ULTIMATE 40oz Cup Comparison

There are so many great options besides just the Stanley for your 40 OZ. cup with a handle and I am sharing my favorites with you today! Which cup would you choose?!
Shop 40 oz Tumblers:
Stanley 2.0: amzn.to/3zTkbam
Owala: www.target.com/p/owala-40oz-s...
Reduce: www.target.com/p/reduce-40oz-...
Hydrapeak: www.target.com/p/hydrapeak-vo...
Simple Modern: www.simplemodern.com/collecti...
Other Discount Codes and Affiliate Links:
linktr.ee/poppinsapproved
Follow me: / poppinsapproved
Contact for Collabs: [e-mail]

[@jessiebrooks6011]

The simple modern is the best! I have the cream leopard and love it! The lid has 1/4 turn technology so you can put the straw in 4 different positions. 😀

[@nomo1479]

Definitely sticking with simply modern, affordability, all companents dishwasher safe, sleek and cute, leak resistant but most importantly LEAD free (Stanley tests positive for lead).

[@patiencewright3591]

Thank you! Finally a video that answers all my questions!!!

[@mrslminns]

ThankYou for doing this featuring all the cups ❤

[@eponine318]

Love this! You do such good reviews.

[@julie2530]

Watched your review as I was on the fence about Owala vs. Simple Modern. Thank you! I got a Simple Modern!❤

[@Umbrellatoo]

Thank you for the review! Very helpful.

[@Razan3bdullah]

I love how your cups matches every color in your room

[@lisetteyareli]

I literally have 2 simple modern cups in my cart. Now I’m going to check out lol 😂 Thanks for this!

[@sarah607chang]

I love simple modern cups the Disney one are so cute and they have kids tumblers with the rubber straws that does not come out

[@lauriefowler836]

I prefer Simple Modern. I have three now. They have so many pretty colors. One thing that you didn’t mention is the weight of the tumbler. The Simple Modern is lighter than the Stanley. Idk about the other brands. Very good review!

[@susanabushaban2719]

When you have the straw in the simple modern I assume it will leak or am I wrong

[@JoseOnTheAir]

I bought a Simple Modern after hearing my boss's struggles with her Stanley and it's really a great tumbler! I did get some stainless steel straws as well, and debating if I'm going to get an Owala to supplement/rotate with my SM since I typically leave my tumbler at work unless I'm planning travel or a long time out of office

[@maryanderson2507]

Thank you for the reviews! I bought the jumbo (maybe 60oz) Reduce at a thrift store for $5.00! It has the same lid as the 40oz one you have there. I use it every day and have really love it, but I am now looking for one that fits in my car drink holder. The only thing I noticed with the Reduce, is that the little grey rubber stopper that seals the chug hole, got some mold spots on it that not even bleach would remove. I only use it for water with Zip Fizz, or Celsius in it. 😊

[@shannondennis9]

Great review! Thank you!

[@mxandrew]

I love the simple modern and I’m honestly impressed with how light the 50oz one feels when filled with water. I just bought the light green “sandy seas” color they just released

[@Jacqxoxo]

I have Stanley’s and simply Moderns and I just love my simply moderns . They look so clean and sleek .

[@RaqReviews]

Ooh I love the simple modern thanks ❤

[@trishr.3986]

I started out with GreensSteel, $40 for a 40 ounce. They have specials quite often, though. They come with no handle, but you can purchase a handle that slips onto the tumbler. The issue I have with the handle is it bumps into my vehicle cup holder. I recently purchased a Stanley v. 2 H2.0. The handle does not interfere with the cup holder. The Stanley has a narrower base as well as being a taller, more slender profile. I have a Reduced tumbler, too. The base of that is wide profile like GreensSteel. All in all, I think if your biggest concern is spilling you should purchase with that in mind as priorities. Otherwise, go for what appeals to you. I will say also that GreensSteel has kept my water cold even with Arizona heat, while in my car all day and overnight. They also include two stainless steel straws (one straight, one bent) and brushes for cleaning the straws. Many colors. Sold online only.

[@user-hq1zh4cq6m]

Thank you! Your review was very helpful. I was debating between the Owala and the Simple Modern. They both have better reviews than Stanley. I think I might go with the Simple Modern now. The hand washing might be a deal-breaker. Thanks!

