in not getting any videos to you sooner. I hope lockdown is treating you all okay - I'm going to try and get as much content out as possible for you guys while we're all stuck inside!

[@geraldd9738]

Hope your recovery is going well!

[@schneblen]

Praying for your recovery! ❤️

[@willknowsright9615]

no need to apologize man. Get better soon. God's speed.

[@yt-sh]

Good analysis. Thank you for this. Take care.

[@Keyser___Soze]

Good luck, well wishes. Hope your recovery goes perfect.

[@oliverfolan8479]

This dude made an 80 minute analysis of this masterpiece and it only has 182 views. This deserves more attention.

[@Novum_YT]

Thank you so much Kitchen Rhymes!

[@Starduckvalley]

Well half a year later it might be! Just showed up on my algorithm!

[@LuxPerp]

@stelle202 You sound like Wake when you say that. So commanding.

[@TigburtJones]

Here here!

[@musicalarchitecture7875]

@stelle202 you’re right but I also disagree with you. Movie was trippy and atmospheric. You’re entitled to your crappy opinion lmao

[@fowledfilm]

No one actually explained this movie in all of their "explained" videos. THIS is an "explained" video. Nice work!!

[@Novum_YT]

ayyyy, my dude!

[@accidentallyamy1063]

@@Novum_YT Yours is one of the best channels I’ve stumbled across on this godforsaken app, and your efforts are so greatly appreciated 🥹👏👏

[@ggnoreeree]

Everyone is gay and everything is dicks. Yeah I think there was more to this film but alright

[@jeffwalker6815]

"This new movie explained!' *proceeds to describe the events on screen for ten minutes*

[@AmbroseCadwell]

Great work, this is what a video essay should be. Been getting tired of videos that just walk through the plot of a movie step-by-step in mechanical fashion and slap "EXPLAINED" at the end of the title.

[@Novum_YT]

Robin that is exactly to the letter why I made this channel. Thank you so much for that!

[@chase_h.01]

The 35mm frame and narrow field of view adds SO much to the feeling of isolation i can't believe it wasn't done earlier, its actually genius

[@Novum_YT]

Yeah, it definitely is that. I used to hate people messing with the viewing ratio but now I'm in widescreen I can see it for what it is a lot more. I think WW1984 did it recently and it was really the only part I enjoyed. But yeah, I think this oppressive square ratio is so good for forcing the viewer to think on what's outside the lens and for forcing them to focus on what's within it. It just provides a really high degree of control over where the audience is looking. Thanks for watching dude!

[@gregoryalexanderswart7138]

If you enjoyed the claustrophobic atmosphere I recommend you check out Son of Saul. It's a Hungarian film about a jewish prisoner-made guard at Auschwitz. The aspect ratio is 1.375:1 and with the exception of the first and last scenes the film consists exclusively of close-ups following the main character through his hellish adventures in the camp. There are no long shots, there is no relief. It feels like you're there in the camp with the main character, a truly morbid and unique experience.

[@snower13]

But I'm sad the cinematographer didn't get a larger canvas.

[@Blueklima9708]

I am near speechless. I have never seen such a well-researched, comprehensive explanation of ANY sort of media (except for maybe classic high school required readings), I am stunned. Well done, my dude. I’ve seen this movie multiple times, and rewatching it after this video is the first time I’ve ever actually FULLY felt like understood it. Thanks a bunch, man. Hope your lungs are doing better now!

[@Novum_YT]

Damn man, I needed that today! Thank you so much for the kind words bro, it’s extremely high praise and it means a lot. Cheers.

[@mariodrv]

I strongly recommend Rob Agers videos (Collative Learning) on legendary movies like Alien, The Thing, Clockwork Orange etc...

[@bonnibuns381]

i know this is four years old but after i don't think ive seen such a well made video essay that dabbles in these types of topics. especially so seriously and respectfully! definitely gonna binge more of your videos because this was an awesome watch!

[@Jeszyk]

Prolly nobody will read that after 4 years, but J wanted to say how amazing job you did and how helpful this video was. Also in reference to this interpretation that Howard killed Winslow, as we know Howard said that after “the accident” he only wanted to smoke. We can also see that first thing he does after realisation he killed Wake, is smoking a cigarette which confirm that he killed Winslow in first place.

[@tirzahgayla]

My brother had a collapsed lung several years ago and it was a terrifying time for my family. So glad to hear you made it through the other side. Such great insights on this film, ty for enlightening me to so much that went over my head.

