Nuclear Engineer Reacts to Animation vs. Physics by Alan Becker

Original Video @alanbecker • Animation vs. Physics

[@tfolsenuclear]

Thanks so much for watching! If you would like to see my reaction to Animation vs. Math, please check out: kzbin.info/www/bejne/iHStiGVnga-DZqssi=P3SedBGrEDouslhx

[@arminheinaste9021]

First Reply!

[@SolarizD_12559]

i was waiting for you to react to this

[@medkitty]

I love your reactions because not only do we get to watch the video, we also get background knowledge and more information. Keep up the good work!

[@dougkyle685]

Look up spinlaunch

[@villss894]

the fact you are nuclear engineer is insane

[@_Biofodder_]

little known fact: the sun has an atmosphere (but that trick he did with the hat is still 99.9999% impossible)

[@_Biofodder_]

(more specifically the "corona" of the sun)

[@itsmetaphor2153]

id say a solar sail would be a lot more efficient the closer you are to the sun... but yes still would be HIGHLY unlikely

[@colixart]

ill take those odds, imma get my camera.

[@slowpurplealien]

Yup, the star (don't think it is the sun) has such a high force of gravity

[@couththememer]

@@colixart "Welcome to Fact-or-Cap, where we test things out to see if they're true or not"

[@Goomba456]

I hope this guy does an 'Animation vs Chemistry' video someday, I think that'd be really neat.

[@BobtheBuilder-gb2sf]

with Blue, or aka Blue Figure. for some of the people who doesn't know, Blue is showed to have a passion for potions and cookery in the Alan Beckers lore of Minecraft

[@bryonyhatb.s4341]

Imagine a 'Animation vs Biology' it could be so epic

[@Changed.User100]

Animation vs Culture Could be good one where the animation meets a whole bunch of gods and traditions in the past

[@limepelt2348]

I think animation vs chemistry could he next, as I think this was meant to be a sequel to animation vs math

[@jamergameridiot6631]

@@BobtheBuilder-gb2sfjesse…

[@somdudewillson]

<a href="#" class="seekto" data-time="1050">17:30</a> He's a _literal_ stick figure. i.e. an animation. Therefore, he's not even actually made of matter - he's basically a primitive physics object in a computer physics simulation that has been moved to the real world _unchanged._

[@riah9549]

I was wondering about that, even if being an animation wasn't taken into consideration any 2d "object" you can think of doesn't necessarily have matter, im not rlly good at this field tho lol

[@pokemonfanmario7694]

I personally headcanon that the AvA world is one where imagination can literally come to life - such as stick figures, video game characters, even graffiti and cave art! Its a 'Amazing world of Gumball' type situation. TSC is one case, and the maths and physics dimensions are another (the latter cases being representation of humanities understand of those fields, not theoretical true models.) Eventually those two dimensions will change as mankinds knowledge grows deeper.

[@SpecterNeverSpectator]

i dont think he moved to the real world unchanged, i think he is simply *inside* the simulations, hence why the planet is white and empty or heat and oxygen not accounted for, because this is a physics simulation.

[@kristoferleobaisac5631]

He *matters* man 😢

[@callumstonehouse8407]

"Maybe there's something a little bit out of the ordinary about him" If only y'all knew the lore... 😂

[@savdebunnies]

The director has said they're most likely going to do a whole "Animation vs. Education" series now so that's something to look forward to.

[@Gabboele]

this comment made me think about a possible "animation vs chemistry" video where he plays with elements and electrons to make different kind of reaction and eventually discover nuclear fusion

[@johncollinowensy4255]

God bless us all, that’s the best news I’ve heard on KZbin all day

[@andrrjod]

thats cool and all but i do want him to work more on animation vs animator cus its sick

[@nuh_uh210]

@@Gabboele”No, orange, don’t pull on that enriched uran-“

[@jonathanodude6660]

@@Gabboele nuclear reactions technically arent chemistry.

[@tristangreenlee9272]

<a href="#" class="seekto" data-time="1118">18:38</a> Compact dimensions were explained to me like this: imagine an ant walking along a straw. The ant can move forward, back, left, or right. However, if you zoom way way out, the direction along the circumference of the straw is no longer noticeable, and it looks like the ant only goes forward or back. That small, circular dimension is called 'compact'.

[@amesky4589]

Is that inside or outside the straw?

[@dinojack5567]

It can go around tho

[@rickroller1566]

@@amesky4589Doesn't matter. In fact, the ant is in the straw, not air.

[@mattstarwolf-08]

For a moment I thought we were gonna have another acrobat answer again.

[@tristangreenlee9272]

@SonaNerikovvv Not exactly. The moon appears to move slowly because its distance from Earth means that it subtends very small arcs per unit time when viewed from Earth, not because of compact motion. Imagine if the moon were lopsided and wobbled on its axis, by a kilometer or so. From Earth, you would need a telescope to see it, because a 1 km wobble is negligible compared to the distance between the Earth and the moon. The point of a compact dimension is that its size is negligible, not merely that it is difficult to see.

