Peter Judges: Viewer Art

Watch Episode 2 here: kzbin.info/www/bejne/lWLOlWZ7iM6qo6M
A lot of amazing stuff here, no doubt. I had people include their twitter handle in the pic with the art so that they'd get credit as I flipped through, and also in an effort to only share art made by the person who posted it. Also it increases the effort required to share a piece of art, otherwise I probably would have actually had hundreds of submissions.
THANK YOU FOR EVERYONE THAT SHARED SOMETHING, I know it can take a lot of courage to show the world your art sometimes. You all did wonderfully.
Follow me on Twitch to join me next time I do a live stream: www.twitch.tv/peterdraws
Join me on Patreon for extra perks: www.patreon.com/peterdraws
Check out my new book Dayfever here: amzn.to/2WWIFuK
And all the rest of my books: www.amazon.com/-/e/B00HVOQ27S
My website has lots of helpful links for buying shirts and other merch: www.peterdraws.com/shop/
Use this link as your Amazon bookmark to support the channel at no additional cost to you: www.amazon.com?tag=petdra-20
Instagram: peterdraws
Facebook: peterdraws1
Twitter: PeterDraws1
Email: [e-mail]

[@peter_draws]

Hopefully I can dispel a bit of the drama if I say that I intended to joke about the whole video being a mistake at the beginning, not the drawing I was looking at. I think some people misinterpreted my joke and are (perhaps with some reason) upset. Regardless it was still a joke at the artist's expense, but I still think it was funny. I guess I'm not apologizing for the joke, but just that so many people seem to think that it was a much harsher joke. I would never tell someone that their art was flatout awful or a mistake or bad, and from the artist's response on twitter, thankfully I don't think they took it as strongly as some people on here, they were just looking forward to seeing my reaction to some art which is obviously in a style at sharp contrast to my own, which is reasonable. Also sorry if there wasn't enough critique on some pieces for some people's liking. We'll see how the next video goes, and I'll try to more obviously label what I'm doing as a critique or a roast, this one was a bit of both in some places, which was kind of bad maybe :P Thanks everyone, I just wanted to make a comment to get this off my mind. To all of you that reacted strongly when you thought I was calling the drawing "a mistake," thank you, that's good.

[@gildersleevee]

Good on you mate, I think it is a great thing to know your frame of mind that you had when you went over the art folks sent to you for your feelings on if you like it or not. To be honest that ONE critique is the only one of all them you did that seemed a bit out of place. That is probably why it got taken the wrong way. On a whole I thought your remarks were spot on and very kind at times. Do more of these it can help the artists that are sending their work to you for your ideas on what they did.

[@weirdosq5225]

Also quite unfortunate that it was the first one too, bet if it was somewhere in the middle of the video we would have seen less reactions, nevertheless, thanks for clearing it up.

[@doodletime9041]

Thank you, I'm happy that we got this out the way, I don't want to criticize you, I like you xD

[@thomastakeshita4979]

You're not allowed to joke peter this is my safe space

[@LeChakaraka]

Don't apologize big guy! I think it would be a priviledge to get critique in this way. You're providing an ubiased persepctive on all these people's art, which they may never get from their friends and family or even their art teachers. Plus, you're not being a jerk about it at all. AND you're taking a break from looking at your own art work to look at other people's work, which shows humility and empathy. Do more!

[@lebeleb]

*is this a mistake*

[@peter_draws]

lol I meant the video

[@NoodleGoblin]

@@peter_draws please pin this comment so people aren't confused x3

[@lebeleb]

Peter Draws ohhh that makes more sense!

[@nataliamiller8461]

I laughed so fucking hard

[@Sonicaleb1]

What video? I’m confused

[@Altim4643]

0:50 My dad some years ago, taking me in his arms for the first time.

[@butteredbananas1394]

Hahhaha. Sorry through.

[@lilroadrage]

Damn I relate to this on a hard ass levvl

[@CaptGismo]

Oof

[@lapicaraviborita7751]

Same

[@Sirbanza]

L e L iiii

[@TT-sg3vt]

Oh my god the first picture Peters reaction. I can’t breath. Help call the local authorities.

[@han5965]

911 I just witnessed a murder

[@MrSparkSo]

"This was a mistake"

[@riteasrain]

Overreacting guys. Settle down 😃

[@eldritchemissary2161]

Can't spell either

[@slavski33]

@@eldritchemissary2161 y r u here anyway ? Shouldnt u b fixin that piece of shit game u just released ? Lol. 👊🖖

[@irritatedempath]

Hi all 👋 I was the artist of the first one! I was excited to see his reaction because our Aesthetics™️ are so different and I’m not surprised. He said in the original tweet that he might or might not be nice so I was prepared for harsh criticism/negative reaction, I’m not hurt by his joking! My style is Very anime and super obnoxious, it’s not everyone’s cup of tea and super different from his style! To everyone complimenting it, I appreciate it and thank youuu💗💕✨

[@jellygoaway1219]

Im do releived to know you weren't hurt, I for one think you nailed the obnoxious anime☆♡◇ style and I can deffinetly appreciate that. I look forward to see more art from you in the future.

