@@charguigou ne nsnsnsnsbsbsbbsbsbbsnsnd.s. Snsndndnnddbbbsbdbdbwbbfieiid
@rishabhrox19 жыл бұрын
OK, the amount of dislikes really disappoints me, because your comments are actually very well-written and not at all mocking any singer. For the ranking, fine.....I saw a lot of 'unique' voices in the top 10, but I'm glad that this 'uniqueness' thing didn't took over your top 3, many people just put up an old-sounding voice at the top calling it 'unique', whereas the voice-acting should also be taken into account... :)
@Mirilda9 жыл бұрын
Comme d'habitude j'adore tes personal ranking ! :D Merci pour la première place ! ^^
As usual -clap clap clap- Oh your videos have never made us disappointed! The editing, just WOW! I love how you put the design of Frozen's ending credit in this ranking. Wish I could be as creative as you :( I disagree with Finnish, Hebrew and English. Oh, Véronique too. Btw Véronique would be on my first place of my Elsa's ranking if she was Elsa. Goodnesssssss! She is PERFECT as Elsa IMO I would put Japanese lower and German higher because they should be like that. (I guess that is a concrete reason HAHAHA.Just kidding) But the ranking is yours :) Agreed with Bulgarian and Ukrainian. Agreed with Croatian and Slovak too. Although they sound weak but their voice are gold. They can stabilize the 'heat' of their 'sister' And now I just realised how beautiful is Portuguese Anna is. Italian jumped into my heart after I listened to it for the first time ever. Actually because of Italian language... Vietnamese Anna is one of the most fitting Anna here! One of my favourites too. I guess THANKS A LOT FOR MALAY ♥♥♥. I have never thought that she is here as someone said that she used too much auto tune and annoying. Well I blame TV pitch for that reason. TV pitch made her voice to be babyish. Well it is quite sad to see that foreigners love our dub than most Malaysians. Hmmm I guess after this would be Elsa. Merci beaucoup ^^
@charguigou9 жыл бұрын
Appa21 Thanks a lot :) I agree she's great as Elsa, and she has a great singing voice, don't know why she changed it, to french ears it becomes highly annoying after a while. The first time I've heard Malay, I was like : that's the Anna I wanted, she's perfect ! Don't understand not everyone love her lol. It's true that DVD pitch made her - just like Emmylou - more babyish and people have wrong opinions then, that's too bad, in normal pitch they're perfect ! Malay dub of Frozen is GOLD! It's really perfect, don't understand Malaysians don't like it ! Yes now is Elsa :) Thanks for your comment :)
@arjunabetta45729 жыл бұрын
Hahaha. Oh ya, there is no DVD version of Malay Frozen and I don't know why? Hmmmmm. It looks like Amylea and Emmylou have same case Again thank you ^^
@arjunabetta45729 жыл бұрын
The Legendary Of The Wings Yeah! I can imagine Anna with that voice. I will explain it in my ranking. Hihi
@arjunabetta45729 жыл бұрын
Never mind :)
@arjunabetta45729 жыл бұрын
charguigou Is Russian Anna the Russian musical Ariel? I just want to be sure of it
@albafontdemorapaes94909 жыл бұрын
I love this video!!! The end of the video is perfect! My favourite voice is the italian. It's beautiful.
@yaminarayah60222 жыл бұрын
KwkwnNNnNnwnwnnwnwnw Wnnwnwnnwnwnnwnwn w.wnwnnwnw Wnnwnwnwnnwnwnwnnwnwnw Ndndnwnnwnwnnwnwnnwnwnwnnwnw Ndndnnwnwnwnnwnwnnwnwn Nwnwnnwnwnwnnwnw wnwnnwbwbw Nwnwnnwnwnwnnwnwnwnnw Wnnwnwnnwnwnwnwnnw w w w w Dnwnnwnwnnwnqkwnwnwnww Wnnwnwnwnnwnwnwnnwnw Nwnwnwnwnnwnwnnwnwnwnwnw Wnnwnwnw.. wnwnwnwnwnwnnwnwbbw Wnnwnnwnwnwnwnnwnw Nwnwnwnwnnwnwnwnnwnwnw. Nsnsnwnwnwnwnnwnwnnww Wnnw.nwnwnwnnwnwnwnwnnwnw Wnw.wnnwnwnwnnwnwnwnw W..w.q.nqnNnqnsnnqnqnqnnwnwn Qnwnsnafwwwwwwwndndnnwnw Wnwnnwnwnwnwnnwnwnwww Wnnwnwnwnnwnwnwnnwnwnw Wnwnw..w.wnwnnwnwnnwnwnwnnwnw Nwnw..w.wnnwnwnwnnwnnwnw Ndndndnndndddldndklwnwnnwnwnw
@frenchhufflepuffie836 жыл бұрын
Thanks for the first place! Love!
@HM_Taro9 жыл бұрын
Thank you for Mandarin,Vietnamese,Japanese,Ukrainian,Slovak,Serbian,and so on! But it's interesting to see many different opinions :) My disagreement:Hungarian,Finish,Latin Spanish,Korean,Quebec French,Cantonese,and French,sorry :( There's a lot,isn't it? :) I really love your video!I can' wait for Elsa !
