'Out of the Manhaj!' - In Defense of Shaikh Muhammad Al Munajjid┇IslamQA.info

Biography of Shaikh Munajjid:
[Ref: islamqa.info/en...]
Questioner: Shaikh, I have question:
Few people hurry in tabdee' and they say that you are as well from Qutubiyyah and Ahl-al Bid'ah...
Answer:
Okay, what I understood is that there are few students of knowledge who declare a number of da'ees and scholars to be
from Ahl-al Bid'ah, including me and others.
Okay, you know about the website islamQA.info, isn't it?
IslamQA.info uses a methodology. For example, I quote the four
madhaahib, Ibn Baz, Ibn al Uthaimeen, Saleh al Fawzaan. And the senior scholars, and the permanent committee for Fataawa... and I always show the proofs from Qur'an and Sunnah. And I always use authentic ahadith, and I follow the salaf in aqeedah in Allah's names and attributes, Iman, Qadaa' and Qadr, and Sahaba.. and I pay attention to the issue of Tawheed and combating shirk.. and to sunnah and combating Bid'ah So what else is left them? I mean to say: What else is with them of truth that I do not have?
When this is my understanding of Tawheed ar Ruboobiyyah, Tawheed Asmaa' wa Sifaat, and Tawheed al Uloohiyyah. And the issue of Shirk and Tawheed, and Sunnah and Bid'ah.
And I take knowledge from Qur'an and authentic Sunnah, and combat weak and fabricated ahadith. And I quote the senior scholars, and shaikh Ibn Baz and Ibn al Uthaimeen, and Majma' fiqh al Islami, Ibn Taymiyyah and Ibn al Qayyim.. so what more is with them that I do not have?!
Dear brother, Ibn Baz would direct people to me. For instance, if
a man were from where I live, in the Eastern Province in Saudi, so he would say: 'Go to Shaikh al Munajjid.' And the same thing with Ibn al Uthaimeen. If someone would meet him, he would ask them: 'From where are you?' If they were from the Eastern Province, be it Khobar or Dammam, he would direct them towards me. And the same thing with Shaikh Salih al Fawzaan, and I have been certificated by him.. and Shaikh Ibn Jibreen as well.
Questioner: And shaikh, I have another question as well. That they have this sort of a principle, that if one of the scholars or anyone else were to err in one issue, then he becomes from Ahl-al Bidah.
So how do we respond to them?
Answer:
Dear brother, I swear by Allah that this is oppression. And the
scholars, be it Ibn al Qayyim, Ibn Taymiyyah, Ibn Rajab and Dhahabi would reiterate that if we were to leave a man only due to his mistake in one or two issues, ...then none would be left. Subhanallah, this is oppression and hostility. But what can you do anyways? I mean, don't they themselves err? Are they angels that they don't err?
May Allah reward you with good. May Allah make
us and you firm upon truth.
Most welcome. And give salaam to our brothers there with you.
السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته
And a major issue that concerns me is that some of them have limited 'salafiyyah' to aqeedah only. Are we not to follow the salaf
in their manners?
And sarcastically asking, have you ever seen them removing people out of salafiyyah just because someone did not behave well?
No disaster strikes upon the earth or among yourselves
except that it is in a register before We bring it into being -
indeed that is easy for Allah. (57:22)
And we believe, in the footsteps of our salaf, and due to our creed being Tawheed, that nothing harms nor benefits except Allah.
And if Allah touches you with harm, none can remove it but He, and if He touches you with good, then He is Able to do all things.
We are certain that if the nation were to gather together to benefit you with anything, they would not benefit you except with what Allah had already prescribed for you. And if they were to gather together to harm you with anything, they would not harm you except with what Allah had already prescribed against you.

[@الشيخانورالقرنيإماممسجدسلمانال]

Imām adh-Dhahabi رحمه الله, speaking about the mistakes of the scholars, writes: If we were to discredit every person who made a mistake in judgement or declare those people as innovators - people who are essentially of good faith and sincerely seek the truth - then scarcely any of our scholars would be spared. Siyar al-A'lām un-Nubalā (14/374)

[@GilesHartop]

i think youve exaggerated it here way too much

[@oxi3245]

@@GilesHartop Not at all. Read رفقا أهل السنة بأهل السنة by Sheikh Abdul Muhsin Al-Abbad

[@asrhanful]

