What If Anakin Skywalker Told Mace Windu About Darth Plagueis

[@Achuidian179]

I would have thought Anakin would tell Mace about Plagueis AFTER the opera, not before he’s about to confront Palpatine.

[@TangyGuest1]

He does have a doctorate in Darth Plageius the Wise studies

[@BigBaj]

NOT AGAIN WITH THE FUCKING THESIS!

[@Falcon_Primal]

"Darth Plagueis had an apprentice who was a little b****. He had to wait for his master to fall asleep before killing his a**. It was Ironic though because Plagueis was trying to discover the secret to immortality and was apparently 80% of the way there but you know what they say, a near miss is just as bad as f***ing up so badly." -Mace Window

[@samcarpenter7104]

You missed the entire second half of the quote. "You know what they say, "a near miss is as good as f***ing up so badly you hire an army that eventually kills your everyone you care about... Or writing the sequel trilogy."

[@Falcon_Primal]

@@samcarpenter7104 It’s been a while since I’ve seen that video so I had trouble remembering

[@cicerobully]

Mace doesn't want to hear Anakin's damn thesis!

[@ballisticautistic5398]

What if Savage Opress stayed loyal to Dooku, killed Ventress, and remained Dooku’s sith apprentice?

[@dkallday4]

Great idea If savage was on the ih things could change

[@V0SRU]

I’ve been looking forward to this.

[@matthewthompson6908]

I can see anakin coming back from cretinous 2. Mace: what took you so long? *snickering* Anakin: what took you so long *mocking like.*

[@Reaper_Rapi]

Nice GTA five reference. :-)

[@theseekerofancienttruth3873]

Just checked Wookiepedia, and "Krayiss II" is Legends. Not only that, it is possibly Connected to the Rakata, as it is At Least 28,000 Years Old.

[@Thaumh]

Just had a 🤯idea for a branch timeline story from this one. With Mace in the Expansion Zone, I could see him finding Qimir and the Knights of Renn, and "lightening" them up a bit. Him teaching them his Vapaad, and them teaching him that not all Darksiders are "evil".

[@Dat_Sock]

Day 2 for : What if Anakin and Obi-Wan swapped? What I mean is instead of Obi-Wan going through youngling training, getting trained by Qui Gon, and eventually finding Anakin and his mother on Tatooine. Anakin is the one to be trained as a youngling, get trained by Qui gon, find Obi wan and his slave mom on Tatooine. Swap the Midichlorian counts of the two and try to keep the personality’s close to the same. Example : Anakin is still a cocky Jedi but he has to suddenly train the chosen one (Obi wan) after his master (Qui gon) dies at the hands of a sith. Also you should make Padme fall in love with Obi-Wan instead of Anakin since they are swapping places. In my opinion the new relationship between Anakin and Obi Wan would be very similar to Dooku and Qui gon. There are lots of different ways you could go with this what if. I think this could be an awesome story and you should make it! (make it at least 1 hour long?)

[@SuperDuper-CoolGuy]

Seems interesting. Is Obi-Wan the chosen one then?

[@Dat_Sock]

@@SuperDuper-CoolGuy Yes keep the personality’s the same but not how strong they are I’m mainly trying to see what would happen had Obi wan been in certain situations

[@jozefmasny8349]

Alternative title: What if Mace had one brain cell and actually gave Anakin an "important" job instead of making him wait.

[@abrakadabra6364]

God, I wish the "riddle" bit was in the movie. That and not making Tinn and Kolar look like punks when being taken out. 😅

[@ballisticautistic5398]

What if Darth Vitiate was revived during the Clone Wars? Vitiate vs Sidious would be the ultimate force battle!

[@Savajj_nahold]

This was already done before by pente

[@Allmightyimortal]

Also good name for him. Was going to start calling grand inquisitor bob

[@Thaumh]

Mace: (entering Sheev's office) Chancellor, what do you know about Darth Plaguis the Wise? Palp: (blink-blink) ...wait, what?

[@Thaumh]

Violum: I could'a been a contendah!

[@Thaumh]

"Anakin would become Grand Master before his eventual death..." and finally have a reason to have a Force Ghost that looks like the pre-Special Edition version. 🤣

[@Sienna6164]

0:36- Sith lAWd lol, im dying

[@sighingsaichania7033]

Thank you for not turning Barriss to the Dark side. Everyone likes to make her evil, and I like that Canon turns her back to the light. She is one of my favorite characters!