[@ultralaggerREV1]

Ok so I love how the music composer that Alan paid for, he literally added a little easter egg on the soundtrack played when the camera zooms out to show the black hole. That piano part is literally straight out of Interstellar

[@mikblues_146]

It was probably Shuriken255 since he left animation as his main thing to go for music

[@ultralaggerREV1]

@@mikblues_146 it was never shuriken (who even is that), it’s Scott Buckley. The music used in both “vs Math” and this one comes from Scott Buckley. He literally added a piece from Interstellar as a bit of an easter egg

[@dizdawgjr34]

I KNEW IT SOUNDED FAMILIAR

[@SomeRandom_personInTheInternet]

​​​@@ultralaggerREV1Shuriken 255 is an animator who's part of a certain community called Hyun's Dojo.... Also yeah, Scott Buckley composed all of the orchestral pieces in Alan Becker's videos

[@hihihihihiiii]

So glad to see somebody else heard that too

[@HeyItsQuantum]

<a href="#" class="seekto" data-time="1049">17:29</a> "Maybe there's something out of the ordinary about him..." If he watches the entire Minecraft vs. Animation series he'll definitely understand how TSC didn't get immediately killed when he reached the event horizon

[@itsdiscocreeper]

i was gonna say, if only he knew what TSC is capable of XD

[@Shartmaster_]

if he watched Animator vs. Animation he would know that he's basically the most powerful being in his universe XD

[@Zack-xv2yc]

I mean, TSC did literally fought a mathematical concept almost to the death. So I'm pretty sure this whole video is actually lightwork for him.

[@luzellemoller6621]

Yeah plus he NEEDS to react to the whole series idc of ot doesn't have to do with what he knows, he's a good reaction person

[@ToniShiawase]

Can't be delete by Alan Becker, survive the heat of star, survive a black hole, smart enough to defeat Euler Identity, have insane speed, strength, abilites when awakening. Definitely a god

[@kennyholmes5196]

<a href="#" class="seekto" data-time="547">9:07</a> - <a href="#" class="seekto" data-time="562">9:22</a> Actually, it would. But not because of the hat. Because of the way the rocket is pointing. If you look closely, you'll see the rocket goes from pointing directly away from the star to pointing perpendicular to his previous path, giving him lateral motion that isn't counteracted by the star's gravity, enabling him to orbit and eventually slingshot outta there.

[@ronakjain1872]

only if rocket dont melt down so close to a star like sun

[@kennyholmes5196]

@@ronakjain1872 Indeed. Lucky him that the rocket was made of a single closed cosmic string then, no?

[@thefactspherefromportal2740]

Also a good thing that TSC isn't human (and) the rocket isn't made from conventional materials!

[@agooddoctorfan651]

Oh wow didn’t think abt that, thanks!

[@nightmaerghost9129]

Just hope he sees this

[@yogurtofthemultiverse2200]

Just because im sure youre curious, the only reason TSC survived the black hole is because he has deletion immunity. In other words, he cannot be vaporized or erased. Funky, right?

[@HyperVanilo]

Ah yes, the VS wiki lingo

[@yogurtofthemultiverse2200]

@@HyperVanilo lmao I actually don't use vs wiki, I'm just a nerd

[@pokemonfanmario7694]

A singularity consumes matter and energy. TSC is imagination given life, and couls reasonably not be killed by doing something like unplugging the computer he lives in or throwing him into a black hole. Though Im also certain the black hole isnt even a real one, its also similar to TSC in that its a manifestation of imagination - just one based on humanities 'perception' of what a black hole is, just like the entirety of the physics dimension is all human concepts and no 'true physics'.

[@kupatopia]

@@pokemonfanmario7694 I mean also they're cannonically immune to deletion it was literally shown in AvA 4 (I think)

[@beardedzeus1337]

<a href="#" class="seekto" data-time="1232">20:32</a> there wasnt any quantum entanglement with the rocket. He used closed strings to create the rocket himself and then sent that rocket through the wormhole. Same with the solar system, flashlight, apple that all of his past versions used. And as far as the hat trick near the star, stars absolutely have their own atmosphere(its how solar winds exist) but yes his hat wouldnt do anything, but it wasnt his hat that changed his velocity, it was him kicking the rocket away from the star giving him enough of an angle for his acceleration to slowly change his trajectory from a collision course to a slingshot. And at the very end he didnt go to another "universe" as it were, rather he completed the Causal Loop by returning to his own timeline. Edit: so he did go to another universe which means he avoided a Temporal Paradox by leaving the universe, which means the Causal Loop only exists for those that have yet to complete it.

[@dibbidydoo4318]

No he went to another universe, a type ii multiverse. Tegmark's four-level classification consists of Level I: an extension of our universe, Level II: universes with different physical constants, Level III: many-worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics, and Level IV: ultimate ensemble.

