🤔 Por que o Present Perfect é tão difícil de entender❓

[@luizdomingosbavellonijunio4697]

Hello teacher Ulisses, I"ve watched your videos for 2 years and I enjoy it a lot. I've been improving my skills with your tips. Thanks a lot and God bless you.

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

I'm glad to hear you find the videos helpful. Thank you! Take care

[@TheAnacas]

Good tips! Tks. 🙂

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Thank you! 😊

[@ludemilafelixdossantos5347]

I've worked in São Paulo for 10 years... Thanks.....

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Great! Thanks for commenting. Take care

[@claudioroberto3171]

I have seen your videos for 6 months, and I like it.

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

I'm glad to hear you like them. See you later

[@discipuladoprofetico]

Tkx very much!

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

My pleasure! See you later

[@juriscon8630]

Parabéns, Ulisses. Qualidade a toda prova, como é usual.

[@maramiranda2506]

I have been learned a lot with you. Thanks.

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

I'm glad to hear that you have learned a lot. Take care

[@catatalsempena5727]

I have been learning English for about 3 months. I am from Brasil, but I have been living in Portugal for about 12 years. Thanks teacher. I love this channel!

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Thanks for taking the time to write. Take care

[@analuciacdr]

I've looking for a teacher like you a long time! And a video like that, as well. Besides the clear explanation and good tips, your voice is wonderful and your calm way is perfect to make me assimilate it with a good rhythm. Nowadays, there's a lot of youtube profiles for teaching english, but many of them are fast and agressive, made to be that way. Your profile is recommended not just for learning english but even to relieve anxiety. Thanks a lot!

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Ana Lúcia, tudo bem? Muito obrigado pelos elogios. Tem espaço para todo mundo... ;-) Abraços

[@JaquelineOliveira2000]

Que video bom hein... devagar, claro e objetivo... tenho procurado alguns canais..mas o seu eh impar.

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Jacke, tudo bem? Fico feliz em saber que você gostou do conteúdo do canal. Volte mais vezes e comente sempre que possível. Abraços

[@ednaf.2909]

I have worked for DHUAN for 22 years!! Curto demais seus videos!

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Hi, Edna! I'm glad to hear you like our videos! We really appreciate the feedback. See you later

[@ednaf.2909]

For sure Ulisses!

[@LuciaPPereira]

Hi Mr Carvalho. I've been learned English from you a long time, so I'm very thankful.

[@julioalonster]

Parabéns Ulysses! Excelente sua explicação sobre esse tempo verbal😊

[@robertotadeuspindola3623]

I've been read "Textos Mastigados" for many months. Tank you Ulisses

[@leibraybdangule8819]

well objective and ver clear

Ulisses, I've been trying to learn English for a very long long time! It seems I found the way! I'm loving your videos. Tks!

[@simarques]

Lately, I've been working as a journalist and teacher in a public school. Nowadays, I am working as a teacher in full time. Right?! You are the best! Tks for your videos...

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Thank you for commenting! Take care

[@simarques]

thanks...

[@Juniorsaxplayer]

Hi Ulisses!!!! YOU'VE SAVED MY LIFE! As an English teacher, I've had a hard time with my students about that verb tense. Mas você, com sua categoria habitual, acabou de me dar as ferramentas necessária para acabar de vez com as dúvidas (por sinal tão frequentes) dos meus alunos sobre o Present Perfect! Fantástico esse vídeo! Parabéns pela sensibilidade e competência! Grande abraço!

[@andresonjose3284]

Hello, it was a great lesson! I have been studied English for one years!

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

I'm glad to hear you have studied English for one year. Good for you! Take care

[@nadiapullig]

I've worked so hard to teach it in a simple way! And you've just got it! Congrats.

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Thank you! I'm glad you liked it. Have a good one

[@PatyFernandes]

Thanks ! 🤘🏻

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

You bet!

[@yellowsunshine65]

I´ve been watching your videos and learning a lot from your explanations.

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Thank you so much! I'm glad I could help. Take care

[@Sunshine91370]

I have been watched your videos everyday. Thanks for tips.

[@emersoms]

I've watched your excellent videos to learn English!

