Photography On YouTube Is Becoming Boring

[@jumpingjohn280459]

I have to honest and say that I’m watching fewer and fewer channels now, and restricting myself to just a few where the content is refreshing and inspiring. This is one and The Art of Photography is another. We as viewers are shaping what is served to us. We might complain about ‘all the content being the same’ but if that’s what we are watching, the algorithm will continue to serve it up. In a way it’s up to us to influence what is promoted. It also calls for confidence on the part of the content creators to put out material that is innovative and interesting. We need to support these people.

[@KarloFio]

... And, check Simon d'Entremont who is equally good although doing a different genre!

[@tornenzen]

Totally agree with all channels mentioned. Scott French is another for me. It seems that the dilemma described mimics what I experience in photography. Maybe it's best to just focus on our passions - our followers may be fewer, but the experiences will be richer. So go deep rather than wide, perhaps.

[@Lt4991]

Let me add Mike Browne. He is an amazing photography teacher and has a good and engaging online community. Very friendly and supportive group that he built.

[@meijboomm]

Sean tucker as well! Love his work

[@jpdj2715]

There are a few names in this comment and responses, of other channels that I know well. Alex's approach of art school lecture type and motivational videos totally stay away from "tools". To me, Alex does great from the start of his channel. Forbes discusses tools in between 80% and 90% of his content and to me that's a waste of time. While he has turned pages of some photography as art books, his own photography boils down to elevated snapshots. Simon - very knowledgeable in the technical side, but could be more structured in the sense of breaking lessons down for different levels of prior knowledge. I did photography school in the late 70s - the curriculum is an applied/vocational BSc today - and from the general technical photography point of view there's nothing new. As most fluencers do not have that background, I see most of them making errors at the deeper levels. After 10 years well-paid professional photography, I went back to university and studied a.o. a full Bachelor/Master curriculum of software engineering with AI, which I also taught at those levels. So digital photography has no secrets, although I must admit it took me some time to figure out how stupid it really is. We all are bothered most by the Bayer paradigm. And most "luminance noise" or "colour noise" that fluencers talk about merely is inadequate or failed raw processing - they should call the noise "Bayer noise". DxOMark state they test "sensors" - not they don't. The videos in YT generally are at the wrong level of abstraction and make very fundamental mistakes. Imagine a Ytoober in their video showing two images in Lightroom Classic and saying of the left one, that it is "raw" while the right one had some AI Denoise applied. They don't know their shit and actually have never seen a raw image "as is". Happens too many times in most "tool" focused videos. Simon is on the best side, not perfect. Sean presents his videos as a sermon in a church. And next to the preaching tone, there also is a sadness in his tone. I am allergic to sermons and do not need the sadness. Sorry. (Sean has been a minister in a church community, by the way, I discovered later.) If you are familiar with art history - painters, sculptors, architects - then which of these fluencer people in YT today will have their photographs hanging in a museum of art? If that is not your ambition as a student of their lessons, then you can learn more, faster, by spending time out there shooting. A fool with a tool is still a fool. And I hasten to add that a pro with inappropriate tools also is a fool. Idiots waste my time with "1.8 is not professional" and then "I need 1.4" or "1.2". Baloney and a silly excuse to not shoot images.

[@charlottedavies9379]

Please keep producing content that is meaningful to you, Alex. That's what resonates with us. I think channels like yours, Ted's, Sean's etc are the ones people come to when we've ploughed through all of those other channels. Your channels are the gems we find and stick with. Thank you :-)

[@ThePhotographicEye]

Thanks for watching

[@amv7m]

The “This is why I switched to (insert camera brand)”. Not that you asked for a virtual hug, but I’ve gotten far more valuable information from your channel, and channels like ‘Art of Photography’ than any of those other kinds of channels. Thank you, and happy 2024. I look forward to more good content from you/your channel.

[@kingofetiquette1652]

This is an old video, but one I really enjoyed. One thing I've learned from streaming, is it doesn't matter what subject you cover, it's your personality and understanding that makes people watch your stream/videos and honest; I'd be happy watching a video of you talking about your favourite postcard.

[@delthomas-n4m]

TPE is my first choice of photography channels because you’re not afraid to share your frustration with your viewers. Your honesty is one of the best things about your videos. But I’ve also discovered so many photographers that I wasn’t aware of thanks to your videos. Keep up the good work in 2024!

[@ThePhotographicEye]

I appreciate that!

[@ricmondelli5846]

Hey Alex, Your dedication to educating others about the art of photography is truly admirable. The way you break down complex concepts into easy-to-understand discussions empowers countless aspiring photographers. Your channel isn't just a platform; it's a nurturing space where creativity and learning blossom hand in hand. Keep enlightening, guiding, and sparking that passion for photography in everyone you teach. Here's to illuminating minds and framing futures through the lens of knowledge!

[@markorchard2272]

I'm 58 with 45 years of photography experience.Totally with you. During a workshop in 2017 we were lunching in the Tate Modern Cafe. A 19 year old girl was about to embark on Photography BA in Falmouth. When I asked "who are your biggest influences?" I was met with a shrug and a 'I dunno. Mainly people off Instagram'. THERE'S THE FUTURE RIGHT THERE!!🤦🏼‍♂

[@KevinRoy-b9k]

The other day I walked into an ornate establishment and took a few pictures with my camera. A woman, quite shyly, walked up to me and said, "Please, only cell phone pictures, thank you." I stared at her with a look of bewilderment and disbelief. I wanted to ask her what the difference was, but decided to be nice and just leave.

