Physicist: Space objects appeared, disappeared years before first satellites | Reality Check

[@NewsNation]

SPONSOR LINK: 3harmfulfoods.com/ross

[@thesuperskull]

not working for me

[@MrPokerblot]

@@thesuperskull KZbin obviously bandit

[@Sweatyfleariddledcamelblanket]

works4me

[@mattstroker3742]

Well, seems like she has gained a couple of million fans around the world in one go today 😃 Well deserved! 👍❤️

[@mattstroker3742]

Please ask Loeb and Nolan to collab with her?

[@user-xn9zj3yd7u]

I think she hit the nail on the head ! It has been a systematic effort to confuse and stigmatize ufologists

[@theinstituteforuniversaltr3629]

They did that to themselves

[@Canuckbelgo]

Lockheed Martin. Look up Ashton Forbes. He was interviewed by Redacted about 2 weeks ago. Absolutely mind-blowing.

[@jase4270]

​@@Canuckbelgoyeah but that guy is a proven lier. How in the hell can you listen to someones stories and believe they are telling the truth? You can't.

[@Canuckbelgo]

@@jase4270 Ashton Forbes is a "proven liar" by who ? You ?

[@examinatorant4522]

Ufologists? Jeepers! Lady, Which credible university has degrees in that? I've met a few self-declared, but all of them were 4 parts emotional, 3 part delusional. Some have even written bestseller books on it, but non-irrefutable proof. I enjoy the odd hallmark movie but I don't confuse that with reality .

[@DavidRBlundell]

Thanks Ross and News Nation for showing the excellent work of Dr Beatriz Villarroel. The doctor is a brilliant scientist and an appears to be a very nice person and human rights activists. It’s shameful she is being vilified by certain sections of the scientific community for being an honorable person.

[@examinatorant4522]

I'm sure she's a nice person but tell me what has/will she achieve that will make the world a better place. If and it is an enormous If she found an actual irrevocably extraterrestrial's created object what could she or we do about it

[@DominikPlaylists]

I am sorry but using single pixels on one frame as data point is as science is precisely an anthesis of a scientist.

[@victorpearson1418]

Jacques Vallee has been reporting these sightings since the early 1950s . He started his work as an astronomer when he saw objects at high altitude orbiting the "wrong " way.

[@daffidavit]

I saw what I thought was a "star" back in the mid-1960s when I was a sober, eagle-eyed teenager that moved like a satellite across the sky, but stopped on a dime several times before slowly fading away. It zigzagged across the night sky before coming to a complete stop before slowing fading away, as if it was leaving the atmosphere to go somewhere else. It moved and stopped several times across halfway across the sky before leaving. This was in the northeast USA. To this day, I doubt we have satellites that can do what I saw. My buddy was with me and he saw it too.

[@theunspokentruth5987]

Yea he's managed to managed decent living out of it

[@souless08]

@@daffidavit Early 2,000's I seen the same thing 2 different times in the same summer while out in my boat fishing, between 2-5 am, in Michigan. Sat there watching thinking wow a satellite and then it started moving all over and stopping just like you said and then just blinked out and vanished. Same thing both times. Lasted anywhere from 30 seconds to 2 minutes if I had to guesstimate. Still freaks me out over 20 yrs later to think about

[@Jerry-b7f]

​@@daffidavitnaive and ignorant is no way to go through life

[@CARPB147]

@@Jerry-b7f 👎

[@MisterBluesSounds]

She isn't alone. The number of scientists who openly accept that the Earth is being visited by machines created by non-human intelligences is increasing. Just to name a few - Astronomers: Joseph Allen Hynek (professor at the North Western University and Ohio State University), Peter Sturrock (professor at the Stanford University), Frank August Halsted (professor at the University of Minnesota ) - Physicists /Astrophysicists: Michiu Kaku (professor at City College of New York), Kevin Knuth (professor at the University at Albany-USA), Rudy Schild (professor at the Harvard University) Harley Rutledge (professor at the University of Missouri), James Edward McDonald (professor at the University of Arizona), Bruce Maccabee (Ph.D in Optical Physics.) , Massimo Teodorani (PhD in Stellar Physics, professor at the University of Turin), Stanton Friedman (nuclear physicist), Illobrand Von Ludwiger (Master in Astrophysics, professor at the University of Erlangen-Nuremberg), James Benford (PhD in Microwave Physics, professor at the University of California) etc.

