Partition | Identity | Education Crisis| Pak/India Relations | The Unspoken ft. Dr. Pervez Hoodbhoy

[@dharmeshparikh7837]

😂😂😂 I don't understand pakistani intellectuals confusion. No offense to Mr. Hudhboy but during 1960s also Bhutto and your political intellectuals were labeling India as Fascists and Islamophobic state. At that time nobody even knew in India what is Hindutva & RSS. That time was pure Congress rule. So I don't understand this dishonest attitude of pakistani intellectuals including Mr. Hudhboy. Because its clearly documented fact that pakistani political & Intellectual class labeled India as Fascist & Islamophobic even during 1960s & 70s. So why this much cry Mr. Hudhboy now. 🤷🤷

[@chaitanyakada1341]

You don’t understand their special selective logic.

[@sumitkumarj]

A baseless country , after 75 years they are still speaking about what should vision of country ....

[@Darsh_Yadav__2025]

😂😂😂😂

[@kumarakantirava429]

What's the Vision of India ??

[@naveenawadhi6240]

​@@kumarakantirava429congressian aa gaya.

[@Soullight09]

Indian governments and it's people have worked very hard for 'taqat ka nasha'. Also it's not a nasha, it's the resilience and courage of Indian people. Why would India engage with a failed country like Pakistan when the latter has constantly entertained terrorism in India? India has good relatiions with all its smaller neighbors, also with Arab countries. But we are not interested in Pakistan except for ensuring our security from its nefarious activities against us. Period

[@nareshjoshi123]

yea gajva e hind ka nash ke bare me nahi bolega . vo nash kya hai ?

[@salimalvi5178]

Anglos mastered use of Islam as Weapon of Mass Destruction just like Taimurids, Turks & Afghans before them. Anglos were much smarter than those brutes. They didn't have their hands have any blood stains. They merely had to breed Khalifas among the progeny of cowards, crooks & criminals who took Bedouinized Yahoodi names under duress, due to enticement and threat of rape & death. By the second & third generation MohMadism and other AbraHarami gangs/legions Christianity, Marxism & Fiat Currency like $ driven Hedonistic Consumerism succeed in completely cutting roots of new gang members. The guilt of abandoning ones ancestral spirituality, culture & language is replaced by extreme hate of everything native in second & third generation. Anglos cooked this hate to breed Khalifas. Thus they bred Khalifa Al Lundoni Chiknah Jinah & EkBall. Father of EkBall & Chiknah took Bedouinized Yahoodi names and declared themselves MohMadden. MohMaddens of today's Bharat voted 97% to create the first ISIS (Islamic State of Indian Subcontinent). Some of them even sent younger brother to newly created ISIS land called Pakistan, to occupy fleeing HinduSikh properties, lands & businesses. MJ Akbar who was BJP minister in Modi's cabinet till 2018, had his Abbujan move to ISIS land called Pakistan to occupy HinduSikh properties especially lands. His Abbujan sold these properties & lands which he got free in 5 years and made lot of money. Then he came back to current Bharat. MJ Akbar told to Terry Gross in Fresh Air program that in the ISIS land he couldn't get firangi thurra freely so decided to come back to Bharat. MohMaddens by design are deceitful and are waiting for GazwaEHind when the population % is in their favor. We saw this in Kashmir Files.

[@VG-bf9cy]

90% Pakistani talks are in 2 nation theory. They never seem to get over that and they don’t have anything to talk about as their country is already down the drain. They still think Hindus are causing a hell like situation to Muslims in India when it is quite opposite. He probably haven’t heard of sar tan se juda activity

[@kmohan24]

He should stick to Physics. The people who lost the most were the Hindus in Pakistan. They literally came as refugees to India. The people who gained the most were the Muslims of Pakistan. The Muslims of India who chose to stay back were not harmed and their properties were not damaged. The muslim population(percentage) of India has doubled since 1947. IMHO, there is no use talking about the 2 nation now. It has happened. Given the hatred of the people of Pakistan towards Hindus (this professor included), it is better to not have any relations. I would like to stop all diplomatic relations, build a 20 foot wall from Kutch to Kashmir and do a one time naturalization of all Hindus/Sikhs/Jains in Pakistan who want to leave Pakistan. We Indians can live happily and progress without doing anything to do with Pakistan.

[@vikasbhargava5653]

Nazariya Paxstan is that Paxtan is an anti-thesis of India. Whatever India stands for Paxstan has to stand for the opposite. Whatever India does Paxstan has to do the opposite. It is an amazing "Nazariya" that has got Paxstan to where it is. And I am sure Paxstanis love it.

[@gopalramanathan7062]

Spot on. Bharat and “Pakistan” are exactly like Matter and Anti Matter. “Pakistan” is a curse upon humanity Only when “Pakistan” ceases to exist peace and prosperity will return to this part of the world 🛑

[@ramanv.r3422]

However much I admire the Professor he is totally wrong about Hinduism. The Hindutva party made a Muslim the countrie's President. Hinduism is a securlar philosophy unlike Abrahamic religions. India is secular because of Hinduism. Muslims are living happily in India. Their numer is increasing. Professor must look at Pakistani minorities. It is a pity that science has not opened his eyes fully. May be he is constained by the prevailing circumsatnces in his country.

[@chandreshmehta2399]

He shall read translation of Shreemad Bhagavad-Gita. Or he can read any of Upnishads. Hindu is the most rational concept in spirituality.

[@agnosticatheist4093]

He didn't mentioned about Hinduism he only highlighted the dark side of Hindutva which is damaging India's secular minds

[@agnosticatheist4093]

@PavitShokeen Well jhut bolna, nafrat failana, logo ke sochne ki kshamta ko khatam kardena tumhare liye sahi baat hai toh Hindutva tumhe mubarak ho.

[@agnosticatheist4093]

@PavitShokeen dekh bhai main tera koi teacher nahi hun jo country, state, constitution, social fabric kyu important hota hai parau. 1947 ke baad Pakistan ka kya bana hum sabhi jante hai agar tumhe bhi wohi banna hai toh thik hai Hindutva ki ideology ko follow karte raho ekdin zaroor tum bhi unhi ki tarah ban jaoge. Aur haan agar tumhe koi ghalatphaimi hai ke hum Hindu hai woh Muslim hai, humlog secular hai shanti priye hai toh mein yeh kahoonga thik hai tumhe jo yeh ulti seedhi chize shikha rahe hai unse poochna pahle Hindurastra yah Hindutva ka definition aur constitution likh ke de aur main dawe ke saath kahta hun koi maikalal nahi jawab nahi dega tumhe.