@morenokingindrawan98825 жыл бұрын
I'm sad no Indonesian and English is too low but I'm glad malay at the top. And also glad to see the vietnamese elsa and anna on the same positions.
@g.7059 жыл бұрын
What an unusual ranking, and that's amazing! I have disagreements, but that's your opinion. I'm glad that I'm not the only one who is a big fan of Carmen López, or Vássia x3 I'd put Malay, Swedish & Flemish lower, and Japanese, English and Latin Spanish higher. I agree with Emmylou, she's Anna! I didn't recognise her as the teen Anna. And yep, her speaking is totally awesome, and perfect! Thanks for the version of Véronique of Let it go. Anyway, thanks for 22nd place!
Why are your videos always so freaking amazing? Thanks for 30 (noticed now that you never put Brazil in the top 20!) But there's no problem, and your number 1 is in my top 15 ^^
@charguigou9 жыл бұрын
Celso Rimoli Yeah sorry about that, but I can't change my opinion
@celsoArimoli9 жыл бұрын
charguigou As I said, there's no problem, I understand and respect your opinion
@xxgamergirlxx79178 жыл бұрын
where'd you get the clip of Anna and Elsa in the castle skating? about Anna's voices i think I overall agree especially with the lower placements but I'd put Turkish higher my favorite Anna's currently are:Japanese,mandarin,putonghua,Arabic,German,vietnamese Serbian,Croatian Malay,Ukrainian,Greek,quebec,Italian but I think Lithuanian,polish,Icelandic,Bulgarian,Slovak and French sound great too!
@xxgamergirlxx79178 жыл бұрын
oh and Swedish duhhh :)
@lolopomelos5837 жыл бұрын
OMG France is first!!! I love Emmylou's voice, it's like an angel for me ❤ And I love my country
Coincidentally I upload my Anna ranking just 24 hours after you do ;D And I'm honestly so surprised at how much we have in common in a lot of the same low places! That Veronique clip you played :OOOOO She sounded really really good. I like Veronique as she is in Frozen, but if she sang with some middle ground between her cute/fake and that deeper voice from the parody clip I bet she'd be AMAZING. I guess all the middle bits of your ranking are a bit of a scramble on if I agree or not...but I do agree with the general sentiment that a lot of Annas are GOOD, but maybe not quite special enough. There are a few really cool unusual voices she has (Greek and Arabic come to mind) but I find some languages really played it safe and chose a very talented singer who has a beautiful but common-sounding voice (Hebrew comes to mind). I start agreeing again in your top 10 mostly because of a couple of uncommon favorites that we both seem to appreciate :D You saying Serena and Vassia sound alike made me rethink my feelings for Vassia. I agree they have similar voices but there's one major thing that sets them apart, and it's that Vassia has a deep, heavy, solid voice and Serena's is much more nimble and airy. AH I ALSO LOVE THE 'MAI MAI' THING!!!! Not surprised by your number 1 at all :P I've grown to like her quite a bit. I agree about the do you wanna build a snowman thing, I think that's my favorite singing bit from her, and I enjoy her talking too.
@yaminarayah60222 жыл бұрын
Kqksbsbsbbsbsbsbbsnss Nsnnsnsnsnnsnnsnnsnsnsnnwnw Snnsnnsnsnsnsnnwnwnwnw Snnsnsnsn d snsnndndndnnwnndnd Snnsnsnsnnwnsbsbnwnwnw Snnsnsnnsnsnsnnsnsnsns Qnnsnsnnsnsnsnnsnsnnwnnwnw Snnsnsnnsnsnsnnsnsnnsns
@342roblox9 жыл бұрын
YAAYYY! Its here! Thanks to Google which notified me. :) Great videi and ranking! Cant wait for ELSA. :)
@charguigou9 жыл бұрын
ArendellianPotato Thank you :)
@Lunijma9 жыл бұрын
Very interesting and great ranking once again :) I always enjoy watching yours. I'm especially glad to so Vietnamese so high since she is a big favorite of mine too and seems to be so underrated most of the time. Emmylou is soo difficult to judge for me ^^' she is not a favorite in singing but I do like her! Sometimes more sometimes less, but her speaking parts are, as you said, perfectly done :) She is after all quite controversial Anna I guess^^
@charguigou9 жыл бұрын
Lunijma I'm glad to see another Vietnamese fan ^^ Lol yeah Emmylou is a hard subject for everyone x) Thanks for the nice words :)
Thank you so much for Serbian ! I am surprised and happy to see her at that position.People don't really like her because of her mature voice but excluding that she is a great singer ! Also I love your number one.And beautiful editing :)
Thank you so much for 6th and.. well 36th place =) I am so happy you like Vassia so much, especially because you liked her since the first time! I so loved Vassia but she grew on me even more lately. As for Saara, well she is my favorite Anna _EVER_ but I really respect your opinion., Your opinion differs so much from the ''usual' and it is so nice to see different rankings! Your editing is splendid! And I really like the intro! Where did you find it?! And OMG, is Emmylou really playing little Anna as well?!?!
Really Perfect Ranking, Thank you for 29th place! (Korean) Ji-Yun is my favorite Anna. I almost agree with your opinion, Really Beautiful opinion! I love your Top 10, I almost agree :D And I totally agree with your number one! She is one of my favorite French Heroine :D Nice editing, I love you very much!