[@TeakTeakchannel]

He shouldn’t have spilled his beans

[@yourmomshouse6984]

Aye

[@brokebrox]

I can tell you put so much time and effort into this and it’s genuinely really impressive. You deserve so much more attention!

[@Novum_YT]

Thanks so much Brooke!

[@dunkace]

What an incredible breakdown of the film. This really helped me make my mind up on a few points of the film.

[@Novum_YT]

Thanks for watching Duncan!

[@radiohippie]

This video must have taken ages to make - well done! I love how layered Robert Eggers' films are and how they can be viewed through so many lenses.

[@Deliquescentinsight]

The scream of the siren drives sailors to their doom, Ulysses fills his ears with wax, ties himself to the mast. I am reminded of the songs 'Home at Last' by Steely Dan, and 'Tales of Brave Ulysses' by Cream, both songs of existential desolation and loneliness, the striving of men. Great analysis of the film Novum, I very much enjoyed it having watched this film earlier today. Impressive presentation!

[@Novum_YT]

Thanks so much Michael!

[@toddwarren3980]

Stellar video - this should be a documentary on the DVD release. Great breakdown explanation for a great film. Thanks again for spending the time and effort!

[@Novum_YT]

Wow thanks so much dude! Made my day with that. Thanks for watching!

[@agaspversilia]

DeFoe is a monumental actor. Robert Pattison is great too in this great film, but DeFoe is just perfect 👌

[@WickedIndigo]

Couldn’t agree more. This was also the film that made me realize Robert Pattinson can actually act. I remember watching the twilight movies as a kid and just feeling awkward the whole time. But I now assume it was a script issue as opposed to his lack of acting ability.

[@Hakhoumbha]

@@WickedIndigohe’s also done a lot more small indie films in the time frame between the two movies

[@seamus7d]

That was incredible Shame on youtube for this not being at 4.4M views

[@Novum_YT]

Thanks so much dude, maybe one day but I won't hold my breath!

[@MrNick99]

​@@Novum_YT getting there!

[@xenogard]

This analysis was fantastic. You absolutely deserve more subs than you currently have. It's a damn shame how little your content has been picked up by the algorithm. I hope that changes.

[@Novum_YT]

Me too Xeno, thanks so much for that!

[@codyrussell707]

I’m pretty surprised that such a thorough breakdown failed to mention meaning of the gull Howard murdered. The left eye was missing, just like the head of Howard’s predecessor, & Wake said gulls contained the souls of dead sailors. The shared disfigurement & taunting of Howard is a giveaway, but also Wake’s violent reaction to Howard scoffing at the notion the birds were more than pests. In this context I believe the lighthouse station is more a metaphor for the afterlife & the light is an ascension to a kind of heaven, “relief” or “salvation” as the former assistant believed. Wake is gatekeeper (likely a dead soul himself who is just as drawn to the light but can restrain himself because he has duties to fulfill) who eventually gets Howard to confess his sins. Howard’s response to knowing his own unworthiness is to force his way into the light. The light of course rejects him & he falls into purgatory, consumed by & thus becoming a gull just like the man in his place before him.

[@Novum_YT]

I really like that reading dude! Thanks so much for commenting!

[@AmbroseCadwell]

Yeah deffo on first watch I assumed it was all some kind of purgatory deal where Poseidon or suchlike (Dafoe, or perhaps he's a ferryman figure) is weighing up Pattinson's soul for drowning a man in Hudson Bay. I took the brutal gull killing to suggest that despite his insistence to the contrary he did actually kill the guy rather than just watching, since he's shown to be a big liar shortly beforehand anyway & the gull killing shows he's inclined to violence.

[@chriszold9980]

You just blew my mind. That's an excellent interpretation

[@the_plutonion]

this, to my mind, is a much more accurate and astute analysis than the video to which the comment is attached. I would only humbly assert that he ends up in Hell rather than in purgatory, which was where he was for the entirety of the movie up until the last scene. Thank you for taking the time to write this out good sir.

[@aeronautisch]

I really like your interpretation!

[@RATLANTIS]

Not gonna lie, I just watched this to see if you would finally tell me what that painting was called (it was Hypnosis), but this was fascinating to watch. To think that one movie can be stuffed with so goddamn much symbolism is incredible.

[@BillThisdell]

I'm going to be re-watching your analysis a lot and reading more Greek mythology too. Very inspired by how rich the storytelling is -- thank you for this!

[@madhurimadas2616]

Omgggg this video deserves at least 10 million views! So incredible. I watched the movie and then watched so many explanation videos on KZbin. But yours is the best and in a league of its own! So intricately made touching upon every reference and point of view! Your video cleared so many of my doubts about this awesome film, so thank you for that :) Just shows your passion and dedication! Keep going.