[@kahlrhoam6769]

Too bad, due his own arrogance, Neil DeGrasse Tyson won’t ever be on that list!

[@ormrinn]

Don't put your faith in "scientists." Only 5% of studies produce results that go against the best interest of the entity funding the study.

[@martinw245]

​@kahlrhoam6769 It's not arrogance. He simply asks for definitive evidence, rather than blurry photos or "what someone said".

[@realsatoshihashimoto]

You won't see Neil De Grasse Tyson on that list. Because Neil cares about his credibility amongst his scientist peers far more than he does about the truth.

[@stevemumbling7720]

Without a scrap of tangible evidence to support any of it. Shame on them.

[@jmelzwe848]

More than ten thousand photos and videos, who wants to see them.?

[@michael-4k4000]

not me. Lou is the man, buy his book and donate to Lou!

[@TalkinKush]

@@michael-4k4000you’re so mad for what? 😂

[@Merkazzzzzzzzzzzzzzz]

✋🏽

[@emilgustavsson7310]

​@@michael-4k4000​Dude ffs just stop it. the guy is the most obvious plant and controlled opposition in history.

[@guncreep9905]

☝️😀

[@onethreefiveeye]

In Germany we have right now also "drones" over two industrial facilities with nuclear waste. The authorities allegedly observing the events but are not able to identify neither the "drones" nor their intention. But they are sure that these were drones. ..😂

[@javahaxxor]

Hostile nations doing mapping of potential targets? 🤷‍♀️

[@Frog89mad]

there is increased radiation levels all over europe coming from chernobyl cause of wildfires in the area. we know they are interested about everything nuclear. Keep eyes peeled to skies

[@onethreefiveeye]

@@javahaxxor maybe...but it reminds me of the "drone" sightings a few years ago in France. They had many of those events over different nuclear power plants. As far as I remember the investigation wasn't successful...

[@j.w.r3730]

What matters is not what they are as tools,but who.. or what is behind their existence and their intent of purpose. My best answer after 47 years of looking at this issue of such significance is this: I hope something isn't like us in certain behaviors and intent. And yet it seems the most successfully advanced life in the universe will develop under a commonality of intelligence development.

[@j.w.r3730]

​@@javahaxxorWith some humans,always.

[@oscarsh2909]

What a smart and brilliant woman. Awesome interview!

[@Alios_World]

and beauuuutiful too!

[@executivesteps]

Brilliant?

[@lindaslater6969]

@@Alios_World what’s that got to do with it?

[@theresacurtis-smith1613]

I felt actual physical pain when she spoke of the destruction of Harvard's astronomical plates and records. So awful. Criminal!

[@Tigerskys-6699]

Please don't be too disappointed at not seeing a UFO on your short flight recently. I've been flying for 35 years with 14000 hours of flight time and I've not seen one either.

[@bodhiray393]

I saw a angle once and you would belive what she said, would I like another drink.😂

[@MIck-M]

We always were looking for other aircraft (or even birds) while climbing to skydive and I could never spot anything (300 odd hours) even when others would point out other planes or gliders. I see things easily from the ground but think it is an incorrect assumption to think we can see airborne objects more easily from the air perhaps.

[@reyariass]

Maybe it depends where your route is? Maybe even the time too?

[@Alios_World]

It will change your life. Mine changed at 10 years old. I've been on topic since 1967. Most current perspective that makes most sense is Allies of Humanity, the briefings.

[@rattlecat5968]

​@@Alios_WorldMy parents and I (age approx. 9-10 or so) along with hundreds, if not thousands of other people witnessed an up close sighting over Corona, Queens and the NYC metro area in the early 1970s. Headlines in the news paper reported a *"Mass Hysteria"* overtaking NYC residents as so many people saw an unidentified craft in the skies that night. It was close enough to us to see details. Now, five decades later, I can not find any reference to that mass sighting in any publication. But, having my family with me that night, I know it was not a figment of my imagination. I hope to see another UFO in my lifetime but, am thoroughly appreciative I was one of the lucky, and relatively few, who did see one. The experience absolutely infected me with the yearning to someday have a clearer understanding of what, exactly, was in the sky, right over our house that night.

