Pashu Ki Bali - Iska Tantra Mein Kya Importance Hai? - Rajarshi Nandy

पूरा Podcast यहाँ देखें:
• Tantra Explained Simpl...
नमस्ते दोस्तों!
आज हमारे साथ जुड़ चुके हैं The Ranveer Show के Star Guest Rajarshi Nandy जी जिन्होंने हमें 3 Blockbuster English Podcasts दिए है। वे एक Author, Columnist और Speaker है। Tantra और Sanatan Dharma पर इनकी जानकारी निसंदेह सराहनीय है।
चलिए आज जानते हैं जानवर की बलि के बारे में।
#tantra #dharma
🎧 सुनिए #TheRanveerShow हिंदी Spotify पर :-open.spotify.c...
✅ Subscribe To Our Other KZbin Channels:-
BeerBiceps (English Channel):
/ beerbicepsofficial
Ranveer Allahbadia (Hindi Channel):
/ ranveerallahbadia
TRS Clips (English Podcast Highlights):
/ theranveershowclips
BeerBiceps Shorts (English Shorts):
/ @bestoftrs
Ranveer Allahbadia Shorts (Hindi Shorts):
/ @bestoftrshindi
BigBrainco. :
/ @raaazofficial
BigBrainco. Shorts :
/ @raaazclips
--
INSTAGRAM : @ranveerallahbadia
/ ranveerallahbadia
FACEBOOK : @ranveerallahbadiaofficial
/ ranveerallahbadiaofficial
TWITTER : @beerbicepsguy
/ beerbicepsguy
LINKEDIN : @beerbiceps
/ beerbiceps
TELEGRAM: @beerbicepsguy
t.me/beerbicep...
SNAPCHAT: @beerbicepsguy
About :
The Ranveer Show Clips हिंदी Channel में आप सभी का स्वागत है। इस Channel पर आपको मिलेंगे #TheRanveerShowहिंदी के Podcast Highlights. यहाँ आप Indian History, Ancient India, World History, Hinduism, Personal Finance, Latest Business Opportunities, Top Businessmen In The World, Sports और Bollywood जैसे कई सारे Topics के बारे में जान कर अपने Knowledge के Hunger को Satisfy कर सकते हो।

[@ronitkaushik4634]

Being a student at IIT Guwahati and being able to visit the temple multiple times is such a great boon in itself

[@krishsnr]

I am privileged that last year i visited this temple of maa🛐🛐 in ghuwati... Love from himachal pradesh

[@studysharma9312]

Waro bdka g minjo moka milgaa ta maa b janaa🕉🙂

[@krishsnr]

Mere sougi chli poyan tu bhai

[@arsenalf.c6443]

How come Himachal and Uttrakhand mei bali pratha par ban laga diya.

[@krishsnr]

@@arsenalf.c6443 bhai 100 %main se 30% par ban lga hai ground level par abhi bhi ye sab chlta hai..jisko koi nahi rok skta

[@DishaThakur-uk5yr]

True , happens in village too but I don't support ​@@krishsnr

[@shiruc1168]

Ye hui na baat yahi to chahiye dark side in hindi wo bhi aise topics... respect... der aaye durust aaye 🫶🏻✨❤️‍🔥🔥🔥❤️

[@MrDeeporaj]

I am proud to be a Bengali Shakta and Sanatani from Assam....Jai Maa

[@Lucizepeto]

Bro can Maa kali Make someone alive whose body has been burnt ?? Please reply🙏🙏🙏

[@sameersachdeva9100]

Proud idio..t

[@rupamjyoti8412]

Proud to be an Assamese 💫 Jay maa kamakhya 🙏🏻.

[@ashwinkulkarni9472]

I want to come to Assam after this to see the heritage that Lachit Burphukan saved from Mughals. JAI MAA KAMAKHYA

[@bestmclips8677]

Jay Guru Shankar

[@Justkiddingbutuknow]

Asemes or Chines 😂

[@ImLearning-127]

Jai maa kamakhya🙏

[@Yogमांpi4vr]

जय गुरू देव 🙏🏽🌻 जय मां दक्षिणे कालिके

[@mAviralbhanu]

I am so happy that my mother mata kamakhya is being glorified here at 1:33. love you maa ❤

[@subhadip_Singha999]

are u mad ? maa is not a glorified thing ... she is supreme ,,, not a promotional object ,,, you re seeing it like promotional material

[@akshayoturkar2]

Mata glorified🤣🤣🙄

[@mAviralbhanu]

@@akshayoturkar2 are you dumb?

[@mAviralbhanu]

@@subhadip_Singha999 she is my mother, if someone even takes her name with respect my heart melts.

[@Bharatkhand77]

@@mAviralbhanunot your mother only “ bt evrybody,s Mother

[@debasishrabha]

I'm from Goalpara district of Assam as Nandy ji has said about hierarchical sacrifice I have heard in ancient times in mayong there is a temple name kesaikhaiti Gukhani thaan at the foothills of mayong hill where human sacrifice was practiced the villagers says that in ancient times before the sacrifice the Bali pashu appears by itself he takes bath and let the priest to perform the rituals before Bali and he gets ready for Bali by himself and people do not know from where that person comes and gets ready to be sacrificed and no-one forces him for sacrifice.

[@14SEahorSe]

Thank you for sharing this information

[@Yogमांpi4vr]

जय गुरू देव 🙏🏽🌻 जय मां दक्षिणे कालिके

[@Nobody-hj6hh]

I am Buddhist but i highly respect sanatan❤.jo hai vahi hai bas itna samjh aa rha hai.

[@AnandVenkatramanAIIM]

Happy to see the change this video is producing in the public mind🙏

[@Yogमांpi4vr]

जय गुरू देव 🙏🏽🌻 जय मां दक्षिणे कालिके

[@rudramanisharma4390]

I was against bali but after witnessing the result after giving bali to maa kali the effect is really beyond our imagination

[@atheismisthefutureofhumani3967]

True even I gave Bali of cow

[@Ankit-fc7rp]

​@@atheismisthefutureofhumani3967 abe gaye bali nhi dete mosh ka bali diya jata hai😭😭😭

[@sukanyaghosh24]

Rajarshi Nandy sir 🙏🔥❤️

[@sumilongupta747]

I am very lucky to visit Kamakhya temple recently all credit goes to her blessings🙏❤

[@santoshgoswami9291]

Our nation also is our father/mother and it also takes sacrifices of some soldiers to protect citizens.

[@sumitkunwer6500]

Is non hindu people are not successful and prosperous?

[@SriniwasT-dq7pe]

KNOWLEDGABLE PERSON...HE SHOULD BE BROUGHT MORE AND ASK HIM MORE IF HE FEELS COMFORT.

[@arjunjoshi1760]

Love this man ..need to learn abt shiv sadhana being a mahadev bhakt

[@supriyapan2276]

Even Chamunda mata is there as a protecter deity, and the iconography of Chamunda devi there is as described in tantra shastras।

[@vishnur3035]

In Phalashruti of Durga Sapthashati, balipuja is recommended. Maa is Balipriya. Period. No place for virtue signalling sentiments.

[@arjundeb2440]

😂😂😂 offer your flesh and blood as bali. Can you?😂

[@godfather2078]

​@@arjundeb2440 We don't hai any problem in offering goat.Tujhe itni chull machi hai tho ek bakra ki jagah khud kat ja ek bakra ko bacha le

[@aishikextra2243]

@@arjundeb2440 Education is important read the scriptures then bark.

[@arjundeb2440]

@@aishikextra2243 i dont bark i roar. You need to stop oinking like a pig. Stop watching p%rn in the name of tantra and read scriptures. Brain ko thik kar beti

[@vishaldasgupta4573]

Indeed Devi is Bali Homa Priya ❤

[@shubhamsutradhar5835]

What a perfect explanation by sir... 🙏

[@joyshreesinghal5150]

People from erstwhile East Bengal, present day Bangladesh are very much aware about the injunctions of balividhan in Shakta texts. Our Kuladevis of that region used to be offered Bali regularly in Ashwin Durga Pujo of goats and buffalo. They have a much nuanced and expanded perspective on the subject of pashu bali. Learn from them. They are more rooted to Shakta shastras

[@zarinewadia5395]

True!

