[ENG sub] PRODUCE48 [3회] ′맞잡은 손에 담긴 간절함′ 칠전팔기ㅣ여자친구 ♬귀를 기울이면_1조 @그룹 배틀 180629 EP.3

[3회] ′맞잡은 손에 담긴 간절함′ 칠전팔기ㅣ여자친구 ♬귀를 기울이면_1조 @그룹 배틀
[#3] ’繋いだ手に込められた切ない願い’七転八起ㅣGFRIEND ♬LOVE WHISPER_1組 @グループバトル
2018년, 당신의 소녀에게 투표하라!
국민 프로듀서님! 잘 부탁드립니다!
매주 금요일 밤 11시 본/방/사/수
프로듀스48 (PRODUCE48)
Every Fri. 11pm (KST)
-
프로듀스48 (PRODUCE48) 최신 클립 다시보기 : www.tving.com/s...

[@areummmmmm]

진짜 손은채 저때 정말 가장 맘고생 심했을듯.. 혼자 한국인 ㅜㅜ 근데도 리더로서 팀을 잘 이끌기도했고 이조 멤버들도 열심히잘했어서 무대를 잘했다고봄..

[@김지민-u3p]

마지막에 울먹거림...

[@딩푸링]

1000번째 조아요 내꺼

[@ddeguri]

좋아요가 1천갠데 댓이 2개밖에 없어ㅠㅠㅠㅠ

[@ddeguri]

제가 달아드릴게요!!!

[@ddeguri]

무대를 잘했다고보는건 ㅇㅈ입니답!!!!

[@앨리스양]

와 ...근데 손은채 음색이 너무 맑고 예쁨..진짜 감탄사가 저절로 나옴.. 저 목소리로 노래 다 부르는거 듣고 싶다.. 진짜 목소리 너무 예쁘고 맑아요......ㅠ

[@유지석-d1l]

대박이네 ㄷㄷ

[@점쩜-q3v]

Face..

[@꿀꿀이-r4y]

마자용❤️ㅠㅠ

[@Laura-f8s5k]

저랑 똑같은 생각하셨네요 저도 저 무대보고 손은채양 응원해었는데.. 아쉬워요

[@담-x3e]

점쩜 귀엽기만 하고만 왜그래

[@momomomo-vs9rg]

개인전은 나코가 잘했는데 팀으로 보면 애네가 더 잘하고 연습하는거 보고 봐서 그런가 뭔가 뭉클했음 마지막 ㅠ

[@김유-p4l]

걍 나코가 멱살잡고 간거지

[@최예뿅]

저는momomo mo님말에동의합니다!

[@mr.b2169]

1조가 2조보다 더 잘했는데 나코가 쌉캐리 한거지 혼자 330표 받았는데ㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@mr.b2169]

@@user-wf2gd1vb9c 개인의견 모르세요?? 본인 생각 이 다르다고 해서 응 아니야는 아니지 않나요??

[@YYJSJK09]

@@mr.b2169 맞음ㅋ 나코표발표전까지 거의 150표던가? 앞섰음ㅋ 나코한명으로 이긴거라고 봐야함~ 거기에 이조는 헬바야보다 더 심한 한국인 1명 있는조ㅋ 왕크어도 중국계고 나머지는 다 일멤이고~

[@무치킨-o2b]

와 손은채 뭐 옥구슬 굴러가는 목소리네

[@jung8679]

ᄏᄏ ㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@eunk3415]

@@야오-d6p ㅇㅈ

[@알고싶다그것이-f3z]

손은채 빼곤 전부 일본 중국인 이였네 근데 한국어 노래를 이렇게 잘하고 단합 이 잔된건 진심 대단하다

[@예다감사했습니다]

크어가 중국인이에요?

[@한유진사랑해-s3b]

와 이댓글 봐서 정신차리고 알았네.... 저 진짜 일본,중국인 많아야 3명정도 있을줄알았.... ㅂㅂㅇ2조보다 더 어려운 조합....그래도 자연스럽게

[@소연-f7w4n]

@@한유진사랑해-s3b일본 애들이 다 어려가지구 ㅂㅂㅇ에는 어울리지두 않았죠ㅜ (근데 이겨브러?)

[@서인돼지]

@@소연-f7w4n ㅂㅂㅇ이 뭐에요?

[@뭘봐-k4m]

@@예다감사했습니다 처음알아쒀ㅜ

[@user-wr5du8dv7m]

손은채 목소리는 듣는 사람을 진짜 편안하게 하는 힘이 있는듯..

[@dawn_1214]

약간 어린이용 애니메이션에 나오는 언니?목소리 같아서 편ㅡ안

[@ghijkabcdef6887]

저 무대를 방청 가서 봤었는데... 무토토무 예쁜거 아직도 기억나네요

[@cjw2639]

손은채 진짜 안정적으로 잘했는데 너무 빨리 떨어져서 아쉽 ㅠㅠ

[@헤이즈-v5t]

진짜 그때 음색이 쩔었었음

[@히힛-f1j]

제 원픽 ㅜㅜ

[@존나충]

와꾸가 저따구니 탈락할 수 밖에 .

[@cjw2639]

존나충 말넘심 ㅠ

[@히힛-f1j]

째니최애니 그러게요 매력있는데 ㅜㅜ

[@yonseisophia]

완성도를 떠나서 뭔가 감동이 있음 ㅠㅠ 다들 혼신의 힘을 다 하는 게 느껴져서 그런가

[@doublejackson8528]

For people thats saying that the main vocal of this group isnt up to standard, it is cause all the members of this group had their focus on dancing, instead of vocal (so thats why no one can really uphold yuju's high note). But props to wangke for taking over the role as the main vocal and trying her best with her capabilities when soyou found that the original main vocal of the group is not stable during the vocal trainings!

[@septi_77]

Double Jackson yep, so proud of her.