[@DatBoi_TheGudBIAS]

​@@dibbidydoo4318there were 6 selectors, wat were the other 2?

[@danielcojocariu8438]

@@DatBoi_TheGudBIAS Something from string theory. There are 5 or 4 possible types of universes that can be described with string theory, I thing one of them is super gravity type of universe. From string theory, one univers is with open and closed string, another with closed string and those string can have different vibration and so on. You can watch "M Theory | Towards a theory of everything?" from "ScienceClic English", it explain those theories.

[@beardedzeus1337]

@@dibbidydoo4318 fair enough I'm not too familiar with the Tegmark classification of multiverses. So I'll concede there.

[@elmundodenatanael4173]

so that was him from the future so the present he after his future get into the Type II universe he has to do the same thing to the past himself and then do the same thing like an eternal loop?

[@toyuki6367]

<a href="#" class="seekto" data-time="1353">22:33</a> I like the detail of how the orange without the hat isn’t laughing as much cuz he’s already went through the same event

[@JamUsagi]

I wondered why Orange began shrinking at the black hole’s singularity, but I think it actually makes sense? Everything else is a real-ish thing made of real-ish particles that obey real-ish physics, but Orange is literally just a cartoon. So everything else is compressed until it can’t be compressed any further, but because Orange is a cartoon, he can be compressed further to the point that he’s smaller than the smallest particles in physics. …I think.

[@Time_Lantern_Gameplay]

According to what I read over 7 years ago. I heard entering the blackhole would crush something into an infinitesimal dot after spaghettification

[@cooly1234]

its actually an effect called Frame Dragging which would be noticeable near the inner horizon of a black hole. due to how the extreme gravity bends space time, objects appear bigger than they are. Now is that a 100% realistic depiction of frame dragging? ofc not.

[@pokemonfanmario7694]

Its because TSC is an imaginative concept of a flash stick figure. In flash you can resize objects - the black hole couldnt "crush" him like it did with the apple, but it could 'resize' him as its closest approximation. Fortunately, resizing an object in flash doesnt kill it.

[@fuzzystudiosofficial]

I think that's because tsc is drawn as a scalable vector (file type), so it can be literally scaled to any size

[@mophin]

Yes, besides, this video "Animation vs Mathematics" probably happened inside a computer, in a public simulator or something like that. It's not like orange is seeing real planets

[@minecraftpala5575]

I don't understand how can he accelerate using fixed magnets because when accelarating before entering the loop, he would equally deccelarate when getting away.

[@dovos8572]

@@londonjedi he would need to swap the polarity of his own magnet or detach it for this to work or he would lose all or at least 80% of his accellerated speed after going through the mid point. it is the only mistake i can see inside the video. also the shown magnets have a symmetrical field so the amount of force while flying towards it is the same as when flying away from it and thus it would break you a similar amount to what it accellerated you. (this is the reason why coil guns need to be electronically controlled (polarity switching) in a pretty precise manner.

[@PincKen]

Pepega

[@pedronevesurias2318]

Nerd Edit: It's a joke, I repeat, it is a fucking joke 😫

[@electrifiedbathbomb7383]

Actually, yeah he would instantly get recoiled back or hit a magnetic brick wall if that were to happen

[@londonjedi]

@@dovos8572 You are right, this layout wouldn't work, I was thinking of a different set up. Ferromagnets can be used ot create an accelerator though, but even then guass guns are less efficient than coil guns.

[@jeremy1860]

Either Alan is a really smart guy, or he's got a whole team of researchers helping him with his vids 😊

[@user-js4xl7pw7l]

No, just that his lead animator is a nath and physics nerd

[@NonsensicalSpudz]

yeh people, the math one was done by his PHD friend

[@Remir_]

@@user-js4xl7pw7l so you're basically saying that there won't be more videos in this format?(

[@charcoalcharcoalcharcoal]

the head of his animator team is the nerd who made it all

[@user-he2bo4zg9c]

most likely the researches one.

[@TheAgamemnon911]

On a more serious note... relativistic doppler effect is more than just color shift. It also affects observed time at a distance. (objects in rear mirror age slower)

[@GregJumpscare]

WARNING: Objects in mirror may age slower than they appear.

[@TheAgamemnon911]

@@GregJumpscare I mean... I could be pedantic now, but it would kill the joke.

[@Pickled_Poet]

This is time dilation which is included in the animation

[@lightning4743]

i watched the Alan Becker video on his channel and fried my brain and now i watched it here with the explanation from a expert and still fried my brain, I'm just gonna stick to my computer science.

[@moxstoleyoursocks2241]

me too my guy

[@Parallax-ec4ik]

We're opposites because I tried computer science and it fried my brain. I'm just gonna stick to physics

[@moxstoleyoursocks2241]

@@Parallax-ec4ik actually, if you know how to do algebra, you can learn the programming language python pretty easily!