[@jeremyfielding2333]

I've been hearing this one quite a lot recently. Worrying. @@KevinRoy-b9k

[@JamesTaylor-yz1ov]

Bang on the money Alex. I've unsubscribed from so many channels recently because of what you've talked about in this vlog. For me your content is constantly interesting and engaging, it's great to have conversations about different aspects of photography rather than the constant 'on location' and gear reviews. Keep up the good work!

[@ThePhotographicEye]

Thank you

[@grahamniven]

The channels I keep watching are the ones with presenters I find interesting as people. Without KZbin I wouldn't be able to easily find ideas about photography from all across the globe. KZbin is a fabulous resource, but to get the best from it, don't sit back and let it serve up what it wants to show you, use an external search engine to look for the type of content you want to see.

[@spektrograf]

Alex, your channel is one of the rare ones out there that I've kept watching over the years. I've pretty much stopped watching gear reviews and how-to's long ago and crave depth in thought and discourse, which is what I rely on you to deliver. Thank you! Depth will always be a narrower audience in any hobby-even profession, because gear and technical are accessible from day 1 of having interest-and there's a lot of people who have interest and aspirations. For better or for worse, aspirations drive sales, which subsidizes the cost of gear for all because that market segment is sizeable for any interest. That being said, depth is gold, and you're definitely delivering it. Thanks again! 🙏

[@ThePhotographicEye]

Thank you for watching

[@ladymary22]

Photographic Eye is refreshing because it is about the joy of art and the act of creation. I have watched others and they don't quite equal this channel. You have such infectious enthusiasm.

[@ThePhotographicEye]

Thank you

[@gjcoop5625]

I dislike three things about many KZbin videos. 1. Music overlaying when people are talking, in particular, but most generic music. 2. Waving hands. Can these go the way of flared pants? 3. Rapid cuts that don't have continuity. And that is why I like this channel!

[@ThePhotographicEye]

Thank you

[@ninepinezine]

Hi Alex - you can't fix the algorithm - don't try. Views and the measures that KZbin uses are not something to chase. Repeating your message is important, and it's also important to remember that we live in an edited world. No matter how good anyone is in taking pictures, choosing what to show and what not to show is an essential skill. Great pictures are a distillation of the captured and the published. How to distil our myriad of captures is truly important and that process will never be boring. Don't worry about account views. Please keep making the videos. Thanks for the great work. Mike

[@jorik.d.braber]

True, truth....

[@ThePhotographicEye]

Thank you

[@jimtipton8888]

I subscribe to a lot of photography channels, but this is my go to for the art of, history of, and philosophy of photography. The Photographic Eye fills that gap. Happy New Year!

[@ThePhotographicEye]

Happy new year

[@waldemarwinkler1344]

What consistently resonates in your presentations is depth. You converse with us, your viewers, well below the surface to the core of the topic. Just deep enough into that topic to inspire our own explorations. There are not many presenters of your caliber in the tabloid world of KZbin. Please continue.

[@ThePhotographicEye]

Thank you for your words

[@danieldarks3721]

I have responded to you and being taught about photography in a way I have not been used to. This links to your comment about Authenticity. People are tired of plastic attitudes just trying to get money out of them but you give genuine care and thought about benefiting others by what you have been taught about photography. I for 1 enjoy it.

[@desmondpainter7313]

I am very happy that people like you and Tatiana Hopper and some others talk about creativity and art in the context of photography, rather than making endless 'why aren't your photos sharp' and 'what's in my bag' videos.

[@holdencoalfield9308]

I have discovered your channel 4 days ago, and the quality of content really stands out, so please keep sharing your honest views about the craft. 90 percent of other photo channels are rubbish

[@TonyHogrefe]

The topics you tackle are multifaceted and nuanced. You perform a "deep dive" examination that requires the viewer to "think" about what they're hearing rather than simply absorb it like the dopamine hit videos that are so prevalent on all social media platforms.

[@Grunf64]

Hi Alex, I rarely comment, but you really moved me - congratulations! A mature , but beginner photographer ... yadda yadda... i can comment at this point that first - all of us need to let photography go through us. Technology, art... all of it. During the process we start to express ourselves through photography. Then, everything depends a lot about what is moving us: Money? Fame? Competitiveness? Looking at all the photography related videos - all of them swing between technology and art. Naturally. Two aspects of the photography. You are the only one I found so far clearly addressing: Expressing our own personalities through photography. I find you and the CamerasLensesEtc the opposites on the spectrum and I thank you both!

[@ThePhotographicEye]

Thanks for watching

[@Consciousphotography]

I really enjoy your work and I appreciate that you're not doing what so many others do and instead choose to do what feels right to you. So you're a huge source of inspiration for me

[@lmartin8790]

And for me too

[@ThePhotographicEye]

I appreciate that!

[@peterhuskinson4111]

Thank you, Alex, and may you have many, many happy New Years to come. I’m much refreshed by your channel and by one or two others, but otherwise I’m watching less and less, as I think, like you, i believe, that they are just stunningly boring with their f stops and apertures and iso settings etc. So please keep up the good work. Yours in photography, an old photographer that’s re-finding his mojo thanks to you.

