Patrick Jane Relives a Painful Memory

[@adoreonly]

This scene literally broke my heart. Simon Baker nailed it.

[@shreeshashreekumar1773]

I forgot which episode it is

[@adoreonly]

Shreesha Shreekumar S1E07

[@shreeshashreekumar1773]

@@adoreonly thanks ☺️♥️

[@adoreonly]

@@shreeshashreekumar1773 (ෆ˙ᵕ˙ෆ)

[@judyosborne]

The love Patrick Jane had for his wife and daughter is shown without a word in the last 30 seconds of this video. POWERFUL and extraordinary acting!

[@victorpradha9946]

Lots of parallels in Monk and the Mentalist from the standpoint of personal loss. Monk lost Trudy and clung to her for years and sought to find her killer...never knowing his identity. Somehow though, in Mentalist, the story was more deeply affecting AND more visceral. Jane's pain was more palpable because unlike in Monk, Jane's loss was attributable to his own arrogance.

[@scotty6858]

Watch Jane's face slowly drop as Kristina speaks. He briefly holds it together as she walks away, then breaks down when he believes no one's looking. Van Pelt does see, and slowly closes the door and walks away to let him grieve in peace. This man is carrying around a lot of grief and guilt.

[@AnantharajJack]

What grace did in the the end is nice

[@Arthur-jy2so]

She always goes into rooms at the wrong time lol it happens too much haha

[@fallreflections08]

that's really nice how Grace gives him privacy

[@doctorwho415]

simon baker is a brilliant actor. my heart is breaking. i love how the mentalist has elements of fun, but can move effortlessly into scenes of extreme emotion! this is a truly amazing show.

[@millieo7155]

This is the most natural, believable cry scene I have ever watched.

[@CursedCero]

Your wife wanted me to tell you that "Your daughter never woke up, she didn't know what happened, she wasn't scared not even for a second " The amount of emotion that Jane emits is just beyond anything, After I heard her say that I literally broke into tears,

[@victorpradha9946]

Jane would be desperate to believe THIS. It would have been interesting to have Jane ask RJ this particular thing (was my daughter awake when you killed her...blink once for no, twice for yes).

[@smurfyday]

@@victorpradha9946 You're missing the point. He was crying because he saw what happened to them and Frye was talking out of her ass. She believed her BS and didn't care this would cause Jane more pain.

[@Lucy9596]

@@smurfyday I never thought of that but you are probably right.

[@hirakaiko5570]

@@victorpradha9946 He'd want to believe it but he knew it wasn't true - he mentions at some point that Red John's killings like this (planned and with his trademark) are always done with the victim awake, so he can see their fear. If anything, this was just cruel of her to say - or rather a cruel reminder his daughter died terrified.

[@GrammeStudio]

how insensitive , selfish, deluded, oblivious, and self-righteous do you have to be to bring up a man's painful memory while being aware that he doesn't believe your psychic power. he's not getting the comfort because he doesn't believe in power, hence your story of meeting his late wife is fake to him but he suffered because you brought up the painful memory. how outrageous.

[@SolusDarkcoat]

Agreed

[@adriandoe1090]

Yes, quite stupid, as everyone know that jane is suffering, but for him, at least to hear "she (his daughter) died peacefully" can make a little relief.

[@jacob7110]

He seriously is one of my favorite actors. He can act soooo good. Gives me goosebumps!

[@alalducente]

i think she did a nice thing. hearing those words gave jane a little comfort instead sadness when he remembers them

[@Exactix]

@@alalducente it gave him no comfort because he knew she was a fraud , the daughter probably suffered too there was no way he didnt wake her up during the murder

[@keksnaselive9951]

Why do I have the urge to cry?

[@callanightshade8079]

keksnase live because this was something that cut him deep. And even though he didn't wanna think about it he was just relieved that someone was willing to tell him, even if it was a lie, that his daughter didn't wake up when she was being murdered and wonder where her dad was

[@adriandoe1090]

Cus u r gay

[@thomasdessoye9935]

Adrian Doe Genius. Bravo. You really got ‘em good by telling them that.

[@Farzadhoss]

You know this scene is great but I also love the scene in which a woman tells him that if you find happiness never let go of it and Patrick sighs with that look in his eyes, full of sorrow and regret.

