PM Modi's SURGICAL STRIKE On Black Money: The Newshour Debate (8th Nov)

Watch Ravi Shankar Prasad Speak Exclusively On Demonetization ►bit.ly/2g1OAZR
On THE NEWSHOUR, Editor-in-Chief Arnab Goswami along with panelists Dr. Sudhanshu Trivedi, BJP, MR Venkatesh, CA and Policy Analyst, R Rajagopalan. Senior Journalist, Dr Ajay Alok, JDU, Atul Anjaan, CPI, Gaurav Bhatia, SP, discussed whether Prime Minister Narendra Modi has led the charge against corruption.
Subscribe to NewsHour Debate | Click Here ► goo.gl/LfNgFF
‘Download the official TIMES NOW mobile app - Give a missed call on 1800 4190 300. Stay updated, stay ahead.’
Subscribe Now To Our Network Channels
ET Now : goo.gl/5XreUq
Times Now : goo.gl/U9ibPb
To Stay Updated Download the Times Now App :-
Android Google Play : goo.gl/zJhWjC
Apple App Store : goo.gl/d7QBQZ
Social Media Links :-
Twitter - goo.gl/FzJIpz
Facebook - goo.gl/CC7rGc
G+ - goo.gl/O1iEp5
Also visit our website - goo.gl/XPUXe8

[@MrSinghhr]

Atul Anjan is so pissed what will he do with the crores of Black Money

[@mukeshpandya4171]

that bastard commie cpi is abusing that guy Tilak wala and Jata Dhari etc... fker is in India and abusing those symbols... bastards where cheering when china attacked India and published news papers that India is responsible for the war ... bastard party

[@BH-yl1ni]

+Mukesh Pandya Bro, Atul Anjan has lost control over his brain. Rather, he has gone in depression as he has not found solution to clean his black money staked in Rs.500/- and Rs.1000/- denomination. Now he will talk only stupid!

[@manoj9596]

My question to the dislikers of this debate.. You have Black money??????😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@shwetankvats3748]

grt one 😂😂😂

[@debasispanda1657]

ha ha ...bat kya bole beta tu

[@TonyStark-xu2nv]

Ｍ. ＭＡＨＡＪＡＮ jo business karte hai thoda bohat to unke pass hota he hai bhai.. u think the whole world is so honest? Will u take the responsibility of someone's family and future? Giving philosophies on internet is very easy and I am neither a modi hater nor sickular

[@mrcoolcool9224]

Ｍ. ＭＡＨＡＪＡＮ hai is it u in pic sooo nice

[@jayabratadas4873]

we are proud to have such a prime minister.

[@sahilkhurana4401]

Only u r proud. He s a scamster

[@varunpillai]

Modi Ji ..First Gutsy PM of India. Please be the PM of my country for at least a 20 years.

[@habijabi1430]

people who dislike this video either have a black money or have a black mind.

[@monajitmajumdar5891]

HERO(Arnab) IS BACK....ITS OUR SHOW

[@shreyamishra3685]

atul kumar ranjan sud not be called in such discussion.... wat rubbish he talks every time 😠 gawar sala 👊 arnab is d best ☺👍

[@dorshyadav4202]

Shreya Mishra hi

[@vick2380]

He is soooo Upset because of the HUGE amount of BLACK money in CASH , he is going to loose :p

[@harsh3355]

Shreya Mishra As his name suggests-he is completely anjaan from what is going on.totally incongruous.saale black money China se ab kaha se milega.Modi ne gala hi ghont diya chutiyon ka

[@Shobhu007]

atul kumar abe gadhe debate mtlb pta bhi h tjhe

[@abbujaan]

Shobhu Rajak hahaha well said

[@koushikshomchoudhury9108]

Shobhu Rajak 😹😹😹😹😹

[@mukeshpandya4171]

idiot hijacked the whole debate with nonsense talks.. bastard and his bastard party traitors

[@vaddurichandrika]

Gadhe ko definitely pata hoga. Yeh phir bhi commie hai.

[@bhartesh3344]

We indian will support our PM Shri.Narendra Modi

[@arnabsen8633]

Surgical strike for internal enemies. Jai hind. Modiji plz keep on. we all are with you.