[@salimalvi5178]

@agnosticatheist4093 Romans hijacked Jewish theology and invented a personality called Yeshu/Jesus. They divided the people of Levant (Middle East) by creating new gang/legion to grab REgal political power to enslave, rob and deracinate natives. This was born ReLigion called Christianity. Romans gave plum postings to those who joined Christianity gang, esp Tax Collector posts. They dated this Jesus character 300 years back and made native Jews responsible for his death. The deracinated gang members were made brutes full of hate and they made living hell for the Jews the land of their ancestors and waves of Jews took refuge in BharatVarsh. Romans used this gang of brutes to attack, enslave & deracinate natives of Europe by calling them Pagan. Soon Roman empire expanded till Britain. Arabs saw this Roman success in building a gang to create an enslaving empire, so created their own gang called Islam. It was almost a copy of Christianity. To attract gang members Islam had to offer enticement of Sex-Slavery of not only females but also of young boys. They also had to promise 72 Hoors and 140 Gilmays of Jannat after death. To survive in competition with Christianity Islam had to pump more hate of everything native, hate of those who are not gang members. Persians who were exhausted by constant warfare with Romans to defend their land civilization were easily defeated and Islamized in mere 18 years. In first decade of MohMadden rule over Persia, native Persians couldn't own any property unless they take on Bedouinized Yahoodi names & declare themselves MohMadden. Mind that for MohMaddens wife & children were property. No wonder a million or so Persians/Parsis took refuge in Bharat. These two gangs spread slavery, traded slaves, if there was any resistance whole native communities were genocided. 140 Million Africans perished in 1000 year merely in transportation to slave Bazaars of Baghdad, Rome and Americas. 100+ BharatVarshiya (natives of greater Bharat) perished in wars to defend their civilization. MohMad Bin Kasims attacked Sindh of Raja Dahir to capture female progeny of MohMad Kureshi-Hashmi the so called founder of Islam. These females with their kids were trying to escape Islam and it's KhanaJungi in which first 5 Khalifas were murdered. MohMadism couldn't win for next 700 years even in Afghanistan, Balochistan & Sindh because of the bravery of natives of BharatVarsh. In last 800 years BharatVarsh is severely wounded but it can only survive and become healthy if it nurses it's roots of native spirituality, native culture, native languages and most importantly pride in achievements of native ancestors such as Decimal System, Astronomy, calendar (both lunar & solar), Metallurgy, Ayurved, Yogi & Samadhi/Dhyana/Zen. The criminal gangs (Christianity & Islam) destroyed natives of MidEast, Europe, Africa, Americas, Australia and big portion of Asia. If you do genetic investigation on Royalty Of Europe especially those who colonized native lands all over the world then you will find that they have Roman & Khalifa genes. There's a reason why MountBatten was a pedophile and why he was murdered by a young boy whom he abused. Roman civilization was destroyed because of extinction of marriage as institution. As loot & plunder from colonies started pouring in the European/Roman elites didn't want to share it with Christian clergy though this clergy ran the cannon fodder of Christian zealots who formed the colonial army. This they called Secularism - separation of state from ReLigion. Natives of BharatVarsh have Dharma which is organic & native. It is not an enslaving, brutalizing social structure like these gangs/Legions. European came up with Marxism in 19th century to keep the clergy far away from the power. But this Marxism is not much different from Christianity and Islam. Its founder Marx was East India Company employee and you will find his writings on how BriShits should crush the struggle of independence of 1857. Marxism also has a Slave-manual like Bible & Koran. It also creates evil empires for Politburo brute honchos like Stalin, Mao, PolPot & Xi as Christianity & MohMadism creates evil empires for VatiCunning Pope, Roman King, BriShit Royalty, Khalifas, Mughal Badmash.

[@mridulagrawal6687]

Romila Thapar has no knowledge of Sanskrit,tamil,prakrit which r ancient indian languages,her whole writing r scholarship is based on reading translations of British,who were colonisers of India,u can imagine what her scholarship is worth then

[@agnosticatheist4093]

Aur tumhe yeh koun bataya? Hindutva ke pracharako ne? Woh kabhi yeh baat romila thapar ke muh pe nahi bolenge, woh kabhi Romila thapar ke against debate nahi karenge, woh bas apna youtube channel kholke Romila Thapar ke personal remarks dete rahenge. Education toh li hogi tumne toh kabhi Education ko kaam pe bhi lagao. Main nahi kah raha Romila Thapar achi hai yah buri hai lekin yeh zaroor kahunga kisi ko judge karne se pahle unke kaam ko without any biases check karlo, dekho unka kaam factual based hai? Koi references dia hai? Koi Archeological saboot hai? Yah phir apne mann mutabik stories likhi hai.

[@apoorvchauhan6258]

​@@agnosticatheist4093you should read bibliography of Romila's book. She has mentioned secondary translation texts through which she has quotes extensively

[@agnosticatheist4093]

@@apoorvchauhan6258 As for your point about checking Romila's bibliography, I acknowledge that she has used secondary translation texts extensively in her work. The use of secondary sources, however, does not necessarily diminish the value of research, especially when accurate translations are referenced. Scholarship is often built on the work of others; hence, the key is to synthesize the available information objectively and innovatively.

