諾貝爾獎得主告訴你1929年大蕭條的原因，經濟崩潰最終導致世界大戰？金融海嘯吸取了當年的教訓，我們能再次避免陷入大蕭條嗎？

《趙氏讀書生活》，一個歷史學者的視頻，分享學術、社會、政治經濟觀察
/ drgavinchiu
Wechat: chiusreading
Paypal.me/chiusreading
請支持付費訂閱計劃，每月約30港元即可使頻道持續經營下去！
www.pressplay....

[@gctalk]

為了使《趙氏讀書生活》可持續經營下去，請支持付費訂閱計劃，每月約30港元（120台幣），並用Visa Master信用卡（系統不接受銀聯）便可定期閱讀我的精選文章和MP3聲音檔。 www.pressplay.cc/project/about/趙氏讀書生活/0B661A3E03E15D1EC417CC56DCAD79F3

[@gctalk]

為了使《趙氏讀書生活》可經營下去，請支持付費訂閱計劃，每月約30港元，便可定期閱讀我的精選文章和MP3聲音檔。 www.pressplay.cc/project/about/趙氏讀書生活/0B661A3E03E15D1EC417CC56DCAD79F3

[@rasaidtsang4456]

已訂!

[@zizisze]

👍🏻

[@ivylai7492]

剛剛訂購了👍🙏👏謝謝🙇

[@ccchu7892]

多謝你的知識 無私奉獻

[@paultang2849]

已訂閱，支持， 趙先生，不要太勞累，慢慢做。 謝謝。

[@mama4462]

已經在Presspaly成功以visa訂閱，以行動支持趙吳

[@davidc5438]

善軒老師好! 大家好! 早/午/晚上好!

[@hkkaiming]

謝謝分享。 比like，留言， 看廣告，分享 ， 遲幾個鐘睇， 畀時間上訴。

[@Aldronsho]

實支持。你唔好唔講，講理性又實際地分析，老蕭之外就係你。我都Support緊幾個，唔差你一位

[@鯨頭鸛-j3m]

已付款,受益良多.

[@hohowan7e]

人為的推動，那可以用幾條公式或有限的經濟模组便可解及可測，水底的人事是深不可測!

[@elainekwok7289]

謝謝分享🙏加油💪支持你❤️

[@陸皓東-i9k]

唔會避免，幸存者僅極少數。人總會以快樂為先，東西方壹樣。

[@Vitam2047]

趙博保重身體~多謝你將深奧理論深入淺出，為啟迪民智出力！訂閱左作為一個小小的支持，加油！

[@chi-yuchan7081]

有用的資訊

[@gary9936]

幫你睇佐幾個廣告當係支持

[@Lili-gw5bv]

見有廣告狂㩒入去

[@cwfong4826]

我都係。

[@injimmyland]

趙老師,多謝一課👏👍

[@kkkksiu2ze2]

啱啱睇完 The Bitcoin Standard 呢本書，講到金錢嘅歷史、金本位再去到而家嘅法幣，有個章節提到海耶克凱因斯嘅主張，即刻搵返你 D 舊片嚟重溫下 ！！（但係呢本書講嘅蕭條原因就係因為脫離左金本位，果然吸收知識都係要聽多幾家之言)

[@l_wong]

Thanks

[@peterwong7599]

趙博士：保重身體。還想多看您的視頻呢！支持您。

[@williamcheung6497]

謝謝分享

[@century7p]

High quality review and analysis !

[@hktaima6543]

I like history and story, I am going to!! think you Chiu Sir. I never study college, I feel like I am in your class.!! : ) : )

[@paulpoon7253]

You're a rare good guy from GZ !!!

[@閒云白夢]

我研究下個月費計劃點比錢先 我會支持你 我好中意文學 當年真係選錯科 聽你片學到唔少野

[@hkmachi]

thanks for sharing~~~~!!

