PAT MCGRATH MOTHERSHIP XI SUNLIT SEDUCTION PALETTE REVIEW! NEED IT OR HAVE IT?

✨Shop Mothership XI Sunlit Seduction Palette! 👉🏼 go.magik.ly/ml...
Try the following codes and try your luck at some $$ OFF
Thankyou30
Missyou20
Sunlit10
✨Get it at Sephora: howl.me/cki42I...
✨Everything on my face! 👇🏼
BROWS 👇🏼
Rare Beauty Brow Harmony Lifting Gel: howl.me/cj6HF2...
Rare Beauty Brow Harmony Precision Pencil: howl.me/cj6HBa...
EYES 👇🏼
PAT MCGRATH Mothership XI: go.magik.ly/ml...
Gxve Mascara:howl.me/ckgT1X...
Velour Lashes (Sinful): glnk.io/v6qy/p...
20% OFF CODE PATTY20
COMPLEXION👇🏼
Charlotte Tilbury Magic Cream: howl.me/cjUJAO...
Caudalie Vino Perfect Eye Cream: howl.me/cj3bHE...
Danessa Myricks Yummy Balm: go.magik.ly/ml...
Pat McGrath Foundation: go.magik.ly/ml...
Charlotte Tilbury Color Corrector: howl.me/ckbLpe...
Very Valentino Concealer: howl.me/ckgT2U...
Givenchy Powder: howl.me/ckiDhn...
Pat McGrath Bronzer: go.magik.ly/ml...
Gucci Blush (01): howl.me/ckiDhL...
LIPS: 👇🏼
ABH Lip Liner (Muted Mauve): howl.me/ckb7Lv...
Pat McGrath (Prima Dona) Gloss: go.magik.ly/ml...
TOOLS 👇🏼
BK Beauty (10%OFF “PATTY10”): go.magik.ly/ml...
Wayne Goss 03 Brush: go.magik.ly/ml...
✨Shop My Must-Have Rephr Brushes: rephr.com/conc...
Eye Brushes: 15, 01, 28, 13, 03, 14, 26, 23, 21
Face Brushes: 05, 36, 37, 18, 31, 19
BRAND CODES
✨REPHR BRUSHES: rephr.com/conc...
✨NATASHA DENONA: natashadenona....
15%OFF CODE: PATTY15
✨KOPARI BEAUTY: shop-links.co/...
15% OFF CODE 15OFFPATTY
✨ODEN’S EYES: www.odenseye.s...
10% OFF CODE “PATTY10”
✨VELOUR LASHES : glnk.io/v6qy/p...
20% OFF CODE PATTY20
✨NOMAD COSMETICS: www.nomadcosme...
10% OFF CODE PATTY10
✨BK BEAUTY: go.magik.ly/ml...
10% OFF CODE PATTY10
✨ADEPT COSMETICS: www.adeptcosme...
CODE: PATTY10
✨SIGMA BEAUTY: www.sigmabeauty.com/PATTYALONSO
Code: PATTYALONSO
✨GLAMNETICS: shop-links.co/...
Code: PATTY
✨FANTASY COSMETICA: fantasycosmeti...
Code: PATTY10
✨GLAMINATRIX COSMETICS: glaminatrixcos...
Code: PATTY10
✨ACEBEAUTE: www.acebeaute.com
Code: PATTY
❤️ Follow me on my other social media accounts! ❤️
Instagram: / pattycalonso
Twitter: / pattycalonso
Facebook: / pattyalonsomakeup
Turn on your NOTIFICATIONS BELL if you want to get notified every time I upload! I don't have a set schedule so that way you will know when a new video is live!
Don’t forget to like 👍🏻 and Subscribe!!
#patmcgrath #newmakeup #mothershipXI
FTC Disclaimer: Today's video is NOT sponsored, but some of the links above are affiliated which means I make a small commission from your purchase. Your support means everything! ❤️

[@PattyAlonso]

✨Shop Mothership XI Sunlit Seduction Palette! 👉🏼 go.magik.ly/ml/1vkpw/ ✨Get it at Sephora: howl.me/cki42IYKIdB

[@caracoates4834]

The problem is that she gives the same three color mattes in most of her palettes. They are different tones but pretty similar. I personally do not love all the red-based mattes. The mattes are the structure of the look. If they are burgundy, brick, or reddish pink, I am always going to get a similar look. If Natasha Denona can bring out different color stories and appeal to the masses, Pat can too.

[@Lilybeans77]

Hard agree. That plus the very similar champagne, and at least one gold/bronze shade, we are getting almost the same palette on repeat (at least since DR1), with different undertones. I love her formula though.

[@karmenfuentes7056]

Totally agree with you ! I’m honestly disappointed! Was expecting a really new color story. As a Mothership collector and after having the “pinks” DV I & II and Mothership IX, I’m going to skip on this as I did with the last one .

[@kr8882]

I have the palette and am quite underwhelmed with it. The special shades aren’t as special, more indie. Dry and flaky. Not flattering on texture. It reminds me of the Natasha Denona Love palette on the eyes. I have a more neutral undertone and it doesn’t really suit me. I thought it might surprise me like Moonlit Seduction that is 👌. But I’m glad I have it and got it for 30% off. It goes well with sublime.