[@raghuch1]

I wish to see bali pratha revived sooner & with full fervor in those peethas and kshetras wherever it is mandated per shastras

[@supriyapan2276]

Rightly said

[@sudbn]

similar in Nepal as well

[@subhadip_Singha999]

east bengal people why weaker people than ? they ran away while the time of defending , most secular anti religion person came from east bengal .. we donot need to learn from them ,,, we are rarhi bengalis we have rooted shakta shatras as well as famous sadhakas like ramkrishnadeb, sadhak byamdeb, swami vivekananda ,,, and also famous vaishnaba shastra chaytanna pravu , iskcon , gauriya vaishnab too ... learn from us rarh bengal ,, rarhi bengalis ... and not from bangladesi bengalis even they also learned from rooted rarh bengal

[@psyddharth]

Mahāmāhēśvara Abhinavagupta deals with paśu bali in his Tantrālōka. Jayaratha raises the question concerning the position of the sheep that is to be slaughtered. ‘Now we have accepted that paśu yāga (animal sacrifice) on this occasion is divine, but still, to cut the throat of a paśu on that occasion is always disliked by the sheep. He will not like it since cutting his throat is not a joke’. To this objection, Abhinavagupta puts forth this answer: ‘This is great blessing and great help that you cut his throat on this occasion. This is a great service to this paśu. No matter if he will not like it at the time of slaughtering, it will not be appreciated by that sheep’. To clarify, Abhinavagupta gives the following example. When you are overwhelmed with some peculiar disease, the doctor prescribes a mixture and fasting; but fasting you don’t appreciate, mixture also you don’t appreciate because it is not sweet, it is sour. But this is a great service to that diseased being. So this is a kind of drug we are giving the sheep, and this drug is a terrible mixture for getting rid of the disease of rebirths - birth and death, birth and death, in continuity.’ Jayaratha then raises the following objection: “If it is true that by cutting his throat he will be liberated, then what is the purpose, what is the sense, what is the meaning in initiation then? You just cut his throat and he will be liberated. Why undergo all these cycles of procedures of rituals, just cut his throat and he will be liberated’. In answer to this objection, Abhinavagupta quotes from the śāstras: ‘In Mṛtyuñjaya Tantra (Netra Tantra), in the section of pāśaccheda it is said by Lord Shiva - when you cut the bindings of an individual to liberate him from repeated births and deaths, at that precious moment, āṇava, māyīya and kārma malas are also removed along with his body. So, he will not come into this wretched cycle of existence again, he will not be born again - because when both good and bad karma are exhausted, then there is no question of birth again. So this is not slaughtering the sheep, we are initiating the sheep, this is one way of dīkṣā.

[@zarinewadia5395]

Beautifully written.. Absolutely true!

[@myselfdivine2503]

Bakwas

[@supriyapan2276]

Yes you are right, Ugravajra.

[@BJha-bc2li]

Proud to be Maithili shakta ✨

[@khuchisingh3630]

Hlo, i want to take diksha in mithila shakta paramparq, can u plz enlighten me abt this.

[@BJha-bc2li]

@@khuchisingh3630 you may ask a Maithil Brahmin pandit .

[@tusharsharma5200]

I'm from UP. And In my Clan and in the entire ancestral lineage. Since 18th century. As per the records. We Do Durga Puja with Vaishanav Padhatti and we are prohibited for using Vam paddhati for Puja. Vam padhhati is allowed only in tantrik families. But in Pandits it's a sin. Tantra yantra mantra. Power is equally gained in form of siddhi with both methods.

[@chaitaliroy9630]

Exactly

[@vishaldasgupta4573]

Did u said in pandit families is prohibited . Come to Bengal and east or go to Kerela or for that matter ur north Kashmiri pandits . Shaktas have to schools or shakas one is Kalikula Shakta Sampradaya the other is Srikula Shakta Sampradaya . In Kalikula Goddesses Rajrajashree Tripura Sundari or Kali Tara is mulashita Devi and pashu Bali is an integral part of it be you from any clan or Varna . In Srikula Devi Lalita Parameshswari or Lakshmi is Mulashita Devi and you can worship her in dakshinachar vidhi by offering Bali of Coconut or kushmanda.

[@tusharsharma5200]

@@vishaldasgupta4573 We know till the extend of What it is taught by our forefathers... Not more than that..I accept. It can be possible in other parts of the country.. I'm saying. Bali of an Animal is not necessary.. bali in form of flower,coconut or any other natural element is constructed... Animal sacrifice is not compulsory... Rest. Those who do that...can do..

[@vishaldasgupta4573]

@@tusharsharma5200 that's what I wrote there are two shakas in Srikula Shakta Sampradaya dakshinachar vidhi you can offer coconut or kudhmanda ( white gourd) in Bali but in Kalikula Shakta Vamachar Vidhan pashu Bali is an integral part as the same is mentioned in our Shashtras and puranas. In Kalika Puran and Devi Mahatmya , Chandi paath there are chapters called Rudhiradhyay where specification of animals and rituals , weapons used are given in description . It is a hypocrisy for a majority of even non vegetarian people within Hindu society to oppose Bali . We can't be above our Shashtras , the Vaishnav interference of one God supremacy , one way of worship one book is a deterrent to the very basic concept of Sanatana where there are major 6 sampradayas and each has their own way of worship n rituals .

[@dipanchakrabarty1789]

See my brother, as per my knowledge, it is almost unnecessary thing to use any method in worshipping, methods are given by scholars and people like us, no God have ever told these ways or Vidhis. We follow vidhis blindly as they are the only way to do puja, but no!! If the person is fully engaged in the deep connection with the devine needs no vidhi Or rituals to be performed. Specially if it consists Vali Or animal sacrifice. Because No Devi or Devta has told people to give animal sacrifice, the whole creation is divine, so how the supreme allow one part to be sacrificed. But man has invented sacrifice because of our avidya Or illusion. We do a lot of unwanted things and forbidden actions which further influences us to give sacrifice, as a means of getting rid of those paap Or Sins. So it's under human nature, and the best sacrifice is renouncing all worldly affairs, attachments and our greed, violence, to keep the mind tremendously calm and dwell in the emptyness so that divine can come into existence. To kill a life is never a sacrifice but a great deal of Crime. Animal sacrifice and Vidhis are made by men, invented by humans but Bhakti and creation is Universal. It is beyond methods, ways or patterns.

[@DoraNobi24]

Sukoon milta hai apne sanskaar apne bhagwan ke bare me jaan ke... Jai mata Di... Keep growing keep giving cultural devine information

[@ambrishkotak436]

I likee Rajshi sir brilliant you're very honest about tantra accept the way it is or just dnt expect the results 🙏

[@gaurabbarman3218]

Hi Ranveer I am from Assam Guwahati and I would love if you could come to Guwahati during Durga Puja so that I can show you the power of Bali Vidhan. I would love to show you the power Mata has over our people the emotion linked with her . The energy she provides us .

[@vishaldasgupta4573]

Take him to Billeswar Debalay during Durga Puja .

[@adityabhardwaj1952]

Please discuss on Maa Bhairavi and her various manifestations.

[@vijayakatoch2715]

In uttarakhand, we have lot of devi, devta s who require bali. We consider it very pious.

[@shounakchaudhry7384]

In 21st century you supporting? You have so cruel heart? How ? You want if your child would be sacrificed infront of God or you ?

[@wilee.coyotegenius7998]

Gai ka Bali v dia jata hai?