[@jeffmccloud905]

Ok, I'm glad you've finally covered this. I'm a hardcore skeptic, but "want to believe". But THIS is one of the most convincing pieces of evidence I've seen. There is no reason for those objects to appear on those plates and then disappear an hour later. And the fact that one of these transients occurred on the same day as the 1952 Washington DC sighting is mind blowing.

[@jacquesjtheripper5922]

Same day really?

[@jeffmccloud905]

@@jacquesjtheripper5922 yup! July 19, 1952. I heard about this on another video/podcast a couple months ago. The transients appeared on several different days, but that one day sticks out in particular.

[@jeffmccloud905]

She was on the Event Horizon podcast a year ago. Title is "Not of This Earth: Were There Unidentified Orbiting Objects in 1950?"

[@jacquesjtheripper5922]

@jeffmccloud905 i see, tks,maybe ill check that out. Been checking lot of nhi uap vids, talks etc since a long while. Good change from all the crappy news lately.

[@Anomaly_Files18]

She also appeared at the SOL conference to talk about this, its an amazing piece of evidence.

[@silviopina_111]

Isn't it a beautiful day when Lou Elizondo made some jaws drop on the Tonight Show? Finally all of YOUR and others work is allowing the message to come through to the general public❤ Thank you for all you do!

[@sitindogmas]

is it on you tube

[@gordonm1690]

Lou is one of these disinformationist who neither tells the full truth nor completly lies. He's worked for the establishment....... The gvt.... They never ever tell the truth.

[@theinstituteforuniversaltr3629]

All we need is that pesky little thing known as evidence

[@kms08711]

Yeah and people can handle it and they will be very very somber I mean VERY

[@jamesmcpherson2018]

If you still dont realize Elizondo is a fake watch yesterdays Vetted channel. John Greenewald says the obvious and what none of the youtube channels are willing to say. He pokes enough holes in Elizondos story to sink a battleship!

[@paulatreides6779]

Thank you, Ross and NewsNation, for making all of this public. People need to know that brilliant minds around the world are struggling with stigma and being harassed during their research into this phenomenon. Dr. Beatriz Villarroel, thank you for your time and dedication. I look forward to hearing about your exciting new discoveries!

[@Kyberpunkkari]

Beatriz deserves a Nobel.

[@Boofi-quat]

Yes

[@ludwigfeuerbach]

why? because she confirms your biases?

[@cruedevil71]

@@ludwigfeuerbach if it can be triangulated, thats huge. Shes gathering evidence and its potentially world changing if theories prove true. Shes amazing, obviously. A Nobel? Extraordinary claims........

[@ludwigfeuerbach]

@@cruedevil71 She does not have theories, but hypotheses. These are different things in science. I realize that in everyday use, these words mean the same thing - but you want her to get the highest prize in science, so I'll insist on the difference.

[@jmua8450]

@@ludwigfeuerbachI mean Nobel prizes come cheap these days. Obama got one for simply being born.

[@robertmacnaughton178]

Back when I was younger, like in my 20's, I and two friends at the time, had a UFO experience. It was hovering in the field adjacent to the road our vehicle was traveling on. We had never seen a UFO, so we pulled off the road, got out and 'hugged' the front fender while watching the UFO. While doing that it left it's hover spot, meandered over our heads, and then sped off to the south. Shortly, it broke west and traveled that direction for a while till it looped upward and left the atmosphere.

[@daffidavit]

I saw what I thought was a "star" back in the mid-1960s when I was a sober, eagle-eyed teenager that moved like a satellite across the sky, but stopped on a dime several times before slowly fading away. It zigzagged across the night sky before coming to a complete stop before slowing fading away, as if it was leaving the atmosphere to go somewhere else. It moved and stopped several times across halfway across the sky before leaving. This was in the northeast USA. To this day, I doubt we have satellites that can do what I saw. My buddy was with me and he saw it too.

[@beans100]

Thank you for sharing your experience.

[@beans100]

@@daffidavit Thank you for sharing your experience.

[@sarahbrown8061]

I've been hearing about disappearing stars for years. FINALLY a professional, scientific discussion about the possible cause. THANK YOU ROSS!!!

[@albinkarlsson9943]

Nice to hear from a fellow Swede.