[@synchro7451]

Also the Japanese trainees also canr really sing

[@enjelele]

Double Jackson ahh yess she really tried her bestㅠㅠㅠ so proud of her

[@1234234r]

Definitely! Though it may have not been the best, definitely a great vocal under the circumstances faced! Good on her for pulling through😊

[@evanyong5871]

Double Jackson She's just passable dear the other team main vocal beat her by a mile , tho this team has more popular members . Does anyone knows the voting points ? But still I don't think a miracle can make 1 person hard carry a full team unless this team is totally useless , which they proven they are *NOT* so we will see how's the vote goes Noe is really buying the audience with her bright energy tho .

[@melodycen8781]

Not going to lie I was rooting for this team, especially wangke. She did extremely well considering she trained for a short period of time and she's more of a dancer. I hope her ranking would rise

[@sssushang]

Melody Cen Her rank raised a lot and passed the first elimination. Actually all the girls from her entertainment passed. :D

[@presbelgera8525]

she got eliminated, sadly. :(

[@arceliachan9136]

@@simpayshenaides Overreact What Lmao

[@larrybello6550]

Setsuko Their voice is actually really nice when you listen to it more often, also their not over reacting their just putting great effort.

[@mikaela_choi]

Yes!!! They did it better.

[@요구르테]

여기 일본멤버들 많음에도 불구하고 춤이 진짜 잘맞았음 크어가 삑사리 난 수준도 아니었고.... 나코표수나오기전에 상대팀보다 100표이상 앞섰음 크어 이때 엄청 울었던거 마음아팠는데ㅠㅠㅠㅜ

[@leesummer8243]

손은채가 진짜 무대매너좋고 표정연기잘하네...

[@KaylahH]

I give them props because anything by GFRIEND is HARD omg

[@vnuz9702]

케일라Kaylah ikr

[@jacobscereal1378]

what song is this

[@charanepho3905]

miss roset love whisper-gfriend

[@yo_chee]

Good job to them. Vocal wise and Choreo wise, it must have been hard. GLEGENDS❣️

[@deandrake7072]

shawtyyboo1996 then why didn't they do the floor spinning part? Btw I think they did really good.

[@nanu9228]

Considering how hard love whisper's choreo is, im so amazed by the fact that japanese trainees were able to pull it off.

[@debie91]

내태랑 and to think this group have the most Japanese trainee

[@wotashionce1260]

Well, never underestimate Japanese trainees. Haha i know they have the talent, they just dont know how to show it since akb dont have the same system as Korea

[@debie91]

WatashiOnce and when this started antis said they don't have talent and lazy

[@abibirawa4119]

Ichikawa Manami is the main dancer and she slayed it lol. Too bad she's so underrated

[@kalopsiavisions]

i watched the third episode and when they showed this team i couldn't stop crying, all of them were always crying because they had to change their parts, eunchae was blaming herself because she was the leader and ke was crying saying "how can i improve myself?", they looked so deseperate even when they were training with the judges eunchae was crying but the judges praised them because of their amazing teamwork, at the end of the perfomance all of them cried and even the japanese trainees were saying "arigato eunchae" and all of them were hugging, they might not have won but in energy and teamwork they deserve a 10

[@jewljuju2929]

m b I agree! They stole my heart! A few of them were in 80s rank so I hope people who are watching in Korea will vote for them and raise the rank!

[@Briguy1027]

That's the important thing, never give up. Quitting is worse than at least trying your best.

[@nabilayasmine3319]

Yeah I cried like a little bitch too :'))) so proud of them

[@user-hd1lw1yl3u]

最後のウンチェの涙が全て物語ってる…本当このときめちゃくちゃ大変だったんだろうな

[@trogdorthe8th]

Yamada Noe just giving us EVERYTHING, I see your smile and insane energy lighting up that stage girl! I was also very proud of Tomu, she worked very hard, and although her vocals still aren't completely solid, you can tell there's improvement from her audition. All the girls, both Korean and Japanese, are working so hard and it shows.

[@debie91]

trogdorthe8th to think tomu really not good in singing and her improvement

[@fauraziakbar9935]

her dance is so sharp like knife

[@infsgkim]

Yeah for sure, all of them already working so hard, and improved..

[@angthuthao2337]

Muto Tomu sing really good but her pronunciation doesn't good much so people think that she can't sing 😭

[@raraci98]

I love her smile

[@MsSira12]

i appreciate Wang Ke hard work seriously

[@DreamHighh799]

Wang Ke is the girl with short hair?

[@nadiata3695]

An Huy Nguyen the one who sing high note at 1:57

[@mio9138]

she needs more exposure

[@filbertfausta9886]

Hubert Damanik she Isn't confideny because she's in dance position not vocal position

[@Briguy1027]

I respect that she took one for the team and was actually up to the challenge. She may not have won, but she did well enough, and while it doesn't necessarily translate into a group win, it will get you points in the popular vote. There's always a week delay and we'll see a lot of changes next week.

[@user-ro4we6kf6f]

たしかにダンスはこっちのがまとまってるんだよなあ… ウンチェの声は天才でしかない

[@Zunzunzun06]

ウンチェちゃんとワンクーちゃんみたいな一生懸命な子を応援したくなる

[@ぽあそん-f5e]

ウンチェちゃんの声めっちゃ綺麗じゃん…高音出なかったとしても。なんも知らないままこの動画だけ見たら普通にボーカルメンだと思ってしまってたわ。

[@magicklemon3435]

Manami as center was a great choice. She really brought energy to the center. And good job to WangKe as main vocal and Eunchae the leader.