[@ananthunair5488]

In which episode

[@zumabbar]

i believe it was A Dozen Red Roses, the one about murder of someone who's involved in an still-on-production movie, and the woman was the main actress in the movie and the killer in the episode. i remember this because the woman was played by Rebecca Rigg, Simon Baker (who plays Jane)'s wife! so that scene was so cute at the time since it was done by them

[@barbaranicoliche5318]

@@ananthunair5488 Temporada 1:19

[@l.a.3479]

Ex-wife, now ​@@zumabbar

[@lyricsposter33]

I think Kristina actually tricked herself into believing she's a physic

[@angelaaltintas863]

no, more likely someone is planting ideas in her head.

[@gsp2176]

@@angelaaltintas863 yea maybe bret Stiles

[@shadowproductions7829]

Auto suggestion, it's a term in psychology that states, if you tell a lie long enough it becomes reality, it becomes reality quicker if you believe it as well

[@funkychannel8481]

There is one qoute in psichollogy, it goes like "you are a cop as long as you belive you are a cop". So if you are telling a lie long eaugh, you'll eventualy start to belive in it.

[@Egilhelmson]

Certainly true for Jane, given that he had been making his living as a fake psychic until he gave a psychological profile of Red John on the TV, to which RJ objected, and expressed his displeasure by killing Jane’s family in their house.

[@PwnzerProductions]

Am I the only one who hated her the whole time she was on the show?

[@wilsonjacob1223]

PwnzerProductions me too

[@ivanbombana9481]

She is hated in Italy too😡😡

[@stingfan16ify]

I may be in the minority but I really liked her and I also liked them together. Not as much as with Lisbon of course, but that seemed out of the realm of possibility then.

[@marystyles7769]

Hated her in suits

[@mayaamis]

yes both character and actress are unlikable and annoying

[@ARCproductionsgirl]

dude when I first saw this on TV and our DVDs and stuff I almost started crying cause Jane like.... never cries!! And it's just heartbreaking to watch that.... :'( What a good actor!!!!!!

[@jarvais56]

Oh my goodness. If I could reach through my screen and give him a hug I'd totally do it in a heartbeat. Poor Jane...

[@NAVEENSINGH-km1fb]

jarvais56 no hug.. just slap that bitch

[@reginaejames2602]

I feel so bad for him. Which monster would do that to a person ? he is a human being u know, and he has feelings.

[@Calriec]

You know, I got teary-eyed too. TV shows rarely get to me; maybe it was just Simon Baker's superb acting or the idea of an innocent child getting killed, but damn! This was heartbreaking.

[@Karkar82]

He's so beautiful! I want to give him a big big hug!

[@OkayAlright]

What makes this scene worse is pactrick knows she's lying because in season 4 he says during court red John wakes up every single victim he's murdered and pactricks known this since the first day of research making this hit even harder when you come back to it

[@l.a.3479]

*Patrick

[@Jean_Genie]

OMG this is soooooo sad, simon baker is an amazing actor! I was so close to tears...powerful stuff

[@markraymond101]

I never believed Kristina Simon the "psychic." To me, she told him this just to generate a reaction.

[@teddiebat]

Well, now that my heart's been broken for the day....

[@chelseabtvs]

ahh he is such a good actor and i love the way he plays a funny psychic and realy he has such a sad history as such

[@andrewmurray409]

That is so evil, to fuck with him like that :/

[@nicktroisi6347]

2:07 Jane’s pain breaks me everytime

[@PurpleNinja8D]

I wanna hug him :'(

[@Cheseeslot]

Me too :(

[@Voileen]

it was good to see this because I was beginning to wonder if he was ever going to be emotional about his wife and child being killed (he is always so cheery!) This really showed that and Simon did great!

[@Egilhelmson]

See the last few minutes of the pilot episode. He sleeps in an empty house (his) on a futon where his (and his wife’s) bed had been, under the bloody image that Red John left.

[@LLKCKS12]

This made me want to cry :( Poor Jane

[@SamuelHabekotte]

I showed this to my sis, who is overly dramatic, and she cried until I picked her up and put her in bed! Still it was a sad part of the series and I love this serie! So thanks for putting this up!