@eadiestroud51309 жыл бұрын
When I saw this in my subscriptions list, the first thing I thought was “I bet Emmylou Homs has the top spot!” and I wasn’t wrong! She’s not my favourite, but I honestly can’t blame you for putting her there, she is amazing! First big disagreement; Finnish; I love her, but I respect your opinion. Also I’d place Quebec French much higher; she’s my second favourite! Also I think Icelandic deserves higher, especially when you compare her to her sister! English low :/ I was hoping she’d make the Top 10, mais c’est la vie! I’m very glad Ukrainian is high though, she’s very underrated! Finally Portuguese and Greek get some love; they are underrated even more so than Ukrainian. Oh how I love the Italian dub! Anyway sorry for this essay; great video as usual!
@charguigou9 жыл бұрын
Eadie Stroud Lol sorry, Emmylou is my favourite French voice as people already know and she's one of my favourite dubbing voice, I love her. I guess I'm the only one not liking Finnish to death. I have the impression so many people love her because she's a Disney fan.. Yeah I understand for Quebec French, as I said, she's good in the start for me, then she becomes annoying and weird, but I think only a French speaking person can hear it. Sorry for English, as I said, the others have more flavour and interesting voices than her, she does everything fine, but she isn't as interesting as the others. Thanks a lot :)
@e-kay16899 жыл бұрын
Thanks so so much for 6th place. FINALLY someone who can understand that a voice doesn't sound old just because it's deep! I think Vassia really fits Anna and she did a great job both in the speaking and the singing part. I hate it when people dislike her just because her voice is deeper than most Annas!!! Nice editing by the way!!! :D
Well, my friend we don't agree too much, but this ranking is so beatiful and you are really respectful with your comments about the singers. I love that,
@charguigou9 жыл бұрын
Gaby Cid Sucre Thank you very much !
9 жыл бұрын
charguigou I have waited for this ranking of yours for a long time, and I cannot wait to see your Elsa ranking. Emmylou is totally the best who did speaking and singing, but for my number one singer Amylea is her! Emmylou is my second overall. I like Carmen too, she is my 14 also, people say she sounds fake, but because it is her real voice, she's great! I agree mostly, but I was sad to see Li Xiao-Xiao so "low",and also Beate, she is one of my big favorites. I also love Ray! I was disappointed by Slovakia's choices for this film, but I definelty think Lucia is the better of the two sisters. Your editing just keeps improving, it is SO meticuluous and perfect this time, even better than ever before!!!
@disneyqueen989 жыл бұрын
Beautiful editing :) Thank you for 10. place :D
@charguigou9 жыл бұрын
Disney Queens Thanks :)
@ClaudiaBronte9 жыл бұрын
You were right, we disagree with almost everything about Anna's voices^^ But surely this was a pleasure to watch, like all your videos :D Thank you for 5th place anyway!
@charguigou9 жыл бұрын
Claudia Bronte Thank you very much :)
@KHeartsdiva543219 жыл бұрын
That intro was so cool and different, where is that clip from?
@charguigou9 жыл бұрын
KHeartsdiva54321 I don't know, Disney posted on their channel this short clip, I downloaded it and then decided to use it as the intro. Yeah, a lot of people seem shock for English place, it's still a good place. Thanks a lot for the nice words :)
@ayoosha2658 жыл бұрын
great job l disgree whit Latin spanish and Finnsh too 😯 thanks for Greek, ltalan and Arabic too❤👍
@paulacabrerahernandez3654 жыл бұрын
And castilian 😔
@serenity99263 жыл бұрын
@@paulacabrerahernandez365 again i see you, stop forcing people to like castilian, no one will like it if you keep forcing it on others, personally i like latin spanish over castilian but do i say "and latin spanish 😞" no i don't now stop
@leoaugust2859 жыл бұрын
Honestly I was so shock to see your opinions! We really have many disagreements. But I really love to see others opinions so I gonna say that your opnions are really different and unique!
@charguigou9 жыл бұрын
Faiq D Yes, that's really her real voice, she's 30 years old and more, and that's how she really sounds in her songs and in real life ! She sang only this part, it was for a show, there's just this. Thanks a lot for the comment :)
@DreamieQueen9 жыл бұрын
charguigou Wait, I swear, she doesn't sound so old when she sings naturally xD she modifies her voice on this parody too. She always changes her tones (high, low, deep, etc). And since she has no songs from herself, she is always immitating singers to sound the closest as possible. And the links I shared in an other comment above were songs she sang when she wasn't singing for immitating.
@charguigou9 жыл бұрын
Hibana Koseki Well, for a first part she doesn't sound old when she sang as Elsa, she sounds like a 30 years old lady to me. I agree she changed it a bit too, but that's closer to her natural voice. Yes the two other links weren't Edith Piaf but as I said these are from 2008, she was much younger at the time !
@diogogouveia41089 жыл бұрын
Ah... Isabel, my forbidden love xD She sounds so clumsy and expressive! She's like the Greek and Italian ones for me, mature, but still amazing :] Quite surprised that Swedish wasn't at the top 3, like I've seen in other rankings.