[@ms-nz2wc]

これ当時、1人韓国人ながらここまでの完成度持ってきたウンチェちゃんが泣いてるのにもらい泣きしたけど、今見ても泣きそうなる。ateamでもうすぐデビュー出来そうだし、もっと報われるといいね。

[@Enyyyy39]

ウンチェちゃんの歌声が綺麗すぎて定期的に見に来てしまう。

[@candylo2218]

We can see the difference, team 1 is focus on choreo cause there's no main vocal and they're dancer. Team 2 is focus on vocal (i think). Both of them did a good job ^^ *And Im so proud PD48 used Love Whisper as high standard for trainees*

[@조면-e9v]

왕크어 춤 잘 추는 건 알았는데 노래도 잘하냐....등급평가 때 셀럽파이브 한 것 땜에 개그캐 이미지 박혀서 그렇지 은근 만능캐네...

[@ahoes___]

아.. 셀파.. 강렬했죠...

[@user-hu5lx1fd3w]

아 강렬한.. 그 무대..

[@amtoohkamui]

Wang Ke you took charge of the situation without thinking, girl you have courage. You are going to debut.

[@user-vj4ru7wp4h]

お団子の子の声がヤバすぎ！ 加工入ってる？？ 透き通ってて好きすぎて

[@ドナーミ]

かなり今更ですが、ウンチェちゃんです！笑

[@hamavocado3706]

Btw everyone needs to remember, Wangke is not a vocalist but she did great. Proud of her!

[@LJ___]

Max Caufield One more thing I think you should add that Wang Ke is also Chinese.

[@alianhkhan]

Also that she is a dancer

[@btsismyoxyjin2013]

Which one is Wang ke??

[@キムかば子チャん]

ウンチェちゃん？はディズニープリンセスの歌声に近くて素敵で綺麗だから癒される。ディズニーの曲歌ったら絶対好き(確信)

[@8Ditsjustmebri]

wang ke was asked to be main vocal and practiced really hard I’m so proud of her 😭

[@홀리워터-d9x]

손은채 음색 뭐야 진짜... 순두부같기도 하고 마쉬멜로우같기도 하고 완전 포근하고 예뻐

[@widysaaja]

I'm so sad watching their interaction in episode 3..and Son Eun Chae really tried to be a good leader and she did, Wang Ke also tried to be main vocal and she cried a lot..oh my heart

[@もも-i1c3r]

お団子の子見せ方うまいな〜 この子メインも見てみたかったな

[@わらびさくら]

知ってたらごめんなさい... 私も調べて見たらソン・ウンチェちゃんでしたよ！

[@りり-m3m]

目線の使い方等とても上手ですよね！私もこのステージとウンチェのリーダーとしての頑張り見てファンになりました！

[@maaami121]

この曲の高音が出なくてメインボーカルできなかったんです。 すごい特徴的な美しい声持ってますよね✨

[@신용철-g4r]

이팀진건 걍 메보가 없어서 진거 왕크어가 메보하기에는 보컬스킬도 딸림 그거빼면 팀웍도 좋고 다좋앗음 상대편 나코의 하드케리 그와 비교되는 메보의 존재감 차이로 승부가 갈렷음

[@헤이즈-x3m]

신용철 ㅇㅈ 현장투표수 왕크어만 적었음 저팀

[@나귀욥찌]

왕크어 존나 불쌍 한국온지 1년도 안된애라 트레이닝도 회사에서 기본만 배운상태라 기획사 평가때 한국애들이랑 셀럽파이브 노래한것도 잘하는게 없으니까 존재감 발휘하려고 대중적인곡 골라서 한거임....한국어도 어눌함 저팀 일본애하나가 음색좋고 그나마 고음할줄알아서 메보시켰더니 안한다고 울고불고 난리나서 그나마 고음되는 쟤가 함 고은채도 진짜 불쌍하고 왕크어도 불쌍함

[@성이름-v2w3n]

마지막 고음 박자 빨랐음

[@wogus2]

@@나귀욥찌 고은채는 내 이름이야

[@bellnyu3472]

진짜 ㅇㅈ 왕크어 노래 부를때 뭐든 너무 짧게 끝냄. 쌤들 칭찬없이 고개 끄덕이기만 하는거 보면... 손은채가 하는게 나았을것 같은데..

[@둔탱-u1b]

나코의 멱살캐리만 없었어도 얘네가 이겼을걸..

[@sidicjcud8eie]

얘네가 더 잘했긴했는데 인지도면에서 너무 딸림...

[@안녕-h1q2l]

미라클오맹걸 댄스부분은 얘네가 더 잘하긴 함

[@大島優子-c3b]

@@sidicjcud8eie 인지도요? 훗 무토토무는 카미 세븐 출신입니다 인지도요? 하 ㆍㆍㆍㆍ 나코는 9등이 최고 였어용

[@김명환-l4y]

ㅋㅋ인정 노래자체가 나코맞춤 이었음 이미지까지 딱맞춤

[@김유-p4l]

大島優子 무토토무 ㅇㅈ 일본에서도 미인들만 찍는다는 광고 찍고 인기 엄청많은데 분량 실종이쥬?

[@que1582]

1組と2組での甲乙は付け難いのに、奈子のあの数秒間がドラマティックすぎたんだよなぁ。 プデュで最も面白い瞬間の1つだった。

[@lrose1310]

This group made me tear up watching their behind the scenes and then their final performance. They worked so hard, its just a shame Wang Ke didn't get enough credit for her hard work (though Nako was very good, 330 points seemed really crazy). Hopefully when people watch the episode they'll vote for these girls and they'll do better rank wise and avoid elimination.

[@weluvvenus5880]

lrose honestly 😭😭😭!

[@mileycyrus201198]

same they made me cry so much especially the leader and wangke

[@kuroro9589]

hope Wang Ke didn't feeling down because she was doing well too! It's hard to accept Nako quality, but I still stand for Wang Ke.. for the progress, effort and how the group get along together!

