Plants Feel Pain And Scream When Stems Are Cut Or Dried Crying Sound Recorded

[@shoaib1847]

My mother used to treat plants as a kid, and when we were moving to the next state, she gifted some to her friend; however, after a month, she tells my mother they are not growing and are dying. I think they can feel love too…

[@TheCosmosNews]

Indeed 👍🪴💚🌱

[@daisybackstar]

I am not human, I am a plant, I changed my shape to live among humans as a normal girl

[@Muhdrad-Iusgay]

​@@daisybackstarlmfao

[@beatnik6806]

Yeah I've been thinking about this when I mow our huge lawn 😂

[@daisybackstar]

ok@@Muhdrad-Iusgay

[@nomad8690]

Vegans have been real quiet ever since this dropped

[@macmillerppp]

Plants don’t have a nervous system, consciousness, or a brain, and therefore can’t suffer or experience pain. However a cow can. If I had a knife and was going to either A - use it on a dog or B - use it on a cactus plant, which would be the correct ethical decision? Plants may make a cry like sound, but again, no pain receptor, no vocal cords and no sentience. Tomatoes don’t scream in pain lol.

[@Lowequay]

Reduce plant suffering, go vegan!

[@A-Very-Specific-Name-Isnt-it]

Couldn't agree more

[@indianindian9970]

Propaganda to kill more innocent animals

[@ish4638]

Actually, Ed Winters recently spoke about this study (and the media's misrepresentation of it) on live TV. Give it a watch.

[@MensoJero]

I'd like to see someone record these sounds then play them back to completely unrelated plants and see what happens

[@ivyjanerefil8864]

That's why the elder said"if you sing for plant . It will grow fast"❤

[@mattiaspersson6459]

And vegans say "we dont eat anything thats alive" 😢

[@dmgice]

When a vegan breathes, they are murdering BILLIONS of microscopic organisms. Every movement we make is some sort of destruction. A realist knows this and still moves, knowing that quadrillions of lives cry out in terror with every moment as their lives end and are reborn. I believe it to be a grand symphony of life. I eat my steak knowing and respecting its sacrifice. I am a part of nature because I consume nature and it becomes a part of me. I feel it would be disrespectful not to eat.

[@ingamingpc1634]

Everything's alive what you mean to say is they don't eat anything that has the ability to understand and talk

[@SamsungJ7prime-mk7zs]

@@ingamingpc1634 do u know plant are alive

[@SamsungJ7prime-mk7zs]

@@ingamingpc1634 vegans eat vegables that the plant growed it and it can cry

[@SamsungJ7prime-mk7zs]

@@ingamingpc1634 vegans eat healthy things but they the plants are alive and might cry becuz of his bodyparts that got chopped there a vid of a plant talkin tho using technolgy

[@richardthered]

I remember when i was about 6 years old asking my Mother about this as she was a keen gardener. She said no don't be silly as she was cutting flower heads. I said to her, well plants need sun, water, food (soil) etc and they grow from a small seed like us i wonder if they talk to each other in the garden in a language we cant hear. She laughed and said that is some imagination. Funny a few years later we were all watching the TV and Tales Of The Unexpected came on and to my mothers amazement it was a episode all about a man that has a machine that tunes into the frequency of plant, flowers, tree's etc and can hear them express pain when cut etc. PS Also on a side note, my mother used to take a little battery radio into the garden greenhouse, since she had taken that radio in there the tomato, cucumber crop had been twice as good as the pervious years. Just sayin

[@daisybackstar]

I am not human, I am a plant, I changed my shape to live among humans as a normal girl

[@gordon8282]

Classical music makes them grow well

[@neesqueendom6107]

They say....so I've heard .that they like classical music but I bet in fact different plants like different music 😊

[@bluemoonerheart5316]

One stem from one of my money plants was plucked and stolen by my neighbour. It was almost dead and adamant, not trying to live. Still, I watered it everyday for a year, and one day, it grew new stem. I was so happy that the stem started growing and now, it has several leaves on it.

[@nymerianan4short314]

So literally the hills are alive with the sound of music

[@Kenya_Berry]

Can’t wait for Alexa to tell me my flower says it’s thirsty

[@JulianCaesaro]

That’s a revolutionary idea 😂

[@Methad-One]

Life is more ALIVE than we think!