[@ivylai7492]

剛剛訂購了👍🙏👏謝謝🙇

[@gctalk]

謝謝支持

[@LAZYBEE360]

人類是經濟動物，也是政治動物。

[@alexchung686]

多谢分享

[@kenken3737]

转發也是支持！

[@Jack388-n5h]

支持

[@wing7542]

想聽聽你講會唔會有糧食危機既出現?

[@cch312]

聽左一半, 一直勁希望你將會講既係Milton Friedman, Bingo! Thanksgiving剛到U Chicago專登到經濟系睇佢既exhibition. 佢係20世紀自由既守衛者之一. He didn't really have any new discoveries. He simply explained the "invisible hand" theory by Adam Smith to those that benefited from it, yet have forgotten about it.

[@bboybenny7]

剛剛訂閱了你的 PressPlay

[@gctalk]

謝謝支持

[@harrytse4239]

Thank you Professor Chiu!

[@vanesa9689]

我係電腦盲，唔識訂。不過一定舞得掂嘅。撐趙博。希望同路人都撐九子，24日去法庭聲援，這些志士犧牲太大了。

[@denniswkwong]

已即時訂閱

[@CA94949]

網上用VISA有保留，可否直接中銀過數，以示支持趙生繼續營運KZbin，身體要緊。

[@aktungchung8426]

,趙生又錯,美國第31任總統胡佛於1928年競選美國總統時，許下承諾，提高農產品進口關稅，協助經濟拮据的農民。當時農民受商品及地價下跌影響，導致負債纍纍。胡佛上場後兌現承諾，國會於1930年通過斯姆特霍利關稅法案(Smoot-Hawley law)，法案要保護農民，也保護美國製造商。但此法案有超過1,000位經濟學家反對，亦有被質疑是否漠視美股健康狀況，而美股早在1929年10月已開始崩圍。不是經濟大蕭條之後有貿易戰,系大蕭條之前已經有貿易戰,間接令到經濟出事,08年1萬1千幾點,升到3萬2千,3.幾倍,同美國當時差不多,趙生股市比例不對,咩12萬點,系由低位計算

[@frankchanny1006]

Comment share like ad watching

[@Winnie_The_Poorer]

請分析下近年黃金大漲原因，及黃金要到咩問題出現至會大跌。🙏

[@洪呆呆-m1u]

趙博可以说说阿桑奇. 我佩服的一个英雄人物.

[@ecosphere123]

刘小帅 白痴

[@johnnyleong3989]

支持，如何付費，找不到付費的入口？

[@gctalk]

收費平台可獲參考資料和專欄分享，請以每月5元或更多的美元支持：www.patreon.com/Chiusreading 或於KZbin 上按加入成為會員，可獲影片的參考資料 kzbin.info/door/mi1...

[@jeremy3195]

可唔可以補拍返你講海耶克提出比信用本位更好既學說？

[@gctalk]

可講到，可查比特幣系列

[@jeremy3195]

貨幣非國家化理論對政府或既得利益者而言 應該係只有壞處而無好處？ 如果係咁，係政府不帶頭推行既前提下，大眾市場要推反國家化貨幣都好有難度WO。 就算過分QE引致信用危機，富人稅對政府而言，應該係更容易既解決方法。 但個人認為，富人稅治標不治本，因為整個cash flow都無變過，最終都係由窮人手上流入富人。趙博點睇？

[@jeremy3195]

Gavinchiu趙氏讀書生活 thx 陣間睇下

[@mchan3649]

Overall quite right but the theory of MV=PY can be better

[@Kevin-finity]

我人在美國沒辦法用debit card 支付。 希望可以有paypal的支付渠道 亦同時可以享受到pressplay的服務。

[@joesingsing4829]

WECHAT 課俾你

[@skhohon9940]

現今中國的經濟和政治情況，和德國在第二次世界大戰前夕，十分相似！！由其是這種利用"愛國"情緒，來令國民聽命于一人，是十分危險！！

[@mr_shawn]

很棒的歷史講解！大約每過10年會出現一次大蕭條 這影片教三個方法讓你不怕疫情影響工作，不再擔心失業 也推薦給大家看！ @6RMg

[@wingyu99]

The title should be "PressPlay".