[@magicklemon3435]

I cried for this team. When they cried and hugged after the performance my tears dam broke 😫

[@thanhchi4013]

i feel weird too,Wang Ke was placed at 33th it's not that high but it isnt a low rank either,and that day only 28 people voted for her.Nako was incredible,but i stand for this team.Hope they will survive through the 1st elemination

[@choerrychoi2447]

Aside from Nako's vocal, this group energy, dancing, and stage presence was better. They put more energy in the dance and they seemed happy and genuinely enjoyed the performance. And Wang Ke did hit the high note nicely, although it was not comparable to Yuju's high note of course. So I don't really get the point of comparing this to Nako's team performance because literally only Nako stood out.

[@LUNACYS]

I might have to disagree with you. This group was mostly full of dancers however, the vocals were much more subpar in my opinion. Many of the lines were added with staccatos & rests and breathing in between. I feel that it can be a stylistic aspect as some groups may prefer a more energetic type of performance in terms of dancing and singing. The other group's vocals were much more clean, strong and clear. The dynamic of the of the other group's vocals combined melded much better just by comparing the choruses. The solo lines of the other group were not cut short in between each phrase but still kept the originality of the song's style of singing their lines like a full sentence unlike individual phrases with breathmarks in between. And that also goes for the dancing, this group was like an energetic group of happy bunnies the other were like a group of graceful smooth soaring fairies. And this of course is to NOT diminish any of the efforts that this group made. I think that it was an amazing technique for them to sing in that way to make the lines easier and adding more breaths in between. Wang Ke proved herself to have vocal talent aside from dancing by being able to hit the note for her musical background which is impressive by efforts. However, musicianship-wise, Nako stood out because of how effortless she made the note seem with the belt and everything how she landed on top the note and had evidently a better breathing technique. But ya this is all my personal opinion of course, audiences all have their own preferences of what makes a better show I just personally enjoy analyzing tiny things in terms of classical musicianship.

[@zero-bj9ml]

@@LUNACYS indeed.

[@mikaela_choi]

Yes!!! Definitely!!

[@mikaela_choi]

I like this group better.

[@ramdevera9465]

But the energy, is really overpowering that it looks sloppy. If you see during the start of the chorus, Noe almost falls down because she leaned too far. It just is a bad look on their for seeming too energetic, but they are a really good team. But I just think that they were just overmatched by higher ranking competitors like Nako, Nayoung, and you can also argue, Misaki won them more votes cause she smiled for once.

[@으-p4b]

심사위원들 반응보면 답 나온다.. 이팀도 좋긴했지만 나코가 너무 압도적이여서 ㅠㅠ

[@mymemu9]

그런 것도 맞긴 한데 마지막 고음 할 때 약간 짧았어요 그니까 "너를 느낄 수 있어 두 눈을 감으면어언 어어어 어어~어" 해야 하는데 "너를 느낄 수 있어 두 눈을 감으면어언 어어어 어어어" 요기 마지막 부분에 짧았어요

[@wdodoo]

@@mymemu9 어어어 어어어ㅋㅋㅋ

[@user-cq8kv2ne7i]

@@wdodoo 왕크어어어 어어어

[@xCupidPanda]

individually this team is more popular than the other team...but then NAKO hard carried >.< im so proud with this team doe...i almost cried with them...

[@happyfacesmanager4295]

Yes..

[@Tesh49]

Same here...

[@ooooo7653]

Which one is nako?

[@polee2362]

ooo oo She was the main vocal for the other team I think

[@amiliyana2]

same... seeing how hard eun chae to pull and make this team really work and the whole teamwork they showed, really touched me.

[@letylek]

1:26 IM STILL NOT OVER HOW ADORABLE HER SINGING VOICE IS

[@nanu9228]

letylek tbh she sound like there's a food stuck in her throat haha i wish the trainers would help her improve her vocals.

[@yoon9521]

내태랑 it's her pronunciation I think

[@kaedekagome811]

How dare you compare her to Jisoo?

[@lillieslollies]

here comes the annoying blinks jesus christ let people have their own opinions ahhaha

[@Kenneth_MJ]

She sounds like a minion, but that's interesting. She still sings better than most of us :). She was pretty stable so I applaud that.

[@anythingisfine5049]

The tallest girl going for the high note is WANG KE!!!!! She had really tried her best. Fighting Wang Ke!!!!!

[@delacruzjuan6972]

Anything is fine HOW ent. fighting 😍😍😍

[@민트쵸코프로젝트]

아 너무 예쁘다. 나한테는 이 무대가 프듀48중에서 원탑이예요.. 모든 멤버들이 마음의 상처들을 극복하고 환하게 웃으며 만든 무대.. 정말 너무 예뻐요

[@lynbertdavisocampo8133]

I'm so proud of Wang Ke 😢 Doing justice to Yuju's part. I'm proud to stan her so badly!!! Hwaiting WANG KE! 💕

[@sundayyymay]

Same!!

[@Patricia_Rosas]

💛💛💛💛

[@btsismyoxyjin2013]

The one that hit the high note is Wang ke right??

[@hienvan6775]

Ichikawa Manami is one of the most powerful dancer of the Japanese idols. Her moves are so energetic and I love her professionalism. She must have been worried with changing positions. She was assigned with a role that she didn't want and was pretty upset that I was worried. She probably didn't want to fail at such a big role and bring everyone down. Thank goodness Wangke did well to not ruin the performance. She also had less time to practice the main vocal position due to the sudden change. And she did so well for a position that differs from her specialty. I love these two professionalism on stage. So much energy that you couldn't tell they had trouble.

[@luxdecrocs]

Hien Van 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

[@luxdecrocs]

Finally someone talking about she ❤️😭😭😭😭😭😭

[@unfairartms]

Was she the previous main vocal but they had to switch to Wang Ke?