[@annealbaugh919]

Agree with you 100% it just seems like same old same old it’s beautiful but nothing new !

[@Niccis_Narrative]

I think Pat McGrath is in trouble, something tells me she’s just using mostly the same pigments and crappy packaging because she doesn’t have the money to get any more color pigments and wants to see how much she can pull the wool over peoples eyes. I hope her brand dies on the vine at Ulta. The fact that she sued little indie companies for using the word “divine” like she gave birth to the word 🙄 makes me never want to buy anything from her again, even if she had cool packaging, instead of grown up princess doily crap 😂😂😂

[@sikay6340]

I have to say… this Mothership makes me appreciate all previous Mothership color stories that much more 😂. I will be using them and enjoying them even more so.

[@karmenfuentes7056]

You’re so right! Let’s do so ! 😂😂

[@monochino3371]

ikr! mothership I is by far my fav one, the color story is so unique

[@megk1787]

I said I was not going to get this, but I did anyway. It's very pretty.

[@hybamajed3614]

Hi Patty ☺️ I want to say thank you. You're the first (only) one on social network who addressed the issue with PML IG team handling "negative" comments. I was amongst the too many ones that got blocked. That left a terrible taste in my mouth... I am over it now but won't be wasting my precious coins on their products anymore. I was such a hard-core fan and now I am cured! Concerning the special shades what made them special that they were backed. It's a really expensive process but the result was for the blitz ones silky smooth shades that were elegant and non texturiasing on the lid and could also be blended thus ideal for exquisite one and done. For the astral shades (also baked) they used to have a translucent base thus allowing them to be used as toppers for extra shine and glimmer and in many cases they were also transformative shades which made the motherships so exciting and versatile. This was the case in all motherships till number 9 huetopian dream. The trio chrome shade in this one had a metallic pan and thus non baked. The result while pretty still was nothing compared to the similar shade in mothership 8 divine rose 2. Nearly no one mentioned this issue and PML team succeeded in sneakily replacing a baked shade with a non special one while maintaining the same price tag. It was sort of a test run for them, and they moved away completely from the baked shades in mothership 10 moon lit seduction were none of the "special" shades were baked. Just wanted to let you know. Love you 💕💕💕

[@StrangeQuack]

And the baked shades made the price reasonable, as one can cost 15-20€. Now its a palette you can get everywhere else and a colourstory that everyone else does.

[@Sarayscrochet_yarn_art]

I'm impressed with your knowledge! If your feedback to PMG was this elaborated they surely missed the opportunity to improve their products. All feedback is valuable and should be taken into consideration, especially when it is so specific and in depth. They should be thanking your review even if they don't agree with it or it doesn't match their business idea. It is gold!

[@hybamajed3614]

@@StrangeQuack exactly the baked shades were what justified the price tag for a mothership. One could argue that they provide luxury packaging but even that has been modified to cut down the cost and the "art" work in the outer packaging hasn't really changed since divine rose one!

[@hybamajed3614]

@@Sarayscrochet_yarn_art thank you 😊 I am a bit of a nerd 😅 I think they are specifically targeting people that mention the issue with the new formula of the "special"shades

[@Amber86queenbee]

@@hybamajed3614very interesting read on the formula. I don’t think they aren’t too particular in who they block - PML team has blocked a small influencer who showed on her own IG page that the Star Wars packaging was a sticker. Or a customer that previously said I’m not interested in blush but would love bronzer (back when they released the blush duos). I found it frustrating to see as it was often people who was disappointed they did this for so little after spending $,000s on the brand. I greatly respect Patty for being the first to speak out about it.

[@TheRealAriLove]

ngl, seeing your eyes without mascara and eyeshadow truly hits different. your eyes are so gorgeous Patty

[@kellycastillo241]

Right?? All of that eyeshadow hides her eyes

[@clairecrispin260]

I love that you addressed the issues! Not just the colour story, but the way they have chosen to manage the feedback. Well done, and thank you for your realness.

[@RoseOfMadina]

Patty, all last 4 shades in the older palettes are baked. The glimmery, sparkly shades as well. 6:31 Their baked texture is why they are able to be used as a topper. And the thing is, they cost more to produce. For a long while, Pat has been cutting costs, but degrading in packaging and formula. Edit: guys, do follow Mariam A if you like Pat McGrath. Mariam is SO well versed in her reviews of pml!

[@carla3693]

They are apparently facing out the special blitz baked formula which is disappointing since is one of the reasons that I love her palettes

[@Gizmolover77]

Uuugghhh...not Loving the swatches at all!! The blitz shades used to be soooo Amazing!!! These are definitley no where near as pretty and sparkly as the former blitz shades!! Super disappointed!!!🥺

[@lacheinc]

CUTTING COSTS AND CHARGING MORE! UGHH!