[@apoorvchauhan6258]

@@agnosticatheist4093 you are working on the assumption that those Colonial Translation are absolutely uncontested. It's a fact that much of the early works have been thoroughly scrutinized by independent scholars. Romila has drawn parallels that are absolutely rubbish and if a person is speaking from a level of responsibility, she should watch her words. Saying Yudhishthir was inspired by Asoka is cuckery

[@agnosticatheist4093]

@@apoorvchauhan6258 Firstly, Thapar doesn't solely rely on language translations but utilizes an expansive array of multidisciplinary historical evidence. A prominent feature of her work is the usage of archaeological findings which present concrete evidence of past civilizations and their practices. She refers to inscriptions and coins, primary sources that provide a firsthand, tangible glimpse into history, not subject to linguistic translations. Moreover, Thapar also incorporates letters and memoirs into her research. Such sources offer experiential accounts and personal perspectives from the periods she explores, further complementing and substantiating her narrative. Thus, her work stands as an analytical amalgamation of various kinds of evidence, far beyond translated texts. Secondly, Thapar’s use of a vast array of secondary literature maintains the integrity of her work. Secondary sources are essential to historical analysis as they provide interpretations and context which further our understanding of primary sources. It enables the engagement of multiple viewpoints and helps minimize the effect of individual bias. In fact, historical research is rarely, if ever, based on a single source. It requires a comprehensive and comparative analysis of various sources to create a rich, nuanced, and accurate account of events and eras. In this light, Thapar's methodology aligns seamlessly with the standards of quality historical research. Thapar’s interpretations, such as the comparison between Yudhishthir and Ashoka, are part of her analytical work as a historian. She does not claim to have the final or definitive word on the past, but rather offers her insights based on the available data and her expertise. She also acknowledges the limitations and challenges of historical research, such as the gaps in the sources, the biases of the authors, and the changing contexts of the readers. She invites critical engagement and dialogue with her work, rather than imposing her views on others. Therefore, one cannot undermine Thapar’s scholarship based solely on her use of translations or some controversial interpretations. Instead, her exhaustive usage of diverse sources, from archaeological evidence to secondary texts, underscores her meticulous approach and commitment to providing a holistic representation of historical events and figures.

[@srijandatta287]

Asmani physicists should stick to their core competencies. He is totally out of his element here. I would be surprised if anyone buys his book other than his lackeys like Shakil.

[@chaitanyakada1341]

Absolutely correct

[@kumarakantirava429]

If you had pointed specific fallacies, you would have earned some merit. Useless comment.

[@srijandatta287]

@@kumarakantirava429 I don't even remember now. This was a short criticism of what I found problematic in the video. A skim showed me 8:18 muslims don't consider themselves to be equal to hindus in terms of religious rights, Pew Research would like to disagree. 31:20 "Humkumarani ka nizam accha tha" not quite true. 33:45 "Pakistan ka education system including african nations is the worst" What is he basing this on?? I would consider niger to be worse.

[@indian9428]

37:39 after chandrayaan 3 INDIA will see a boom in space startups .. it is going to be multi billion dolar industry in INDIA in next few years , and if Pakistanis are not happy with BJP it means BJP is doing good job .. and pakistan this nightmare is going to continue to for long time because BJP is going to stay their for very long time

[@HOG1070]

These so-called Pakistani intellectuals will be saying that Hindu who were left in Pakistan are in very good condition? They are more concerned about Indians( Muslims) than Pakistanis( Hindus)

[@chaitanyakada1341]

It is called special selective logic

[@anujay81]

Most of the ISRO Scientists and Engineers are not from IITs.

[@snathan3198]

Hoodbhoy is a soft islamist with a physics degree!

[@rahulrasiklalbora4296]

Dr. Saheb give 90 % marks to Nasa & 20 % to Other . NAsa Is Having 40 % Indians and runs a Space Agency . Whereas Isro is not having any American and Running a Successful Space Agency .

[@jitendrabansal798]

Country which based on religion can't survive...... Nehru Ji is right

[@ArvindMohanGupta]

Hussain saheb we Indian never talk about Pakistan, Modi tried to normalise situation but what did Pakistan Uri Pathankot then Pulwama, then Modi change his mind, no talks with Pakistan untill Pakistan stop terrorism in India

[@krishnatikoo3445]

Power of clergy and their interference in all aspects of life in Pakistan needs to be seriously addressed. The Army as well as Politician has to depend upon the clergy for their existence.

[@salimalvi5178]

Anglos mastered use of Islam as Weapon of Mass Destruction just like Taimurids, Turks & Afghans before them. Anglos were much smarter than those brutes. They didn't have their hands have any blood stains. They merely had to breed Khalifas among the progeny of cowards, crooks & criminals who took Bedouinized Yahoodi names under duress, due to enticement and threat of rape & death. By the second & third generation MohMadism and other AbraHarami gangs/legions Christianity, Marxism & Fiat Currency like $ driven Hedonistic Consumerism succeed in completely cutting roots of new gang members. The guilt of abandoning ones ancestral spirituality, culture & language is replaced by extreme hate of everything native in second & third generation. Anglos cooked this hate to breed Khalifas. Thus they bred Khalifa Al Lundoni Chiknah Jinah & EkBall. Father of EkBall & Chiknah took Bedouinized Yahoodi names and declared themselves MohMadden. MohMaddens of today's Bharat voted 97% to create the first ISIS (Islamic State of Indian Subcontinent). Some of them even sent younger brother to newly created ISIS land called Pakistan, to occupy fleeing HinduSikh properties, lands & businesses. MJ Akbar who was BJP minister in Modi's cabinet till 2018, had his Abbujan move to ISIS land called Pakistan to occupy HinduSikh properties especially lands. His Abbujan sold these properties & lands which he got free in 5 years and made lot of money. Then he came back to current Bharat. MJ Akbar told to Terry Gross in Fresh Air program that in the ISIS land he couldn't get firangi thurra freely so decided to come back to Bharat. MohMaddens by design are deceitful and are waiting for GazwaEHind when the population % is in their favor. We saw this in Kashmir Files.

[@abhinavgoyal2210]

75 saal musalman ban ke dekh liya .....ab 10 -15 saal insaan banke dekh lo.....Ho skta h ki mulk sahi ho jaye

[@Irene-m9n8b]

Sir,the partition still remain a quite muddled issue, yet it was indispensable. One should now move on and not worry about how things are on the other side.

