Income Cannot be the ONLY criteria for Creamy Layer : Supreme Court | Impact on OBC Reservation

[@pathfinderias]

To avail the BEST offers on any Unacademy Subscription, click here: unacademy.onelink.me/081J/sramoon1

[@aman.306]

Sir ka lecture always detailed analysis rehta h ....history se current tak 🙏🙏🙏

[@study-holique2030]

My suggestion for improving reservation, to have maximum impact is to extend creamy layer rule to Scheduled Castes and Tribes, only well off from these communities are getting benefitted from reservation.

[@coolboi1621]

👍🏼

[@amreshsingh3079]

Though Supreme Court had already Said " Reservation is not 'Garibi hatao karyakaram'. Article 16(4) says " nothing in this article will prohibit a government to provide reservation to those communities which are not well represented ".

[@sidquote4527]

Exactly

[@InsignificantChap]

@@amreshsingh3079 a job is not a olympic game where u can represent your community It's a workplace where u can work and get your pay It has nothing to do with caste

[@ajaykumarsingh702]

@@InsignificantChap It does actually. The higher caste people never hire a lower caste person no matter how well qualified and deserving he/she might be. Even if it results in poor efficacy of the workplace. The reservation was put in the place to counter such things in the society.

[@kunalbhardwaj3237]

i hope Govt. will create a new layer called Belgian chocolate layer for those with high class Standards of living in reserved cats Literally we generals are toned milk if OBCs are creamy

[@vaibhavvishal1819]

In my opinion some sort of creamy layer rules should also be applied to SCs and STs

[@CHAILSI_NIRANKARI]

Bhut bekar opinion hai

[@harkeshmourya655]

@Mr ReX L LO MERA 😂

[@hkm6353]

@Mr ReX true

[@yashvardhanojha6796]

@Mr ReX q Kisi gareeb Ka hak kha rhe , jab Kabul ho gye ho to aur neeche wale ko labh lekar aage aane do

[@vaibhavvishal1819]

@@CHAILSI_NIRANKARI didi ko unreserved seats bhi chahiye, apni category ki seats bhi chahiye, economically sound hone ke baad bhi reservation chahiye "Aise kaise chalega didi?"

[@soumods]

Same criterion should come for SCs/STs in national level

[@coolboi1621]

@UCuDcTZUigGWAJDImybrKcEw bhout sare st aise ha jo ameer ha aur wohi wohi reservation ka fayad utha rhe ha niche wale st ,sc jo sach mai garbi ha unko reservation nhi mil pa rha is wajh se

[@sudeeptKJ]

Mere hisab se Reservation kisi ko mat do Sarkar ko agar lage ki yeh barg k pichhda hai to Phir unke bachcho ko styphen ab se jyada de de unko books provide karde exam dene k liye aane jaane ka kharcha de lekin school jobs me sirf ranked people ka selection ho

[@coolboi1621]

@@sudeeptKJ reservation mat do free education de do jo garbi ha

[@amreshsingh3079]

@@coolboi1621 But Supreme Court says Reservation is not for profit but for representation.

[@coolboi1621]

@@amreshsingh3079 nhi mera matalb ha jo sahi mai garbi ha usko de do bhout sare sc /st mai ameer log ha woh use karte ha reservation ka

[@pathfinderias]

👉🏼Women in National Movement unacademy.com/class/women-in-indias-national-movement-l-freedom-struggle/O2TGQ3Y1 👉🏼Women's Movement in India unacademy.com/class/womens-rights-movement-in-india/YV7UPXK6 Unlock Code - MAHIPAL 👉🏼 Crash Course On Medieval History: unacademy.com/course/medieval-history-793/V1DRLP0E 👉🏼 Pathfinder 5.0: unacademy.com/test-series/unacademy-pathfinder-50/N6NK75MI

[@turismoknowledgewithrealey2648]

Galat ghatiya or curuption or student k maa bahan hogi lol alredy income base h fir v ese h hota h

[@turismoknowledgewithrealey2648]

Bahot se facter h to jis facter me vo piche h vaha arakshan do na income me kyu de rahe ho student me farming sab me kyu de rahe jisko jiski jarurat h vahi do only

[@tasneembharmal3795]

Like OBC creamy layer is there a similar concept for SC and ST ??

