Carnatic Pattimandram l Perasiriyar Solomon Pappaiya l Sri Parthasarathy Swami Sabha

[@narindrasamy7745]

நன்றி பாரதி பாஸ்கர் அம்மா. பேச்சு அருமை.

[@ganapathiramanneelakantan6574]

Our life long happiest memories of this patti manram .our soul annexes with our ever pride bhakrhi carnatic Music.Treasure of wisdom and Bhakthi.pranams.om nama shivaya.

[@venkataramagopalansubraman9304]

Super

[@nagarathinams6888]

Super super. அருமை அருமை . நன்றாகப் பாடத்தெரிந்த இவர் களுக்கு நன்றாகப் பேசவும் தெரியும் என்பதை தெளிவாகப் பேசினார்கள். பாடுவதை விட்டு விட்டு இவர்கள் எல்லாம் பட்டிமன்ற பேச்சாளர்களாக மாறிவிடுவார்களோ என்று ஒரு அச்சம் தோன்றுகிறது. பேசுவதற்கு நிறையபேர் உள்ளனர். பாடுவதற்கு அதுவும் கர்நாடக இசையைப் பாடி பரப்பு வதற்கு இவர்களை விட்டால் வேறு யாருளர்?? இடைவேளையில் இளைப்பாருவதற்கு மட்டும் பேசட்டும்.. பாராட்டுக்கள்.

[@thiyagarajanv.s3733]

Raja sir speech semma super. வாழ்க வளமுடன்

[@vjraghavan802]

Barathi baskar amma speech excellent. Mesmerising speech. Hats off.

[@NadhVD]

Bharathi Bhaskar you are supreme today what a speach epic please print a book on this.Tha music people are so arrogant.

[@muralividhya]

அருமை இனிமை புதுமை. மிக நல்ல பதிவு நன்றி. தமிழால் இணைவோம் என்று சொன்னால் அது மிகையாகாது.

[@ManiKandan-pr4fz]

அற்புதம் இந்த நிகழ்ச்சி

[@ganesann6125]

Best speech of Bharathi bhaskar It was a fantastic, sensible and lively speech

[@ramakrishnants3608]

Excellent pattimandram.Hats off to all speakers.

[@subbaiahshanmugam9560]

மஹாபேரிராசிரியர் சாலமன் பாப்பைய்யா அவர்கள் நடுவராகஉம் சகோதரி பாரதி சகோதரர் ராஜா இவர்கள் மூவரும் இந்த மேடையில் வீற்றிருப்பதுமிகப்பெருமையாக இருக்கு.பாராட்டுகிறேன்.இவர்களை மேடைஏற்றிய கர்நாடகசங்கீதமேதைகளளுக்கு வணக்கம். சுப்பையாசண்முகாம் கும்பகோணம்.

[@subbaiahshanmugam9560]

கடம் சபாஷ் சபாஷ் சபாஷ்

[@manilayam]

மிக அருமையான பட்டிமன்றம் ஒரு இசை நிகழ்ச்சியை ரசித்தது போன்ற உணர்வு ஏற்பட்டது இதனை பதிவிட்டவர்க்கு மிக்க நன்றி

[@sridharannatesan592]

பக்தி இலக்கியத்தினால் தமிழ் என்றும் வாழும்.

[@visalakshinarayanamoorthy9927]

Bharathi Bhaskar what an excellent speech. Hats off. Miga miga arumai.

[@indragurumurthy5008]

🙏🙏🙏👍👍👍 மிகவும் அருமையான உரையாடல்.

[@ManiKandan-pr4fz]

அற்புதம் ஐயா

[@radhakrishnanvs4877]

பக்தி கலை இரண்டுமே ஆன்மசந்தோஷத்தை தருவாதால் வாழ்கிறது.

[@vijayavallichakrapani7091]

I

[@vijayavallichakrapani7091]

💕

[@vanju313]

Amazing analysis of the very difficult and tricky subject. The final verdict by Shri.Pappaiah was scintillating and emotional. His bakthi is phenomenal. My pranaams to you sir .I am your fan from today.

[@vijayasambathkumar7980]

Very enjoyable

[@lathasreenivasan2265]

​@@vijayasambathkumar7980000000000😊😊😊😊😊😊s😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊l))0

[@lathasreenivasan2265]

​@@vijayasambathkumar7980000000000😊😊😊😊😊😊s😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊l))0

[@lathasreenivasan2265]

​@@vijayasambathkumar7980000000000😊😊😊😊😊😊s😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊l))0

[@angappanregupathi7573]

Amazing programme!