[@DarthWinterMadness]

Anakin having a room for when he looses an argument, il love it! This What If is really good. Cheers from France! 🍻

[@Shevindelton]

I've been here since day one and it is honestly heart warming in seeing your growth as a writer and creator i live for these videos ❤

[@somethingforsenro]

was NOT expecting Grand Inquisitor to become the next Sith Lord

[@ballisticautistic5398]

What if Ventress fell in love and had a child with Maul or Savage Opress? Their child would undoubtedly rival Sidious’s potential!

[@darthbane5357]

Palpatine is the most powerful Sith in history dawg

[@milkymilky5527]

Even if what if I disagree

[@brendanolearybradford9162]

@@darthbane5357power isn’t potential. Palpatine acknowledged that maul could one day achieve his level of power. That was just…..cut short lol

[@Tottleminerftw]

" room inside the temple for when he lost arguments" 😂

[@ballisticautistic5398]

What if Cal Kestis and his crew (Grees, Merrin, etc) joined the Ghost Crew?

[@RayAkuma]

The inquisitor in this story: ,,i wanna restart the rule of 2 which only worked so well because of secrecy, but I'm going to send a message to the jedi before i do."🤦‍♂️

[@LeviMartin-o2y]

Question for Pente: At what number of Patrons will you stop reading them in the video? It's not like I don't like it when you read them, but once you get like 100, that will be quite a lot of names to read.

[@richardbarrett4488]

A challenge?? GET THIS MAN TO 100 PATREONS AND HAVE HIM READ EVERY ONE OF THEM

[@hanging4176]

He might appreciate the verbal challenge 😂

[@Reaper_Rapi]

That gotta be one of the dumbest things to complain about. That point the video is pretty much over. :-)

[@LeviMartin-o2y]

@@Reaper_Rapi I didn't mean to complain. I really appreciate the shoutouts and understand their importance. I was genuinely curious about how Pente plans to manage it as the number of Patrons grows.

[@TheSpy-oo8fv]

The only what if i truly ever have on mind is what if Anakin was used as the clone template. Full on force sensitive clones that even rival jedi in raw power. Could make it that anakin never becomes a jedi, the inhibitor chips just outright fail. So Order66 doesnt occur and Palpatine is captured. Just an idea :3

[@Reaper_Rapi]

The only thing I can visualize from this is a Kopany of Anakin clones saying Anakin most famous quotes from the movies.

[@watrebel9595]

This feels amazing as I am in the middle of reading the plaguis novel

[@Rjfromoutsouth.04]

the temple guard arc here, reminds me of the story of Darth Ruin from legends

[@itstaylor2137]

I appreciate that you sometimes go beyond the initial story.

[@desperado8605]

Always good to see Baris getting redeemed

[@PinkMawile]

If there was a race that wanted to join the Republic, but had naturally high M counts… Would they be denied self-representation? Also with the failure of Palpatine, I’m surprised Darth Forehead didn’t reject the rule of two and strike out for a new Dark Side philosophy.

[@crayonchomper1180]

Darth Forehead lol

[@surferdude4487]

That's it. Send the chosen one on a snipe hunt while the grown-ups take care of Palpatine. I love it! I would still like to see a story with a street smart Anakin reading Palpatine like a cheap novel and playing him for a sucker. That would be hilarious.

[@reeceemms1643]

Day 113 of asking for one of these ideas. 1. What if Jyn Erso survived and went onto fall in love with Luke Skywalker? 2. What if The Sith returned during the High Republic era? 3. What if cal and Merrin had a daughter? 4. What if Bo-Katan and Din Djaran fell in love? 5. What if the Jedi didn't forbit attachments? 6. What if the Yuzhan Vong invaded during the galactic civil war? 7. What if the Yuzhan Vong invaded during the First Order-Resistance war? 8. What if Kylo Ren never destroyed Luke's Jedi order? 9. what if Omega was force sensitive? 10. what if the Yuzhan Vong invaded during the Clone wars? 11. what if Avar Kriss and Elzar Mann had a daughter? 12. What if Padme was forced to marry Rush Clovis during the Clone Wars? 13. What if Padme and Anakin had triplets instead of twins? 14. What if Mara Jade existed in canon? 15. What if Kana never died? 16. What if Governor Pryce defected? 17. What if Dr. Aphra joined the Rebellion? 18. What if Dr. Aphra was force sensitive? 19. What if Quinlan Vos and Ventrass Eloped? Ps. How am I first?