[@CharlieGirlDoll]

IrritatedEmpath Oh I’m so glad that you’re doing well! Loved your bright and poppy style. It makes me happy to see everyone care about a stranger’s art so much that they’re writing large paragraphs and kindly worded notes towards you and criticizing Peter’s criticism in the fear that he went just a tad too close to a line of being rude. I feel Peter was joking, it was obviously not his kind of aesthetics, not the kind of thing he looks for in art or gets entertainment from. But again, glad people were thoughtful enough to jump to a stranger’s defense just in case.

[@FathomlessChaos]

Its extremely pleasing to see you aren't as soft as the majority of the people in this comment section. Its definitely a cool drawing, but I like anime lol

[@SlightlyMiscalculated]

Seeing your comment made me happy. As someone who growing up had a lot of people dismiss my art rather than critique it, it made me sad seeing Peter skip over it without actually saying anything constructive or even positive. I think you draw legs really well, and pastels are always great, your use of simple rounded shapes on the head and face is very pleasing to the eye. There's nothing wrong with grasping hold of a style or technique based on popular media or other's work that keeps your interest in creating early on, even if others don't like it. No matter where your art takes you, I hope you continue to create and grow as an artist! Much love to you!

[@sheeplorde]

GG

[@RatsDoDance]

Idk why that first one made me laugh as hard as it did, but It made me lose it LOL

[@aeonm9857]

it was supposed to be funny 😂

[@nataliamiller8461]

Sameee

[@callummandragore9004]

For real though i laughed so hard 😂 Tumblroid art be like

[@traww9537]

What did you lose

[@senza4591]

@@traww9537 it, duh

[@somescrub8951]

This video solidified my belief that Peter is secretly a grumpy old art teacher.

[@slendermanoncrack3603]

some scrub lmao

[@largegrape]

​@slendermanoncrack3603 what do you mean by this

[@somescrub8951]

@@largegrape that's my username followed by them saying "lmao"

[@largegrape]

@@somescrub8951 ohh I thought it was a burn

[@somescrub8951]

@@largegrape 😂😂

[@spacetashy]

0:50 "Is this a mistake?" 😂😂💀 damn peter

[@thesaltyseacracker456]

rip whoevers art that was

[@lomo3362]

He meant making the video lmao

[@aulerius]

Welcome people. A lot of you realized just now that Peter is a human being and not a super being of peace and art with unlimited kindness and patience for everyone.

[@Choccoco]

Yes. Welcome to youtube culture where everyone is forcefully angelized until they act human.

[@turkeymcduckin7909]

@@Choccoco OH my god, are you serious? He said he would critique, not shit all over art without critiquing it. It's not him being angel, I don't think it's that much to ask to just respect that someone put effort into something and sent it to him.

[@schlubenno3827]

Turkey McDuckin He’s _joking_ and they signed up for it when they sent him their drawings.

[@liverrse5680]

It's just a contrast from his normal chill talking about "you do whatever you makes you happy" then calls a cleany finished piece a mistake?

[@orls9068]

@@turkeymcduckin7909 Exactly, people have him on a pedestal and make excuses for his shitty comments.

[@Vyrilien]

Aw, whoever did 31:15 : I actually love the scribbliness of it all. What would normally be a rigid, sterile and impersonal environment instead looks chaotic, worn and personal if that makes any sense. I dig the contrast. And I don't think the erratic strokes, wobbly lines and not entirely filled in areas are a failing so much as a conscious decision. Or well, it's all shots in the dark here till the artist pipes up, but I felt pretty strongly about this one so that's out there now. Anyway, it's been kinda surreal to see how very in sync in some areas but how super different in others our tastes and opinions are. If you ever do one of these again, I'd be up for joining in.

[@sofvckingtired]

u seriously made a speech here

[@slackjaw703]

That kid that looked familiar? Do the words “Dammit, Bobby!” ring a bell?

[@buuvegas]

Where?

[@slackjaw703]

@ 18:08, the kid on the far right is the spitting image of Bobby Hill.

[@Project_Worm]

Yes!!! That's what I was figured he was thinking

[@GhoulScoutCookie]

Propane!

[@lifeimitatingdeath3608]

This is what i was looking for.. BWAHHHH!

[@QuiteShallow]

Anime was indeed a mistake Peter.

[@juiciebox]

That wasn't an an anime style. Anime is more realistic (I know it's not really but the proportions aren't CRAZY off mostly.) The style of the first artist was closely related to a chibi-type style. Thanks for your understanding! :)

[@aedin_]

HOLY CRAP QUITE THIS ISNT WARFRAME WHAT ARE U DOING HERE

[@ajer_]

Dude I watched your 1680p well spent before this and I had never heard of you prior, and now I come to find out you like peter. Hell ye defo earned a sub

[@natshenkin]

HEY ITS YOU !!!