[@உதிதீ]

Raja sir very nice speech

[@vinu2005]

Pls do a Olympiad in Carnatic Music among schools in Chennai and through out other districts and complete tamilnadu

[@vthyaga]

Sudha akka's arguments and speech were amazing! It's not all "bhakti" folks.

[@vinu2005]

Namaskaram I'm a lover of pattimadaram and come across your channel and fabulous pattimadaram related to Carnatic Sangeetham. Today I have subscriped your channel with the love of knowing our values of our music.... with great talents and expertise in the field. I request the Sabha to spread the awareness of our culture to the younger generations. Pls continue your great work.

[@musicmate793]

சூப்பரா 🌹

[@MrSathishved]

salute to papaya sir. awesome speech by subhasree and bharathi

[@sowmyaprasanna6635]

Siruvargalkathai

[@rkramachandran7130]

superb speech by bharathi baskar.hatsoff to you madam.

[@chellappakrishnamoorthy1460]

After folloing ghiru solomonpapaya and patti manta tmt bb and raja we can leran any subject including Carnatic music and analyse this wther it is for bakthi or kalai. With the tutoring of santhana Gopalan ghtamkarthick Sudha madam Subhashree madam and raja sir. Very lucid explanation my infernce is Carnatic muc sic art filled divinity kkc

[@athreyars6697]

Panchakacham was the unique beauty to Neyveli sir

[@indragurumurthy5008]

👍👍👍பாரிதி பாஸ்கர் பேச்சு மிகவும் அருமை.வாழ்த்துக்கள்.ஆனால் ராஜா பேச்சு சுமார் தான்.

[@lalithasathyamoorthy6376]

Idamadiri. Oru pattimandram kettal manadu full happy aahivitadu. Nadathiavargal pesiavargal. Naduvar. Share panna you tube ellorukkum ennudia koti nanaskarangalai thetivithukolgiren. Bharath bastar avargalai en lifekkul oruthadavai katti mutham kodukjavendum. Ennaku age 65.

[@lakshminathana7440]

, சபாஷ் புதிய முயற்சி

[@abirami2398]

Bharathi bhaskar madam super speech

[@rajaveleagambaram43]

வணக்கம் என்பது சரியா... வணக்கங்கள் சரியா...

[@rameshneelakantan2346]

One of the very best பட்டிமன்றம்

[@skan5996]

Awesome speech Bharathi

[@NadhVD]

Bharathi Bhaskar you are supreme today what a speach epic raja himself agreed and he Raja never looked this absymal

[@narsikanvar9359]

Bharathi Bhaskar was incredible. It was like watching an unstoppable T20 double century knock. The way she laid to waste opponent arguments and not getting personal is an art form. It was sad that some of the debaters turned this into a political platform but Mrs Bhasker, kodu pottu adhu mela road pottuttaanga.

[@srinivasanrajagopalan7350]

Ko

[@sistasarma390]

Where is T.M.Krishna

[@umamaheswari604]

Thank god he has not selected. Would have spoiled the show

[@SucilanSundar]

@@umamaheswari604 wow what a judgement !!?

[@umamaheswari604]

@@SucilanSundar my judgement will always honest

[@sureshk1839]

No words - Namaskaram

[@ramsundaram4615]

அருமயான பட்டிமன்றம் நெயவேலி, சுதா, காரத்திக், சுபஶ்ரீ, பாரதி, ராஜா அனைவரும் அருமையாக பேசினார்கள்

[@srividyaramani3843]

Privileged to be a subscriber

[@umamaheswari604]

Our saastiya sangeetham's basement is only bakthi. Without bakthi the songs are body without soul

[@bimasu]

To add to my earlier comment, the vaggeyakaras were all immersed in music and the nada form of the divine itself was used by them for their devotion. But, a concert held in a hall is patronized by connoisseurs of music and musical excellence is what they want from a concert. If it is soul stirring, it is an added bonanza. Very few like MSS could truly bring out the bhakti bhava in the compositions of vaggeyakaras straddling both aspects, living the life of a grhastha-ascetic(?), donating most of her earnings to causes dear to her. Another great stalwart Shri KJY concentrated on both but one was supreme at carnatic concerts and the other at his temple and ayyappa season concerts. His guru Chembai is known to have passed into the divine realm after a concert prior to which he prayed at the local temple asking for him to be released from mortal bondage.