Shaykh Saalih al-Fawzaan (Hafidhahullah) on Shaykh Saalih al-Munajjid (Hafidhahullah) ========================== In his written tazkiyah for the Shaykh pictured below, Shaykh Saalih al-Fawzaan said: "الحمد لله وحده وبعد: فإن الشيخ محمد صالح المنجد معروف لدي منذ زمن طويل بقيامه بالدعوة إلي الله في المنطقة الشرقية والتدريس في المسجد الجامع الذي يصلي ويخطب فيه. ومعروف أيضا بالالتزامه والاعتدال في أقواله. هذا ما نعرفه عنه. ولا نزكي أنفسنا ولا نزكي علي الله أحدا. ونسأل الله أن يثبتنا وإياه علي قول الحق والعمل به. وصلي الله وسلم علي نبينا محمد وآله وصحبه أجمعين كتبه: صالح بن فوزان بن عبد الله الفوزان" "All praise is due to Allaah alone. To proceed: Verily Shaykh Muhammad Saalih al-Munajjid is well known to me since a very long time with his accomplishment in Da'wah Ila Allaah in the Eastern Province, and also with Tadrees [teaching] in Al-Masjid ul-Jaami' in which he prays and gives lectures. And he is also well known with his commitment and moderation in his sayings. This is what we know of him, and we do not claim purity to ourselves nor do we purify anyone over Allaah. And we ask Allaah to make us and him steadfast upon the true statement and allow us to act upon it. And May Allaah's peace and blessings be upon our Prophet Muhammad, his offsprings, and all of his companions." Written by: Saalih bin Fawzaan bin Abdullah al-Fawzaan" Translated by Ibn Abi Raza (@facebook)

[@AftabKhan-qj9dw]

Arshan Umer beautiful work akhee. barakallah.

[@tayib7665]

Arshan Umer brother please send me those documents used in video. (i mean all letters) to [e-mail]

[@abumansurismail5699]

But this tazkiyah was before his praise for Saed Qutb right?

[@ejasharis5041]

@@abumansurismail5699 dude get a life ... syed qutb is not the scale for praise and criticism ...

[@researching_Islam]

@@abumansurismail5699 correct, these guys are playing with fire.

[@shahidbhat7249]

islamqa best islamic website

[@CaptanElectric]

In sha Allah.

[@CaptanElectric]

Ignore them who warn against each and everyone and claim truth is only wiht them. Indeed they are Innovators according to Imam dhhabi's fatwa. BarakAllahu feekum

[@shahidbhat7249]

+Wasim Iqbal I know that some people call him qutbi... But the greatest scholars like Shaikh Fawzan praises him

[@mohammadmikail6664]

@@CaptanElectric May Allah honour you , grant you Jannat firdos

[@abu-alAwzāī]

​@@shahidbhat7249what's the title of this video?

[@mmtariq8]

Dear Brother Arshan Umer JazakAllahu Khayr Al-Hamdulillah you have done a great job. Also because of your video Allah Ta'aala gives me opportunity to wiped out my confusion in respect of several matters as i have taken lots of help through Islam Q&A.. May Allah Azza wa jall give you lots of happiness in your life & help us to follow the Siraat-al-Mustaqeem, Aameen.

[@asrhanful]

Zaadakallahu ilmak (may Allah increase your knowledge)! Ameen!

[@riajaliofficial2767]

Really very good job ...

[@contentsailor5764]

May Allah make this your one-way ticket to Jannah by protecting the honor of our honorable shaikhs.

[@asrhanful]

Ameen

[@GilesHartop]

@@asrhanful kzbin.info/www/bejne/aoKogHqFp5mmbLM the man is a qutbi the mufi of saudia didnt know what u knew>? your a layman who doesnt know stay in your lane

[@adamdaif4246]

Akhi, if you could ask him to clarify his stance on the Islamic rulers, and give further explanation regarding Sayyid Qutb. These are the issues in questio, barak Allahi feekom

[@anoniem012]

May Allah bless you highly, since I learned a lot from this sheikh but then they showed tabdee of other shuyukh i was in shock..

[@mannamohammed392]

Arshan Umer,Barakallahufeekum Akhi.May Allah reward you for this.May Allah silence and guide the brothers who revile and slander the virtuous Shaikh...

[@asrhanful]

Manna Mohammed Zaadak-Allahu Ilmak (May Allah increase your knowledge!)

[@sheikprofessional]

JazakAllah khair

[@aamirchandiwala2166]

أحبك في الله يا شيخ

[@asrhanful]

Al-Imaam al-Faqeeh Abdul Azeez bin Abdullah bin Baaz (rahimahullah) on Shaykh Saalih al-Munajjid (Hafidhahullah) ====================== Shaykh Ibn Baaz (rahimahullah) said in his letter pictured below: "من عبد العزيز بن عبد الله بن باز... السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته بعده. من خصوص الأخ في الله الشيخ محمد بن صالح بن محمد المنجد معروف لدينا بحسن العقيدة والسيرة والأهلية للتدريس في العقيدة والعلوم الدينية صالح للإمامة والخطابة وهو من خريجي جامعة البترول والمعادن بالظهران زاده الله من العلم النافع والتوفيق قاله ممليه الفقير إلي عفو ربه عبد العزيز بن عبد الله بن باز الرئيس العام لإدارات البحوث العلمية والإفتاء والدعوة والإرشاد ٢٧/٦/١٤٠٦ هجري وصلى الله وسلم على نبينا محمد وآله وصحبه" "From Abdul Azeez bin Abdullah bin Baaz to... Assalaam-o-'Alaykum wa Rehmatullaahi wa Barakaatuh, to proceed. Our special Brother in faith, Shaykh Muhammad bin Saalih bin Muhammad al-Munajjid is well known to us with sound Aqeedah, good character and the eligibility [al-Ahliyyah] to teach [Tadrees] the science of 'Aqeedah, and other Religious 'Uloom (Sciences). He is suitable [Saalih] to be an Imaam and Khateeb. And he is from the graduates of the University of Petrolium and Minerals in Zahraan. May Allaah increase him in al-Ilm an-Naafi' (Beneficial Knowledge) and At-Tofeeq This [letter] was dictated by the needful of his Lord's forgiveness, Abdul Azeez bin Abdullah bin Baaz, Chairman of the Departments of Scholarly Research, Ifta', Da`wah, and Guidance 27-06-1406 AH May Allaah's blessings and peace be upon our Prophet Muhammad, his offsprings and his companions." Translated by Ibn Abi Raza (@facebook)