[@superatanu7]

​@@wilee.coyotegenius7998no mahish ki

[@रहस्य369]

मैं उत्तराखंड से हू वहां गंगोलीहाट नामक जगह है जहाँ महाकाली का मुख्य मंदिर है जिसमे युगो से बकरे की बलि दी जा रही है अभी कुछ समय पहले वहां पशुबली रोक दी ग्यी dm के आदेश पर उसके बाद से वहां देवी प्रकोप इतना बढ़ गया प्राकृतिक आपदाएँ बाघ द्वारा इंसानों पर हमले और पहाड़ो का टूटना सब अचानक से शुरू गया और तब जाके dm को लोगो के भारी विरोध के बाद आदेश वापस लेना पढ़ गया उसके बाद सब नॉर्मल हो गया .. अगर देवी देवता को बलि नहीं चाहिए होती तो ये क्या था?ऐसे सैकड़ो वाक्ये और भी हैँ 😎 जैसे इंसान हैँ वैसे ही देवी देवता भी हैँ तामसिक देवता भी है और सात्विक देवता भी सबको अपना भोग लगता है यहाँ हिस्ट्री से इन देवताओं को समझना मुश्किल ही नहीं नामुमकिन है उत्तराखंड पूरा शाक्त और शैव उपासको का एरिया है यहाँ देविय चमत्कार और देविय प्रकोप दोनों आम बात है 😎 यहाँ प्रसाद के रूप मे बकरे का मीट दिया जाता है हर किसी को. जो भी सांसारिक इच्छाओ की पूर्ति के लिए बलि देते हैँ इन देवताओं को वो उनकी इच्छाएं पुरी करते हैँ देवी देवताओं की पूजा का मोक्ष से कोई लेना देना नहीं इसीलिए भगवदगीता मे कहा गया है एक मात्र निर्गुण परमात्मा की शरण लेने को वो सब गुणों से परे है भगवदगीता मे सब देवताओ की उपासना और उनका फल साफ साफ बता दिया गया है सत्व गुनी उपासक सत्व देवताओं को प्राप्त होते हैँ रजो गुनी उपासक पितरो को पाते हैँ और तामसिक उपासक तामसिक देवताओं और भूत प्रेतो को प्राप्त होते हैँ लेकिन सभी देवी देवता और उनके लोक पुनरावृति हैँ नाशवान हैँ किन्तु जो मुमुक्षु ज्ञानी होते हैँ वो केवल मोक्ष की ओर जाते हैँ और ब्रह्म को प्राप्त होते हैँ इसीलिए मनुष्य तीनो गुणों से ऊपर उठ कर केवल निरगुण परमात्मा की शरण गति ले 😎इसके लिए कर्म योग से ज्ञान योग और ज्ञान योग से भक्ति योग की ओर जाने का निर्देश दिया गया है भक्ति का अर्थ किसी साकार रूप या नाम की भक्ति नहीं बल्कि पूर्ण समर्पण से है केवल निर्गुण परमात्मा की. इसीलिए ध्यान का मार्ग ही परमात्मा का मार्ग है जिसे जीवन को सफल करना है वो परमात्मा के मार्ग पर जाये जिसे सांसारिक इच्छाओ की पूर्ति करनी है वो देवताओं के मार्ग पर जाये सबको अपनी स्वतंत्रता दी गयी है 😎

[@रहस्य369]

​@@wilee.coyotegenius7998नहीं बकरे की केवल. तांत्रिक लोग मुर्गे की देते हैँ

[@bimalbarui]

Joi Maa Tara.

[@bedantachakrabortty3564]

Visited so many time specially two times in Ambubasi 🙏 Lots of love from Assam ...

[@joyshreesinghal5150]

Even till my great grandfather's time the eldest male of our family used to offer two male chhag balis on sandhi kaal of Ashwin Durga Pujo. Then Bengal got divided and many families had to leave everything behind. Yet they succeeded to pass on to their progeny the understanding and the necessity of pashu bali. We never let our education interfere with our understanding and our respect for Dharmam and Dharma and Shastras are above cheap sentiments for us always. The way they should be 🙏🏼

[@bishalbhattacharya1285]

Most of our Modern 'Sanatani' youths do not understand the meaning of Pashu Bali and end up with emotions. Bali is Very Important in Shakta Kalikul sect. Shakta granth like Kalika puran and Tantras have depper and high level knowledge which cannot be percieved easily by normal ppl. Tantra is not a random day to day life factor to be understood. Jayatu Balipriya. Jayatu Madyamansapriya Kaivalyadayini Kaalika.

[@bishalbhattacharya1285]

Although Bhagavat puran and Brahmavaivart Puran says Bali to be banned in Kaliyug but it is only restricted to Vaishnavs and normal Grihasta Adikshit Sanatani ppl. In the age of Kali , Only tantra provides correct method of Bali and only Shaktas can give it. Nice to know that your family still continued the culture. When Bamakhepa and Kamalkanta themselves don't have problem with Vamachar practices, then who these lily white Satvik ppl are to stop Bali.

[@pkmishra6763]

Thankyou 🙏🙏

[@supriyapan2276]

​@@bishalbhattacharya1285 absolutely

[@supriyapan2276]

💯

[@sunainasharma3557]

100 percent right bola hein bali ki bishayme

[@soumensenapati9287]

Proud to be Bengali Shakta...Joy Maa Tara 🙏🏼

[@xtremes19]

Our scriptures have always referred to Balividhan and till few decades nobody used to question the Bali Ritual. Following are few references: 12th chapter of Chandipaath/Durga Saptasathi: "jānatājānatā vāpi bali pūjāṃ tathā kṛtām। pratīkṣiṣyāmyahaṃ prītyā vahni hōmaṃ tathā kṛtam ॥11॥" Meaning: When bali and puja is offered to Durga with or without knowledge of rituals it is still accepted by the Goddess Herself** Also in other references Vyasa discusses the issue of animal sacrifice near the end of Adhyaya 3 Pada 1 of the Brahma Sutras: If it be argued that rites (invoking killing of animals) are unholy, we say, no, since they are sanctioned by scriptures. And all the commentators I have come across take this to be a statement that animal sacrifice is not immoral and does not generate bad karma. This is what Adi Shankaracharya says about this in his Advaita commentary on the Brahma Sutras: "We proceed to refute the remark made by the pûrvapakshin that sacrificial works are unholy because involving harm done to animals ... Now from scripture we derive the certain knowledge that the gyotishtoma-sacrifice, which involves harm done to animals (i.e. the animal sacrifice), &c., is an act of duty; how then can it be called unholy?--But does not the scriptural precept, 'Do not harm any creature,' intimate that to do harm to any being is an act contrary to duty?--True, but that is a general rule, while the precept, 'Let him offer an animal to Agnîshomau,' embodies an exception; and general rule and exception have different spheres of application." Reference: www.sacred-texts.com/hin/sbe38/sbe38101.htm

[@zarinewadia5395]

Well researched and well said

[@sethuraman1242]

This is how one must make a discussion and inform. It is useful. thank you.

[@go_go1]

You completely missed the mark because in Durga shaptashati it clearly mentioned that the flesh of asura is what she feeds upon and drink the blood of asura as offering. And it is our animalistic tendencies that have to be offered to mahamaya Literal translation will never work and shastra can be challenged that's what Budha had to do when he saw all the stuff happening around him

[@rinkypatnaik1990]

Absolutely dear..woh bahut hi bada universal secret hai..it is completely pious..

[@rinkypatnaik1990]

Thanks for sharing this brilliant piece of information..Adi shankracharya is absouletly right..

[@abhishekbhattacharjee9486]

The greatest Kali bhakt of all time was Shri Ramakrishna Paramhansa. He never supported nor gave any bali of animal. He had tremendous kindness for all animals. Once he cried and said someone is beating me with stick, a cow's calf was hit by a stick, he could feel that calf's pain in his own body. Bali is ethically very very wrong.

[@ruchira7444]

Thakur Ramakrishna may or not have given bali But show any record to prove he was against Bali vidhan.. Devatas do not gv a damn about Your opinion .. A person may be averse to bali but who gives him the right to dictate his likes n dislikes. Don't like bali dont give, who asked you.. But dare you challenge shashtras.. NO human is above divine n shashtras Forget devata, try to stop the religion of peace people from butchering cows.. It's their form of bali.. Empty hollow lectures are only for Hindus because we do not do sar tan se juda if one dares to speak nonsense. But if a person claims to be a Hindu then atleast respect the deities and all those rituals attached to them. Instead of being a hypocrite hindu. Jai Ma Kamakhya 🙏

[@soch1110]

Absolutely.

[@koushikghar4150]

Please quote your reference-that ramakrishna paramhansa did not support sacrifice. Also a priest (purohit) does not give the bali, so ramkrishna -who was the priest at dakshineswar,did not give the bali himself.

[@abhishekbhattacharjee3904]

Dakshineswar Mandir use to have Bali Vidhan, Shri Ramakrishna Paramhansa asked the people to stop this pratha. But I still believe that in Shakti Puja Bali Vidhan is necessary.

[@utkarshyadava2488]

Also stop consuming animals alright ?