[@mohammedghouse7655]

After being a CM..this is the first time modi has done a very good job..and i support for this..only

[@schneiderheathers833]

Bhai tu support kar ya mat kar, apne 500 aur 1000 key notes exchange karley bank jaake.

[@AnubhavSingh259]

Chutiye he is PM not CM

[@sahilkhatreja1168]

Anubhav Singh HAHAHAHA😂😂😂

[@abbujaan]

long live Modi ji we want Modi ji for at least another 20yrs.

[@ptrivedi369]

First GST, then .surgical strike.. Then ..black money.. Now please take some steps on RESERVATION... NOT EVERY GENERAL PEOPLE ARE RICH.. NOT EVERY ST/OBC PEOPLE ARE POOR... this is also a topic which needs to be discussed. Being a student o general category I request times now channel and Arnab sir to conduct a discussion on the reservation system in India. #reservationsystemsucks

[@yashwanthravula9867]

I belong to OBC ,but I support this. Reservation should be done based on the family income and not based upon the caste.

[@abbujaan]

Priyansh Trivedi very good point

[@abbujaan]

You reap what you sow reservation should be on economical grounds and not on caste base

[@abbujaan]

You reap what you sow What do you think about mayawati and alike?

[@abbujaan]

You reap what you sow And what do you think about those how are upper caste who are capable but poor who really deserve the support?

[@nishantnayak3792]

I have mentioned it before and I will do it again Sri Narendra Modi is the greatest prime minister in the history of India. 💪

[@Amitkumar-np3oy]

atul Kumar anjan literally crying

[@sambitsubhas]

keep it on arnab sir.we all Indians are with you.YOU ARE real GAME CHANGER in journalism...

[@swapnilghoshal1852]

mr anjaan is anjaan to reality!

[@aamodkumar3790]

great step by modi....!!

[@veersinghsisodiya6352]

Viral videos

[@ramshalla664]

great step for big boss

[@munitjsr2]

i never liked modi and BJP...but i was so wrong. He and BJP are doing good great job for the country and people. I never liked arnab as well but i support him now....these people dont listen if you say them anything politely

[@djrdjr1096]

U were right before, but not now bro......

[@munitjsr2]

what happened now according to yu

[@ffu100]

If because of ban on 500 and 1000 rupees note...m in trouble ...not able to eat or spend and need to sleep in footpath for 2 days ..i am ready for that....this is responsibility of every citizen of India...they may face problems for next 1 month but need to pass this for future of this country

[@DaSnipy]

OR, you could just go to a bank, or post office and deposit your 500 and 1000 rs notes and get cash or i am sure you must be having a debit card ..... so no you dont have to be in trouble .. also, if you dont have an account, just go to any bank with your ration card, licence or such and open a 0 balance JAN DHAN account .. EVERYTHING HAS BEEN PROVIDED BY THE MOTHERLAND THROUGH THE DECISIONS OF GREAT LEADER NAMO ALREADY ... AND BROTHER THESE FACILITIES ARE YOUR RIGHT .. USE THEM .. JAI HIND.

[@jainhardik11]

Brother I might don't know you personally But I have huge respect for you.

[@ffu100]

Ty hardik

[@rabindrakejriwal1364]

Surjewala congress point is just laughable. Now you are talking of farmers, Common people,garib aadmi but please note that these people don't keep 500/1000 rs notes like youe masters who keep it in plane loads.

[@alphazero5653]

I don't think farmers will have problems.. garib se garib farmers ka bhi bank account hai.. they mostly deal in 100s

[@muralikrishna-mf1oh]

Agnostic awesome bro I like your comment😂

[@OlahuUber_29]

Now i am confused . i dont know who is more nervous idiot on debates ? Atul Anjaan of CPI or Ashutosh from AAP ?

[@shawshank7263]

Great Decision. Its not appeasement politics. Its a strict and swift decision that is taken for benefit of this nation as a whole. People in opposition and some industrialists will still cry foul as their stocked in cash Black money is going to be worthless now.

[@ppuruu]

Arnab Sir ... May I meet u ... I m fan of ur Attitude...

