PAPER SOLUTION I CA Foundation Sept 2024 Business Law Paper Analysis & Review

[@mr.anonymous1283]

Question paper ❌ Newspaper ✅

[@Sahib091]

Are bhai yehi toh comment Dund raha tha 😢

[@Sahib091]

@@SumitraDevi-ry2gh Icai ne easy paper daal kar lamba kheech diya. Hamere sath dokha hua hai 😢

[@krishnamaurya9873]

@@Sahib091 bhai kya easy tha, ek ek ques me do do law mash karke Dale hai konsa sahi bhait rha hai pata karo aur woh chodo jaha easy question ban sakta hai waha bhi koi na koi chota element dalke band baja rakkhi hai aur max marks ki conclusion ko dete hai wohi sabka galat aayega yrr kuch easy nhi tha paper

[@Sahib091]

@@krishnamaurya9873 je bhai Aapki baat bhi sahi hai merging bhi es baar kar rakhi the.

[@Sahib091]

@@krishnamaurya9873 aur aur Bhai question kitne lenthy the 5 min toh read karne aur smjne me waste ho rahe the.

[@luxurishqqq]

30:14........30:33...these lines hits hard 😭😭

[@Brokeasf-ej8kp]

Fax

[@harshrathod1752]

Sir today law is very lengthy but topic clear tha to 90 marks ka attempt kiya paper. Aur aap k prediction mai over all 86 marks ka content match hu aa hai. Par points mai thoda difficult hu aa hai par jo dekha hai prediction mai we sa topic wise likha hai. Thank you so much dir for this. Yes sir law mai PASS to hai.

[@Ronak-r8k]

bhai pichli baar sabne 90-100 kiya tha aur lag ra tha 70+ ayenge but aaye 30 33

[@baka_.07]

Sir dard lag raha hai sab khtm 🥲 50-60 tak he attempt kar hai

[@rahuljangra3429]

Arey koi na mera toh 55 ka attempt hua 3rd attempt thaa

[@baka_.07]

@@rahuljangra3429 nhi paper aata tha but bohot sara tha isliye rhe gaya ab dard lag raha hai 🙂

[@z01k1]

​@@rahuljangra3429chod de bhai 3rd attempt me itna kam attempt karna is not right

[@krishnamaurya9873]

​@@z01k1 bhai paper was hard as well as lengthy pls don't make such comments

[@krishnamaurya9873]

​@@z01k1abhi questions ki ek ek gehrai me jaoge tab pata chalega kitna galat hua hai agar pura paper bhi attempt kiya hoga toh

[@Krrish_goyal]

Sir aapka solution dekh ke tasalli mili thank you ❤ Accounts Maths And eco total kre mere 200 cross ha Law ka darr lg rha tha ab sahi h thank u sirji 😎

[@srabanisahu5621]

50:57 sahi he?

[@MananBathani]

Sir quantitative aptitude me jaldise paper or vo sab provide kijiyega , please 🥺🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@PuraniMemeGathaa]

Sirji 80 Marks ka attempt Kiya hai kuch questions ke conclusion glt likhe hai baki sab direct questions sahi kiye hai 40+ to ajayenge sirji bas itna hi chahiye baki scoring to accounts aur economics mai ho hi jayegi❤❤ Thank you sirji for your support and efforts ❤❤❤

[@rudracsk1187]

Bhai Mera bi ohi hal hii

[@ummar_Faruq]

Bhai nikala kya

[@littlestepSKA]

Law ka paper pattern nahi hota kya like maths? LR statics and modules theoretical question kyu nahi aate ase Case study jese?