[@ColofulThought]

Harvard needs to answer for that plate destruction

[@davidt3563]

She definitely stumbled on a smoking gun. Those objects should not be where they were. And as an amateur astronomer there is no way I would destroy any plates let alone 1/3rd of them.

[@janemiettinen5176]

And stopping the sky surveying project! I cant see any reasonable explanation for doing something like this, except the obvious one. Destroying years worth of someone’s work serves no scientific purpose. Disturbing.

[@jakeswarm216]

Fantastic interview with Beatrice.

[@rarabbb]

Love this journalist!!

[@Willmine11]

Great interview I hope the best for this brave , wonderful woman. She needs to do more interviews

[@martinmclean4801]

Great report Ross!!! Keep them coming!!

[@austins.6805]

Holy shit. So three "stars" appeared and disappeared within half an hour ON THE SAME DATE as some the July 1952 Washington D.C. UFO sightings?!? Thaaaaat's interestingggg... 👀👀

[@walterbenjamin1386]

What a marvelous guest! Thank you for this illuminating interview.

[@mariaarnott6061]

Sooooo interesting! Hopefully you can interview this lady again down the track to see how her research is going.

[@defensebydesign]

Fascinating interview! Thanks, as always, Ross!

[@bradstringer5080]

Wonderful to see unambiguous scientific data of UAP that cannot be dismissed by prosaic explanation. Thank you Ross for interviewing Beatriz! Thank you Beatriz (we’re missing your input - come back ! 🤗).

[@Frog89mad]

i'm sure Mick West has a good balloon theory

[@tinkerstrade3553]

Her findings are a hot potato for the official story, so they froze her out. That sounds familiar.

[@Klaus293]

Menzel was a menace! Destroying plates is outrageous.

[@simonpegg1943]

Brilliant work Dr Beatrice!

[@ianstewart6021]

Utube always blocks comments to good uap reports. God forbid if the main stream reported anything to do with uap.

[@mattdavis4937]

Dr Villarroel rocks!

[@KCnLex]

THANK YOU so much for this podcast. Women are still not represented proportionally in the sciences and am thrilled when such an intelligent woman is interviewed. Young girls need role models and she is a worthy one.

[@manuellubian5709]

It is interesting that you should mention that. Because actually here in the United States there were four pioneering black women that were responsible for getting the U.S. space program up and running. These four women were responsible for doing all of the programming all of the coding all of the scientific calculations that went into actually sending spacecrafts up into space. In fact after all these years the surviving members of this group of women was presented with a Congressional Medal of Honor. For more context may I suggest that you possibly look up on the internet or find a copy of the movie called "Hidden Figures" and that will tell you a lot about the pioneering work of these women.

[@roskana]

I agree with you, but not with you last sentence. I do not believe we need to see someone the same sex, race and origin as us for us to become something great. We need to get inspired by ideas and concepts, not by being like other people. Identity politics and mentality are a mental prison. Someone needs to be the 1st in a domain, but no one wants it because they had no role model? What happened with being a pioneer?

[@KCnLex]

@@roskana I am 67 so my world view is a bit different. Luckily I also liked history and reading about women in the sciences, like Marie Curie helped me realize how absolutely stupid it was to push women away from certain fields of study. I was really aggravated when girls were excluded from taking shop classes and boys from taking home economic classes too. I was blessed to have parents who made it clear I could do anything I wanted to if I just worked hard enough. So yes I agree with you today but in the 60s and 70s it helped to have someone to look up to.

[@padbender2972]

Ross is the MAN!

[@rogerhatcher3502]

Fantastic Interview with Dr. Beatriz Villarroel. The D.C. UFO connection to the nine "transient" objects opens great research opportunities. I look forward to hearing much more. I wish her great success and happiness!

[@No-filter-yi7vc]

Fascinating, well done DR.

[@granand]

Damn, Ross is an absolute gem as a Spl Reporter. He used science, deductions and knows how to extract information from a the Professor.

[@user-ku8ov9uo2q]

One of the most curious features about alien and ufos experiences is that some people are unable to see them or forget rapidly after exposed to it. That has been my experiences with some of my friends.