[@madhurimadas2616]

@@Novum_YT Hey! That's so sweet of you. I'm genuinely blown away by the way you made and presented this video!. Keep making such awesome and dedicated content.

[@tomasvanes]

Really really great work! Your explanation really manages to harmonize all the dispersed simbolic elements on the film, and really have them all working at the same time but at different narrative levels. Best analysis on youtube, congrats!

[@Novum_YT]

Wow, thank you so much! I'm so sorry it's taken me so long to see this comment. Seriously, thank you!

[@MrMcAlmy1]

One thing I noticed on rewatches were the Sisyphus references as well. Winslow/Howard pushes the oil tank up stairs only to be told he must push it down again. In the final moments he ascends to the light and is then pushed down again. I think this speaks to a cyclical/purgatory-like punishment for Howard/Winslow and maybe what causes him so much fear at the end when he sees into the light-he realizes his eternal punishment - emphasized by that final image of his body strewn across the rocks being picked apart by gulls. Both Sisyphus and Prometheus.

[@icewindalegeorge752]

It's criminal you don't have more subscribers, this was an amazing video. I love this movie so much, thank you for sharing your insights!

[@Novum_YT]

That's so kind of you to say George, so glad you enjoyed the video!

[@feliciamarie6395]

an absolutely breathtaking analysis, very well done! I very much appreciate the time and effort put into this, as well as the fact that you tried to analyze the film in isolation from the short "explained" videos that like to pop up about this and so many other films. Makes for much more rich and meaningful content. I hope to rewatch the movie soon, because I feel like i can appreciate it so much more now, understanding all that you've explained.

[@NALBilge]

I'm very sorry that the algorithm has stopped pushing for this video. Ik I'm very late but you are a great channel and I thoroughly enjoy your channel.

[@Novum_YT]

Thanks so much dude, there’s more coming very soon, whether the algorithm likes it or not :)

[@truebaran]

Wow, I'm pretty impressed by the richness and accuracy of your analysis

[@Novum_YT]

Thanks man that's really high praise, thanks for watching!

[@enjoyeroflemons9342]

i always find myself rewatching this video. it’s made so well. beautiful work!!! i appreciate your insight on this amazing film :)

[@Novum_YT]

Thanks so much, I think you're the first person who's told me they've rewatched and that means a lot to me! Really appreciate your comment epic boss!

[@timburr4453]

This was brilliantly done. You've dug into every crevice of this movie and elucidated everything. enjoyed this very much. the depth of your analysis is amazing. Eggers himself could probably learn a thing or two from this video Also I thought by Canady they just simply meant Canadien...since Howard was a timber worker way up north

[@Novum_YT]

You're spot on about Canady, from discussing it with people in the comments here I'm 100% certain you're right. I think there is still an element of feminization or perceived canadian softness in the delivery though. Akin to how an Englishman at the time may have looked at a frenchman where they see it as a softer version of manhood. Thank you so much for your praise, honestly, that comment about Eggers made me smile (although that man is a genius so I'm sure he still has far more to show/teach us. Seriously thanks so much - more stuff coming soon!

[@IDyslexiaHave35]

Just got done watching this film for the 4th time and what a masterpiece. Really appreciate you putting in the time and effort to make this, excellent analysis dude 🙌🏼

[@Novum_YT]

Thanks so much bro! Yeah, it really is. Massively took me by surprise. Thanks for watching!

[@nanosuit100]

When I’m thinking of an ‚explained‘ video, I’m thinking of a video like THAT! Unbelievable great job you did there. I’m certain if the movie was more known your video would have millions of views. You definitely deserve it. Subscribed

[@Novum_YT]

Thanks so much dude, was needing some motivation this morning! Cheers!

[@lucassavvas7956]

This context changes the whole film!!! Amazing analysis really inspired to read between the line a bit harder and more often. Sub earned right here (y)

[@Novum_YT]

Thanks so much Lucas!

[@kit2770]

I just watched 'The Lighthouse' the other day. I very much enjoyed it but wanted some additional insight. This Novum vid is what I found. Hats off to the creator, this video is impressive, enlightening, and very enjoyable. It helped me to appreciate the film on a proper level. Cheers.

[@Novum_YT]

Thanks so much Kit, those are some very kind words!

[@danielm8698]

I hope all is well. Just saw the movie yesterday and hope you’re feeling better.

[@Novum_YT]

Thanks so much dude, that’s really kind!