[@yvettemontez9209]

I have 2 Stanley old version and new. definitely love the new version better because it does spill less. I just bought SM 40z and I love! I think its sleek feature is what wins it for me

[@yvettebarnett5085]

Awesome review thanks

[@stephaniesenrud2192]

I have been shopping around for cups similar to Stanley and the Simple Modern cup was the one I chose. I love it and it is definitely affordable and in my opinion, better than Stanley.

[@Lynnnduhh]

The Hydropeak is amazing! I love mine!!!

[@kazooboo2431]

Great and informative video 🥰

[@shayzoo2]

The simple modern is my favorite. I love the look and the way you can easily have the straw point in any direction because of the 1/4 turn lid. I think completely upside down is not the best way to test for spills. That’s not usually how your cup falls over and it creates a vacuum after a bit. On its side is a much better spill test. Also, having the straw in is a more life-like test. How often are you carrying it around without the straw in? Thanks for the comparison test. I was thinking of getting an owalla but I didn’t realize it was hand wash only. My kids are likely to accidentally put it in the dishwasher. That’s too much money to ruin because it got washed incorrectly.

[@nicolebauer766]

I wish you would have done the leak test with the straws in as well, I think most people would have the straws in at all times when the cup would accidentally be knocked over

[@Astrologynchill]

Thank you so much for this review, I was going to get a Stanley but I don’t like that it leaks. Will most likely get the SM in black.

[@candisehb]

Ive had the hudrapeak for a while it really is the best. The open handle is soo convient. I use it in my airport bag, on airpot seats, on my trendmill. on my shopping cart. I love it and for 19.99 at TJ Maxx

[@fstacy85]

Simple Modern'a trek is the best! I got rid of my Hydrapeak voyagers for them. SM ice lasts way longer. Hydrapeak's open handle gets stuck on things, gets tangled up when I put it in a bag. The SM is more slim and fits right in my bag and I don't ever have any leaks, even when hiking

[@rebekahramirez9041]

Great review!

[@aszxmoon2459]

Thank you for the through review ❤

[@jimbuckley4986]

Great review.

[@robinmartin5788]

Love my Owala!

[@NightSyndicate]

lovely video, ty!

[@kustompainter7754]

I’m going to buy a few to Kustom paint them.. Thanks for the video nice job…

[@Teeyah2]

I just bought the Hydrapeak Voyager yesterday at Marshall's for $16.99. I haven't used it yet. Gonna look into your favorite before making up my mind. Thanks for review 😊

[@ridonculously]

I’m obsessed with hydrapeak as a brand. The voyager isn’t my favorite style but it keeps my water cold, is easy to drink from and helps me stay hydrated. I had originally gotten mine full price at tjmaxx amd lost it at a Trader Joe’s. I decided not to get another one because I had other bottles I really liked (the 32oz hydrapeak is my favorite). I found a damaged voyager on sale for $6 and snapped it up. I was quickly reminded why I liked it so much. Very satisfied with it

[@princess3193]

@Teeyah2 what did you end up going with? Did you keep the Hydrapeak?

[@AngelSGG]

same, at marshals for 16.99 too

[@eileenabacusbengalsbutler-6923]

A handle which lights up is also available called Zebo. I find this handy at night and in my vehicles for tumblers that need a handle. It even comes with an insert sleeve for thinner cups. We love them.❤❤

[@cancer_journey]

Where did you get it. I goggled and didn't find any?

[@kiiteecali]

I love my Reduce but just bought a beautiful Owala tumbler since I love the quality of my other Owala Freesips (they keep my drinks cold FOREVER).

[@Jennifer-sj6in]

Good video! Thanks

[@pamelaoboli6076]

My favourite is orchid, if I was winning or buying one that would be the best to get ❤

[@bgrizzly]

Watched all your reviews. Would you go with the Brumate or simple modern 40oz?

[@HE4RTS4EM1LY]

my friend has a stanley and i really like it so i ordered one it comes in 2 weeks 😊

[@Phlegethon]

Spill test is really well done it means these are really meant for drivers or going to class / the office not really for hiking

[@KourttneyL]

I don’t have issues with spilling my water bottles, so I’m just gonna get the SM, owala and use them with my Stanley’s lol

[@candiceheath2482]

I've loved the Rtic cups...ice stays forever!!