[@ThePhotographicEye]

Happy new year!

[@patford9943]

Alex, your format is great! You have introduced or reintroduced me to interesting photographers. Rather than f-stops and ISO you emphasize the thinking and seeing parts that make up the art of photography. I support your efforts!

[@ThePhotographicEye]

Thank you

[@stevemphoto]

I have to agree that there is a lot of regurgitated content on KZbin. But what has been great about your channel, and why I have chosen not just to watch your channel but interact with you, is that you filled a void in this space. There aren't enough channels like this one, or Tatiana Hoppers, Sean Tuckers, etc. But in the long run that can put you in a lead position. I do enjoy other channels for different reasons...I'm not a landscape photographer but I watch James Popsys because I think he's funny....I don't shoot much medium format film but I watch Kyle Mcdougall's because I love his process. This is all a long winded way of saying I think you're in a perfect spot to do what you do. The algorithm sucks...but when I want contemplative, engaging content I come here! 👍

[@RCZ588]

Sean Tucker is one of the most boring and pretentious by far

[@snoogly]

You really are a shining star. In several ways you have reawoken the observative/creative eye I had 40 years ago! I share the frustration you shared in this video, but I think you should stop worrying about it. As long as the Tube isn’t your primary source of income, I don’t think what is going on in the wider ‘photography’ scene should concern you. Kick back and take your shoes and socks off!

[@dstathisfying]

The reason I watch your content is because you push me out of my previously acquired comfort zone. I am a point in my life when I can and want to dedicate time to an artistic endeavor. Photography makes me feel good because, for me, it combines the tech side, which I find easier to develop, with the art of creating something. The later is the challenging part and that's what your content is helping me develop. It's painful and exciting at the same time. Keep it coming.

[@timccphoto]

Your channel is so refreshing to watch. I love that you dig into the why of photography. The gear channels get as exhausting as a time share salesman. They can be useful when I am actually shopping for some kit but once that decision is made they are useless to me. This content, I will happily watch again to see if there's something new I didn't catch the first time, or if I just wasn't in the mood to hear it the first go round.

[@Mike_Stokes]

When I finally started to pursue my lifelong interest in photography a couple years ago I came to KZbin to learn as much as I could. At first I enjoyed watching some of the technical mumbo jumbo but it was because I didn’t know anything about things like the exposure triangle. Once I started to have a good understanding of the technical side of photography that stuff became boring for me. I found your channel pretty early on in my search for knowledge and it has remained my favorite. While I also enjoy other channels, it’s yours that I always suggest to other people. I really enjoyed the first video’s I came across because it was so interesting to learn about other photographers. I’ve always felt that you could learn so much from those who came before you. This channel has always felt unique and personal to me. It has had its own soul and didn’t feel so generic like all the others out there. Your video’s feel more like a one on one conversation than just someone spouting flashy attention grabbing words. This channel is more philosophical and goes deeper into what photography is. Keep being you and doing what you do. It’s the uniqueness you have brought to the channel that has kept the same people continuing to follow you video after video. Another thing that I have loved about your channel that seems different compared to others is that when watching yours I don’t feel lesser than. I feel like I could sit down with you and have a conversation as an equal even though you clearly have the time and experience I don’t. I respect the kindness you show to everyone. Thank you for taking the time to make these video’s.

[@ThePhotographicEye]

Thank you for watching

[@nilofido411]

Thee reason why I am subscribed and watch your videos is that it constantly remind me of my personal motto that I coined and lived by for more than 20 years..... DON'T EXPECT TO SEE WHAT YOU LIKE, I CAN ONLY SHOW YOU WHAT MY EYES, HEART, MIND AND SOUL CAN SEE.

[@buchanoz]

As a relatively new photographer I’m desirous of finding my style and niche. It feels natural to do so. Your channel has given me permission to do that and greatly expanded what is possible. KZbin is driven by marketing. I’m driven by learning and expanding my comfort zone. That’s why I enjoy spending time with your insights. Thank you.

[@davidhayden39]

Alex. I always enjoy every video I have watched of yours. I don't catch nearly all of them, sometimes because I am unaware and often because I prefer to get away from the computer and do photography or whatever. However, when I lose inspiration for photography, often because I've been doing too much shooting for other people, I turn to your videos to regain inspiration. Thanks for all you do and for all the great photographers you have introduced to me. I first heard about you and Sean Tucker from Donald Giannatti and am forever thankful.

[@Cloudtop_city]

I love this channel. Not about gimmicks, just pure passion for sharing your view of the world through photography of any medium/ format

[@ThePhotographicEye]

Thank you

[@classic.cameras]

One thing I do like about you is that you do not do gear reviews. There are so many KZbinrs who started off with a photography channel that just turned into a review channel. I do not blame them whatsoever either as I would do the same thing as well but still gets annoying sometimes when you are watching a video and then it hits you "Oh this is an ad for a new lens". Wont name names but I am sure anyone reading this could name a name and it would be a yup, that one.