[@zandar5735]

Genuinely the best analysis I have seen of what is one of my favorite films of all time. You gave context and careful research to all aspects and easily earned my sub. The only thing I wish you would’ve discussed that you left out is Wake’s final speech and I would love to see another video by you about his final dying rant. Outstanding work nonetheless.

[@Novum_YT]

That's a really good idea dude, you may actually see it as a bonus video in the future. Thanks so much for the kind words (and the sub), more coming soon!

[@Keyser___Soze]

I haven’t seen this movie yet. I really want to but I know I could never pick up or understand whats going on as well as you can. I’m always amazed how some people can break down films like this. You have a gift my friend. If you keep making videos like this, you will have millions of subscribers instantly (Edit, I just realized I wrote a similar comment here the other day and totally forgot I wrote it. Thats how much I don’t pick up on things...)

[@Novum_YT]

I don't mind hearing it twice my dude, thanks so much!

[@jern9899]

dude, the amount of effort you put into this, goddamn, hats off to you. this video really does deserve more views, and your channel more attraction, cant wait for more

[@Novum_YT]

Thanks so much dude, that really means a lot. More coming soon!

[@annawisteria]

I've loved The Lighthouse ever since we watched it for film class in college. Thank you for the interesting guide!

[@Novum_YT]

Thanks for watching Anna!

[@beatricewhitcombe]

Here I am again, to express how glad I am to have found your channel. The diligence and intelligence you bring to film comprehension is remarkable, and I desperately wish I was at a place in life to contribute to your Patreon. You’re objective, but also compassionate, refusing to succumb to bias, laziness, or oversimplified concepts. The sheer artistry of your work is enormously deserving of encouragement and support. Thank you for all the work you put in!

[@EmLucyLocket]

Amazing content as always! Thank you for keeping us sane in isolation 🙏

[@vsmff81]

This is fantastic and I don't think I'm alone is saying I would absolutely enjoy hearing a commentary from you. Hope you are feeling better.

[@klepie3874]

HOW THE FUCK HAVE YOU STAYED THIS SMALL. LITERALLY SO MUCH QUALITY CONTENT ON YOUR CHANNEL,, I HAVE SO MUCH MATERIAL TO WATCH FOR THE NEXT FEW DAYS I LITERALLY LOVE YOU

[@Novum_YT]

Ahahah thankyou so much! KZbin literally crippled this video by putting an 18+ rating on it when I asked for monetisation. Everything was growing quite well before that. There’s lots more coming soon though so hopefully things will pick up. Thanks so much for watching and commenting!

[@uwustinky3790]

you've put so much effort into every minuet of this video! this deserves so much more attention

[@pumathurman]

Came here after watching the midsommar and hereditary explained vids and gotta say I love how in depth you are in your analysis of these films and I'm looking forward to your next big project!

[@pegacorn13]

Again, I love, love love your interpretations! The Lighthouse is playing at our local movie theater this weekend and you've just inspired me to see it yet again!

[@Novum_YT]

Thanks so much - I would love to see it at the cinema!

[@pegacorn13]

@@Novum_YT It is great both ways. I really like to watch it at home with subtitles too! I wish they offered that at the theater!

[@alexbeth5763]

Rewatching this as a weird-but-makes-sense comfort watch on an emotional day. Thank you for amazing work, your consistency and your charming voice.

[@eugenesesmaiii3278]

Incredible work! My jaw was on the floor at several points in this vid and I was enthralled with your story telling. Thank you for making this beauty!

[@Novum_YT]

Hey cheers dude! Thanks for listening I'm glad you enjoyed!

[@abparry5159]

Great explanation on everything, really well done and put together, I thoroughly enjoyed this! Wishing you blessings in your health and recovery.

[@Novum_YT]

Thanks so much Ab! More coming very soon!

[@Keyser___Soze]

Great video. Keep at it man. You will blow up soon enough if you keep making quality videos that you can tell a lot of hard work and effort went into. Its rare to find people with videos on youtube that were made with hard work, research, effort and high quality

[@Novum_YT]

Thanks so much dude!

[@aadyeahhhh]

Came here from the complete guide to witch video, and your channel is a goldmine!! Thanks for being the smart friend, seriously. As for the two howards scene, i always thought that it meant to show that humanity's Prometheus is humanity itself. But thank you for the amazing videos!!

[@catygarza]

Thanks!

[@Novum_YT]

I'm not sure how I missed this, thank you from two years in the future!

[@MassiveSwordAndCards]

Thank you for this fantastic analysis. You're a true academic. This is so much more well thought out and delivered than anything I was forced to endure in school. Seriously, I can't give you enough praise.

