Pentatonix vs. Dan Vasc: Amazing Grace - Reaction and Comparison!

[@cherylviger1359]

Dan Vasc hands down!

[@kristinabassi4215]

Basically both very nice versions... Nevertheless, my heart beats for Dan Vasc, fantastic, incomparable, world-best voice ♥️🤘

[@Chriss-yes]

YES!!! ❤🤟❤

[@katrinakelker4864]

Pentatiox is okay, But in my take Dan version brings more Power and awakens the Soul and brings New Life in a 250 year song that we need

[@iiiisssssaaaaaacccccc]

Same comment but Dan version is okay,

[@pamagnolia]

Amazing. I love Pentatonix but Dan was brilliant!! 😅

[@shirleyemrick1700]

Dan Vasc is by far the best. Best rendition of the beautiful song I have ever heard!

[@Deborah-h3p]

Dan Vasc has the best rendition of this beautiful classic hymn! His version is the traditional version!

[@bobbielay5447]

Dan Vasc is best by far❤

[@jeresmith5858]

Amazing Grace is such an iconic song and the Pentatonix version is beautiful. Dan Vasc took the song to another level entirely. Dan Vasc's version is truly amazing!

[@magdao8235]

Dan 🎉Thanks 😊

[@GloriaCote-o1c]

Dan Vasc is the best artist/singer in the world as we know it. He has no equal.

[@sandrachagas9832]

Sem a menor sombra de dúvidas é o Dan Vasc, ele mexe com minhas emoções sem contar sua voz lindíssima! Obrigado por seu apoio ao nosso Dan e abraços do Brasil!👍🇧🇷

[@ivandavis8710]

Dan

[@vvinww]

Dan Vasc is for me faaar way the best!

[@LeighBeckman]

Dan Vasc won this hands down. Not even a contest

[@joettamcqueen1954]

Not even the same song, really, so hard to compare. PTX is great, and they did a very entertaining variation. However, there is no comparison. Dan Vasc just sang the most beautiful version I have ever heard. Powerful, yet respectful, and it touched my heart. Dan didn't just win. We ALL won. P.S. I don't like comparing artists, personally.

[@dianalindenmeyer4847]

Dans version is the BEST Ive ever heard. Pentonix is ok, but I'll listen to Dan sing it any day over them.

[@iiiisssssaaaaaacccccc]

For a solo singer, Dan did amazing. For a cappella group, PTX did amazing.

[@LyndaCarnes]

Amazing Grace is always magnificent, no matter who sings it. I like Petatonix very much. They show both the strength of the song and the peace of the Lord. But I have to say: I LOVE Dan Vasc's powerful vocal reach, especially when he sings Amazing Grace! I have to vote for Dan, I have never heard a voice with such broad, consuming power. I have tremendous respect for how he has pushed himself to the limit to perfect and expand his vocals. I feel so strong when I hear him sing Amazing Grace. It's carrying a great power.

[@pamelariker5525]

Both were great. However I preferred Dans version, for the energy he brought to it!

[@Sue-u2e]

Both are good but Dan’s version always gives me goosebumps every time I hear him sing it best cover of this song ever ❤

[@-Lilian-1]

Sorry for Pentattonix,but Dan brings it to a oder level. So for me Dan... Thank you for this❣

[@anitasaint7717]

Agree with apples and oranges but Dan sang by himself through about 4 octaves. Vocally I think he By far showed his vocal prowess but I also love PTX!

[@lauriep2018]

Three majority of PTX had three to four octaves. I’d argue it’s more difficult in a group bc if one person is off, it’s totally noticeable. Whereas a solo singer can just go with the flow if a little flat or sharp. Both PTX and Dan are exceptional I like the or sharp

[@Dolly-wc9ne]

Dan’s better! Sang with a lot of heart and feelings. PTX good but did they change the song, added to it? Didn’t like that.

[@umarae27]

Many singers have touched me deeply with this song, but Dan Vasc takes 1st place every time. Even against Stan Walker (my other most favorite) or Ptx.