[@markwhyatt8923]

I love the alternative, more thoughtful perspective of your videos. It’s the philosophy rather than a how-to guide, and that is refreshing. I agree that the algorithms of KZbin is pushing video makers into a homogeneous approach where very one ends up doing the same thing. Seven great tips for better photos! The three things you must know! What professional photographers don’t want you to know! You need to watch this video to be a worthwhile human being! All of it false and none of it does credit to the video creators. They end up boxing themselves in rather than expanding our experience.

[@ThePhotographicEye]

Thank you

[@Carramrod324]

Hey Alex. I’ve been on and off about photography for about 5 years! I am not even sure how I got interested in it! It just kinda fell onto me. Alls I know is it captured my interest greatly and I’ve dipped my toes in for about 5 years! Your channel has been a huge relief because you talk about the actual art of photography! Not just how to make a good image that’ll appeal to the vast majority of people! And as a person who loves the visual arts but is a terrible creative but still Seeks a creative outlet. You have helped me with photography a tremendous amount! I always resort to your channel pretty much anything photography related! Keep up the great work

[@ThePhotographicEye]

Thank you

[@WilsonPhotography1]

I totally see what you’re talking about, but I must say, KZbins suggesting new channels is how I found yours and I’m glad it did. I really enjoy your take on photography and photographers. I like that you’ve introduced me to photographers and work that I’ve never heard of or seen before. I’ve been practicing photography for the 47 years, and as I don’t want to say there’s nothing for me to learn, I don’t necessarily need another how-to explaining depth of field or why to use a faster shutter. Keep up the good work my friend and know I’ve shared some of your videos to my photography group (actual real life group) on our Face Book page. Hopefully you’ll get a few more views.

[@iqueque]

I like Peter McKinnon’s work because it is beautifully crafted, entertaining, original and the films are short. It is entertainment rather than instructional. And I like Thomas Heaton’s cheerful approach to life. I watch yours and Sean Tuckers for thoughtful insights and introductions to great photography from great photographers. For the rest, I search for a specific topic that I want to learn or brush up on, usually post processing topics. After 55 years of taking photographs I feel there is not a lot I can learn from the majority of KZbin photography channels. Thus I ignore what KZbin serves up on my home page.

[@mikskinner6431]

This is so refreshingly honest. I say 'this' because I've just had to pause you on the telly, and find you again on my phone, so I can comment. Something I guess a lot of us do, which must surely have an impact on your interaction with viewers. I'm guilty of not commenting much because of this reason. I always 'like' though. I imagine you must pull out your hair on a regular basis, but I'll be here watching you when you've gone bald. So don't stop you doing you. You're doing great, and it's really appreciated. Right.. that's enough from me, I need to finish this video.

[@marthabenedek8864]

Your content is fantastic. It is a joy to see you show work from past masters and give us things to think about our craft. Many "how to" channels boast only their own work. Please keep the channel going!

[@Bethos1247-Arne]

right. "Do THIS", "Don't do this!", the next lens review of a lens no-one needs, the next vid about composition "rules", ...

[@coltharwood494]

You have articulated what I have bee thinking for the past few months. I have stopped watching some videos because they became boring. It is not just KZbin. Photographers posting Instagram shorts are mirroring each other. Especially the ones that start with the photographer holding their camera and then showing one or a series of photos. It seems that every few months a new trend is started and others mimic it.

[@mattcallahan3015]

Your channel is one of the very few channels I subscribe to that I always make sure to watch every new video. And it’s also one of the only ones I think about while I am out taking photographs.

[@ThePhotographicEye]

Awesome thank you

[@jeremydavis3249]

When I was first starting out I watched a lot of how-to photography channels and gear-based videos. Now that I am comfortable with photography I enjoy watching videos discussing the "why" in photography and analyzing photography from other successful photographers. Please keep creating your videos!

[@ThePhotographicEye]

Thank you

[@theoinstitute3036]

You are absolutely correct in your assessment that people watch and don’t comment. I am guilty of that as well. I watch your work, think “that was good!” And just move on. I hope this engagement and that of the many others gives you the feedback necessary to keep being true to yourself and your unique work. 🤙

[@ThePhotographicEye]

Thank you

[@aeniii]

Alex, please know there is a silent majority that has, and will continue to seek out your unique contributions to the study of photography.

[@ThePhotographicEye]

Thank you

[@amandawaschevski339]

Hi Alex, I've watched every single one of your videos. In fact, I only watch yours and a couple of other channels these days. You hit the nail on the head when you said that your viewers are the ones who watch your videos until the end, sit back and think "I really like that!". I think this is the first video of yours I've commented on. Thank you for what you share - it's refreshing, easy to listen to and well considered.

[@ThePhotographicEye]

Wow, thank you!

[@christopheredwardf1250]

Alex - I think I have watched the majority of your videos and can honestly say that I have not seen one of them that I have not enjoyed, or been inspired and/or challenged by. Quite a few of them I recommended on the FB page run by the university photography school I attended 2018-21, and received a number of positive comments back from fellow students and grads. I tend to find channels that I like and stick to them (maybe its an age thing lol), and that's why I am a subscriber to yours. Long may you continue to delight, inform and challenge me with your particular style and choice of content. Happy New Year and looking forward to what you serve up in 2024.

[@ThePhotographicEye]

Thank you, happy new year to you to.

[@AnthonyJones-d5n]

I've never made a comment until now, I enjoy your channel very much even though I don't photograph the kinds of subjects you generally talk about. You have exposed me to people and their work that I have found extremely interesting. Thank you, and I'm looking forward to what you have to say.