[@jamieshepherd5979]

Wow what an incredibly insightful + in-depth explanation. Made me realise points I hadn’t considered, nice work mate. The gull on Winslow’s chest after he falls at the start is a cool piece of foreshadowing

[@Novum_YT]

Cheers dude! It certainly is, well caught!

[@Luvthexmen]

I’ve loved these long videos of yours the guides, like the hereditary one and this one and soon imma watch the alien one your analysis is just so nice to hear alongside my own thkughts

[@BishopShotgun]

I still come to this video every few months, I wish things were are well researched and put together like this

[@Novum_YT]

Midsommar video coming very soon!

[@scotforrest7168]

Your'e back. This is absolute lobster!

[@Jonjzi]

Comment as an offering to the algorithm gods. Great work. This is the video I was hoping for but never done. YT should realize this is the video most people actually want to find instead of making more difficult.

[@victoriansquirrel]

I watched your analysis right after the movie and you make really good and interesting points that might add to the experience, should I ever watch the movie again! Thank you, good work!

[@Novum_YT]

Thankyou Victorian Squirrel! A++ name, Really glad you enjoyed it!

[@kirstymacca4384]

no way does this only have 700 likes what

[@rasqberre]

im rewatching all these movies just to watch your videos about them atp.. theyre all so cohesive and insightful and fun

[@eldritchwang1006]

Wow this is amazingly well done. So glad it got recommended to me. Good job mate!

[@Novum_YT]

Cheers dude! Glad you enjoyed!

[@arefem9450]

i can truly say before this video i watched and read lots of other blogs but nothing was accomplished from them and i didn't understand anything , but this video made every confusion super clear for me. idk how to thank you for you extraordinary work, thanks for giving us this great explanation. really good job 👌🏿

[@Novum_YT]

I think you just did man thank you so much for that! It means a lot dude and I’m so happy I could help further your understanding of this amazing film! Thanks for watching.

[@jcmurie]

A great companion to this video is Acolytes Of Horror's The Lies of The Lighthouse. It looks at the film from a capitalistic angle, analyzing the relationship of employer and employee between Wake and Howard. Phenomenal work here! Highlighted and explained some things that I overlooked or didn't understand, and put a lot of what I felt into words in a way that I couldn't have

[@pratikpatowary9404]

I'm so glad I clicked on your explainer amongst everything else that popped up. Thank you for this. Brilliant.

[@Novum_YT]

I'm so glad you enjoyed it Pratik, thanks so much for watching!

[@lordmacaulay8739]

Fantastic analysis! As others have commented there should be more mention of the previous (one-eyed?) lightkeeper and the slain one eyed gull. Subscribed! Please do the commentary video. Please do The Shining in the future. Thank you!

[@Novum_YT]

Now the shining is something I hadn't considered yet but definitely worth doing, I will do sir.

[@299meena]

Oh my goodness! I hope you are doing well and your lungs are fully recovered! Thank you for such a great and informational video even while you were recovering from such a serious health issue

[@Novum_YT]

Thanks so much Yasmeen. Yeah - they’re all healed up now! New (long) video on the way in a few days to celebrate 1k subs! Thanks so much for watching!

[@JulesA5266]

Wow amazing work! You took a very confusing movie with really challenging dialogues and unpacked it so well, including information about mythologies and how they tie in and everything. I'm super impressed!

[@fender306]

hour and twenty minute explanation to an hour and fourty minute movie lol. well worth the watch. one of the few movies i've finished and was genuinely unsure what i was supposed to be thinking.

[@joefetzko7334]

My Personal interpretation of this film wasn't homosexual. It's about how isolation and loneliness can drive a person mad. The two men are isolated at a light house in new England. The setting and surroundings take over with Pattinson's sexual visions. He also sees Defoe's character come in his mind because that is the only person he sees every day. Pattinson's loneliness even in vision can't get rid of him. Same with the sea interfering as well. He wants to vision a woman but is interrupted by it being a mermaid. The tentacles are suffocating him because he is suffocating not seeing what he desires. I really like how you can totally see two different interpretations and it can be just as valid.

[@Novum_YT]

That's a lovely and well worded write up dude, thanks so much for that. I absolutely agree with what you've said in terms of it's not homosexuality so much as the sexuality of necessity and isolation. For the most part 'homosexuality' is a bit of an umbrella term here. Thanks so much for watching and taking the time to comment, I'm routinely impressed by the discussion below this video!