[@J_loves_lu]

I agree friend however not all the special shades are baked … the baked ones are not housed in a pan (if this makes sense) the ones she’s releasing now are glittery but not baked & if you notice they are flat & have pans … again the previously baked special shades were kinda domed not flat & you could not see the pan hence they were baked into the palettes ❤ hope this helps & makes sense 😊

[@karmenfuentes7056]

@@carla3693exactly, me too

[@PattyBookh]

I think the disappointing aspect of her removing the baked Astro formula is that that was the only thing that made her different from any other Indian special shadow brand like clionadh, terra moons, give me glow, etc etc all of those companies have gorgeous eyeshadow but it’s that creamy chunky formula and now there’s no point in spending 130 on four special shades when you can get like 7/8 from clionadh for that amount andddd you can choose exactly what shades and I’m not gonna lie they’re better 😬😬😬 I do love the looks you created

[@aurigavega]

Exactly

[@celinag9968]

A moment of silence for the special shades…

[@RoseOfMadina]

Yes indeed. (Typo in your comment - indian/ indie)

[@debbieotoole1072]

💯 agree

[@lavayuki]

I never knew about the baked shades. I just have the Mothership 1, but from what point did she remove the baked blitz astral shades?

[@Kimbyroseh]

Thank you so much for showing us all of the comparisons! I was afraid I wasn’t going to like the color story in sunlit seduction, but after seeing comparisons, I think I’ll love it! I appreciate the comparisons so much! So many KZbinrs don’t want to bother comparing, and I get you can’t really compare formula, but comparing colors can be so helpful to show someone if they’ll maybe like this color story or not. Thank you so much!

[@danigirl1318]

If I was blocked for constructive criticism by a brand I would NEVER purchase from them again. Honestly its so so disappointing to hear they’ve done that I’m not sure I want to purchase this anymore. I was a definite yes before but that kind of behavior from a major company is wrong and again extremely disappointing and very disrespectful to their customers. Just my opinion

[@Observette]

Why would you take something a huge brand does on social media that seriously? Genuinely just wondering.

[@danigirl1318]

@@Observette I’m a small business owner. And I find it unbecoming. If you can’t take constructive criticism and feel the need to block loyal customers, for me, it’s time to move on and support another brand. Indie brands are honestly crushing it lately. The formulas, the color inspiration. Again just my opinion And no my business doesn’t have anything to do with the makeup industry.

[@lacheinc]

@@Observette you say this until it happens to you.

[@J_loves_lu]

@@Observettehonestly it’s rude & a slap in the face 🤷🏻‍♀️ it’s her hard core initial fans that IMO put PMG on the map & really blew up her brand & literally made her a billionaire overnight 😒 this is why most of her hardcore fans were annoyed & disappointed & if you are such a huge brand why not instead listen to ALL opinions good or bad ?! Deleting & blocking people (the ones that literally made her rich) is shady & off putting & it’s simply WRONG !

[@Amber86queenbee]

I have seen them block a small influencer for being the first person to show the Star Wars packaging was a sticker - posted only on their own personal IG channel so PML actively looked to block them. I’ve also seen them block customers for as little as stating “I’m not interested in blush but would love bronzer to be released”. It is so unprofessional for a brand to do this and they are literally blocking their own customers who have spent thousands previously. Why reduce your customer base - and kudos to Patty for calling this out!!

[@Yolli.Maceda]

I have her entire collection, plus a lot of palettes and singles from indie brands. I think I can definitely skip this, I hope she listen to her audience and bring the magic she used to have. I'm done with pinks is not my cup of tea. The look you created was beautiful, thank you for the video and the information!

[@meghasinghaniahmu]

That's kinda rude to say!

[@amiraking6688]

@@meghasinghaniahmustop riding so hard for Pat she doesn’t know who you are and really wouldn’t care if you dropped dead tomorrow

[@J_loves_lu]

@@meghasinghaniahmusorry but there was nothing rude about her comment 🤷🏻‍♀️ at the end of the day it’s just makeup & it boils down to preference … we can certainly agree to disagree but calling someone’s opinion rude is uncalled for 😒

[@Yolli.Maceda]

@@meghasinghaniahmu 🤯 How? I missed that part. 🤦🏻‍♀️

[@kr8882]

@@meghasinghaniahmuthat’s kinda rude for you to try to police a persons opinion.

[@raquelsenra3977]

Just to clarify, all the 4 special shades in Subliminal are baked, not only the 2 you mention. Same for the Motherships 2-8 except Decadence, of course. Mothership 9 had 3 baked shades. 10 and 11 have no baked shades. You have to look if the eyeshadows are in metal pans or not. Baked shades are not.

[@cassiel.6918]

I think her flakey formula is the only thing that sets PMG apart from indie brands, so I’m disappointed there are no baked flakey shades in this palette. I love the color story, but I already own a few pinky Huda palettes, and I prefer Huda’s mattes.

[@kr8882]

The special shades in this palette are like indie brands. Not her lovely fine milled formula.

