Pakistan Hasn't Changed | Ali Zaidi vs Shabbar Zaidi | EP 02 | Z2

"Pakistan Hasn't Changed", Watch a candid discussion between former Federal Minister Ali Haider Zaidi and former FBR Chairman Shabbar Zaidi now on MM News KZbin channel.
-----------
MM News TV - The Unbiased Perspective
MM News is a subsidiary of the MM Group of Companies. It was established in 2019 with the aim of providing people of Pakistan access to unbiased information.
-----------
Follow us on:
Website: mmnews.tv/
Twitter: / mmnewsdottv
Facebook: / mmnewsdottv
Instagram: / mmnewsdottv
-----------
#pakistan #shabbarzaidi #alizaidi #z2 #institutions #ziaulhaq #ziaulhaque #marshallaw #pervaizmusharaf #HamoodurRahmanCommissionReport #genociderun #pakistanpolitics #1947partition #podcast #mmpodcast #mmnews #bhutto #zulfiqaralibhutto #supremecourtofpakistan #liaqatalikhan #nawabmushtaq #benazirbhutto #pmmodionpakistan #electionsinpakistan #kashmir #fbr #inflationinpakistan #freedomofspeech #alexanderthegreat

[@ashwwal3409]

This interviewer consider himself very smart and intelligent . He spoiled the interview by repeatedly stopping Mr Shabar Zaidi .

[@ranahammad4561]

Right interviewer Ali Zaidi should not do this, This is not fair.

[@Yankee7000]

@@ranahammad4561this is the second comment you have made against the host. Hopefully you won’t be here for the next podcast. Good luck to you.

[@zaf7794]

​@@Yankee7000is this Ali Zaidi himself 😀

[@Profit_Momo_Pdf-File]

Ali ZAIDI is typical paxtani but mild

[@Yankee7000]

@@zaf7794 yes it is.

[@javedfazal59]

Our country is run by people who have a tribal mindset! Whatever is happening will go on happening ! Mr Shabar Zaidi sb is a learned person and is well aware of the ground realities of our system and his opinions are very informative and commendable!

[@zaf7794]

The GCC countries are also tribals but there leadership is sincere with there land and people. They want to prosper and became a part of global economy. They are not fools. Problem in Pakistan is hypocrisy, dishonesty and lack of law.

[@MohiHash]

Frankness is like close family members. Amazing flow. 20 minutes into discussion and it feels like I am sitting in my own drawing room with two elders speaking on issues waiting for my turn haha.

[@Ozzybloke5]

Shabar Zaidi is brilliant and intelligent. Really like his sense of humour - basically, this is a free lecture on the history of Pakistan and how this country is run.

[@muhammadsaqib2961]

plz zaidi sb. let him complete his sentence dont interfere

[@ranahammad4561]

Yes

[@nicepankajsaini]

Islam or democracy kabhi sat nahi chal sakta

[@fahadzia6862]

Yes, this man is not letting Shabbar Zaidi talk/communicate. Shabbar Zaidi is an intellectual and well read person. Former Chairman FBR

[@behuman1967]

Two out of millions, honest, patriotic Mohajirs

[@zulfishah4999]

Sir Shabbir zaidi ko bat krne du completely

[@ranahammad4561]

Right, darmian me bat kat rhy hn Host ko suna jata hai hamesha, Interviewer apny apko nawab samjhte hn

[@sulemank3061]

Behtareen, Absolutely loved it. Thanks alot Sir, really appreciated both of you, stay blessed

[@zaf7794]

⚡ excellent conversation by Shabbar Zaidi.

[@sanatani_bhau74]

Seeing the level of discussion above i as a normal indian can frankly tell indian think tank thought process is way ahead than pakistan 😂😂 Pakistan can never get ahead of india intellectually i am assured😊

[@Yankee7000]

Firstly: not a think tank. One is an enormously experienced Chartered Accountant, the other is relatively less experienced politician. They are having a drawing room style discussion on events, using anecdotes. Secondly, not sure what relative standards you are applying here but if you are happy, then so be it.

[@IndoPakCanvas]

Another RSS / BJP deluded 🕉️

[@tridevkotwal2169]

​@@IndoPakCanvas he is not deluded .. It's due to focus on STUDIES since childhood .. It's about FOCUS / COMPETITION within .. It's better you first accept then move on .