[@InsignificantChap]

Beam ki shakti Dhoom machaye General wale Bhaad me jae Neela beam Neela beam Neela beam Neela beam Beam Beam Beam Neela beam Neela beam

[@sanat5605]

Bolna kya chahte ho What do you mean by 'beam' ?

[@varunshedigudde1880]

Rhyming😅

[@AnnuSingh-hs2is]

bhik ki shakti

[@tirelesssoul1061]

bhai reservation 1951 - 1961 th kewal uska bad political benefit ke liya ambendment krke aga bdhaya

[@RudraWorld84]

Saala koi paida hote hi Brahmin ban jata h aur kisi ko dalit bna diya gya h.... Aur reservations ka faida tab milta h jab exam de aur lagbhag marks laye ..... Fir kuchh hypocrite usse bhikh kah jate h ... Aur bhed bhao krne wale ko rakshas ya janwar nhi kahte h jo 3000 salon se discrimination krte aarhe h

[@gagan_deep_AAO]

Mahipal sir deserves more view.

[@roshanrajput7559]

Yes but he focus on advertisement and he never made video less than 10 min video ke bich mai last mai suru mai sab jagah add you tube ka alag do do add

[@partha0098]

A man who earns a lakh/month, and live in a bungalow,how come he is a pichada???

[@NimishGargtheultimate]

Bhai , yahan IAS bhi pichda hua ho sakta hai .

[@shubhammishr]

Anything is possible in Reserved republic of India.

[@rudraryan]

Adhi jankari mt rkho dost.

[@ajaykumarsingh702]

@99 Because even President of India was prevented from entering the hindu temple. The society is "Pichada" not the Sc/St community. The reservation is there to protect Sc/St from "Pichada society".

[@ss-xf4ku]

@@ajaykumarsingh702 singh kuy lagata tha be tu

[@sudhanshuranjan179]

How long creamy layers of sc and st be a backward(Pichhada) class?

[@Bwin20]

jab tk social economical inequality rhegi tb tk

[@neerajhoney9129]

Till the so called upper caste feel no hesitation for keeping their relationships (including marriage) with them.

[@sudhanshuranjan179]

Who deserve reservations in SC/ST are utilized by creamy layers, in this way there will be never come social equality.

[@neerajhoney9129]

@@sudhanshuranjan179 This issue can be solved by sub-categorisation of castes within SCs/STs and OBCs.

[@biplabroy3205]

Me sc hoon mujhe kuch ghanta milta ni bas naam yuh rakhe hai ea sab chiz

[@prashantgupta220]

I have a pertinent question: If government/PSU/civil service officers' children are not eligible for reservation, then how did Tina Dabi get the benefit of reservation? Her parents are/were both high ranking government service officers at the time of her selection. And, it's not about one specific person here, but I personally know this happened in many cases.

[@nikhilk2809]

Right

[@dipalidewangan1484]

May be the creamy layer criteria only applies to OBC not for SC or ST

[@shashankrai713]

@@dipalidewangan1484 yes thats the reason

[@ajaykumarsingh702]

Creamy layer doesn't apply on Sc/St community. It is applicable for only OBC.

[@mukulsanatan5937]

because wo dalit hai dalit(broken) ke liye koi creamy layer nhi bhavishya mai hamara pm ya prez ydi dalit hue to bhi unke bacho ko reservation milega aur ek general chAprasi ka bache ko kbhi reservation nhi milega😖😭😖😭😖 AISA KHADA DESH HAI YE TUM PM PREZ BNKE BHI PICHDE REH GYE AUR WO CHAPRASI BNKR BHI TUMSE BAHUT AAGEY HAI

[@prashantbalyan]

SC ST me bhi creamy layer concept hona chahiye. Jo log 2,3 pidhi पीढ़ी se reservation ka fayada le rahe hai unko bhi creamy layer me rakhna chahiye.

[@SatwikSatapathy]

General Caste - Where is our savior!!?? Doomed*

[@amanjha5916]

@@saulgoodman1046 Seriously? At least make some meaningful point at a UPSC educational channel....it's not a Republic bharat or NDTV newsroom...