[@joefetzko7334]

@@Novum_YT heck yeah! Thanks for the reply :). Also I’m not sure if you’d be interested but I’d love to hear your opinion on Ray Harryhausen films. You are incredibly knowledgeable in Greek mythology. So, have you seen clash of the titans or Jason and the Argonauts? Your viewpoints of the movies would be very interesting.

[@Beach_flower]

Wow Novum! I’m on a rabbit hole of your content after discovering it!! You lay this out perfectly. Thank you for all this work!!

[@imsamposener]

Mate this video is amazing , thank you so much for creating it. In a totally different universe to any other youtube critique I could find. What a crazy film !

[@Novum_YT]

Cheers for the kind words dude! Glad you enjoyed it!

[@imsamposener]

@@Novum_YT of course man, just finished the video. Stunning analysis! Thank you again

[@KidFresh71]

Hey brother, just want to say I'm really enjoying your channel. I also almost died form Covid a couple years back (actually I did die for about 15 seconds), so I can empathize with everything you went through. Glad you are still with us!!

[@Novum_YT]

Fck dude that sucks so bad I’m so sorry that happened. Utterly terrifying going through something like that as is but even worse to be separated from loved ones while it’s happening, and let’s face it conditions were lacking everywhere during that time. Very glad you’re here today too brother. Let’s kick todays ass.

[@tomsawyer095]

I would also want to remark about how what you refer to as prison homosexuality is as much asserting ones own dominance as it is sexuality so the implied rape scene could very much be interpreted to be a matter of Man overpowering and asserting his dominance over the Gods as it is about Ephraim embracing his closeted homosexuality.

[@Novum_YT]

Absolutely sir, spot on!

[@Fivedollarflowers]

This video is so well done. I'm new here and I know I'm 4 years late but this video will live on along with this great film. Bravo!

[@billyturner9930]

I know this is 3 years old but i'm commenting for the algorithm.

[@Novum_YT]

My dude

[@tridentninja1244]

There is a moment in the film that immediately gave me the impression of the God vs Man struggle is when wake tells Howard to mop a spot on the floor and Howard says he’s mopped and scrubbed it and wake goes on a long drawn out description of tedious and unnecessary work that Howard will do if/when wake commands. What really gave it away is that wake tells Howard that he will follow his commands with a smile on his face because he will like it which reminds me of Sisyphus’ punishment to roll the boulder up a hill bc it is his punishment from the gods but some theorize he does it smiling because he is known for outsmarting the gods. The only way to outsmart a god/gods when they take pleasure in your eternal struggle is to smile through it. The same way when you see on tv someone being tortured by another person and the person being tortured is smiling or laughing it makes the person torturing them angry and upset as they are there to break them and hurt them.

[@GabrielBorica]

Jeffiot recommended me the channel, i couldn't pass the opportunity to see such a well constructed essay about one of my favorite movies. Great work!

[@amberhughes7397]

what a incredible break down of this film!! good job man, this film isn’t an easy one to take on and you killed this video!! fantastic analysis

[@amberhughes7397]

certainly an instant sub from me :)

[@Novum_YT]

@@amberhughes7397 Thanks so much Amber!

[@tridentninja1244]

I saw an interpretation for this movie that blew my mind. It’s something along the lines of wake and Howard being the same person at different ages. The interpretation is that the movie is the human psyche of a man with a guilty conscience is a purgatory like state torturing himself for what he’s done in his life. There is little but good evidence for this as the gull Howard kills is missing a left eye the same as the predecessor Howard claims wake murdered after he discovered the body. The reason wake is so upset about Howard fighting with gulls is because of his guilty conscience of killing Howard’s predecessor. Also they’re both named Tom. I’d speculate that Howard had homosexual relations with Winslow and killed him and went on the run and grew old as wake where he murdered another man. It could also be part of the reason wake sees through Howard as he asks Howard why he became a wickie and wake asks him if he on the run. Similar to how a guilty conscience would penetrate a lie someone tells themselves. Howard is also desperate for the light and wake is selfish with it as they’re both seemingly obsessed with it. It seems wake is an old man bent on torturing himself for his past of regret (Howard) with making him work hard and being unfair and cruel to himself. And Howard is desperate to escape his past through “relief” such as drinking, sexual desire, and the light. Howard says he dreams to go build him a house where nobody can tell him nothing which is exactly what wake is like as he tolerates zero input from his subordinate. wake believes he is above criticism or being questioned about his demands. I think wakes symmetry to a Poseidon like figure alludes to a future version of Howard that has become enmeshed with his station at the sea. I like how the movies portray their insanity as the beginning makes you believe Howard is sound of mind and wake is crazy but then it flips later in the film to make wake seem more believable. I think this is done to show Howard’s journey through insanity. I believe they’re both equally insane by the end of the film but wake is more believable as an old man who is aged and grounded in his insanity as Howard is the young one being driven insane unable to deal with losing his mind and wake is completely gone already which is why hes so much more believable towards the end as he’s an old man with less emotional stake in his sanity. Making him more comfortable with gaslighting Howard and being abusive is his unreasonable demands of him. I think their sexual tension reflects one character as a whole grappling with his homosexuality and his desire vs his denial. Also another weird detail I think Howard falls absolutely snaps his leg and wake has a bad leg also that he lies about