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Thank you, Emerson! You're the man! Take care

[@cassiosilva7287]

i have been watching your videos for many times

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Hello, Cássio! I guess you meant you've watched my videos many times, is that right? Thank you! Take care

[@emersonmagalhaes2464]

I have been studied English for eleven months. by the way, your lessons are awesome. Thank you for help us.

[@3523105586000]

Muito bom, pois é sempre complicado mesmo o Present Perfect ...

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Maria Fernanda, tudo bem? Muito obrigado pelo feedback. Abraços

[@xanderodrigues1556]

Por isso que eu te amooooooooo!!! Show! Show! Show!...

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Valeu! Abraços

[@crisloren9956]

I have been following you since 2010 and always I learn Good things...TKS!

[@MrSaulo140]

You've been following him since 2010 and you've always learned good things. You're just like me then.

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Thanks! I really appreciate the feedback. Take care

[@FlaviaSchettini]

Great explanation!! I've been learning a lot from you! Thanks!

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Thank you, Flávia! I'm glad you liked it. See you

[@domiingospaulinocaluisambu7610]

Thanks

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Thank you! Have a good one!

[@viniciuspeixoto6794]

Bacana você falar de assuntos "engessados" na metologia de ensino dos anos 70 de uma maneira mais informal, leve e com notável maturidade. Estou gostando muito do conteúdo produzido. Parabéns!!! "I have watched your videos for only 2 weeks..."

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Vinícius, tudo bem? Muito obrigado pelo feedback. Volte sempre! Abraços

[@Sunshine91370]

I´ve travelled to Europe many times. I´ve studied English for many years.

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

That's great! I've been to Europe a couple of times myself. Thanks for commenting. See you later

[@FIFLincoln]

Very good explanations! No words.

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Thanks a million! See you later

[@PevertLafayette]

I think that's the most clarifying video about Present Perfect I've ever watched!

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Hi, Steven! This is the nicest comment I've read in weeks! Thank you! Take care

[@felipecolella]

Dear Mr. Carvalho, I love this kind of class! Thanks! I've been studying English for 4 years. As you're traveling I'm watching your old videos hahaha See you soon

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Oldies but goodies! 😎 Thank you so much, Felipe! Have a good one

[@moacirmeireles3516]

I have watched yours videos since long time, and I have a confession to make: I learn a lot.

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Hi, Moacir! I'm glad to hear you've been watching my videos for a long time. Take care

[@robsonassuncao9680]

I have worked for Andreazza for twelve years. But recently, i have studied English for becoming a teacher. Thanks!

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

I'm glad to hear you have been studying English to become a teacher. Welcome aboard! 😎 Take care

[@MrBruno-nj1mb]

Oi, Ulysses! Gostaria, por favor, que você fizesse um vídeo sobre chunks of language. Obrigado, abraços!!!

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Bruno, como vai? Muito obrigado pela sugestão. Vou fazer, sim! Abraços

[@MrBruno-nj1mb]

Bem, obrigado. De nada. Inglês para mim é como uma segunda língua por isso é um prazer colaborar!!!

[@helmarbertuol2264]

I have been studing English for a long time.

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Hi, Helmar! It's great to hear that you have been studying English. Good for you! Take care

[@ruicarlos400]

I've seen your videos from the indication of "Teacher Allie", and I'm learning a lot, thank you !.

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Thank you! Take care

[@somusicasasmeninasdoingles168]

Congrats Ulisses you're awesome!!!!!

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Thanks! That was very sweet of you. Take care

[@albertofaria7288]

Great, Ulisses. So good !

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Thanks! Take care

[@ibagv]

Hi, Ulisses! Can you show me when I can use "I have worked " or "I have been working"? Is there any difference between these two expressions? You're simply the best!

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Wilmo, tudo bem? Muito obrigado pelo comentário simpático. Vou fazer um vídeo sobre o assunto porque em um comentário não cabe tanta informação. Abraços

[@ibagv]

Obrigado, amigão! Vou aguardar.

[@Lima7179]

I´ve benn glad, because founded channell and I´m learning more ,more. thank so much teacher. See you later ,bye,bye See you soon!!!