[@popdenayeon5532]

smol worm: yes, she was

[@jenn5422]

Finally someone acknowledge her:(

[@kiyomaru-qk3wo]

矢吹奈子の1人に負けてしまったけど、このチームも良かった点があったので本人たちに伝わってほしいなと思いながら感想です。市川愛美ちゃんの涙はとても気持ちが伝わりました。皆んなのために頑張る気持ちでいたのに、本人の意思と関係なく降ろされると頭では理解しても寂しく悔しい気持ちになるのは人間誰でも一緒です。それでも腐らずに最後まで頑張ってくれてありがとう感謝です。リーダーをやったソン・ウンチェちゃんの心労もめっちゃ記憶に残ってます。環境も実力もバラバラな子たちをひとつに纏めて適所適材に配置する事は大変で、短い時間の中パフォーマンスの完成度も上げなきゃいけないから、そのプレッシャーは大きかったはずです。メインボーカルを変えた時に市川愛美ちゃんに申し訳ないと言いながら泣いて、その後はずっと泣いてましたね笑 涙もろいリーダーで優しさに溢れてました。お疲れ様でした。皆んなキラキラしていて、感動的なステージに出来たと思います。

[@jewljuju2929]

同意です！このチームを応援続けます！全体的にこっちのチームが良かったと思います！組2のリーダーも盛り上げるのが上手でしたが感動したのはこっちでした。一緒に泣きました。 Wishing the best for this team! There were a few of them whose ranking was in the 80s so I hope they will rise after this ep. I think they did better overall.

[@지윤-y3n]

손은채 음색 ㄹㅇ 보석이다

[@im.onalei]

Wang ke's voice sounds more adorable tbh, like a child's voice, even if she wasn't as good as Nako hitting those high notes, there's something natural about her voice that I can't avoid to like. Also, it surprised me she was a dancer. Idk,

[@OrbitOnceAround]

It really teared me up when Eunchae started crying and everyone started to cry too.

[@jiunjiun9773]

ONCEfineapplinus same i cry because of eunchae her voice., i really want her to stay

[@bangye2739]

나코가 멱살캐리한건 맞지만 이 팀이 잘한건 손은채 밖에 없는것 같은데... 춤에 힘이 있긴하지만 잘 추는것도 아니고, 발음은 그렇다쳐도 리얼 잘부르는걸로 들리시나..ㅎㅎ 나코 없다해도 나코가 가져간 점수는 뿜빠이했을때 이팀보단 나코팀이 더 가져갔을껄..?

[@먕먕-p2c]

은채 없었으면...터졌을 것 같음... 은채가 멱살잡고 이끈 팀이지만 나코의 고음멱살이 너무 강했음ㅠㅜㅜㅜ

[@user-onedayonestory]

전 이쪽 그룹이 더 걸그룹 같았는데요. 멤버들 합도 좋았고 춤도 나름 칼각에 노래에 맞게 상큼하고. 나코가 있던 그룹은 뭔가 어수선해 보였어요

[@재은-u8t]

딱히 실수는 없었지만..잘하진 못한 느낌인데..

[@외않되-e6l]

올 댄스포지션인데 노랜 당연히 부족하죠

[@오리꽥꽥-w5x]

이 노래 이정도면 춤 완전 잘한거 아닌가... 이거 발동작 진짜 힘듦ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@yuyuchanaimi]

中国人が韓国語で歌うとこんなに可愛い発音になるの？ 今まで聞いてきた韓国語の中で1番可愛くて癖になる！ ワンクーちゃんが特別可愛い喋り方なだけ？

[@kiswsugeng]

Actually, this team get a good point at the last show. They're just lost with Nako-chan. Nako-chan save her team with 330 point about main vocal.

[@banbanhxinhdop]

*her :v

[@namphunglemontea]

I think so

[@rigsalbert4658]

true, nako hard carried her team

[@amyrose651]

I'm still sad, this group deserved more T-T I cried when they lost T-T

[@kiswsugeng]

I know... And than girl with short hair Manami-chan make me speechless. Her dance is so powerfull and energic. And she is so bright. Make me happy when i watch it.

[@Cubeq81]

This performance is so lovely, even though their vocals are not as “perfect” but they are so energetic when they perform! Korean performers are good but just not as energetic whereas while there are still areas for development for the Japanese performers but their energy level is amazing. Good balance

[@himeairi5394]

The Q just looking at the other team with lots of korean trainess, nako really shine with her energy and smile...

[@user-lj8mn5zz7p]

最初の手繋ぐところでウンチェの練習した時に泣いたのが思い出してつらくなる、、、

[@ch.wx_n]

진짜 여기팀은 손은채가 다 살린것같다진짜ㅠㅠ 개인적으로 손은채목소리 진짜좋고 왕크어가 울때 자기가 이기게해줄께 라는말듣고 진짜ㅠ 마음이 예쁜아이같다

[@さんぴ-s2j]

ウンチェちゃんめっちゃ応援したい😭✨

[@ナズナ-p9r]

こっちのグループはダンスがパワフルな感じ！！

[@KawaiiLolaa]

Just watched the episode! So proud of them ♡

[@yurikaempire8901]

Kawaii Lola excuse me! Where did u watch full ep? >

[@kristyshi3991]

Yurika Empire here is episode 3: drive.google.com/file/d/1XcVPugHO5IXdZzPpiS8i2nUwaK2H6cjM/view

[@KawaiiLolaa]

Yurika Empire kshowonline :)

[@YesJadey]

Kawaii Lola exactly

[@jiunjiun9773]

I started crying when they starts performs this is for realll

[@오빠만오억명]

이무대는 볼때마다 울컥해지는 뭔가가 있음

[@yolanday391]

Wang ke shows her attitude and courage. Sometime you just stuck in the worst situation: the song is the last choice,no vocal, all the girls are dancers... It's not about you win or not, but if you try you best or not.

[@SHOTARO2525]

このチームにワンちゃんは勿体無かったな

[@amateurnikki5175]

no kidding but yamada noe is just shining so bright. she almost overshadows other member

[@Tesh49]

She got the highest vote in her team.

