Over Reinforced V/S Under Reinforced Beam Section | Reaction Test

[@nikhilraj5343]

I request you to please upload more videos like this. It's a blessing for students.

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you Nikhil 🙌. See you soon.

[@dkxtro2562]

I was looking at this as a reference for game development. We want to make more realistic environments and didn't know the difference between the X Reinforced Sections. Very nicely explained, and the 3d modelling definitely helps the demonstration!

[@yuvrajchavda44]

Very well explained... most helpful for students and freshers in the field of Structural engineering... Good Work

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you so much Sir. It is teachers like you who inspire students like us. Thank you Sir 🙌

[@TheHowtoDad]

this was a great refresher. thanks for that!

[@AmitKumar-ck9un]

I just came across your channel, now its became my free time task...thanks for the content visualization.

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you King Khan for that wonderful comment 🙌 Waiting for Pathan.

[@MustafaMohammedutube]

Bhai.. everything u said is correct except the last part @6:01. Strain in steel at failure will be (0.002 + (0.87fy/Es))... Thus steel will fail before concrete crushes for under reinforced section...

[@VK-fn9bh]

Finally....I got a best channel to gain knowledge.thanks sir 😊😊😊

[@chen6406]

Wow i love the presentation...I wasn't able to have a clear picture first bcoz I couldn't imagine it..now I have a clear understanding 👍👍👍👍

[@ReactionTest0]

Happy to know we were able to provide you value🙌

[@editorspace9715]

Nice bro you explained very well and your voice is nice I liked your way of presentation

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you so much for the compliment. 🙌 And thank you for watching. Highly appreciate it.

[@satyaprakashkhuntia10]

Your explanation is very good and clean sir

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you Satyaprakash 👍

[@Koh-Wei-Jian]

In short, either rebar snaps first or the concrete at the top half of the beam suddenly crush. Ideal case is where the concrete crack becomes visible at the bottom so there is enough time to react, and in the mean time, the rebar holds the cracks .

[@ReactionTest0]

Yup that's right. But this is for general case and educational purpose. In practice if the load is high enough, there is no option but go for Over reinforced beam as you can only increase depth to a certain amount.

[@joelmausisa1005]

Great video, my mind got refresh of what learned 23 yrs ago.

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you Joel🙌

[@TishyRose]

I don’t know why this was in my recommended, I don’t know anything about this stuff and I am terrible at any kind of math. But I watched this anyway because the way you say “concrete” sounds really nice in your accent, and your animations and diagrams actually made these things make sense to me and I know nothing about this stuff, so there’s proof you’ve made a great video if you can make things make sense to a dummy like me! It was very interesting :)

[@ReactionTest0]

Highly appreciate you watching it. Thank you.

[@anuzonienu469]

Simple and proper animation

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you Anüzo

[@hanumanbhakt7234]

Brother the ease with which you explained this is commendable 👍

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you Kapil🙌

[@alamamatha3349]

Nice explanation with images. Our teacher don't show the images, don't give any clarity, but you EXPLAINATION is very nice than our teachers thank u so much

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you for watching and appreciating the effort. 🙌

[@riteshchauhan4904]

Really nice explanation with wonderful 3d animation. Thanks for sharing. Great job.

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you for watching Ritesh 🙌

[@akshaypatel5477]

Finally got to understand this concept. Nice visualization

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you Akshay

[@sumansubedi7319]

So beautifully presented!!! love from Nepal. please keep going with those animations and knowledge.

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you Suman🙌

[@govindgupta3805]

Very nice video, thanks for making my concept clear

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you Govind 🙌

[@zerozero3264]

upload more videos regularly..your videos more knowledgeable than classroom..

[@goggo2345]

I paid 250k for uni and I learnt more here then there 😳

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you Krishan Raju. I'm reading this in the morning and your words made my day. Thank you 🙌

[@ThatEsque]

He can't give u degree tho

[@yesicanu]

No ladies here

[@alisrour3228]

Excellent job. Thank you for the information

[@jom_and_terry]

Imagine paying for education

[@SarikaAli-cw9xf]

Thank u so much. U deserve much more subscribers

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you Sarika🤘

[@anandgor4181]

Very useful and informative video. Thanks for sharing your experience with us.

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you for watching Anand. 🙌

[@vasukanapala8233]

Great animation detailing brother 👍

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you🙌

[@aliqadri4672]

If we make stronger concerete ratio in over rienforced beam so does it act like under rienforced beam ? and does the strain or yield of beam get high or stronger ..????

[@ReactionTest0]

Great question, but there is no absolute answer to this. It is relative and depends on the load, area of steel provided initially and the increase in concrete grade.