[@saradashankaran8956]

Very nice

[@ramarajagopalan2744]

Raja speech good. references good

[@MASADHIYA]

Bharati Baskars best oration in this has come out...

[@viswanathanbalasubramanian3934]

Set sudha s,speech sooooper

[@raji1607]

The best part was the theerpu. The best. How articulate.

[@viswanathanbalasubramanian3934]

Raja's speech top

[@NadhVD]

Bharathi Bhaskar you are supreme today what a speach epic raja himself agreed and he Raja never looked this absymal

[@vov-voiceofvictims]

Wonderful Patti- mandram My one doubt is what will all these stalwarts do with the ponnadai . They must be having hundreds at home . Why don't we stop this habit of ponnadai ? It is neither a saree Nor a towel Nor a dhoti Nor can we make blouses out of it . It is a waste cloth which cannot be used as a waste cloth also (to mop the house or something ) Time we changed some of these habits and just get on with the job . In these days of eco concerns this ponnadai is another garbage which is going to occupy the house forever .

[@raji1607]

True. My grandfather was a great Carnatic musician. He had so many suitcases full of shawls. We grand daughters picked a few and used it for salwars !!

[@MASADHIYA]

Don't Worry, Sivaraman sir is an expert in Converting All the Jarigai Ponnadais into Jibbas, Mridangam Glapes etc. Off late UKS sir has stopped draping costumes with Normal clothes. And he is in Direct Competition with late Sri Kunnakudi and more with Ananth Vaidyanathan of Super Singer fame..😂🤣😀🤔

[@anooradha39]

Mrs BB! After yeppudeee madam... Yena topik kuduthaalum, Vilaasareengalay!!!

[@sathishbalu3519]

"Hello! Naa Padma Vibushan" @6:45. How crazy they are about titles.

[@MITworker]

Sathish Balu He just clarified that he wasn’t a Padma Bhushan, “only” Padma Vibhushan.

[@sathishbalu3519]

@@MITworker that doesn't make sense. Padma Vibushan is higher than Padma Bushan. How could he have meant it as "only"? And he wanted the emcee to make the correction immediately.

[@vishnuramprasadvasudevan2668]

@@sathishbalu3519 Sir, the Govt.of India has honoured him with Padma Vibhushan last year. I feel there was nothing wrong in correcting the speaker. After all he has been performing since 1940s. :) I mean no offence to you here.

[@rshiva08]

Sir, mistake is a mistake. It has to be corrected, that's all. If somebody else had corrected it, he wouldn't have said anything.

[@MASADHIYA]

UKS was a very humble and down to earth, simple person until Birudhu started honouring him, then he became Egoist, Adamant, Arrogant at times and money minded..he lost all the humility and simplicity in the last 20 years of his Post Awarded (Off course All are Match Fixed and stage managed ones) life..😐🤨🙄

[@Narasimha1993]

Amazing

[@natarajansuresh6148]

Audio is breaking

[@sarojini763]

🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@rmeenakshi9919]

அந்த கைலாசநாதர்கோவில்எந்த ஊர் புரியல சொல்லமுடியுமா

[@bimasu]

sangeeta jnanamu bhakti vina sanmargamu kalade -Saint Tyagaraja. Post Purandara dasa and the trinity, Carnatic music compositions are 99% bhakti. But it is also true that the musicians themselves are driven by fame and esthetic expression of the art form.

[@sridharvaidyanathan594]

When u r singing bhakti song, devotion is must. All songs may not be devotional. But singing devotional songs without bhakti is fruitless song as they have been composed by saints for God. Singing songs composed by saints and saying bhakti is not required for song is against the sentiment of song or raag.

[@umamaheswari604]

True. That too our saastriya music basement is only bakthi.

[@bimasu]

although everyone spoke very well, Smt. Bharati bhaskar's words stand out: if you remove bhakthi from carnatic music as it is today, what will be left of it? And can you even remove devotion from this form of music?

[@natrajan5284]

z

[@prabaharanm9320]

Kuppusamy chetti avarai vida panatthai thavira muttra ellavatrilum moothavarana solomon pappaiyya avarhalai verumane solomon pappaiyya endru kooriyathu sariyillai.