[@ThePhotographicEye]

Wow, thank you!

[@ralfhedin]

Your value is that you always treat your subject more seriously and well "grounded" than most creators. Of all important videos you have published, this might be the most important. It has great value far outside the photography niche of KZbin. Tnx a million!

[@tgsnider]

Thank you for another enlightening video, Alex. Like many others who have commented, I scroll through the channels at offer to find something satisfying to watch and learn from. There are only a handful of channels I watch regularly, and yours of course is one. Please keep on doing what you're doing as long as you feel like doing it. Also, now I'm looking forward to finding your initial videos to see you looking "professional." 🙂

[@ThePhotographicEye]

Thanks for that! ☺️

[@morganfrelsy2403]

The way you´ve introduced us to so many really good photographers and photographies , is way more interesting than all the gear-and how-to-talk from way too many youtubers (not photographers). Keep on with what you do as long at you enjoy it. PS, Next time, a «fatter» vocal sound, wouldn´t hurt. Best regards, Morgan F (Norwegian photographer and journalist)

[@juliasumerling5229]

Hey Legend, keep doing what you are doing. You videos on photography are always so original and carefully thought out. You stand out well from the others (and not just because you wore a waist coat). Your content is always so insightful and from the heart. Don't change anything. Just keep on doing what you do. Looks forward to watching what you do in 2024

[@suetownson7747]

I like listening to your personal thoughts on photography. It is much more than the images! And it helps me define my own path. Happy New Year!

[@andriescarstens9245]

Being a professional for all my life the past 53 years, and familiar with your "photo school", I must agree with most of the comments here. I do not watch or subscribe to any other channels really and agree that they are boring, as suggested. The only exception is most of the B&H videos on certain topics are very good. What I would like to see you discuss is some "in depth" discussions about contemporary photography and conceptual photography. Something that, to my knowledge, is not always well understood, but important for us to understand.

[@flyingo]

I’m amazed at how, with the rising cost of film, so many photographers are “wasting” expensive film on test shots, boring landscape photographs that have been taken thousands of times before and generally the same kind of photos as hundreds of other photographers. Personally, I’m hoping to concentrate on taking photos of people - portraits or candid street shots - because when there’s a person or several people in a photograph, there’s a story there. Locations don’t change much over time. People change constantly.

[@geofffield7805]

Thanks Alex for saying what needed to be said. I watch your videos because I like to hear your ideas and opinions, and you have introduced me to different aspects of photography other than gear reviews and post processing techniques (both of which have their place). I have started to notice a trend with content creators trying to encourage engagement with comments and asking questions of their audience to gain traction with the algorithms. I am always disappointed when I compare views with likes. It seems viewers just can't be bothered to click the like button which seems to me to show a lack of appreciation of the work and thought which goes into producing a video from a content creator to whom they have subscribed. Anyway, have a great 2024 and keep provoking my thoughts about using my camera.

[@ThePhotographicEye]

Thanks for watching

[@kencawley3121]

I’m new to the channel having been attracted by your upcoming Using Natural Light workshop. The videos I have watched so far have given me a greater appreciation for “the art of photography” and I plan to work my way through all of past ones.

[@brianm.9062]

a lot of folk have to be told what to do, they can't listen because they can't hear, they like images. Your not like that its an intellectual, amusing thought provoking debate which because of your delivery stands high and above others, you make the thinkers think, you give and open doors that we never knew were there. And all of this without saying which lens you used, a refreshing change which is why we come back.

[@Jubular]

I'm one of those who rarely comments, yours is one of the channels that I enjoy. Relaxed commentary but most importantly, passion. Keep it rolling as you like to. If you ever attempt to satisfy people, you lose your real self I think.🎉

[@ThePhotographicEye]

I appreciate that!

[@LadyTracyOfTheDisk]

Alex, I so appreciate that you just sit down and give it to us straight about things that matter to you. Your enthusiasm is contagious. You have introduced me to photographers I hadn't heard of and ideas I hadn't thought of, and given me motivation to keep trying to think about things in new ways. Thanks for all you do!

[@ThePhotographicEye]

Thank you

[@minimumformat534]

Your work is appreciated, Alex. I have learned about many photographers through your channel and I much prefer this type of content (I hate that word!) to the in-your-face videos about sharpness or megapixels or autofocus speed. Thank you for the effort

[@ThePhotographicEye]

Thank you for watching

[@geoffreygriggs484]

