Oral Arguments on Abogado, et al. vs. DENR, et al. - Part 2, July 9, 2019

G.R. No. 246209 - MONICO A. ABOGADO, ROBERTO M. ASIADO, LARRY HUGO, ANGELO SADANG, NONELON BALBONTIN, SALITO LAGROSA, ARZEL BELIDAN, RONALD GRANDIA, TROY LAGROSA, RONEL BADILLA, ARCHIE GARCIANO, REGIDOR ASIADO, ELY LOPEZ, EXPEDITO MAGDAYAO, RENY MAGBANUA, ROMULO CANA, JR., ROGELIO HINGPIT, JONEL HUGO, ROBERT VALDEZ, RIZEN GALVAN, RICARDO NATURAL, SANNY BELIDAN, ROWL P. EJONA, FELIX ULZON, RAFFY M. ASIADO, PRIMO M. ASIADO, ADRIAN P. ABAYAN, RANDY DACUMOS, DANILO BELONO, ROMEO MALAGUIT, DENNIS BANIA, JASON VILLAMOR, GARY CASTILLOS, ALBERTO SONIO, DOLIE DUSONG, BJ PIR][NG, and JING MALINAO (collectively known as the "KALAYAAN PALAWAN FARMERS AND FISHERFOLK ASSOCIATION"), NILO LABRADOR, WILFREDO LABANDELO and ROLANDO LABANDELO, and INTEGRATED BAR OF THE PHILIPPINES, petitioners v. DEPARTMENT OF ENV IRONMENT AND NATURAL RESOURCES, represented by SECRETARY HON. ROY A. CIMATU, DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE, represented by HON. EMMANUEL PINOL, BUREAU OF FISHERIES AND AQUATIC RESOURCES, represented by NATIONAL DIRECTOR HON. EDUARDO B. GONGONA, PHILIPPINE NAVY, represented by FLAG OFFICER IN COMMAND HON. VADM ROBERT EMPEDRAD, PN, PHIL􀂟PPINE COAST GUARD, represented by Commandant HON. ADMIRAL ELSON E. HERMOGINO, PCG, PHILIPPINE NATIONAL POLICE, represented by CHIEF HON. PDG OSCAR ALBAYALDE, PNP MARJITIME GROUP, represented by DIRECTOR HON. PCSUPT RODELIO B. JOCSON, and DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE, represented by SECRETARY HON. MENARDO I. GUEVARRA, respondents.