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Lindomar, como vai? Muito obrigado pelo feedback simpático. Volte sempre! Abraços

[@TacianaKellyGonzaga]

I have been very confused with Present Perfect lately (kkk...) but I hope get better. Thank you!

[@marcosasgeo]

I have been waiting for a teacher like you a long time... You are the best! Thanks!!! Sua explicação é nota 1000, realmente você é muito bom! Estou aprendendo muito com você. Obrigado mesmo!

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Marcos, blz? Muito obrigado de coração pelos elogios. Valeu mesmo! Abraços

[@hadassahqualidade]

muito boa explicação e ótimas dicas pra fixação! I have been study english for 10 months by myself :)

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Hadassah, tudo bem? Muito obrigado pela participação. Abraços

[@msaoki2010]

I've worked for... and I've been working for... ambas seriam equivalentes? Thanks in advance

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

msaoki2010, tudo bem? Na prática, sim. Há, no entanto, uma diferença sutil entre os dois tempos verbais. Vou tratar disso em um vídeo em breve. Abraços

[@paulonayan]

I have been wachated your videos recently.

[@Ariane1000XMaisEu]

I've been to Europe and India once. I'd like to ask you, why we have to say "I've been TO somewhere" and not "I've been IN somewhere". The second sentence makes more sense to me. Thanks a lot Ulisses, your lessons are really outstanding. And I feel very happy seeing the great attention that you give to all of your students. Please correct me if I've made any mistakes here in my comment. Thanks again ❤️

[@elviraobata8982]

I have been widow for 2 years.I have been in London many times.I have studied English since I have been retired. Ulisses, agradeço o seu trabalho, gostaria de receber comentarios sobre essas frases, se assim o merecerem. Thank you very much!

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Hi, Elvira! You need the indefinite article before "widow". We say "I have been a widow for two years". We say "I have studied / I have been studying English since I retired". By the way, I've been to London a couple of times myself. Take care

[@gilbertolima8752]

I have been to New York before.

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

So have I. Thanks for commenting. Take care

[@phrodrigues2009]

I've worked as a journalist since 2006.

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Great! That's one of the most fascinating professions. Thank you for commenting. Take care

[@CassiaHarue]

I have watched much videos in Ulisses's channel. And I have learned a lot about English.. =D

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Hi, Cássia! I guess you meant you've watched many videos in my channel. I'm glad you have learned a lot here. Thanks for commenting! Take care

[@xanderodrigues1556]

I have lived in Ceará since last october.

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

I hope you are enjoying it. Take care

[@xanderodrigues1556]

Thank you friend!

[@felipecolella]

Dear Ulisses, I don't know how many times I have been watched this video... My main doubt is about your second example, because I always want to translate "Eu trabalho na empresa X há y anos" as "I am working....", but thinking about it, I'd be like "I'm working for years without vacations, holidays, weekends, etc", isn't it? Thanks again for this marvellous content! (gastando adjetivo hahaha)

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Felipe, tudo bem? Se você estiver se referindo ao uma ação que se iniciou no passado e perdura até o presente, não há outra opção a não ser o emprego do _Present Perfect._ O segredo é se desvencilhar da comparação pura e simples com a língua portuguesa. Bons estudos. Abraços

[@catanazio]

I have worked for DAE for 1 year.

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

And how do you like it? Take care

[@marcioerda]

Great video, Ulisses! I've watched your lessons recently and I appreciated it.

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Thank you, Márcio! I really appreciate the feedback. Have a good one!

[@aialaoliveira9018]

Olá! Venho acompanhando o canal e os materiais disponíveis no site e estou gostando muito! Obrigada pela disponibilidade, pelos vídeos e pelos materiais. Parabéns pelo seu trabalho! Tenho uma dúvida e gostaria de ter uma ajuda : estou morando nos Estados Unidos e essa semana precisei puxar uma amiga pelo braço, muito rápido, porque uma outra pessoa passou correndo na direção dela. Parece engraçado e meio sem lógica esse exemplo, mas na hora tudo que eu queria ter dito era: " Se eu não tivesse feito isso, ele ia te empurrar." . Pois é, desisti da frase porque não soube "traduzir" a frase "se eu não tivesse feito isso [...] ".Como eu resolvo esse problema? haha Abraços!