[@mikethemonsta15]

To be clear, the popping noise is not the sound of the plant. The sound has been modified to become audible by human ears.

[@i.d.6492]

Obviously, they make high pitch sound

[@TrueFork]

the sound reminded me of "day of the triffids" 😄

[@hedgewitch59]

My plants talk to me when they're getting dry. I can hear them in the next room.

[@Alex-ft1df]

My plants are fake indoor ones.

[@Alex-ft1df]

There are real plants outside in the yard, and the garden.

[@melaniesmith1313]

So what the hell are we supposed to eat? Rocks?

[@truth4004]

no, fruit and vegs when they are ripe. They're gonna fall anyway.

[@aleksandarobradovic6943]

Bugs

[@TheHypercarnivoreChef]

Rocks cry too 😢

[@xgengx7530]

Animals, i like my steak medium well 🥩

[@scarlethorse5391]

@@xgengx7530 Absolutely degenerate. We all know steaks must be cooked rare!

[@thesidecharacterr]

"Plants don't feel pain" -the vegan teacher

[@JmanKO97]

Who eats more plants? A) Vegans who only eat plants B) Meat eaters who eat plants as well as animals that are fed a lot of plants before being killed If you really care about plants, you should still be vegan

[@Wawaballcar]

@@JmanKO97still a meat eater 🥓

[@HamzaZaid-n2n]

@@JmanKO97the plants would be already eaten by the animal so who cares?

[@JmanKO97]

@@HamzaZaid-n2n People who believe that plants feel pain would care

[@HamzaZaid-n2n]

@@JmanKO97 plants don’t fell pain..in that way

[@TochedGrass3742]

2023 just got even crazier!

[@ixataca9596]

I made a study where I fried a couple of bacons. The higher the temperature the louder the sizzling sound they make to warn the other bacons. In my other study, a drinking glass screams as it crashes down the floor thereby signaling me to check it out and prevented our cat from pushing down the other glasses. Also the higher a hit the glass with a spoon, the louder it screams in pain and when I put out my cold glass of water out from the fridge does it cry with tears as it warms up? I also burned some paper, and it released paper pheromones (smokes) to warn all the other papers.

[@logitchy]

i ate some chips, and it screamed in my mouth to alert the other chips. it sounded like crunching.

[@AnimeGIFfy]

thats funny af

[@MrOneanddone91]

😂😂😂

[@mofo6907]

This is gonna blow your shit out. Are you ready? Glass cups, pieces of paper, and bacon frying on the stove are inanimate objects. Plants are however NOT inanimate objects and are living things 🤯

[@MrYyelo]

Great.. VEGANS! The plants scream! What do we eat now?! 😭

[@mylesraymond7364]

I just opened a can of soda and it made a sound. I have thus concluded the soda is screaming in pain.

[@MensoJero]

Not the soda, the can, sodas just the lifeblood

[@misterauctor7353]

Hva?

[@jesusislord4060]

You still can't hear the plants so what does this comment prove

[@cedriclavoie8123]

Plants dont have a nervous system like humans, so no plants cannots feel pain like us. They scream, but thats to alert other plants and insects, more like a survival scream

[@MensoJero]

They don't have a nervous system like ours, but they do have an internal system that alerts the plant of anything going on at the surface. They "feel" touch because signals are sent interally when you touch it, though it's unclear how that sensation would translate to human senses.

[@teranosimons3134]

How do we know only things with nervous system feel pain in the universe 🤔 ion know but God creation is complicated 😅

[@misterauctor7353]

It's different.

[@TrueFork]

up until about a century ago the general scientific understanding was that animals are a kind of automatons that may appear to act like they have feelings but they don't really

[@SSS-rd3wr]

So your telling me just because they can't feel pain we should destroy them? so is it okay to kill an animal that does not feel pain. Like if scientific discovers that chicken don't have self awareness like we do. Will it be justifiable to kill them? (not attacking you, just need answers)

[@rosspirsig]

how and where can I get one of these special microphones? Anybody know?

[@vinuthag644]

The Sound Machine by Roald Dahl just got real 😳

[@GenericHandle666]

Vegans crying like Kaneki in Tokyo Ghoul

[@phbhf]

The sounds are not new, and it is not plants "talking" or "screaming", it is a natrual phenomenon of water moving in the vascular tissue of plants. What might be new is associating these sounds with something that has happened to the plant - maybe.