[@tridentninja1244]

Also wanted to say I think this movie is brilliant and I think the actual context of the movie isn’t important in “figuring out” what’s going on. I think what’s important is both characters behavior and the littler details into their past and who they are. I don’t think it matters who is right on how long it’s been since they missed their boat whether it’s been two days or weeks. I think what’s important is how both characters react to the distress of not knowing when the boat will come get them. This movie reminds me a lot of a dream. Dreams aren’t necessarily important in context and are often confusing. What usually matters in the dream are subtle things like small details, characters, atmosphere, how you are feeling emotionally

[@tridentninja1244]

Little edit: I think whats important in dreams is how you are feeling emotionally about what happening to you or around you and less about what is actually happening. Like being naked in a dream isn’t necessarily important but if you are feeling anxious about being naked in the dream the core message is usually about being ashamed of who you are

[@MeatGoblin88]

I noticed one scene where Ephraim was smoking a pipe while Tom was smoking a cigarette, which is the opposite of what they both usually smoke. I'm not sure if it meant anything but I'm new to movies so I'm proud of myself for noticing.

[@kpa7013]

Sooooo good dude that was an amazing analysis...first one I've ever watched all the way through 👏👏

[@Novum_YT]

Thank you so much dude! Sorry I only just saw this 10 months later!

[@shanehambrick6941]

What an incredible analysis 👏 props to you for putting in so much time and research for the is masterpiece of a video

[@milesaph]

thank you so much for this video, you truly deserve more recognition for your work!!

[@Novum_YT]

Thanks so much for watching milesaph!

[@FidgetTyme]

This was a amazing video, Thanks so much for all the work you put into this. I'm sorry that it seems KZbin did a silly towards you because a video made this well it's a shame it's not getting the attention it deserves. I wanna say right now the main thing I like about this video is you don't feel the need to speak 100 miles per hour, you take your time with telling everything and that, that we need more of. As someone who gets overstimulated it feels lately by too much noise, too fast of speech and etc, it's nice to be able to listen to a video (I typically multi-task with watching/listening to videos and doing other tasks) and not feel like it's bringing me anxiety from overload on the senses. Enough on the quality of the video and more on the subject the video is on about. I finished watching the movie a few hours ago and out of the videos I found seeing what people said the movie was about, yours is the best. I love how the comparisons to mythology (pardon if not using the right term) with the gods and titans, because watching this movie it was a lot to unpack but I did sense and suspect there was some mythology up in there. As for all the sexuality, I did pick up on that but I didn't really realize the full depth of it like you describe. It's honestly a interesting movie because it has psychological aspects from the characters past and behaviors, but it also has the other side of the coin that makes you wonder what is real and isn't. I've always been intrigued by how the mind works when it comes to madness, how it flips things on us as either a defense or just avoiding confronting the sins(?). Anywho, enough rambling. Thanks for this video and I appreciate all the time and effort you put into it. I'll take a dive in your other content as well. Keep up the good work!

[@epiccat676]

i understand this video is old, however for a channel with a fanbase way too small for the quality of the content you put out im absolutely amazed at the fact that you actually care about putting content out to your small fanbase. its great to see that this video has gotten some traction, and i really hope that you get the attention that you're shockingly high quality content deserves

[@Novum_YT]

Wow dude, that was the boost I needed this morning! Thanks so so much.

[@billjenkins302]

Your hereditary video popped up in my recommended and I thoroughly enjoyed your presentation and how insightful everything was so I had to check this video out too. Did not disappoint, I love this movie and your in depth breakdowns made me appreciate it even more. Very excited for future videos from you

[@mrpoool1015]

This channel is an absolute gem, glad I stumbled upon it.

[@Novum_YT]

Thank you so much dude!

[@aydenottolini7994]

Great video man! I never was able to understand this movie but you really explained it a way that clicked. Can’t wait to watch more!

[@MM-bm5zx]

Regarding Howard turning the body around and seeing himself after "spilling his beans", the body is actually wearing the real Ephraim Winslow's clothes. I just double-checked and it's the exact coat (check the distinct sleeve pattern) he wears in Howard's memories/flashbacks of him.