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Aiala, tudo bem? Muito obrigado pelo interesse no conteúdo do Tecla SAP. A resposta para a sua dúvida está no post "Gramática: Conditional III" em www.teclasap.com.br/gramatica-conditional-iii/. Bons estudos! Abraços

[@Cris2010m]

Bonjour, Ulisses. Te acho o máximo! Super besos!

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Criss, tudo bem? Muito obrigado pelo elogio! Fiquei ainda mais pimpão agora... ;-) Abraços

[@dervalgiliofreitas3911]

I've been living in Brazil for 8 years

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Great! Thanks for commenting! Take care

[@josianemachado1978]

I liked!

[@Bodybuilder13013]

*Poderia ser tbm: I've been working for X-company for 5 years. - present perfect continuous?*

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Pode sim, sem grande alteração de sentido. Muito obrigado pelo interesse. Abraços

[@saulomizutani0625]

Boa tarde Ulisses! Tudo bem? Seguindo a idéia de algo que aconteceu no passado e que ainda continua, entendo também como a colocação do verbo "have" mais verbo particípio, como, "eu tenho estado, ela tem trabalhado, eles cantavam desde..." é isso mesmo? Agora outra coisa que não consigo entender é o present perfect continuous. Qual a diferença no modo de expressar, traduzir, pois na regra gramatical até aí vai, mas o sentido de expressar são bem parecidos. Poderia fazer um video com essa exlicação? Obrigado!

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Saulo, como vai? Pois é, as diferenças entre o Present Perfect e o Present Perfect Continuous causam mesmo muita confusão. Vou fazer um vídeo sobre o assunto em breve. Muito obrigado pela sugestão. Abraços

[@anavijf]

I've studied english two days a week.

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

I'm glad to hear that you've been studying English twice a week. Take care

[@mariaizabelsilva7575]

I have been studied all day long

[@carolinegallao]

I've been happily married for 10 years! :)

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Good for you! Take care

[@jamesdelooeste]

I worked for a company in my city for 6 years. But now I'm unemployed, since then, I've studied english everyday.

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Thanks for commenting. I hope you find a job soon. Take care

[@henriquearaujo672]

i've studied computer programming for 3 years

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

That's great! Thanks for commenting. Have a good one!

[@joaoxaviervilanculos3113]

I have tought english for many years

[@cesargiupponi]

I have worked at same company for three years.

[@rogerioarmando1]

I've been studying English on the web lately.

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Good for you! Take care

[@ealexandre1973]

Good evening Ulisses, I've worked as a safety technician for 11 years.

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Hi, Eduardo! Thank you for commenting. Take care

[@deboratraducoesful]

Obrigada pelo vídeo Ulisses. I've been married for 25 years. (Is it right?) Thanks.

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

I don't know... you tell me! ;-) Take care

[@soniareginazorzi8969]

Olá Ulisses, gosto muito de suas dicas, gostaria de saber se na 2a. frase eu não poderia escrever . I've been working for....?

[@elianesil7921]

I have been sick for about two months. I hope to be well soon!!

[@ozeiassantos402]

I have been studing english for 2 years

[@marcelovieira7007]

I've been in Spain 2 years ego.

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Marcelo, tudo bem? Se colocarmos uma definição de tempo no passado (_two years ago_), a ação deixa de ter relação com o presente e, portanto, fica no _Simple Past Tense_: _I was in Spain two years ago._ Bons estudos! Abraços

[@marcelovieira7007]

Ulisses Wehby de Carvalho Super esclarecido, muito obrigado e grande abraço.

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Valeu! Abraços

[@marcosrogeriozefirino3393]

I've just watched this video.

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

It seems it did its job... Thank you for stopping by. See you later

[@taniaantonio6702]

I have tried to understand present perfect. But, I'm brazilian and I never give up.

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

You seem to be doing a good job! Keep at it! Take care

[@taniaantonio6702]

Thank you, teacher!!!