[@colixart]

@@Parallax-ec4ik physics is easy, it’s just: big stuff go down fast, and big big stuff pull stuff

[@moxstoleyoursocks2241]

@@colixart Yeah…and then it goes to quantum mechanics, and string theory, and black holes, and spaghettification, and I don’t know how we got to the doppler effect AFTER rocket science in this video.

[@Gancrothor-II]

<a href="#" class="seekto" data-time="1080">18:00</a> if you didn’t know, that dimension is strings from string theory.

[@kidzfrenz]

Like Film Theory! But with strings!

[@AmaiarAiramand]

I don't think the animation is meant to be totally realistic, but rather an interactive and fun way to illustrate concepts. Remember the Math video, where they were "magically" using math as weapons and means of travelling between planes and stuff. Granted, this one delves into a lot of more... theoretical assumptions, but from the beginning the "Animation VS" series already was lead by reality-warping stick figures anyways

[@sugardude]

Your perspective helped for me! It indeed does make lot more sense when I see it as creative playaround with various concepts.

[@duxbellorum2772]

This is the best video I have ever watched. The original is so amazing, but this commentary takes it to another level because you are able to further inform.

[@tfolsenuclear]

Thanks so much!! I truly appreciate that!

[@AielHeart]

I think the waving of the cowboy hat was to speed up the horse-rocket. It’s something you’ll see them do in western movies sometimes. So the rocket is the one actually creating thrust not the waving of the hat

[@Kzorith]

Part of me wonders if it was an homage to Doctor Strangelove or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb. In that movie there was a guy with a cowboy hat riding a missile.

[@pokemonfanmario7694]

​@@Kzorithit absolutely was a reference lol.

[@Sir_Uncle_Ned]

Fun fact; active stars like the one show here do actually have an atmosphere of sorts. It’s called the Corona and is alarmingly hot to the point where the surface of the star is colder. I don’t think we’ve been able to find a way to explain that.

[@martinhrubjak9625]

I do believe it has to do something with the magnetic field concentrating in those areas. After all Sun's magnetic field is uneven and holds tremendous amounts of energy that can be released as solar bursts.

[@AleXxTM123]

Every time the Stick figure interacts with the world around it it is described in physic equations/drawings. What he does with his hat wasn't for lift. Its a Cowboy style while doing rodeo. Slap the bull/horse with your hat on the back to make it go faster. Just go watch some Rodeo videos and you see what i mean.

[@Real_MisterSir]

There was a recent study and video explaining all the different measurable layers of the sun, how they form, and what they do. It's called "The Deepest We Have Ever Seen Into the Sun" by Astrum, and has an entire section dedicated to observing and explaining the Corona with camera visuals. It's really great. Link to vid: kzbin.info/www/bejne/bHbFpnR7lsyEoJY&ab_channel=Astrum

[@tichtoch234]

I rly like this guy's reaction and also telling what the words and numbers and symbols are talking about great work man. And the fact that he predicts most parts is really cool

[@tfolsenuclear]

Thank you!!

[@jayde4872]

<a href="#" class="seekto" data-time="551">9:11</a> counter argument: stars have coronas, so he technically could do that.

[@Kuze_Oscar]

I love how the time paradox didn't take effect because the timeline wasn't altered because future orange did the exact same thing the future future orange did...now if the present orange decides to change things and doesn't tell past orange about the things future orange taught him it'll then take place altering history...which can lead to different outcomes

[@nathanpfirman625]

Someone should make a game where it uses actual physics to do everything in the game and it shows the math and calculations above you whenever you attempt something.

[@cooly1234]

closest ive seen is Noita. it doesn't tell you why stuff happens though which is the funny part.

[@noahhui1976]

To incorporate all the different mechanics and concepts accurately in a single is going to be really maybe 100s of years from now when we are very advanced

[@RadioactiveCo.]

<a href="#" class="seekto" data-time="1047">17:27</a> "maybe there is something a little out of the ordinary about him" - Orange casually shoots lasers out of his eyes and lifts up things with the force and magically heals himself in The Showdown

[@johnflux1]

At <a href="#" class="seekto" data-time="660">11:00</a> when he gets accelerated through the magnets, nobody seems to have noticed that it's important that the magnets get switched off as he goes through them. Otherwise they just pull him right back again. You can't just make a accelerator with nothing but a line of magnets.

[@NguyenMinh792]

No, they’re permanent magnets

[@ryanchen3327]

Alan Becker was smart enough to make a literal time paradox

[@minhsu6082]

there is a big team behind it! And the one that is doing all the science/math stuff isnt Alan Becker at all hahaha. He's said before that he's trusting a coworker with all this and animates it on the trust ^^

[@hishamrashid5293]

Not really. All the credit should go to the lead animator since he was the physics nerd who was able to make this happen.