Well, you seem to have touched a nerve with this one, Alex, including my own. I fully agree with all your sentiments here. I basically learned photography from watching KZbin, so there was a time when videos with tips about camera settings and techniques for using Lightroom etc were useful, but then, like you, I found Ted and appreciated that he was doing something different, and his reverence for the photographers he introduced inspired me to further my photographic journey by studying the masters. At some point, I found Sean and Jamie and they inspired me to look at photography through a more philosophical lens. Somewhere along the way, a video of yours popped up, and I have been a devoted follower ever since, though I am as guilty as others of not leaving comments even though your videos always inspire me, and what you say always resonates. By now, though, there are very few photography channels left on KZbin that interest me, and yes, there seems to be an endless stream of new, young, and I'm sure well-intentioned, photographers putting out slick content in the style of Peter McKinnon (though nobody so far seems to have improved on what he does) whose goal seems to be to grow their channels and promote themselves, rather than engage people with straight talk. And, I guess if you get big enough, you reach a point where it is impossible to respond to all the comments, anyway, and inevitably you become inherently distanced from the very people you perhaps originally wanted to connect with. Which makes me think that a small, but devoted following might be better than a large one if the goal is interaction, and indeed with many channels, like Ted's, I have mostly lost intereest as they seem to have moved on from from their original intentions for the reasons you cite here. So, in a selfish way, I almost hope that your channel will not grow more because I want you to keep doing what you're doing, and not succumb to making videos that feed the algorithm. I suspect you are already too big to respond to all the comments you get, but I feel like you still might take the time to at least read them. For the most part, I've moved on from KZbin and mostly just listen to podcasts now for my photography fix, but I will continue to follow you, Tatiana Hopper, Tin House Studio, the Crit House (I hope that one doesn't get too big, either) maybe a couple others. Reading through the comments here, it is clear that there IS a community of photographers who appreciate what you're doing, so I hope reading through these comments is confirmation for you, regardless of what the algorithms might think, that you are doing the right thing. 471 meaningful comments (as of this counting) from thoughtful photographers seems far more valuable than the 1000,000 likes and 50,000 generic "Great video" comments that the latest flashy channels might be getting.

[@ThePhotographicEye]

Thank you so much for taking the time to comment. I appreciate it, enjoy the podcasts!

[@chrisdavenportvideos]

You're right. I often watch good videos and don't comment because I don't feel that just saying "Good video, thanks for sharing" is contributing anything useful. But actually, quite apart from encouraging the content creator, it would be helping the algorithm surface the content that I most enjoy, like your channel. New Year resolution: leave more positive comments, even when I have nothing substantial to say.

[@ThePhotographicEye]

I appreciate that

[@ActualCounterfactual]

I have been with you since the beginnings, I signed up because you are different and stand out from the crowd, no boring technical specs or GAS discussion, you are diving into the art, not the gear... keep going, you are on the right track, enjoy every video. And yes, it feels like we sit and have a chat in the pub/coffee place having a decent face to face discussion 😊

[@PerrySheneman]

I agree. I've been looking for something different lately. It's hard though. I feel every video is the same. I enjoy watching your videos. They are different from what I see everyday, and you do a great job. You are enjoyable to listen to, and watch. Thank you for what you do. Never quit or give up. 😁

[@ThePhotographicEye]

Thanks for watching!

[@alancradick7189]

I have been watching you for awhile now and I have to admit I like your channel and you method of showcasing photography. I have been photographing for many years and love my time with a camera in my hand. Your see your videos as a conversation and often follow up on thee subject you present. Keep,it up. Do what you feel like doing. It keeps fresh ideas coming and that is a good thing.

[@ThePhotographicEye]

Awesome, thank you!

[@elizabethjohnson2371]

Your channel has inspired me in a myriad of different ways from encouraging confidence as a new hobbyist to remembering photography is supposed to be meaningful and pleasurable for OURSELVES FIRST. Our expression is unique, and just go for it! I watch your videos all the time on my tv, and being able to comment is not available in that format. Thank you for your time and thoughts and energy - please know you are making ripples.

[@marilyngiannuzzi9867]

I must say you are an exception,I truly I enjoy your videos!Happy New Year!

[@ThePhotographicEye]

Happy new year!

[@gregkiserphotography]

What I love about your channel is that you make it acceptable to do photography in different ways. You talk about other photographers and the way that they see. You focus on the creative end, the parts that you will never find in a book. Technical topics aren't a big deal because you are more interested in the essence of photography. Keep it going!

[@ThePhotographicEye]

Thank you

[@petercameron4380]

Thank you for this video. You're the third or fourth KZbinr I subscribe to who has expressed similar sentiments this month. Many channels I used to enjoy have become gear of the minute and precious little about what said gear can bring to photography. I now know a lot of lenses that will take sharp pictures of brick walls or throw almost everything out of focus, and cameras that will fill a memory card in seconds. Anyway, you prompted me to go through my subscriptions and see which ones had offered me anything about photography in the past six months to a year. About half got culled.

[@kenhunter6024]

Keep doing what you do the way you do it Alex. I look forward to your "matter of fact armchair" chats on photographic art and photographers.as if we are sitting having a coffee together sharing our interest. I've been taking photographs for many years, from a young age and just enjoy it, and i enjoy listening and learning from your relaxed conversation. Looking forward to seeing you in 2024. Have a good one!

[@romekk3975]

Sharpness is key. My favourite photos are often out of focus. I know what you mean, when you skip the technical part, because I know it does not matter much as it is easy to learn. The word "Eye" in the name of your channel tells it all. Some say I do have some repetitive style in my photographs but I am never satisfied myself.

[@JesusChrist-xb7jq]

Firstly, I have to say that your channel was a refreshing discovery. It’s like having a one-on-one discussion with a friend or trusted teacher. I have found myself watching less and less photography videos for many of the reasons you have mentioned. On other channels, I typically scrub through the B-roll. I don’t need to see drone footage of every single hike a landscape photographer goes on, and when I see footage of them walking down a trail or crossing through a gate on the countryside, all I can think is, “I wonder how much time it took for them to set up their camera and take it back down just for that one shot?”, instead of thinking about the topic of the video. Please keep up your amazing work. Your videos are probably the only ones that I don’t fast forward through.