THANKS FOR SLOVAK VERSION ON 8TH PLACE. I am so glad that you like it and I absolutely agree with yours opinions for them.😊😊❤
@Aeeliy9 жыл бұрын
Proud to be French x)
@franckout16056 жыл бұрын
Moi aussi
@serenity99263 жыл бұрын
moi aussi
@DreamieQueen9 жыл бұрын
Actually, Véronique changes a bit her voice in this parody to sound more mature since she is ''immitating'' a woman of 50 years old xD Of course, she will modify her singing in case to suit the character. And to me, she doesn't sound fake at all as Anna. Here how she sounds most of the time when she sings kzbin.info/www/bejne/eKupmZdmmJifbbs kzbin.info/www/bejne/faquo2SXjdFso8k kzbin.info/www/bejne/gZqxYqWDqNFln7c
@charguigou9 жыл бұрын
Hibana Koseki No, I've heard her sing live, and she sounds much more like her Elsa than her Anna. In the videos you linked, in the first one she's imitating Edith Piaf and that's why she sounds a bit more like her Anna, and second, those videos are from 2008, she was much younger, now she's in her 30s and her voice has aged, and she's clearly changing her voice for Anna. That's good I guess to fit the character, but for me it makes her sound fake after a while, you can hear it's not natural ...
@DreamieQueen9 жыл бұрын
Well I guess we have different opinions about her Anna where I think she sounds really natural and not fake. But oh well, I respect your opinion! ^^ (If only Véronique was singing a full version of Let it Go and not just a parody, my life would be completed)
@Diddykun68 жыл бұрын
Ça ne m'a pas du tout étonné de voir Emmylou en première place. x) Quand je l'ai entendue la première fois, je la trouvais un peu… trop… "gnan-gnan" ? o.O Mais quand je l'ai entendue en "original pitch", OH MY GOD ! she was so much better. :o Je sentais sensiblement la même chose avec Karine Costa et Marie Galey. Maintenant, je la trouve super mignonne. :3 Il y a des parties où je la trouve pas assez énergique ou excitée. :/ Tu as raison, ses parties parlées sont un chef-d'œuvre.
@charguigou8 жыл бұрын
Haha ça me fait plaisir qu'on partage le même avis. Et tu sais, moi aussi la première fois que j'ai entendu Emmylou, je la trouvais un peu banale ! Haha comme quoi les opinions évoluent. Oula, oiu désolé mais je n'aime vraiment pas Joël Legendre. Je le détestais étant petit et ça n'a pas évolué avec le temps :/
@Diddykun68 жыл бұрын
+charguigou Je l'aime bien en tant qu'animateur, chanteur et comédien, je l'avoue, c'est une personne extraordinaire. :) Mais sur Aladdin ou Hercule ? Non… juste non ! J'ai tellement l'impression qu'il se sent obligé de chanter qu'il le fait contre son plein gré. Et je trouve que ses émotions sont forcées et… fake ? faux ? o.O (Je suis tellement habitué de le dire en anglais que, quand je le dis en français, ça sonne bizarre. XD)
@charguigou8 жыл бұрын
Entièrement d'accord, il fait fake et pas naturel du tout sur Aladdin :/
@moviepie28499 жыл бұрын
Well, Thanks for 42, lol... I'm a lot disagree with Canadian French, she's just perfect IMO. I agree with your comment about Kristien, just I think she deserves to be a bit higher, but It's your opinion and I totally respect it:) And glad to see Slovak and Emmylou that high, but I disagree with your comment about her young Anna, anyway I like her:)
@lilifranc44509 жыл бұрын
There is something weird with the french canadian version of "Let it go". I'm french and the lyrics are no sens, it seems to be a joke
@edithgagnon68008 жыл бұрын
This is a joke, it wasn't for the movie. She just did a cover on it for making fun of politicians. In Quebec, it's the same version as the french one.
@palacenight9 жыл бұрын
Latin Spanish 42? :(
@charguigou9 жыл бұрын
Sorry, I don't like Romina in this role :/
@peru40684 жыл бұрын
and I hate Carmen I prefer Laura
@leonardoayala27379 жыл бұрын
YES!! Romina as one of the lowest, I knew I wasn't the only one! I'm really agreeing in the low places, wow! Well, Deniz and Bernadett would be higher for me I guess, but yes, Danish, Slovene, so true! I used to have Saara on around the same place you have her, but then I realized how similar she sounds to Maria Ylipää, whom I love with all my heart, so I can't be rough on her. Then we get to a lot of forgettable voices where I agree again for every one of them expect for Korean, Quebec and Putonghua. And then the Kristen bomb was dropped. You're brave as heck for putting her outside the top 20, I don't personally agree, but I get it, she is standardly perfect. Your top 20 is hot or miss for me. Yay for Carmen
@charguigou9 жыл бұрын
Leonardo Ayala Yeah lol, I never could love Romina in this role, there's just something ... not. I don't know. Lol I didn't think it would be a bomb, not because she's original that she's the most awesome ^^ As I said, and as you said perfectly, she's standardly perfect. But many others have more flavour and are more interesting to me. Yeah, I'm always sad to see people dislike Emmylou for being childish, while she was 19 (one year older than Anna), while Véronique is in her 30s and clearly changing her voice and sounding fake and nobody notices it :( Thanks for the comment :)
@natasaarsic3718 Жыл бұрын
Where I an found your Original Elsa Ranking with this editing Thank you for 10th place btw🇧🇦🇭🇷
@samoyede02089 жыл бұрын
Emmylou Homs ? I'm very surprised! [Irony] ;-) Seriously, I really think she's is great even if I prefer her in the speaking parts... I agree with you to say she has a true skill for acting! For example I didn't recognize her as child Anna either... ^^' I just discovered the Slovak dub and I think Lucia's voice is so cute!