[@ntfoperative9432]

Except not really, there’s nothing paradoxical about it. It’s all one closed, concise loop. There’s nothing to really break it

[@mikblues_146]

@@minhsu6082 That lead animator is Terkoiz

[@supercharged5-39]

not really a paradox, more like a closed loop. TSC goes in, orchestrates stuff for his past self, meets his past self, grabs his cowboy hat, and leaves, letting the second TSC to do the same thing

[@phanquan9470]

the fact that you understand and predict whats going to come convince me you are god tier at physics

[@lucrayzor9657]

One of the coolest little details in this video is that when you first get that cinematic shot of the black hole, the orchestral drone that plays is nearly one-to-one with the score from Interstellar! Makes sense since there’s significant visual inspiration as well. It’s from the tail end of the docking scene

[@I_Am_Transcendentem]

I think I just experienced the sorrow of ten thousand souls in a cycle where the same item is passed through, the same apple the same tree the same cosmic string.

[@compendium72]

I don't think it is a cycle. In the beginning, TSC appeared out of a flash, not dropped from a hole or anything, implies this is the sequel of vs Maths video. Later, we saw the Penrose Diagram, which means the multiverse is possible. At the end, the past TSC changed the "mode" of wormhole, allows him to escape to different universe with the hat. So the story is linear.

[@brll5733]

It's only one soul though

[@RedmondtJacks]

<a href="#" class="seekto" data-time="546">9:06</a> the hat here is used to signal the rocket to speed up, it’s a cowboy gag, you can see it multiple times

[@user-yu3dg5ml1z]

Who else wishes teachers used animations like this to educate us? I understand so much more from this 1 vid compared to 3 years of physics in school 😂

[@TheLanguageShikshak]

ok, this means you've understood nothing

[@thechrisgrice]

You saw an animation, you didn't actually learn anything. Do you think this would enable you to pass a Physics exam?

[@user-yu3dg5ml1z]

@@thechrisgrice just coz ur mind couldn't comprehend wat was going on doesn't mean mine didn't, if the exams were on the subject matter in the video then yes

[@thechrisgrice]

@@user-yu3dg5ml1z Somehow I doubt that. And I'm a physics teacher too. It's bold of you to assume that students even watch animations or videos like this. They certainly don't absorb information from it.

[@axeldewater9491]

As a student in aerospace engineering, a couple hours ago, I was doing my dynamics homework, which is basically based on the first part of the video, and boy, I wish that video would be enough for my exam. Explain to me please what vectors are, I doubt you could tell me without looking it up. And yes they were in the video.

[@Aety9]

<a href="#" class="seekto" data-time="541">9:01</a> I think he was just "yee-hawing" the hat and kicking the rocket for more thrust. Shifting the angle of thrust from away (up) <a href="#" class="seekto" data-time="538">8:58</a> to forward <a href="#" class="seekto" data-time="546">9:06</a> with the added thrust was enough to slingshot the star.

[@beansnrice321]

Entanglement is pervasive on macroscopic objects. It's like the whole mess of atoms are entangled with each other.

[@beansnrice321]

Since it's truly impossible to not be in motion. Technically, you're always doing work. =D

[@Sunnee26]

excuse added to queue

[@keyravens]

Work is force x displacement. You can be moving without force being applied.

[@fruityloops11]

@@keyravens wouldn't that make work 0 as force will be 0 pretty similar to when you are in space and just in resting position will that be called a work done or not as force applied is zero??

[@JustAnotherCommenter]

Aww thanks for covering up me doing no work whatsoever

[@cooly1234]

@@fruityloops11 if you do work to something, it means you applied force to that thing over a distance. if you applying force to something without any distance (perhaps theres an opposite force) you do no work.

[@thefactspherefromportal2740]

<a href="#" class="seekto" data-time="1232">20:32</a> In the animations, Orange is a stick figure with the power to make drawings come to life. Here's an example using similar rockets in a fight against a computer virus: kzbin.info/www/bejne/inecemR9rbOXgLMsi=_6ZNC8-y8wA_RkyH&t=228

[@theheresiarch3740]

Could you maybe do a video about what systems and procedures are in place to deal with a nuclear power plant's auxiliary structures and its immediate grid connections being damaged by something like a major tornado? The tornado outbreak last night went right over several nuclear power plants, and one of the tornadoes was fairly close to Brown's Ferry NPP.

[@4RILDIGITAL]

I may not understand everything you said, but I sure enjoyed listening to your explanations.

[@noppornwongrassamee8941]

This whole "TSC makes stuff out of strings" makes me think TSC has Dr. Manhattan powers. It'd explain his mysterious powers in the main series.

[@finalone24]

That one was really cool and a nice intro to physics up to the entering the black hole part where things become purely theoretical.

[@kerfumblelumble]

Love how he says "Maybe theres something a little bit special about him," completely oblivious to the fact TSC has thrusted himself literally to the speed of light COMPLETELY by himself in AvA 5 where the virus was about to infect all the internet, then get suddenly torn apart seemingly out of thin air. We couldn't see TSC rip them apart because he was moving either at the speed of light or literally faster than the speed of light.