[@abhinavslathia]

You are not become a doormat. Well said! 🔥

[@bhairavakripa]

The importance and significance of Bali (sacrificial ritual) as compiled in our shastras (scriptures) cannot and should not be ignored. For our dharma to sustain, shastras are the pramanas (standard authority) and not what you feel in your own antaratma. There are references in Vedas on its importance and has clear specification on how to offer Bali of specific animals for specific rituals, how it helps in ascendance of the jiva of those animals as they get released from pashu yoni (lower births) and attain higher births (like that of a cow or human being). Rajarshi ji’s reference of kalika puran and several other tantra shastras clearly emphasize the importance of ritualistic sacrifice when it is required to propitiate certain fierce form of devatas whose inherent nature is not sattvic but either rajasic or tamasic in their projection for a sadhaka to appease or even to have communication with that devatha. Where Bali involving animal sacrifice is not needed or rather one should abstain from offering it is with regards to sattvic devathas (sri rama, tirupathi balaji, maa saraswati as such examples). Even for these devathas, you will observe that the temples have specific places near the dhwaja sthambham where bali is offered regularly. Here is one more clear example of what chandrasekharendra sarasvati swami mentioned about animal sacrifices in bali. Hindu Dharma, The Universal Way of Life: Voice of Guru - Pujyasri Chandrasekharendra Sarasvati Swami (Part V - The Vedas, Chapter 23: Is Sacrificial Killing Justified?) QUOTE: In the concluding passage of the Chandogya Upanishad where ahimsa or non-violence is extolled you find these words, "Anyatra tirthebhyah". It means ahimsa must be practised except with regard to Vedic rites. Considerations of violence have no place in sacrifices and the conduct of war. If the ideal of non-violence were superior to the performance of sacrifices, it would mean that "sacrifices are good but non-violence is better". The performance of a thousand sacrifices must be spoken of highly but the practice of non-violence is to be regarded as even higher: It is in this sense that the Kural stanza concerning sacrifices is to be interpreted. We must not also forget that it occurs in the section on renunciation. What the poet want to convey is that a sanyasin does better by abstaining from killing than a householder does by conducting a thousand sacrifices. According to the sastras also a sanyasin has no right to perform sacrifices. There are several types of sacrifices. I shall speak about them later when I deal with "Kalpa" (an Anga or limb of the Vedas) aaand "Grihasthasrama" (the stage of the householder). What I wish to state here is that animals are not killed in all sacrifices. There are a number of yagnas in which only ghee (ajya) is offered in the fire. In some, havisyanna (rice mixed with ghee) is offered and in some the cooked grains called "caru" or "purodasa", a kind of baked cake. In agnihotri milk is poured into the fire; in aupasana unbroken rice grains (aksata) are used; and in samidadhana the sticks of the palasa (flame of the forest). In sacrifices in which the vapa of animals is offered, only a tiny bit of the remains of the burnt offering is partaken of - and of course in the form of prasada. One is enjoined to perform twenty-one sacrifices. These are of three types:pakayajna, haviryajna and somayajna. In each category there are seven subdivisions. In all the seven pakayajnas as well as in the first five haviryajnas there is no animal sacrifice. It is only from the sixth haviryajna onwards (it is called "nirudhapasubandha") that animals are sacrificed. "Brahmins sacrificed herds and herds of animals and gorged themselves on their meat. The Buddha saved such herds when they were being taken to the sacrificial altar, " we often read such accounts in books. To tell the truth, there is no sacrifice in which a large number of animals are killed. For vajapeya which is the highest type of yajna performed by Brahmins, only twenty-three animals are mentioned. For asvamedha (horse sacrifice), the biggest of the sacrifices conducted by imperial rulers, one hundred animals are mentioned. It is totally false to state that Brahmins performed sacrifices only to satisfy their appetite for meat and that the talk of pleasing the deities was only a pretext. There are rules regarding the meat to be carved out from a sacrificial animal, the part of the body from which it is to be taken and the quantity each rtvik can partake of as prasada (idavatarana). This is not more than the size of a pigeon-pea and it is to be swallowed without anything added to taste. There may be various reasons for you to attack the system of sacrifices but it would be preposterous to do so on the score that Brahmins practised deception by making them a pretext to eat meat. Nowadays a large number of animals are slaughtered in the laboratories as guinea-pigs. Animal sacrifices must be regarded as a little hurt caused in the cause of a great ideal, the welfare of mankind. As a matter of fact there is no hurt caused since the animal sacrificed attains to an elevated state. UNQUOTE

[@raghuch1]

Well said!

[@khanaksharma4923]

Can ya'll please suggest some good books related to such topics

[@nischalghimire5186]

From nepal🇳🇵🇳🇵and we have that tradition of Pashu Bali in Asthami of the navratri Whereas as much I'm concerned people do fast and even don't touch tamsik in India during dussera that is 'dashain' in nepal People here gives bali in Asthami and enjoy meat during this time

[@sinyuv]

For all those who are placing sentiment and namby pamby emotions above scripture , here are one of the two greatest seers, Ramanujacharya and Madhavacharya have to say about Bali Vidhan. here is what Ramanujacharya says in the Sri Bhashya, his commentary on the Brahma Sutras: it is not so, on account of scriptural statement. For Scripture declares that the killing of sacrificial animals makes them to go up to the heavenly world, and therefore is not of the nature of harm. This is declared in the text, 'The animal killed at the sacrifice having assumed a divine body goes to the heavenly world'; 'with a golden body it ascends to the heavenly world.' An action which is the means of supreme exaltation is not of the nature of harm, even if it involves some little pain; it rather is of beneficial nature.--With this the mantra also agrees: 'Thou dost not die, thou goest to the gods on easy paths; where virtuous men go, not evil-doers, there the divine Savitri may lead thee.' An act which has a healing tendency, although it may cause a transitory pain, men of insight declare to be preservative and beneficial. 0:02 And here's what Madhvacharya says in this excerpt from his Dvaita commentary on the Brahma Sutras: It may be said that sacrificial work involves injury to life, and as such it is productive of sin and consequently of misery, and that, therefore, it is not to be performed. But this objection is to be refuted on the ground that the injury to life involved in holy duties is permitted by the word (scripture); for the Varahapurana says, "To do harm to any life except as enjoined by scripture is really productive of sin and evil consequences; on the other hand, no evil consequences possibly arise from the act of killing permitted by the Vedas."

[@neilkamalseal3413]

I will not listen to you, not these acharyas, and definitely not vedas when it comes to Tantra Shastra. Vedacharya is the primary level. There are puja where Bali is not even physically done. Just the animal is sacrificed with mantra. That animal will be dead in few hours. Who took the life???

[@sangishsharma5610]

​@@neilkamalseal3413 bro kabhi aapne puja mai nariyal ko poadte dekha hai wo b bali hi hote hai. Or mai himachal se hu. Professionaly mai ek electrical engineer hu par sath mai mai ek pujari hu devi ambika ka apne yhan pe bakra jab tak khud nai kehta bali k liye tak bali nai li jaate.

[@neilkamalseal3413]

@@sangishsharma5610 Eastern India, primarily Bengal and Assam and Nepal jaha pe shakt mat se tantrik puja hote hai, yaha har kism ka bali hai. Veg, Non Veg, And Extreme. Veg me hamare ganna, kaddu , ye sab bali dia jata hai. Non veg me it starts with pegion, then goats and finally buffaloes. Depends on how strong u want the worship force. Finally extreme is where u give bali of urself. Tantrik shastra me there are tantriks who give own blood also.

[@marinasharma782]

HAR HAR MAHADEV Thankyou Be Blessed stay blessed be happy and keep everyone happy God bless you

[@supriyapan2276]

বলির কথা তন্ত্র শাস্ত্রে সুস্পষ্ট ভাবে বর্ণিত আছে, এমন কি মহাকাল ভৈরব দক্ষিণা কালী স্তত্রম এ "মুক্তকেশী বলিপ্রিয়ে" স্পষ্ট বর্ণনা করেছেন।

[@edwardjhon180]

Arya Samaj says Vedas says Bali is not required etc etc 😑

[@wonji5385]

@@edwardjhon180 because arya samaj is vedic. shiva and sakti is tantric.

[@bishalbhattacharya1285]

Jayatu Balipriya. Jay Shakta Mahadharma

[@Life_race1991]

তাই যদি হতো তাহলে ঠাকুর শ্রী রামকৃষ্ণ দক্ষিনেশ্বর মন্দির এ বলির ব্যবস্থা করতেন। মা তো স্বয়ং তার হাতে খেতেন। কিন্তু কোই তিনি তো কোনোদিন বলির কথা বলেন নি।।

[@Life_race1991]

Bali is not mandatory.. If it was then Sree Ramkrishna Paramhansh would also mention it to his disciples and would have started Bali in Dakshineshwar Temple.