[@p_HoE_niX]

@@amanjha5916 He's taunting

[@amanjha5916]

@@p_HoE_niX I know.... that's why I mentioned it's not a newsroom😅 But I guess people like him are beyond redemption 😂

[@p_HoE_niX]

@@amanjha5916 Leave the poor soul on it's own, may he get reservation in heaven😊

[@HAmit12567]

आपकी बुलंद आवाज के बिना दिन अधूरा लगता unacademy का पता नहीं लेकिन आप सर्वोत्तम शिक्षकों में हो। वीडियो अपलोड नियमित रूप से करते रहिए। धन्यवाद🙏

[@AkashKeserwani]

When are we going to have Creamy Layer for SC/ST ?

[@rajeevpratap9224]

For generals....don't think much about reservation....you can't do anything...except geting furastated.

[@hhhhngg]

generals are landed, having stable economic backdrop and they are free from caste discrimination which does not hinder them from job opportunities. Reservation is for the downtrodden communities, and due to the fact that reservation is not efficient, the question of creamy layer came about. For generals who would have been below say, "creamy layer", there is reservation for them in form of ewc

[@bhaktaharisahoo4666]

@@hhhhngg @Read about EWS

[@un_expected_8237]

Ews ka naam suna hai uska income cap toh obc ncl se bhi zyadaa hai phir bhi obc badnaam 😂

[@mad9430]

@@hhhhngg exactly ...kya soch se nichli aur badi jati ka bhedbhaav mita payenge ? Reservation se bhot logo ko problem hai lekin hakikat hai ki soch me haavi hai bhedbhaav

[@priyanshunegi3833]

@@mad9430 to bhai Sc/ST act diya hua hai constitution mein... Discrimination hita hai to tum usse use krte ho simple....But if you are economic stable then why are you eating seats of Deserved ones 🙃

[@Ajaykumar-u3v6b]

Thanku so much sir..Nice session.....Sir apse request hai ki aap privatisation me ek detail video banaiye.. plz sir🙏

[@nahimchoudhary4996]

Best educational channel with best teachers

[@pradeeplovely8370]

Sir aap bahut lajbab padhate hai main bihar Sharif se Hoon aapka main all video dekhta Hoon

[@vivekkaran4918]

Mahipal sir is a gem of history and polity

[@IndoWorldwithSam]

The Awesome Compilation of Reservation... for GS2 Polity

[@nikeshkumar8353]

Gajab ka lecturer hota h sir vvi topic sir continue sir thanks

[@shrishtijha2822]

Sir please complete the series of modern indian history 👈

[@Deeps230981]

Sir what is the criterion for calculating annual gross income for government employees for creamy layer purpose???? Is it calculated through ITR or adding basic pay , DA, HRA etc... Plz clarify... Thank You

[@krishnakant1752]

A grade teacher a great explanation no words to appreciate your explanation is just crystal and clear..

[@sangitadevi706]

Hello sir 🙏🏻 my question is -- if my father is retired from army with subedar rank, can i eligible for obc ncl certificate as I am from obc category ???

[@deepaktiwari2186]

Sansad aur vidhayk k beto ko v creamy layer me rakhna chahiye...

[@RudraWorld84]

Bilkul hona hi chahiye

[@kumarutsav23]

Yas

[@adarshpandey8023]

Inko vese bhi nahi chahiye. Unhe bas jaatiwad chahiye taaki votebank bana rahe. Aur iska jimmedar dusro ko bana dete hai ..

[@siddharthshukla2832]

If this judgement fortifies then there must be an interview of Parents of applicants who clears a govt exam that will clearly shows how pichdra is the applicant

[@kothurukoushik2530]

the explanation is good sir easily understand

[@coolboi1621]

Same criterion should be in sc/st

[@VishalKumar-xp6gz]

repeal EWS quota also..