[@salimalvi5178]

Anglos mastered use of Islam as Weapon of Mass Destruction just like Taimurids, Turks & Afghans before them. Anglos were much smarter than those brutes. They didn't have their hands have any blood stains. They merely had to breed Khalifas among the progeny of cowards, crooks & criminals who took Bedouinized Yahoodi names under duress, due to enticement and threat of rape & death. By the second & third generation MohMadism and other AbraHarami gangs/legions Christianity, Marxism & Fiat Currency like $ driven Hedonistic Consumerism succeed in completely cutting roots of new gang members. The guilt of abandoning ones ancestral spirituality, culture & language is replaced by extreme hate of everything native in second & third generation. Anglos cooked this hate to breed Khalifas. Thus they bred Khalifa Al Lundoni Chiknah Jinah & EkBall. Father of EkBall & Chiknah took Bedouinized Yahoodi names and declared themselves MohMadden. MohMaddens of today's Bharat voted 97% to create the first ISIS (Islamic State of Indian Subcontinent). Some of them even sent younger brother to newly created ISIS land called Pakistan, to occupy fleeing HinduSikh properties, lands & businesses. MJ Akbar who was BJP minister in Modi's cabinet till 2018, had his Abbujan move to ISIS land called Pakistan to occupy HinduSikh properties especially lands. His Abbujan sold these properties & lands which he got free in 5 years and made lot of money. Then he came back to current Bharat. MJ Akbar told to Terry Gross in Fresh Air program that in the ISIS land he couldn't get firangi thurra freely so decided to come back to Bharat. MohMaddens by design are deceitful and are waiting for GazwaEHind when the population % is in their favor. We saw this in Kashmir Files.

[@RoamingDoctors]

Mr parvez seems to hv delusion about current state of muslims in India. Their situation is due to lack of education. Those who hv taken education hv done very well... Ppl should take trip to india to understand actual situation..

[@pardeepbhambra2459]

Sir hood boy I am an Indian American big fan of you although I don’t agree with you sometimes but still love to listen to you god bless you sir

[@agnosticatheist4093]

Woh aap ki biases hai jo aap ko kuch chizo se agree karne se rokta hai

[@rakeshbarman3486]

​@@agnosticatheist4093not biases its called data and inclusive policies

[@agnosticatheist4093]

@@rakeshbarman3486 It's biases, atleast iss video mein Dr. Hoodbhoy ne jo bola woh sach hai. Agar tumhe lagta hai unhone kisi baat pe bongimaari hai toh please mention it.

[@rakeshbarman3486]

@@agnosticatheist4093 everything related to india from a pakistani is a bongi ,thats why we say people shouldn't trespass their field of expertise , he is a physicist (and a good one ) talking about social science which is laughable, funniest shit is he wrote a book on history, his understanding of india is shallow , just few weeks back kushal from carvaka podcast exposed him vehemently , he doesn't double check at all ,just believes his favorite source blindly , that's called conformation bias ,in which you follow those media and news portal which massage your idealogy and then you get into citation loophole, so the end you are just hearing binaries , without nuance ,social science is all about nuances in society

[@salimalvi5178]

Al Baqistani, be s/he Anglophile or Arabophile - Hai toh woh RAPE (Royal Anglophile/Arabophile Paki Elite). @agnosticatheist4093 Romans hijacked Jewish theology and invented a personality called Yeshu/Jesus. They divided the people of Levant (Middle East) by creating new gang/legion to grab REgal political power to enslave, rob and deracinate natives. This was born ReLigion called Christianity. Romans gave plum postings to those who joined Christianity gang, esp Tax Collector posts. They dated this Jesus character 300 years back and made native Jews responsible for his death. The deracinated gang members were made brutes full of hate and they made living hell for the Jews the land of their ancestors and waves of Jews took refuge in BharatVarsh. Romans used this gang of brutes to attack, enslave & deracinate natives of Europe by calling them Pagan. Soon Roman empire expanded till Britain. Arabs saw this Roman success in building a gang to create an enslaving empire, so created their own gang called Islam. It was almost a copy of Christianity. To attract gang members Islam had to offer enticement of Sex-Slavery of not only females but also of young boys. They also had to promise 72 Hoors and 140 Gilmays of Jannat after death. To survive in competition with Christianity Islam had to pump more hate of everything native, hate of those who are not gang members. Persians who were exhausted by constant warfare with Romans to defend their land civilization were easily defeated and Islamized in mere 18 years. In first decade of MohMadden rule over Persia, native Persians couldn't own any property unless they take on Bedouinized Yahoodi names & declare themselves MohMadden. Mind that for MohMaddens wife & children were property. No wonder a million or so Persians/Parsis took refuge in Bharat. These two gangs spread slavery, traded slaves, if there was any resistance whole native communities were genocided. 140 Million Africans perished in 1000 year merely in transportation to slave Bazaars of Baghdad, Rome and Americas. 100+ BharatVarshiya (natives of greater Bharat) perished in wars to defend their civilization. MohMad Bin Kasims attacked Sindh of Raja Dahir to capture female progeny of MohMad Kureshi-Hashmi the so called founder of Islam. These females with their kids were trying to escape Islam and it's KhanaJungi in which first 5 Khalifas were murdered. MohMadism couldn't win for next 700 years even in Afghanistan, Balochistan & Sindh because of the bravery of natives of BharatVarsh. In last 800 years BharatVarsh is severely wounded but it can only survive and become healthy if it nurses it's roots of native spirituality, native culture, native languages and most importantly pride in achievements of native ancestors such as Decimal System, Astronomy, calendar (both lunar & solar), Metallurgy, Ayurved, Yogi & Samadhi/Dhyana/Zen. The criminal gangs (Christianity & Islam) destroyed natives of MidEast, Europe, Africa, Americas, Australia and big portion of Asia. If you do genetic investigation on Royalty Of Europe especially those who colonized native lands all over the world then you will find that they have Roman & Khalifa genes. There's a reason why MountBatten was a pedophile and why he was murdered by a young boy whom he abused. Roman civilization was destroyed because of extinction of marriage as institution. As loot & plunder from colonies started pouring in the European/Roman elites didn't want to share it with Christian clergy though this clergy ran the cannon fodder of Christian zealots who formed the colonial army. This they called Secularism - separation of state from ReLigion. Natives of BharatVarsh have Dharma which is organic & native. It is not an enslaving, brutalizing social structure like these gangs/Legions. European came up with Marxism in 19th century to keep the clergy far away from the power. But this Marxism is not much different from Christianity and Islam. Its founder Marx was East India Company employee and you will find his writings on how BriShits should crush the struggle of independence of 1857. Marxism also has a Slave-manual like Bible & Koran. It also creates evil empires for Politburo brute honchos like Stalin, Mao, PolPot & Xi as Christianity & MohMadism creates evil empires for VatiCunning Pope, Roman King, BriShit Royalty, Khalifas, Mughal Badmash.