@morenokingindrawan98825 жыл бұрын
Charguigou, when you'll redone?
@icecrystalqueen96239 жыл бұрын
Oh, I disagree with a lot. xD (Finnish, Turkish, Estonian, English and so on) But beautiful edititng, that's sure. I'm quite disappointed about the place of the Hungarian version, in my opinion we don't deserve a place like that, because she isn't a "fresh voice".... Anyway, "thank you for the 38th place". :P
@charguigou9 жыл бұрын
IceCrystalQueen Well that's just my opinion I grew tired of hearing Bernadett that's all
@icecrystalqueen96239 жыл бұрын
charguigou Okey. Pleasant to hear. :D
@Ysreen9 жыл бұрын
Wow! Quel speech sur Emmylou! J'admets que si j'ai une horreur absolue de la voix d'Anaïs pour Elsa, Emmylou (et Véronique presque autant), sonne complètement naturelle pour Anna. Elle partage la 1ère place avec Mimi, parce que la version Suédoise est parfaite de bout en bout pour moi. La seule chose qui me dérange pour les chansons en français, c'est la façon dont ils ont changé le sens des paroles, je trouve que ça rend un peu plus enfantin un Disney qui l'est déjà bien assez. petit mini nb: je suis juste ravie qu'il y ait un autre Français mature et parlant bien anglais ici bas dans l'univers de Disney, je me sens moins seule uhuhu ...
@charguigou9 жыл бұрын
Ysreen Il y a beaucoup de français ici qui parle anglais :)
@yaminarayah60222 жыл бұрын
@@charguigou nsnsnnsndndnwnnw w S..d s d wnwnnw wbbwbwbwbbd d.s wnwnbwbsbsbsbbwbwbbdbdb. Nsnsnnwnsnnsnsnnwnwnwbbww
@sketchthemouse13737 жыл бұрын
I love how comments here are so nice!
@charguigou7 жыл бұрын
F1ixiazo 4 oh thank you so much, I always try to be the more respectful and kind possible in my comments
@sketchthemouse13737 жыл бұрын
charguigou Well you achieved it! :) I subbed! 3/3/17
9 жыл бұрын
Thanks for 11th! ^^
@miawinters22467 жыл бұрын
OMG I'm so glad you love Emmylou more than Veronique ;) I'm not a fan of Veronique she is to robotic :) Thanks for 1 st place
@miawinters22467 жыл бұрын
And ???
@channeldusydoo77419 жыл бұрын
I'm sad that Korean(Mrs. Park is my Anna!) and English(True princess..)is too low.. But I agree with Emmylou and Lucia M. Bugalova! They are wonderful!
@balafenn_7 жыл бұрын
Thank for the 1st place !
@juliaenter53059 жыл бұрын
Thank you very much for 19th place :). Personally I put her a bit higher as she is in my top 5 Polish voices, but it's okay, of course :) You editing changed quite a lot, but it's still perfect and professional. My favourite background was this with the trees (from 39 to 34). No, you're not alone with Finnish :). She is one of the most loved Annas and Finnish voices, but to be honest her voice is very uncontrolled and agressive for me :/. Your nmmber one is very good, but I don't put her that high as she is too sweet for my taste, what bothers me a lot. However, I can't deny she sings and acts very very well :). I disagee with some versions like Canadian French, Korean, Latvian, Russian, Cantonese and Swedish being that low as I totally love them, and Malay, Arabic, Croatian and Vietnamese being so high as they are not so great for me. Fantastic and beautiful video as always and I can't wait for Elsa raking! x)
@charguigou9 жыл бұрын
Julia Enter Really ? Lol well nothing changed, besides except background images I put the end credits images ^^ THANK YOU, she's totally a normal Finnish voice to me, nothing much special or outstanding. Thanks a lot :)
@juliaenter53059 жыл бұрын
This time you also didn't write any information about the movie in the intro. But I think it would be useless as the movie is known, very very very well ;) Yes, I don't really understand why people love her so much. She is good, but there are better. You're welcome!
@charguigou9 жыл бұрын
Julia Enter Yes true because the video was already quite long, and there was this short extract of 15 minutes, so I've decided to just put this extract so I had to shorten what I write in the intro usually. And as you said, everybody knows the movie very well.