[@Kiennguyen-gn4rz]

First, in under reinforced section, the failure begins with the yielding of steel before concrete crushing in top chord. Secondly, in case when the reinforcement ratio is too low, beams might fail due to steel rebar rupture without concrete crushing at top part. These two failure mechanisms are different to over reinforced section which is needed to elaborate.

[@gnekotv]

amazing explanation. great job!

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you 🙌

[@bhargavraj9897]

First time I understood so clearly this concept.

[@rajanvenkatesh]

Thank you for the informative video. I am building a load bearing house using red laterite stone and NO concrete. I would welcome a video on load and strees issues for such construction. 🙏

[@SpicyAl3000]

Great vid! Thanks :)

[@yogeshshrivas21]

My whole concept is been cleared thank you

[@ReactionTest0]

Happy to help Yogesh

[@harsh-iy5sc]

very helpful video

[@ReactionTest0]

Thanks Harsh.🙌 I've released a new video today. Tell me what you think about it

[@architectsacademy9147]

Very nicely explained! Great video! Thank you

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you

[@nipun8138]

EXCELLENT VIDEOS MAN, Students need content like this, keep it up👍

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you Nipun 🙌

[@praveenkg3518]

Pls tell about single and doubly reinforced beam

[@bard2746]

EXCELLENT GRAPHICS SIR, UNDERSTOOD EASILY THANKS

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you for watching🙌

[@light9574]

how about comparision standard to compare over and balanced ? Eurocode or ACI 318

[@randmayfield5695]

I love these instructionals. Thanks. Subbed with a thumbs up.

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you 🙌

[@dearindiamotivationvideo6284]

Very informative 🙂with diagram

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you🙌 I've also released a new video. It talks about the principles which dictate if an object will float or sink in water. Watch it and tell me what you think.

[@civil378]

Very informative, much and much I learn and understand very effectively. Thank you brother! ❤️

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you for watching 🙌

[@anwar_staadworks]

Hello brother. Like your concept. Can you tell by which software these animation are made. I want to make mechanical videos

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you Anwar🙌 The software is called Blender. And, I've just released a new video. Watch it and tell me what you think about it

[@civilengineering4099]

Great Explanation... We will waiting your next video's 💯

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank You

[@kennethbuluran2348]

omg you explained very well. I just came across this video. 😂

[@ralinnewaminal2340]

Thank youuu. Helped me understand better our topic on RC Beams

[@7_saifi_7]

Pls pls make these type of videos for us ... to understand and feel real engineering thanx bro keep growing

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you Umar Saifi

[@santoshrawal4644]

Very very good concept keep it up

[@anjalivishwakarma0517]

Jo topic teachers se smjh nhi aye ajtk vo ynha smjh agya thank you... But hume Or bhi topics or subjects chahiye the pure plzz upload ❤💯

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you Anjali 🤘

[@BB-hl3ro]

Excellent and very informative information even if you are in civil

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you 🙌

[@mohammadmadu]

Really a good class for my M.Tech project

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you Mohammad

[@wrazni]

great explanation i’m looking for structural engineer specializing in rcc design with knowledge of structural software like safe e tab walid kuwait

[@prathameshsutar3195]

Thank you for this video🙇🙇

[@olgajoachimosmundsen4647]

If you then compare steel to concrete; would you say that concrete provides building material while steel holds it all together in the function of the two?

[@ReactionTest0]

Both serve their own functions, concrete is exceptional in compression but barely contributes to strength when it comes to tension. Hence, in the tension zone, concrete provides strength. While in the tension zone, steel is responsible for strength.

[@rameshsunkasari7017]

Good informative video presentation

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you

[@VAIBHAVSPAL]

Aj Tak Aisa Video Nhi Dekhaa Bhai..Great Job 👍☺️

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you Vaibhav 🙌

[@Deltadigit]

Liked your presentation and animation. Keep up the good work

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you🙌

[@neilbondad9477]

Always follow the code rules in regards to steel ratio, do not go beyond the limitations especially with large beams with long spans. Nice video mister.

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you Neil 🙌

[@airwarrior_1987]

Thank you sir ✌️❤️

[@brahmatejaballipalli3392]

Thank U very much sir,,, you are sharing good knowledgeble contents,,, today I learn 1 useful basic,,, thank U sir,,,,

[@ReactionTest0]

Happy to help🙌

[@joseprince9115]

Excellent teaching...and thanks upload more videos.

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you Jose🙌

[@MrAnubhav116]

Amazing work

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you Anubhav🙌

[@DR-rg1sl]

Which can take more load sir ??