[@tanmaykapoorpura123]

sir mere baki tino paper achee gye hai or aggregate bhi ban jaega agar law mae 37-38 rahe tho grace mil jaega kiya

[@iulgguigb]

40 plus for suree ❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉🎉😊😊😊

[@Aman-mm4fz]

Sir question ke number itne kam the samjh hi nhi aarha ki kitna likhe aur kya kya likhe 🙂

[@Shafat_1223]

bhai same mai pen hi nahi othaya phir last mei dekha to 63 hue the bs

[@Aman-mm4fz]

@@Shafat_1223 mujhe bhi laga tha ki itna sare questions kare hai Lekin last me count Kiya to sirf 70 marks ka attempt Kiya tha Aur ek galti aur ho gye , jo question ache se aaate the wo reh gye last ke , aur jis question me doubt tha wo attempt kar diya Confusion thi bhai paper me ,

[@Shafat_1223]

@@Aman-mm4fz bhai konsa attempt hai?

[@Aman-mm4fz]

@@Shafat_1223 1st , tumhara?

[@Shafat_1223]

@@Aman-mm4fz mera bi first hai

[@akshatshah5099]

1 ka paymemt by interested party hoga na ?

[@akshatshah5099]

Kya lag rha h bata do na

[@Aman-mm4fz]

Mene bhi yehi Kiya hai ​@@akshatshah5099

[@ffgamers3839]

Haa vhi hoga

[@akshatshah5099]

@@ffgamers3839 and bhai 1 ke a ka 2 and 3

[@AryanJakhar.]

Yeah section 69

[@KavyaShrimal]

Usko read karne ke liye 30 ghanta chaiye 🤡

[@tanukashyap3178]

Sir ji heavy paper lengthy tha haad se jada 🙏😞sir maine note nhi likha

[@365editingbro3]

90 Marks pakke 🎉

[@fitretsugaminglists9508]

Sir attempted for 90 expecting 60

[@Ommdev09]

Never expect bro 🥲

[@fitretsugaminglists9508]

@@Ommdev09 sahi bola bhai expect krna hi nhi h 🥲

[@Shreyaaaaah]

Sale by description aur warranty as to merchantability ka jikra bhi kiya hai provision mein galat to nahi hoga na pls tell

[@Ronak-r8k]

warranty as to merchantibility esa kuch hai hi nahi bhai

[@krishnamaurya9873]

Partner by holding out ki jagh estopple likh diay toh chalega kya?🥲😭

[@mayank_chauhan0925]

Hn

[@Kneeyeahtea]

haan mere liye bhi ye galti hogyi paper me 😭

[@harjeetsinghtalreja6184]

Haan chalega.... Module me bhi ye hi diya hai ... Do don't worry.... Most of the students ne woh hi likha hai

[@krishnamaurya9873]

@@harjeetsinghtalreja6184 bhai hai yeh mera koi kuch bolega nhi iske baare me life savior 😭😭😭😭😭

[@lokeshvlog7860]

Ek he baat h

[@vanita8215]

Thnk god attempted 82+ abhi answer dekh ke lgrha atleast 50+ aajayenge mere 🥴🥴🥴💀💀💀 very damgerous law paper

[@nandinichaubey5390]

Same i have attempted 82 or ghar aake check kia toh lag rha hain bas 45 aah jaaye 😅 conclusions mere thode wrong hogaye toh kitna milega like jo conclusions wrong huye na woh question 2 -3 mark tha??

[@frustratedmonk6660]

Conclusion ke 2 marks hote haan if 4 marks ka question hai tho

[@frustratedmonk6660]

Provision ke 2 marks

[@nandinichaubey5390]

@@frustratedmonk6660 agar 3 mark hai toh??

[@frustratedmonk6660]

@@nandinichaubey5390 1-1.5 marks

[@KrishTarsaria]

Thank you sirr❤ Exam centre se ghar ate ate tak dil dhak dhak krha tha then apka live class dek ke sukoon mila hai,you always support us sirr ty very much ❤❤

[@mr.mohitpal4881]

Sach me bhai mujhe to dar lag rha tha 😅

[@KrishTarsaria]

@@mr.mohitpal4881 same😃

[@Shibusriwastwa]

Sir paper bhot hi zyda lendi tha ab to confirm hu me next attempt dena hai 😢😢😢😢😢

[@SumitraDevi-ry2gh]

I think dormat co. Ka answer yes hona chahiye.