[@IndoPakCanvas]

@@tridevkotwal2169 You're fkd as a country. India is light years ahead in EVERY SECTOR. You will. Implode due to the terrorist you kept as dogs

[@asadali2311]

@@tridevkotwal2169feeling stupid?

[@javedfazal59]

Mr Ali Zaidi has nothing new to say. He , in fact and reality, is a beneficiary of the present system and is bent on defending the status quo ! His input is in direct contradiction of the ideas/ opinions of Mr Shabar Zaidi sb ! Let’s take Ali Zaidi as an unwanted addenda!

[@ranahammad4561]

Right 100%

[@Djwgevs]

Am Khalistani I will come karachi to meet you both

[@muhammadsaqib2961]

very clear and realistic opinion on henry books "future ka mtlb ghaib ha" hahahhaha :)

[@ghazanhussain2070]

😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@vijayv5335]

Indian rupees 83.58 are equal to one American dollar,not 98 dear zaffar zaidi ji

[@mirfanali1937]

It was a mere slip of the tongue.

[@bhadshakhanaa]

Mir jaffar

[@corpsertag5967]

Seen his discussion with Indian girl Amber Zaidi and now know his true Pakistani anti-Kafir and anti-Indian Mindset. I thought he would be at least a man of Character. But he is a propagandist like all other Pakistani. No big difference. Educated Jihadis.

[@rizwanmallick4884]

Vijay : yeh figure dono mulkon ki currency ka big difference (vs USD) butane/idea dene ke liye use kia gaya tha.. Objective was served. Tum ne jo 83.58 correction kia, within seconds rate change ho gaya tha. Context aur objective samjhna chahye! Clerical mind her jagah kam nahi aata.

[@rizwanmallick4884]

@@mirfanali1937: it was not a slip. It was used just to give an idea of the big difference. Yeh koi business transaction ke liye use nahi kia jana tha!?

[@fauzi.a]

Wah Shabber bhai Glasses Biddat hai or Future K mitaliq bat krna Kufr. Boht dino bad itni khul kr hansee ayee. Shukriya kia khoob explain kia k Ghazwa e Hind hogaor hum qabza krlein gay.... Khuda hum pr rehm frmaye ...tesweer to bilkul sahee khenchi apny. Salamat rahiye

[@rohailamin6347]

Zabardas good conversation

[@ranahammad4561]

شبر زیدی صاحب کے علم و تحقیق کا لیول علی زیدی صاحب سے بہت اوپر ہے۔۔۔ معذرت کے ساتھ۔۔۔ علی زیدی صاحب نے شبر زیدی صاحب کو نہ صرف ڈسٹرب کیا بلکہ گفتگو کا مزا بھی کرکرا ہو گیا۔ على زيدی صاحب کا انداز روائتی ٹاک شو والا ہے۔ اور انہیں وہی کرنا چاہئے۔

[@ghazanhussain2070]

بلکل درست فرمایا ❤❤❤

[@ashokanand8202]

Some points of analysis are very interesting

[@rajkhosla8513]

Zaidi saab BEST PODCAST ❤

[@dourbeen]

For ali zaidi.."Aaap aap"."ali bhai".. for rest of the world.. "tum tum " "toh tumhain kia masla hai."

[@zaf7794]

Hahah nice observation. True that.

[@Yankee7000]

Glad you found something to learn. Would have been a waste of time otherwise.

[@dourbeen]

@@Yankee7000 this guy is amazing with numbers and economy details and i indeed learn new stuff from him not shared elsewhere.... but he has his biases..his history and IR sense w.r.t india and china are poor. Reading wrong books and sitting in wrong company does that. I willgive you an example.. he thinks government let go the family of the the killer of Liaquat Ali khan.. why should relatives of a killer be punished for a crime they didn't do ?