[@ThePhotographicEye]

Thank you for watching

[@CharlesMuccia]

What brought me to your channel and what I love about your videos is you discuss the thought processes and ideas of photography rather than the technicalities. I see too many videos on KZbin talking about what camera and/or lens I should use and how I should compose my photos instead of discussing the nature of capturing an image or idea and what drives us to photography in the first place. I really appreciate the relaxed, down-to-earth way you discuss photography. It inspires me and gives me something to think about as an amateur photographer. Thank you!

[@ThePhotographicEye]

Thanks for watching

[@barneysaunders6278]

There is much blatant plagiarism and a need to be selective. However, there are a number of channels that have helped greatly. Grateful for these.

[@gransha3]

Couldn't agree more. Go out take a photo, talk about the settings, show us the (mostly mediocre) photo and drone on about the light. Oh and let's not forget the close up B roll of opening a gate.

[@garypeck1559]

Your comments about authenticity really hit the nail on the head. Conversing and sharing real perspectives and ideas is how we move forward. Endless streams of "how to's" throw, me at least, off balance and make me question my photographic methodologies, and then I lose track of the why and keep falling back to the how. I've been photographing for over 30 years. I know how! Finding inspiration in a new project and staying true to a vision is where the challenge lies.

[@warwickarnold2420]

Thank you for your fireside chats! You've really hit the nail on the head with this essay. Over the years, I've pored over the how-to channels to hone my technical skills but longed for a broader view of the photographic art and aesthetics. I enjoy AOP's photographer series and book reviews but switch off whenever Ted starts stroking his Leica. As much as I admire the work of certain landscape photographers, bar those with the "distant human figure for scale" cliché...quick, pass me that clone stamp! - life is too short to watch 30 mins of one trudging up a misty mountainside for few fleeting moments of insight. So, ever since I stumbled upon your channel (the algorithm god smiled that day), I have devoured your content - not a minute wasted. You can go as deep and meaningful as you dare - and keep your loyal audience. Here's to The Big Picture.

[@ThePhotographicEye]

Thank you

Great discussion :) It feels like these days everything has kind of become a copy of a copy of a copy. And maybe not because it is the creators’ wishes to do so, but because these platforms have now become so much algorithm-driven that people feel like the only way to be seen is to fit this pre-determined mold of whatever is trending.

[@davidpowell5437]

I've had the best part of a year away from photography. I stopped finding it rewarding (emotionally). I think it was largely because I had drifted into trying to do what others had done before, rather than relying on my own impulses. I have an adequate amount of kit, and I know the basics of using it. Anthing I don't know in that regard I at least know how to look it up. What's harder to find is help with treading my own path and your content is about the best I've found for that. See you next year - Enjoy the Holiday!

[@ThePhotographicEye]

Thank you

[@sharondmeber3802]

I have followed your channel from the beginning and love it! I remember when you were so blown away at how your viewers had grown so quickly in such a short period of the time, your appreciation was wonderful to watch💙 I have stopped following many channels and you are one of the few I continue to enjoy 😊 thank you for consistently great content! 🙏

[@ThePhotographicEye]

Thank you so much!!

[@fastswimming]

Thank you for your honesty in this video, you make some great points and WOW, screw all the hateful commenters! You got one of the best photo channels by far, I check it everyday and I've been shooting photos for 20 years. Keep up the awesome work!

[@ThePhotographicEye]

Thank you

[@The_Hero_Is_Back]

Thanks for your thoughts, Alex. Speaking as a non-creator for the moment, I can say that I hate YT’s interface. I can’t reliably exclude keywords or channels. I can click Exclude on a channel time after time and yet the channels return, like YT is saying “You will watch this whether you want to or not”. It’s not working for the audience either.

[@narelle4868]

At least you're not boring Alex! I enjoy listening and watching you express your viewpoints and sharing your love of photography. I also enjoy your Saturday newsletter. All for free! How good is that?! Best wishes for a terrific year.

[@ThePhotographicEye]

Thank you! You too!

[@RockyRutherford]

Thanks Alex for highlighting what I have felt for a long time. Also you are right in saying that we need to comment more. So here I am commenting. Have a great new year.

[@ThePhotographicEye]

You to.

[@kendrasusan3409]

There are very few channels I consistently watch - yours, AOP and Sean Tucker. I like the laidback, conversational format of your videos. Thank you for sharing your knowledge and experience. I’ve been looking into starting a channel of my own. I watch those “10 things to always do…” videos. I’m not that flashy, b-roll, music (that they paid a ton of money for), “something on the screen needs to change every 6 seconds to keep your audience’s attention” kind of person. My channel will be about photography, creativity and inspiration. I’ve been scribbling down topics. But, the “how to” videos that you mentioned are all listed as backups for times I am short on ideas. I know they are white noise (unless I come up with a revolutionary take on the rule of thirds). So, thank you for looking into the camera and pointing it out. I am going to stay true to myself. And, I’m glad you have stayed true to yourself! Thank you 😊

[@darlgleed9233]

I started watching you because you start your videos with “howzit” and I’m from Hawaii. Turns out I’ve learned tons about the art, spirit, and intellectuality of photography. Excellent channel and content.