[@TheChriswong4238]

Payme 會方便過presspay

[@心心念念明顯沒怎麼]

香港人反抗

[@hkHo-iu8uc]

聽蕭生講好過趙博 同一題目類比

[@llll7813]

1929还有贸易战，贸易壁垒。 （其实你加字幕估计订阅很快会翻倍）

[@gctalk]

試過有有10幾條有字幕，但增長不足2%

[@llll7813]

@@gctalk 慢慢来嘛。（设计个醒目的艺术字封面，估计会有效果）

[@yilinghu5870]

I will ask my friend how to pay via PayPal. 💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪

[@gctalk]

Credit card is also okay

[@yilinghu5870]

Gavinchiu趙氏讀書生活 Thank you! I’m learning pay via Wechat. My friend told me, open Wechat wallet first, then my friend send money to my Webchat account.

[@archiekleung]

Present

[@archiekleung]

I have a slightly different view on the Great Depression. At the end of WW1 we do not know much on the working of the economy particularly world trade. Germany lost the war. The allies each come up with a dollar figure demand (reparations) from Germany. Soon after Germany defaulted. The allied marched back into Berlin and found there was no money in the vault. (don't laugh, we learn a lot in the past 100 years). So Germany started to print money to pay reparations. That quickly started the hyperinflation. That is contagious. Skip details. Britain caught it then America followed. Germany found a solution to break the trend. It was Socialism. The leader was Hitler and his power base was the Nazi Party which was a socialist political movement. He asked people to believe in a new currency and to built infrastructure. The economy revived very quickly because it was the right medicine at the time and the hard working people. A British guy Maynard Keynes witnessed the change and wrote a book called The Managed Economics (I think). Basically be was writing the Germany experience using deficit spending to neutralize the depression. At the time America was having a bad time. Poor people marched to Washington got nothing. They were pushed out of the state. Neighbouring states gave them petrol and guarded them along the way OUT. Teddy Rosevelt learned the lesson from Keynes and wisely decided to build the Hover Dam. There was no need for a dam at the time but successfully provided jobs to absolve the marchers. Google the distance to fathom the depth of the tragedy. The world put Keynes on the pedestal but carefully ignored Hitler's role in the idea of Managed Economics. It is also for this reason Churchill was kicked out of the PM office and installed Labour Government. Some people saw Nazi (1933 to 45) minus the war years could bounce back so quickly with such force they thought they would do that same. (By the way the allies bombers could not find the arsenal factories. The economists only solved the mystery after the war ended).They almost lost the country, This come back in a lighter note on the movie Tiger and Dragon. For some people, even if they have the code book they would not amount to much.

[@martintsang9224]

Archie Leung excellent explanation

[@oscar19960823]

CLS LIKE

[@tszkwan5282]

CLS

[@唯真史]

有胆讲吓大6货币政策來聽吓 1949至今

[@ccc3636]

如何支付訂閲？

[@gctalk]

www.pressplay.cc/project/about/趙氏讀書生活/0B661A3E03E15D1EC417CC56DCAD79F3

[@patrng0322]

cls 返先

[@何其樂]

拍一段什訂閱的視頻比D有需要的人睇睇會好D😬😬☺️

[@Winnie_The_Poorer]

感覺上通漲對低下階層不利，通縮對商人不利。

[@laohai9209]

点解今集拍得甘差，理论上iphone7都唔会甘

[@gctalk]

支咪插唔實

[@支蝗]

試下推斷 支共幾時碌街呀

[@陸皓東-i9k]

大陸佬今次（2024年9月）無錨印鈔2萬億，不足外可再印2萬億；恐怕經濟大災難即將加重到來。

[@AXSSOLI]

wtf 就系印钱😅

[@bonnielee8734]

多謝分享

[@billychan204]

香港人反抗