[@narindrasamy7745]

நன்றி சுதா ரகுநாதன் அம்மா .

[@ramsundaram4615]

பாரதி பாஸ்கரை மிஞ்ச முடியாது.

[@tulasi8382]

nice

[@ramsundaram4615]

சிவராமன் ஒரு மஹான்

[@ramsundaram4615]

கார்த்திக் பிரமாதம்

[@MASADHIYA]

🤣😂 Watch from 17.10-17.18... UKS sir, has he Deliberately Avoiding to mention Subhashree ? Obviously, it is very glaring and Schemed as he almost finished his opening talk, Krishnamurthy, hurried to him to remind that he Ommitted Subhashree from the key note address, Poor man was over heard in the powerful mike🤣😅.. All'these, discards, unpleasant experience May be due to the Inglourious, Disgraceful Fall out of Subhashree from Jaya TV's "Margazhi Maha Uthsavam" that was organised and aired for more than a decade, due to Irregularities, Controversies in Administration, Organisation and Financial related issues and she was Ousted and thrown out of the program as the Chief producer, Organiser and Convenor. Who knows UKS Mama was one of them in the Carnatik circuit she rubbed badly on the Wrong sides...🤨🤔🙄.. But I thoroughly enjoyed the conversation, Confusion and later the Compensatory praise UKS mama showered on her as a damage control measure, but with A Pun and hidden meaning, saying "She also knows to give All those what is not to be given, in a nice way" 🤣😅... The Whole World watched this Haragiri...

[@priyadas-2903]

Subhashree doesn’t know anything. But Showing like she is the one who knows everything.

[@murugaiyanparameswaran3407]

🙏 வணக்கம், கடம் காரத்திக் மிகச் சிறப்பாக பேசினார். ஆனால் நடுவரைப் பற்றிப் பேசும் போது பணம் பற்றி பேச்சு வந்தது.கச்சேரி முடிந்ததும் கொடுப்பார்கள் என்பது ரசிக்கும்படி இல்லை. அவர் பேச்சில் அது அபஸ்வரம்.

[@adithyasalem5621]

Sudha ragunathan is not a padmavibushan awardee . correction to be done

[@sabasabapathy2073]

Adith Salem why

[@vthyaga]

Bharathi Baskaran is obviously a talented and charismatic speaker and performer! But her arguments are ridiculously weak and almost laughable. It's all performance and bluster. - "Why kitchen adai and idly is not art?" Seriously?!! This is the argument? Of course culinary delights are also part of south indian identity - Her Bismillah Khan's comment example about Ganges doesn't really illustrate her point. Khan sahib was talking about iyarkai (the nature, the beauty of the land) NOTHING to do with bhakti esp since he wasn't talking about religion at all. - The difference between idly/adai and carnatic music is not bhakti LOL! It is the form. The better example is the difference between the audience attendance for nama sankirtanam (strictly about bhakti) and a traditional standard carnatic concert - The rest of her arguments are just mocking Subhasree's manner of speaking. Sure it's funny/hopefully in good fun! But not really well thought through. - Her whole point about "thiruppavai recitation events" vs "thiruppavai singing events" demonstrates the opposite of her position. But respect to Baskaran ma'am!

[@kalpakamsubramaniam6138]

😂😂

[@chakrapanikamala8468]

QS 0

[@NadhVD]

Lord has created everything including bhakti music.In lords bhakti there is avery rasa ...maadurya vaatsalya saakhya daaysa saanta ,,, lords one small energy/art is music.. bhakti is supremely powerful , even it attracts all powerful supreme ,. So. music is great only in the service of lord otherwise the music that is not in the service is just a marana naaadam or frogs croaking inviting death of snake

[@venkataramanvaidehi5181]

Subhasree as usual mokkai.

[@priyadas-2903]

Yes she doesn’t know anything. But Showing like she is the one who knows everything.

[@lalithasathyamoorthy6376]

Sorry Barathi basker madem

[@attalgasketsattalgaskets6828]

அருமை இனிமை புதுமை. மிக நல்ல பதிவு நன்றி. தமிழால் இணைவோம் என்று சொன்னால் அது மிகையாகாது.

[@adithyasalem5621]

Sudha ragunathan is not a padmavibushan awardee . correction to be done