[@rinkuchatterjee82]

No plants have life and they feel pain just like any other living being does.

[@phbhf]

@Rinku Chatterjee that's a silly remark from someone who doesn't know plants. Certainly a plant can respond to an injury because it does heal, but not through the process of feeling it like it has a nervous system. But good try, made me laugh.

[@rinkuchatterjee82]

What I tried to say here is that plants have life too and since they are living beings, they might respond to pain too. I don't know how their nervous system responds to painful stimuli, but my common sense told me since they are living beings they might be susceptible to pain too. It is good that i could make someone laugh. What we are lacking in life is a good dose of laughter. Yes I am no expert in plants, but I am a budding psychiatric social worker.

[@phbhf]

@@rinkuchatterjee82 yes, plants have life and allow animals to live because of photosynthesis. They are truly remarkable. But this article is trying to make them more than they can be. It's a problem with how people want to describe things from a human perspective.

[@Buttz2Buttz]

Explain the sound of animals affecting plants without touch? Plants need Sunlight, water, food. Anything that is alive needs at least these three things. Take Water away from a plant it dies. Take food away? Take Water away from animals, they die. Take food away? See a pattern.

[@yahyaayman6298]

وإن من شيء إلا يسبح بحمده ولكن لا تفقهون تسبيحهم❤

[@paramitamajumdar6275]

Yes plants have a life its already said by a bengali Scientist Dr. Jagadish ch. Basu.

[@somecat22]

this is cavitation, the releasing of trapped gas. It isn't pain, it isn't screaming.

[@GayKermit-._-.]

Can someone please like this guy's comment already? 🗿

[@ActualDrunkAtheist]

Trust the science

[@BrooklynBaby100]

Marry me

[@gurkengamingpvz21]

finaly a person with a brain

[@misterauctor7353]

Proof?

[@ameliapangan8279]

Time to send this to That Vegan Teacher

[@MattBaldwin-u8l]

My plants have an attitude.

[@Cookie_man23]

Should I play this video next to my plant and see if the plant try’s to kill me

[@br0s4ver56]

This is interesting. The study definitely jumps to conclusions and further testing is needed but definitely interesting. If this study is legit, we now know that plants make noises based on their status, now we need to find out whether these are screams or not: record these sounds, play it back to other plants and see if they react, play different animl sounds to plants and see if they react, etc.

[@Who-cu9eu]

According to science if something doesn’t have a nervous system it cannot feel pain so comparing killing plants to animals is ridiculous

[@BrooklyFire]

No way they did "tomato" and "tabaco" as a coincidence. Also, I kinda always knew plants had sentience and pain. It really messed me up ethically whenever I ate something that wasn't grains. So I ended up concluding that it's ok to eat all life, but plants are more ethical because they don't die if you cut off a leaf

[@tomgray971]

Considerable anthropomorphism in the title.

[@daisybackstar]

I am not human, I am a plant, I changed my shape to live among humans as a normal girl

[@darklaboratory1697]

Eventually as science advances we will learn to digest rocks, sand and photosynthesise. But for now we'll do our best ethically to our ability

[@darklaboratory1697]

this may sound funny, but our medical advances over just one century are astounding

[@darklaboratory1697]

also, we don't know the true interpretation of those sounds(yet at least)

[@stillcantbesilencedevennow]

You know that's impossible, right? Plants are specifically designed to photosynthesize from the beginning. Plants stay plants, animals stay animals. The first creatures we came from were animals....

[@mamunursiam9806]

the coping is unreal 😂😂😂

[@moxine_]

I mean Buddhist and Hindu monks have been doing this for thousands of years

[@edwardhighmann6421]

Ask before you take. The leaf will just pop off if it's ok.

[@MensoJero]

Ask in the fall ;)

[@fasterhorses]

The video says they click when they're thirsty, not that they scream. Or did I miss something?