[@muhammadaaus105]

Asalām-Alaykum. The videos states that there will be a major video refuting this usool of tabdee', can I get link, Jazak Allāhu Khairan.

[@adamdaif4246]

وعليكم السلام

[@ayazkhan-hq5ci]

@Arshan Umer assalamualaikum warahmatullahi wabarakatu brother jazakallah khair you clear all of our doubts brother I have 1request as you know Arabic and English you could be a great source of helping us in our deen alhumdulillah so as you know today there are only few ulema left . Plz uploads videos of our great scholars like Sheik bin baz Sheik uthaymeen Sheik albani Sheik fawzaan sheik luhaydan Sheik ruhaily Sheik abdur razzaq al Badr Sheik Saleh Al munnajjid and others . jazakallah khair

[@asrhanful]

Imam Ahmad Ibn Hanbal's methodology in Takfeer, Tabdee and in Politics crescentmag.blogspot.my/2017/01/imam-ahmad-ibn-hanbals-methodology-in_23.html

[@syedsadiq-or4ko]

Who is Qari in background? Jazakallah khair...

[@asrhanful]

Shaikh Nasir Al Qitami, barakallahu feek :)

[@ayazkhan-hq5ci]

@@asrhanful assalamualaikum warahmatullahi wabarakatu brother jazakallah khair you clear all of our doubts brother I have 1request as you know Arabic and English you could be a great source of helping us in our deen alhumdulillah so as you know today there are only few ulema left . Plz uploads videos of our great scholars like Sheik bin ban Sheik uthaymeen Sheik albani and others . jazakallah khair

[@sbgjamjam2696]

Great video! much needed. dear brother would it be possible to send me the tazkiya of bin baz and fawzan in original picture form? I need them to defend the sheikh with evidences. let me know and ill give you my email iA. BarakAllahu fik!

[@asrhanful]

May Allah accept it. Alright, send me your email akh.

[@sbgjamjam2696]

[e-mail] Awesome, thanks, I really need em

[@ManLyk326]

+Arshan Umer (TheThinkingHuman) please send to me aswell. [e-mail]

[@hijrahbeginner9329]

Please sent to me too. [e-mail] I will make Thai subtitle for this clip to protect shaykh, in Thailand this problem is happening. May Allaah protect us from ignorance. Jazakallahukoiron

[@ejasharis5041]

@@asrhanful [e-mail]

[@ignoranceremoved3450]

Can you send me the tazkiya of shiekh baaz and fawzaan in it's actual form? I

[@ejasharis5041]

جزاكم الله خيرا .. Ex iisd

[@mohamedmuienudeen8992]

May i know why his son was killed and by whom??

[@dr.sulthanalrashid4668]

He supports tablighi and praises ikhwani seyyad qutub. He is not sound in aqeedah

[@muaviya624]

There is a fatwa on his website IslamQA in which it clearly states that the Tablighi jama'ah have major issues in aqeedah and interpretation of some verses of the Qur'an. So no , he does not support the Tablighi jama'ah

[@hasan9.11]

It's not true. Although it is said he used support sayyid qutub. But he returned from this

[@WU-HU-XI-LIAN-DA_STRIKE]

@@hasan9.11 is there proof?

[@abelo2305]

@TawheedPromoterfaris labelled him a deviant UH OH

[@1eV]

​@@abelo2305Who the hell is Faris? Has he even sat close to Ibn Baz, Ibn Uthaymeen and Salih Al Fawzan?

[@AbdullahAlSalafi]

this video is a refutation on him he mentioned ibn jibrin who bin baz was the teacher of and ibn baz had him imprisoned for his deviated beliefs

[@jamastereel]

I wanted to download it why can I not???

[@asrhanful]

I am not sure bro. Try using some other software or application. Or you may download videos from (keepvid.com)

[@hafiztahir7633]

+Arshan Umer (TheThinkingHuman) i want to meet shaikh munajid where he lives and cell no

[@asrhanful]

Shaikh al Munajjid lives in Jeddah, Saudi Arabia. And he regularly visits Al Khobar, in the Eastern Province of KSA. You may contact him on www.islamqa.info