@fallingsapphires9 жыл бұрын
Great ranking. I don't feel like making an elaborate comment, so I'm just gonna say I disagree and agree on some parts :D And I am shocked upon hearing Veronique's real voice! It's very beautiful, but unfortunately I don't like her Anna. I'm glad that Carmen is high, and thank you so much for Greek! I love them both a lot. Thank you so much for 2nd place, it was such a big surprise! I thought you didn't like Amylea or something, so it started to creep me out when top five passed and Amylea still didn't show up. I really thought you forgot her! Well I'm glad you love her! I don't love her as much as I used to but she's still one of my favourites. I absolutely agree on your first! Such a great, wonderful voice. In the end, this turned out to be an elaborate comment anyway :P
@HABbigxsmile9 жыл бұрын
Where is FLEMISH?? Did I miss it xd
@charguigou9 жыл бұрын
HABbigxsmile You did miss it, watch again ;)
@Meirenyu9 жыл бұрын
No surprise for 1st, but agree with top 5! And thanks so much for 4th
@fyraksvkthestudiosnailstep83337 жыл бұрын
Thank you for 8th place! Wow! I didn't expect us that high! Wooohooo! :D
@jaisajosh83108 жыл бұрын
I disagree when you say Emmylou is more sincere and natural as Anna than Kristen. Kristen is the original voice, true, but she embodied her in every way, every breath, she almost created Anna. For me Kristen = Anna. I've never felt such a big connection between a character and a dubber (excepted Paige O'Hara and Belle, what a perfectly amazingly awesomely voice for her), Emmylou is a great but Kristen is on another level.
@charguigou8 жыл бұрын
Uh, where did I say she's more sincere and natural than Kristen ? Nowhere. And moreover, that's YOUR opinion, it doesn't make it a generality. For me, Emmylou is much better and more interesting than Kristen, that's all
@jaisajosh83108 жыл бұрын
I think you're a little too subjective. And I don't think the fact that Emmylou sang for child-Anna is a good thing. It proves that Emmylou has such a too young voice for Anna, even if she is 19. No matter if she is 13,19 or 40 years old, her voice is still too young, cute and sugary for a such modern and rebel princess. Kristen nailed this side perfectly : she sounds bubbly, youthful, emotional, powerful, with personnality and elegance. A perfect voice for this princess. There's no voice who can beat Kristen in term of embodiement of Anna. And that's an objective judgment.
@charguigou8 жыл бұрын
Lol and aren't you subjective as well ? What makes your opinion a truth ? I never said "Emmylou is better than Kristen", I said it was MY opinion. When Emmylou sang as Teenage Anna, she changes her voice, that's not her natural voice. And I don't see how a 19 years old girl can be said to be too young for a 18 years old character, do you realize how silly is that ? Kristen was 33 years old - I don't say she's not good for Anna - and you think she's better age-wise for a 18 years old character ? Sorry, but you'll never make me agree with that. If Emmylou, at 18 years old, sound like that, then Anna, who is 18 years old, can also sound like that. That is all. Lol that's an "objective" judgement ? Pardon me, but you're not objective AT ALL.
@jaisajosh83108 жыл бұрын
charguigou Je suis désolée mais j'essaie justement d'être la plus objective possible. Certes Emmylou a le même âge qu'Anna, mais ça n'a pas de sens de dire que tel doubleur peut jouer tel personnage juste parce qu'ils ont le même âge.. C'est la voix qui compte, et non le physique. Donc je reste sur mon avis, Emmylou a certes 18 ans mais sa voix est bien trop juvénile et mignonne pour la personnalité d'Anna. Il faut avant tout que la voix corresponde à la personnalité, même si il y a des exceptions. Disney France a voulu comme à son habitude, choisir une voix de princesse typique qui au final donne l'impression qu'Anna est une fille girly et mignonne, insouciante et presque énervante, tout le contraire de Kristen qui lui a donné de la modernité, de l'humour, du caractère, de la personnalité et de l'élégance. Et de manière objective, Kristen est bien meilleure actrice et chanteuse qu'Emmylou. De plus justement le fait qu'elle soit capable se chanter pour une enfant d'environ 13 ans montre bien que sa voix est trés jeune et donc trop jeune pour Anna.. Là où Kristen, à 33 ans, avait la voix parfaite pour elle.
@harrietamidala16919 жыл бұрын
I think I finally caught on what you're doing with the intros prior to the dub rankings--you're using the DVD menus. Am I right?
@charguigou9 жыл бұрын
harrietamidala1691 This one isn't the menu, it's a short clip Disney posted on their channel
@Merlin_EmrysPendragon_Jr.5 жыл бұрын
Sorry to say that but it's not the Québec French version of Let it Go, it's a parody 😂😂. And thanks for the 1st place 😍😍
@charguigou5 жыл бұрын
Avengers Fan I never said it was, if you had read, I said it was a parody
@mulwerk85747 жыл бұрын
Well, i wasn't expecting 42th place, but sincerely i'm not a fan of her as Anna.. She has a LOT of roles where she sounds amazing, but as Anna( at least her singing) is very liveless to me( her speaking parts are better IMO), in FTFTIF reprise she is like "talking" while Elsa is REALLY singing. Well, i guess is true the fact that Veronique sometimes can sound fake, i still like her anyway, but i like Emmylou more! And i love your top 10 and editing :) Nice Ranking!
@Julie-jy5cj3 жыл бұрын
Les pays fantastiques 💖💖💖💖💖💖 La Perse Le Mexique La Roumanie La Hongrie La Finlande La Hollande La Thaïlande Le Brésil La Norvège Le Canada Le Macao L'Angleterre La Lituanie Le Japon L'Arabie L'Espagne La Suède La Croatie La Slovaquie La Grèce Hong -Kong La Malaisie
@Superibis.9 жыл бұрын
You perfectly sumed up my opinion on Véronique. It's a shame because I truly think she could be a great Anna :/ and I was surprise to hear she actually can sing very well when she's not faking her voice ^^ Also agree on English. I really enjoyed her but now I find her a bit too old sounding for Anna. I loved Pia's Rapunzel and I think she's even better as Anna for some reason (because honestly, I think she sounds exactly like her Rapunzel ^^ I don't know why it works better here). I also think Carmen is much better here than in Tangled but on the other hand, I couldn't "hate" her more ^^ So glad to see Portuguese high :D She's my instant favourite and as weird as it seems I think she's one of the most fitting Anna. Just perfect
@charguigou9 жыл бұрын
Superibis haha glad you think the same of Emmylou, she made Anna real !