[@Yankee7000]

@@dourbeen well we have competing claims then. Shabbar mentions a book by the son of the alleged killer. You are definitive that he wasn’t the killer. So be it. That’s the trouble: the investigation is shrouded in mystery and controversy

[@dourbeen]

@@Yankee7000 true... . I didn't say he wasn't the killer.. he indeed was the killer and was killed on spot by guards...his wife and children were barracaded in a house for years to be investigated and be saved from any murder attempts ....at the end when they were found innocent they were allowed to go. Right after that moment unknown arranged visa for them and got them settled abroad.its pretty evident they can be those in our bureaucrats who wanted to keep them away from our courts in case they blame them or a foreign power that saved them..but zaidi believes his family were also involved in the murder.. that's a stretch

[@MuhammadJunaid-bt4qq]

When he was in power, what did he achieve except being a toady of a bureaucrate.

[@zaf7794]

Nonsense, Shabbar left the Chairman position in FBR when he realised he has no powers and need to compromise. He didn't cling on the chair for perks and benefits.

[@MuhammadJunaid-bt4qq]

@@zaf7794 i didn't speak about shabbar idiot, think before you speak.

[@humanbeing2460]

​@@zaf7794exactly

[@aamirshahzad4047]

Honestly you have to change host ... intellect of guest and host doesn't match

[@ranahammad4561]

Right 100% agree

[@jz8955]

Zaidi is no host. Should’ve let Shabbar speak. What can you expect from someone who used to sell reject brands from Los Angeles

[@ManekPremchand1950]

Shabbar Zaidi is brilliant

[@shayannaseem]

The previous episode was very well executed, like capturing lightening in a bottle. Mr Shabbar brings balance to the conversation and he has shown he's the most well informed and knowledgeable person in the room. As we're all human with some deficiencies, his might be that as an office bearer he lacks the emotional stamina to deal with a large amount of public members and their narratives / baggage

[@chintakgurjar8426]

Indian rupee never go above 85. Currently 1 USD = 83.50 Indian rupee And 1 USD = 281.59 Pakistani rupee 1 INR = 3.37 PKR

[@muhammadraza1739]

You should discuss following subjects. FALL OF ALL THREE MUSLIM INVESTORS. AGHA ABUDI BCCI BANK NAQVI OF ABRAJ CAPITAL SHEIKH SHOEB OF EXACT CO Why did they fall from top. 2ndly should give overview of Crypto Currency.

[@ViewsGoogler]

They are big time cheaters

[@shivajibhilare2881]

Shabbar jedi ❤ great intellectual person

[@dourbeen]

Its zaidi..not jedi🤣

[@hawkingdawking4572]

Z can't be pronounced by north Indian Hindus. 😂😂😂

[@muhammadzubair-tw6lh]

Ali Zaidi is not an intellectual Personality. Let Shabar to express his point of view without any hindrance.

[@CANCERIEN]

Always a pleasure watching Shabbar Zaidi. Amazing person.

[@HumanityOutsourced]

Shabbar Zaidi is the person every Pakistani should be listening to Pakistan is at a pivotal moment and the decisions you make today will be the future of the country , If we keep going the same way it’ll be like Afghanistan or Syria, and it if come to reality Pakistan can prosper

[@healthyways...dr.waseeq8191]

Wonderful discussion 👏👏👏👏

[@azharhashmi2367]

Zaidi is the superstar of IK government, imagine, please think if...

[@ghazanhussain2070]

My teachers said something similar to Shabar that "plaining is intrinsic to modernity and before modernity there was no concept of plaining".

[@sirajahmed8616]

Very informative. 👍

[@free.thinker.]

Shabbar wants to prove to let the system go on its own... ali zaidi being later generation, is of opinion that things can be improved

[@ranahammad4561]

Right

[@ghazanhussain2070]

Zaidi is trying hard to be smart 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 He is no smarter than a layman 😢😢😢😢

[@lapampa4296]

Ali Haider's thought process is terrible. These are the type of people that have landed Pakistan in the ditch it finds itself in. The country needs better thinkers and leaders. This interview is so bad...hard to even listen all of it.