[@silviopina_111]

Yay! Finally catching you LIVE🎉🎉🎉

[@pranaymishra7009]

When he said 'fun guest', I misheard it as 'fungus' for a sec before realising what it is😅

[@powerfuldreams]

Brother you have to let her finish an answer before you interrupt

[@daffyduck3701]

Exactly, not sure why he's cutting her off so often. If I was her I would just shut up and say thanks for the talk, see yah.

[@duncanmacl3od]

Then he won't be able to ask all the questions he wants to ask.

[@paxtech9060]

So then it's a 2 hour interview instead of 1 hour?

[@guncreep9905]

Yes , it was a bit annoying to be honest 🤨

[@leghunter9201]

brocuz used t be a lawyer so thats why.

[@quinnmcdonald3763]

Thank you, Ross Coulthart, for everything you've done to really push the UFO project forward. You and countless others give us hope in uncovering this long held deception in our midst.

[@user-pd6bf6oi3n]

he was forced to destroy unwanted proof of aliens

[@toowiseforyou]

Forced? He was a professional debunker. He destroyed evidence, so he could continue getting paid to be dishonest. He did not care who he destroyed in the process, as long as he got his. His dishonesty lives on today, in all the debunkers today. I guess you must be one of them.

[@hardcorefishermen]

imagine inviting a guest to hear their opinions and experiences and then having the audacity to keep interrupting the guest mid sentence because you aren't patient enough to contain your input for two seconds

[@mpetry912]

Ross and News Nation are kickin it !

[@cknowles3980]

Thank you Beatriz for keeping your moral character and not being bought out. Your scientific way of doing things is the best way. To many people today are bought off like DR Menzall, it’s nice to see you have moral character that cannot be paid off or bought!

[@jlucasound]

You are wonderful, Beatriz!! Congrats on the invite! 🙂❤

[@dantaylor1724]

Ross, why did you keep cutting her off ? Very annoying.

[@rosscoulthart4394]

I’m sorry, this does appear to be a consistent complaint from the audience. I will shut up in future. One of the considerations I have to keep in mind when I’m doing an interview with Scientist for a audience is to ensure the audience is going to understand and perhaps sometimes I overcompensate. I certainly don’t mean to be talking over Beatriz. My apologies.

[@cyphermote6857]

@@rosscoulthart4394 No need to apologise Ross. We know that it is an interview - a conversation we are listening/watching. Compared to just a plain lecture, this format allows a more interactive engagement and the "interruptions" often reveal more interesting information than we might not have gotten originally. You do fantastic work... all the best from sunny Sydney 🙂

[@rosscoulthart4394]

@@cyphermote6857 Thanks for your understanding!

[@jamesmcpherson2018]

​@@rosscoulthart4394I had a TS SCI clearance for 40 years and was in the U. S. Air Force for 7 years. If you want to promote Elizondo youu have to solve The Elizondo paradox...... Everyone has to understand the importance of the prepublication review. If you have a clearence and you are going to publish anything, even sending out resumes, you have to submit it for prepub review. Then the government reviews it looking for anything that may be classified or sensitive. Then you have to remove what ever they find. If you dont and publish it anyway you will lose your clearence or go to jail. Whatever then gets released after the review does not mean the government condones it or is saying that it is true. Their only concern is that its not classified. So in Elizondo's Glen Beck interview he said he held the Roswell material in his hands. So this can only mean 3 possible things. 1) The Roswell crash did not happen. In this case he could say he had tea on the ship with the Aliens and the government wouldnt care. He is just making it all up and mixing it with publicly known lore. 2) Roswell is not classified. In this case you could contact JPL where he said the material went for testing and they would be glad to send you a report on their findings and of course the government has come out and told everyone Roswell was true. 3) Roswell is classified and the government is allowing him to say certain things that are classified because it serves their own agenda. That means he is still working for them. There really isnt any other options. This paradox applies to all the other "whistleblowers" Who have done a prepublication review. If you think these people are telling you anything the government doesnt WANT you to know you will be deceived.

[@tranilator]

⁠@@rosscoulthart4394 G'day from Australia! Online interviews can sometimes be a bit tricky, especially with latency, which can make it seem like people are talking over each other. That said, for the most part, the interview/discussion flowed naturally.