[@priyamtalukdar5845]

जय माँ कामाख्या , मुण्डमाला बीभुसिते नारायणी नमस्तेस्तु 🚩🚩🚩❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@santuchatterjee823]

I know this story but I heard it for Tarapith and there is a small temple near cremation ground of Vasishh muni as well

[@harshsnehi8952]

Maa bhagwati trigunatmik shakti hai or maa ki puja tamsik तरह से भी होती है कालिका puran , durga saptshati, devi bhagwat, mundamala tantra.. Etc me btaya bhi gya hai bali ke baare m . Aise bahut mandir hai jaha pr parsad me nonveg diya jata hai jaise tarapith m parshad me fish dete h or bhi aise mandir hai . Pashu bali sahi विधि से और एक ही झटके मे होनी चाहिये नही तो pap lgta hai or pashu ko pashu yoni se mukti milti hai maa bali priya hai maa ko sirf satvikta m nhi baandhskte lekin apne taste ke liye khana galat hai . Jai maa kamakhya kali.🔱

[@SantuSharn-eo4lb]

Jay ma kamakha

[@deepayandutta5748]

Randikamakhya

[@neeb2004]

Just basically it's difficult to fully understand Sanatan dharma, or can say next to impossible. It will make u question ur ideas, beliefs, what's right n wrong, but in the end there'll still be more to be discovered. It's something almost beyond human capacity to comprehend, hence just flow in, just mix in it.

[@Vegetasinghyadav]

In my family kali pooja is taken quite seriously. I m from western UP. And by family i mean whole family. The big family, in which u know ur 3rd and 4th cousin as well. Like we cd easily connect with each other through our great great grand father.....for such a normal farmer family ,,,it was quite astonishing for me. So i m modern educated person. Once i attended this kali pooja in my village. Literally the whole village participated becoz its a yadav village. I was shocked to see a real sacrifice. Then everyone doing something. Like they know what to do. If u ask them why they doing, they say they dont know. Thats how ancestors did. One fascinating thing is , they cook it and then whole family eat it like its a prasad. And mind u this is a custom in the family where majority are strict vegeterians. So on that day, everyone has to consume the prasad. Women wd just taste it formally. Few men wd eat it properly. I also tasted non veg first time there. Some people hav just oversimplified our culture. Our culture is so great and advance that they know on certain lower levels everything is a taboo and on certain higher levels nothing is a taboo. The concept of good and bad , divine and evil , everything is everywhere all at once. And nothing is black amd white. Its all grey. From that day i hav kept an open mind. I learned that its foolish to conclude things and pass absolute statements abt anything becoz we dont know anything COMPLETELY. So its really ignorant to pass judgements abt a practice just becoz u concluded in ur little ignorant mind that its animal cruelty. The priest knew me personally so i asked him respectfully the same thing, isnt it wrong to kill innocent animals for devi worship. He said: " tell me does nature kills thousands of humans and animals in a day when it wants??? Yes. So is nature murdering innocent people? Can ur law put nature behind bars ?? The. He laughs.... He added: " every animal that dies in such a manner in a proper sacrifice ritual done by advance worshippers, is immediately confirmed to get a human life" To ur eyes it was cruelty, to that animal's soul, it was blessing

[@dikshasingh66]

Just like how Muslims defend by saying ki jannat me hoor milengi. And on the name of jihad, they kill and convert stating that Allah asked them to grant peace to kaafirs. It’s okay to have religious beliefs, but only till the time you know the truth to the core. Till the time goddess doesn’t ask you to perform something or shows you how the animal’s soul will achieve moksha or how’s the animal being sacrificed is going to repeat the process of birth or how the animal was meant for this sacrifice or the Devi herself doesn’t clear doubts and ignorances, it’s tough for me to stand by this process. I need to know the truth or I must build immense trust on the goddess to do this process. I love Hinduism but animal slaughter and standing by it without understanding the core is something that I can’t agree upon. I have utmost trust on Maa Kali but not on the people who do the upaasna. And if animal sacrifice is that important then why did Ramakrishna not support this? He was one of the biggest upasaks.

[@sevati-sn7nk]

Tum ne Dekha hai ?? Don't believe blindly in all theses things ....read bhagavat Geeta ...words of the lord himself

[@deb2607]

​@@sevati-sn7nkBhagawat Gita is a Yogashastra specifically meant for Yogis. It says nothing against forms of worship.

[@deb2607]

​​@@sevati-sn7nkLord or Bhagwan in unmanifest form is Nirgun Nirakar(formless and attributeless) Paramatma. While in manifest form Bhagwan is Ishwar and Ishwari which are both inseperable. Ishwari of Ishwar is called Shakti and in Shakti worship Bali vidhan is approved.

[@sevati-sn7nk]

@@deb2607 yes ....but he can take form too and he doesn't want us to kill an innocent animal for him...all these sacrifice stuff are idiotic

[@rh2400]

9:42 that's actually "Ash gourd".

[@sanu1231000]

In bengal, women don't handle even household Chal Kumro (Ash Gourd). Evertime my mom had to cut a ash gourd, he use to ask my father to do it. If my father was somehow not around, she use to ask me to give the initial cut.

[@ashishanmolsahoo9316]

Yes in odisha too... same goes for my family and if she has to cut then she first smash the ash gourd on the ground then after it broke she used to cut it... it's also same in case of pumpkin

[@nameisAjaykumar96]

I think i am blessed i visited kakakhiya tempel last year nd going for Maa ki darshan next month 🙏 jay maa kamakhiya

[@mrgupta8863]

For those protesting against bali on emotional/moral grounds, few logical points to think about: 1. Everyday BILLIONS (100s of crores) of animals are killed for human consumption. On top of that, a lot of that meat is wasted. Imagine an animal dying only to end up in trash. 2. Who says nature/God is compassionate all the time. Compassion is one of the attributes of God / Nature but not the only attribute. In this Nature itself animals kill and eat other animals including newborns, eggs, etc. Nature runs by rules and violent deaths are part and parcel of that system. 3. Animal's pleading eyes dekhi nahin jati - hey guys grow up. There are hundreds of pleading human/animal eyes all around you everyday. Pay attention to them as well. Most likely you are a soft urban cocooned child who has not been exposed to the harsh realities of everyday life. You will faint if you see a surgery being performed. 4. Why all this gyan only for Sanatanis? Mulla ko bhi samjhao na eid par kaatna band karein! 5. Ugra devatas require ugra bhog. Some deities are pleased by fruits, but others require meat. Why should this be so shocking to understand? And who are ugra devatas? Somebody you would worship for victory in a war. Wars are won when the fighter has killer animal instincts, naturally the devatas also have to be like that. To access their krupa for victory, you have to please them by offering what they want. Imagine pitting a khichri-eating waifish Indian football team against a meat-eating solid muscle European team! You get the idea! These are purely logical arguments. In addition, bali is approved by numerous authoritative scriptures written by the most learned and wise rishis. To question or mock them and implying that we have become wiser or more civilised them, is a laughable notion. If anything, humans of today are just a fraction of the ancients in every possible way.

[@xtremes19]

Perfectly put. Hope people think more about it logically along with the vidhaans given in our Shastras to understand the reasonings for Bali

[@mrgupta8863]

Esp non-vegetarians protesting against bali is height of hypocrisy!

[@mrgupta8863]

And vegetarian folks should spend their energies on first converting non-veg ppl to veg.

[@zarinewadia5395]

Agree sir! Well said!

[@mrgupta8863]

Hindus have got their priorities completely wrong.

[@punambarman4871]

Infact we do not eat chalkumro during durga pujo and kali pujo,,,,

[@sweatswirlstudies]

thankku rajarshi ji for speaking so beautifully on bali pratha, nowadays people have been brainwashed and its sad to see that people are drifting apart from their roots, however, we do need people who not only support one stream of dharma but its every branch from tantras to aghoris and respect everything. We don't have the knowledge or means to understand the concepts so we need to stop entertaining those who raise questions on bail.

[@Facts_bookss]

Shristi Stati Vinashanam Shakti Rupen Sanatani 💓

[@debayanchakrabarty4089]

Rajarshi Da apnar fan hoye jachhi ❤️🙏Jay maa Tara 🙏

[@Annvhay-wz5kz]

meine 1 jagah par padha tha ki Bali dena matlab insaan me jo ripu ( negativity like greed, lust etc.)hai usko bali do ... Devi devta khud aake nhi bola tha ki mujhe pashu bali chaiye... ye Shastra insaan ko kahi rachit hai insaan nehi iss bali ka pratha chalu kiya tha... iska bhi ek history hai..... prachin yug me log bher bakri palte the aur fasal ugate the..bakri sare fasal kha jata tha.. Animal quantity bahut zyda hota tha... tab logo ne socha tha ki inka ishwar ke naam pe bali charahte hai ( kyunki tab log andh bhakt the) tab se ye bali pratha chalu hua... aur isko shastra ka naam de diya 🙄...