[@Achuidian179]

Actually in regards to number 9, Omega is to a degree force sensitive. But like Sabine Wren she needed training but never got a chance.

[@robertmanski8844]

That was a good one👍

[@28467Vanus]

What if Count Dooku ordered an unaltered clone of himself to be his apprentice and heir? What if Illum bestowed a naturally red kyber crystal on Anakin? How would the Jedi react? What if Palpatine saved Shmi Skywalker as a way to bind Anakin even closer to him? What if Ahsoka was with Anakin when he pledged himself to Palpatine and became Darth Vader, and she chose to join him? What if the Republic lost the First Battle of Geonosis? What if Palpatine created the Imperial Knights as a light side counterbalance to the Inquisitors personally loyal to him? What if General Grevious was made of beskar? What if Palpatine desired both Mace Windu and Anakin as his (rival) Sith apprentices and spent years manipulating both of them to that end? What if Anakin was not the Chosen One as the Jedi believed but was instead destined to be the Sith'ari? Just a few what-if ideas...

[@jdgreen1802]

Always love to see Barris get a redemption arc

[@haydenstarkiller4708]

What if Din Djarin was force sensitive? What if Cal Kestis found Grogu? What if Ahsoka found Cal Kestis? What if Darth Maul didn't lose half his potential? What if Galen Marek was a Mandalorian? What if Mace Windu was on Jedha during Rogue One? What if Darth Vitiate trained Cal Kestis after Order 66? What if Cal Kestis and Merrin joined Taron Malicos? What if Quinlan Vos discovered Galen Marek? What if Jaro Tapal survived Order 66? What if Taron Malicos trained Starkiller? What if Boba Fett joined Darth Maul's Crimson Dawn? What if Meetra Surik somehow returned during the Rebellion?

[@paulrasmussen8953]

And the thesis begins

[@brianvernon249]

Excellent story. But here is the one note I have: Tarkin. He was glossed over in this story & is the only blind spot before Palps is taken out. Or have the Inquisitor reach out to Imperials.

[@claudiostudios9002]

Anakin Skywanker and his GODDAMN THESIS!

[@Fallen_Clone]

What if anakin trained gungi after ahsoka? What if the temple guards refused to remove ahsokas padawan briad in protest

[@LordMayorOfDairyBell]

What if Plaguesis was a Mandalorian?

[@chasetauscher9544]

So like a Foundling?

[@MegatronusPrimeX10]

1. What If Luke and Ahsoka met during the Original Trilogy? 2. What If Hondo Ohnaka met with Luke and Obi-Wan in the cantina instead of Han? 3. What If Ezra Bridger trained Ben Solo? 4. What If Ezra Bridger stole Jabba the Hutt's identity and took over his criminal empire? (aka What If Ezra WAS Jabba) 5. What If Din Djarin kept the Darksaber and became the new leader of the Mandalorians? Sequel Trilogy What Ifs: 6. What If Thrawn joined/led the First Order? 7. What If Darth Plagueis was the true Big Bad of the Sequel Trilogy, not Palpatine? 8. What If Rey and Ben Solo switched roles? (Ben never turns to the Dark Side, never becomes Kylo Ren, and remains a Jedi. But Rey either becomes Snoke's dark apprentice or is raised by Palpatine and becomes his dark heir) 9. What If Luke went to Jekku, found little Rey and adopted her? (aka What If Luke raised Rey) 10. What If Ben Solo survived at the end of Episode IX? 11. What If the New Republic didn't fall and aided the Resistance against the First Order? 12. What If Luke's Jedi students survived and joined the fight against the First Order? What If Galen Marrek/Starkiller was Canon? - 13. What If Galen Marrek Joined the Rebellion? - 14. What If Starkiller was an Inquisitor? What If the Yuuzhan Vong invaded during.... - 15. What If the YV invaded during the Clone Wars? - 16. What If the YV invaded during the Galactic Civil War? - 17. What If the YV invaded during the First Order-Resistance War? And finally... 18. What If Jar Jar was a Jedi?

[@Allmightyimortal]

What if tarkin's ungrateful but died in the citidel instead of Even Piell

[@ballisticautistic5398]

What if Obiwan was killed before attack of the Clones? Who would finish Anakin’s training?