[@tamikaparks6783]

I love my hydropeak I found a purple blinged out tumbler at TJ Maxx for under $20.

[@Anaya_Surage]

I just brought the 30oz mutnitt cup I have not tried it yet very exited though

[@doreenc3223]

Love my simple modern..the best

[@mitchellness9920]

the owala is designed for left hand and right hand people that want to use the sip option. for right start the sip side on the top and tighten for left start the sip side on the bottom and tighten . well engineered also the grip on the straw is not to prevent it from coming out but whatever

[@reallyluckygirl1]

Great reviews. I just wished the Owala was dishwasher safe. I’ll stick to Stanley for now.

[@suzannekliewer223]

Great review. I have most of these except for Simple Modern… May have to try it. I do love my Brumate mugs as well because they do not leak. I have the Toddy 32 oz and 16oz. Brumate just came out with a 40 oz tumbler. Has anyone here tried it? That would be a great one to review as well.

[@eileenabacusbengalsbutler-6923]

My don and I have used stainless steel Hydra Peak which is BPA free for 6 years. Great video wish you mentioned BPA free or Polyethylene free. Neither are biodegradable or reusable like stainless steel.❤❤❤❤

[@liatyacob1344]

I have a reduce tumbler and if you take out the straw a close it it doesn’t spill completely

[@Mary_fff]

I got a Hudson tumbler it's pretty good I did not want to get an more expensive one so I went with the 40 OZ 1.2 L it does me good so far just got it 2 week's ago...

[@allycanuck]

Thanks! Have you tried the Corkcicle Cruiser 40 oz which has non-slip rubber insert on the bottom to keep it from toppling over!

[@adamchambers1906]

What’s nuts is that Stanley makes the leak proof feature basically only if it’s fully flipped over. On its side it leaks like a sieve. With the straw it’s even worse.

[@adamalford5650]

I have a few from Temu. I’ve had water bottles from simple modern that were great though.

[@melissapetzer3560]

I got one on shein to see first if id actually use it and then im def getting the simple modern!

[@margaretthacker7964]

Have you done a spill test with the straws in the lid? I’m curious if they’d still all hold up

[@AngelaCovacs]

Great review, thank you. I usually use Hydroflask bottles because I love the design on those and I personally love Klean Kanteen's tumbler with straw, it holds the ice so well. But was thinking of buying one with a handle but didn't want to jump in the Stanley train, I want something different and Simple Modern might be the best one for me.

[@PoppinsApproved]

I found a new one called Hydrojug! It’s my favorite!

[@AngelaCovacs]

I just saw you have another video, I will watch that one. Thank you!

[@angelt103]

I’m curious to know which one keeps the water coldest the longest?

[@Vjl246]

Great video. RTIC just came out with one. Their marketing video shows some features that make it look like a real contender, but I can’t find any videos on KZbin.

[@minnesotasteve9382]

Nice video! Chapters would be cool too.

[@AquaLew]

I love my Owala 40oz FreeSip❤

[@stephanierice4468]

Simple Modern is my favorite 💖

[@GaneshKumar01]

Can you do a spill test with the straws on?

[@vitabrennan4909]

Did you or can you do a spill test with the straws in?

[@sarinadasilva3880]

I wish you did spill test with the straw in

[@stephylouise]

Takeya cups are my jam!!!

[@jessicamilone3355]

Can you do the new hydro flask 40 oz with handle

[@ahnaleejohnson3485]

Hi , Could you & Hello Happy Mom do a review of RTIC Road Trip tumblers (30oz & 40oz)?

[@nikkiV2120]

How do they fit into the cup holder in the car

[@1mama402]

I almost bought a Hydroflask today but held off till I could browse Amazon, so glad to come across this video it’s very helpful. I had seen the SM one before and worried it would be cheap feeling but obviously not. Would of loved a weight comparison in this video.

[@candisehb]

hydroflask is different than hydrapeak

[@LucidBunnyTarot]

The hydro peak I purchased at tj max and after 1 week using it , the lid gets stuck and it imposible to open !!