[@BHADRUPONDU]

No, insignificant transaction tha wo

[@VISHALSINGH-rt2pm]

nahi NO he hoga its mentioned that company has no transaction from past 2 years

[@radhikasoni5199]

Yes it was as it can hold asset gir future project

[@radhikasoni5199]

​@@BHADRUPONDUtha bhai ache se padho definition uski asset hold kr skti h

[@BHADRUPONDU]

@@radhikasoni5199 it can hold,but he can't purchase any asset

[@ChinmayDevmane]

Sir, I didn't understand this question and which provision will be applicable for this 6:30. Could you please tell it again. I have just started CAFC.

[@Shimlaahhh]

Acceptance must be given within proper time. (Mr.B communicate his acceptance on 14th for which is already sold at 13th)

[@Fit_style-r2z]

Maine ek question mai galti se dusra concept laga 6 mark ka tha Ghar aake dhyan aaya Speed meri sahi thi 90 mark atempted 😢

[@Ommdev09]

Same but gare aake usko exclude kiya to bhi pass ho raa hu🙂

[@Ronak-r8k]

@@Ommdev09 bhai pichli baar 100-100 ka logo ne attempt kiya tha aaye 33 35

[@Ommdev09]

@@Ronak-r8k attempt karna aur sahi answer lilhna dono me farq hai na and gar aake mene aise hi check kiya 40 k upr jaa raha hai

[@Ronak-r8k]

@@Ommdev09 bhai ye marks kat te hai Agar ese check karke 40-50 ke aas paas Ara hai to chances hai 40 ke niche bhi ajaye Paper checking dekhna Sahi sahi answers ke bhi 4/7 and 5/7 diye the jiske pure bhi sahi the

[@Ommdev09]

@@Ronak-r8k maine aise hi check kiya hai bhai pure kisi me nai diye pura sahi ho to bhi half and half correct ho to 1/3 1/4 aise diye hai

[@HenilPrajapati-zi3kl]

Sir if case law ka conclusion galat ho to kitne marks milege ?

[@ShamAgarwal-zf1gx]

Sirji 3 ka old debts ke new incoming partner cant be held liable as creditors permission was not taken and hence creditors cant bind him for the old debts

[@Vaishnavi-9-11]

Exactly..I too wrote the same thing in paper

[@tanyaprakash2004]

Exactly

[@vanita8215]

No no agar majority of the partner consent se agreed hoga toh he will be liable

[@ShamAgarwal-zf1gx]

@@vanita8215 module me saaf saaf likha h its a kind of novation and creditors ke knowledge ke bina yeh novation ko creditors bind hi nhi kra skte

[@Pirategamer5656]

UNLESS OTHERWISE AGREED, Incoming partner is not liable for old debts aur waha pe UNLESS OTHERWISE AGREEMENT tha

[@ntnp2005]

Sir agar sare aapke bataye hue provision se answer match kr rhe ho to expect kr skta hu ki 40+ aa jayenge ,90+ attempt kiya h bs 2-3 questions me conclusion galat hue h.... Kya ab inter ka strt kr du sare 3eeno subject mila ke 200+ ho ja rhe...

[@rohithalder9125]

98 ka attempt kiya 2 ka chhoth gyaa time nhi tha😢😭

[@sidhipatel-ul2xr]

😂😂

[@lokeshvlog7860]

😂😂mene 61 ka attempt kra or bahi tu 98 ka krke ro rha h😅

[@z01k1]

incompetent paper setter

[@mrunknown6968]

1(a) kisa quasi contract honga? Vo log toh rent agreement kare tha and electricity pay ke quasi contract toh by law create karte hai na 🙄 and by law create hone ka baad he liability hoti hai and interest by person atha hai!

[@ShamAgarwal-zf1gx]

@@mrunknown6968 section 69 lgega jo ki ek type of quasi contract hi h

[@mrunknown6968]

@@ShamAgarwal-zf1gx jab quasi contract honga tab apply honga na but vo question me agreement hua hai mention kare hai!!

[@UtpaalPaswan-yp9yq]

Payment by interested person hoga😊

[@mrunknown6968]

@@UtpaalPaswan-yp9yq even it's agreement vo quasi contract kisa hua?