[@heatherrohde6541]

DAN ❤

[@smokymthiker]

No need to filter Dan. He doesn't copyright his videos.

[@PatPrice-fn4ws]

Can't touch Dans forever .🌠🌠🌠🌠

[@rose-hk5pm]

Dan's version is the best of the best. no one comes close to him

[@LuceliafeodealencarAlencar]

São duas versões diferentes !!! Com certeza o DAN VASC MASTEPIRCE! Os outros cantam bem!

Enjoyed the Pentatonix version , but Dans is the best , hands down!

[@carolaO-v2d]

Thank you for your nice attempt to compare 2 very different versions of Amazing Grace. Both Pentatonix and Dan have made this epic song their own in their own way. Comparing a group with a solo singer is not fair, but you have already noticed that yourself. Thank you anyway for showing us these wonderful cover versions.

[@derekpetersen7571]

Dan blows everyone out of the water

[@derekpetersen7571]

There version was not good I’m sorry

[@iiiisssssaaaaaacccccc]

@@derekpetersen7571that is matter in your own opinion.

[@cindyshawver9986]

Please don't filter Dan, you don't have to !!!.....we ladies like to look !!.....LOL......my vote is for Dan, but PTX should get recognition for their version as well, but i prefer Dan usually every time he is compared to someone else. He is just so powerful and so expressive !!!

[@cclarke9301]

Don’t have to filter any of Dan’s music. Having said that I prefer Dan by far.

[@derekpetersen7571]

That simple no one is better than Dan Vasc they should take notes

[@iiiisssssaaaaaacccccc]

That is a bias opinion. Other singer are better than one another. Just matter of preference for you. So that is your opinion, and my opinion is Scott, the male singer in PTX is better singer than Dan.

[@christmascarol87]

It’s not really fair to compare these two very different versions of this classic hymn. I really prefer to just see reactions to each artist separately.

[@derekpetersen7571]

You do t have to do that with any of Dans vid there is no copy right I promise ask around please Don’t hide Dan anymore you don’t have to

[@susanwozniak6354]

The way five people might sing a song v. a soloist seems a little silly.

[@cindysorensen9197]

Would be nice if we could actually see the video's...... there is no competition here..... Dan has it hands down.

[@df5199]

Not into comparison reactions, but good luck.

[@davephillips7209]

PTX using only voices no instruments always surprises me. His version is beautiful. Not a great comparison very different, both enchanting. I prefer the PTX sound. Just a preference.

[@LyndaCarnes]

And you have a right to a preference. That's the purpose of the question. I wrote my own post without reading anyone else. Scrolling down the page has shown me how overwhelming the preference was for Dan. He has a lot of "fans'. But I expect PTX does too. I salute you, not because I agree with your choice, but because I admire your courage to speak up for your preference in the face of such a "great crowd of witnesses." Personally, I chose Dan because I have only become aware of him in the past month or so, but I am blown away by his style and vocal range. There is something very powerful about watching and listening to him sing. I think I may be following the path of a "fan". That's something I have never claimed in all my (I won't bother to mention how many) years. God bless you!

[@helenabdulah7263]

You're comparing apples n oranges! There is a place for both but really no comparison. Apart from the group dynamic, Dan Vasc stuck to the more traditional version of the hymn, which I like. However, he was all over the map in terms of tone n pitch, so I prefer the PTX version.

[@anjanette02]

Dan’s verson for me because music needs to speak to your soul and his did so more than P’s version

[@Chriss-yes]

YES!!! ❤🤟❤

[@chrispavlich9656]

@@anjanette02 I guess everyone’s soul is different. PTX always speaks to my soul.

[@umarae27]

Dan used octave changes, stayed on pitch & shared a story about the adventure of love, grace & joy. PTX sang it really pretty.

[@Christine-hl4rl]

From the first time I heard Dan’s version I felt that he was singing it the way it needed to be sung- new believer being introduced to Gods Grace, humble believer accepting Gods Grace, to all out warrior in His army ! To me - totally powerful!