[@anujay81]

As usual no Pakistani or for that matter any Muslim is seen in the comments section of this channel too.

[@pschhu]

Who are you to decide whom we should select as government.

[@rakeshbarman3486]

he says invaders came made beautiful architecture and sang songs 😂, what about killings hindus , making hindus second grade citizen and forcing them to pay jizya ,

[@twistsandturns6121]

India say baat karna hay , trade bhi Karna hay magar HINDU , RSS , BJP MODI pasand nehi . Lagta hay dimag kam nehi kar raha hay. 😮😮😮 Isilea MODI JI nay bolatha Pakistan apnay boojh say apnyapp giir jayeaga .

[@fakeneyoo224]

13:21 What is hindutva is not an action against muslim it's the reaction against the Muslims (cause and effect) because of Muslim do riots in India. Indian Muslim voted and supported Pak but stayed back not because of the love or patriotism of India but mass migration wasn't possible on that scale. So they decided to stay in the system and take over the system. As one group decides to create a new madina (pak) and take over Mecca (Delhi) back by following the sunnat and make Darul harb into Darul Islam , their end goal is the same but means we're different. "Islam is divided in sets but it's United for the hatred of kafirs". Don't bring This Marxist that because of jobs and other things they created Pakistan, its core is religion and jobs and other things are other consequences or out comes of that . Don't look at the history from today's lens .

[@agnosticatheist4093]

Even if we accept that Muslims have spread hatred and committed atrocities, although this isn't entirely true, does it mean you will support such hatred, atrocities in the form of Hindutva? Those who study medicine become doctors, those who study engineering become engineers, and those who continually amplify hate become haters themselves. We don't want to become the next Pakistan, we want to be India, a nation that believes in Vasudeva Kutumvakam (the world is one family), and holds faith in humanity and love. Those who voted for the Muslim League have passed away, and today's Muslims are not responsible for it. Similarly, the Hindu Mahasabha had also formed a coalition government with the Muslim League and had opposed the Quit India movement. If you keep bringing up old baggage, then history, which means partition, will repeat again. Our issues should not be Hindu versus Muslim, but instead about Quality Education, Health Facilities, and Wealth Inequality.

[@fakeneyoo224]

@@agnosticatheist4093 THAT'S THE CAUSE AND EFFECT, ONE IS Aggressive And other is doing defence hindutva is reaction to Islamist extremist . And we know which community is aggressive on kafirs , and in 1947 Lahore Hindu had good health education and wealth , same with kasmiri pandit look at what happened to them, I think you are so ignorant about reality. ECONOMIC HEALTH EDUCATION OTHERS THINGS WILL GO IN HAND WITH SELF DEFENCE (HINDUTVA) .

[@fakeneyoo224]

@@agnosticatheist4093 PAKISTAN IS CREATED BUT IDEA OF PAKISTAN IS STILL ALIVE IN INDIAN MULLAS. AS THE IDEA COME FROM QURAN IT self world is divided into Darul harb and darul Islam. DON'T BE FOOL . YES PARTION WILL HAPPEN WHEN MUSLIM POPULATION REACHS AT A CERTAIN POINT OF PERCENTAGE.

[@fakeneyoo224]

@@agnosticatheist4093 same things was told by LEHRU and Gandhi economic health education bhai chara what it's results in partion. When muslim population reaches a significant percentage of the population then PARTION is inevitable don't fool yourself.

[@agnosticatheist4093]

@@fakeneyoo224 You're perpetuating the familiar narrative of supposedly false Hindu Nationalists who never take part in debates. Do you have any proof that Muslims desire another Pakistan? Just because their population is growing doesn't imply they'll create another Pakistan. Turkey is proof that a Muslim-majority nation can be well-educated and part of the EU. With proper education, we can educate our Muslim population. It's your bigotry and bias towards your own dogma that's the problem. The partition occurred due to several factors including the fascist mentality of the Hindu Mahasabha, the Hindu landlords of Bengal who supported the Britishers against poor Muslim farmers, Jinnah's arrogance, the Muslim landlords of Pakistan who wanted to seize Hindu lands, and the Muslims who were brainwashed by the Muslim League. The same way so-called Nationalists are brainwashed by the BJP and RSS. If there was such unity among Hindus back then, why were Dalits asking for separate state electorates? Why did they back the Muslim League against us? It's because casteism was rampant at that time. We all have a share of responsibility for the partition.

[@ArvindMohanGupta]

Muslims are in India very happy except those who live in Bharat but Dil n dimagh full with radical islamic thoughts Dr. Saheb a advice for you, pl once visit India just like Istiyak saheb, they just spend three months in India, they thoroughly visit India North to South and you himself feel and decide how Present Govt act with bhartiy not for Hindus Muslim Sikhs Cristian Secondly in Pakistan where you live , how your Govt n citizen doing with minorities

[@maheshparanjape9]

Hindu aur sikhone sab kuch khoya....prof.jhut bolta hai...

[@Rishi6901]

Bhai meri family Pakistan se aayi thi Rajasthan aur bhai shuruat me unko dikat ayi thi lekin baad me wo bhi sahi hogaye or hum bhi ab sahi kr rhe life me. Mere khyal se to bahut sahi Kia waha se aakar warna pta nhi kya haal to hmari generation ka waha. Partition me khun BHA lekin overall ab uska result dikh rha.

[@rakeshmamgaain5362]

What is CSS? It was referred to more than once in the video.