[@snehajha4364]

Sir facts of case likhne ka tym nhi thaa toh nhi likhaa...toh marks katenge?? pr provision orr conclusion likha h orr 70 ka attempt kiaa h...pass ho jaungi kyaa

[@JanviGohil-x7v]

Thank you sir

[@abhiman.katiyar]

Dissolution by court me sirf state likha hai toh maine define ni kiye 😂🙂

[@Pranav.7117]

Bhai wo state karne ke thodi 7 marks denge 😂

[@abhiman.katiyar]

@@Pranav.7117 Bhai uss tym tnsn me jyada dimag chal gya 😂

[@abhiman.katiyar]

@@Pranav.7117 tumhra kaisa hua paper ?

[@Pranav.7117]

@@abhiman.katiyar koi na bhai hota hai Mera bhi itna accha nahi gaya almost 75-80 marks ka attempt kiya hai abh bas result ka wait hai 40 bhi agaye toh bahot huva baki ke subject mei cover kar lunga

[@abhiman.katiyar]

@@Pranav.7117 hnn par ye lg rha ab 7 marks easily mil jaate wo chle gye Tumne 75-80 marks ka toh atleast 45-50 toh aa hi jaayege bro..tnsn Mt lo 😁

[@anitakedia1350]

Sir ma 60 no. tak ka solve Kiya hun

[@MananBathani]

Sir maths ka paper pridiction

[@Aman-mm4fz]

Sir on admission of a partner he will be liable for old debts ke liye creditor ki consent bhi to chahiye Iss basis pr mene to NO kar diya ? Sahi hai ya nhi

[@radhikasoni5199]

Yes as he agreed to pay them mentioned tha bracket me

[@piyushvlogs6662]

Sir Paper was so lengthy but attempted 90+ and some conclusions and provisions are wrong and direct question are easy and attempted correct , But sir fir bhi dar lag rha ki kya hoga😢

[@ankitkumarranjan3394]

Sir aapke padaaye gaye materials k wajah se 90 marks k questions k answer mujhe aate the maine point bhi kiya tha ki ye answer karna hai par time hi nahi bacha Sirf 58 marks ka hi attempt kar paya Answers to saare sahi the par presentation bahot galat ho gayi Abhi bahot bura lag raha hai Aata hua questions chhut gaya

[@aditidas1290]

Conclusion ka kitna number milta hai?

[@abhiman.katiyar]

@@aditidas1290 1-2 marks for 4 marks ques

[@aditidas1290]

@@abhiman.katiyar okayy

[@lokeshvlog7860]

Jb 7 no ka question ata tha tb 1 mela tha merko ab 2 no ka question h pta ni kitne dega

[@shorts_yash2601]

chill guys grace milega

[@biituraghuwanshi5672]

ajji mera kadduuu milega 🤡

[@CAhub2006]

Never expect to icai.😅

[@visheshkirar7969]

Please mazakk se hatkee bolo 😢

[@Ronak-r8k]

@@visheshkirar7969 linient checking to hoga hi

[@Mayank0880]

Sir ques 2(a)i m maine decreption vala topic nhi likha sirf condition likhi h to marks kitne milege

[@Ronak-r8k]

1-2

[@Mayank0880]

Maine 70 ka attempt kia h to pass hone k chance h?​@@Ronak-r8k

[@sneha-s3d]

Sir khud ki language m likhege to marks katege??

[@Ommdev09]

Chalta hai bs keywords module k hone chahiye

[@Mayank0880]

4 (a)i m sirf provision shi h conclusion glt h to kitne marks milenge?

[@Ronak-r8k]

milega 1-2

[@Nikhiltiwari57198]

Sir 93 attempt

[@ar__ffgaming7592]

Hua kya cler

[@Futureca_10]

Sir... jaise 1st waale meh quasi contract nahi likha..mtlb explain usii ka keya h par quasi contract yeh word yaad nahi aaya...ase he 3 4 aur questions meh bhe hua h kitne marks cut honge???