@nightghost95149 жыл бұрын
Thanks for 11th place i'm glad that you like Lejla :D i lot peopls don't like her :/ and put Lejla on very lower places :/ but this place is one of the best places for her :)
@charguigou9 жыл бұрын
NightGhost 95 I wish I could place her even higher, she's totally among my favourites, but I love a lot of Annas!
@nightghost95149 жыл бұрын
I understand you totally there is a lot great versions :D
@vinaykapse93507 жыл бұрын
You wrote in description that you add hindi but there is no hindi
@charguigou7 жыл бұрын
Meow Kitty TO BE redone, as in WILL BE remake
@alifnajmi37919 жыл бұрын
Wow! Simply wow! You posted in youtube. But, i have many disagreements,sweetie. Especially with English. First,i think she'll be your number one.I mostly agree with Hungarian(i kow in my opinion she is would low),Ukrainian,Mandarin,Malay(they are amazing!!). So,maybe Italian,French(sorry!),and Vietnamese ( a bit) LOWER!! They are not very very awesome.. But least,I respect your opinion. Sorry for long comment :)
@Julie-jy5cj3 жыл бұрын
Les pays merveilleux 💚💚💚💚💚💚 L'Albanie L'Estonie La Slovénie La Turquie Le Danemark La République Tchèque La Lettonie La Russie La Corée La Catalogne Le Hong Kong L'Islande L'Israël La Pologne L'Allemagne L'Ukraine La Bulgarie La Serbie La Belgique Le Portugal L'Italie Le Vietnam La Bretagne
@hefraindisnerd9 жыл бұрын
I am only agree with Malay because in the rest I am completely disagree especially in the high and low places. Though I am so happy finally Swedish is not the number 1 again xD. And about French Anna she is a cute sweetheart :33 >u
@lemonred25449 жыл бұрын
Carmen is lovely, better than Romina (al menos para mí) ^-^
@hefraindisnerd9 жыл бұрын
A mi también me encanta su version de Anna ^^
@lemonred25449 жыл бұрын
+Francisco LunaXD ¿Porque a todos les gusta la version Malaya? Realmemte su autotune me moleta mucho, aunque ella es perfecta como Nala ;)
@hefraindisnerd9 жыл бұрын
Tal Vez por que le queda muy bien xD
@lemonred25449 жыл бұрын
+Francisco LunaXD LOL, las unicas cantantes que son asombrosas en Anna para mí son Hạ Trâm, Lejla, Isabel, Vassia, Serena, Pia, Ray, Shorouq & Vesela.
@Julie-jy5cj3 жыл бұрын
Les pays mystérieux 💘💘💘💘💘💘 La Perse Le Mexique La Roumanie La Hongrie La Finlande Les Pays - Bas La Thaïlande Le Brésil La Norvége Le Canada Le Macao L'Écosse La Lituanie Le Japon La Palestine L'Espagne La Suéde La Croatie La Slovaquie La Grèce La Chine La Malaisie
@elsasicekingdom81463 жыл бұрын
2:54 딱새야 딱새야
@carlosalejandroalvarenga49137 жыл бұрын
I thought Rimina Narrow u in deserved a little higher.
@Julie-jy5cj3 жыл бұрын
Les pays mystérieux 💘💘💘💘💘💘 La Perse Le Mexique La Roumanie Les Pays - Bas La Thaïlande Le Brésil La Norvège Le Canada Le Macao L'Angleterre La Lituanie Le Japon La Palestine L'Espagne La Suède La Croatie La Slovaquie La Grèce La Chine La Malaisie
@alaamohsen23679 жыл бұрын
Thanks for the 16th place and the nice comment
@franckout16056 жыл бұрын
Did they know that The meaning in let it go of quebec was A parody And we Dont Even know it was really her
@tanukitanuki55859 жыл бұрын
Mon dieu j'ai eu peur je croyais que c'était ka version officielle la québécquoise :')
@someonesomewhere66339 жыл бұрын
I love the Greek Anna, I think she's the best!
@JessieRiri9 жыл бұрын
Superbe vidéo
@charguigou9 жыл бұрын
jessie riri MDRR merci c'est gentil ^^
@cpa56778 жыл бұрын
thank you for 6th place
@kurniliaayudwiyanti88906 жыл бұрын
Wheres Indonesian
@8is4 жыл бұрын
I thought you liked deeper voices and then you had EU French in first place. I a bit surprised you didn't have Swedish in the your top 5 since you like EU French so much. I mean both don't have that deep voices, both were 19 in 2013, both have great speaking voices and both made great performances. I Prefer Swedish though because in the EU French she sounds a bit powerless/not sure of herself which I don't think reflects the character that well. I mean Anna, in my mind, is the type that gets things done. It's actually a pretty common thing with the lighter voices. So I like Swedish's middle ground here, not deep voice, nearly perfect age, great performance, fitting voice, great speaking voice and, of course, she sings with confidence when appropriate.