[@kelvinliemanto423]

curiousity how did u know? I want to watch eps 3 but its not out yet...

[@Koko_Jon]

we watched the live stream

[@sabrinamourah1647]

Crystex K-POP She probably watch it in korean. Since the episode was already out today. For us, we need to wait for the subs that will come out on Sunday!^^

[@kelvinliemanto423]

Li Quanzhe is precious go vote for him how to watch the korean one? I could understand 50% of korean language and the other 50% i just have to understand body sign and their emotion 😂😂😂

[@ところてんかんてん-m2t]

、このチームはメインボーカルを途中でまなみさんからワン・クーさんに交換したりしてみんなたくさん苦労したチームだから1分40秒くらいの振り付けがまなみさんからワン・クーさんにバトンタッチみたいになっててすごいこの振りが来ると何回見ても練習中の映像を思い出して感動してしまう （ツタワレーー）

[@dt8602]

Wang Ke did so well as a main vocal but got the least vote out of everyone :(

[@meidiarsihekasavitri7249]

Danni Thach because she was against nako chan, most of the voters choosed nako that's why she got least vote

[@colby_247]

Wow she did really well

[@liIacs]

It’s position vs position and the main vocal of the other team stood out

[@tannedpotato5375]

to give u a fact as a Korean who was there, Wang Ke made a huge mistake on her high pitch part. There were many stages that were a mess but MNet re-recorded their singing after their stage. NAKO slayed her live performance. That's why there's a huge difference in the votes. Most Koreans didn't even know who Nako was but had to vote for her no doubt

[@byeongari0404]

Sonny rerecord the singing? while the life of this girls depend on votes? It's unfair!

[@benjamin-qe7ob]

結局、アイドルグループが人気を得られるかどうかは、平均点の高いメンバーを揃えるかでは無く、万人にインパクトを与えられるセンターを見つけられるかにかかっているという事だね。 センターメンバーがグループの窓口になり他のメンバーにも次第にファンが付く。

[@RrkmMr]

圧倒的すぎてもダメだけどね。 例えば橋本環奈のグループとか。あれ以外全員ダメ。

[@leondc1894]

I was so surprised how good the Japanese did! They we’re as professional as the Koreans, makes me so happy seeing the huge improvements❤️

[@lunacxx1330]

This group did great but Nako hit the note better. But this group had such amazing energy for the whole performance. Props to both groups

[@valentinarebolledo5961]

I know that Nako created the "cute avengers" but this group plus Nako's voice could be the real "cute avengers". CHANGE MY MIND

[@ubeml06]

yamada noe made me feel so happy and just fuzzy when watching this! her smile is so beautiful and she has sich a cheerful vibe!!

[@bulankuning1015]

Muto Tomu should've been the centre.. Can't take my eyes off her..

[@altinmemaj3556]

bulan kuning only bc she is pretty doesnt mean she should be centre I am not saying that she is not talented though Probably the centre was more talented at what was required for this

[@shika4730]

Altin Memaj but become a center not always have to be the most talented. they should be able to catch audience attention. I didn't say they have to be pretty too but they need to have at least decent skill and charming

[@kenzelaylo990]

bulan kuning yahhhh we're the same, since the start of the video, she already catch my attention hahhahaa oh my god, i'm inloveee 😍😍😍

[@bulankuning1015]

Altin Memaj maybe yes the centre is more talented. But who's the centre in this stage though? I always thought centre should be the one that caught audience's attention the most. So, to me, in this case, it is Muto Tomu.

[@bulankuning1015]

kenze laylo ikr? She caught my attention ever since AKB make their entrance to the audition hall. lol..

[@1mar1ove725]

編集で分かりづらいけど、このチームは完成度が高かったと思う。

[@みさき-v3i]

ソンウェンチェちゃんの人柄、歌声、目線、表情とか好きです！いつか彼女の努力が報われますように....！応援してます

[@_eotwr3922]

報われた、、よかった

[@katerynaostrova5646]

My heart breaks when I see crying Eunchae, she was such a good leader. It's a pity that this group didn't win. All of them did great and their performance was amazing! I hope all of them will survive first elimination

[@delacruzjuan6972]

Minnie Changminnie Leaders of both team should at least get to the next evaluation jebal kfans, knetz, kpeople 😍😍😍

[@katerynaostrova5646]

delacruz juan Nako is safe, cuz she is high on the list, and Eunchae jumped higher, but mnet is snake and can't be trusted

[@bayubramasta4828]

Note sure :( 4/6 of them is.low rank

[@nineteenwest8881]

1組は みんなダンサー希望だからやっぱりパフォーマンスのレベルとチーム全体のバランスは勝ったと思う。 メインボーカルで負けたのが惜しい。

[@コナンくん-h4j]

ダンスレベル比較すると全然違うな。

[@sally7966]

たしかに、ダンスレベルで言ったら こっちの班はなこ達よりも高い☺️ だけど、この曲のイメージとか、 ダンスの踊り方はなこ達の方が合ってる気がしました😢この曲は、激しくエネルギーに踊るよりも爽やかで可愛らしく踊る方が合ってる気がしました😭

[@user-ki6kg6ip4b]

k-pop fan 本家に近いのはこっちのダンスじゃない？

[@yeonsss9813]

。。 声もユジュはなんか奈子みたいに高くないから歌もだと思います🥱

[@rosaintlaurent.7755]

their voices are so cute and stable 💗💗

[@YaelKozeniuk]

J E O N S É aren't they lip syncing?

[@your-regina]

But this is all lipsync

[@takakinako496]

Luisa Regina No, I don’t think this is lypsinc because Jang Gyuri will have voice crack next week. It’s stable because They edited their voices.

[@heyitsrosie]

J E O N S É it's not live tho it's an LiveAR track lol

[@heyitsrosie]

Rizky Jauhar it is lipsync. It's been like that since first season.