[@nitingupta7808]

Bhai main topic hi nhi likha

[@rithesh_k.r]

Mene to payment by interested person likha hai

[@Aman-mm4fz]

​@@nitingupta7808bhai 3 number mil rhe hai paper itna lamba hai insaan kitna likhe Mene bhi direct payment by intrested person likha hai

[@Futureca_10]

@@Aman-mm4fz marks pure milenge??

[@Aman-mm4fz]

Milne to chahiye ​@@Futureca_10

[@Ommdev09]

Finally, pass ho raha hu sir🙂

[@rcbians34]

broo icai hh vo never expect anything in law especially but i wis god u and me pass this attempt

[@Ommdev09]

@@rcbians34mene waise hi solve kiya gar aake pure ans likhe to bhi half marks count kiya 40 upr jaa re anyway wishing too u and me pass🙂

[@rcbians34]

@@Ommdev09 shii h broo acha h eas bbarr easy checking hogi to 60 pluss aajege apkep,,,m to fail hi hu i will give jan attemp all the best maths or eco ke lie...

[@Ommdev09]

@@rcbians34 itna bura gaya hai aapka direct fail hi maan rahe ho

[@rcbians34]

@@Ommdev09 bro yesss mere to icai ke hard checking ko dekee 10 marks vi na de,,but anyway dekte h ab

[@rudracsk1187]

Sir mera 35 mark araha hii gress mark dekar pass kardenge kiya 😢

[@25sahil]

Bhai Mera bhi 35 aa raha hai

[@25sahil]

Attempt 55 ka kiya

[@Ommdev09]

Baaki papar me 60 plus lekar aa jao grace mil jayega

[@chaudharypavani444]

​@@Ommdev09you sure ke esa kuch hota h??

[@Ommdev09]

@@chaudharypavani444 pure chances hai bcz jab paper hard ho to checking itni hard nai hoti

[@SusmitaPanda-p3p]

Sir 90 kiya bad fat gayi

[@masteroffinance273]

It's enough

[@aksangwan7912]

14:50 😂

[@RaunakD]

Maths paper prediction

[@shreyarajput8190]

70 marks attempt hua hai pta nhi kya hoga dar lg rha hai

[@UtpaalPaswan-yp9yq]

Mera 69😢

[@khu7shVAL]

Sir 30 No. tk hi ban rhe hai😢

[@khu7shVAL]

@@Sharma.a27 mera toh 1st hai bhai aur shyd me aaram se pass hojaunga kyuki mere 35no. to aaram se aare h 4-5 upar bhi aayenge

[@Sharma.a27]

@@khu7shVAL Shi que Kitna attempt kre h tumne

[@khu7shVAL]

@@Sharma.a27 bhai vese mene 65 ka hi aatempt kiya h bht kam chance hai pass hone ka

[@UtpaalPaswan-yp9yq]

​@Sharma.ma27 Mera 5 th😢

[@HiIamme7878]

Being resident of india is not necessary so...how how the answer can be no ?

[@rushergamer2892]

Being residents of India is not necessary may be but it's necessary to became nominee in OPC that the person stayed in India more than 120 days in a FY .

[@radhikasoni5199]

Both mese koi v ban sakta tha both satisfied criteria but 2nd wala more suitable tha

[@HiIamme7878]

@@rushergamer2892 not it's not .. check the module

[@shivanimahadevsoni]

sir how to buy your paid lecture for ca foundation jan 2025

[@gulshansingh1654]

😊

[@ShivamMaddheshiya0501]

Sir Kasam se paper bahut jyada lengthy tha. 3num ke liye 1 page ka answer lg gya

[@raghavsharma2171]

Dormant company ki khali definition hi likh paya abd conditions bhi bta di aur conclusion nahi di toh kuchh marks milenge kya ??

[@aditidas1290]

@@raghavsharma2171 provision ke marks mil jayenge

[@raghavsharma2171]

@@aditidas1290 kitne kuchh idea hai ??

[@ms.siddharthpratapsingh4172]

bhurj khalifa tha🙂