[@GlennPavett-fc5nw]

Pull the camera back mate bloody hell close up much c’mon. Seriously can’t watch as the whole screen is your head

[@mannoo4261]

Your a legend! Keep up the great work 💪

[@jasondeardorff]

The DC flyovers were a diplomatic response to the US covert programs attempting to reach out to the civilization that the downed ET craft in Roswell in 1947 were from. There was one live ET captured and it was kept in a cage at Los Alamos Lab until it became ill and died in 1952. The '52 flyovers were his people. It was a gesture of peace and good will to a nation that had displayed hostility and violence toward ETs.

[@Frog89mad]

Well it's like the Sentinel Islands where the isolated tribe is been left alone by laws. and if someone civilian happens to land with boat and die nobody will go prosecute them or take in custody. and we do good small things for them. checking their numbers and whatnot. nothing negative.

[@XPLOSIVization]

Thank you Dr. Beatriz Villarroel for the important work that you do, and congratulations on publishing those papers

[@bigcauc7530]

This woman is incredible impressive to me. I could tell she was a bit annoyed with your constant need to insert ufo/uap/non human intelligence into every segment of the interview. We all understand the topic and possible implications. You lose credibility as a host the more you assert the same thing over and over when it's not necessary. She seems entirely logical and open to the possibilities and this leads me to believe her observations and discoveries are as objective as it gets. It doesn't seem like she's here for exposure, but simply informational purposes. I love this. Someone very much necessary to the ufo topic.

[@christophercook2467]

Thank you, Ross, for helping this project.

[@Ghostrider-ul7xn]

I used to be skeptic in my naive childhood years until i started digging more into the literature and doing thorough research. This was what motivated me to become a physicist ( academic research in gravitational waves). A year ago, i conducted a statistical analysis to investigate if there's any strong correlation with UFO sightings and nuclear reactor sites in US. Not surprisingly, there was indeed a strong correlation. These sightings weren't just random, they were more concentrated near nuclear sites in my analysis of data for 4 years.

[@pantloadd]

Excellent guest, excellent interview.

[@Cedric_Ironwood]

there is some 200 billion stars in just our galaxy and some 2 trillion galaxies in the visible universe . studies have shown that nearly all have planets around them , now does anyone really still think we are alone ?

[@randybradshaw7060]

High level of integrity coming from an academic in a very interesting area. Thank you! Due process is very underrated in today’s culture. Please have the good doctor on again with an update.

[@debnorris110]

Ross organise for Dr Beatriz to speak at the next Aust. NEXUS conference. She's perfect.

[@paulharrisonadventuregearm5457]

This has been reported by other experts with plates

[@DreamJourneyJo]

Poor Dr Beatriz - there are a lot of strange things going on, but hopefully she can continue her excellent work and will discover some fascinating results. Thanks Ross for picking up this story.

[@Juice_Angel]

Thank you, Dr. Beatriz! Thank you, Super Ross!!🙏✨

[@Leanne-u5f]

I so hope she gets the help to carry on! Thanks for getting it out there Ross!

[@brucederkonstante3405]

In her autobiography Dorrit Hoffleit has no good words for Menzel, but she never suggests he wanted to discard plates that could document disappearing stars -- an idea that she never even hints at. Rather, she perceived the criterion for discarding a plate to be image quality whose value for constructing star catalogs was less than the cost of its shelf space. However, it doesn't appear that she did much of the sorting herself, so disappearing stars can't be excluded as a criterion used by someone else.

[@petesandwich3246]

But then why would he stop continued sky survey’s for 10 years? I am very very skeptical he did it because of “low quality”

[@tastyfrzz1]

Did the Vatican observatory have slides from that time?

[@Alejandrakoxxx]

good luck trying to see them

[@markhunter341]

Didn’t expect that much news, wow!

[@DankSergeant]

I love NewsNation fr

[@talldwarf]

what a fantastic guest and episode. Keep up the good work

[@StrictlyMad]

Hi Ross and Dr BV

[@phillipmolis8398]

Not a native American but still a National Treasure ❤❤❤

[@gerardlynch8099]

How or why did they let Menzel destroy those plates??

[@defuse56]

As a retired college professor in the Humanities myself, I've never envied my friends in the hard sciences. Their careers depend on getting funds from outside sources. I've had a couple of close friends who've had their lives affected by a failure to secure enough grant money. I do wish Beatrice the very best. Although I'm no scientist, I too believe deeply in the tenets of academic freedom to study what you want, teach what you want, and publish good science. I tend to think in literary tropes, so I find the name _Beatrice_ to be a slightly ironic but hopeful analog of Dante's inspirational muse, Beatrice Portinari. 👽

[@douglasburt1622]

Great interview, Ross.