[@coolboi1621]

@@VishalKumar-xp6gz EWS quota mai kitne criteria ha dekh lena fat jaye gi

[@HS-jk8fj]

@@coolboi1621 Yaha UP mei rich general wale EWS leke bethe h. Mere khud 2 dosto ke pas hai EWS. Unke pas four wheeler aur 150 + gaz ka ghar hai. Aur mast EWS ka fayda utha rahe hai har exam mei. Laken cut off fir bhi clear nhi ho rhi unki

[@coolboi1621]

@@HS-jk8fj toh fir bhi kuch bhi ho sc,st mai bhout ameer log ha jo use kar rhe ha reservation mera dost ha st ha papa mummy govt job fir bhi reservation ha uska ghar dekhe gya toh general se toh bhout acha ah

[@HS-jk8fj]

@@coolboi1621 Inn logo ki itni % population hai aur inko reservation milta hai. SC - 19% Res(15%) ST - 10% Res(7.5%) OBC- 41% Res(27%) EWS- 20% Res(10%) GEN - female-4% ( women reservation 5%) GENERAL male - 6% population( inko koi bhi reservation nahi milta hai) Although population of General is very less still they fight for 40%+10% unreserved seats. 95% jobs in India are private which don't have any reservation. Defense exams and sports don't have any reservation. For your better understanding I would request you to watch Vikas divyakriti video on reservation. All your doubts will be cleared.

[@kumarutsav23]

Creamy layer concept should also be imposed on ST/SC reservation also

[@anandsaini]

sir "income from salaries and agricultural land shall not be clubbed " iska mtlb kya hua ..govt employeer ki salary isme count hogi ya nhi ?

[@bawa9399]

Same doubt

[@Motivationhaker]

The supreme Court is also not impartial. It's judgment often seems biased.

[@shwetanshujha4464]

This channel and all the teachers associated with it are providing us with an ocean of knowledge.... The information...updates are so beautifully covered and discussed that it help us to easily understand the topic..!!

[@AmitKumar-rc2yx]

Agar achha laga hoga aap ka yeh andaaj dil jit leta hai outstanding performance

[@sudeeptKJ]

Mere hisab se Reservation kisi ko mat do Sarkar ko agar lage ki yeh barg k pichhda hai to Phir unke bachcho ko styphen ab se jyada de de unko books provide karde exam dene k liye aane jaane ka kharcha de lekin school jobs me sirf ranked people ka selection ho

[@HAmit12567]

EWS p bhi ek detailed video bana dijiye🙏.

[@anooppaswan7938]

Thank u Sir🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@akshaymeena8577]

Detailed Analysis.

[@Ishaahaahaa]

Sir when are you going to upload history lectures continuation Now got use to of your teaching explanation and method

[@alpanapaul6848]

This must be implemented for all caste not only for obcs

[@priyakar5289]

Sir please make a video on Narayan Rane vs Uddhav Thackeray case. Can someone be arrested for criticising a state CM?

[@maniktratha2587]

Very beautifully explained..

[@indiansightseer7451]

sandar jankari di gayi hai sir

[@krishankumaryadav6245]

If a person is Group B officer in Central govt then while applying for other job he himself will be considered in which OBC layer (Creamy/Non-creamy) ??

[@Chanandler_bongg]

No he wont be considered creamy layer untill both the parents are in group B or father is in group A. There are other certain criteria for navratnas

[@AbhishekHalderCOCHUT]

General talented students leave india

[@arindamghosal7277]

Already

[@world_conquerer]

Exactly because economic situation do not remain constant

[@prahladkashap6252]

Or ye bta k agar kuch confusion hai ncl ya cl k liye kis deptt ko letter likha jayeee. Jahan se jawab mil sake

[@aman68931]

Can anyone tell what us the meaning of salary and agricultural incime not included

[@vishalbhardwaj4221]

Thank you sir for the information.

[@GurpreetKaur-tf5zp]

Very helpful

[@SB-jc4vf]

A) 1st create or tell clearly that why reservation is given, how it is given. B) Remove decision making power about reservation from the hands of politician. C) create a separate committee to decide which caste should placed where. D) create solid Creamy layer law and definition for them. E) Tell every year that how many people got reservation and how many peoples are now above Creamy layer and their reservation is struckt down, how many caste are now can not be called OBC and they are now in general category, How many SC ST are now not scheduled Caste and tribe and are now included in OBC and how many are now general category.