[@mariakeogh1147]

I agree that it's not as similar as a lot of people thought, it definitely stands on its own. One thing I noticed when you swatched the special shades against the ritualistic rose astral quad is that the special shades seem to be less shiny and sparkly in this palette than her previous astral formula... I'll have to wait till I see it in person but for me this doesn't seem like a good thing

[@Sandycvgx]

The formula in the new Mothership is not a backed one, maybe that's the difference

[@mariakeogh1147]

@@Sandycvgx that definately could be the case, that there is more of a translucent base. I suppose we'll have to see when it's layered over a pigmented base like the Matt's. The Huetopian dream special shades though also have a translucent base and the sparkle off of those is blinding 😅

[@lacheinc]

no it dosent.... its just the same shades with different undertones.

[@kr8882]

I have the palette and today I have the purple one over my eyelid like a normal metallic shade. It has faded quickly and is not a topper shade at all.

[@mariakeogh1147]

@@kr8882 that's what I was afraid of. Mine came in today and I've just swatched them myself. Definitely not the same formula as previously. No where near as special 😔

[@adeleshand240]

I bought it with 20% off and free gift and really like the palette. Something about the undertones and the shades works perfectly with my deeper, warm toned complexion. I have every Mothership up to Midnight Sun then skipped everything since Divine Rose 1 including all the quads and 6 pans so this is a good collection of rosy shades I like that work for me and I would use on a daily basis.

[@ava8510]

I really like my Bridgerton 2 palette from Pat and I feel like nobody talks about how fun and diverse those shades are! I know it’s only 6 but I’ve gotten so many different types of looks with combining those with others in my collection. Love Pat but still haven’t loved a mothership enough myself, still excited about the brand tho!

[@rajeeii]

same! i feel like bridgeton 2 has similar pink astral and pink purple mattes that divine rose - sunlit offer so i never have fomo

[@exomake_mehorololo]

That's a good point. I think if you have both Bridgerton palettes you own basically all the pinks and mauves you need from PMG and in a great formula... If you add the Warm toned Love palette to the mix you're all set😅

[@NatalietheDoll]

I love the Bridgeton 2! I love colorful eyeshadows, but due to work and lifestyle, I rarely wear a shadow, and couldn't justify paying for a Mothership. The B2 was the first one I could afford that had so many colors I liked. I love pink shades, and I took that palette and used it as my only shadows for about 4 months of traveling. I got day to night looks, that I could wear to work, or more glam smokey or sparkly looks. I used it more over one summer than shadows I've had for ten years. I would honestly buy a second one!

[@vanessalamontagne4443]

So the Blitz shades are the ones that are pigment-rich and smooth, the Astrals are the flaky sparkles and the VR are the duochrome/multichrome shades. At least it appears that way outlined on her website. I think this is stunning, and my PML collection is curated enough that I plan to pick this up eventually on a sale.

[@Soapartisan875]

I think I’m going to buy this newest palette because those are my colors 😊. I don’t own any of her palettes except for a small quad of neutrals I received from the brand in a beauty box and I loved the creaminess and richness of her shadows❤ thank you for the review the palette is beautiful.

[@shellykozun3813]

Your ability to create beautiful eyeshadow looks fills me with envy!! You’re SO talented! I love all of the looks that you create!

[@mariakeogh1147]

She really hasn't done shades as sparkly as Huetopian dream since... They are just mind blowing

[@kieutran5983]

Appreciate your review of this palette. You always make the most stunning looks!! I have all the Motherships and a lot of her other palettes but I don't think I'll collect this one. Also, all the last 4 shades in the Motherships in the whole collection have been baked except for Moonlit Seduction and Sunlit Seduction. She hasn't released new true baked astral shades since the Bridgerton palettes. :(

[@kristentrep5038]

Is it beautiful? Yes!! It really is stunning! I’m going to enjoy my indie singles, and use my existing mother pat palettes with them! (FOR NOW!! Lol! When there’s a 30% sale, I’ll maybe scoop this beauty up!)

[@jillhiggins3246]

Patty, your comparisons were super helpful! I own #8 divine rose II as well as the ritualistic rose quad so I can pass on this palette. But it is gorgeous and warm colors look best on my skin tone. Also, with the texture of my eyelids, I prefer the older baked vs. the chunky glittery special shades. Thanks for this very thorough video! Your eye look is gorgeous and I can’t wait for the next 5!❤️🤗

[@shannondeppen1343]

Your looks are always absolutely stunning!!! You are incredibly talented. I follow quite a few people in the beauty community... and I have to say you are the guru of eye looks. You truly inspire me. Thank you. 😊

[@rree4551]

💖💖💖 First and foremost, your look you created is GORGEOUS and your hair today is lovely!! Secondly, congrats to you for doing an amazing ‘comparison’ section of this video! Great job and I truly appreciate your hard work! Now, I don’t have any PM palettes because I can’t justify the cost but if the price wasn’t a consideration or if it goes on a killer sale, THIS palette would be the one I would choose as it is the perfect curation of what I consider to be ‘my kind of neutrals’ color story…..the best of all compared swatches! I do understand others frustration but hey, it’s her brand. What I don’t like is what you mentioned in the beginning, about her IG and this whole ‘controversy’. Companies need to be careful with how they treat their customers. Not cool! And what I REALLY don’t understand (as someone who has owned businesses in the past) is WHY she hasn’t given her core , dedicated, money paying fans something different? A beautiful purple based palette with some silvers and a green or something palette?? She has the fan base… I don’t get it….?! And can someone please explain why, oh WHY, is she referred to as ‘Mother Pat’???? Seriously, why? Patty , thank you for another amazing video! xxx!💖💖💖