[@pvppro5036]

I love how one of the hat's purposes is to serve as an indicator for which direction the character is facing

[@abslon4772]

<a href="#" class="seekto" data-time="194">3:14</a> That trick should not work. Because the ball should go forward, but that also means he gets pushed backwards. Because of the string, that would result him in just being stuck in the same place.

[@K0nam3Two]

the gravity add more force to it

[@acakeshapedlikeatrainonatable]

@@K0nam3Two that doesn't change anything, abslon4772 is correct. he needs the throw and let go of the ball in the other direction to move along the frictionless surface

[@someoneweeb]

I think it works because as you said , the forces do cancel out at first but once the ball stops , the tension in the string due to inertia would pull him forward.

[@tibetje226]

​@@someoneweebit would not, throwing the Ball gives him momentum in the other direction. Grabbing the rope cancel both so he would stand still again.

[@someoneweeb]

@@tibetje226 hmmmm but while throwing the ball ahead, he didn't move back means he was holding on with his feet? So that's why the inertia when kicks in can bring him forward? If he'd moved back and then forward then it would have been same, but he held on and didn't move back right?

[@ZXZMARKyle]

Loved the reaction I Never expected a Nuclear engineer to react to this

[@epikoof]

i couldn't wait for you to make a vieeo as soon as this came out, if this becomes a series please keep reacting, it's nice understanding things

[@deyzick32]

exactly what i was waiting for when i saw that video uploaded. glad it blew up for you again :D

[@rowan.mp3]

there's something about the ending of the video that i genuinely don't remember but they cut the ending off like that for a very specific reason?? something about conceptual stuff. i genuinely don't remember and don't know enough about physics to remember exactly what but the amount of thought and detail they put in is incredible

[@karlharvymarx2650]

Especially when I was in school, I did so many free body diagrams, I was seeing an overlay of them on reality. So I can relate to sketch dude except my vectors were in color and I never rode a rocket or fell into a blackhole. We did some relativity but not enough to have an intuitive feel for it. For instance, in our time frame, has anything had time reach the "bottom" of a black hole? Maybe we don't see white holes because nothing is coming out of them yet?

[@TyoAtrosa]

He wasn't producing thrust with his hat, he was telling the rocket to giddyup! 😂

[@aleafreinn]

I was waiting for youtube to recommend me the video of you reacting to Alan Becker’s Animation vs Physics! I think everybody does haha

[@smallsavage1297]

I'm learning more from this video than I ever did in my actual physics class lol

[@justynpryce]

I'm sure you have, now use the information in this video to do actual physics

[@DianeSteele]

@@justynpryce cant use info for much if you don't have an interest in it, can you? effective science communication is more about getting people interested than anything else, this animation is a wonderful jumping off point for just, looking shit up and learning. finding a fun application for physics is the only way to learn that stuff without losing your mind from boredom

[@justynpryce]

@@DianeSteele Agreed, it's really bothersome when people will say they learned from a youtube video that didn't actually teach anything. Like you said, what they mean is they're much more interested and they feel like they know something they didn't before. That's valuable but that, of course, isn't the same as being taught and doesn't bring the same types of value as learning. Comments framed this way devalue learning and teaching by conflating knowing a fun fact and trivia with actual deep physical and theoretical understanding that can only be obtained by actually learning the subject and not through these sorts of videos which exist as spectacle.

[@bobbobby5442]

It just gives basics and theories. You need to research further if u wanna learn

[@yuleizhao5908]

That's the apple which hit Newton lol

[@OneColdRepublican]

I think my favorite within the video is the music. Really feels like something greater as we go through each defination of physics.

[@cappunocci9211]

Your explanation of the Doppler Effect finally made the lightbulb in my head light up when I had a flashback to Sheldon Cooper in The Big Bang Theory explaining his costume - which I never got, until now.

[@reaganlpeterson]

You didn’t mention how the stockman can manually start at those high velocities, he has incredible reflexes.

[@whosamuwhat]

Been seeing your videos pop up in my recommended over the past couple months and I've enjoyed everyone I've clicked on so far. Love the content. Keep up the great work!

[@tfolsenuclear]

Thanks so much!

[@Otatsuke]

So cool to see some of the ways these laws and theories can apply from a professional perspective.

[@noelsoto4329]

The short animations of basic formulas are gonna be references so much in the future I can just tell by how basic and simple they are to understand.

[@MegaBonBonified]

Just some character context For both the math and physics episodes. TSC-> (our favorite orange super being with amnesia),these episodes that take place inside his head to pass the time in his cell while he's in holding. He's really just meditating on the concepts.😊 giving quite the representation of the fun to be had thinking about this stuff. Especially if you have "a different way of thinking about things "

[@amadeusoliveira9846]

This is a red cannon, not reality

[@DarkShard5728]

​@@amadeusoliveira9846what about a green cannon?