[@IraMurphy-kq6nn]

Every six months Pakistan gets six billion dollars from IMF. It is Bhik not loan

[@sougatamukherjee1975]

Hats off to you sir. You are absolutely right in saying India doesn't want Pakistan to disintegrate. If Pakistan fall, India will be vulnerable of Afghanistani terror

[@shahjee675]

شبر میاں کو assignment ملی ہے کہ آذاد کشمیر کا حلیہ بگاڑو تاکہ راستہ ہموار ہو سکے۔ پنجابی میں کہتے ہیں عقل نوں ہتھ پا۔۔

[@angeleyessvenska9330]

Good heavens - I give a million thanks my great grandparents STAYED IN INDIA, instead of making the hijrat to this pagalistan

[@sameenfatima143]

Jo islam ko acha nahi samjhta ya muslims ko bura kehta hai wo pakistani qaum k liye kuch nahi kar sakta

[@chintakgurjar8426]

Aap ne sahi kaha. Me bhi chahta hu ki sab Pakistani ye soch me pade rahe.

[@zaf7794]

Madam, ap ko lagta hai zai ul haq ka molvi version of islam he islam hai? Malaysia Turkey Saudia Oman mey islam nahe hai? Wo behtar islamic countries hain compared to Pakistan or wahan k loag beh behtar hain.

[@rizwanmallick4884]

Shabbar Zaidi Sb aur Ali Zaidi ke intelligence level & understanding of situation mein bada gap hai !

[@IraMurphy-kq6nn]

Zaidi has better understanding of Islam

[@muhammadsaqib2961]

plz shabbar sb. release some part of that book.... very concise and clear thought individual and collective gunnah.

[@free.thinker.]

He proves that he was connected and worked as baira ... or else he wud have done something on his FBR charman position

[@zaf7794]

​@@free.thinker.bulls hit, SHABBAR resigned in 8 months when he had a clear understanding that nothing can be changed in this system. Instead of taking perks benefits for the remianing years of government he opted to resign respectfully and leave the office with dignity.

[@DrAahad-xo6ev]

Shubber Zaidi Zindabaad! Paksarzameen shad baad! Speed money is not bribe? Ha ha ha! 1/3rd chairman, 1/3rd DG, 1/3rd Director, 1/3rd district officer and 1/3d drawing and disbersing etc. Amazed! Pakistani Tujeh Salam!

[@adeelakhtarmangi3266]

Ali Zaidi is completely useless here

[@ranahammad4561]

Right 100%

[@welingkartr416]

Ali Zaidi mocks the so-called Red Temple Bull story. Ironical, for he and others of his quom must be very sure that Prophet Mohammed ascended heaven on a wonged horse there

[@syedalihyderzaidi6931]

علی حیدر زیدی صاحب آپ خود ہی بول رہے ہیں. شبر زیدی صاحب کو تو بات کرنیے دیں

[@bodhisattva6308]

Shabbar zaidi is speaking like a non Muslim honestly.

[@Khanprospective]

Aur gariyan bhi hain....the best part....with those eyes open😂

[@asrehman100]

ali Zaidi should learn how to conduct an interview. He is kept interrupting, harshly.

[@inayatullahlohar3977]

انٹرٹینمنٹ کے لیے اچها پروگرام۔ تها۔

[@nicepankajsaini]

Shabbar Zaidi ko dala na utha le jaaye

[@ranahammad4561]

Hn sahi keh rahy Allah reham kry

[@HistorywithShahrukh]

Shabbar bhai kamal

[@secretagent1273]

Please sir continue this ww want to see both every week.❤❤❤ love zaidi ❤

[@K.Riaz59]

Ali Zaidi Bhai, you are not understanding Shabbar Sahib's sarcasm about religion.

[@akbargoraya7656]

واہ کیا کہنے

[@muhammadsaqib2961]

this is reality podcast and whatsapp

[@ranahammad4561]

Great discussion. One recommendation to the host, is to avoid completing sentences of your guest, as it is detrimental to the attention span to the listening audiance

[@SaadKhan-yd7ss]

Best conversation about our reality

[@ahshah2745]

A great debate....but Shuber sahib should give our youth a lead to exit from this rotten past . Shuber sahib would definitely have extracted solid solution from his such vast reading.

[@shaguftasiddiqui2618]

Mr Ali seemed devoid of sitting , speaking and questioning mannerism and so of thought process, his Jaccobabad summer incarceration has prompted him to repent in a very ugly way however hats off to Learned Shabbar Zaidi

[@salmansiddiqui4854]

Ali Zaidi nam lo us wazeer ka jis ke pass abhi bhi gariyan mojud hain. Tmhara paisa nahihai ke naam nahi lunga kehty phirty hou. Name lou, yeh ahamara paisa hai, hum decide karengy ke name lena hai ke nahi.