[@Unspokendigital]

Central Superior Service (Top Bureaucracy) Just like the Indian Civil Service (IAS, IPS)

[@NithishRathore]

There is no particular record of how women were treated by the Islamic invaders. However, it is a known fact that whenever enemies from the middle-east have made invasions into Indian kingdoms and succeeded, women have been raped, brutalised and enslaved. In fact recently there was one Bollywood film made depicting the same concept and was the centre of controversy. The movie “Padmavati” showed the concept of Jauhar which was prevalent in the Raiput kingdoms. The movie was based on the life of Alauddin Khilji of the Khilji dynasty and Padmavati wife of a Raiput King whom Khilji wanted to capture and enslave. Basically if the king lost or got killed in the war, the news would reach the queen back in the castle and she along with wives and mothers of other martyred soldiers would commit jauhar by jumping into the fire alive. This way she could avoid the rape, torture and pain she would face once the enemies entered the castle. Mostly those women would be raped and kept as sex slaves by the Islamic invaders if captured alive.

[@salimalvi5178]

Wonder why all sexual abuse and the words used in them are Arabic? Aurat=Vagina, Laundi=Sex-Slave girl, Randi=prostitute, Lauda, Choot, gaand etc @agnosticatheist4093 Romans hijacked Jewish theology and invented a personality called Yeshu/Jesus. They divided the people of Levant (Middle East) by creating new gang/legion to grab REgal political power to enslave, rob and deracinate natives. This was born ReLigion called Christianity. Romans gave plum postings to those who joined Christianity gang, esp Tax Collector posts. They dated this Jesus character 300 years back and made native Jews responsible for his death. The deracinated gang members were made brutes full of hate and they made living hell for the Jews the land of their ancestors and waves of Jews took refuge in BharatVarsh. Romans used this gang of brutes to attack, enslave & deracinate natives of Europe by calling them Pagan. Soon Roman empire expanded till Britain. Arabs saw this Roman success in building a gang to create an enslaving empire, so created their own gang called Islam. It was almost a copy of Christianity. To attract gang members Islam had to offer enticement of Sex-Slavery of not only females but also of young boys. They also had to promise 72 Hoors and 140 Gilmays of Jannat after death. To survive in competition with Christianity Islam had to pump more hate of everything native, hate of those who are not gang members. Persians who were exhausted by constant warfare with Romans to defend their land civilization were easily defeated and Islamized in mere 18 years. In first decade of MohMadden rule over Persia, native Persians couldn't own any property unless they take on Bedouinized Yahoodi names & declare themselves MohMadden. Mind that for MohMaddens wife & children were property. No wonder a million or so Persians/Parsis took refuge in Bharat. These two gangs spread slavery, traded slaves, if there was any resistance whole native communities were genocided. 140 Million Africans perished in 1000 year merely in transportation to slave Bazaars of Baghdad, Rome and Americas. 100+ BharatVarshiya (natives of greater Bharat) perished in wars to defend their civilization. MohMad Bin Kasims attacked Sindh of Raja Dahir to capture female progeny of MohMad Kureshi-Hashmi the so called founder of Islam. These females with their kids were trying to escape Islam and it's KhanaJungi in which first 5 Khalifas were murdered. MohMadism couldn't win for next 700 years even in Afghanistan, Balochistan & Sindh because of the bravery of natives of BharatVarsh. In last 800 years BharatVarsh is severely wounded but it can only survive and become healthy if it nurses it's roots of native spirituality, native culture, native languages and most importantly pride in achievements of native ancestors such as Decimal System, Astronomy, calendar (both lunar & solar), Metallurgy, Ayurved, Yogi & Samadhi/Dhyana/Zen. The criminal gangs (Christianity & Islam) destroyed natives of MidEast, Europe, Africa, Americas, Australia and big portion of Asia. If you do genetic investigation on Royalty Of Europe especially those who colonized native lands all over the world then you will find that they have Roman & Khalifa genes. There's a reason why MountBatten was a pedophile and why he was murdered by a young boy whom he abused. Roman civilization was destroyed because of extinction of marriage as institution. As loot & plunder from colonies started pouring in the European/Roman elites didn't want to share it with Christian clergy though this clergy ran the cannon fodder of Christian zealots who formed the colonial army. This they called Secularism - separation of state from ReLigion. Natives of BharatVarsh have Dharma which is organic & native. It is not an enslaving, brutalizing social structure like these gangs/Legions. European came up with Marxism in 19th century to keep the clergy far away from the power. But this Marxism is not much different from Christianity and Islam. Its founder Marx was East India Company employee and you will find his writings on how BriShits should crush the struggle of independence of 1857. Marxism also has a Slave-manual like Bible & Koran. It also creates evil empires for Politburo brute honchos like Stalin, Mao, PolPot & Xi as Christianity & MohMadism creates evil empires for VatiCunning Pope, Roman King, BriShit Royalty, Khalifas, Mughal Badmash.

[@vsing1789]

Let me answer to the question what will India benefit from Chandrayan 3? 1) share prices of all private companies in India increased from 20 to 45% 2)ISRO will be invited in global space partnership projects, like it was not invited for international space station earlier 3) The technology used in landing chandrayan will be used for landing man mission on moon 4) Antrix , commercial wing of ISRO will get more projects for satellite launches 5) Soft power, India made headlines in many countries

[@anujay81]

As the Sky Book contains all the knowledge, the Muslim Invaders destroyed and burnt Universities and Libraries in Baghdad, Takshila, Sharda, Nalanda, etc.

[@bhavinsampat590]

7.30.. factual errors.. indian muslims overwhelming voted for idea of pakistan, madras state, UP, MP all. they stayed back coz of economic reason. they should have gone to pak as they voted for pak and not india.

[@jaspaldhillon8311]

Jinnah did not want his daughter to inherit his property, and that was only possible in an Islamic country.

[@HOG1070]

we would like to maintain the status quo for at least the next 25 years. Whatever you call it, takat ka nasha ... or whatever 😂 but Pakistan ko kiska Nasha hai!!!? 😂😂😂

[@VG-bf9cy]

I will tell prof that our space race is Hindutva space race

[@FactFinder1988]

Ek padha likha pakistani bhi kaisa duffer ho saktaa hai dekh le..... Lekin ye to hamesha se kehte hai fir bhi koi indian pakistani citizens ke lia apply nai karta...... Aap ye bataiye rights kam hai kya yanha

[@saabmukarramnawazofficial394]

ye kasor b ap k media ka hai. or apki government ka hai.