[@MegaBonBonified]

@@amadeusoliveira9846 😅Sorry ahead of time. I fully expect you to go "TLDR" and trash talk me for personal amusement.😗 I'm fine with that. Anyway...😌 😊 I thank you for giving me a reason to explain my thinking on the subject. it's a fitting and logical conclusion to come to considering the spacing and placement of the videos have a full chronological order to them. It's a pattern Allen has used to great affect to tell a complete and profoundly compelling story. There's not a truly "stand alone" video unrelated to the narrative as a whole anywhere in his catalog of work that he's publicly shared anywhere. There's even a video showing that every "short" took place while other events were happening. The president for it to be a "true statement" has already been set by Allen from the start. In a Narrative sense,It's a complete logical conclusion to make considering all last evidence presented by the pacing and structure of the whole narrative thus far and no further. 😗I simplified my statement before with some dramatization in order to drive viewership and interest over to Allen's overall work. He deserves it for his mastery of his Craft. 😮‍💨 Further more... 🙄It's far less "Head Cannon" than it is a Logical conclusion to reach based on all patterns presented in Allen's creative methodology. 😗This being only slightly different from a "fan theory" in that I'm not trying to predict his next move or story beat. I'm simply taking notes on how he does things and following along as a largely passive observer. Just to reiterate, Allen hasn't shown a president of skipping a story beat with his characters.

[@Sanjay.2133]

This is currently a head canon nonetheless, Alan never confirmed this (though DJ had the idea)

[@MegaBonBonified]

@@Sanjay.2133 Fair enough. 😗My mental structure is built almost entirely on Pattern Recognition and doesn't allow for confirmation byse.(call it a glitch in my Firmware 😆). A pattern is a pattern and I'm strongly drawn in to notice them. He could as at any unknown point break that pattern as the independent entity that he is, completely capable of doing at any moment beyond the observable.

[@Radioactive-Braincell88]

I wish I had this guy's voice in the back of my head to tell me everything I don't know about physics, at least I'm smart enough to someone understand

[@zerdda]

Your delight in the formulae appearing is the best!

[@justsock.]

this is the reaction content that i support, people who know their stuff reacting to content about their stuff so they can make actual meaningful commentary

[@Library_Of_Gurkistan]

Yesss the reaction is out, finally another super epic TFN Video, i waited waayy to long for this [And i am early too, perfect for the evening : D]

[@tfolsenuclear]

Thanks!!

[@As3th8r]

No gas around a Star? There will be a gradient where the H is in it's gasform i would bet.

[@_Biofodder_]

i think you are right

[@Angrydestoyer69420]

😊

[@itsdarkos]

I was waiting for your reaction on that. Happy you were so fast. Thank you! :)

[@tfolsenuclear]

You’re welcome!

[@AluCunt_Tepes]

I HOPE this is used as an example to inspire in schools one day! My ghaud! How amazingly fun it all was! PERFECTION!

[@WatcherObsi]

Even with explanations to what's going on in this video, I still very much feel like a baby watching one of those baby sensory videos at some parts. Very much the "IDK what the hell is going on here but ooh pretty :)" I think the last point in which I understood things was when TSC started shrinking and it went through the parts of the apple that seemed to grow in size. Still really cool to see you go through the video, I always appreciate specialists watching these videos and explaining as best they can on what's going on! I hope Alan decides to continue these strange almost-lesson like animations. I'd love to learn math and physics if it was shown to me via really cool animations like this.

[@pokemonfanmario7694]

Basically he began to shrink and entered increasingly smaller and smaller spaces - first the stem of the apple, then its stem's cells, then the Chromasome of the apple cell, then the DNA, then a hydrogen atom, shrinking all the way down to the planck length (the 'lowest limit' of space. Think of a pixel where it always has a set size. Now apply it to real space.) The space at a planck length is so tiny that basically all models (our 'approximated understamding') of physics break down. At that point of the video, everything you observe is theoretical - unproven.

[@BluiciousOfficial]

For context, the orange guy is currently captured in a lab with his friends and is imagining all this out of boredom.

[@Szy96335]

Not confirmed

[@BluiciousOfficial]

@@Szy96335 you're right but it might come true since they spoke about it in AVG

[@amadeusoliveira9846]

​​@@BluiciousOfficialThis is Theory, Allan not confirmed

[@NguyenMinh792]

He’s sleeping to forget brutal reality

[@lukeyxo]

it was so fun seeing how excited you get, it was great :)

[@markatonc]

<a href="#" class="seekto" data-time="560">09:20</a> not to be nitpicky... wait... I am on the internet... so let's get nitpicky. :D At this distance to the star (while remembering that this universe is somewhat simplified and with twisted scaling) there would be "some" solar atmosphere there. :D and the way he is tilting the rocket during it is also changing his trajectory to let him achieve orbit.

[@thomaslevel1731]

Salut, juste pour dire que un français regarde tes vidéos.😊

[@inkyinari9364]

J'en suis aussi -w- et je pense pleins d'autres pour comprendre tout ça :3 !

[@thomaslevel1731]

@@inkyinari9364 T'es aussi français ?