[@user-eu2vq4vq8f]

This is a pure political judgement? What is logic behind it? U are stealing general peoples right to live. Is this justic

[@Abhianand420]

Btw, this judgement is not related with any General Category... The quota which is fixed for SC, in that, Non-creamy layer to be given more preference

[@VishalKumar-fb7jg]

This quota is within 27℅ my brother.... This judgement will not effect generals...

[@Abhianand420]

@@VishalKumar-fb7jg Not within... It will within 7+7= 14% for SC and ST

[@VishalKumar-fb7jg]

@@Abhianand420 will u explain..brother

[@sumits4903]

Sir what do u think such sub categorisation also needed in SC/ST because as some group from OBC has economically better condition had put in to creamy layer means out off the reservation so such categorisation also needed in SC/ST?

[@albatross967]

Shi bola sc st me na krenge ye log usme bhi to aise log hai puri family ki family fayda le rhi hai.

[@rakeshsharma-jm8je]

Superb sir ji

[@pawanroz]

Very detailed lecture sir

[@AnnuSingh-hs2is]

the same supreme court allows 4 wives to muslims and 10 years jail for lgbt people if they caugt in public.They didnt allow legal marriage for lgbt .Supreme court is siyapa.

[@Abhianand420]

Supreme court can't do anything... Sharia is given to Muslim community by Constitution... So Supreme court can't do anything... And as far as i know, LBGT marriage is legal now in India

[@GauravSingh-gv5gp]

@@Abhianand420 it's mean if a Muslim do crime he/she should punished by Muslim law Ya yha Indian low

[@AnnuSingh-hs2is]

@@Abhianand420 no bro...marriage is not legal yet.only they removed 10 years priosnment

[@avinashverma8558]

SC has allowed LGBT marriage

[@letitbe6594]

@@GauravSingh-gv5gp civil cases by sharia law criminal by IPC

[@harkeshmourya655]

Very Nice lacture ❤️🇮🇳

[@bishwajitabayan4651]

Thank you Sir.

[@hinasaeed5491]

Very well explained Thanku❤️❤️❤️

[@santoshkumarbajpai2029]

Very good video,very informative

[@wirathu-aashin]

Creamy layer is well needed for sc/st reservation.

[@sushruthmallikarjun1921]

Thank you..

[@saurabhkumar2834]

Explain with example,sir🙏

[@avishekkumar1328]

Sir Jharkhand CNT, SPT per ek video bana dijye ..exam samne hai ,Apne Kaha tha banaynge ..

[@MahendraKumar-hd6fx]

finally understood the meaning of creamy layer thank u ❤️

[@tirpatiji7773]

Thanks 🙏sir

[@samarendrasingh5196]

Sir lectures are too good

[@kiran_diaries]

Family income includes income from all sources of parents and the candidate or it includes candidates siblings also.

[@parijatnath3980]

Sir West Bengal ka OBC A and OBC B clarify karke ek video banaiye

[@ravisachan5738]

SC, ST and OBC k alawa EWS bhi hai for Gen. category.

[@vipinlogic1]

Question: Does Family income include all family members income?? or only oncome of father? If father is retired from job and son is applying for govt job along with private job, does his family income calculated as per father or combined?? Can anyone please help with some explanation...

[@Abhianand420]

Yes, income of all family members (dependent) is calculated in Family income

[@PriyaKumari-hg2wf]

Salary is not included as income..

[@parveentanwar7101]

Great job sir 👌👌👌👌👌👌👌

[@hitman8633]

मेरा भारत महान 😔🇮🇳

[@rahuls8613]

I just want to ask those who support reservation over merit. 1)Why do you send your child to best teachers who actually cleared the exam and not to the teacher who is a product of reservation. 2)why you prefer good and top doctors and not sc st doctor? 3)why everyone prefer top general caste engineers. students who are abusing upper caste are watching videos of Mahipal sir who is also a upper caste. This is irony🤣🤣🤣🤣.