[@dr.agupta]

211 Likes vs 2 Dislikes - speaks for itself! I have no bounds of happiness to hear Arnab Goswami debate this, one of the greatest leaps taken by my Prime Minister!!

[@shuklaswadha5375]

Atul anjan ki shakl se hi pata chal raha ki uski kitni phati padi hai....Y is he nt discussing the actual point n making such personal comments ??

[@jaryalable]

Atul anjan knows if he critices the BAN, he will have his ass kicked (metaphoricaly) so hard by most of the other panelists that he will bleed from his mouth and start peeing through his ears. SO, he choses to cause distraction by trying to make personal comments about Arnab. It just goes to show he has a sick mind. What else can you expect from a commie?

[@sonumor007]

excellent step by govt to curb on corruption and terror financing, hats off to govt but one question why to introduce 2000 denomination note ,is it another loophole ?

[@arundiptadebnath8508]

it has no gps technology just google it

[@ppatel75]

He is not going to pump 2000 rs note and monitor it. Rightnow our economy is not such that we can discontinue big bills but new bills will be very difficult to counterfeit

[@ppatel75]

but it was easy to counterfeit. and i would not help to bring domestic black money back because we have to continue old 500 and 1000 rs bills too

[@sonumor007]

shripad krishna-..as u rightly mentioned above 2000rs note help in easy high value transaction with lesser no of notes..ur not thinking in other way its also easy to give 1 bag full of rs 2000 note instead of 3-4 bags for bribe...or keeping the large amount of money as black money with denomination of note 2000

[@arundiptadebnath8508]

pushpender mor sry there is no nano technology it was just an myth

[@anamika7107]

Now Modi has done something which proves that he doesn't care how much black money politicians of his own party have and how will they cope up with the upcoming elections! he is a true patriot....and iam proud of having him as a PM.

[@rebel8037]

champ is here.....this is my show :D

[@deepakkumarpradhan9177]

First time in history of India poor & common man is laughing and NETAS are CRYING....

[@mrs.alissa9039]

congress ki fati padi hai....

[@veersinghsisodiya6352]

Jaysan marsh U nailed it..!!

[@dobbyisfree1126]

why hasn't anyone done this before...? what was the need... ?? when people like Atul Anjaan and congress decide we will loot the people together and accumulate wealth...and eat it together... everybody will be happy and benefited... Gehun and Rabi you people really dont give a shit about farmers... its more like if you had some time before the decision of banning the currency maybe you could have saved more money... and you're pissed about it...

[@bharatindian6633]

Hey Ram! Congressi ki sattar saal ki mehnat ko Modiji ne ek minute mein mitti mein milaye diyo....

[@BH-yl1ni]

+Bharat Indian Well said. I fully agree. Now Rahul Gandhi can claim: Chaiwala ko sirf choti note hi pasand hai, woh badi note ka soch hi nahi sakta!

[@bharatindian6633]

Bhawana But, Rahulji also raised valid point... What is the need for 2000 rupee note? How will it help in discouraging black money again?

[@radhatripathi]

Debate is not about y arnab leaving times now, Atul Kumar Anjan irritating character. Sad to know we have such politicians

[@Vishaluniyal12345]

ये तो बस शुरुवात है भाइयो कही ऐसा ना हो के कल हम सुबह नींद से उठे और हमें पता चले की...... . . . . . . . . . पाकिस्तान अब नहीं रहा 😂😂😝😝 #Modiyug 😘🇮

[@s.dilipkumarsingha6494]

The corruption level in India has reached its climax. Modi Govt took the right decision. Few days pains and troubles are to be borne for strengthening the nation further. We all are with the Govt's decision.

[@manoharprasad4418]

#arnab he is the best reporter in indian journalism.. proud of him.. he should be reporter till the end.

[@bhartesh3344]

We are proud of Prime Minister of India Shri.Narendra Modi.

[@syedazher7106]

what the hell... datz his wish whether he want to continue or not...arnab sir plz continue doing your work......