[@JaqHandle]

Item #: SCP-4521 Object Class: Safe Special Containment Procedures: SCP-4521 is to be kept in Site-551's Bioterrarium and only accessible by personnel with Level 2 clearance or higher. Additionally, attempts are to be made daily in an attempt to provoke vocalizations from SCP-4521. Description: SCP-4521 is a Douglas fir tree with abnormal shape and leaves. SCP-4521 was discovered within God's Silence, Oregon after reports of an "ear piercing silence" from within the tree's vicinity. Amnestics were administered, and SCP-4521 was transported by implanted Foundation agents to Site-551. Currently, SCP-4521's anomalous property is that it is incapable of screaming. No apparatuses are found on SCP-4521 that allow it to scream, and attempting to create one has been met with failure (see testing log). Attempts are being made to provoke screaming within SCP-4521. No memetic or cognitohazardous phenomena originate from or affect SCP-4521. Multiple attempts using several other anomalies have been made to detect any screaming, but no screaming was detected. Test Log: The following are attempts made by on-site personnel to eliminate SCP-4521's anomalous ability. Test 1: Carve a mouth on SCP-4521. Outcome: Several holes were placed upon SCP-4521 using a chainsaw. No screaming appears to emanate from these holes. Test 2: Use an extremely hot branding iron to imprint the word "SLAVE" onto the base of the tree. Outcome: No screaming detected. Brand disappeared within 2 days time. Test 3: Place multiple species of spiders upon SCP-4521's base. Outcome: No screaming detected. Approximately 30% continued to stay on the tree. 50% of the spiders that stayed burrowed further into the tree. No screaming was detected during this time. Test 4: Take a tree that is genetically similar/related to SCP-4521, and slowly destroy it in a close radius around it. Outcome: Tree successfully destroyed over the course of 28 hours. No screaming detected. Test 5: Take a tree that is genetically similar/related to SCP-4521, and [REDACTED]. Outcome: [REDACTED BY REQUEST OF ETHICS COMMITTEE]. No screaming detected. Test 6: Use a D-Class personnel under the effects of mnestics in the event that SCP-4521's screaming is antimemetic. Outcome: No screaming detected. Test 7: Attempt to communicate with SCP-4521. Outcome: See attached audio file. AUDIO FILE: FILE-4521 INTERVIEW [BEGIN LOG] Dr. Hanz: Uh… hello, SCP-4521. Can you hear me? Silence Dr. Hanz: Did you say something? Silence Dr. Hanz: Oh, that was my imagination. I'm sorry. Silence Dr. Hanz: Listen… do you want to talk? Do you have something on your mind? Just let it out. Silence Dr. Hanz: Come on, it's not healthy to bottle up, You can tell me, I'm friendly. Silence Dr. Hanz: D-do you not have a reason to… you know… Silence Dr. Hanz: I do hope those thoughts in your head are doing you well, but they need to be let out. This is for your own good, I promise. Don't worry about making too much noise, I don't mind. Silence Dr. Hanz: Can you hear me? Can you even hear me while you're trapped in your mind? Can you see me through the foggy, muddy waters that are your eyes? Silence Dr. Hanz: Come on, the deafening silence is killing me! If you don't want to speak, or at least scream, the tests will continue. It's only healthy. Silence Dr. Hanz: P-please! You're scaring me! Silence Dr. Hanz: Y-you know… when I was a kid, I… I assaulted a kid. I took a bike lock and crushed his skull in. It went on for 6 minutes before being stopped by one of his friends, who I also clocked in the head. I went down the street, and I saw this lady. She fell off her bike. It was the same bike I stole the bike lock from. Silence Dr. Hanz: I took that bike, cut it up into several small, tingly pieces, and fed her the bike, over the course of several hours. She just laid there with her broken leg, and her stomach eventually ruptured. The black ooze that dripped from her stomach indicated that someone might have called the cops, so I went home, and locked my room. Do you want to know what I did? Silence Dr. Hanz: I screamed. I opened my mouth and let out the largest roar that was trapped at the bottom of my lungs. All those wasted opportunities, all those memories, fading away as the calming ring of my torn voice box filled the room. And look where I ended up! I got a doctorate and I'm working for one of the best organizations on Earth. It's not too late! Silence Dr. Hanz: Or… you haven't felt that thrill yet, haven't you. Typical. Outcasts like you, born in some random remote part of Siberia, no other individual in sight. You're too weak to impress anyone, so you just stay by yourself. I see your game. Silence Dr. Hanz: But I can help you! You need to scream! Silence Dr. Hanz: You need to scream! You need to scream! You need to scream! Dr. Hanz proceeds to say the exact same phrase for 37 hours before being escorted out by onsite guards in order to prevent death by dehydration. After waking from a short 4 hour nap, Dr. Hanz promised that he "will not stop until this tree finally screams." Testing is to continue. [END LOG]

[@TonySuperano]

did you write all this?