[@ROHITKUMAR-cb6zj]

As a Kashmiri Azad Kashmir not Pakistani Azad Kashmir independent sovereign country

[@Djwgevs]

Rohit Kumar Lindu / P@jeet Kashmiri ? 😂😂😂😂 Khalistan Jindabad

[@ROHITKUMAR-cb6zj]

@@Djwgevs Lindu Pakistan 1971 93000 😂😂😂😂😂

[@DoctorsHealthyFoods]

Other doesn't applies in Pak,even God's fear is also to few people not much

[@DrAahad-xo6ev]

Kya bata rahay Bhai! Drust keh rahay Bhia!

[@sabahatatiq4372]

Ali Haider zaidi ruined this interview his knowledge totally based on tiktok videos kindly let him speak

[@motivationandyourlife7391]

Har shaks her ilm may alim nahi hota shabbat zaidi accounting may alim hongay but deen may jahil hay he haven't done any research on deen he thing what molvi is telling is deen he apppose religion because of his ignorance of deen

[@RajveriKadal-ei8rp]

Zaidiyu ka ijtama.. eik siyasi ha aur eik ma ashi- when we have not made any mistake then why should we admit

[@shahidhassan8799]

Ali zaidi sahab you are doing disservice to yourself by speaking total nonsense pl let mr shabbar speak without your irrevalent interventions

[@user-fy2ux2ei2d]

Is fazool admi ko haq ni k shabar sb k interview kary..he dnt deserve😢

[@muhammadkashif7613]

This is what they both have capability to do Imran Khan give them chance to perform but both persons are coward, they run away and now can bark only on youtube 😂

[@waseem5623]

shabar sb is a brilliant person

[@randy1as]

Allah is liye nahi deta kyun ke Pakistan ki akal to tala laga hai.Allah. - Tala.

[@AbdulRehman-kr5sl]

Zindabaad ❤❤❤❤

[@arsalsheikh5927]

Shabbar Sb I love your commentary on religion.

[@naveednaushad6973]

Baat Dil pe lagi k ❤ Allah mashray ko azab deta hay jb qanoon ka aur mashray ka khof khatam ho jaye

[@dakoo16]

Ye Kon chawal hay jo interview kar raha hay?

[@amerramday]

PTI ka bhghora Zaidi . Bhonka

[@ranahammad4561]

Bevakof ali zaidi Unethical unaware

[@ranahammad4561]

Why does the host keep interrupting the guest! And unnecessarily keep completing the guest's sentences. Such an annoying way to interview. Sorry for this negative feedback but it really marred the experience of listening to this learned guest.

[@user-jm4xd4ql1n]

Ali zaidi anchor nahi hay.planted by company.

[@ghazanfarzaheer]

Shabbar Sahab se ek sawal hai , ager apke pass pesay bohat Hoon to property or Sood ke ilawa wo usko kaha invest keraingy or kis mulk me jana Pasand kreingay siwae america k?

[@ghazanhussain2070]

Sood mai invest karo best hai 😂😂😂

[@free.thinker.]

Where was ahabbars intellect when he became FBR chairman... he was also a WAITER then, with position given by some powerful ppl n probably not khan

[@sandipbhattacharyya7540]

Interviewer should let Mr.Zaidi to speak...

[@ranahammad4561]

Ali zaidi is completely useless here

[@danishsiraj8242]

Next program men pehle topic decide karen k baat kis pr krni he .esi idhar udhar ki ghumti baten ab social media podcast ka hissa hen .behtar hoga ek ya do topic dicide kar k history future sb us pr discussion karen wrna next programmes men in aaye bayen shayen koi nahi dekhe ga

[@motivationandyourlife7391]

Bhai ager khuda ka khuf hota tu pakistani mashra asa na hota

[@girwarsingh9777]

Ye Sabbar Jaidi saheb kafi akalmand adami h... Ye Islam ki sacchai jante h...kabhi inko Oria Maqbul Jan ke samne bittao taki us Makkar ko acha jawab mil sake,🙏