[@timipass111]

Jinnah like other Muslim league leader didn’t believe in competition/democracy and his failure to win over Gandhi led to the partition. His failure in congress and his superiority complex led him to wrongly blame Hindus/Congress for believing Hindus will not give fair share to Muslims. His authoritarianism came out open when he wanted to impose Urdu on Bangladeshis. He was no visionary or a statesman but selfish lawyer who divided a holy cow for his selfish personal goals.

[@SR-pk2ph]

Mahmood Gazavi and Muhammad Gauri were true followers of Nazaria-e- Pakistan !!!!

[@RG-iw4c]

Duri hone se hi kai baar rishte bnte h. Saath rhkr to 70saal dekh liya.

[@parjanyashukla176]

Going by this analysis, Congress party in 1940s under Nehru sounds like a Hindu fascist party from the Muslim League perspective of the 1940s. Now, 75+ years later, BJP is slowly taking over the role of the rotten Congress and ironically Pakistanis are now in concurrence with the same Congress party, now calling the BJP as a "Hindu" party. 😂😂 So in essence nothing has changed even after 75+ years and it seems nothing will change in the next 75 years either.

[@NithishRathore]

Pervez hoodbhoy a intellectual can't hate anybody,he try to understand their point of view. But hoodbhoy knows hating BJP 😂😂

[@althea_is_smokin_hot]

Sirs, India pak relations mean Kashmir. A suggestion regarding prelude to any activity. Bismillah Kashmir, Kashmir, and Kashmir.

[@parashurampawar5505]

Modi will return again in 24 elections

[@satkrapp7697]

Kongrass potty & TN pig Stalin are crying in the corner 😂😂😂

[@Darsh_Yadav__2025]

Modi ji ❤❤❤

[@sanjeevbjain]

HOODBHOY SHOULD BE THE PRIME MINISTER OF PAKISTAN

[@salimalvi5178]

He will not be much different from Khalifa Al Lundoni Chiknah Jinah, 1000 year Warwala Bhutto, Farukh Abdullah of CashMere. Romans hijacked Jewish theology and invented a personality called Yeshu/Jesus. They divided the people of Levant (Middle East) by creating new gang/legion to grab REgal political power to enslave, rob and deracinate natives. This was born ReLigion called Christianity. Romans gave plum postings to those who joined Christianity gang, esp Tax Collector posts. They dated this Jesus character 300 years back and made native Jews responsible for his death. The deracinated gang members were made brutes full of hate and they made living hell for the Jews the land of their ancestors and waves of Jews took refuge in BharatVarsh. Romans used this gang of brutes to attack, enslave & deracinate natives of Europe by calling them Pagan. Soon Roman empire expanded till Britain. Arabs saw this Roman success in building a gang to create an enslaving empire, so created their own gang called Islam. It was almost a copy of Christianity. To attract gang members Islam had to offer enticement of Sex-Slavery of not only females but also of young boys. They also had to promise 72 Hoors and 140 Gilmays of Jannat after death. To survive in competition with Christianity Islam had to pump more hate of everything native, hate of those who are not gang members. Persians who were exhausted by constant warfare with Romans to defend their land civilization were easily defeated and Islamized in mere 18 years. In first decade of MohMadden rule over Persia, native Persians couldn't own any property unless they take on Bedouinized Yahoodi names & declare themselves MohMadden. Mind that for MohMaddens wife & children were property. No wonder a million or so Persians/Parsis took refuge in Bharat. These two gangs spread slavery, traded slaves, if there was any resistance whole native communities were genocided. 140 Million Africans perished in 1000 year merely in transportation to slave Bazaars of Baghdad, Rome and Americas. 100+ BharatVarshiya (natives of greater Bharat) perished in wars to defend their civilization. MohMad Bin Kasims attacked Sindh of Raja Dahir to capture female progeny of MohMad Kureshi-Hashmi the so called founder of Islam. These females with their kids were trying to escape Islam and it's KhanaJungi in which first 5 Khalifas were murdered. MohMadism couldn't win for next 700 years even in Afghanistan, Balochistan & Sindh because of the bravery of natives of BharatVarsh. In last 800 years BharatVarsh is severely wounded but it can only survive and become healthy if it nurses it's roots of native spirituality, native culture, native languages and most importantly pride in achievements of native ancestors such as Decimal System, Astronomy, calendar (both lunar & solar), Metallurgy, Ayurved, Yogi & Samadhi/Dhyana/Zen. The criminal gangs (Christianity & Islam) destroyed natives of MidEast, Europe, Africa, Americas, Australia and big portion of Asia. If you do genetic investigation on Royalty Of Europe especially those who colonized native lands all over the world then you will find that they have Roman & Khalifa genes. There's a reason why MountBatten was a pedophile and why he was murdered by a young boy whom he abused. Roman civilization was destroyed because of extinction of marriage as institution. As loot & plunder from colonies started pouring in the European/Roman elites didn't want to share it with Christian clergy though this clergy ran the cannon fodder of Christian zealots who formed the colonial army. This they called Secularism - separation of state from ReLigion. Natives of BharatVarsh have Dharma which is organic & native. It is not an enslaving, brutalizing social structure like these gangs/Legions. European came up with Marxism in 19th century to keep the clergy far away from the power. But this Marxism is not much different from Christianity and Islam. Its founder Marx was East India Company employee and you will find his writings on how BriShits should crush the struggle of independence of 1857. Marxism also has a Slave-manual like Bible & Koran. It also creates evil empires for Politburo brute honchos like Stalin, Mao, PolPot & Xi as Christianity & MohMadism creates evil empires for VatiCunning Pope, Roman King, BriShit Royalty, Khalifas, Mughal Badmash.

[@ArvindMohanGupta]

Hussain saheb pl tell in which field Pakistan may compatible with India

[@vikasbhargava5653]

Baaton se aise lagta hai ki yeh anchor 2 Nation theory aur Partition se khush nahin hai? Isn't this "Treason" in Paxstan? You know Nazariya Paxstan ke khilaaf.

[@FactFinder1988]

Ye professor sach mie dimag se paidal hai....

[@satkrapp7697]

MIT pHd holder..how can you say that ?