[@kimjongun918]

All is appreciated. But the biggest fishes have black money stacked abroad in terms of stocks, real estate as well as other assets. We are getting our house in order with this step but it is just a small tip of the iceberg. Billions of dollars are still in Swiss banks. Hope that is traced too.... Although it's incredibly hard.

[@karnam7444]

Arre Dictator sahab just chill. Everything has a beginning. Rome was not built in a day.

[@djrdjr1096]

I appreciate the move,...still have 28 lakh crore black money in foreign banks. .......

[@alphazero5653]

i guess not more than 1% of black money is held in cash..

[@rashmikolluru]

Rishank Devadiga yes but that black money in cash is helping inflate real estate prices and I think govt should follow market rate for registration of properties. let's not have that concept of having one market rate and a different govt rate. Which contributes to black money and corruption. also every dept including income tax excise transport should have target oriented jobs like there many culprits in this category etc. because yesterday Delhi police could only find 500 unfit vehicles in Delhi roads. Which is insane. id suspect every 1 in 4 to be without pollution compliant.

[@alphazero5653]

I'm not saying that this move is useless.. my concern is regarding the big fishes like sharad pawar, gandhis etc. They'd have stashed black money in real estate, foreign exchange, etc.

[@phoenix-yx7xd]

Rishank Devadiga it is a small step towards curbing black money. I'm sure our PM has given thought to all the black money in real estates. all will be done in due time

[@alphazero5653]

so if it's a small move.. then why calling it gamechanger, politicians ki lagg gayi, sharad pawar sabse garib admi..

[@dollysahu2438]

arnab you are superb

[@Pramodk1010]

Dolly Sahu chutiya hai arnab

[@busybusiness9121]

We support Modi.

[@petermoore5750]

Arnab you are doing a great job. These Congress and others who are against Modiji have to be so hateful that they will sacrifice the safety of the nation for their own selfish reasons.

[@deepeshbl3861]

one of best debate proud of our modi

[@vemalarajuraju6639]

Arnab sir you are the person with full of courage I appreciate you keep on going I pray God to bless you all the way

[@armstrongMHA]

great steps awesome... but what will happen for those people who doesn't have even a single bank account like local sabji wala, chai wala and small vendors..

[@swatibora7605]

jhandhan isliyai aaya tha

[@armstrongMHA]

I am sorry my friend I can not understand that the word jhandhan, can you please help me out in english.. please don't mind

[@sonumor007]

the planning for this change had already took place in 2014 through PMJDY in which bank accounts are open even with zero balance...still if some section left behind they can also open now its nt too late...yeah it may be causing little inconvenience for some tym bt for national interest its very gud step..

[@swatibora7605]

JhanDHAN account

[@bipul100100]

Ksh Armstrong They can open account anytime.

[@Amuuuuuuuuuuuu]

arnab is back. WELCOME BACK

[@jayeshjangid6307]

as always Arnab... You rocks

[@rohitrevi]

Who is watching this in 2018, not knowing whether to laugh or cry?

[@muzikbucket3873]

best decision taken by government ....i am from middle class family ....i pay tax ....i have no black money .....and i am very very happy ....haa haa haa ......aaj garib hus rahe hain aur corrupt log ko heart attack aa chuka hai.....india ke neta log jo note bhar ke rakhe hain unka "maa kaa naa kaa" kar diya modiji ne......modi jindabaad....jai hind

[@reviewmaster4586]

Send Atul Kumar Anjaan in Big Boss.. he will be a great contestant

[@Rohan-yz3mp]

This time I say this is bravest move by an Indian Govt in its fight against corruption.Kudos to the PM Modi and to the Indian Government fr this bold move ! Other political parties may come up with some 'rubbish' arguments to mislead us all.We should not fall in it.We should have zero tolerance fr corruption. The thing is that India had a problem and the Govt did the surgery(This move) it will have little implications but will slowly heal and makes way for a Better India #IndiaFightsCorruption

[@rajinderprabhakar518]

Sky has not fallen Why hue and cry of this bold step of PM MODI POLITICIANS should stop worrying about common men.

[@sushantkumar7592]

We are proud of Modi and Arnab as well.

[@Learnsomethingnew3456]

hero is back

[@krishnamurthy1992]

Great and hard decision which will pull most of an idle money from hidden areas.