[@HS-jk8fj]

Read good books bro and talk like an educated person. Your comment is full of casteism. Who ask the caste of Doctor before any treatment? Who ask the caste of Teacher before getting any knowledge from them? All reputed educators on youtube respect Dr BR Ambedkar who is the symbol of knowledge. I know you have lot of hatred in your mind for reservation. I can understand. But I would request you to watch Vikas Divyakriti sir's video on reservation. All your doubts will be cleared in that single video which will help in many exams and interviews. Remember a biased, hateful information vomited in exam or interview can drastically reduce your selection rate. So i would humbly request u to watch that video and clear all your doubts.

[@HS-jk8fj]

Inn logo ki itni % population hai aur inko reservation milta hai. SC - 19% Res(15%) ST - 10% Res(7.5%) OBC- 41% Res(27%) EWS- 20% Res(10%) GEN - female-4% ( women reservation 5%) GENERAL male - 6% population( inko koi bhi reservation nahi milta hai) Although population of General is very less still they fight for 40%+10% unreserved seats. 95% jobs in India are private which don't have any reservation. Defense exams and sports don't have any reservation. For your better understanding I would request you to watch Vikas divyakriti video on reservation. All your doubts will be cleared.

[@ascherzoid9591]

@@HS-jk8fj they are general seats dalit can also acquire them pr aukaad nh hai vo acquire krne ki 😂

[@adityanarayandwivedi8605]

@@ascherzoid9591 shi bole bhai 🤣🤣🤣

[@arindamghosal7277]

@@HS-jk8fj whatsapp se data mat bhej bhai

[@thunder2174]

Sir You have not explain point 2 properly,this criteria only applies when parents had recruited directly to class A officer before the age of 40, otherwise the candidate is eligible for reservation

[@odiapk9855]

Ese kuch pata nii😂

[@Dhruv-zl8oe]

General castes are neglected because of being minority

[@neerajhoney9129]

Yet these General castes are enjoying 10+40% (= majority) undeclared reservation.

[@roarbooster3518]

@@neerajhoney9129abe murkh 40% for open category ST,SC,OBC sabke liye hein

[@jasperkadugula5754]

Sir within 8 lakhs on what annual salary or income from other sources or both for determining non creamy layer

[@funday9991]

Focus on education for these communities 🙏

[@crazyshorts4278]

There should be clause for Income that people with certain income (upper class at least) will not get benifits from reservations.

[@manavk4088]

Sir u r the best....

[@mangeshjoshi1065]

Great video.

[@surajgupta4696]

ek taraf general banda jo din bhar majdoori karta hai or Rs.300-400 kamata hai, or dusri taraf 1 SC/ST ka banda jo kaafi ameer hai or logo ko employment bhi deta hai, to kya reservation (EWS and SC/ST) dono ke liye hona socially or economically shi hai ?

[@parveentanwar7101]

Great sir

[@aspirant9239]

Very informative sir....

[@PriyaKumari-hg2wf]

Sir , kya salary v include kiya jata hai annual income mai...obc ncl category...if a person's father is not officer.....

[@Pavitr_00]

best first time

[@aman_aswal]

Why India is very complicated

[@ajaykumarsingh702]

Because it is a False nation made by the British. Princely states of India were forced down to join the nation at the tip of the gun point.

[@adityak9408]

Thank u sir

[@TheVinscee]

Supreme court ne sahi kia.

[@singhrajput6949]

Tum kis category ke ho?

[@DileepYadav-bc6vt]

Nice video Sir

[@starksuman]

Ham general walo ko jine mat do, ek ek tea stall khulwado.

[@p_HoE_niX]

sath me pakode bhi, thodi income bdhegi😂😂

[@starksuman]

@@p_HoE_niX han bhi nice idea, aja statup kholte hay 😂

[@vipvibes02]

Sir, when u complete modern history......

[@mrigs.397]

Point 2 of obc criteria have some information mistake about group b

[@vidyabhushansingh3205]

osm lecture sir..

[@amitkashyap1903]

Good

[@ReGioNaLSuPeRHiTS044]

Aur EWS ke bare me bhi kuchh btaiye

[@narendrakhatik7255]

Very nice sir

[@barunkumarmandal2637]

Cast census 2021 pr ek video sir advantage and disadvantage