[@microwavemad]

Absolutely BRILLIANT analysis!!! This is so wonderful!!

[@PaulLee1990]

How does this video not have more views. Great detailed analysis!

[@Novum_YT]

Cheers Paul! I guess it's just a tipping point with views - I'm going to keep at it.

[@kerrybruce760]

Truly enjoyed your breakdown of the movie. I have already seen the film and was confused about the deep lunacy that Rob’s character seems to spiral down into. You have totally cleared up a lot of the imagery that I just wasn’t sure if it was supernatural in nature or if it was all in Rob’s character’s mind. It was awesome. I too loved this film. It reminded me of the Hitchcock films that too were in beautiful black and white. Cinematically this film was truly beautiful and I’ve listened to what Eggers described as how they went about filming this. I truly miss films that are two different characters interacting with just each other and no special effects just pure dramatic perfection. I’m as excited about this film as you are because of the nuances the beautiful cinematic views and the amazing performances. 5 Stars from me. Do you break down other films? If so, please let me know. I’m very glad that you are back to being healthy. Everyone should be so fortunate but it’s just not to be. Say a grateful prayer and I’ll say one for you also Sweetie. By the way, I’m a 47 yr old married Mother and I’m always obsessed with amazing cinema from all corners of the planet. Do you breakdown foreign films or perhaps older films from an earlier time when drama reigned supreme? Thank you so much Sweetheart. Sorry I run on and on but you excited me about the mythos of this beautiful noir film.☺️ Take care.

[@Novum_YT]

Wow Kerry, thanks so much for taking the time to send me such a thoughtful message. I couldn't agree more with your praise for the film, and Eggers himself. Thanks so much for your concerns and prayers also, it means a lot! I absolutely do breakdown other movies and there is lots more content coming very soon! I do enjoy foreign cinema, although I'll admit my experiences with it are limited. If you have any suggestions though, I'd love to check them out! I *love* older cinema, although again I would love to hear suggestions as I'm not as experienced as I'd like to be. So glad I could get you excited about mythos and noir! Thanks again for your kind words, take care and best wishes!

[@CaymenLeP]

I am commenting for the sole purpose of giving you a little boost for the algorithm. PLEASE continue doing what you do. You deserve far more than the work you’ve put into this channel

[@Novum_YT]

Those are some really kind words Caymen! Thank you so much!

[@user-fo7rk4gg2l]

I know this is late... I just discovered your videos recently, but I hope everything has figured itself out by now. Your videos are really amazing!

[@gsogso3444]

I don't want to exaggerate but with the way you did analyzed the movie ,you added color to the movie Thank you

[@newsmales1179]

This is such an incredible video, I watched the whole thing before realizing it came from such a small channel. Great job, those 0 dislikes drive the point home. Pretty sure I ruined that ratio by pointing it out but still, you should be more than proud of the work you did here.

[@Novum_YT]

Thanks so much Paul, I only just noticed the ratio too that's awesome.

[@rachelodle2569]

this is such an amazing video, you deserve so much more recognition!

[@Novum_YT]

So nice of you to say, thanks for watching!

[@MizzAnthrope]

Thank you for summarizing and thus confirming my thoughts about this film. I'm not one who is usually a fan of sci-Fi/horror films, but the performances of Robert Pattinson and Willem Dafoe are just so good, I had to watch the film a second time (with subtitles) to actually confirm the context. I certainly wouldn't be able express my thoughts on it as thoroughly as you have here. Great work.

[@Novum_YT]

That's extremely kind of you to say Lin! Thank you so much and I'm so glad you enjoyed the movie so much! Pattinson is rapidly becoming my new favourite actor!

[@MizzAnthrope]

@@Novum_YT You're very welcome, and I agree. I get more and more impressed with his performances, but this one in particular is so far his best to me.

[@adrianaraffa597]

Bruh this is awesome. I'm ready for a part II lezzzzz goooo!

[@Novum_YT]

Ahaha cheers dude! LESSGO

[@kaylafinlay8502]

when i watched this film for the first time, i viewed Wake’s contradiction of what we saw in the film as a form of emotional and psychological manipulation, a way to establish a hierarchy of power almost. my knowledge of greek mythology is very limited, so i had never viewed it through that lens. however, this review has essentially entirely changed my view on the film. i recently watched the film a second time, then immediately came to this video, and it has completely changed the way i felt about it. this was so well done and i’m so happy this video was made. just saying that a full commentary on the film would be an incredible insight.