[@ssoulssniper9287]

Why are you here shy

[@guyshapon]

911 I just witnessed a murder omg

[@Kingbradersth]

00:50 peter kills a artists hopes and dreams

[@josiahirons1921]

blue moded he was referring to his software acting up

[@brad6220]

Josiah Irons No, he was referring to the idea of doing a video criticizing people’s art

[@fraudulent_taxation5383]

An

[@webba0342]

[To avoid making Bradley look like he is correcting a ghost, i decided to edit my reply rather than deleting it. The following statements are all false and unedited. It's pure assumption from my side.] He was referring to it being so far out of his range of art style (he was probably thinking the artist sent it to the wrong person by mistake) ,, he meant that it was just not that exciting to look at for him, as he prefers another type of art. But i get how people misread that, as he wasn't that clear about it...

[@brad6220]

webba03 No, Peter LITERALLY CLARIFIED in the comment section that he was talking about whether or not making this video was a mistake.

[@itzkaleb6775]

This is ssoooooo.... *waiting for him to say something nice about this drawing* sloppy! *oH*

[@evunee]

honestly, it was one of the best drawings there, left me shook

[@unoriginalpersonALT]

time stamp?

[@thecumzone2412]

@@unoriginalpersonALT 31:10

[@Ambidextroid]

I love how you flip flop between insults and praise. "Yeah, it looks great... Dude, if I had a picture of that on my wall - I'd probably take it down. But no, it's good... It's sharp."

[@vvolfsblood]

Is it weird that I really like sloppy art? I dont know what it is but it's just so appealing to me

[@lordofthepage845]

There called sketches and I like them too

[@LukieLuke5]

I only make sloppy art.

[@bonkers2394]

me too!!!!! Fine and precise art can look nice but the sketchy lines on art can really give you an insight to the thought process od the artist!!! I reccomend look at Portal 2: Labrat! (Its a quick comic!)

[@adamwest8711]

Probably all that weed dude.

[@MrThankman360]

“Coochie Milk” 😂😂😂

[@quinnbrohelfilms]

Holy shit I was gonna submit something if he did another vid like this but after that first one idk 💀

[@shawnsmith8558]

you should, its good to get other opinions, take them with the grain of salt, but it is one way to improve

[@Kam-ji8nv]

He’s honest. It’s just not his type

[@avimartin3711]

Shawn Smith it seemed really discouraging to me

[@Irispatcher]

Shawn Smith still at the beginning of the video but he didnt seem to give any opinions. Not sure what opinions you’re talking about

[@redzombiew6439]

@@Irispatcher He still gave his opinion on almost all of them. A critique wasn't designed to ensure you feel good, it's to help you improve.

[@thomastakeshita4979]

Lol I love how you just skipped the first one. what the hell loln

[@len1135]

ayy i'm the artist at 1:04:03 !! i was indeed very inspired by jamie hewlett, hope it didnt look like i was copying him! i almost started crying when he said the coloring was cool ahhhh

[@Gigi_Ouija]

IS THIS A MISTAKE

[@josiahirons1921]

Jack Skellington he was referring to his software acting up

[@egg7491]

@@josiahirons1921 no he was not lol

[@support16s45]

Therapy Watermelons yes he was, he literally said it too

[@orls9068]

@@support16s45 So he said that makes it true? I think that was an excuse to be honest. He didn't give much after he said that which leads me to believe what he said was about the art.

[@cazimircouble]

"Nobody actually tell me how that works; I just want to keep wondering" Peter Draws, 2018

[@joehaschill2059]

Viewer Judges how Peter pronounces 'drawing': Is this a mistake?

[@DadaPoopoo]

Ya can't spell drawing without the WING!

[@hdezoo]

Obviously Peter hates the first artist. Obviously. He for sure wasn't joking or being facetious.

[@GyreArts]

XD

[@alejandra57]

Haven DeZeeuw mate he said on twitter he was joking

[@therecipegod1766]

mortee that’s low key the point of the comment, maybe read it again

[@alejandra57]

TheRecipeGod 17 ah i see, my apologies

[@j0394]

Haven DeZeeuw fantastic picture! I screen shot your art work for inspiration, i am really taken back by your piece of work! Really, wonderful picture. I don't think it looks rushed. It's a wonderful composition.

[@natshenkin]

31:00 ........Jesus i get what he's saying but i havent roasted chickens as much as Peter did peoples drawings in this video.

[@cascal7503]

He's a tad arrogant and insensitive for my liking when doing these sort of videos

[@Shmyrk]

cas cal my sentiments exactly. I didn’t expect it.