[@liambhandari3600]

Based on this explanation, I solved more than 30 mcq

[@ReactionTest0]

That's great. Thank you for watching 🙌

[@vi683a]

Very well explained. Thank you.

[@ThupallyGurappaswamy]

Clear Explanation 👏👏👏👏👏👏

[@NakulSingh-ro8zh]

Nice video it helped me very much thankyou

[@YTLegend8]

Nice information about sections

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you

[@dhananjayr.shinde1153]

U r so under rated bro,but I am pretty sure One day U will succeed 👌

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you Dhananjay. It means a lot! 🙌

[@kylestanton6698]

Great video! The only point that you brought up in this video that I would contest is that 'overreinforced' concrete beams are more costly, less economical and more dangerous. That is not actually inherently true. Firstly, you might have height restrictions for your beam depending on what you are designing, and therefore must over reinforce the beam. You don't always have the option in real world design to make your concrete section bigger. Also, AASHTO LRFD and ACI specify a reduction factor of 0.65 for concrete beams with 'compression controlled failure', and a 0.9 reduction factor for tension controlled. I don't think it is fair to say that compression controlled failure is 'more dangerous', when you have a stronger section and a lower reduction factor. If you don't believe me, design two beams simultaneously (for same maximum bending), one for compression controlled failure and the other for tension controlled. The computations will prove to you my point on that. Whether one or the other is more or less economical, is completely dependent on what you are designing. That is a common misconception that compression controlled failure is either 'not allowed' or ' inherently less economical'.

[@ReactionTest0]

I completely agree with you 100%. But I made this for students who are being introduced to this concept for the first time. So for explanation purpose I said you prefer an under reinforced section. But I don't mean to completely disregard the use of over reinforced section, they have their place like you've stated. I hope this answers the reasoning behind my statement. Thank you for bringing this up, others might also have had this doubt.

[@kylestanton6698]

@@ReactionTest0 Yes, definitely! I thought this was a great video. Thanks for posting!

[@SavasPapasokratis]

how do you get so smart ? I just graduated and all these concepts seem difficult.

[@tamaninesauc]

A designed height limit wouldnt result in an "over reinforced" beam. if the load requires a certain amount of reinforcement than it will be designed to such specification. an over reinforced beam would mean that it is unnecessarily strong for its intended use.

[@kylestanton6698]

@@tamaninesauc Correct. Sometimes people use the term 'over reinforced beam' when they mean 'compression controlled failure'. I was simply using the same verbiage that was used in the video for clarity.

[@7_saifi_7]

Such a great effort you r put into this vedio .. thanku is a small word .....but really u made a wonderful vedio ❤️❤️

[@ychodneker]

Nice explanation 👍. Do you use blender for making such beautiful animations ?

[@ReactionTest0]

Yes, I do use blender.

[@ychodneker]

@@ReactionTest0 Thank you for your response.

[@anandkumarmaurya8709]

Amazing animation

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you Anand 🙌

[@ajaybiradar4902]

Really good please do more videos on structures

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you🙌

[@redaes4384]

Be Brief The Difference Of Compression Strength and tensile strength

[@ReactionTest0]

Can you please elaborate

[@PotatoPredator]

Brilliant video!

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you Rahil

[@sandrotorres1298]

The steel yield strength at 6:14 is not in the same units as concrete's. Therefore the rationale is mistaken

[@ReactionTest0]

0.0035 and the range 0.20-0.25 is strain and not yield strength. Strain has no units

[@sandrotorres1298]

@@ReactionTest0 Exactly. 0.002-0.0025 is the usual range (there are some zeros after the dot)

[@ReactionTest0]

@@sandrotorres1298 I got you! That's right, I intended to write 0.2% (missed the "%"). But thank you soo much for pointing that out!

[@ReactionTest0]

@@sandrotorres1298 I have added a info card at the timestamp which corrects it.

[@chirdeepnr4000]

Great video man! I will surely recommend your videos to my friends. One correction- you have to reduce the scale of stress strain curve of concrete with respect to steel.. Because, steel has higher yield stress value compared to concrete.

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you Chirdeep🙌

[@wrazni]

great explanation plz i’m looking for structural engineers specialized in rcc , has good knowledge with rcc structural software walid kuwait

[@harshitkumartaiter5889]

One word for you sir Fantastic 👍🏻

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you Harshit for the appreciation 🙌

[@harshaa.b9103]

Very nice video. Loved it!! Can you please show how to check if a beam is under-reinforced or over-reinforced at site?

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you for that wonderful comment Harsha. There is no non destructive way of checking if a beam is over or under reinforced. You have to check the design of the member to confirm the type of beam design.