[@tatianalyulkin410]

It's incredibly accurate. The tears come first. Then the rage.

[@city.street.lights]

+maria maldonado it means his daughter was asleep at the time red john came & she didnt wake up when he cut her or watever & killed her. Which in a way means she didnt feel its pain.

[@scotty6858]

Jane was (and still is, afterwards) skeptical about Kristina's ability, but when she tells him about his wife, he takes her word for it...

[@dflaming1371]

I don't think so. I think that the comforting words are warring with hoe doubt. He wants what Kristina said to be true. But RJ awakens his victims always to see these fear, and Jane doesn't believe in psychics. But what father wants to believe their baby died in pain. I think, as per usual, Kristina hurt him deeper by flapping her mouth, yet Jane still wants to believe theses hope it was truth

[@dduduru_k5881]

‘’Your daughter never woke up, she didn’t know what happend. she wasn’t scared. Not even for a second.’’ this sentence make me feel something that i could’t describe

[@SG1Mitchell]

season 1, episode 7, Seeing Red

[@r6uocs]

This is so sad! Amazing show!

[@yaniquepalmer]

That look on his face at 2:11 was heartbreaking😞😔😢

[@nicktroisi6347]

Simon can act and just the thought of hearing how his daughter didn't wake up while Red John murdered her mother and herself is just gut wrenching. I'm watching the Mentalist right from the beginning and man I hope Jane finds Red John and makes him pay and suffer. Don't spoil anything please

[@AnnLafemme]

Oh this one is so sad. He loves his wife and his daughter so much. Sosweet

[@lilrice15]

that scene made me cry so much poor jane

[@jaredt-f3007]

Red John's M,O is waking them up to c their faces as he kills then

[@shishirnair4563]

Another theory may be that this was the first time Red John killed someone out of revenge, especially a child. Hence perhaps what Christina said could be true, because she knew what was haunting jane.

[@Potahsium]

I’m a bit late, but doesn’t Red John wake their victims up first because he wants to see them suffer? Or am I wrong?

[@Whynot83848]

She was lying, she's not a real psychic

[@TVmieliesMAD]

I KNW I cry every single time i watch this epi- its sooo sad...

[@CalmCommotion]

thanks so much for your comment. It makes more sense now :) You answered all the questions I had lol ^^

[@SG1Mitchell]

@FenstenSpn She was returned but she's in basically a comatose state. Red John hypnotized her into thinking she had died.

[@shubhisehgal2447]

Wat a scene so real ❤️❤️ as if Simon was feeling the same way....

[@klcarr892]

@SG1Mitchell No...in redwood, Patrick has a flashback to his wife and daughter playing the piano. She's young but she's not an infant. She could have been in her mother's room for many reasons... or RJ could have just put the two together... she looked about 5 ears old in the flashback.

[@l.a.3479]

*years

[@SG1Mitchell]

@ajones1113 Sorry, poor theory. That doesn't explain her death, with no weapon around, the Red John face on the wall and Jane's flashback to finding them dead with the note from Red John. Red John has also left mocking calls and notes to Jane. He's the whole point of the show.

[@L105343]

I wanna give him a hug!!

[@TheWinnerOfTheDinner]

Kristina: I talked to your wife...(Patrick begins to stop her) ah, ah... (Kristina pauses) Ever since your wife and daughter were killed, there's a question about that night's events that's been tormenting you, yes? Yes? Patrick: Yes. Kristina: Your wife wants me to tell you that your daughter never woke up. She didn't know what happened. She wasn't scared, not even for a second. Patrick: Are you done channeling? That's it? Kristina: That's it. Patrick: Thanks. Kristina: Goodbye,MrJane

[@nightingalesrealm5566]

howdy- lovely So why did you write the whole text? Thought we couldn’t hear it? 😒

[@Yldaro]

@@nightingalesrealm5566 don't bully my man 8 years later, this is emotional.

[@negarlambert]

thank you so much xo

[@Ridgepack]

I think a lot of people are missing the point, that yes even if the scenario that "your daughter never woke up, she didn't know what happened, she wasn't scared not even for a second" is an unrealistic scenario, for jane it is believeable because it's supposed to be a message from his wife. His wife would know his grief, and would want him to feel at least a little more at ease even if it's not the full truth, and that makes Kristinas message so much more important to him.