[@theinternetofficer6594]

He is correct tho, it looks rushed towards the end and with the sloppy coloring.

[@-zephyressence-2018]

Guys he's upset because they spend so much time on the amazing drawing and then rushed through adding values creating sloppy values with a refined structure. It doesn't make sense to do that. They obviously have the skill to (showcased by the wonderful drawing) it's just a shame to see wasted potential on that particular piece...it wasn't a roast. Just pointing out obvious laziness. He was like "bruh you're so good at drawing why'd you rush the last bit after you worked so hard to make everything else look nice?"

[@bigo2553]

It wasn’t that bad. It’s just the drawing ✍️ was too much for the artist to stay consistent. I actually love the lines of it

[@thomastakeshita4979]

46:30 The elian script says: area derli vesat housa ndl ifes irem ained toomuc hinsid edy head "a reader lives a thousand lifes i remained too much inside my head"

[@subtlenugs]

That's really cool how they segmented the letters into odd words for the reader to decode. I was so confused at first.

[@AlizaJayne]

Winner: 1:09:45 highest praise from Peter “I feel like I don’t deserve to look at this.” Goddamn!!!!

[@floweur5810]

"Is this a mistake?" *Vsauce music plays*

[@Teee...]

Hi peter , mine is 34:48 I’m really happy that you thought it was cool and that it made you feel frustrated because it’s kinda the purpose of it , I wanted to show my emotions and the overwhelming that I felt so I’m happy that I was able to show that . And thank you for your review I’m really happy 😆

[@zijing9548]

Oh dude , I'm happy I found your comment,I really enjoy looking at your drawing,it has a nice choice of colors and it's soothing, keep it up 🙂

[@GoldenLeafsMovies]

I've been reading a few comments and I think some people get the wrong idea. 1-Peter said he could be harsh in the tweet. 2-He didn't really say anything about the first image, I think the words "Is this a mistake" was referring to himself reviewing art and not directed at the artwork. 3-Sure he could be more open and said something about the artwork but it's his video, if he doesn't want to say anything about it, he has the rights to not do it. Overall I think people got the feeling he hated the artwork that was shown first, but I don't think he actually hated it.

[@noidea7523]

artists need to grow thicker skins, thats it, thank you for being one of the rare people with common sense

[@suree861]

yee yee those are a bunch of softies that can’t accept criticism or humor. Btw i like your user name i have that name on another account.

[@bludaizee24]

Peter, just so you know, when you're on the ocean temperatures, currents, land features, and other things all affect the surface of the water and waves and sometimes the surfaces really do look they way the waves do in the drawing of the boats on the ocean. So the person may not have given up, they may have been depicting reality. You will see an area of choppy waves and an area of a calmer surface, especially in harbors and bays where freshwater rivers meet saltwater sea. Just thought you'd like to know.

[@peter_draws]

good point, good point

[@joepvanderven4882]

However, for the uniformity of the drawing sometimes its better to alter reality a little so it's easier on the eyes. Loved that drawing tho

[@bludaizee24]

Joep van der Ven Yes I agree, sometimes it's part of the artist's job to tweak reality, and part of the "art" is to know when and where to take artistic license! I loved the drawing too. I just hope the artist doesn't come back and make me look like a fool by saying "yeah, I just got tired and wanted to get it finished ". Lmao

[@hdezoo]

@@bludaizee24 I prolly just got tired and wanted to get it finished

[@bludaizee24]

Haven DeZeeuw Lol, it's funny then because I've actually seen water look like that in person from a boat. I just finished watching Peter's new video and saw your new submission and wow, your work is beautiful! I'm not surprised you'd get tired sometimes, you must have great patience. Also what pen do you use?

[@stanislavsekacov3202]

18:31 is totally bobby hill

[@peter_draws]

THAT COULD BE IT

[@andrewwaller8499]

Checked the comments to see if anyone else saw bobby as well. I was not disappointed.

[@lovejoshii2044]

Stanislav sekacov YES

[@tawatikata9530]

@@peter_draws I was thinking that kid from the rockstar game "bully"

[@WuchtaArt]

"Hey, nobody actually tell me how that works, i just want to keep wondering." I find that line to be very inspirational.

[@RobertMilesAI]

7:20 You're not going to run out things to wonder about! Nobody ever runs out of things to wonder about. What usually happens is, once you know the answer to one thing, that knowledge makes you realise two new things that you never thought to wonder about before. People sure do stop wondering about things though! I'm not sure why, but I'm pretty sure it's not because they ran out of mysteries.

[@ltsBoxes]

you only run out of things to wonder about when you run out of questions to ask.

[@gustavada6964]

So that's how branches grow :)

[@ethandaniel333]

A hour and thirty minute video This is it Chief

[@j.knuchel1129]

you should watch his lives if u want to be entertained for hours

[@ethandaniel333]

Jenni nya Tru I usually do if I catch them

[@debstawecki6843]

Don't apologize so much, please. We all should be thanking you, Peter

[@andybono94]

"I do like giraffes though. It's kind of a family obsession but I can't really describe why. I inherited the obsession but I try not to talk about it too much."