[@BlackAndBold]

Thanx for the review! Did I miss the part whether the Simple Modern can be put in the dishwasher. I have one in my cart right now 😅

[@nellj3421]

It shows hand wash only

[@OfficiallyEvita]

It’s dishwasher safe

[@tomwesley978]

Been going back and forth between simple modern and stanley. I ended up going with simple modern

[@comfycozycrochetwithtris1188]

Have you tried the brand Swig?! I see nothing on KZbin about this brand

[@lindaduty6865]

The Reduce can be used with a straw, to sip, and chug. The lid has three settings.

[@DrMarvinLara]

I got the Hydrapeak for only $20. Canadian!

[@kkilgore_23]

I had a hydrapeak bottle I had spillage with it and also I accidentally left creatine in mine and it absolutely ruined my cup causing the straw part to come out

[@tinacummings9169]

Have you trued the BruMate? Im a travel mug junkie and they have a leakproof straw and ice seems to hold out the longest from the ones I have.

[@PoppinsApproved]

Yes! In my newest water bottle video I tried BrüMate and it’s awesome

[@LilacHillaman]

Owala !! Baby

[@darlisa23]

I am just wondering if every different color Stanley can be dishwasher safe

[@perseverates]

Is your Simple Modern Sea Glass or Retro Mint colour?

[@PoppinsApproved]

sea glass:)

[@SpaceWolf21]

It's not ultimate until you have meoky in there

[@tsunami888]

The cups don’t drip because there is a vacuum effect. This effect while preventing drips might make sipping out of it difficult because air has to go back in before you can sip more.

[@andy_2221]

No matter how you screw on the lid for simple modern, the straw position ends up the same. That’s how screws work….

[@mokkamellb6811]

i saw reduce at superstore, seems cheap to me. the straw kept moving around.

[@9mmfederalrimmed235]

These all hold equally cold and hot regardless of the brand. Clearly the Ozark Trail and the Stanley H2O quencher aremade in the same factory in China. So no real difference. I did notknow Walmart did the same cup now as well. I may order some in dark blue although I would prefer them in unpainted stainless. The handles seem identical on both being screwed on plastic handles on some stainless supports which are welded to the cup. Biggest negative is the on both the drinking hole can be just on one position at 90 degreesto the handle. I need the drinking jole at the 180 degree position like on an water pitcher. This issue is caused by the screw on lid. The threads allow just for one position which is an huge negative.

[@J_Cai98]

There's two different Hydrapeak tumblers, the 40 oz Voyager and the 40 oz Roadster

[@MikeTrieu]

Eh, I don't like how you did the ice test. Nobody just puts ice into these things in real life. Why didn't you just stick a thermal probe into an equal amount of ice water in each cup? That would have been a much better comparison methodology. See Project Farm for how to do this test right.

[@RAD6150]

I do... I am disabled and just fill my cup with ice and drink it as it melts.

[@mr.e5286]

hydraflow is the best brand

[@houseoflearninghomeschool]

I don’t think the reduce cup fit in my car or any other cup holder I have

[@lindaduty6865]

The Reduce doesn’t fit in all cup holders.

[@sarah607chang]

The owala straw you put it in the wrong way that’s not a stopper it’s meant for it to be in the top all the pic shows it from the top

[@user-px8re6gg3x]

It's not ultimate until you put the tal cup in

[@rommelrodriguez6883]

Es interesante ver como una chica tan hermosa tiene un lenguaje sublime dentro de su habitación cuando sostiene VARIOS VASOS DE GRAN TAMAÑO EN SU MANO... 😏 Por Cierto 🤍tengo un🐻‍❄️Artic🤍 Twilight de 30Oz y me va super genial, todas las bebidas las he disfrutado en 4 horas... No entiendo para que guardar por mas de 8/12 horas las bebida, el ser humano debe hidratarse al menos cada 2 horas y poder recargar el vaso si estas de viaje

[@JStyne]

S|m is better, I have so many different cup,mugs and tumblers from them

[@geektarded]

Any reason that you left out the yeti 42 oz rambler with handle? They are smaller and less bulky than the stanley 40 oz but hold more.

[@masterfox3539]

Those are ugly

[@isabellvelasquez4915]

I just bought the Simple Modern and its beauuuutiful, but if I have the straw in it the ice would stay for a long time? Or it’s just when it’s close and without the straw?🫣🫣