[@inkyinari9364]

@@thomaslevel1731 oui !

[@thomaslevel1731]

@@inkyinari9364 Ok

[@salzhaltigersalzhaufen586]

this is such a good summary of physics it´s short entertaining and relativly acurate

[@ARAGAMINGALOK07]

Hey! I watched your reaction to Animation vs Math like a week ago. I knew that you would react to this for sure!

[@The_one_who_asked200]

I misread that as animation vs. meth ✋😭

[@Liesmith424]

Would the part where he was stuck on a frictionless surface and threw the ball attached to the string to propel himself forward actually work? I thought that he'd propel himself backward by throwing the ball, and then then he'd be pulled forward with equal force by the ball reaching the end of the string.

[@rallok2483]

i agree

[@johncollinowensy4255]

While I’m only saying this on a fried physics brain and zero hours of sleep, I’d wager the rotational motion he did prior to throwing it did something for that. The precession that occurred while he was spinning it is a key thing in gyroscopes, because anything that’s spinning along an axis will absolutely hate being moved from that axis. So the he spins as a result of the spinning ball physics trying to preserve its axis (technically momentum, but I don’t think I’ve had enough sleep to confidently explain it off the top of my head)

[@rallok2483]

@@johncollinowensy4255 All of that should be reversed as well when slowing down/thrown resulting in net zero force. Also the friction slows him down yet he was unable to move a single inch while trying to walk and run, that's clearly not possible.

[@cebbolla4629]

i agree, it doesn´t seem possible

[@user-gk2rq4lq5s]

your reaction was really helpful because i didnt understand the video well like displacement and hyperbolic space, so thanks

[@tfolsenuclear]

Glad it helped!

[@zadezapper]

<a href="#" class="seekto" data-time="1048">17:28</a> "Maybe there's something a little- out of the ordinary about him." Oh god does he not know.

[@NguyenMinh792]

Second is a genius, you mean so? 😉

[@DrownedWick]

Alan Becker should really do an Animation VS Biology or Chemistry. That would be amazing

[@terohannula30]

<a href="#" class="seekto" data-time="1247">20:47</a> Oh, I didn't notice at first, but now watching this video I remembered there is theory that spinning infinitely long cylinder would allow you go back in time.

[@pig0r]

I was sooooo anxiously expecting this reaction!!!!

[@pig0r]

I get goosebumps with every smile you make, it's like you're watching a cartoon that was designed for your passion. Thank you for doing this and sharing this with us.

[@kozmikozmo01111]

crazy and explains a lot and more so the confusing parts in dilation including the center of the black holes effects. The Einstein rosen bridge part was a nice touch although i have to credit the stickman for surviving such a trip through so many deadly spaces and speeds😂

[@unsweetened3781]

I'd like to imagine that with all the impossible feats that Orange accomplishes, that he's just super being. His atoms are super glued and the cowboy hat was magical.

[@kaida_mtd]

watching this guy just having fun made my day

[@divital]

Wow, didn't know all of the nuclear fission stuff involved red and blue shifts , thanks for that, indeed its a great video

[@chabie617]

The best part of this video is just watching this guy nerd out. It’s awesome.

[@comelonplayground4218]

This is what i like the most evertime alan uploads about subjects that we need it i alreadys search for the teachers who reacted it its like me and the teachers are reacting and amaze with it thats why i always watch the reactors first after alan ir alan after reactors btw u did a great job❤❤❤❤

[@Exterconz]

I got a physics video clip from Alan but I didn't understand it, and this video finally made me understand the meaning of physics. Thanks for the explanation of physics.

[@chiateghang3629]

Been waiting for your reaction 😁

[@CatOnACell]

so in the lore of these videos (way before this was an educational series) animation vs animator 2 introduced orange stick figure as "the second coming of the chosen one." they have been the main character of the Animation vs series ever since. it would make sense that the chosen one could survive a black hole.

[@onesimesirois]

This video really blew up, congrats!!

[@themeepanaught]

Its so satisfying, the clueless of everyone in every reaction video of this.

[@Linguini955]

When he says that there may be some a little out of the ordinary about him, I remembered that he was "The Second Coming"

[@leol3545]

ive been waiting for this since yesterday

[@KerMaWaffLe]

It’s really crazy to how physics can go from simple measurements to alternate universes and time travel

[@Radioactive-Braincell88]

"ooh all the colors!" it definitely stood out😂

[@aminahoora7184]

Amazing, thanks for clarifying

[@Akigahdam]

i personally did not know what job i wanted but when i saw alans animation vs math i thought of being a accountant since they mostly deal with math now that i saw this i wanna get a job related to physics but im probably gonna stay a accountant as my job that i want since i dont wanna deal with physics and shit

[@themutatednut]

I like how they used the apple instead of any other object for being thrown at the stickman. As the apple is a reference to Newton theory of gravity. Basically the "Father of modern physics"

[@12SlimJims]

This had both applied and theiretical physics concepts. Pretty cool.