[@14mukunda]

Krishna Murthy

[@14mukunda]

Krishna Murthy

[@Sikhi277]

Brave as always ...Arnab ..respect and what a great decision by Modi Sir

[@348vicky]

अतुल को सदमा लगा है, लगता है बहुत कला धन है, भगवन इस मुश्किल घड़ी में इसे विवेक दे।

[@sandipacharya.trippy]

what else we expect from congress??

[@karthik.marx777]

Master stroke by the maestro himself... all hail NAMO..

[@priyaranjansingh8944]

I stoped watching times now debate last 5 days when i came to know that you are leaving. Good to see you Arnab.....

[@madhumitamukerje5682]

★ Anjan... Thume jane pahchane lagta ho.. Ha-Ha !!! Jalwa ho rahi hai inko bhaiya ★ No matter what our beloved Narenda Modi does its always a bone of contention with these people. .. isn't it laughable. . Arnab have exposed a nerve for Atul ..that is why he is mad.. Wonderful Arnab dear. ... ★ Modiji amar rahe ☆

[@veersinghsisodiya6352]

Madhumita Mukerje 👏👏👏👌

[@rahulannarayan]

Arnab have exposed a nerve for Atul ..that is why he is mad..it is otherway round

[@bhushanambavane9013]

ur sounds sweet and lovely dear

[@Learnsomethingnew3456]

newshour wapsi...feeling goood

[@self535]

Any one watching on 2019 ?

[@sureshsoni9826]

Brave step ,Red salute to our prime minister , go ahead the Aam admi with u

[@dvnikte]

Superb debate Arnab......BALLS OF STEEL.....Salute !!!

[@bikanerplasterindustries8555]

i really very happy from modi ji desision which help india to become free from corruption

[@boogum7996]

"Lekin Rahul Gandhi koh mahine mein 20 hazar se jada rupiyo ki zaroorat kyon Hai""😂😂😂

[@kshitijdeshpande3205]

People are forgetting the equally perhaps more important issue of inflation.

[@TheHarharmahadev]

Anjaan ji ka kitna 500 -1000 rs chala gaya hai u can just see in his arguments. Hahahaha

[@dobbyisfree1126]

Maybe Atul Anjaan has lump sum hard cash which he's gonna lose after this... slave to system now if there is change criticize it.... lol fought corruption when?? you he was part of all the scams did by congress ministers... now he is threatening an anchor showing what shit is is made of on entire national television... These are the real faces that hinder the progress of the country... Shame

[@dobbyisfree1126]

why hasn't anyone done this before...? what was the need... ?? when people like Atul Anjaan and congress decide we will loot the people together and accumulate wealth...and eat it together... everybody will be happy and benefited... Gehun and Rabi you people really dont give a shit about farmers... its more like if you had some time before the decision of banning the currency maybe you could have saved more money... and you're pissed about it...

[@kaustubhratan4655]

GM

[@sachidanandapadhi6764]

Arnab'll continue his journalism carrear to screw the politicians like anjan. Arnab plz continue good work like this.

[@aspirant7907]

CA log crorepati banne wale hai,if you know what I mean.

[@maddyx3711]

Dear Lord.... How the hell did these goons become successful "Politicians" is beyond me! Pray for our mother nation guys

[@shri6323]

Arnab how do you tolerate these negative people !!!

[@GauravMauryastar007]

black money walo ko raat bhar neend nhe aa rhi hai ..... :):):)

[@GauravMauryastar007]

ha ha

[@umeshxzs]

Sahi mein.

[@jitendrabhosale3400]

gaand fat gayee black money walo ki jyada karke congress ki

[@ashishsinghparihar8491]

proud to have a pm like this salute you sir #pmmodi

[@veersinghsisodiya6352]

Ashish singh parihar

[@sanjaymeriya5224]

a great action by our PM Modi. Salute you Modi Ji. VANDE MATRAM

[@bavi5409]

Arnab u r the best News Anchor i watch times now only because of you.... plz dnt resign.......... You really inspired me always

[@TVSCDN]

Arnab the country wants to know even after the Hon'ble Modiji's Surgical Strike on BLACK MONEY your HAIR is STILL SO VERY BILAK? What is the STORY of your BILAK...err.. HAIR making U look soooo Young even at 60???