[@smurfyday]

Nope, you're missing the point. Frye met a ghastly end at the hands of RJ, knowing Jane's experience and repeating the same mistake, shows she's delusional. And Bruno Heller confirmed there wasn't any real psychic on the show, even if he didn't go as far as saying there couldn't have been (on the show... he himself didn't believe). So anyone who thinks there's any truth to Frye's ramblings lack either comprehension or logic.

[@ashleywass4]

sorry, but after she was kidnapped by red john what happened to her? I never saw that issue concluded. If anyone knows the episode that it's resolved in please reply with it or just tell me what happened that would work too. Thanks.

[@smurfyday]

It was in a later season. She got broken mentally.

[@EmmerDoucheface]

they eventually found her in an abandoned house with tubes attached to her body to take blood, when they interviewed her she wouldn't speak, so Jane got a candle and 'called' her spirit and she told him she was dead even though her body is still physically alive.

[@victorpradha9946]

Which means that RJ made her watch as he killed someone...killing her spirit to see such depravity. She witnessed unspeakable horrors. She was left alive as a message from RJ to Jane...that he seeks to break Jane's spirit before finally killing Jane!

[@CBiscuit221B]

that almost made me cry. :(

[@unpredictable920]

It's amazing how he can just cry on que like that.

[@l.a.3479]

*cue

[@hollyshepherd101]

This is soooooooooooooo sad! :(

[@judyosborne]

@Hellobooboo11 , This episode from the first season was titled "Seeing Red".

[@Palmen1990]

@SG1Mitchell for deaf people

[@TheWinnerOfTheDinner]

@CJDobstar3010 the reason i did that for two things, first one is that i liked these moments secondly there is some ppl who didn't get every word in this and especially the australian accent and most of ppl here don't speak the english very well and they would appreciate that

[@OnyxBizarre]

Thank you

[@skyraiman]

You can just feel how much he wants to smack her for telling such a obvious lie

[@montannaleveque2907]

Well that was depressing

[@SG1Mitchell]

@000andreo000 wow. really you're asking that? his wife and daughter were killed a year or two prior to the series beginning by a serial killer named Red John who Patrick mocked on television

[@Farzadhoss]

Wow, that's a toughie. Well I did some research and it's episode 19 in the first season. A Dozen Red Roses.

[@klcarr892]

@SG1Mitchell I'm sorry. I realize that sounded rude. I didn't mean for it to come out like that. Just didn't want you to have missed such a great ep/scene. Thanks for posting this one by the way. The mentalist is my new favorite show and my previous favorite show was SG-1 so... double thumbs up. Sorry again for sounding so rude in my previous post.

[@juliannamontanna]

that was just cruel of her .. did she really think he would now believe she is a psychic when any person in janes position would have tortured themselve with the question if his daughter woke up

[@MrsPresleyLennonFrey]

One of the standout scenes in the series. It not only reveals that Christina is in fact blessed with a gift, but confirms what keeps Patrick awake at night... It also shows Grace's compassion for Patrick. I cried when I first saw this. Xshewanx, I wanted to hug him too! I still do!

[@kayequinn7146]

Watching the series again as it just began being broadcast on TV. Never forgot this scene. Definitely didn't like her & I think it was a cruel thing to do to Patrick. I think a part of him so desperately wishes it were true which makes it even more painful to know 💔 😢 it isn't. Either way,true or not I would never ever bring myself to do that. Grace's actions were so quiet and kind.

[@millieo7155]

Silently closing the door. Powerful.

[@ferardforever]

omg i remember this episode And at this part at the end i was crying too omg i love the MENTALSIT!

[@jakerams4505]

I cried.

[@Serienjunky08]

falls du den Titel der Folge meinst, der ist Stimmen aus dem Jenseits

[@CantStayAway]

"...your wife wants me to tell you that your daughter never woke up." ...such a touching/emotional scene!!!!

[@smurfyday]

From someone who knows Jane's story and still taunted RJ on TV, yeah, she's telling the truth. I also have a bridge to sell you.

[@CantStayAway]

@@smurfyday something tells me your bridge doesn't extend all the way, so no thank you.