[@gaming-verseandadditionalv2500]

What if Obi wan died during Anakin Skywalker’s training is the first version he might make a second one good idea

[@Allmightyimortal]

He did this what if I think about a year ago.

[@isaachouston6207]

What if Ventress killed Dooku and became Sidious' new apprentice. What if Palpatine never learned Force transfer and officially died on the DS 2

[@LeviMartin-o2y]

What if Obi-Wan killed Maul and Savage on Florum? In the end, you could have Obi-Wan wake up from a meditation a couple of months after Satine's death and wish he had stopped Maul back then.

[@ballisticautistic5398]

What if Dagan Gera was released during the Clone Wars?

[@LeviMartin-o2y]

What if Darth Plagueis trained Mace Windu. What if Sokka was a Jedi. (from last air bender) What if Ahsoka killed Maul on Mandalor. What if Satele Shan killed Darth Malgus on Alderaan.

[@28467Vanus]

I like the first one. Mace Windu has immense potential as a Sith, and I'd like to see a story where he reaches his full potential as a dark sider. Both Darth Plagueis and Mace Windu don't get enough love, in my opinion...

[@Wasilele]

I thought the story'd go totally in a different way . Tbh i'd rather if windu sent anakin to sith planet, where anakin was corrupted killed all jedi which joined him. Came back and destroy jedi as a sith lord. Windu 'd be like "what have i done "😂😂😂

[@ballisticautistic5398]

What if Maul killed both Qui-Gon and Obiwan and made his way back to Sidious?

[@Allmightyimortal]

I think he did this one. That or starwars galaxy.

[@jaredfetzer7041]

A Sith Lawd!?

[@xxdeesoloxx1522]

My favorite part was " Meesa Gun Di "

[@ogTryhard21]

"The new Grand Master, Plo Koon" That doesn't make a lick of sense. Couldve sworn Mace Windu is next in line for that title. Since hes, the Master of the Order and all....

[@DrownedInExile]

I thought the Grand Inquisitor's real name was Melvin myself.

[@ballisticautistic5398]

What if Darth Maul was made the Grand Inquisitor after Order 66?

[@ballisticautistic5398]

What if Darth Revan was frozen in carbonite during the Old Republic and was freed during the Clone Wars?

[@Savajj_nahold]

Lovely stuff, buddy im not sure if you could do what if coleman trevor (you know, the dinosaur jedi who died on geonosis) trained anakin skywalker

[@ballisticautistic5398]

What if Boba Fett killed Windu during the Clone Wars season 2?

[@Bwillis2099]

What if Finn was mace windu’s grandson?

[@Hiipower23]

This was a good story def enjoyed the second act of the story the most

[@cuoy13]

What if Maul & Assajj we're siblings? (Also, what if they were lovers.) What if Darth Talon was Dooku's apprentice during the Clone Wars?

[@marikam2998]

1. What If Ferus Olin Trained Сade Skywalker? 2. What If Cal Kestis Trained Nate Skywalker? 3. What If Leia Skywalker Trained Finn? 4. What If Shaak Ti Trained Rey? 5. What If Count Dooku Trained Caleb Dume? 6. What If Obi-Wan Kenobi Trained Ferus Olin? 7. What If Qui Gon Jinn Trained Ferus Olin?

[@mentalist7772]

What if Anakin became a Jedi Detective? What if Obi-Wan became Grandmaster? What if Jar Jar accidentally exposed Palpatine as the Sith Lord?

[@Duwangman]

Well, he makes a thesis, that's what

[@madnimrod2489]

DICHOTOMY

[@christophermiglino2869]

"...for when he lost arguments" Freaking hilarious!! You're married, right?

[@ballisticautistic5398]

What if Anakin was trained by Jaro Tapal?

[@TenkoBerry]

Dang This Gonna Be Great I^0^I👍

[@TenkoBerry]

Was quite Interesting 👌

[@Borealis233]

What if The Jedi were trying to take over?