[@mintygraceuwu7774]

Peter, I wish you wouldn't assume that these people are sloppy when they don't fill in a dark space, because I love to do that! I love the texture, and I have seen it a lot in art. I think it's a lot more interesting than flat black... I get that some people do get lazy with filling stuff in, but some of these artists obviously used a small fine liner to get texture and not just fill it in completely with one color.

[@kd1330]

Yeah, and that person could've used alchohol markers to make the streaks go away, but I understand that it might be difficult for some to get them. The streaks didnt make the drawing any less cool to me. In fact, I was really impressed. The artist may not have had much art supplies other than a pen and some markers, so to make such a cool drawing really inspires me

[@peter_draws]

That's true, but I think this is why ultimately you have to be your own biggest critic. You're the only one that knows what you're doing, and what your goals and intentions with your art are. Getting outside criticism can be a mixed bag (anywhere from very helpful to totally useless) depending on how closely they understand what you're trying to do, and you just have to learn to take it with a grain of salt and temper their perspective with your own artistic vision.

[@darrinsmith6326]

I did the elephant 1:02:55 with the lines....I printed it out and didn't even notice the lines 😶 I drew it in photoshop. Thanks for including me Peter.

[@firstnamelastname4366]

the elephant was probably my favorite of the bunch, nice job

[@darrinsmith6326]

Thanks

[@lexiwagner4541]

Printers suck sometimes this happens with my essays sometimes

[@sladefidler]

"Is this a real dinosaur photograph?..." 🤣🤣😂😂😂1:24:30

[@josh__jimison]

1:24:31 "Is this a real dinosaur?" I literally couldn't stop laughing

[@matmat4105]

I really love peter s videos and i don t have anything bad to say about him because he s just that great of an artist. But the way he skipped the first one 'cause it wasnt his style... for the first time i felt like his reaction was a bit off and didnt like how he treated the situation.

[@dffgffffffdddddddddd]

he didn't skip it tho

[@avimartin3711]

Proximity still uncool

[@Nadohunter]

ok but why would you submit anime-ish art to a channel that is more centered on fineart... to someone who literally said "I might not be nice" and not expect something like how he awkwardly glossed over it? Like, its all fine and good, it wasn't like he was viciously insulting it, but the artist had to know what their getting into.

[@alejandra57]

Blumat 5 he later said on twitter he was joking about the reaction, he liked it and the artist of the piece was alright with it

[@josiahirons1921]

he was referring to his software acting up

[@GLA-ld5ij]

Oh come on Peter, you might've made that first person cry.

[@dragoon3084]

I like the brashness, really wouldn't be Peter without it.

[@avimartin3711]

Dragoon I think it was unnecessarily mean. There’s much better ways to say you don’t like something

[@shawnsmith8558]

thats aer for you :/

[@antoniohorgan5352]

ahahaah peter is a freaking beast

[@luluvanhoagland5348]

The off things about it are so extreme that it can come off as a joke submission. I assume the artist is quite young tho.

[@sliceofmaggpie]

OH MY GOSH THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR THE CRITIQUE I WASN’T EXPECTING TO ACTUALLY GET FEATURED THANK YOU

[@nhc8030]

maggpie WHICH ONE WERE YOU?

[@sliceofmaggpie]

NateThePrettyGreat the one starting at 2:31

[@ixchelish]

Oh my gosh! I loved your piece, you're so versatile! And your piece was really close to the beginning, lucky duck! Mine's over an hour in :D

[@sliceofmaggpie]

Swammies AHHH Thank you! What time did he get to yours?

[@ixchelish]

​@@sliceofmaggpie Mine starts at 1:12:44 , I'm amazed he went through so many artworks before running out of steam!

[@dingdonglouie]

I get it that this is Peters channel and we are all inspired by his art, but holy moley there are so many that are so similar to Peter, you can't tell who did it. I guess that's a compliment, but work toward finding your own style, while still being inspired by others. imitation is the sincerest form of flattery I suppose?

[@jillzord]

No wonder... He is a meanie when someone does a different style like the first one

[@theguy3348]

@@jillzord yet all the other styles he sees hes okay with them maybe he just didnt like the first one

[@barnacle-]

@@theguy3348 Understandably.

[@rhanx8689]

Jill he said somewhere in the comments that "is this a mistake" had nothing to do with the art. But yeah he could have said something to the first picture too.

[@christianpaz7751]

IDENTITY THEFT IS NOT A JOKE JIM !