[@AnaMercD]

Great show. Thanks Ross and Dr Beatrize. 💫⭐️ 👽🤍

[@auzziewoz3620]

Well done Beatrice!

[@briangriffiths114]

Great interview and all credit to Dr Villarroel for maintaining her ethics, despite being put under pressure to do otherwise.

[@scottlemurianboxer]

She a woman of pure science, to where no matter where it leads!!....and for that she is being prosecuted. Its a disgrace on the rest of the community and to Harvard! They should be ashamed for how they've treated this intellectual woman

[@gardener3030]

The 1952 D.C. UFO event!? Explains, some things.

[@SpamMouse]

Thank you Ross and team.

[@thevagabondtree6426]

I think some crash retrievals may be older civilizations in orbit satellites and/or space ships/stations that have simply fallen out of orbit

[@forranach]

I am an experiencer. I have seen MANY ufos and had 3 close encounters. First close encounter was cigar shaped that caused 5 hours of missing time. Was about twice the length of a school bus. Metallic gray with a large blue light on each end.

[@BouncyStickman]

You're off your meds again...

[@cknowles3980]

Beatriz is a great astronomer, amazing, honest, intelligent and not scared of the so called debunkers! Thank you Beatriz🙂

[@peteliebl2881]

Thanks Beatrice it's interesting how your relatively recent work shines a new light on events in the past. It's too bad not much reflects back because of the destructive work of the Menzels of the world who put forth one persona but hide away another.

[@anniewelch3436]

Great interview. Thank you

[@popcornadvisor3193]

Great interview Roscoe! keep on keeping on Dr Beatriz Villarroel

[@jameshattingh]

Awesome stuff,i live for this

[@bstampl1]

"I'm Ross Coulthart and today we have a fungus."😂

[@MLG85]

I’m so glad I purchased an Ad-free premium membership!… oh, wait…

[@UpInTheSky2025]

It supports the channel.

[@MLG85]

@@UpInTheSky2025 it’d be concerning if it didn’t lol

[@boxlessthinker1973]

Great interview Ross. I appreciate you digging into the facts.

[@UAPReportingCenter]

Not shocking at all they’re legal in the US. Corporations own America.

[@davidwhiteford4936]

Ross, you are doing the work of ethical enlightenment. More power to you!

[@davidcranealabama]

As usual.. very interesting.. Thank you Ross !

[@Bluefin_Custom_Boat_Hire]

Great interview. Cheers Ross.👍

[@medicalmisinformation]

What a delightful and brilliant young lady and researcher! Thank you for this interview.

[@richardautenzio8117]

Thank you Ross and Beatriz. I live in Brisbane Australia and have no qualifications in this field. However I have believed for years that if we believe what we are seeing is from outer space, then it is also equally possible that we are seeing a past civilisation from earth. Either still here and or hidden from sight, perhaps in a few bases, or have been here for many thousands of years and long before our know logged history. There are so many facts and information surfacing that connects with this possibility. If some living species knew more about our history than we do ourselves, then that would be an enormous revelation and turn us on our heads. To know the real history of the world and every natural disaster or catastrophe, that has occurred on earth, would open a can of worms and enable us to know how we survived and how other more advanced civilations, may have survived in ways we may not have even considered.

[@douglasburt1622]

Obviously, she’s a good and brave scientist and good soul.

[@myks6068]

Ross, each and every of your interviews are meticulously objective and full of behind-the-scenes events that are trying their heinous best to cover this up . Hats off to you and hope you continue to do such work despite pressures from all quarters.

[@pyropainter]

I don’t see how they could rule out dust particulate in the scanning process

[@jcrosby4804]

As always there many naturalistic explanations before we should even consider something so ridiculous as aliens. I’m not convinced this woman is real. If she is she’s going to destroy her career.

[@steveng8727]

I dreamed I opened the side door of my childhood house and several beings that looked part human & part animal were staring peacefully at me. I asked "where are you from?" One of them said 'Meridian'. Upon waking I immediately looked up this term online- first page was a UFO newsletter!