[@Striker-jg9kv]

​@@satkrapp7697and imraand Khan too was from harward, according to porkis , so what ? Did he turn islamic Republic of hira Mandi randistan porkistan bhikharistan Pakistan into some sort of heaven😂😂

[@Darsh_Yadav__2025]

​@@satkrapp7697to kya ho gaya, imran Khan ka bhi degree dekh lo , Pakistani politicians ki bhi degree dekh lo 😂😂😂

[@satkrapp7697]

@@Darsh_Yadav__2025 imran is a womaniser cum Bawasir Khan...also corruption king...so don't capmpare

[@msdolly6101981]

​@@satkrapp7697: Osama bin.laden was a civil engineer. No matter what degree they have , mindset is exactly the same 😅

[@rachnachouhan8268]

No body is asking ur opinion professor sir. U have made ur nation and keep ur opinion to it only and think about ur govt..think what u so called intellectual did to ur nation. Stop thinking of INDIA concentrate to ur nation. Its my opinion 😂

[@chaitanyakada1341]

Thinking about Bharath is their compulsion

[@rpsharma636]

Pervez hoodb😊😊

[@nishu413]

It's not taqat ka nasha. It's saving our energy for meaningful progress. Aapse baat karne se koi faayda nahi. Ek terrorist attack hoga and we will be back to square one. Aapne apne problem samajh liye hai. Ab unko solve kariye phir agar terror infrastructure khatam hoga to baat kar lenge

[@Pushpalal0]

Dear Parvez, Aap ne Indian musalmano nuksan to bataya pakistan banane ke baad... but jo hindu waha se bhaage ... aaj pakistan me hinduo ki halaat aap ko nuksan nahi lagate...Bangladesh me jo hinduo ke haal hai unka nuksan aap ko nuksan nahi lagata... Sir ji aap scintists ho aap atleast bias mat bano... any how I applied for VISA Pakistan and hope I will get it and will visit you sure...

[@v.kpareek790]

Pakistani Punjabi phoj moolla military ghathjod ne Pakistan ko barbad kar diya garib aawam ko padhaya nahi koi sahoor nahi aane diya or aaj bhi lootkar videson me arbon kharbon Dollars ki sampatiyan banai

[@jaspaldhillon8311]

Islam does not allow any kafir to rule over them.

[@NithishRathore]

We think pok is a best way to divert Pakistanis.

[@ringuanung1876]

Highly intellectual analysis

[@jitendrabansal798]

Taqat na nahsa NHi humne taqat kamayi hain

[@rakeshbarman3486]

mind your own business until you are harboring hate and terrorism against hindus and india

[@khalidmufti4463]

Very sad story 😢

[@Poison_Top]

professor pak mein to hindutava nahi hai but musalman rojana jaan se ja rahe hain… mai sikh hon mujhe koi problem nahi hai.. tumko molana molvi ke jalse or speeches pe study karke kuch bolna chahiye.. 70 saal se rojana molvi sar e aam hindu devi devta ko galat bolte hain jabke hindu chup raha hai or aaj bi kuch log bolne lag gue but kiya kuch nahi abhi tak but hoodbai jaisa banda bi india pe jehar uglta rehta hai bina ye dekhe ke muslims tv pe beth ke jo bolta vo to hindu fight mein nahi bolta…

[@HGB987]

India was fortunate to get ride of gr..ge. Mullas and military is doing good to keep the country where it belongs.

[@RG-iw4c]

Pakistan m muslman ko roti nhi mil rhi rojgar nhi mil rha life achchi nhi mil rha Dos kiske denge ab Hindu to 1% bache h kb tk ekta bnayege bs yhi glti ki pakistan bnakr Lekin india muslman gribi ya hr karn ka dos asani se hindu pr daal denge Vo arfa jaise ankr ke cheenel hi dekhege ya mulla maulana k Sare vhi milege or vo asani se hindu and govt pr blame daal kr apni kmiya Or ekjudta bnaye rkhne mekamyab ho jate h. Inka islam Sirf ek piller pr tika h Muslim vs non Muslim-kafir Vajebul ktl Ab kafir se react to hr haal m aayega Or inki ekta bni rh jayegi. Ye h mohmmad ka concept.

[@giridharreddy9690]

Now a days parvez Ghoda Bhai became cutter moulvi, RIP

[@pradeeppawale7547]

Pakistani padhalikha ( so called ) ho ya anpadh dimagi taur par ek jaisa hi hai.

[@rahulrasiklalbora4296]

Dr. Saheb need not to worry / like or Dislike Other countries Goverment . Pl .take care of your own countries Goberment .

[@RG-iw4c]

Koi y nhi sochta Muslman me thodi bahoot ekta aggr h to vo sirf hinduo ki bdolt. Jb tk hindu ke saath hoga ekjut hoga Alg hua aapas me hi ld k mra. Unke kafir concept hi unhebnye rkhta h

[@professoraftab7488]

What nonsense? Hoodbhoy is a physicist. he is poking his nose everywhere.jack of all trades is master of none.please only ask him about physics.I think his physics knowledge has gone out of date also.

[@sunnyaden3626]

Chaand pe jana chhotti BAAT hai .... ? Kmaal hai

[@rahulrasiklalbora4296]

Bhade Ki Fouz .. You are Not More than that .

[@ArvindMohanGupta]

Parvej saheb we bhartiy don't care of your and your thoughts for present Govt of Bharat

[@ramjas174]

Sorry but pokistan is died ,not even in ICU.

[@agnosticatheist4093]

Always pleasure to listen Dr. Hoodbhoy love from an Indian ❤

[@mbv1462]

Bcz he praises Indian scientific growth?

[@agnosticatheist4093]

@@mbv1462 Indeed, I admire Dr. Hoodbhoy since he is a sound individual and embraces critical thinking. Speaking of Indian scientists, their accomplishments genuinely speak volumes about their success; there is utterly no reason for me to seek validation for them from others.

[@RG-iw4c]

India ka bhi khrab h vo art wala ba ma bkwas.

[@ranjanghanshyala9263]

Atom bumb ander le lo

[@naveenawadhi6240]

Mohammad ne 6 saal ki ladki se shadi ki thi kya ye such hai pervez tu bata.

[@naveenawadhi6240]

Pervez reply dey