[@HaiderAli-pb7nj]

Ager pakistan behter ho raha hay tou khudbakhud nahi huwa aaj ager kuch log jaisay judges insaf kay liay kharay huway hain tou yai imran aur awam ki koshish jo unhoun nay nikal kay vote diya hay uski wajah say hay aur koi bhi cheez aisay hi sahi nahi hoti hay uskay peechay kuch koshishain hoti hain, mazeed shabber zaidi sahab keh rahay hain kay mazhabi mashray may log sirf khuda say dertay hain tou aisa bilkul bhi nahi hay asal may hamaray mashray may koi khuda say nahi der raha hay issi liay tou hamari buraiyoun ka yai haal hay qanoon tou waisay hi iss mulk may bika huwa hay tou qanon say kon daray ga in chezoun ko bhi sahi kerna perta hay khudbakhud kuch nahi hota hay, dosray yai shabber zaidi sahab akser kehtay hain kay corruption koi masla nahi hay sub mulkoun may hoti hay asal masla tax system sahi kerna hay tou yai bhi bilkul galat baat hay tax system bikul sahi kerna chaiyai laikin corruption iss mulk kay liay bohat bara masla hay woh kaisay may sabit kerta houn, dosray mulkoun may jo corruption hoti hay woh 10 say 15% tuk hoti hay baqi paisa mulk may lugta hay aur nazer bhi aata hay hamaray mulk may ziaulhuq kay waqt tuk mulk ka baironi qarza 18 arab dollar tha jo aaj 131 arab dollar tuk pounch chuka hay, kia awam ko iss liay gai qarzay say itna kuch bana huwa mulk may nazar aata hay bilkul bhi nahi tou yai paisa itnay arsay may PPP, Nawaz L eague aur fouj kay baray mil ker kha gai tabhi tou jo leaks bhi nikakti hay usmay in sub kay naam nikaltay hain aur aaj bhi jo qarza milay ga woh yai sub kha jain gay aur awam yai qarza bharay gi, yani mutlab yai kay dosray mulkoun may jitna paisa yani 85% mulk may lagaya jata hay utna hamaray mulk may khaya jata hay aur jitna dosray mulkoun may khaya jata hay utna hamaray mulk may lagaya jata hay tou bhai iss tarah itni corruption ker kay yai mulk nahi chal sakta ismay dosray mulkoun ki misaal daina banta nahi hay aur corruption bilkul hamaray mulk ka sub say bara masla hay jub hukumat may chor log baithay houn tou woh koi cheez kisi ko bhi theek nahi kernay dain gay aur cheezain sahi tub hi ho sakti hain jub imran jaisa mukhlis aur imandaar insaan hukumat ki bari seat per baitha ho aur fouj sirf border sambhalay aur hukumati mamlaat may mudakhlat na karay jis kay liay imran koshish ker raha hay, shabbar zaidi sahab ki bohat si batain bilkul islam kay beraks hain jis ko koi zeehosh shaks qabool nahi karay ga kuonkay woh aik tax maher hain aur her cheez ko usi tanazur may daikhtay hain, jub bhi tajzia kia jai tou her cheez bashamool islam kay nazeriyai ko bhi samnay rakh ker baat kerni chaiyai kuonkay dunya kay log aur khaas ker maghrabi dunya kay log sirf apna insani faida hi sochtay hain laikin hum kuonkay musalmaan hain tou hamay usi angle say mamlaat ko daikhna chaiyai werna phir hamaray musalmaan honay ka kia mutlab hay.

[@sushbist4]

The host is so irritating keeps on interrupting

[@noushadrajani4587]

Great Man ❤❤❤

[@asghai9584]

The other side may be allowed to say something .

[@sohailsiddiqui1986]

Lie please Allah ka khoof karo

[@abdurrehman3254]

I am waiting for the next episode.

[@farhaajalam3504]

Behtareen sir

[@nusrathussain865]

Shabbar zaidi sb is intellectual and much credible men so i think Ali sb yr sitting posture in front of him quite questionable

[@user-jm4xd4ql1n]

Ali zaidi establishment ka bacha lagta hay.bagharat.