[@J_loves_lu]

Hey friend ❤ loved this comment & you’re not the first to ask this question 😂 PMG is called MOTHER because she’s so iconic & she’s been known as an icon for years before releasing her own makeup brand; Pat McGrath Labs; has been innovative & been known for her fashion runway shows where she was again known for her fashion & makeup artistry 😅 once she did release her own brand; she was already known as “the Mother of makeup” hence Mother Pat ❤

[@rree4551]

@@J_loves_lu thanks for the explanation and I appreciate it but I just think it’s kind of creepy (iconic mother thing….) . Innovative for sure, Iconic in the makeup artist and business realm ok…. But mother? Too far…..lol xx

[@J_loves_lu]

@@rree4551 LOL 😩🤣🤣🤣 I completely understand ! 😄

[@MissRayy21]

It’s not giving sunlit seduction. It’s giving Devine rose 3. The look came out pretty though.

[@girbgirl]

This is the first mothership I skipped on launch since I started purchasing from Pat. The warmth of the palette is great for my golden skin tone but I love Pat for her duo- and multi-chromes. My fave palette was huetopian dream for that reason - so many gorgeous special shades! If I get this one, I’m doing it while it’s on a 30% or more sale.

[@J_loves_lu]

I just received my palette today ❤ it’s pretty but nothing great, different or innovative to say the least … there are some really pretty shades BUT this is the first mothership palette released that doesn’t feel or look like the typical mothership palettes we used to know 😅 the back is now cheap gold plastic (it used to be a metal plate) & the “special” shades aren’t anymore but instead are just glitters 😢 even Alicia said she didn’t feel like this was a mothership 😮 alas I did get it at 30% off but I could’ve just passed … I do however own all her motherships & all her quads & most of her 6 pan palettes etc … this palette does appeal to the masses however which equates to money in sales & I also believe the target audience for this palette wasn’t her die-hard fans & collectors but those who didn’t have most of the previous mothership or are brand new to the brand 😒 ugh bummer ! But I’m still here to support Patty & see her beautiful looks & hear her thoughts 😊 now back to the video ❤

[@MiraclesandMessages333]

You perfectly summed up my thoughts. I missed the 30% off code but I don't know if I would've pulled the trigger either way. I'm actually gonna wait for 40% off, whether that be 1 or 2 years from now 🤷🏾‍♀️

[@KaliKali-hv9bt]

Wow thanks for sharing!!!❤❤❤

[@LisaF_]

The back isn’t even metal anymore? I hadn’t heard that. I’m guess it’s not surprising. I too have all of her MS (except this one) and 99% of everything else she’s ever released. This mothership is so disappointing. I’d not even complain (much) about this repetitive color story if there were baked shades. Anyone can make sparkly shimmers. The baked shades are so versatile and different than what other sparkly shades can do. It’s sad to me.

[@J_loves_lu]

@@LisaF_ I completely agree !!! I miss those delicious baked formulas & especially think about her initial 3 special shades quads she released 🤔🥰👌🏼 as a matter of fact im wearing one of those quads in my pic … nocturnal nirvana 🤩 it’s these shades that I miss ! You’re so right about the sparkly shades too … at this point with indie brands those shades can be found anywhere 🤷🏻‍♀️ but Mother Pats baked special shades were STILL something special & truly unique ☺️ this “mothership” is just so meh 😭

[@J_loves_lu]

@@LisaF_ and yes I was shocked when I turned the palette around 😱 … ugh it’s just kinda sad 🥺

[@zbluesy]

It's unfair that I wasn't allowed to use the 30 percent off code that others were (and honestly not sure why). I would have been thrilled to get it at 30 percent off and get the gift that came with it that others got. While I have almost every single mothership palette (except for the Naomi Campbell one with the green shade, because I wasn't crazy about it, it was an early one), I have to say that these are my colors and I will wear this every day, which justifies it for me. Right now, I do this with the Natasha Dennona "My Dream Palette." I love mauvy pinks and roses. I love that deep plummy shade probably best of all for some reason. This looks great on you. We have the exact same coloring, so I know this will work for me too. Another reason to get it. Especially since I'm someone in a hurry always and I don't want to comb through more than one palette to put on an eye look for the day. Plus, they don't last forever. I'd rather spend the money on something I will wear every day, than all these special shades I've been buying that I love to look at but ultimately rarely end up wearing. So... I ended up getting the set with the primer (so it's like getting primer free), with 10 percent coupon AND I got a pair of the Bridgerton lipsticks that I love (nude ones) for $30... and she threw in that eye liner, mini lipstick duo, which is nice for traveling (free)... this is why I am the queen of rationalization.

[@luisacampbell619]

Really useful video. I have 9 motherships, but will definitely be passing on this one. Pat's next palette should be her Redemption palette!