[@Felahliir]

"I know, I'm a dude, and we're only allowed to like chainsaws and calliber 50 bullets." - Peter Draws 2018

[@perhaps5095]

Absolutely decimated that first person

[@bigsaroo5775]

~*is this a mistake*~ I'm deceased 💀

[@jasmine2501]

I am a biologist who understands the development of trees, and it is still MAGIC. Understanding the mechanism uncovers additional layers of beauty and doesn't distract from what you're saying.

[@orls9068]

Can you tell me more about trees I love to draw and photograph them, love them!

[@jasmine2501]

@@orls9068 I could talk about trees for hours. They are amazing.

[@MrSomeDonkus]

YES!!! Peter witnessed me! Anyway im glad that you caught on to the comedy that I try and go for in my drawings, your comments made me have a good ol laugh.

[@scoobit]

An hour and a half of art and Peter’s dry humor? Yes please

[@Thepurpleful]

44:43 EXCELLENT WOOD BURNING!!!

[@666TheGamingGods666]

thanks nina! You can follow my twitter for now to stay updated, i'm going to make an Instagram page for my work too, soon.

[@danitheuerkauf7095]

I really enjoy you showing others artwork Peter. I'm old enough to be your mom and came across your channel quite by accident. I really enjoy all the things you try on your channel. And yes I listen to you to fall asleep to while you tell stories. Bad insomniac. :) please keep being inventive and creative. I check regularly on Peter reads. I would love if you added more to that channel.

[@leoward6609]

43:30 Poetry was incredibly heart felt, however its composition was 3/10 I would say. the last few lines were interesting though. the idea that your love keeps a part of you, that resonated with me. good concept.

[@The_Snooooopy]

Leo Ward thank you(:

[@Thepurpleful]

I think @irritatedempath deserves some sort of explanation. I'd rather have a detailed list of harsh judgements than to just skip with no explanation. SAY IT!!! JUST SAY WHAT YOU WANT TO SAY!!!!!!!! (That's my criticism of your criticism)

[@joepvanderven4882]

I guess for manga eyes they are pretty good. I think there are quite a lot of "rules" for manga eyes but I have no clue. I guess the posture is kinda weird. Obviously she's sitting but nothing to sit on. But its obviously not his style so maybe he just thought: I cant critique this

[@JRexRegis]

yeah, his reaction to their image was pretty assholish imho. the way he reacted was way more insulting than anything he could have said, if not more, because the artist didn't even get a *why*.

[@josiahirons1921]

JR he wasn’t referring to the image, he was referring to his software acting up

[@Thepurpleful]

Everyone is just guessing at what he actually meant because he didn't say what he really wanted to say.

[@JRexRegis]

@@Chubbicat art is art, and it was higher quality, from a technical standpoint, than some of the other ones.

[@dekumight7599]

no one gonna talk about how he has minecraft

[@MetropolMacro]

The nest question is, is he pewds fan?

[@splashkissv4803]

Who came here from creepshow art to see if her drawing is here?

[@Laffy_Taphy50818]

Is this who she was talking about??

[@OldLady-um9kt]

Okay, You made this old woman look it up because inquiring minds want to know and I had no idea. So, on WikiDiff = "As adjectives the difference between noxious and poisonous is that noxious is harmful; injurious while poisonous is containing sufficient poison to be dangerous. " I just want to say that I enjoy 99% of your videos very much. They bring a ray of sunshine to my day. I wonder if I may be your oldest fan. Oh well, a fan for the rest of my years anyways. Yes, I still draw and some watercolor when the weather is warm. (Too bad I'm so old and you're so young. hee hee) Keep moving forward, Peter. Don't look back, as it will rob you of the life waiting ahead of you. Hugs!

[@10kCrows]

"This better not be pickle Rick. I think it is, I'm out of here."

[@ShareloveT]

The instantly getting of your delivery tripped me out! Lol

[@Zullala]

I feel bad for the first person. My empathy is going off the charts!

[@Gkowi]

52:58 I absolutely love this. Such an amazing piece

[@Walter-jl3zt]

Team Ico vibes.

[@Tovutaki]

it makes me happy that someone on earth posts hour long art reviews on youtube

[@Timid_Artistry]

10:20 -- What?! Drool? How did that get there?? I swear, my drawings tend to have a mind of their own, hahaha. Also, the picture was very difficult to take due to lighting, so you be grateful for that seemingly blue surgical gloved blur! It was a sacrifice I had to make! xD Seriously though, thanks for the critique. I appreciate it! :)

[@cozmz]

It's beautiful

[@Timid_Artistry]

@@cozmz Hey, thanks! :)

[@hassanfayad4585]

I am really happy that you liked and appreciated ASTRO-GARDEN !! ( and yeah you’re right about the planet ).Thank you, not just for featuring my art in one of your videos, but also for inspiring me for the last couple of years.

[@peter_draws]

Really amazing piece!