[@スニフ-h4i]

このチームは素晴らしかった、しかし相手チームにはとんでもないモンスターが居た。

[@ハロハロ-p4b]

モンスターって言うなwww

[@Ressel_]

i have to say.. i watched the episode. i think this team. as a whole is way better than the other team. they lost in vocal department, its wangke vs yabuki nako. its a crushing defeat. everything else was fine. i feel their dance is better, they probably better in synch dance, energy is great, and tomu's pronounciation kinda fun to listen to. if only they have a real strong vocalist. im not saying wangke is bad, no.. she definitely did her very best. but unfortunately it wasnt enough.

[@Tio230395]

ian dwiki i agree with you. If it was 1 vs 1 battle system, this team would won. But based on total votes, Nako wiped the 1st team by far. I hope that the 1st team won't get elliminated yet. I believe that they still have a lot of things to show to us.

[@yana_desu]

ian dwiki i enjoyed this perf a lot. Hahaha raping the replay button

[@knockknock3304]

japanese trainees really fits this song😻

[@jobanana28]

Rap Moanster since japanese trainees did well in everything which is cheerfull. they are so shining and suitable with cheerfull theme

[@knockknock3304]

Johan Al Falah true! and they also have a really positive vibes that makes people happy to see them, hope they do well in this show

[@Star-dl2qb]

loa lo no. please no

[@0502-i5y]

Thats why Gfriend is popular in Japan lol especially Umji she is well loved over there

[@evelynn5917]

Because all gfriend songs are anime opening lol 😂

[@Nesallienna]

Team 1 sounded like Volcaoid in a good way lmao

[@rickdipadua]

Auto tune maybe

[@nightingale4786]

Rick Padua yeah it's not them but literally every performance has autotune on it but that's to be expected on a talent show nowadays regardless of the country lol

[@Nesallienna]

Haha I see, they litterally made it sound like it was volcaoid especially when most of them have nasal voices I think.

[@tsunkiuchoi171]

I think the mentors taught them how to sing without a nasal voice. EP2 F class shows that

[@tsunkiuchoi171]

The audio was auto-tuned but not that much. Watch S1 . If the trainee makes a serious mistake, it can be showed

[@민트쵸코프로젝트]

나한테는 이 영상이 프듀48 무대중에 베스트임.. 여자친구보다도 곡을 더 잘 살린거 같음.. 일본멤버들도 화면 잘 받고 예쁘게 잘 나왔고 춤도 잘 춰 주었음.. 세리카양, 무토양 춤선 예쁘고 표정 죽여주고~~ 크어양도 예쁘고.. 흰 옷도 다 잘 어울리고.. 첫무대라 그런지 긴장감과 표정이 살아있고.. 가장 큰건 은채양 춤실력과 보컬, 그리고 마지막 표정.. ㅠㅠ...... 은채양 데뷔소식 들리던데 찐팬으로써 응원할께요~~~

[@user-go8kf7fh2h]

本当、귀를 기올이면はどっちも良かったと思う！武藤十夢と山田野絵ちゃんはボーカルもう少しがんばってほしい、、

[@letylek]

1:14 she looks like a doll

[@minerva5601]

Is wang ke

[@jimjim674]

Love wang ke so much. She did so good.

[@Jacob-ve9cx]

Omg you're right I thought she sounded like someone familiar.

[@colby_247]

Wow her voice is really good

[@bemm7906]

Please support a Wang Ke T T She's so pretty :C

[@kalincoto]

チームとしては負けちゃったけどセンターの子めちゃくちゃ可愛い〜〜！ 女優の杏さんにどことなく似ててきれい☺️☺️

[@kalincoto]

そしてリーダーの最期の涙目の笑顔が最高にきれいで泣けた😭💕

[@paixy1679]

お団子の子可愛い♡♡♡♡♡ ショートカットの子ダンス‪w‪w‪w‪w‪w なんでも大ぶりになげやりにやればいいってもんでもないでしょ笑 日本人っぽい子達はもっと曲に合わせて踊って欲しかったな笑

[@dianaramba1513]

Their leader Son Eun Chae if i am not mistaken is a good leader! They did very well and she lead her team in a good way!! Both team are veryyy good cause we know Gfriend's songs are difficult in vocal & choreo wise.. But DAMN!! Both Team Daebak Sagun!!!!

[@padang14320]

her voice so good in this song, so stable

[@dianaramba1513]

padang pandanaran *her Hahaha.. yes she is.. People should appreciate her more.. Even tho i am Noeppi's fan but I really love her leadership!

[@padang14320]

lol im not her fans, just notice her voice so different when i compare with her re-eval video

[@dianaramba1513]

padang pandanaran Which one? Noeppi or Son Eun Chae?

[@padang14320]

eun chae

[@Wlerin2]

十夢ちゃんすごいな Tomu did so good!

[@seventeenxoxo7971]

This group have half younger members and make this song energetic 😍😍 even most trainee in this group Japanese member.. I hope they will survive from mnet snake.. They did well even all member thin voice

[@jobanana28]

Seventeen Xoxo snake 😂 but they have done a great job.. thin voices 😂

[@flyinghigh6953]

younger members? ohh, perhaps you didn't include Tomu 😂

[@avocartlovers6032]

Seventeen Xoxo tomu is 25 years old u know? (Koreans age)

[@seventeenxoxo7971]

Lukman Sanusi i mean halfmember 😂😂 I'm forgot tomu was oldest

[@seventeenxoxo7971]

Nurul huda Linnas when you mention suddenly I'm remember 😂😂😂 it's okay i already edit.. Say half member

[@a_9498]

市川愛美は練習態度が悪すぎたし自分の実力不足を「最初からそうやっとけばこんなに大変じゃなかった」とか言って人のせいにする始末、あり得ないと思った ウンチェが泣きながらレッスン、勝たせてあげるから信じてととメンバーを励ましてステージが終わってもまた泣いて 勝つというよりもこのメンバーで！って気持ちが強いように見えてこっちも泣けたし高感度爆上がりした 奈子が驚異の330票(全体でダントツ一位、二位との差は100票以上)叩き出して負けてしまったけど、１組もすごく良かったと思う ワンクーもウンチェもいつか報われて欲しい