[@ThePhotographicEye]

Love it!!

[@alistairmerrifield5035]

I am guilty of not commenting often, but I do think your channel is exceptional. I started with Peter McKinnon (and similar channels) and he’s very entertaining. But there was a point when I outgrew what he had to offer and wanted something deeper… that’s where channels like yours fit the bill!

[@ThePhotographicEye]

Wow, thank you!

[@aljawad]

Hello Alex! As you’ve mentioned, some others in so-called photography channels occupy themselves with reviewing - “pitching”? - gear and techniques that makes them resemble a cacophony of one another, sort of a bazaar for photographers. I must say that if I have to choose one word to explain what attracts me to you and your channel, it is: “honesty”. Your honesty in conveying to your viewers what is the intended message of a photograph - or the photographer. Keep up the great work, and an early happy 2024 to you!

[@ThePhotographicEye]

Happy new year

[@kencox2267]

Your explanation of what and why KZbin serves up content is so accurate…and sad. Like you, if I try something new or different, my feed becomes inundated with similar content. Some hold my interest for a while, but most are just distractions. In the long run, for me at least, the “gold standard” has become my commitment through hitting that Subscribe button. That way I have a known starting point with a quality product in the offing. Thank you for producing video content that I will choose to continue to watch. And thanks for the reminder that creators of good work deserve more than just a thumbs up. I will be sure to let them know that I enjoy their work.

[@maciejzielinski5249]

Hi Alex! I would like to say that I really appreciate what you’re doing here! Your channel is refreshing, authentic…You don’t have to be a Sean Tucker or Ted Forbes (although they are a great inspiration). I must add that I enjoy current formula which is a meaningful conversation not about newest gear but more about photography itself with a philosophical approach. Thank you!

[@ThePhotographicEye]

Thank you for watching

[@ChrisHunt4497]

Thank you Alex for keeping going despite the occasional rabbit hole and cut de sac moments that did not bring you satisfaction. New channels pop up al the time and the creator soon fizzles out because they have nothing new to say. So I stick loyally to the ones I trust and enjoy; you of course, Thomas Heaton, Sean Tucker.and I find all I want from those few channels. I think you are so successful because you are true to yourself. Looking forward to ALL your 2024 content. Happy New Year!

[@yopuivideo]

This is an engagement placeholder put in by a subscriber. Alex. Keep doing whatever you damn well please because that's the key to your success.

[@ThePhotographicEye]

Thank you

[@m1ndcoreX]

Normally i don't comment on videos but i needed to come back to tell you, that your channel is one of the few where i, after watching a video, want to pick up my camera, go out and shoot something. The amount of inspiration i get through your videos is just amazing, so keep it up and pls don't change to "7 hacks to make better portrait" or "i whish i knew this one thing about aperture earlier". Thank you so much for all the insights and inspiration. Have a happy new year!

[@ThePhotographicEye]

Happy new year

[@garycope5332]

Hi Alex, I started watching you tube videos to help me learn more skills in doing my various hobbies. I didn't immediately start with photography videos, and only started when one came up on my feed. The first photography video I watched was indeed about composition, and I have watched a load on the subjects you have mentioned. Sharpness, Aperture, Gear!!!!, and all of the others have been dominant in my watching until the last year or so. The sameness of many of these videos, no matter the polish of the creator, have become boring. I now don't even watch quite a lot of these videos, because it feels all the same. I came across one of your videos about a year ago and was struck by the message. I love the way you present the message of "Don't get caught up in what others think". This was a revelation for me. It suddenly occurred to me that if I found a photo attractive and I liked it, others will too, but more importantly, it's my photography, not other people's. I am a landscape and wildlife photographer mainly, so I don't watch all of your videos. I am a subscriber though, because I enjoy the ones I do watch. I often find inspirational content watching you present the work of photographers you find interesting and appealing. I learn a great deal from those videos, and I thank you for going about the creation of content on photography in perhaps a little different way than some of your peers. Keep doing what you are doing. Keep drawing attention to other photographer's work. Keep discussing the more thought-provoking subjects. I will continue to watch while you do. Thank you.

[@fbraakman]

I am an analog photographer, shooting film and printing in the darkroom. I noticed in the last few weeks a huge number of newer youtube channels devoted to film, very few of whom print in the darkroom, and generally the subject matter is the same old same old. Most are not experienced photographers, and a lot like to tell the world how they screwed up their exposure. I appreciate your channel and Ted Forbes' channel very much. I am more interested in the art of photography than how to select my shutter speed and aperture.

[@JohnColorado3811]

Well said, when ever KZbin offers up a video showing the photog pointing to the back of his camera its automatically hidden. Enjoying the chat side format.

[@ElectricCelluloid]

I really enjoy the contrast you provide with the "How to videos". Helpful as they are you are quite correct in saying that there is a very great tendency to present others work as their own in a different package. Thanks to you showing a book in a previous video (Photographers A-Z) I purchased it myself and it arrived yesterday. Thanks for the heads up.

[@PeterStreck]

Totally agree! Thank you and keep up your awesome work! Happy new year!

[@curiousabout1]

I, for one, think you hair looks vibrant and alive with zest and a zeal for LIFE!