[@nonameismypreference8542]

The copy/paste is Nasty work

[@AlokKumar-ul6og]

So we can eat it if it's died

[@alguem292]

"Though we may hear this information and feel compassion for the plants' pain, there is no definitive evidence to date that plants have "feelings" in the human sense of the term, Hadany said. "I think we are not there yet," she said. "We cannot say the plant feels stress and therefore makes sounds. It might be that the sounds are made completely passively, like a physical process," she said." This is literally written on the study, but you guys left it out, i wonder why?

[@F3ral-n01s3s]

Dr sherman needs to watch this

[@gurkengamingpvz21]

why would a plant evolve the need to feel pain anyway?? it cant move plus it produces fruit in most cases, that need to be eaten. its rather just something with water, or if it was a wound, something filling up the plants wound

[@marymcdonagh-ql4sx]

Did you know that you can actually HEAR??? celery growing in your vegetable garden??

[@justxj9-557]

So do trees scream too?

[@berrnisimon9785]

Yes they do. Indigenous people knew it ages ago, that’s why the tree hugging and offering is made before cutting. Also thanking them for being part of their lives.

[@DaniHBV]

Incredible!

[@odesamusic]

What if they're talking to the sky to make it rain 😳

[@Blooming_Bee_Yoga]

I love a good comment section with a KIA lol

[@beatnik6806]

Those screams will repeat in my head next time I'm going to mow my parents huge lawn 😂

[@exgod1]

So we need a PETA for plants now

[@Tiffanylouisekelly]

😂

[@the_wobbly_witch]

well yk, metal and wood make sound when u break them as well so..

[@vanderWsthuizen]

Metal and woods are not a living things

[@juiuice]

Ok, i was expecting actual screams lmao that'd be horrible to deal with lol

[@crux1on]

im begging yall to send this to that vegan teacher

[@barnyard_fab]

Imagine the screams when mowing a lawn 🤣

[@wraith_2309]

this is how the shriekers in dnd are made

[@royawoftrainer8882]

was 4:15 that sound from the plant or what?

[@TwoLeggedTriceratops]

It's the plant beatboxing to the creatures crowded by.

[@ZacksCreativity]

"Beat boxing" 💀💀💀💀

[@yaaelohim3748]

So….am I the only person who remembers The Secret Life of Plants by Christopher Byrd?

[@Legit_leigh]

What defines life. For all we know oxygen carries consciousness we aren’t aware of lol

[@treasey8655]

no they don't FEEL pain. That's misinformation!

[@MensoJero]

Plants have been proven to have an internal system that sends signals to other part of the plant when it's touched/harmed. It's not touch/pain like how humans might feel, but it's certainly got a type of awareness

[@misterauctor7353]

Yes, they do feel pain.

[@Jay121]

Nature Is Metal

[@ramenaddict1676]

Im gonna go hug a tree now

[@eliseclo6492]

Dang that sucks I still have to feed my beardie lettuce tho

[@realopinions5477]

Kinda like noises in an old building or house..

[@battshytkrazy156]

F A L S E

[@thewatcher1120]

Yeah….you’ve got an appropriate name! 🤡

[@Romesdramazone]

Ok weirdo

[@ryanhp3170]

I take it you are a vegan?

[@SealowMapping]

maybe consciousness is life..?

[@jodiknutson1209]

The Vegan Teacher is crying rn.

[@_crazy._.kid_]

Real

[@LonelyBoySteven]

I heard nothing but game noises when the *noise was supposed to happen

[@Allabouttrends1126]

Vegans still don't believe this since it dropped💀

[@munmunsarkar1726]

This video spreading wrong information. It is due to its response against environment. That response is natural that does not mean they feel pain.

[@TheCosmosNews]

Hi..If any organism didn’t feel something it will not response to environment..

[@munmunsarkar1726]

@@TheCosmosNews it doesn't mean they feel pain like us. It means they can feel the surroundings and can response to their external stimuli.

[@StreaminGames]

This inst acurate... I hear the sounds... At night..