[@owainjones4034]

Day nine What if Luke was raised by Mon Mothma What if Luke raised by sola Naberrie What if the empire invaded tatooine before a new hope What if obi wan actually did kill Darth maul on naboo What if the mantis crew found Ezra What if Luke and Leia were raised together on alderaan What if the separatist killed Anakin on mustafar What if Han and chewie joined enfys nest What if the Death Star self destructed before blowing up Jedha city What if Han manage to kill Darth Vader during the trench run What if palpatine was on the first Death Star when it blew up What if the new republic fought the first order What if Luke and the lars moved to Alderaan after the obi wan kenobi show

[@claudiostudios9002]

What if Ezra saved and brought into canon Galen Marek (Starkiller) in the world between worlds?

[@MasterHypearyon]

What if Pong Krell escaped Ubrara and joined Dooku?(day 1)

[@まっちゃん-l1c6k]

I'm using a translator What if Sith purebloods had survived into the Clone Wars?

[@sirclonemageda1st]

What if Revan was Anakins ancestor?

[@matheusdemello2323]

What if Shmi Skywalker was a Mandalorian Warrior?

[@rasmusjensen6962]

What if Anakin was trained by Yoda or Windu, but still turned to the darkside.

[@megakyloscorpiodon1577]

Can you please add more voice acting into your Star Wars theories?

[@cuoy13]

What if Han & Lando were a duo?

[@dimitricruz8151]

I think Palpatine would’ve won the fight against the four Jedis he knew they come and would still 3/4 the pit quick with or without Anakin Skywalker.

[@matheusdemello2323]

What if Anakin Skywalker was born a girl and Padme Amidala a boy, how would *Revenge Of The Sith* change in this scenario?

[@phoenixroberts4559]

What if Sliver the hedgehog was a jedi?

[@johnpittsii7524]

What if Anakin was trained by Bastillia Shan. Also what if Anakin was sent to kayshaxx instead of Yoda. Also what if Anakin trained sabrene wren. Also what if Anakin fell in love with mon montha

[@mr.vorrnyvorrn2516]

Bastila Shan Kashyyyk Sabine Wren Mon Mothma

[@EZRABINEFOREVER-t6p]

What If Ezra And Sabine Saw Their Future and they were Married and they Fall In Love With Each Other And They Got Married And What If Thrawn Betrayed The Empire From The Emperor's Throne And The Rebellion And Empire Joined Forces To Defeat Thrawn

[@Goliath-co2xn]

I think it is interesting that you chose to not have Luke at least join the order.

[@davidfarkas4010]

What if Jango Fett survived the battle of Geonosis

[@davidcatabui2018]

If the Senate barred all with an M count above 5k from becoming members, Luke and Leia would not have been able to join

[@9000jamez]

What if the jedi bombing happened at the start of the clone wars

[@starlightdelt4796]

What if the colonials from Battlestar Galactica made it to the star wars galaxy and Galactica and Pegasus joined the rebellion

[@Templewindle9741]

What if the covenant from halo was in the Star Wars universe?

[@matheusdemello2323]

What if Maul never betrayed the rebels?

[@shadowfast541]

What if ahsoka becomes the apprentice to count dooku in the clone wars and Ventress was a jedi that becomes a good friend to anakin and obi wan?

[@oisinm332]

Riddle?

[@OrangedinoTrexBundle]

What if Anakin Skywalker was framed for the Jedi temple bombing

[@havesomeculture]

Lord* not Lod!!!

[@isandreproust1783]

Year

[@Noe-hv4ho7bn6g]

what if cis and the republic used stormtroopers

[@clarity2199]

The fight against Palpatine is an issue. If he can get into people heads, like Anakin and Windu, then he's also know that Anakin was not showing up. That means there's no reason to face them all, himself. He's have his guards, he'd probably have prepared to have an alarm with clone troopers show up to attack them, for trying to kill the Chancelor. Them doing this would have played right in his hand, because he'd have proof of them trying to take him out, giving even more credence to Order 66, which he'd probably activate while they were fending themselves against Clone Troopers and personal guard. They'd eventually be killed or be forced to retreat. The mass killing of Jedi would still happen. The problem is in your stories you always make it TOO convenient for Palpatine to die, and too stupid by continuing to follow his plans regardless of what changes you make, as if he's just a mannequin unable to do anything but 'follow the script'. The whole point of a fanfiction is to change AWAY from the normal plot once a change is made. But you seem unable to do that. I actually stopped watching for vids for a long time because of which. But I tried this one after months to see if anything changed, which sadly did not.

[@christinebouzas3090]

What if Ahsoka was Anakins daughter and neither knew it, just screw with time line to have the clone wars happen much later