[@abipat2138]

Congress cannot create panic.. they are in panic

[@ViNEETGamingz]

we love you arnab sir.... thnku! for come back on time now! ab daily apka debate main dekh skta hun...

[@deewakardubey4298]

we have proud for anchor like you Bhai .

[@shiyari8800]

I m happy modi..good work modiji..

[@TheManasmita]

Mr. Anja, don't be "ANJAN" and warm up your ignorant mind!!! Your party is at stake as it is been led by a PAPPU...

[@dineshangirus2480]

very good move by our PM Modi g..it shows Prime Minister's intention about Bharat

[@apbadman]

i think we were talking about 120 crore indians and the fight against curroption ,and not about 1 person and his resignation letter.

[@prabhatjha6849]

atul anjaan apna mansik santolan kho baithe

[@jaryalable]

Prabhat ji, kuch khone se pehle aap ke pas uska hona zaroori hota hei. Atul Kumar Anjan ki bato se to mehsus hota hei ki inke pas mansik santulan to kabhi tha hi nahi. I will go even further by saying that his brain itself seems to be defective. Arnab should not invite idiots like Anjan, Rajiv Desai, Sanjay Jha et al to debate on subjects of national importance. Kudos to P.M.Modi ji and his team to have worked tirelessly to put into place all other measures in place to support and complement this move. Brilliant work.

[@prabhatjha6849]

Sahi bole.

[@DrJG9]

It does get tiresome hearing clowns and morons, liers and goons, but then perhaps those they represent have no alternative options? Which exposes the organisation that sends them!

[@shatrughnasingh5778]

please do some #Yoga# Mr. Anjan

[@jaryalable]

Anjan should go to the loo and have a crap immediately before participating in any debate. It will take the pressure off his brain and he may then be able to think what to say. All this crap pushing against his brain makes him talk shit most of the time.

[@laksh096]

Rajdeep Sirdesai ko 2000 ki note nahi milegi, 2002 ki milegi. 😂😂😂

[@murgadanand]

Arbna ur real hero for me because u no how to handle this politicians pls don't stop ur job keep going we are with u

[@hiiloveindia]

JAIL KHOLDO KOI BHAGNE KE LIYE TAIYAAR NAHI HAI...TIJORI KHOL DO KOI LUTNE KE LIYE TAIYAAR NAHI HAI....ACCHE DIN AA RAHA HAI BHAI.... WAIT AND WATCH....Jai Hind Bharat Mata ki Jai...😃😂😎😇

[@anuj11singh]

Nice Arnab Goswami

[@prakashjan15]

Mr.Modi, you don't need support from such politician ,till public support you.

[@roysmith5711]

1. Don't know why Mr. Anjan is brought into these debates. He has nothing to offer except personal attacks and pandering. 2. Arnab does not like criticism. 3. People always have choices, what a fascist thing to say that you have no choice but to agree. 4. Things should be analyzed ALWAYS. Don't criticize someone cause he is trying to analyze. Commentary on the topic: I love the decision and I think most common people would be happy about this decision. I would like to point out that this government should also make political party donations tax liable to fight corruption.

[@Ravikumarpinninti]

well done modi ji ..

[@sanjayrakshit8797]

I thought Arnab had retired

[@hrishikesh07m]

Sanjay Rakshit he only resigned as editor in chief

[@prashantyaragatti9530]

he is behind global news...

[@JagtarSinghRana475]

arnab is a great journalist and we all love his courage to ask question

[@damusscone4373]

atul kumar made me laugh every time he spoke. Really guys that is fun to watch . I recommend every one to watch this.

[@kushagra782]

Mr anjan is anjan of politics and black money

[@sandeepg1375]

love u arnab ,every second congress is crying.

[@hariomjadon1746]

I had been supporting SP fr no reason and PM modi ji gave me the reasons to follow Modi govt. and answered why...??to follow their party.. in his style.👍👍

[@gangadharanpazhangode3053]

It is a very bold decision.