[@genrev3368]

Eating soil for those vegan plants is also hurt when😅 you eat them .😅😅😅 Animals and plants are here to feed us.

[@sandmanlopez9920]

That’s sad 😥💅💯

[@陳-o2o]

I wonder what vegetarian will say

[@sandystephenson1107]

Babies within a woman's womb also cry when they're "cut" and destroyed. "Love them both . . . stop abortion!"

[@thatboredaroace]

HEY SOMEONE GET DR SHERMAN ON THIS

[@Biology60___]

😮😮 its already mentioned in quran which was reveled 1500 years ago 😮

[@sansational15]

Do flowers talk too?

[@ZacksCreativity]

Yes. They are also plants

[@yaaelohim3748]

This treatise was published in 1973. I personally knew Christopher and his wife Shabari Bird. Probably the author(s) of the above should DO THEIR RESEARCH instead of picking up what someone else wrote! BIG THUMBS DOWN!

[@zaxisontherun]

Veganssss where yall at

[@tobiasdontmatter1868]

Tell the HOA I’m no longer mowing my lawn,

[@gurkengamingpvz21]

they dont scream. there is no reason for a plant to evolve feeling pain

[@shivendrasingh5590]

Vegans punching the air rn

[@ish4638]

Animal agriculture actually kills far more plants than vegans do. A vast majority of agricultural land is used to graze livestock and to produce their feed. Also, the word "scream" was never cited in the study. Nor was "suffering" or "pain". This sound is simply cavitation: a release of gas after damage to the organism. Response to a stimulus in this way does not equate to the same pain livestock feel in the slaughterhouse.

[@ava1421]

Meanwhile the vegans salads are literally screaming with every bite they take.

[@pinkroses135]

Stop mowing your lawn it makes mices ears yell

[@bigtonithegreatjamboni9850]

All life is life.

[@bonsaiunik176]

Trimakasih

[@yaaelohim3748]

Christopher Bird and Peter Tompkins, The Secret Life of Plants. Published 1973. Wake up!!!!

[@lemniscatelogos7917]

Chicharrones for the win

[@Shadowman-1960]

Do the vegetarians care?

[@Anggelos876]

Why translate the sounds to an adjective such as crying and hurting. They have stated the logic of thr sound, and it does not suggest crying or hurting. Why do humans like to humanise things that are not made as humans? 🤦🏿‍♂️ And in thr end still treat their fellow humans worst 🤷🏿 I do not understand it.

[@sown-laughter4351]

Fruits are like the ovaries of the plant, so I'd probably scream too if someone took my apple's.

[@mohamadsyaqibsyahputrabins3631]

Vegan teacher caught being a killer

[@klaalter69]

Send this to the vegan teacher

[@gauravsangal]

A animal eat kgs to tonnes of plants before becoming meat. So it's better to be vegan.

[@JCKC815]

Allah already mentioned this us 1400 years ago in Quran

[@LOL-bs1hg]

Bro, now what the vegans gonna eat? dust?

[@realman8003]

Eat the reality...humans need both , meat n vegetables 😋

[@cexxy]

@@realman8003 no they will start eating vitamins

[@gurucarcar]

Vegans and vegetarians will have to face that they cause pain and fear to their food sources.

[@ish4638]

Animal agriculture actually kills far more plants than vegans do. A vast majority of agricultural land is used to graze livestock and to produce their feed. Also, the word "scream" was never cited in the study. Nor was "suffering" or "pain". This sound is simply cavitation: a release of gas after damage to the organism. Response to a stimulus in this way does not equate to the same pain livestock feel in the slaughterhouse.

[@aryansavita3118]

yeah they feel pain without central nervous system😂😂

[@gurucarcar]

@@aryansavita3118 yes - it is different, but all and all still distress.

[@mylesraymond7364]

So? You can distress your clothing with a pair of scissors-does that mean your jeans are sentient? No.

[@gurucarcar]

@@mylesraymond7364 apparently you just don't get it or want to. Plants feel.

[@M_Jono]

Vegan starting to only drink water and eat air

[@someone-kw3ou]

4:12

[@Nathan-tn5yb]

Take that vegans

[@supercia1]

Well the only other option is synthetic food. For vegans some much humans done know. Interesting researcher need more data. So maybe folk rumors were right all along.

[@kibbyvoom]

vegans need to watch this...