[@sridharachanda8347]

reference please

[@krutarthmakavana9451]

Fir jab muslim har saal laakho bakriyo ko marte he tab Teri Gand kyu fatti he? Tab kyu nahi bolte muslim ko

[@Annvhay-wz5kz]

@@krutarthmakavana9451 duniya mein bahot sare gand hai kisi ek ki gand fatti se kuch nahi hota.. aapko zyda fatt raha hai toh.. Awaz hutao.. Meine jo jana padha wo bola... aap koi aitraaz hai toh bhar me jao..

[@kanyakumari610]

@@Annvhay-wz5kz Aapne padhna nahi hai Bhai !! Aisa kahi nahi likha aapne apna Logic laga Diya ,Aap bologe Devi Devta Kiyun mangenge,Sabhi Devi Devtao ke Sath specially tantrik Devi devtao ke Sath Yogniyan matrika hoti hai ,Jinhe Bali di jati hai aur yehi Bali mangti hai aur na di jaay to Tumhara hi khoon pi le ,Kiyunki jinke yaha par bhi Bali hoti hai devi ko Vachan Diya jata hai ki Har saal chadhega,Isliye Agar kisi ek Saal na do Jaan buijh kar To paaka us Ghar me ulte fulte hone lagte hai mere Khud ke Ghar me yeh practice hoti hai ,jinke yaha nahi hota bolna aasan hota hai ,

[@Annvhay-wz5kz]

@@kanyakumari610 ladka nhi ladki hu... meine koi logic nhi lageya... Google or book padhlo.. Tantrik me bali important hai jnti hu mein..

[@sauravkumar-fm7nw]

Thank you sir incredible knowledge❤

[@joyshreesinghal5150]

Neo organisationa like Arya Samaj etc. have caused a lot of havoc in the sphere of understanding of shastras correctly. They project a half baked understanding of everything they think is Dharma and expect the world to bow to that. Traditional texts and sampradays always ha e an answer and it is them that should be approached to have a correct picture of what is what. Sentiments exist in the realm of humans. Not on the plane of the divine. There life is looked at very differently and in your comprehension, pretty mercilessly

[@bishalbhattacharya1285]

not to missout ISKCON who say all dogshit information regarding Bali and Shakti pooja.

[@bibhachoubey545]

Why to go only after Arya samaj. Even Shankaracharya did the same, much before Arya samaj. Arya samaj infact has undo many things, bought awareness among the masses, when people were promoting dharmshashtra in the name of vedas. Especially regarding prohibiting women during menstruation in any religious activities.

[@sameersachdeva9100]

You both are idiots...

[@abhinay4200]

Correct ,Arya samaj is neo organization .All Hindus must convert to Buddhism

[@kankanjyotipatgiri7390]

Jai Maa Kamakhya🙏 proud Assamese love from Assam ❤

[@Joyboii1]

In buddhism also there is a anecdote where sage gets akashvani to re do their sadhana again in correct ways…. In nepal Guru rinpoche and shiva they have lots of same pilgrimage and people treat them as one. It’s him guru rinpoche who brought and taugh tantra in tibetan buddhsim and he is said to be in this world till date.

[@deeptirabha8886]

Here in South, you see the lemon and Chaal- kumro/ Ash- gourd (Hindi mein Raakh Lauki- patthe jisse banta hai) bahut..kahein toh daily shop- keepers log use kartey hain...nimbu/ lemon kaat ke kumkum aur ash- gourd par Kumkum, haldi- chandan lagakar naariyal ki tarah phodte hain, Before coming to South, only knew about sugarcane and coconut ki bali as an Assamese! WOWWW, after internet have come to learn so many facts...gained knowledge about our civilization and Sanskritis/ traditions!!! Amazed at the vastness and depth!!!

[@ThapaBackyardFarm]

Woh toh apka nazar aur burii aala bala utarne ke kaam aata hai.

[@dronzerdanks7163]

As a semi rural guy from Bengal, I have deep respect for Bali pratha. When I was young my father used to bring the meat Prasad from nearby Maa Manasa temple Bali. We had it with great affection for Maa. Later on this invoked a sense of gratitude and respect for non veg food in me and whenever I consume non veg, I do it with gratitude for the creature which laid its life to feed me.

[@priyadwivedi1860]

Bali is always done by illiterate people. Have u seen Ambani, Adani, yogi, Amitabh Bacchan or any famous personalities viral, Ronaldo etc etc No one performs Bali Pratha and they are more Rich and Happy than we Idiots who perform Bali... Now it totally clear who believes in God's worship without hurting anyone are more Blessed

[@ancientminds199]

​​@@priyadwivedi1860I've seen Ronaldo do it

[@Anonymous-sf4hw]

​@@priyadwivedi1860your amitabh bachchan's family is nonveg. When yogi ji came in Bengal only few people recognized him. Your up was ruled by mughals. Hinduism is completely flawed there. So don't give lectures about hinduism. Nobody cares about your culture in west bengal and also north eastern states.

[@subhammondol4354]

​@@priyadwivedi1860sabki apni choice hoti hai 😊

[@crisharmstrom9715]

@@priyadwivedi1860 Tumko kuch nahi pata, pahle ja kr Shastro ko padho...

[@pranabdas8866]

Mai bengal se hu idhar bali pratha bohot common hai ❤️ Joy maa Durga 🙏🏻

[@mrboss4834]

Boli is something extraordinary The vibes it creates during Bali ❤️❤️

[@Zenvinu]

I personally don't find it extraordinary, we have rules to follow to achieve the blessings of that particular deity. Stil there is lot more to understand, i have never done that but my great grandparents used to do that during mahashivratri in Kashmir.

[@mrboss4834]

@@Zenvinu You should go and watch that episode sometime You will feel the energy like maa herself has come to drink the blood

[@arijitdhar2926]

@@Zenvinu same here. We also give bali to the goddess at our house but at least i don't get thrilled by it. It's something that we must do and therefore we do it. It's not done for fun or enjoyment. I've seen some women go into trance during bali which is a different matter. They enter turriyavastha and I'll not comment on that with my limited understanding of the universe

[@alexhopper5154]

Ohhh really, Then feel that vibe with your neck under the Machete.

[@mrboss4834]

@@alexhopper5154 Say to your community first then who eat pork and beef in the name of religion Do you know what Christians are the most meat consuming in the world

[@manishagoswami6306]

बहुत बढ़िया जानकारी दी है🙌

[@shivtejdeshmukh6868]

bha ask Rajarshi Nandy sir about gayatri , gayatri sadhana , mantra sadhana of gayatri

[@ytmemes5572]

I think he cnt discus on that topic bcz it's for Brahmins only and negative energies run away from maa gyatri

[@rinkypatnaik1990]

7.32..blood episodes in kalika purana ..brilliantly true..🙏

[@joyshreesinghal5150]

Quite a few people do understand what the requirements for bali are, as enjoined in the shastras. Ask them. Try to understand with study. Because life and the divine do not operate on your conditioning of what the world comprises. The rules of the divine are very different

[@pineapple9644]

The divine has no rules

[@bishalbhattacharya1285]

@asdf exactly. to understand the divine rules have to be followed in initial steps

[@shekharshankarmajumder6847]

Nomoskar dada vaiya, im from Daka bangladesh, hamari family me bhi bali deta hai boli k somoy us posu go kaan me mantra dekar uska diksha bhi de jata hai..kalika puran me ek episode kariye vaiyaa..please Pray kori apnar joono💕🙏🙏🙏

[@krishhV06]

Superb 🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@mr.darksoul9109]

4:15 Woh Buddhrupi Narayan Lord Dattatreya the jo Lord Vishnu ke hi roop hai...Shri Gurudev Datta..

[@doctornorthern]

Correct

[@madhwadasa]

when rudrayaamala and brahmayaamala clearly says budh rupi janardanah then where is the need to bring lord dattatreya here.... i mean both are vishnu roopas no doubt but mentioned budha taught tara upasana to vasishtha and tara upasana in modern buddism of gautama budha is also well known so where does lord dattatreya comes in...