[@alissa02]

This is a very cohesive and beautiful palette but considering the price point I'm a bit disappointed. Not only does it look veeeery close to mothership IX, I think it's just a bit too safe and neutral for a palette this expensive. Thank you tho for this great review and comparison.❤️

[@elizabethjones2]

I would love to see someone just take any shades of their pat collection (like a shade from any palette that they think would be similar) to try and make a similar look compared with the new palette. That would be interesting to see if they would look pretty much the same once on the eye.

[@shellykozun3813]

I really appreciate your comparisons and your live swatches!!

[@michelleh7968]

What I’m irritated with is the early launch with the discount working for some people but not for all. Either the discount works for everybody or not at all.

[@zbluesy]

Me too! I don't want to buy it on that alone. I just missed being able to use the 30 percent off. It really bugs me.

[@Hannashome]

I think it’s very similar to recent pink/rosy palettes but for me this is the PERFECT palette. All the shades I love the most in one palette. They shipped my order and I’m supposed to get it on Monday. Very excited. It’s not very nice to delete comments and block people on Instagram. I haven’t seen the comments but I think in general it’s better to give constructive criticism like ”I’m a big fan and would love to see a different colour story. This is very similar to earlier palettes.” Instead people can be very harsh on social media and it’s not uncommon to see mean things being said. Noone reacts well to that kind of comments, so if you want a dialogue and get your point through it’s better to say it in a constructive way. I am no saint and have been upset over things and said things in a not so nice way, but you don’t get someone to listen that way. Anyhow, back to watching this awaited review and enjoy a good cup of coffee. Have a good day ❤

[@nicolawillis1581]

It’s less gold than it looked in the promo pictures, but even pinker lol. Think it’s her pinkest one yet. I really liked the baked shadows, I think they age better too. Creamy shadows go off quicker i think. I bought it for 30%, as I think it’s nice for that price and I will use a lot of the colours, but I don’t think it’s as special as some of the other motherships.

[@ivonneperez6921]

Lovely look Patty! I would rather have another pink palette than another green one. Especially if it is Pat McGrath!

[@Anic6500]

I’m so glad that YOU took the time to hear the customer feedback on pats “pink” palette problem! I think that when a brand does a certain product well they get stuck in a rut… like charlotte’s pillow talk… there’s so many of them and nars’ orgasm… you get it! We get it, but the company’s do not!! So thank you for being brave enough to call it/her out!!

[@lucysbeautyroom]

Hi Patty👋, I love Pat McGrath Eyeshadow Palettes as well her formula is Amazing, I love the makeup look you came up with. You are definitely a Natural Makeup Artist. I love watching you do your transformations you really outdo yourself always, and you're always so informative and very helpful with your comparisons I really love that about you. Thank you for Sharing your thoughts and feelings with us, have a Beautiful Blessed Day ❤️ 🐾

[@CamilleRodriguez]

This was beautiful on you. Your looks are always beautiful! I feel like I can get the same look or very similar with her 7th & 9th palette. I can’t wait to see her holiday palette. I’m hoping there is more variety of earthy tone colors in it 🤞🏼🤞🏼🤞🏼

[@manicagency]

Mine is in transit, i live in the uk so its shipping from the us. Anticipated to receive it. The social media team for the brand newd to find a better approach then blocking people, its very poor move

[@rabbiroz3806]

Per usual, your look is DIVINE! You ALWAYS make every palette look gorgeous. While this is a similar color story to PM’s other palettes, I actually like this better than Mothership’s 8 and 9; it is more wearable to me than those and a warmer version of the original Divine Rose, which is also easy to wear. I really liked Number 10 with all of the Taupes too. This is her aesthetic and it is beautiful. I totally agree though that they should not delete people’s critical comments; it is not a good business practice or ethical.

[@stephaniesharpe1359]

Such a gorgeous look! I think you’ve convinced me 🤣🤣😍

[@karenp3278]

That was a very thorough comparison to other Pat palettes! Thanks Patty.🥰

[@clairefurness7809]

Thank you for comparing the new palette to the one from from Valentine’s Day this year. I haven’t bought this new one yet. I am very on the fence. Sigh. 😣

[@steffygg]

Love watching your videos, swatches, and tutorials Patty! I will not be picking this up anytime soon… not sure I will want it at 30-40% off either. For those who do not already have any mothership palettes, this may be a good pickup. As a collector and lover of makeup, it’s hard to pass on a mothership palette, even though I already have these shades 3 times over. I agree with you on the red shimmer shade. Thank you for your review! You are so enjoyable to watch! 🤩

[@lucianarodriguesdesouza2973]

I loved the color story and can not wait to receive my palette. The look you created is amazing! I love something basic and well done.

[@Dreaminlace]

I was among those who went …… over the color story but ordered anyway bc I’m a sucker for Pat. Her mattes seem to have gotten even BETTER (as if it were possible) and the palette has found a place in my heart. Excellent thorough review!

[@janearcher3834]

I was kind of on the fence about this new palette, but after seeing your look, I think the colors work together much better than other palettes. Your look is sublime.