[@eels2187]

i don't usually comment before finishing a video but this is over an hour long and i'm just so sad for the artist of the first one... seems uncharacteristically uncool of peter but maybe he's just not into that aesthetic and that's fine but like come on it's not a mistake it's a style choice. i think it's cute. @ the artist: keep slaying . you do you

[@avimartin3711]

eels yeah definitely not cool on peters part. If you don’t like something you can just say you don’t like it, you don’t have to call it a mistake and be super mean about it

[@shawnsmith8558]

yeah pretty much, but Pete isn't really "critiquing" the work as commenting on it - that doesn't give him a free pass, but people have opinions and sometimes certain types of art or unnapealing to people or even downright ugly even if its technically well done

[@AtomekKotalke]

Anime is a mistake.

[@pvpperdogs]

same here honestly, it's got me sad. I thought it was cute honestly, and I get that it might not be peter's style but it wasn't necessary to leave it in.

[@SG-xn2rb]

He said in the tweet he would he a meanie

[@azazaelll]

Peter: sees anime Also Peter: “is this a mistake?” 😂😂😂

[@MrPatchPlays]

"Is this a real dinosaur?" The mood for 2018

[@sassyashley123]

The edit of him leaving to get his food and coming back was great. I did a double take and rewatched it a few times lol

[@jillsmcfarland2001]

Water does that currents and boat traffic,I thought it was cool.not predictable.

[@shen6250]

Too many people overreacting on the first art piece. It was a joke that people seem to not have understood.

[@zacktepe2727]

I see all these people in the comments about the first one. While I do think he was harsh and I would hate to have him say that about my art. First of all he didn't say he might not be nice so submitting a piece into this you must be prepared for that response. Second. As an artist you must be ready for the world to hate your art. You have to hear someone say your art sucks and you have to move on if you want to be successful in the art world.

[@gunnybee5655]

“I like very evocative paintings in my bathroom” -Peter (28:02)

[@KyRo_Dread]

the names Draws, Peter Draws.

[@finalbreath15]

Peter, your critiques aren't mean, they are always constructive and it's easy to note when something just isn't your style or something that interests you, but that doesn't mean it goes without saying that your here to help inspire others and allow your own outlet for expression. I am happy to say that everyone posting content on your pages to be critiqued are all going to succeed in the art world if they just put their love and ambition into learning the right techniques to make their particular style really stand out and look finished and presentable. I've been drawing since very young ages and while I may have been on hiatus from drawing multiple times for quite long periods, just watching your channel has inspired me to try and focus on my art nearly full time, and while I don't think you'd be interested in all my art, I'd love to send some in for a critique sometime just to get another artists perspective. You're a legend Peter and keep always doing you. And everyone else, I hope you guys don't let yourselves get discouraged from making the art you love in the absolute best way you can. My biggest tip to any artist is understanding perspective, because whether on a 2d plane or a 3d space, understanding visual perspective is key because it allows you to basically create formulas to determine proper color/shading values and even the size and distance of shapes. Once you understand perspective, you can toy with it and make warped perspectives in a satisfying way, or interesting color contrast, etc. It's not necessarily fun learning these things, but it becomes fun the more you *understand* them, ultimately. Have fun. Always be aware of your strengths, and explore your weaknesses. Pay more attention to improving the weaknesses and it will all come together.❤ Also drawing at 47:20 of Peter was masterfully done. Good job to Ali Goodarzi!

[@joshvan2923]

Thank you for the advice, I totally agree. I'm improving my consistency every drawing! :D (Oh and the weird lines behind the tree were supposed to be light lol)

[@SarahOpossum]

The whole time he was talking I kept thinking "its lines of sunlight and lines of background trees!" But I guess it's a good example of how differently he sees the world lol

[@joshvan2923]

Sarah Torrellas thanks for the smile 😊 you seem like a real Peter draws fan

[@joshvan2923]

Sarah Torrellas do you have a favorite video?

[@joshvan2923]

Sarah Torrellas the day I drew that tree the light I wanted for the drawing was going away, but it was really beautiful. The sun was glistening off of a lake and through the trees right across the trunk

[@NYCRocker]

Zirpu, I was yelling at my monitor "Those are sun rays OBVIOUSLY!!!" XD

[@jessejamesaims8430]

This might have been my favorite thing ever. Please do more of these Peter, your thoughts are blockbuster perfection.

[@TheWumbler]

He did say he might be mean

[@michaeljackson5784]

Wumble He also said he would critique, which he ended up *not* doing.

[@shaunallen7436]

at 16.30 mins great Drawing...the waves are on point, wind moving across a channel, it cancels out the upper water column and surface movement...stalls the wave. Love your work Peter.

[@HK-eu8mr]

I feel so bad for the person who drew the first one. I would cry.