[@SG1Mitchell]

@SwamiEpstein Yes, this was her first appearance

[@tivamcabby5]

awsome scene...i want to start bawling when Simon Baker cries :(

[@aliihsan162]

The music in this scene couldnt find it, any help?

[@janewhiting2741]

Jane knows that RJ woke his victims before killing them because he liked to see their suffering and here Kristina is saying otherwise, which is probably not true. Maybe she is misguidedly trying to offer comfort but i think only Jane knows what his family went through because he saw them. Now he has to relive that memory.

[@steffiigirl2890]

How can she just shut the door like that? I just want to give him the biggest hug ever. It was so sad it made me cry as well, i would just walk in there and give him a hug, it was all so sad

[@luce1F]

I don't know how someone can be stabbed to death and not wake up lmao. Red John, it never appeared to me, killed quickly and painlessly. And I don't even know if you can stab someone to death that quick. Just empty words. Seems like she was out to get Jane more than to help him. Must have been ironic to Jane when she did exactly what he did all his life.

[@sentiews]

SIMPLY AMAZING!

[@SwamiEpstein]

Wait, is that Kristina from the season 2 finale???

[@7777Scion]

@FenstenSpn She's not evil. She truly believes in what she says. And she and Patrick Jane were dating right before she was kidnapped. Don't be too hard on her, whether you believe in her 'power' or not.

[@SG1Mitchell]

@ganja238 No Patrick proved that that man was named Thomas Carter, an associate of Red John hired to bait Jane. Red John has already killed again in season 4, spurred on by Jane to kill a man who was going to get away with murder. Jane got the murderer to insult Red John on TV...

[@supervman2366]

SG1Mitchell

[@McShewan]

This has to be my favourite scene - the raw emotion is just..... awesome =( The fact that he crys makes you think "He must be aching inside =(" Lisbon and Jane need a chance - they get on with each other and he could really open up to her =( I love simon baker =( =D xo ly

[@Kitjo2]

She saw his vulnerability when he was lying down and couldn't resist.

[@negarlambert]

can you tell me which episode that was plz ?I

[@abcilylib24]

awww jane crying breaks my heat!!!

[@l.a.3479]

*heart

[@sachinK_music]

Please tell me season and episode number?

[@ashleywass4]

Intresting. Thanks. Do you know which episode that was in?

[@TVmieliesMAD]

who do u two think it is? who's red john. i seriously have no idea. Plz message me if u can..

[@dwROXthehouse16]

which episode is this from???????

[@OnyxBizarre]

dear T_T so sad :'( From which episode is that taken ?

[@JonnyBauer]

A great scene. The Mentalist is the best show of it's kind as far as I'm concerned. This does in no way though prove that this lady was psychic. If I was in Patrick's position that question would torment me. I think it would torment any parentwho'd lost their family the way he did. Empathy is all you'll need to make this prediction.

[@SG1Mitchell]

1.07 Seeing Red

[@Lolynette93130]

Poor Patrick :'(

[@SG1Mitchell]

You must be thinking of something else. Maybe he had a dream. Can't remember. She was always an infant. Remember, the wife and daughter were dead in the same room. She was a baby.

[@neyo509]

who is red john her becuase i missed the finale

[@desigb]

@jnshaley Yes,she is.The serial killer,Red Josh,who they are searching for killed her and his daughter.

[@breakawayx3]

His wife and kids got killed by red john. I guess this whole series is build around that, that's why every title starts with the word "red". But red john killed his family b/c back then he was a "psychic" and red john got pissed off or something when jane said on-live that he was probably a sad sad man. It was most likely a warning to him saying "you don;t know what you're dealing with"

[@MCLT4Ever]

Which episode is this from?

[@gembocobo9484]

I didn't dislike her as much as some of the commenters seem to do but I dunno how to take this positively. I know I'd appreciate knowing a loved one didn't suffer in their last moments. Granted I can see why this could be seen as an extremely effective emotional nut shot. As much as Jane tries to present himself as the smartest guy in any situation but that exchange just peeled off his defenses.

[@SamuelHabekotte]

8 Wel now she's 9. Why?

[@browncapitalist4884]

Christina's intentions may be in the right, but this was a stupid thing to do to someone who does not believe in Psychic power.

[@SG1Mitchell]

its in the description