[@sandeepbhagat1091]

I loved it. Good job. Keep posting such

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you Sandeep🙌

[@aliqadri4672]

Sir if we provide same dia and amount of steel in top and bottom in beam so how do beam react at ultimate load does this thing is ok or safe ...??? Does beam shows crak before fail..??

[@ReactionTest0]

More context is required to give any answer. For example, what is the magnitude and nature of load, the section size, bar size, grade of concrete and steel, etc. Manual design checks are then required to ascertain safety.

[@civilbrains]

very Nicely explained . good presentation. Btw how u prepared this. which app we should use ?

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you buddy

[@ReactionTest0]

It's a software called blender

[@civilbrains]

@@ReactionTest0 ok . gud

[@PRIYANKA-fz9qq]

Sir it's a great video Please provide such videos for full steel RCC som and other subjects And if there is paid services then also let me know

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you Priyanka. Are you asking for SOM lectures?

[@DanishAnsari-hw7so]

Well explained!!

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you Danish

[@reganawale6525]

Thank you so much for this information. 🙏

[@muhammadusama0071]

Very well Explained bro. 💗

[@gokulkrishnan7217]

U r teach very well easy to understand , either u have to speak in English or speak in hindi don't mix it together.

[@ReactionTest0]

Yes, will stick to English from now on. Thank you for your feedback🙌

[@rashidgavit2272]

I would like to say just awesome videos.....sir just try to make video of other subjects also.....and we need to know what is probability distribution curve....etc.so plz make great animation over it....it will be great helpful for us......tx sir keep doing

[@syedarsalanali8506]

Wonderful explanation.. Kindly tell which sofware used for the graphics and animation?

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you. It's a 3D software called Blender.

[@syedarsalanali8506]

@@ReactionTest0 great.. Can you please make a tutorial on that how these kind of animations can be made by Blender.. Please its a request... Thanks brother..

[@sidhantsingh7200]

I understood exactly what I wanted... Thanks for your vedio..

[@casanova6734]

When the compression zone is "stronger" than the tension one, I would talk about an overdesigned compression zone, rather than an under reinforced beam. Similarly when the tension zone is "stronger" than the compression one, I would talk about an underdesigned compression zone. The reference that has to be taken into consideration is the value that was calculated. From there, if some reinforcement is added, which I would call overreinforcement, the only problem it results in is the additional cost. Not the risk of brittle failure of the compression zone. If this happens, the problem is not the over reinforcement but the under design of the whole.

[@ReactionTest0]

I agree with what you are saying, but the decision of whether to provide an over or under reinforced beam depends primarily on site conditions and practical restrictions. An under reinforced section is preferred for its lower cost and safety factor(If higher depth beam is available) an over section is chosen when there are depth restrictions.

[@anilsuryatale7458]

Graphics is very good. Easy to understand.

[@akshit6795]

Best video to explain via animation 😊 #civil engineering concept

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you Akshit 🙌

[@akshit6795]

@@ReactionTest0 sir. Aage bhi continue kro Bnao Orr video Regarding SURVEY HIGHWAY SOIL B.M.C

[@ReactionTest0]

@@akshit6795 Haa, working on a video related to ETABS. Will post next week. Stay tuned

[@TejasPatilArchtiects]

Was a great video and explanation. Just i want to add that can you please improve reading tone and it's speed n all. Thank you for explanations.

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you Tejas for that suggestion. 🙌 Do you want the narration slower or faster?

[@kunalbadgujar8628]

Nice explanation

[@jijo_joy_puthanveettil]

really helpful

[@hamadqatar5838]

Thank you good informative discussion

[@DrGathimba]

Great vid. kudos. Which software do you use to create these type of videos, if I may ask? Otherwise keep up the good work

[@ReactionTest0]

Thank you 🙌. Animations are made with blender. It is sn animation software.

[@DrGathimba]

@@ReactionTest0 They are great.

[@yousafkhan7622]

Bro.new subscriber here! Mera Q hy ke hard starta soil par load bearing type house keliye strip foundation magar without reinforcment banana hy tu kia strip foundation without reinforcment 40feet long 2 feet deep 2 feet wide bana sakte hy??

[@ReactionTest0]

Thanks for subscribing bro. Cannot comment without looking at soil bearing capacity, no. of floors, plan area, wall thickness, type of bricks, etc

[@altamont_2439]

kinda got clickbaited by the title i thought for sure it was a video that's gonna actually do utm testing on those different reinforcement types with actual beam sections.

[@ReactionTest0]

What made you think this video would have had utm testing?

[@altamont_2439]

@@ReactionTest0 the "reaction test" part, well that was your channel name i guess.

[@ReactionTest0]

Yes it is