[@feralpoodles]

@@Svetty00 use his reaction as motivation? he said "is this a mistake". what does that tell me about the piece? that it shouldn't exist? i totally understand something not being your style or not meeting expectations but damn lmao

[@alejandra57]

hannah kinsey he later said on twitter he was joking about the reaction, he liked it and the artist of the piece was alright with it

[@HK-eu8mr]

@@alejandra57 thank you I can fall asleep peacefully now lol

[@MrStealYoGrill4Life]

Especially if you look up to him

[@disguisedboots]

@@Svetty00 so you would read into it what you would like him to have meant?

[@ghigno6]

The first one made me cry-laugh, thank you artist whoever you are

[@ReegusReever]

Love this channel/series. Peter pulls in some decent art from his fans and gives honest opinions on each. Some channels receive okay illustrations, and offer wishy washy comments, afraid to critique. Not dismissing those videos; I just prefer Peter's videos.

[@SirPieRoyal]

It‘s honestly amazing how time flies watching your videos and listening to you. I just realized I watched this for an hour straight

[@loganheilman5481]

I seriously can’t tell if peter is being serious about the first one or if he knew them or something and it was just a joke, lol classic Peter

[@alejandra57]

Logan Heilman was a joke

[@ames5405]

It was about the video being a mistake, not the art piece haha

[@WeRiseAboveTheFallen]

I guess I always thought of Peter as an unrealistic person with unlimited kindness.

[@brandicook8497]

17:20 I see what you're saying about the waves, but it is possible it was intentional as sometimes (especially at harbor waters) the waves DO drop off (because there is a drop at the floor of the water, making the water way deeper and darker).

[@hdezoo]

I think on the image I drew this from, the water was calm, so I added the waves in. But the lines from the waves were all going to the same spot on the paper, so I wanted to break that up.

[@willsimpsart]

@@hdezoo your art is so amazing and inspiring. Love it

[@susanollington5257]

That one with Adam and Eve was so cool, how the angel (in a true biblical style, with all the eyes) had the flaming sword and was half coloured, and was protecting the garden of eden, which was completely coloured, from Adam and Eve who were kicked out of the garden and now have no colour It’s so thematic and I love it

[@heikohancock9186]

I could do my home work on time or I could watch this demigod judge the offerings of his young disciples

[@Mlsgrfx]

Honestly one of the longest videos I've ever cared to watch on youtube. Good job.

[@MyChristi123]

In regards to the boat scene at 17:26, in real life I have seen two different types of water right beside each other in a lake. Like one section is rippling and choppy, and intersecting it is a flat section of water. I don’t know if that description makes sense but I feel like the artist could have done that from a reference picture maybe

[@androth1502]

so, i'm watching this in full screen, and my eye falls to the bottom corner to read 10:49pm and i'm instantly "omfg, i'm an hour late!" then i realize it's peter time. lol.

[@brad6220]

Peter did nothing wrong.

[@PrimaDel]

ikr

[@wamsjams]

For the first one it looks like he REALLY wants to criticize it. And I’m over here like “ITS SO FREAKN CUTE OML”

[@thomasthompson8629]

Make a video on how you make your coffee

[@thebox4673]

Thomas Thompson yes!

[@need_more_kittens]

There's already a few

[@MicahBuzanANIMATION]

I hope you do more of these. This is illuminating and you're such a friendly teacher.

[@invernoglass8001]

Is Peter ok? He seems so down and negative lately? He just doesn't seem alright? I hope that he starts feeling better soon : < I feel really bad for all of the artists he was so unkind towards, it's so unlike him. He used to always says that what matters is that you enjoy making the art and not to worry about what others think. I have long looked up to him as an artist, but more importantly as a kind person and this is just so upsetting to see.

[@brad6220]

Inverno Glass If he tells artists to not worry what others think, than shouldn’t the artists that Peter criticizes not worry about what he thinks?

[@wakaziar9373]

Bradley Gonyea but then by that logic why would any of his viewers watch the video and why would he upload it?

[@ellieamanders7970]

+Bradley Gonyea Clearly, the artists, who posted their art, wanted to see an insightful criticism from someone in a professional field (what could be improved, color palette and etc). And not for the sake of self-expression and hobby, which what his statement-of-art-expression is for.

[@kaneda7368]

I don't understand the obsession with using question marks at the end of statements? Like what's the point? Why cant you just say what you want to say? Just put a period at the end of the sentence or something?

[@lordlamington5917]

i've honestly never been interested in art most my life, but since following your channel for the past 1-2 years i've learnt to really appreciate it. Thank you

[@antoniohorgan5352]

oh I missed this, will it be happening again pete?

[@mayorofsimpleton5674]

Holy fuck, Peter. This is merciless feedback. I definitely think that first one deserves a lot more credit. Style isn’t really something you can judge, in my opinion. Only execution. I loved that first one. Adorable.

[@awayforthewin1325]

First thing he says about a fans art "Is this a mistake?"

[@HappoApina]

"If I had a poster of this on my wall... *sigh*.. I mean I'd probably take it down" oh Peter, you funny dude :D