[@pinking4023]

うーん、自分がやりたくなかったのに押し付けられて、かつ次は怒られて変えて上手くいくっていう流れは誰でも辛いと思います。。

[@pinking4023]

@@oo.llgg. produce48のなかでもパートを変えられることはよくありますが、今回の件はよくありません。メインボーカル出来ない子が集まって仕方なくすることになって、最終的に怒られるって1つぐらい言い訳させてあげなよ...。しかもあの映像だけで一生懸命やってないとかどうやって判断したんですか...。

[@pinking4023]

@@oo.llgg. 練習態度が悪いのと、一生懸命頑張らないは別かと。

[@pinking4023]

@@oo.llgg. そうですか、申し訳ないですが、あの人が言い訳してると思われる場面を教えてください。本当に努力した、とは？さすがに失礼すぎますよ。あの環境で努力をしてない人をいてた、という心境が分かりません。

[@pinking4023]

@@oo.llgg. 今回の話し合いに努力してるかしてないをもってくること自体ナンセンスなんですよ。カンちゃんとこの子のこのひとつの例だけで努力したかを測ることは不可能です。かつ、カンちゃんの場合変われとか言われてません。自分を過信しすぎて裏目にでてる、それを確信的に裏付ける場面はどちらでしょうか。

[@belleramos18]

Wow I'm just so proud of the Japanese trainees 😭😭😭

[@KPOPTVsugar]

Yamada Noe is so cute😍

[@kaemincha]

I think this group did better. I was a bit bored watching the other group, but this group does a great job at bringing the energy and expressions.

[@debie91]

kaemincha maybe because most of them maintain their expressions and seems to enjoy it

[@caratsoups]

kaemincha now this is something i can agree with, but only the expressions part. the other group was much more clearer and better. but that’s my opinion.

[@huyennguyenthu8394]

yes, this group did better but other team have Yabuki Nako, so...😅

[@ianameivellon6219]

kaemincha Their vocals are cringey so I think the other team did better.

[@nukmanmuhammad4487]

kaemincha for the whole performance, I think the other team did better. But for facial expression this team win.

[@예다감사했습니다]

크어 중국인인데 발음 너무 한국인 같아서 한국인일줄

[@nisz2408]

This song would be so good for the main vocals i wonder why no one wanted this song. Anyways Wang Ke did so well i’m proud.

[@dnc7502]

they thought the choreo was hard as well as the vocals

[@melvin4797]

It's a terribly hard song. No need to be weighed down like that

[@nisz2408]

+Chua Yang yes i know it’s hard but there must be someone who can carry this song. There must be another yeonjung out there and this song could let her be noticed. Yabuki Nako’s rank is so going to rise.

[@cellpon3419]

I'm 19 You fight it was hard enough just watching the choreography, you wouldn't be able to sing properly.

[@delacruzjuan6972]

I'm 19 You fight me lets just say that all happens for a reason , 😁 The leaders shined for both team the main vocals also shined (team 1 for taking over the job and team 2 for hard carrying her team) but i agree how i wish a stable main vocal could sing it

[@dhimasdwykia6314]

I'm sad this team lose, 😥😩, i like this performance so much.

[@hiru836]

IMO nako voice much better and fit so well in this song

[@aprilberte7770]

i beg to disagree. although this performance was energetic (too energetic imo), the song doesn't suit them. I prefer Nako's version tho, fluffy and 'pure' which is probably the closest to the original. well we do have our own opinions hehe let's all support these girls! they worked hard💕💕

[@OrbitOnceAround]

After watching both performances few time again, I can’t help but like this one better.

[@aronlim3683]

Dhimas Dwyki A well.on average wise this team have higher score but nako saved her team...

[@dhimasdwykia6314]

Aron Lim yeah nako suddenly saved her team😊

[@superbluerock8327]

The other team were better in vocals ... But not by much. Dancing wise, this team were clearly better. Visually, both group are equal.

[@banbanhxinhdop]

after watching the full ep 3 engsub, I suprised that this team didn't have anyone as vocalist but they still did a good job

[@blancdespair7678]

Team 2 really owe it to nako , that chibiko is no joke.

[@marckiesan1484]

Took the words out of my mouth!! XD

[@AkaYuukii]

the fix the vocals for broadcast, apparently on stage it sounds worse

[@gisellemaldonado1022]

This was hard for me bc I liked both very much

[@ぴろん-s5t]

この曲は奈子で全てが決まった、伝説すぎる (未だに見てる)

[@gloriaetikatrifena4300]

Everytime I see Noe, I smile 😂

[@akhmadsadar]

mee too. I wanna see her more on screen. she has the brightest, biggest smile that captivate me

[@flufflife2425]

Gloria Etika Trifena Saaame

[@lesdryyurainygalvismeneses3583]

Gloria Etika Trifena me too👏❤😁

[@Tesh49]

She got the highest vote in her team.

[@flufflife2425]

curiousity How do u know how many votes they get?

[@tiredbylife.5589]

Tomu and Noe ❤❤❤❤😭

[@josh_berry]

I'm so happy they both passed the first round of elimination!

[@caco3_mel]

Noe is bully. Don't support her anymore

[@bbangbbang8503]

@kate_n she isn't bully

[@adrnjm2001]

wendy kosasih she is bully lol

[@ごみくずちゃんねる-t2n]

努力をして実力をあげてグループで力をあわせているじょせいのうつくしさったらないね。 日本はいくらなんでも実力が二の次すぎるんだよなー。

[@aya6511]

どっちも好きだけど 私はこっちのグループの方が全体的に見ていて楽しくなれる