[@vinuphadi]

Thx sir u are ryt ❤

[@sarmisthabhutia7170]

Sir pranam, I'm from odisha there is very similar things of bali in odisha also.I want to ask that in some puja some people don't give bali of male goat and the goat can move anywhere ,till it die itself ,what is facts about it.I see all ur podcasts and big fan of urs sir.Thanks Ranveer ...

[@gunajitsarma4184]

Sir, I am a residence of Guwahati, Assam. Guwahati is a city of temple. It is believed that the ancient name of Guwahati, Pragjyotishapura originated from this temple. It is my request to make a podcast on Nabagraha temple, one of the oldest temple in Guwahati city, which was built in the 18th century by the Ahom King Rajeswar Singha, which is situated at Chitrachal Hill, Silpukhuri,, Guwahati-781003, near to Kamakhya Temple, Guwahati.

[@angshumanbhuyan3388]

Maa kamakhya temple is one of the most popular powerful SHAKTI PEETH thats why !!! 1:34

[@NitinKumar-wm4ir]

Ha ye baat Satya ki bali Diya jaata hai Durga Navratri ke samay 7ve din nimbu ka 8 ve din PETHe ka 9 ve din JAYFAL ka Main khud 15 saal se dekh Raha hu kyuki Navratri me mere dukaan se hi mandir pe samaan jata hai aur papa Puja karate hai

[@NitinKumar-wm4ir]

Mandir Durga ji ka hai 50 saal se hai

[@shyamalghoshOfficial009]

Jai maa

[@avinashjha3790]

Devi devtao ko unke gun or swabhav ke anusar Bali ya bhog dene ka vidhan hai Devi kaali ka gun tamasik hai or swabhav sy ugra hai rig Veda my varnan hai jab jeev atma sharir chor rahi hoti hai tho uske undar se rudra padartha nikal jata hai or bali ke dauran yahi padartha uss jagah ki Devi ya devta ki energy ko banaye rakhta hai or shayad yahi karan hai jeev bali ka jis jeev ki Chetna (consciousness) ka lavle jitna jada hota hai usme ess padartha ki Matra utni hi jada hoti hai utne lambe samay tak sidh peeth ki urja ko banaye rakhti hai

[@Life_race1991]

Lekin West Bengal ke Dakshineshwar temple me Ma Bhavtarini ke puja me to Bali nahi di jati.... Swayam Sree Ramkrishna param hansa... Jo mata ko roz apne haato se bhog khilate the... Unho ne bhi to kabhi bali ke liye nahi kaha...

[@astrostudy555]

@@Life_race1991 har devi devta ka alag alag hota hai devi ke bhi bhit se roop hai or bali pradan ek aisa topic jise bina padhe samjhe kisi nishkarsh or tark par nahi aa sakte esiliye is par puri jankari hona आवश्यक है

[@Life_race1991]

@@astrostudy555 aap kya Sree Ramkrishna Paramhansh se bhi ucch koti ke sadhak ho ??... Wo kaun hai pata hai??.... Unke hato se ma kali roz sudh sakahari bhog grahan karti thi.... To aap khud ko unse bhi bara gyani samajh te ho kya???... Swami VIVEKANAND bhi to ucch koti ke sadhak te... Kabhi unko bali dete hue suna hai??... Shirdi ke Sai Baba.... Jo khud param bramh the... Unhone kabhi apne bhakto se janwaro ki bali manga tha kya??...

[@astrostudy555]

@@Life_race1991 mene kab kha ki mein gyani hu mujhe nahi pta isilye bol rahi hu ki hame iske liye ved purano ko padhna samjhna hoga . Mein balI pradan ke khilaf par hame kisi nishkarsh par to nahi pohch sakte n sir

[@astrostudy555]

@@Life_race1991 or ha sai baba bhagvan hai bhot acha knowledge or gyan hai apke pas

[@Nemochills]

Aauumm Namah Shivayy❤

[@deepalighosh9212]

Thank you ranveer for explaining this concept of animal sacrifice .I was very small when I went to chinnamasta temple it it the 6th mahavidya Devi temple I saw Bali of goat .I left eating mutton after that I was searching for an answer and I got it today.i am a spiritual person maa was preparing me to become vegetarian for my spiritual growth from that time itself.

[@maheshtanay]

Mansam se khushi....kushi...kushiii

[@sharauro]

Actually if you read the biographies of tantra sadhaks, there came a time when many of these sadhaks stopped the offering of Bali pashu to the maha vidyas due to socio-ideological reasons. In each instance they were warned by the maha Vidya devi herself multiple times either in visions or dreams on why the offering of pashu Bali was stopped?. How dare she was disrespected in that manner?. After these occurrences, pashu Bali was resumed immediately.

[@shubhajitroy4073]

Can you mention some of those bios

[@deepayandutta5748]

😂😂😂😂😂😂 Lame excuses

[@roodebhatta1277]

I want to learn from him

[@joyshreesinghal5150]

And by the way, super intellectual missiles saying we must give our own bali, let me poi t this out to you at the earliest. When the call comes and the time is reached, we do offer our own heads at the feet of the great goddesses too. The bright red hibiscus flower 🌺 that is offered to forms of Shakti represents the cross section of the neck after decapitation has been done. So we are pretty much aware and ready at all times.for it. Don't think you can run us down or virtue signal to us with the shallow sentiments you are throwing around now. We give no two hoots to shallow emotions!

[@tushnairani-pg9tn]

💯

[@abhirupasen6360]

@@tushnairani-pg9tn Gupta ji ko bhi wah wah. Yahan bhi wah wah. What is your agenda?

[@chiragsareen3154]

Only the Vaishnavas are crying like always, they don’t follow Sanatana Dharma. Their religion is veganism/vegetarianism lol

[@SC-lp6qx]

But what sort of a deity is it which is after your head? Why? Not disrespectful but a genuine question. Here everyone is fighting over vegetarism. But my whole concern is why is your goddess asking your head and not protecting it? Also why the most powerful being of the world is consuming its own creation? And also if so, how do you differentiate between the divine and demon? Demonic beings are also after blood and head. Please reply to main questions not vegetarianism non vegetarianism

[@dcruz9758]

Asli bhakti issee bhot elag h ..jeev hatya mahapap h ..

[@deb2607]

Its not only about bhakti. Its about knowing the transcendental or universal form of God through rigorous sadhana, rituals, meditation combined with bhakti

[@dcruz9758]

If I know a simple way to reach god ..why would I sacrifice something which is not willing to die for my needs ..what is the real need of bhakti ?..to kill someone for own sake ..in our bhakti which I follow ..we never hurt any thing living .... We just want his blessings ..and to be with him when we live and die ..to have control over mind kam krodh lobh moh ahankar and to have control over senses..the real purpose is to oneself by separating ourselves from man(man ,budhi,chit ,ahankar)..God will give whatever is good for you not what you need..it's your own choice to follow and believe..lots of blessings 🙏

[@deb2607]

@@dcruz9758 God is beyond our understanding of good and bad, pure and impure; moral and immoral etc etc that arises out of our Ego or Ahamkara. When a person's Kundalini shakti or Prana Shakti reaches his Ajna Chakra, that person is said to have realised God and its very very difficult to reach that stage. It may take hundred of births for a person to achieve it. When a person realizes God he just observes the world without any judgement. And about Kama Krodh Lobh Moh and Ahamkara it holds true for any sadhaka. When a person becomes Greedy he is bound to fall in his spiritual progress. It does not matter if he is vegetarian or non vegetarian

[@deb2607]

@@dcruz9758 Left hand path of God or Vamachara is also a genuine path to God but one must be very careful. It can destroy a person if he is not fit for that or if he becomes greedy or egoistic during the process

[@deb2607]

@@dcruz9758 You are 100% right when you are saying one should have control over Kama, Krodh, Lobh, Moh, and Ahamkara and over his sensual pleasures to realise God. This is what Bhagwan Shri Krishna says to Arjuna in Bhagawat Gita. But Bhagwan Shri Krishna also asks Arjuna to seek blessing from Adi Shakti Mahamaya Durga before going for war. So Arjuna sings the Durga Stotram and in the stotram he also says Bhagawati Durga is fond of Buffaloes blood and wine. Maa Durga appears before Arjuna and blesses him and gives him Shakti gives him power and courage to win the war and they won. Maa Durga worshipers are Shakta and generally consumes non vegetarian and also gives annual sacrifices to her in Durga Puja. But one should be very much careful to not cloud his mind with lust, greed, ego while doing any sadhana.