@charguigou4 жыл бұрын
I see you have your opinion and I have mine, and I explained it in this video. And no, I don't like "deeper" voices, I like all kind of voices, and I explained why i liked each voice in that video.
@8is4 жыл бұрын
@@charguigou Firstly, I think it is wonderful that you go around and spend your precious time reading these comments, especially after all these years. Anyways, I don't know, it might have been good to state whether how deep voice was going be an important factor or not (it is for me at least). But anyhow, would you agree with me about EU French's voice actor's lack of confidence? For me at least, that's the dealbreaker I have with the EU French version. Not to say that she's bad, she probably my favorite light voiced and unsure sounding Anna, so I am not judging her too hard for it.
@charguigou4 жыл бұрын
@@8is No, she doesn't sound unsure or lacking confidence to me
@8is4 жыл бұрын
@@charguigou I find her pretty weak in for the first time in forever reprise at least. I.e her voice gets quite easily drown out by Elsa's singing. I don't know, feels like she is missing some power¯\_(ツ)_/¯.
@charguigou4 жыл бұрын
@@8is good for you. I disagree.
@hanon8809 жыл бұрын
Je suis assez d'accord Anna en français est très bien (contrairement à Elsa qui possède une voix au final très agaçante)! c'est vrai que son jeu est très marrant est naturel! (Anna a été très bien réussi dans pleins de langues *^*)
@dimitrapl.96159 жыл бұрын
thanks so much for the 6th place
@poszetitus9 жыл бұрын
Sorry, but the 38. it's not Hungarian!
@charguigou9 жыл бұрын
+Tirza Cserpes Well yes, it's Hungarian
@morenokingindrawan98825 жыл бұрын
When you'll redone this? With adding Indonesian, Hindi others
@charguigou5 жыл бұрын
When I have the time
@morenokingindrawan98825 жыл бұрын
@@charguigou oh okay
@morenokingindrawan98825 жыл бұрын
@@charguigou but when you will have time? School holiday?
@erik.s87636 жыл бұрын
08 THX Slovak!!
@MahmoudrezaFarzanegan9 жыл бұрын
My God ! My God ! Now we have the Best Channel KZbin Ranking Anna
@charguigou9 жыл бұрын
Mahmoudreza Farzanegan Haha that's really nice ^^ Yeah, many voices are better and more interesting than English to me. But she's still in a good place. Amylea was just the perfect Anna, the first time I've heard her - while she came late - she directly placed 2nd, and never got dethroned. Don't worry, I love Marsha as well, if you remember my old ranking, she's high ^^ Thank you very much for all the kind words, that's really nice :)
@MahmoudrezaFarzanegan9 жыл бұрын
charguigou Thanks so much
@charguigou9 жыл бұрын
Mahmoudreza Farzanegan I just love her as much as before; just like Amylea, I fell in love with Marsha the first time I've listenned to her ! And I was surprised because at first, in the first ranking of Elsa at the beginning of 2014, Malay wasn't so high, people didn't seem to notice her, while she's clearly amazing ! But now she's getting the love she deserves, she's almost always in the top 5
@MahmoudrezaFarzanegan9 жыл бұрын
charguigou Thanks so much
@oracle99gg7 жыл бұрын
thnx for sixth place!!!
@_rainbow_pie_9 жыл бұрын
Thank you for 15th place.
@MehmettAli9 жыл бұрын
Thanks for 39th and 10th places wow :*
@YHCP146 жыл бұрын
42 pero que ... Por que ?
@charguigou6 жыл бұрын
Yeison Cuesta I’ve written a whole comment why
@YHCP146 жыл бұрын
Why the 42nd place ?
@lorianag50976 жыл бұрын
Of course she’d put French first......
@charguigou6 жыл бұрын
Julia G yass I’m a guy
@lorianag50976 жыл бұрын
charguigou all the comments say “her” but okay
@lorianag50976 жыл бұрын
charguigou sorry about this
@peru40684 жыл бұрын
I put Samin, Romina, Tanja, Cătălina, Deniz, Saraa, Gabriela, Park Ji-Yun, Eva Li, Kristen Bell, Einat, Magdalena, Kanda, Mariia higher I put Tereza, Beãte, Natalia, Paula, Kandy, Neringa, Carmen, Vesela, Lejla, Lucia, Isabel, Vassia lower
@paulacabrerahernandez3653 жыл бұрын
Porque a Paula?
@peru40683 жыл бұрын
@@paulacabrerahernandez365 no me gusta suena demasiado forzada
@elsasicekingdom81463 жыл бұрын
@@peru4068 i put þordis higher.
@PopRock-gl5ey2 ай бұрын
Vesela lower?
@lowings139 жыл бұрын
thanks for 29th places:)
@Julie-jy5cj4 жыл бұрын
Moi je préfère le québécois français , le portugais et le néerlandais ce sont les langues les plus mélodieuses et vraiment magnifiques
@evametezeau56096 жыл бұрын
Véronique ets super en temps qu'Elsa, mais en temps qy'Ana, il y a un truc bizarre, mais Emmylou est juste incroyable