[@nnegociosnacrise]

i've been looking new job for me

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Hi, IG PLayer! I believe you meant you've been looking for a job, right? Take care

[@nnegociosnacrise]

+Ulisses Wehby de Carvalho Yes man... I've tried many times but it's very difficult... one more thing, this is my English that I study every day by myself and I've studied for English for 7 months... what do you think

[@renatoloureiro5347]

I've struggled with Present Perfect for while.

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

But now you don't! ;-) Take care

[@marcello634]

Professor, poderia ser utilizado o present perfect continous, ja que a ação começou no passado e continua acontecendo, na 2º frase: I 've been working there for 5 year

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Marcel, tudo bem? Você tem razão, mas o foco muda um pouco e passa a ser mais no tempo do que no próprio trabalho. Vou fazer um vídeo sobre o Present Perfect Continuous para esclarecer essa dúvida frequente. Abraços

[@marcello634]

Ulisses Wehby de Carvalho valeu professor. parabéns pelo trabalho

[@alessandraalvarez463]

Hello teacher! The explanation about PP was very nice. Thank you But... I have one question: Why I've been TO New York and not IN New York? Thank you

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Hi, Alessandra! Thank you for commenting. There's a very nice video on the issue here: kzbin.info/www/bejne/qp2bnKGwqrpnaZI Enjoy. See you later

[@maizacerqueira]

😘

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

:-)

[@andremachado5539]

I have worked at Cimi for 5 years. I l've lived in Acre since 2014. I have studied English harder recently.

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Hi, André! I'm glad you have been studying English. Take care

[@andremachado5539]

Thank you.

[@nelsonvaleriano7821]

i have been waiting for this video about present perfect,master please in the next video call abaout time markers,because i have must dificult to understing thanks strong hug

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Nelson, tudo bem? Farei mais vídeos sobre tempos verbais em breve. Muito obrigado pelo interesse. Abraços

[@luanarodrigues3868]

Boa noite Professor, eu poderia dizer I've been in New York many times ? trocar o in pelo to ? acho muito confuso alguns usos do to!

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Luana, tudo bem? _I've been to NYC_ é a forma preferencial. O que parece estranho a princípio vai, aos poucos, ficando cada vez mais familiar. Aceitação é fundamental no aprendizado de uma língua estrangeira. Bons estudos! Abraços

[@luanarodrigues3868]

Obrigada!

[@Lima7179]

with n in the finish

[@marcosemmke1400]

I have been studied English for 2 years .

[@estevitaful]

He has studied English for two years.

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Good for him! Take care

[@kmendezable]

Qual a diferença entre o future continuous x future perfect continuous ?

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Vou fazer um vídeo sobre o tema. Muito obrigado pela participação. Abraços

[@rodrigo6958]

uma dúvida ! Se eu disser para o Nativo I have Fixed my car eu foquei na ação Não importa quando., Mas e se ele ficar curioso e me perguntar quando ??

[@marcosemmke1400]

I have studied English for 2 years.

[@ioutube52]

Ulisses, I've studied English for 40 years and always I'm runnig in panic when I've got to speak to people. I give up!

[@wendell494]

I have been busy lately

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

So have I! Thanks for taking the time to write. See you later

[@cebertran]

I have worked for Artefacto for 3 years. I have been married for 7 years.

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

Great! Thanks for commenting. Take care

[@ABUFAYEZx]

i've been trying so hard to be good.

[@MrHumberto287]

I have been married for 35 years and retired for 3 years. So, I expend my time working out and studying English, every day, for Monday to Friday.

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

That's great! I'm glad to hear you spend your time wisely! I know I should but I haven't been able to work out Monday through Friday. Thank you for taking the time to write. See you later

[@joaomilton9285]

Ola Ulisses, Ontem lendo uma materia da CNN, encontrei a seguinte frase que foi postada no twitter da Policia de Portland: Police have deployed less lethal munitions such as OC spray and vapor (pepper spray), rubber ball distraction devices, rubber baton rounds. Entendo que Policia esta na terceira pessoa, estou errado? Sendo assim, porque não "Police HAS deployed less...." Muito Obrigado!

[@TeclaSAPcomUlissesCarvalho]

João, tudo bem? "Police" é terceira pessoa do plural. Logo, "Police have deployed" é a conjugação adequada. Abraços