[@ad6305]

" Mod o mangshe boli priya "🔥🔥 " pret o khorpe dora dehi gyan o chakre maheshwari"

[@joyshreesinghal5150]

Jo bhi bol rahe hain ki masoom pashu ki bali kaise ho sakti hai wo kripya Yamraj ko bhi yahi bola kare jab wo aate hain inke pariwar parijano ke pran harne. Satya ye hai ki emotions and sentiments ke bohot pare Satya hota hai. Sadaiv Satya ko samajhne ki cheshta karni chahiye. Satya shastro se aata hai. Dharm ke path par chalne ke liye shastro ka anusaran karna hoga. Na ki apne personal sentiments ka. Sentiments do not give a complete picture of the world. Shastras do. And Shastras have Bali vidhan inbuilt into them.

[@VikashKumar-qn6bq]

Tum kaun sa yamraj ho ?aur insan ki swabhavik mrityu hoti hi na ki gala katte hi tum khud Satya se dur ho

[@VikashKumar-qn6bq]

Shankaracharya se tum adhik janti ho?

[@bibhachoubey545]

​@@VikashKumar-qn6bqkya shankaracharya Vedic Rishi rishika se adhik jante the kya??

[@abhinay4200]

That is why Lord Buddha exposed pandits and shankaracharya

[@chetanchauhan6333]

Great information

[@Fearless0063]

Yes, During Ashtami, We also give bali to Maa durga under the Supervision of our Kul Guru who is a Tantric from Nepal. I myself gave 11 pashu Bali, Back to back, when I turned 18. My Grandfather did it, My father did it, and Now I do it every year, My Son will also do it or my daughter if she wants to. Edit: All the Vaishnavs in the comments are so hilarious 😂😂🤣.

[@kanyakumari610]

Great 🙏

[@krutarthmakavana9451]

Jai maa durga

[@arijitdhar2926]

Gorkhali spirit must always survive. In Shillong recently bali was stopped at a Gorkha Durga puja pandal (the navratri of October 2022). The government gave stupid reasons like the temple is on the main road and therefore people might feel uncomfortable when everyone in this area knows about this custom and respects it no matter.

[@kanyakumari610]

@@arijitdhar2926 You Gorkhas or Nepalis of West Bengal should make a Different state from Bengal ,I don't Know How a Govt can Interfere in Religious mattets,They don't take a Single actions on slaughter houses on Bakrid,but they have Problem With Asthami and Hindu Festivals

[@arijitdhar2926]

@@kanyakumari610 as far as the government is concerned the Meghalaya government is very stupid. They stopped bali in matri Mandir in 2006 if i remember correctly and they stopped mahisha bali in the nepali Durga puja of a different locality as well

[@sharansharma7138]

Thanks sir🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻

[@devashishsonowal1505]

In assam Sankar dev came and stopped all this thing coz he said if you take bali u will be also the item of bali next life and came Vaishnavism in assam which we r all thankful

[@ruchira7444]

Yes please stick to the deities who do not require bali and stay away from the ones who needs if you are faint hearted. But do not spread false information and your own sentiments in the name of devatas and shashtras!

[@ThapaBackyardFarm]

In which granth, puran, shlok, adhyay? Why creating your own stories MR. VAISHNAV??

[@UGCNETECONOMICS]

​@@ruchira7444 do you know Shankardeva He was an avatar of Vishnu Jai Guru Shankar

[@aajkabaadshah]

according to Your stupid logic , all Christians and Muslims shldve been converted to goats , cows and hens by now , but they continue to grow , while our veg Country is tormented. Keep your stupidity to yourself 🙏😤

[@patnawalle]

Great discussion

[@deanwinchester7723]

I won't give bali of animals but of vegetables.. All living being deserve to live...

[@godfather2078]

Plants are also living being.Don't eat them

[@shahjayesh]

​@@godfather2078 They don't have central nervous system.

[@ThapaBackyardFarm]

​@@shahjayesh but they breath, make food, eat. Is it not sufficient for classifying a living thing?

[@Dhruvvats2008]

​@@ThapaBackyardFarmn right but you eat onions ,raddish ..its also called as a sin .. then why we eat so?? ..

[@shushilshrestha2351]

10:50 😅 Le rajarshi sir: haan dekhi hain😂😂

[@pranabdas8866]

Bengal me normal hai bohot ne dekha hai

[@UGCNETECONOMICS]

Shankardev and Madhav dev our Guru prohibited us from Bali and Assamese people never support Bali and still we are blessed by Maa Kamakhya I think many people don't know Maa Kamakhya resembles the mother earth for Her all living creatures are Her children Jai Maa Kamakhya

[@daffodilshaw1998]

Well said @UGCNETECONONICS

[@UGCNETECONOMICS]

@@Kshatriya_assamese.Kalita I am kalita

[@samratvchakraborty5157]

Apna ye vegetarian terrorism band karo

[@jainil4947]

Very very very informative podcast.

[@Mr_WerewolfIND]

Mai Pashu Bali mein vishwaas nahi rakhta 🙂 Kyoki mere anusaar jo devi mujhme hai wahi us pashu mein bhi hai 🙏

[@godfather2078]

😂 nhi hota hai tum aur koi dusra aadmi agar ek hi devi ki bhakti karoge aur dono ke aage devi prakat ho gyi tho Dono ki deviya alag hogi.Dusra devi digambara hai wo kisi relation me nhi bandhi.Aur unhe chaag bali bahut pasand hai diya karo devi kalyan karegi.

[@rajatchakraborty1661]

Then you don't follow that specific devi.

[@gagadonim3354]

Once you deny what's written in shastras you no longer a hindu

[@Beginner..]

​​@@garimasrivastava4156thanks di I am 15 listening osho and acharya prashant.. I cant see any sort of violence with animals.. Uh r right vedas and upnishads have deep and diffrent meanings and metaphors are used each time unme bali kaa kuchh aur matlb hai apne andar ke janvar ko jalana is bali lekin ye sach main bali dene lag gye.. Only found your comment sensible.. Thank uh ❤️

[@garimasrivastava4156]

@@Beginner.. , thank you for your kind words 🙏😊. I am happy to see so much maturity at such a young age. You have chosen the right people for guidance. Our Hindu dharm does not remotely promote violence and this is what distinguishes it from Abrahamic religions. Thank you

[@joybhattacharya3231]

Bhut acha sa explain kiya ha sir na ❤ tantric sastra ka bare main

[@Nidhijha..k]

I am a maithali brahmin and we are mostly shakta .in my family too we offer bali of laddu to our kuldevi before mundan and janew .and in my mom side of family they offer pashu bali .even though i a m vegetarian but i still stand by bali pratha. These days a lot of people are influenced by vaishnavism which is not wrong but do not disobey ur own kuldevi /kuldevta

[@Yash._.2695]

Jo devi ya devta tumhe adharma karne ke liyea priyukta karta hai woh devi ya devta kehlane ke Yogya nhi~ premanandji maharaj

[@Nidhijha..k]

@@Yash._.2695 I really respect mahraj ji but do not agree with him on this .firstly he is a katha vachak and also a vaishna believer. Hinduism is an umbrella term under which a lot of other sampradiya have taken shelter. Nowadays everyone is a self claimed vaishnav. Bali pratha holds a significant value and is mentioned in our grants. U have internet so u can Google it or search it on KZbin. Also one thing that distincts dharmic religion from Abraham Abrahamic is we don't force our beliefs onto others we all have different faiths and culture yet we are same so please let's embrace it

[@Yash._.2695]

@@Nidhijha..k firstly kathavachak means he already read all vedas and purana of which you haven't even heard of , 2nd try to change your thinking Britisher did same (divide and rule ) There is nothing such thing like vaishnism ,rudraism,shaktism,etc etc we hindus,sanatani worship sanatan which means eternity or energy, there are just different form of energy but all are same

[@Yash._.2695]

@@Nidhijha..k another thing people also use to give human sacrifice why are you against it but not with animal ?? Hypocrisy ??😬

[@Nidhijha..k]

@@Yash._.2695 did he told u that he has read all the Vedas and puran? How did u come to a conclusion that I have not even heard of it . Katha vachak is someone who has high moral values and preached it to other the reason why he is a kathavachak and not shankrachaya or a priest. And just coz u don't know about something that doesn't mean it doesn't not exist. Maybe ask from some real pandit or guru ji and then u will know existence of sampradiya

[@tapashimondal7330]

I tatally adverse of it