[@karlaggarza]

Gorgeous eye look! Palette is basic but gorgeous, totally picking this up, those astral shadows are to die for! Last Mothership I got was X and V is my top favorite 🙌🏻🔝🖤

[@rebeccawainwright4515]

It’s basic, that’s true, and I tend to be a basic B myself, but I’ll wait to get it on sale. You make the most beautiful looks and I always love watching your videos!

[@arianalunsford836]

Well it seems so similar . But I can’t resist I have the whole collection. Bought at full price no codes worked … used your link . I don’t like Devine rose 2 . Do the way I see it . This may be the improved more wearable version . Thank for your video ❤

[@stormomega37]

The palette is beautiful. Yes it is another rose palette; nonetheless, I am here for it. Her formula is beautiful!! I am buying❤❤

[@EbonyNikitaElegance]

The 1st thing I though of was the ritualistic rose quad. I always wanted her to expand & create a palette based on that color story

[@deboraspolaor474]

This look Is really a 'pillow talk intense' look! So lovely!

[@MrsH18]

I was feeling meh about this palette at first, I wasn’t going to get it but then I magically got it early and at 30% off! I’m super glad that I did because I’ve worn it for the last 2 days and I’m in love. Honestly I think it could even be my favourite and I have 9 out of the 11 motherships. It’s like Charlotte Tilbury pinks but elevated to a new level.

[@favoritosbenitez4972]

Same ❤

[@WestEndGirl_]

Hello from Germany 😊 Thanks for this video. Before I saw your video, I thought I don't need this new MS 11, but now I love it. Your look is so beautiful. Also thanks for the comparisions with MS7 (this one I have already). Now I have to wait for the next 30%-Event... xoxo 😊

[@monikapajewska9751]

Hi, Patty thanks for your honest feedback, I just love watching your reviews❤I like this colour story, but I am not a collector of Motherships so if I had more of them I'd probably be dissapointed.

This colors fits you perfectlyy😍😍😍 i understand it’s boring but could be perfect everyday palette where I will use every single shadow!

[@playgirl44]

Patty, I’d love to see a comparison of the browns and golds from all the palettes. There’s so many of them 😅 I want to choose the ones I like! And def would love a quad or quint with all special shades

[@Jennifer_Elliott]

I have all of the Motherships and this one is the first that I can't see myself purchasing. Even when it goes on sale; I feel like I have it already. I don't understand what they were thinking...

[@MiraclesandMessages333]

Yes lol.. the collector in me is secretly crying on the inside 😂

[@rallara]

Really appreciated your point at the start of the video on the way the customer feedback is being handled. It's a disrespectful attitude towards loyal customers and lacks professionalism. What a dissapointing attitude. If this was my company, a few people would be let go. The customer feedback is a basic & efficient measurement of success for any business, and in long term will definitely beat the sale numbers which will drop in time without a good marketing strategy... Anyway, wasting my breath.🙄 Thanks Patty, loved the video. Not so much the pallette though. I stopped buying at Divine rose 2. 🌹 ❤

[@karenflores8261]

I’m loving the look you did with the palette, I was thinking about skipping this palette but you make me rethink my decision.

[@julsz528]

I have a couple of her palettes but I feel it’s boring to me now .. and the way they approached this to their customers is so unacceptable and unprofessional and I won’t be buying anything more from her .. she needs to change her style and maybe look at the color wheel and see there is so many other colors to do and would kill it in sales other then pink !! Jmo

[@AUSTniah-ug3zs]

1st look patty created is so glamorous 😻

[@deborahcates]

Your feedback regarding the deleted comments is spot on! 🧐

[@juliam1573]

I think that it’s beautiful- and you’re excitement is contagious- I bought it. I just think all of those saying “I’m not buying this one” are just procrastinating- they’ll eventually pick it up. It’s a mothership after all.

[@jayadora]

As someone with 4 of her palettes, I will say, I'm 100% not buying her palettes again. They are not bad, but not special against the many indie brands I own that frankly, blow her palettes out of the water completely. Formula and colorstory wise.

[@JackOllie4]

​@@jayadoraI agree! Indie brands have rolled right past Pat McGrath!

[@Amber86queenbee]

A lot of people saying they won’t buy it aren’t actually procrastinating though. Yes a lot of people will wait for a sale but you also have to remember how inflation has been this year and that people are being a lot more careful to not buy too many similar palettes anymore especially at that price point. I can very easily afford to buy this but at this point there is 0 excitement for this one.

[@juliam1573]

My point is as a collector, I have the want to complete the collection- yes the colors are similar to others, but it’s always an all day formula and always makes me look like I know what I’m doing when I wear her brand. Lol.

[@Deanna0456]

Im getting this one. I’m going to be honest. This is the perfect bronze rose palette for me. I have all of the motherships except 7 (it was just not a pink palette I would use). I’m going to give away a few of my palettes anyway because I don’t use them. Literally mothership 1-4 I barely use. So as much as I’ve complained I’m really more basic than I think 🤣. She skipped the golds this time and I’m so proud. As much as I love a good gold I was over that more than the pink 🤣

[@courtneybaeyen]

I appreciate the swatch comparison. Especially with number 7.

[@EbonyNikitaElegance]

I already have this color story…BUT NOT WITH THE PML FORMULA, so yes I will be buying the pinky neutral color story I’ve been wanting from Pat for years

[@karolg206]

❤❤ been refreshing after seeing your KZbin short !!

[@kerriwright4593]

My favorite special shadow from her is in the v mothership, the top far right one. For some reason that one has the most special special shimmers lol but they do tend to leave sparkles falling all day. Idc though, so pretty.

[@nicolastanislaus1975]

Superb review as always and STUN-NING eye look! Can’t wait to get this on my eyes!

[@lavayuki]

I would like another cool toned palette like the Mothership 1, that is my favourite one. I also liked the shimmers in the Heutopian

[@SarahB1133]

I think the mothership 9 is similar to the 11 but more versatile

[@nadiadncr]

Clicked so fast! I love PML and this is a beautiful palette but I think I’ll wait for a sale because I feel I might have something similar from her in my collection 💕 great review Patty

[@RebeccaLavin-je3pt]

Please do a tutorial for the subversive look you did in the reaction video! It was so pretty!!!

[@davidamathis9627]

Mother Pat likes pink. We do too. I threw out my Divine Rose II and Heutopian Dream palettes to make room for Sunlit Seduction. It arrived today and I know I’m going to love it. Great video!

[@mariavega7855]

Awesome review and as always. - your are the master of blending. You achieved a beautiful look.

[@donnatatham4594]

I really enjoyed watching this video, I think all your comparisons and swatches were so informative.I’m so glad I didn’t buy this palette as there just too close to other mothership palettes.

[@MakeupwithMariela1]

I will be passing on this palette but I did order those velour lashes they look stunning on you with the look! 👌🏼😻

[@beatrizsalamon3785]

I would like to give a video suggestion. You could create a PM dream mothership palette. You choose the most beautiful colors you would like to see in a perfect mothership.

[@RB-gx8ss]

I agree, the palette is much prettier in person. I too thought about the ritualistic rose quad for comparison of the one special shade. I am glad I have picked it up .Mothership 11 is a everyday Mothership palette with the ability to glam up with the four special shades. This not a bad thing going forward, however we do need different colour stories.

[@donnal.7366]

This reminds me of the CT pillow talk quad and the Pillowtalk twelve pan palette.

[@anitablanca5050]

Mine is on the way I’m actually excited 😂

[@maricela.torres]

Thank you for the review, I am going to get this palette after having skipped on a some of the previous launches. Looking forward to your five looks with this beauty, thank you for the creative and lovely looks you share with us!

[@fridaoropeza8965]

I love that it looks like a softer palette as in the mattes will suit people of fair to medium skin a lot better if they want a softer look, which I think is nice because is more wearable and given that this palettes are so expensive I think one can justify buying them more.

[@lesleawitter5534]

I thoroughly enjoyed your review, Patty! I absolutely love your eye look, and look forward to seeing your 5 eye looks with this gorgeous palette. Personally, I think this is a beautiful palette by Pat McGrath. I didn’t start purchasing her motherships until she came out with the rose editions. In fact, my very first palette was the Ritualistic Rose eyeshadow quad. After that, I was hooked! Lol It was really interesting seeing the comparisons of those palettes, and actually refreshing. I ordered this palette, so I’m really excited to get it, especially after seeing how beautifully these apply.

[@HisLivingWater]

Thank you for all the comparisons, it really was great!!

[@kerrikelly4016]

Your look was just stunning! I just love all your reviews! ❤

[@tameikatoorie3634]

This colour story makes your eyes really pop Patty. Love it on you, not so sure how I feel about it. I’ll wait until she has a sale maybe

[@collettedaniels3884]

I’ll wait for next year’s release of Starlit Seduction ⭐️⭐️⭐️

[@RoseOfMadina]

😂

[@vivipassionmakeup]

Hello Patty ! Thank you so much for this super complete video you are the best ! 👏🏻👏🏻 Your look is beautiful, I can't wait to see your 5 looks ! 🥰 Xoxo 😘

[@celinag9968]

Fantastic comparisons and I loved how you organized them.

[@anotheremma4565]

This looks more neutral-warm than true warm. The matte shades are so similar and I have Huetopian Dreams already but the astral-blitz make me want it too

[@karrinadusablon9738]

I think it to similar to what I already have. What an amazing video really helps to see if someone will buy it. So thoughtful

[@chinadoll7951]

The color you dislike the most is the color I like the most 😂 I love the red shade. Great review!

[@celinag9968]

I recently decluttered 90% of my PM, mostly because it was old! But I’m not repurchasing anything.

[@naturallyingrid]

Wow! Patty, thanks for getting this up so quickly. To me, it looks like if you have #9 you don’t really need #11. Edited to ask: do you think you can dupe this palette using only shades from other PM palettes?

[@Tified967]

Great question I've been testing this hypothesis!

[@nicoleraps4272]

I have MS 8 only and do love the rose tones. I am liking the warmer tones too. Thank you for swatching this one and doing the comparisons. Depends on what I can afford but I like the look of the matt formula.